Mathematics and power: an alliance in the foundations of mathematics and its teaching

Following a genealogic approach, this paper discusses how logic and calculation are linked to epistemology, spirituality and politics; how mathematics education can be understood as an institution for a mathematical enculturation; and how, therefore, mathematics education necessarily (re)produces techniques of power which privilege some children while disadvantaging others. This approach criticises other critical studies on social dimensions of mathematics education which argue that the social dimensions are to be found in the application or teaching of mathematics alone. Instead, mathematics itself has, since its very beginning, been a knowledge which allows power, represents a specific world view and serves the interests of certain groups in society.     

Electronic vs. paper textbook presentations of the various aspects of mathematics

Based in part on our work in adapting existing paper textbooks for secondary schools for a digital format, this paper discusses paper form and the various electronic platforms with regard to the presentation of five aspects of mathematics that have roles in mathematics learning in all the grades kindergarten-12: symbolization, deduction, modeling, algorithms, and representations. In moving to digital platforms, each of these aspects of mathematics presents its own challenges and opportunities for both curriculum and instruction, that is, for the content goals and how they connect with students for learning. A combination of paper and electronic presentations may be an optimal solution but some difficulties with such a complex solution are presented.     

Potential scenarios for Internet use in the mathematics classroom

Research on the influence of multiple representations in mathematics education gained new momentum when personal computers and software started to become available in the mid-1980s. It became much easier for students who were not fond of algebraic representations to work with concepts such as function using graphs or tables. Research on how students use such software showed that they shaped the tools to their own needs, resulting in an intershaping relationship in which tools shape the way students know at the same time the students shape the tools and influence the design of the next generation of tools. This kind of research led to the theoretical perspective presented in this paper: knowledge is constructed by collectives of humans-with-media. In this paper, I will discuss how media have shaped the notions of problem and knowledge, and a parallel will be developed between the way that software has brought new possibilities to mathematics education and the changes that the Internet may bring to mathematics education. This paper is, therefore, a discussion about the future of mathematics education. Potential scenarios for the future of mathematics education, if the Internet becomes accepted in the classroom, will be discussed.     

Cultural distance and identities-in-construction within the multicultural mathematics classroom

In this paper we present and exemplify our interpretation of some theoretical constructs that have proved useful to our understanding of the complexity of multicultural mathematics classrooms. Constructs such as culture, cultural distance, cultural conflict and identities-in-construction have oriented our study of the complexity of highly multicultural mathematics classrooms in Barcelona. The purpose of this paper is to discuss how cultural distance arising from the different meanings that students, being local or immigrant, inevitably bring to the mathematics classroom may turn into cultural conflicts when cultural interaction is not facilitated through classroom discourse. The lack of cultural interaction and communication may give rise to strong negative feedings and refusal to participate on the side of the students. Students' nonparticipation can be understood as an active response to cultural distance and negative opinions in order to safeguard the identities they (wish to) construct within a context that they perceive as hostile.     

Gender justice,human rights and measurement in the mathematics classroom

In line with international trends, the new South African mathematics curriculum implores mathematics educators to realize a pedagogy in their classrooms that is more practical, activity-oriented, and connected to their learners' lives. Drawing on data from a larger study that explores theory–practice relations in mathematics education, this paper shows how such progressive practices, when interpreted with respect to the teaching of measurement which required learners to use different measuring instruments for measuring the school grounds in learning about length and perimeter, were found to be deeply gendered. In two different contexts of an ‘African' township school and a predominantly ‘Indian' suburban school, girls in a grade 6 mathematics classroom faced direct sexism as they struggled to take the opportunity to participate in the activity and learn how to measure – an important mathematical competence and everyday knowledge and skill. The article analyses the data with reference to the human rights imperatives of the new national curricula and approaches to addressing disadvantage and discrimination for girls in mathematics classrooms.     

Book Reviews

The making of pictures and the use of mathematics are often considered as activities carried out by two different classes of people.

