Teachers’ views on creativity in mathematics education: an international survey

The survey described in this paper was developed in order to gain an understanding of culturally-based aspects of creativity associated with secondary school mathematics across six participating countries. All participating countries acknowledge the importance of creativity in mathematics, yet the data show that they take very different approaches to teaching creatively and enhancing students’ creativity. Approximately 1,100 teachers from six countries (Cyprus, India, Israel, Latvia, Mexico, and Romania) participated in a 100-item questionnaire addressing teachers’ conceptions about: (1) Who is a creative student in mathematics, (2) Who is a creative mathematics teacher, (3) In what way is creativity in mathematics related to culture, and (4) Who is a creative person. We present responses to each conception focusing on differences between teachers from different countries. We also analyze relationships among teachers’ conceptions of creativity and their experience, and educational level. Based on factor analysis of the collected data we discuss relevant relationships among different components of teachers’ conceptions of creativity as they emerge in countries with different cultures.     

Cross-national studies on the teaching and learning of mathematics: where do we go from here?

While the prevailing research interest in East–West comparative studies still seems to be on explaining the superior performance of East Asian students, the time has come for researchers from both areas to focus on what countries can learn from one another. This commentary cites some of the most significant lessons learned from the papers in this special issue and asks additional research questions that might be worth pursuing. However, learning does not end in articulating similarities and differences between cultures and adopting the best practices that these cultures offer. It is hoped that countries will continue to work for increased partnerships and collaboration, greater understanding, and deeper appreciation of individual countries’ uniqueness with the end goal of improving the quality of mathematics teaching and learning for all.     

Time allocated to mathematics in post-primary schools in Ireland: are we in double trouble?

Mathematics educators and legislators worldwide have begun placing a greater emphasis on teaching mathematics for understanding and through the use of real-life applications. Revised curricula have led to the time allocated to mathematics in effected countries being scrutinised. This has resulted in policy-makers and educationalists worldwide calling for the inclusion of double class periods on the mathematics timetable. Research from the United States suggests that the introduction of double or block periods allow for the objectives of revised curricula to be realized. The aim of this study, which is set in the school context, is first to ascertain if schools in Ireland are scheduling double periods for mathematics at both lower post-primary level (Junior Cycle) and upper post-primary level (Senior Cycle). It also seeks to determine if there is a link between teachers’ levels of satisfaction with the time allocated to mathematics and the provision of double periods and to get insights from teachers in relation to their opinions on what can be achieved through the introduction of such classes. Questionnaires were sent to 400 post-primary schools (approximately 1600 teachers) which were selected using stratified sampling techniques. It was found that 8.7% of mathematics teachers reported the provision of double periods at Junior Cycle while 55% reported that double periods were included on their timetable at Senior Cycle. The study also identified a link between teachers’ levels of satisfaction with the time allocated to mathematics and the provision of double periods. Finally, teachers felt that double periods allowed for new teaching methodologies, which were promoted by the revised curricula, to be implemented and teaching for understanding was also more feasible. In essence, it was found that double periods have an influence on the mathematical experience of post-primary students as well as the teaching approaches employed.     

Comparative studies of mathematics teaching: does the means of analysis determine the outcome?

This paper addresses four questions concerning the influence of culture on mathematics teachers’ professional practice. Firstly, drawing on categorical data yielded by the application of low inference coding schedule to video recordings of sequences of lessons taught by case study teachers on four common topics in England, Flanders, Hungary and Spain, we undertook an exploratory factor analysis to examine the ways in which such coded variables interact. This process yielded five factors, each of which was interpretable against the literature and highlighted the extent to which dichotomisations of mathematics teaching as reform or traditional are not necessarily helpful, not least because all project teachers exhibited characteristics of both. Secondly, factors scores were analysed by nationality to reveal culturally located practices resonant with the available literature. Thirdly, cluster analyses yielded four well-defined cross-cultural clusters of episodes, each indicative of particular didactical perspectives that appeared to challenge the exclusivity of these culturally located practices. Finally, the key methodological finding was that the manner in which data are analysed influences greatly the outcomes of comparative mathematics research.     

What do the Chinese value in (mathematics) education?

The achievement in mathematics among the Chinese has aroused the interest of educationalists, sociologists and psychologists worldwide. The coining of the term Confucian Heritage Culture learner??s phenomenon mistakenly led researchers to look for direct attributions from Confucianism, without realizing that Confucianism is just one Chinese school of thought, and it is over-simplistic to draw causal relationships between schools of thought and social phenomena. This paper begins by introducing three major Chinese schools of thought??Confucianism, Daoism and Buddhism??and their views on education. The discussion will then focus on how these schools of thought might impact education in general and mathematics education in particular.     

Assigning mathematics instruction time in secondary schools: what are the influential factors?

