Multicomponent cationic lipid-DNA complex formation: role of lipid mixing

Multicomponent cationic lipid-DNA complexes (lipoplexes) were prepared by adding linear DNA to mixed lipid dispersions containing two populations of binary cationic liposomes and characterized by means of small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Four kinds of cationic liposomes were used. The first binary lipid mixture was made of the cationic lipid (3'[N-(N',N'-dimethylaminoethane)-carbamoyl]cholesterol (DC-Chol) and the neutral helper lipid dioleoylphosphocholine (DOPC) (DC-Chol/DOPC liposomes), the second one of the cationic 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium-propane (DOTAP) and the neutral dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE) (DOTAP/DOPE liposomes), the third one of DC-Chol and DOPE (DC-Chol/DOPE liposomes), and the fourth one of DOTAP and DOPC (DOTAP/DOPC liposomes). Upon DNA-induced fusion of liposomes, large lipid mixing at the molecular level occurs. As a result, highly organized mixed lipoplexes spontaneously form with membrane properties intermediate between those of starting liposomes. By varying the composition of lipid dispersions, different DNA packing density regimes can also be achieved. Furthermore, occurring lipid mixing was found to induce hexagonal to lamellar phase transition in DOTAP/DOPE membranes. Molecular mechanisms underlying experimental findings are discussed.     

Interaction of lipoplexes with anionic lipids resulting in DNA release is a two-stage process

We propose a mechanism for DNA release from lipoplexes in cells that accounts for various observations of lipoplex-anionic lipid interactions. We examined the structural evolution of lipoplexes upon interaction with cellular lipids by synchrotron small-angle X-ray diffraction (SAXD), and the extent of DNA release from lipoplexes was determined by gel electrophoresis. We find that the interaction of lipoplexes with anionic cellular lipids is a two-stage process. In the first step, anionic lipids laterally diffuse into the complex and neutralize the cationic lipids. As a result, the membrane charge density of lipoplexes decreases and interactions between cationic lipids and DNA become weaker, but DNA is extremely poorly released. Only after the cationic charge of lipoplex membranes is completely neutralized by anionic lipids does DNA starts to be released significantly.     

Structural stability against disintegration by anionic lipids rationalizes the efficiency of cationic liposome/DNA complexes

Reported here is the correlation between the transfection efficiency of cationic liposome/DNA complexes (lipoplexes) and the structural evolution that they undergo when interacting with anionic membrane lipids. Multicomponent lipoplexes, incorporating from three to six lipid species simultaneously, presented a much higher transfection efficiency than binary lipoplexes, which are more commonly used for gene-delivery purposes. The discovery that a high transfection efficiency can be achieved by employing multicomponent complexes at a lower-than-ever-before membrane charge density of lipoplexes was of primary significance. Synchrotron small-angle X-ray diffraction (SAXD) experiments showed that anionic liposomes made of dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol (DOPG) disintegrated the lamellar phase of lipoplexes. DNA unbinding was measured by electrophoresis on agarose gels. Most importantly, structural changes induced by anionic lipids strictly depended on the lipid composition of lipoplexes. We found evidence of the existence of three different regimes of stability related to the interaction between complexes and anionic membranes. Both unstable (with low membrane charge density, sigmaM) and highly stable lipoplexes (with high sigmaM) exhibited low transfection efficiency whereas highly efficient multicomponent lipoplexes exhibited an "optimal stability". This intermediate regime reflects a compromise between two opposing constraints: protection of DNA in the cytosol and endosomal escape. Here we advance the concept that structural stability, upon interaction with cellular anionic lipids, is a key factor governing the transfection efficiency of lipoplexes. Possible molecular mechanisms underlying experimental observations are also discussed.     