It may be true that the artist can get on without mathematics, but the converse is far less true.

The operation which an artist terms ‘drawing’, might be described by a mathematician as ‘the mapping of a three‐dimensional network into a two‐dimensional one’.

This article attempts to show how the mathematically minded student can use his mathematics to manipulate pictures. In doing so it introduces him to the tasks which a computer must perform in picture manipulation.

The article is in two parts:

Part A, discusses the use of three‐dimensional sketching and the role it plays in the preparation of ‘orthographic’ working drawings.

It describes how a designer transfers his thoughts about spacial objects to paper, thus assisting himself to refine them and enabling others to perceive them.

A case is made for encouraging perspective sketching in the teaching of engineering drawing.

Part B describes a technique for plotting perspective sketches by numerical methods, which may be useful in motivating numerically inclined students towards involvement with perspective sketching.     

Investigating undergraduate students’ proof schemes and perspectives about combinatorial proof

Combinatorics is an area of mathematics with accessible, rich problems and applications in a variety of fields. Combinatorial proof is an important topic within combinatorics that has received relatively little attention within the mathematics education community, and there is much to investigate about how students reason about and engage with combinatorial proof. In this paper, we use Harel and Sowder’s (1998) proof schemes to investigate ways that students may characterize combinatorial proofs as different from other types of proof. We gave five upper-division mathematics students combinatorial-proof tasks and asked them to reflect on their activity and combinatorial proof more generally. We found that the students used several of Harel and Sowder’s proof schemes to characterize combinatorial proof, and we discuss whether and how other proof schemes may emerge for students engaging in combinatorial proof. We conclude by discussing implications and avenues for future research.     

Humans-with-media and continuing education for mathematics teachers in online environments

This paper begins by situating online mathematics education in Brazil within the context of research on digital technology over the past 25?years. I argue that Brazilian research on technology in mathematics education can be divided into four phases, and then present an example that ??blends?? aspects of the second and third phases. Phase two can be characterized by research with software designed to address traditional mathematics topics, such as functions, while the third phase is characterized by online courses. The data presented show creative solutions for a problem designed for collectives of humans-with-function-software. The paper is analyzed from a perspective that emphasizes the role of different technologies as teachers and professors collaborate to produce knowledge about the use of mathematical software in regular face-to-face classrooms. A model of online education is presented. Finally, the paper discusses how technology may change collaboration and teaching approaches in continuing education, as it allows for greater integration of online learning with teachers?? classroom activities in schools. In this case, the online platform plays an active role in the learning collective composed of humans-with-media.     

Re-sourcing teachers’ work and interactions: a collective perspective on resources, their use and transformation

This paper reviews the literature on the theme of mathematics teachers’ work and interactions with resources, taking a particular perspective, the so-called ‘collective perspective’ on resources, their use and transformation. The review is presented under three headings: (1) theoretical frameworks commonly used in this area of research; (2) teachers’ interactions with resources in terms of their design and use; and (3) teachers’ interactions with resources in terms of teacher learning and professional development. From the literature, and the collection of papers in this issue, we argue that the collective dimensions play an important role in mathematics teachers’ work with resources and in their professional learning/development. Further empirical investigations are likely to be needed on: how teachers may work in collectives and with resources, and in which ways ‘productive’ collectives may form and work together; which roles particular resources can play in these delicate constellations and how particular resources may support teachers in their work and learning; and which kinds of resources offer opportunities for community building.     

Revealing hidden mathematics curriculum to pre-teachers using technology: the case of partitions

Motivated by work done with pre-teachers of mathematics in a problem-solving course, this paper shows how computing technologies, including a spreadsheet and Maple, facilitate an informal journey into a hidden aspect of the formal content of the pre-college curriculum dealing with the arithmetic of partitions. By using three problems from different grade levels within a state curriculum as an example, the paper suggests that a deeper perspective on seemingly disconnected problem-solving contexts may serve as a powerful didactical tool in helping teachers to appreciate mathematics and its pedagogy as an integrated whole. The connection of the hidden aspect of the curriculum to the concept of mathematical play is also explored.     