Similar to countries such as the Netherlands and the United Kingdom, secondary schools in Ireland can decide how to allocate instruction time between curriculum subjects. Although there are national guidelines available from the Department of Education and Skills (DES), the majority of schools make their own decisions about how much time they allocate to different subjects. This results in variations between the amounts of time allocated to teaching mathematics in different schools and between different year and class groups within the same school. Decisions regarding time allocation are generally taken by the school management. This means that the ethos of the school and the individual opinions of school management can determine the amount of mathematics that students experience throughout their second level education. The aim of this study is to evaluate the most influential factors that management considers when assigning instruction time in Irish secondary schools. For the purpose of this research, seven possible factors were identified and 400 deputy principals from a stratified sample of secondary schools around Ireland were asked to select their top three. Timetabling constraints, the availability of mathematics teachers and the perceived importance of the subject were found to be the most influential factors.     

The relevance of advanced mathematics studies to expertise in secondary school mathematics teaching: practitioners’ views

This study investigates the different ways by which secondary school mathematics teachers view how advanced mathematics studies are relevant to expertise in classroom instruction. Data sources for this study included position papers and written notes from a group interview of 15 Israeli teachers who studied in a special master’s program, of which advanced mathematics courses comprise a sizeable share. Data analysis was iterative and comparative, aiming at identifying and characterizing teachers’ different perspectives. Overall, all participating teachers thought that the advanced mathematics studies in the program were relevant to their teaching of secondary school mathematics. Moreover, teachers specifically mentioned the importance of studying contemporary mathematics from research mathematicians. All teachers pointed out at least one specific feature that they viewed as relevant to their work: advanced mathematics courses (1) as a resource for teaching secondary school mathematics, (2) for improving understanding about what mathematics is, and (3) for reminding teachers what learning mathematics feels like.     

Cross-national comparisons of mathematics curriculum materials: what might we learn?

In most of the world, there is a broad public interest in cross-national comparisons. Despite the myriad difficulties inherent in such comparisons, and despite the fact that most studies explicitly acknowledge limited generalizability, news media representatives, policy makers, politicians and educators often take the findings at face value as providing solid scientific evidence of the achievement of students in the countries studied. This often leads in turn to superficial commentaries and unhelpful recommendations. Our task as scholars of mathematics education is to demonstrate the nuanced complexity of such comparisons. The papers in this issue of ZDM succeed in this regard. Using a range of scholarly perspectives (mathematical, psychological and socio-cultural), the authors offer many insightful observations regarding curriculum and curriculum materials in East Asian countries (especially China) and the USA, with careful attention to the central role of curriculum in the teaching and learning of mathematics in schools. In this commentary study I discuss a few of these insights and develop one illustrative example of how cross-national comparative analyses such as these could be used to sensibly inform policy discussions related to changes in mathematics curriculum, teaching, or teacher preparation.     

Predictive factors of students’ motivation to succeed in introductory mathematics courses: evidence from higher education in the UAE

The purpose of the study is to examine whether there is a significant relationship between students’ motivation to succeed in introductory mathematics courses offered by universities in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) as the dependent variable of the research and another five independent variables including cognitive mathematics self-concept, affective mathematics self-concept, extrinsic motivation as expectations of future career and income, students’ age and the number of mathematics courses taken by students. The rationale of the study is based on the significance of mathematics achievements for students and academic institutions in particular, as well as for the society in general. The study is designed based on a quantitative research methodology and a sample of 685 students participated in completing a survey questionnaire. The sample is drawn from students who were registered in different introductory mathematics courses at four academic institutions of higher education in the UAE. The quantitative correlation analysis among students’ motivation, cognitive mathematics self-concept, affective mathematics self-concept, extrinsic motivation, students’ age and the number of mathematics courses taken by students reveals theoretically consistent interrelationships. The quantitative multiple regression analysis indicates that the five independent variables explain 71.3% of the variation in students’ motivation to succeed in introductory mathematics courses.     

From design-based research to re-sourcing ‘in the wild’: reflections on studies of the co-evolution of mathematics teaching resources and practices

This commentary paper looks across the studies of the design and use of mathematics teaching resources included in this issue. It analyses everyday and educational notions of resource; particularly how usage of that term varies across the papers. Key characteristics of each study are identified and the studies are organized into five broad groups representing different lines of investigation of resource design and use. Across the studies, the broad notion of appropriation is influential in conceptualizing user/tool relations, with the instrumental/documentational approach particularly prominent, although close inspection shows that researchers draw on this in different ways. A majority of the studies relate to professional development interventions in a context of large-scale reform efforts, offering insights into a range of approaches to providing practical support for teacher appropriation of resources. One study investigates the resource systems established by ordinary teachers: alongside other research, this highlights the challenges of a re-sourcing approach in which teachers collaborate to curate a localized resource system, and points to conditions which are conducive to the success of such efforts.     