Enhanced transfection efficiency of multicomponent lipoplexes in the regime of optimal membrane charge density

Recently, membrane charge density of lipid membranes, sigma M, has been recognized as a universal parameter that controls the transfection efficiency of complexes made of binary cationic liposomes and DNA (binary lipoplexes). Three distinct regimes, most likely related to interactions between complexes and cells, have also been identified. The purpose of this work was to investigate the transfection efficiency behavior of multicomponent lipoplexes in the regime of optimal membrane charge density (1< sigma M < 2 x 10 (-2) e/A (2)) and compare their performance with that of binary lipoplexes usually employed for gene delivery purposes. We found remarkable differences in transfection efficiency due to lipid composition, with maximum in efficiency being obtained when multicomponent lipoplexes were used to transfect NIH 3T3 cells, while binary lipoplexes were definitely less efficient. These findings suggested that multicomponent systems are especially promising lipoplex candidates. With the aim of providing new insights into the mechanism of transfection, we investigated the structural evolution of lipoplexes when interacting with anionic (cellular) lipids by means of synchrotron small-angle X-ray diffraction (SAXD), while the extent of DNA release upon interaction with anionic lipids was measured by electrophoresis on agarose gels. Interestingly, a clear trend was found that the transfection activity increased with the number of lipid components. These results highlight the compositional properties of carrier lipid/cellular lipid mixtures as decisive factors for transfection and suggest a strategy for the rational design of superior cationic lipid carriers.     

Correlation of the physicochemical properties of symmetric 1,3-dialkoylamidopropane-based cationic lipids containing single primary and tertiary amine polar head groups with in vitro transfection activity

The physicochemical properties of a novel series of symmetric 1,3-dialkylamidopropane-based cationic amphiphiles [M. Sheikh, J. Feig, B. Gee, S. Li, M. Savva, In vitro lipofection with novel series of symmetric 1,3-dialkoylamidopropane-based cationic surfactants containing single primary and tertiary amine polar head groups, Chem. Phys. Lipids 124 (2003) 49-61] were studied by several techniques, in an effort to correlate cationic lipid structure with transfection efficacy. It was found that only the unsubstituted amine and tertiary amine dioleoyl derivatives 1,3lmp5 and 1,3lmt5, respectively, mediated in vitro transfection activity in the absence of helper lipids. This activity pattern was consistent with ethidium bromide fluorescence quenching studies, which indicated that only these two derivatives bound to and efficiently condense plasmid DNA at physiological pH. Dynamic light scattering indicated that lipoplexes made by these two cationic lipids were relatively small particles below 1 microm, in sharp contrast to lipoplexes bigger than 3 microm composed of saturated cationic derivatives. Transmission electron microscopy studies clearly indicated that cationic lipid dispersions made by saturated derivatives form multilamellar tubules at physiological pH. Calorimetric studies showed that cationic amphiphiles with saturated acyl chains longer than 12 carbons exhibit solid-to-liquid crystalline phase transitions above 37 degrees C. In agreement with the microscopy and calorimetry studies, Langmuir film balance experiments indicated that saturated derivatives with hydrophobic chains longer that 12 carbons are not well hydrated and exist at a chain-ordered state at ambient temperature. Calculation of compressibility moduli from monolayer compression isotherms at 23 degrees C suggested that monolayers made by cationic lipids bearing saturated acyl chains are less compressible relative to those of the dioleoyl derivatives 1,3lmp5 and 1,3lmt5. In conclusion, high hydration, increased fluidity and high elasticity of cationic lipid assemblies in isolation, all correlate with high in vitro transfection activity.     

The analysis of serum effects on structure,size and toxicity of DDAB–DOPE and DC-Chol–DOPE lipoplexes contributes to explain their different transfection efficiency

The effect of serum on structural properties of dimethyl-dioctadecyl-ammonium bromide (DDAB)–1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) liposomes and DDAB–DOPE/DNA lipoplexes has been investigated by energy dispersive X-ray diffraction (EDXD) technique, at different cationic lipid/DNA weight ratios (ρ). The role of serum on the size of lipoplexes has also been studied by dynamic light scattering. Lipoplex transfection efficiency (TE) as a function of ρ, and lipoplex toxicity to C6 rat glioma cells have been evaluated in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM) with and without serum. A multi-parametric analysis concerning the role of size, structure and cytotoxicity on transfection efficiency contributes to explain the experimental observation that 3β-[N-(N′,N′-dimethylaminoethane)carbamoyl]-cholesterol (DC-Chol)–DOPE/DNA transfect C6 cells better than DDAB–DOPE/DNA lipoplexes.     