Content and Organization of Teacher's Manuals: An Analysis of Japanese Elementary Mathematics Teacher's Manuals

In this paper, results from a study that analyzed the content and organization of teacher's manuals for elementary school mathematics from Japan and the United States are presented. Studies have shown that the nature of mathematics instruction in Japan is different from instruction commonly observed in the United States. Moreover, other scholars have noted that elementary school teachers, both in the United States and Japan, rely heavily on textbooks to teach mathematics. Thus, teacher's manuals accompanying textbook series may be a contributing factor to this difference. The results of the analysis showed that there are some significant differences in the way Japanese teachers' manuals are prepared from those of the US series. The findings suggest that curriculum developers should critically reflect on how to prepare teacher's manuals so that they become useful resources for teachers.     

What students value in effective mathematics learning: a ‘Third Wave Project’ research study

Considerations of how mathematics can be effectively taught and learnt may be cognitive, affective or sociocultural in approach. ??What students value in effective mathematics learning?? is a research study of the Third Wave Project, an international consortium of research teams adopting a sociocultural approach to investigate the harnessing of relevant values to optimise school mathematics teaching and learning. This paper seeks to contextualise the study, as part of the study examines what the high-achieving East Asian mathematics students value. The study is framed by knowledge relating to the relative cultural influence on effectiveness in mathematics learning, Alan Bishop??s values in mathematics education and the role of interactions in education, in particular David Tripp??s idea of critical incidents as reflecting professional judgement (and, thus, underlying values). Features of the innovative qualitative research design are also presented, which include the facilitation of photo-voice, the argument for an international collaborative team and focus group interviews for all values research, and a two-stage data analysis process aimed at clarifying both etic and emic perspectives.     

A Preservice Secondary Teacher's Moves to Protect Her View of Herself as a Mathematics Expert

This paper discusses the experience of a preservice secondary mathematics teacher during lesson study. Although the preservice teacher was a strong undergraduate mathematics student, she used compensation “moves” to deflect attention away from her insecurities about her conceptual understanding of secondary mathematics. She feared being labeled as “dumb” and redirected conversations in order to protect her identity as a knower of mathematics. This paper investigates the culture in which preservice teachers develop confidence in their personal mathematics knowledge and how that confidence may influence behavior.     

The conceptualisation of mathematics competencies in the international teacher education study TEDS-M

The main aim of the international teacher education study Teacher Education and Development Study in Mathematics (TEDS-M), carried out under the auspices of the International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement (IEA), was to understand how national policies and institutional practices influence the outcomes of mathematics teacher education. This paper reports on the definition of effective mathematics teacher education in TEDS-M, distinguishing between mathematics content knowledge and mathematics pedagogical content knowledge as essential cognitive components of mathematics teachers’ professional competencies. These competence facets were implemented as proficiency tests based on extensive coordination and validation processes by experts from all participating countries. International acceptance of the tests was accomplished whereas, by necessity, national specifications had to be left out, as is common in comparative large-scale assessments. In this paper, the nature of the TEDS-M tests for the primary study is analysed and commented on detail. The aims are to increase our understanding of mathematics content knowledge and mathematics pedagogical content knowledge, which are still fuzzy domains, to provide a substantive background for interpretations of the test results and to examine whether some educational traditions may be more accurately reflected in the test items than others. For this purpose, several items that have been released by the IEA are presented and elaborately analysed in order to substantiate the test design of TEDS-M. Our main conclusion is that the overall validity of the TEDS-M tests can be regarded as a given, but that readers have to be aware of limitations, amongst others from a continental European point of view.     

