Engineering students’ conceptions of the derivative and some implications for their mathematical education

This paper explores Mechanical Engineering students’ conceptions of and preferences for conceptions of the derivative, and their views on mathematics. Data comes from pre-, post- and delayed post-tests, a preference test, interviews with students and an analysis of calculus courses. Data from Mathematics students is used to make comparisons with Mechanical Engineering students. The results show that Mechanical Engineering students’ conceptions of and preferences for the derivative develop in the direction of the rate of change aspects while those of Mathematics students develop in the direction of tangent aspects, and that Mechanical Engineering students view mathematics as a tool and want the application aspects in their course. Students’ developing conceptions, preferences and views with regard to teaching and departmental affiliation are considered and educational implications are suggested for the mathematical education of engineering students.     

Broadening the sense of ‘dynamic’: a microworld to support students’ mathematical generalisation

In this paper, we seek to broaden the sense in which the word ‘dynamic’ is applied to computational media. Focussing exclusively on the problem of design, the paper describes work in progress, which aims to build a computational system that supports students’ engagement with mathematical generalisation in a collaborative classroom environment by helping them to begin to see its power and to express it for themselves and for others. We present students’ strengths and challenges in appreciating structure and expressing generalities that inform our overall system design. We then describe the main features of the microworld that lies at the core of our system. In conclusion, we point to further steps in the design process to develop a system that is more adaptive to students’ and teachers’ actions and needs.     

A tale of mathematical myth-making: E T Bell and the ‘arithmetization of algebra’

Throughout E T Bell’s writings on mathematics, both those aimed at other mathematicians and those for a popular audience, we find him endeavouring to promote abstract algebra generally, and the postulational method in particular. Bell evidently felt that the adoption of the latter approach to algebra (a process that he termed the ‘arithmetization of algebra’) would lend the subject something akin to the level of rigour that analysis had achieved in the nineteenth century. However, despite promoting this point of view, it is not so much in evidence in Bell’s own mathematical work. I offer an explanation for this apparent contradiction in terms of Bell’s infamous penchant for mathematical ‘myth-making’.     

Researching young students’ mathematical world views

As an alternative to questionnaires suitable for young students, pictures, texts and interviews are used as data sources for studying mathematical world views of fifth and sixth graders in a several-step design. The project was developed in three successive studies. In the first study, the approach of using pictures, texts and interviews for researching young students’ mathematical world views was investigated. Object of the second study was the development of an interrater-method for determining mathematical world views which delivered a satisfactory degree of reliability. The empirical results in the second study indicated as well that quite often mathematics courses were dominated by a view on mathematics emphasizing numbers or calculations. An analysis of students’ utterances suggests that some young students might have mixed world views. This motivates a modified rating approach in a third study in which raters can give weights to several world views. The procedure indicates that various mixed forms of the world views can be observed. This brings up the question as to whether this phenomenon is due to the methodology or whether it describes the formation of mathematical world views at that age.     

Students’ conceptions of mathematics as sensible: Towards the SCOMAS framework

In this article I describe the development of a framework for considering students’ conceptions about the sensible nature of mathematics. I begin by using extant literature on conceptions of mathematics to develop a framework of action-oriented indicators that students’ conceive of mathematics as sensible. I then use classroom data to modify and illustrate the framework. The result is a coding framework, grounded in the literature, which can be used to assess the enacted conceptions of mathematics as sensible of a group of students. This work also provides a conceptual framework, grounded in classroom data, of the dimensions of these conceptions.     

Expanding conceptions of utility: middle school students’ perspectives on the usefulness of mathematics

This research explores how adolescents conceptualize the usefulness of mathematics. Integrating sociocultural theory with the study of utility value, this study uses open-ended survey items and interview tasks to examine conceptions of usefulness among a group of predominantly Latinx middle school students. Findings reveal that students primarily conceptualized the usefulness of mathematics in two ways. First, students considered the applicability of mathematics content, focusing on applications of mathematics in everyday life and future jobs/careers. Second, students considered the usefulness of features of the learning experience, such as the form of interaction and structure of the activity. Both conceptions are compared to existing conceptions of usefulness in the literature, and implications for classroom practice and future research are discussed.     

Students’ mathematical work on absolute value: focusing on conceptions,errors and obstacles

ZDM – Mathematics Education - This study investigates students’ conceptions of absolute value (AV), their performance in various items on AV, their errors in these items and the...     

Influence of the multiplicity of the roots on the basins of attraction of Newton’s method

In this work, we develop and implement two algorithms for plotting and computing the measure of the basins of attraction of rational maps defined on the Riemann sphere. These algorithms are based on the subdivisions of a cubical decomposition of a sphere and they have been made by using different computational environments. As an application, we study the basins of attraction of the fixed points of the rational functions obtained when Newton’s method is applied to a polynomial with two roots of multiplicities m and n. We focus our attention on the analysis of the influence of the multiplicities m and n on the measure of the two basins of attraction. As a consequence of the numerical results given in this work, we conclude that, if m > n, the probability that a point in the Riemann Sphere belongs to the basin of the root with multiplicity m is bigger than the other case. In addition, if n is fixed and m tends to infinity, the probability of reaching the root with multiplicity n tends to zero.     

On students’ conceptions of arithmetic average: the case of inference from a fixed total

There is more to understanding the concept of mean than simply knowing and applying the add-them-up and divide algorithm. In the following, we discuss a component of understanding the mean – inference from a fixed total – that has been largely ignored by researchers studying students understanding of mean. We add this component to the list of types of reasoning needed to understand mean and discuss student responses to tasks designed to elicit this component of reasoning. These responses reveal that inference from a fixed total reasoning is rare even in advance high school students.     