Counterion-mediated pattern formation in membranes containing anionic lipids

Most lipid components of cell membranes are either neutral, like cholesterol, or zwitterionic, like phosphatidylcholine and sphingomyelin. Very few lipids, such as sphingosine, are cationic at physiological pH. These generally interact only transiently with the lipid bilayer, and their synthetic analogs are often designed to destabilize the membrane for drug or DNA delivery. However, anionic lipids are common in both eukaryotic and prokaryotic cell membranes. The net charge per anionic phospholipid ranges from − 1 for the most abundant anionic lipids such as phosphatidylserine, to near − 7 for phosphatidylinositol 3,4,5 trisphosphate, although the effective charge depends on many environmental factors. Anionic phospholipids and other negatively charged lipids such as lipopolysaccharides are not randomly distributed in the lipid bilayer, but are highly restricted to specific leaflets of the bilayer and to regions near transmembrane proteins or other organized structures within the plane of the membrane. This review highlights some recent evidence that counterions, in the form of monovalent or divalent metal ions, polyamines, or cationic protein domains, have a large influence on the lateral distribution of anionic lipids within the membrane, and that lateral demixing of anionic lipids has effects on membrane curvature and protein function that are important for biological control.     

Two-dimensional lipid mixing entropy regulates the formation of multicomponent lipoplexes

The mechanism of formation of multicomponent lipoplexes was investigated by means of synchrotron Small-Angle X-ray Diffraction (SAXD). Mixed lipid dispersions were prepared by mixing different populations of binary cationic liposomes. When adding DNA to mixed lipid dispersions, multicomponent lipoplexes spontaneously formed exhibiting structural properties, i.e., membrane thickness, surface charge density, and one-dimensional DNA packing density, intermediate between those of binary lipoplexes. These results suggested that DNA lets liposomes come into contact and fuse and that a complete lipid mixing at the molecular level occurs. The equilibrium structure of multicomponent lipoplexes was found to be unique and did not depend on the number and kind of populations composing lipid dispersion but only on the lipid species involved and on their relative molar ratio. According to recent theoretical models we identified two-dimensional lipid mixing entropy as the key factor regulating the existence of only multicomponent lipoplexes with ideally mixed lipid species.     

DNA–DNA electrostatic interactions within cationic lipid/DNA lamellar complexes

We present a simple theoretical analysis of the DNA–DNA electrostatic interactions within charge-neutral lamellar cationic lipid/DNA complexes (lipoplexes). Although always repulsive as a function of the DNA–DNA interaxial distance, the calculated electrostatic force shows a deep minimum for each value of lipid composition corresponding to an equilibrium distance of the system. The excellent agreement between the equilibrium distances predicted by the model and that experimentally observed in charge-neutral complexes as revealed by synchrotron X-ray diffraction, shows that the spatial dimensionality of both the lipids and the DNA may not be a crucial point to capture the essence of the DNA–DNA interactions within charge-neutral lipoplexes.     

On the gene delivery efficacies of pH-sensitive cationic lipids via endosomal protonation: a chemical biology investigation

In an effort to probe the importance of endosomal protonation in pH-sensitive, cationic, lipid-mediated, non-viral gene delivery, we have designed and synthesized a novel cholesterol-based, endosomal pH-sensitive, histidylated, cationic amphiphile (lipid 1), its less pH-sensitive counterpart with an electron-deficient, tosylated histidine head group (lipid 2) as well as a third new cholesterol-based, cationic lipid containing no histidine head group (lipid 3). For all the novel liposomes and lipoplexes, we evaluated hysicochemical characteristics, including lipid:DNA interactions, global surface charge, and sizes. As anticipated, lipid 2 showed lower efficacies than lipid 1 for the transfection of 293T7 cells with the cytoplasmic gene expression vector pT7Luc at lipid:DNA mole ratios of 3.6:1 and 1.8:1; both lipids were greatly inhibited in the presence of Bafilomycin A1. This demonstrates the involvement of imidazole ring protonation in the endosomal escape of DNA. Conversely, endosome escape of DNA with lipid 3 seemed to be independent of endosome acidification. However, with nuclear gene expression systems in 293T7, HepG2, and HeLa cells, the transfection efficacies of lipid 2 at a lipid:DNA mole ratio of 3.6:1 were found to be either equal to or somewhat lower than those of lipids 1 and 3. Interestingly, at a lipid:DNA mole ratio of 1.8:1, lipids 2 and 3 were remarkably more transfection efficient than lipid 1 in both HepG2 and HeLa cells. Mechanistic implications of such contrasting relative transfection profiles are delineated.     