Back to the future? Children living in poverty,early childhood centres and mathematics education

The present call for structured mathematics programmes in preschools continues a trend from the nineteenth century, in which young children’s lack of mathematical knowledge was considered to have a detrimental effect on their individual futures and those of the wider society. In this paper, an investigation of the philosophies behind several early childhood programmes shows that there is a long-standing acceptance that those not living in poverty should make decisions about the education, including the mathematics education, that children who are living in poverty should engage in. Consequently, the philosophies behind these programmes, and with them the advocated mathematics education, contribute to a homogenised view of the child. This fails to recognise the attributes that children and their communities have and situates those living in poverty as being deviant. The strong promotion in this century of structured mathematics education programmes is solidifying this homogenising process in a manner not seen in previous early childhood programmes.     

How is cultural influence manifested in the formation of mathematics textbooks? A comparative case study of resource book series between Shanghai and England

Focusing on issues about the development of mathematics textbooks from a cultural perspective, this study examined a widely-used curriculum resource series, One Lesson One Exercise, published in China, and its adapted English series, published in the UK, to explore how cultural influence is manifested in the two series of resource books. For the study we established a conceptual framework classifying culture into six types in relation to people’s beliefs, values and ways of interacting about them, for data collection and analysis. The results indicate that there exist considerable differences between the Chinese and the English series that are related to cultural factors. It appears that, to a large extent, culture plays an essential role in the development of mathematics textbooks. Concerning the different types of culture, the results show that most adaptations between the Chinese series and the English series are related to ‘ways of behaving and customs’ and ‘artifacts, flora and fauna’, followed by ‘identities’ and ‘geography’, and the least are related to ‘organisations’ and ‘history’. Based on the study, we argue that the relevance and importance of culture to the development of mathematics textbooks must not be underestimated, and more research in this direction is needed.     

How well prepared are the teachers of tomorrow? An examination of prospective mathematics teachers' pedagogical content knowledge

There is a growing emphasis in the teaching profession on pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) as an important knowledge component. The study reported in this article investigates Turkish prospective mathematics teachers’ mathematics teaching knowledge in the numbers content domain. A series of 10 open-ended scenario-type questions were adopted to challenge 83 prospective mathematics teachers’ knowledge of the learner and presentation of content in the context of PCK. The participants’ responses were analysed by means of rubrics and scoring guides developed by the researchers. The results showed that many of the future teachers performed well in determining what misconceptions students might express in the given scenarios. However, a majority of the participants performed poorly on presentation of content in terms of instructional strategies. In line with these results, the authors offer some suggestions for teacher training programmes.     

Computer use in mathematics education – present situation,intentions, and problems in the Federal Republic of Germany†

Computers, and computer‐related thinking structures, are only gradually influencing mathematics education. On the one hand, there is a discrepancy between involved teachers who already have changed their own classroom teaching to a great extent, and a majority of mathematics teachers who have not yet taken notice of the computer for teaching purposes. On the other hand, knowledge of the computer and of algorithms is frequently merely added to the mathematical subject matter. As opposed to that, the authors argue that it is necessary to genuinely integrate such subject matter, and to include general topics such as social impact and changed attitudes toward application. With regard to implementation, they develop concrete ideas which are aligned in a differentiated manner to the specific situation and the opportunities offered in the Federal Republic of Germany. The rationale for that is that only such reference to a specific situation will provide an opportunity for readers abroad to usefully apply approaches and ideas to the situation given in their own cultural environment.

An abbreviated version of this paper for cursory reading or other purposes has been marked by bold lines on the margin.

     

School mathematics and creativity at the elementary and middle-grade levels: how are they related?

In this study, we evaluated students’ creativity, as expressed in the solution methods of three problems for groups of students in different grades. Posing the same problems to students of similar (advanced) mathematical abilities in different grades allowed us to look for possible connections between creativity and mathematical knowledge. The findings indicate that at the elementary school level, the number of solution methods and creativity scores increased with age. The collective methods space of the eighth graders seemed to narrow almost exclusively to algebraic methods, but the increase in the number of solutions was renewed in the ninth grade.     

Place and use of new technology in the teaching of mathematics: ICMI activities in the past 25 years

Looking back at the place of technology in the past ICMEs during the last decades and on the two ICMI studies devoted to technology, it is obvious that the role and use of technology has given rise to a diversity of points of view and attitudes across the world. The ICMEs and the two studies are places where researchers, teacher educators and practitioners meet. To what extent do they reflect the evolution of the trends of research and/or of integration of technology into real practice? The study will develop a general analysis of the theoretical frameworks, issues and wishes related to the use of technology in mathematics teaching from the proceedings of past ICMEs and of the two ICMI studies. Both a quantitative and a qualitative point of view will be adopted. From the great diversity of questions and approaches, the study attempts to formulate the main trends and their evolution over time within the ICMI community, as well as some pertinent issues for the coming years.