SCHOOL OR COLLEGE MATHEMATICS AND WORKPLACE PRACTICE: AN ACTIVITY THEORY PERSPECTIVE

This paper reports on a case study in which we detail how a college mathematics and chemistry student struggles to make sense of the graphical output of an experiment in an industrial chemistry laboratory. The student's attempts to interpret unfamiliar graphical conventions are described and contrasted with those of college mathematics. Our analysis of this draws on activity theory to assist in understanding the position of the student in both the college and the workplace. This highlights the limitations of the experience of the student at college and we question how the mathematics curriculum might be adapted to assist students in making sense of workplace graphical output.     

The student experience of mathematical proof at university level

While proofs are central to university level mathematics courses, research indicates that some students may complete their degrees with an incomplete picture of what constitutes a proof and how proofs are developed. The paper sets out to review what is known of the student experience of mathematical proof at university level. In particular, some evidence is presented of the conceptions of mathematical proof that recent mathematics graduates bring to their postgraduate course to teach high school mathematics. Such evidence suggests that while the least well-qualified graduates may have the poorest grasp of mathematical proof, the most highly qualified may not necessarily have the richest form of subject matter knowledge needed for the most effective teaching. Some indication of the likely causes of this incomplete student perspective on proof are presented.     

Inhibitory control and mathematics learning: definitional and operational considerations

The topic of inhibition in mathematics education is both well timed and important. In this commentary, we reflect on the role of inhibition in mathematics learning through four themes that relate to how inhibition is defined, measured, developed, and applied. First, we consider different characterizations of inhibition and how they may shape the ways that inhibition is conceptualized and studied in mathematics contexts. Second, we discuss methods that researchers use to study inhibition and how differences across these methods may constrain researchers’ conclusions or what these differences may imply for students’ use of inhibition when solving authentic mathematics problems. Third, we consider the relationship between intuition and mathematics content knowledge, including how this relationship may vary for students with different levels of knowledge. We end with a discussion of inhibition’s practical educational relevance, in which we offer a set of questions that may inform future conversations or research in the field.     

Who succeeds in STEM? Elementary girls' attitudes and beliefs about self and STEM

With ongoing underrepresentation of women in STEM fields, it is necessary to explore ways to maintain girls' STEM interest throughout elementary and middle school. This study is situated within the context of Designs in STEM (pseudonym), an out-of-school program that engages urban youth in authentic STEM experiences. Participants were 30 girls attending Designs in STEM in grades four and five. Participants were interviewed about their STEM interest, out-of-school versus in-school STEM learning experiences, and how gender relates to STEM success. Several key findings emerged. First, although students' prior school experiences with mathematics resulted in less positive dispositions toward mathematics than other STEM disciplines, their experiences at Designs in STEM revealed that mathematics could be fun and valuable when used for real-world purposes. Second, students found Designs in STEM to be more engaging and inspiring due to the context and pedagogies employed by Designs in STEM instructors. Third, despite observing girls' behavior that was more aligned with academic success, participants still identified STEM advantages for boys. Finally, participants defined success and intelligence in STEM based on speed and tracking. Discussion focuses on the need to consider how school-based mathematics instruction may serve as a barrier to girls' STEM interest and involvement.     

FROM ONE LANGUAGE TO ANOTHER: A SEMIOTIC INTERPRETATION OF THE TRANSLATION OF MATHEMATICAL WORDS

The teaching and learning of Primary school mathematics in Malta involves the use of code-switching between the local language Maltese, and English Mathematical terms themselves are usually retained in English and teachers may use various strategies to share the meaning of these words with their pupils. One strategy that may be used in a bilingual situation is translation from one language to another. In this paper I explore how a teacher used this strategy to teach her 7 to 8-year-old pupils mathematical vocabulary related to the topic'Money and Shopping'. While Maltese equivalents for these words exist, it is the English versions that form part of the school mathematics register. I develop a semiotic model where a mathematical word is considered to be a sign, and the process of translation is viewed as a chain of signification from one language to another.