Investigation of the influence on conformational transition of DNA induced by cationic lipid vesicles

Recent studies have focused on the structural features of DNA-lipid assemblies. In this paper we take nile blue A (NBA) as a probe molecule to study the influence of the conformational transition of DNA induced by didodecyldimethylammonium bromide (DDAB) cationic vesicles to the interaction between DNA and the probe molecules. We find that upon binding to DNA, a secondary conformational transition of DNA induced by the cationic liposome from the native B-form to the C-form resulted in the change of binding modes of NBA to DNA and different complexes are formed between DNA, DDAB and NBA.     

Polyadenylic acid binding on cationic liposomes doped with the non-ionic nucleolipid Lauroyl Uridine

In this work unilamellar liposomes doped with a novel non-ionic 5′-Uridine-head nucleolipid, Lauroyl Uridine (LU), were prepared and characterized for their ability to interact with the polynucleotide polyadenylic acid (poly-A). Vesicles, were made up of the cationic lipid DOTAP (1,2-Dioleoyl-3-Trimethylammonium-Propane), the zwitterionic lipid DOPE (1,2-Dioleoyl-sn-Glycero-3-Phosphoethanolamine), and the novel amphiphile Lauroyl Uridine. The influence of the non-ionic nucleolipid on essential liposomes properties, such as the structure and net charge was first investigated by a comparative analysis performed on the different lipoplex preparations by means of ζ-potential and size measurements. Both structure and net charge of liposomes were shown to be not modified by the presence of the non-ionic nucleolipid.The role of the synthetic lipid inserted as anchor in the liposome bilayer in the condensation process between vesicles and the polynucleotide poly-A was then analyzed by UV–vis, Circular Dichroism (CD) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopies. The data presented comparative UV–vis analyses that evidenced the occurrence of staking interactions in the poly-A only in LU containing lipoplexes. CD and NMR studies indicated the presence of H-bonding interaction between Lauroyl Uridine containing vesicles and the polynucleotide poly-A. The results presented in this work support a role for Lauroyl Uridine in A-U molecular recognition, thus, suggesting that cationic liposomes doped with the non-ionic nucleolipid Lauroyl Uridine could represent a model system to study molecular interactions among single stranded polynucleotides and lipid anchor bearing the complementary bases.     

Compressibility study of quaternary phospholipid blend monolayers

The mechanical properties of liposome membranes are strongly dependent on type and ratio of lipid compounds, which can have important role in drug targeting and release processes when liposome is used as drug carrier. In this work we have used Brewster's angle microscopy to monitor the lateral compression process of lipid monolayers containing as helper lipids either distearoyl phosphatidylethanolamine (DSPE) or dioleoyl phophatidylethanolamine (DOPE) molecules on the Langmuir trough. The compressibility coefficient was determined for lipid blend monolayers containing the helper lipids above, cholesterol, distearoyl phosphatidylcholine (DSPC) and pegylated-DSPE at room temperature. Two variables, the cholesterol fraction and the ratio ρ between the helper lipid (either DSPE or DOPE) and the reference lipid DSPC, were studied by multivariate analysis to evaluate their impact on the compressibility coefficient of the monolayers. The cholesterol level was found to be the most significant variable for DSPE blends while the ratio ρ was the most significant one for DOPE blend monolayers. It was also found that these two variables can exhibit positive interaction and the same compressibility value can be obtained with different blend compositions.     

The analysis of serum effects on structure, size and toxicity of DDAB-DOPE and DC-Chol-DOPE lipoplexes contributes to explain their different transfection efficiency

The effect of serum on structural properties of dimethyl-dioctadecyl-ammonium bromide (DDAB)–1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) liposomes and DDAB–DOPE/DNA lipoplexes has been investigated by energy dispersive X-ray diffraction (EDXD) technique, at different cationic lipid/DNA weight ratios (ρ). The role of serum on the size of lipoplexes has also been studied by dynamic light scattering. Lipoplex transfection efficiency (TE) as a function of ρ, and lipoplex toxicity to C6 rat glioma cells have been evaluated in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM) with and without serum. A multi-parametric analysis concerning the role of size, structure and cytotoxicity on transfection efficiency contributes to explain the experimental observation that 3β-[N-(N′,N′-dimethylaminoethane)carbamoyl]-cholesterol (DC-Chol)–DOPE/DNA transfect C6 cells better than DDAB–DOPE/DNA lipoplexes.     

Novel hybrid vesicles co-assembled from a cationic lipid and PAAc-g-mPEG with pH-triggered transmembrane channels for controlled drug release

This work presents an important example of novel hybrid vesicles with pH-triggered transmembrane channels prepared by co-assembly of poly(acrylic acid)-g-poly(monomethoxy ethylene glycol) (PAAc-g-mPEG) with a cationic lipid, didodecyldimethylammonium bromide (DDAB), via electrostatic interaction for effective doxorubicin (DOX) release.     

Evaluation of asymmetric liposomal nanoparticles for encapsulation of polynucleotides

Conventional lipid bilayer liposomes have similar inner and outer leaflet compositions; asymmetric liposomes have different lipid leaflet compositions. The goal of this work is to place cationic lipids in the inner leaflet to encapsulate negatively charged polynucleotides and to place neutral/anionic lipids on the outer leaflet to decrease nonspecific cellular uptake/toxicity. Inverse emulsion particles have been developed with a single lipid leaflet of cationic and neutral lipids surrounding an aqueous core containing a negatively charged 21-mer DNA oligo. The particles are accelerated through an oil-water interface, entrapping a second neutral lipid to form oligo encapsulated unilamellar liposome nanoparticles. Inverse emulsion particles can be consistently produced to encapsulate an aqueous environment containing negatively charged oligo. The efficiency of encapsulated liposome formation is low and depends on the hydrocarbon used as the oil phase. Dodecane, mineral oil, and squalene were tested, and squalene, a branched hydrocarbon, yielded the highest efficiency.     

Physicochemical properties affecting lipofection potency of a new series of 1,2-dialkoylamidopropane-based cationic lipids

The in vitro transfection activity of a novel series of N,N'-diacyl-1,2-diaminopropyl-3-carbamoyl-(aminoethane) derivatives was evaluated against a mouse melanoma cell line at different +/- charge ratios, in the presence and absence of helper lipids. Only the unsaturated derivative N,N'-dioleoyl-1,2-diaminopropyl-3-carbamoyl-(aminoethane), (1,2lmp[5]) mediated significant increase in the reporter gene level which was significantly boosted in the presence of DOPE peaking at +/- charge ratio of 2. The electrostatic interactions between the cationic liposomes and plasmid DNA were investigated by gel electrophoresis, fluorescence spectroscopy, dynamic light scattering and electrophoretic mobility techniques. In agreement with the transfection results, 1,2lmp[5]/DOPE formulation was most efficient in associating with and retarding DNA migration. The improved association between the dioleoyl derivative and DNA was further confirmed by ethidium bromide displacement assay and particle size distribution analysis of the lipoplexes. Differential scanning calorimetry studies showed that 1,2lmp[5] was the only lipid that exhibited a main phase transition below 37 degrees C. Likewise, 1,2lmp[5] was the only lipid found to form all liquid expanded monolayers at 23 degrees C. In conclusion, the current findings suggest that high in vitro transfection activity is mediated by cationic lipids characterized by increased acyl chain fluidity and high interfacial elasticity.     

Structure–Function Relationships of New Lipids Designed for DNA Transfection

Cationic liposome/DNA complexes can be used as nonviral vectors for direct delivery of DNA‐based biopharmaceuticals to damaged cells and tissues. To obtain more effective and safer liposome‐based gene transfection systems, two cationic lipids with identical head groups but different chain structures are investigated with respect to their in vitro gene‐transfer activity, their cell‐damaging characteristics, and their physicochemical properties. The gene‐transfer activities of the two lipids are very different. Differential scanning calorimetry and synchrotron small‐ and wide‐angle X‐ray scattering give valuable structural insight. A subgel‐like structure with high packing density and high phase‐transition temperature from gel to liquid‐crystalline state are found for lipid 7 (N′‐2‐[(2,6‐diamino‐1‐oxohexyl)amino]ethyl‐2,N‐bis(hexadecyl)propanediamide) containing two saturated chains. Additionally, an ordered head‐group lattice based on formation of a hydrogen‐bond network is present. In contrast, lipid 8 (N′‐2‐[(2,6‐diamino‐1‐oxohexyl)amino]ethyl‐2‐hexadecyl‐N‐[(9Z)‐octadec‐9‐enyl]propanediamide) with one unsaturated and one saturated chain shows a lower phase‐transition temperature and a reduced packing density. These properties enhance incorporation of the helper lipid cholesterol needed for gene transfection. Both lipids, either pure or in mixtures with cholesterol, form lamellar phases, which are preserved after addition of DNA. However, the system separates into phases containing DNA and phases without DNA. On increasing the temperature, DNA is released and only a lipid phase without intercalated DNA strands is observed. The conversion temperatures are very different in the two systems studied. The important parameter seems to be the charge density of the lipid membranes, which is a result of different solubility of cholesterol in the two lipid membranes. Therefore, different binding affinities of the DNA to the lipid mixtures are achieved.     

Dynamic interaction between oppositely charged vesicles: aggregation, lipid mixing, and disaggregation

We investigated dynamic interactions between oppositely charged small unilamellar vesicles using positively charged vesicles containing 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium-propane or 3beta-[N-(N('),N(')-dimethylaminoethane)-carbamoyl] cholesterol and negatively charged vesicles containing L-alpha-phosphatidyl-DL-glycerol. Aggregation, lipid bilayer mixing, contents mixing and contents leakage were systematically examined using optical density measurements, fluorescence resonance energy transfer assays, fluorescence quenching assays, light-scattering analyses, and freeze-fracture transmission electron microscopy. The oppositely charged vesicles aggregated immediately. Lipid mixing was observed, but there was no mixing of the contents. The vesicle aggregates disaggregated spontaneously after several minutes. The surface potential of the disaggregated vesicles was neutralized. From these results, we infer that the lipids in the external monolayers were exchanged between the oppositely charged vesicles while the internal monolayers remained intact. The two types of cationic lipids used exhibited different speeds of disaggregation.     

Cationic lipo-thiophosphoramidates for gene delivery: synthesis, physico-chemical characterization and gene transfection activity--comparison with lipo-phosphoramidates

The synthesis of cationic lipo-thiophosphoramidates, a new family of cationic lipids designed for gene delivery, is reported herein. This new class of lipids is less polar than its oxygenated equivalent the lipo-phosphoramidates. Fluorescence anisotropy and FRET were used to determine the fluidity and fusogenicity of the lipo-phosphoramidates 3a-b and lipo-thiophosphoramidates 7a-b. The determination of both the size and the zeta potential of the nano-objects (liposomes and lipoplexes) and the determination of the DNA binding ability of the liposomes have completed the physico-chemical characterizations of the cationic lipids studied. Finally, the cationic lipids 3a-b and 7a-c have been evaluated as synthetic vectors for gene transfection into a variety of mammalian cell lines. The lipo-thiophosphoramidate 7a proved to be an efficient and low toxicity synthetic vector even when used at low lipid to DNA charge ratios.