Undergraduate students’ initial conceptions of factorials

Counting problems offer rich opportunities for students to engage in mathematical thinking, but they can be difficult for students to solve. In this paper, we present a study that examines student thinking about one concept within counting, factorials, which are a key aspect of many combinatorial ideas. In an effort to better understand students’ conceptions of factorials, we conducted interviews with 20 undergraduate students. We present a key distinction between computational versus combinatorial conceptions, and we explore three aspects of data that shed light on students’ conceptions (their initial characterizations, their definitions of 0!, and their responses to Likert-response questions). We present implications this may have for mathematics educators both within and separate from combinatorics.     

Holistic oil field value management: using system dynamics for ‘intermediate level’ and ‘value-based’ modelling in the oil industry

System dynamics has been seen primarily as a strategic tool, most effectively used at the highest level of strategy to identify robust policy interventions under a wide range of scenarios. However, an alternative, complementary and powerful role is emerging. This is at an ‘intermediate level’ in organisations to coordinate and integrate policies across the value chain. It is at this level where business value, as defined by the discounted value of future free cash flow, is both created and destroyed. This paper introduces the need for ‘intermediate-level’ and ‘value-based’ modelling and emphasises the natural role of system dynamics in supporting a methodology to fulfil the need. It describes the development of an approach and its application in the oil industry to coordinate the response of people and tools within operational, financial and commercial functions across the value chain to address a variety of problems and issues.     

‘I’m worried about the correctness’: undergraduate students as producers of screencasts of mathematical explanations for their peers – lecturer and student perceptions

Undergraduate mathematics is traditionally designed and taught by content experts with little contribution from students. Indeed, there are signs that there is resistance from mathematics lecturers to involve students in the creation of material to support their peers – notwithstanding the fact that students have been successfully engaged as co-creators of material in other disciplines. There appears to be little research into what issues may lead to reservations to using student-created content in mathematics learning. This paper takes a case study approach to investigate the reasons for lecturers’ resistance to undergraduate student contributions to learning material, in particular with a view to the production of screencasts of mathematical explanations. It also investigates the views of students producing mathematical screencasts. This study is part of a larger research project investigating undergraduate involvement in mathematics module design. Four second-year students, who were producing mathematics screencasts as part of an internship, and five academics, were interviewed to gain an understanding of their views of the value of student screencasts. The interviews focused on the particular contributions students make to screencasts, outcomes for the students and level of lecturer acceptance of these resources. We argue that students benefit from creating screencasts for their peers by gaining deeper mathematical understanding, improved technological skills and developing other generic skills required of today's graduates. In contrast, we confirm lecturer resistance to using student-generated screencasts in their teaching materials. Lecturer reservations pertain to students’ lack of mathematical maturity and concerns over the mathematical integrity of the content that students produce. We conclude that close collaboration between students and lecturers during the design and production phases of screencasts may help lecturers overcome reservations, whilst preserving the benefits for students. In addition, we provide evidence that the process is a valuable professional development opportunity for the lecturers themselves.     

Basic modelling of uncertainty: young students’ mental models

This paper focuses on a research programme that aims to explore students?? mental models when acting within elementary situations of uncertainty before stochastics have been addressed in school. In order to frame our research, we begin by reporting briefly on the recent history of research in stochastics education. Then, we discuss the main aspects of our theoretical foundation concerning the research programme. Afterwards we restrict our discussion to an exploratory study aiming to further develop our theoretical framework, describing the development of tasks representing situations of uncertainty and the method of the exploratory study involving students of grade 4 and grade 6. Finally, from the perspective of theory development, we discuss the results of analysing students?? solutions gained through quantitative analysis of tests and qualitative analysis of written rationales and of interviews. We conclude our paper with a discussion of our research results and potential future research questions.     

On the use of computational tools to promote students’ mathematical thinking

This column will publish short (from just a few paragraphs to ten or so pages), lively and intriguing computer-related mathematics vignettes. These vignettes or snapshots should illustrate ways in which computer environments have transformed the practice of mathematics or mathematics pedagogy. They could also include puzzles or brain-teasers involving the use of computers or computational theory. Snapshots are subject to peer review. In this snapshot students employ dynamic geometry software to find great mathematical richness around a seemingly simple question about rectangles.

Editor: Uri Wilensky

相似文献   

Farkas’ lemma: three decades of generalizations for mathematical optimization

In this paper we present a survey of generalizations of the celebrated Farkas’s lemma, starting from systems of linear inequalities to a broad variety of non-linear systems. We focus on the generalizations which are targeted towards applications in continuous optimization. We also briefly describe the main applications of generalized Farkas’ lemmas to continuous optimization problems.     

Solution representations of percentage change problems: the pre-service primary teachers’ mathematical thinking and reasoning

Solution representations can reveal how problem solvers communicate mathematical thinking and reasoning in problem-solving process. The present study examined the solution representations used by 20 pre-service teachers for the percentage change problems. The pre-service teachers were invited to solve a combination of simple and complex percentage change problems. The score for the majority of simple problems was 75% or above, but the score for the complex problems was below 75%. The highest percentage error occurred when the pre-service teachers encountered a percentage greater than 100% in the percentage change problems. Irrespective of their level of mathematics qualifications, the equation approach demonstrating two-step problem-solving process was the predominant strategy adopted by the pre-service teachers. The equation approach imposes low cognitive load and, therefore, is more accessible and efficient than the unitary approach. A few pre-service teachers used the unitary approach. The findings indicate that the pre-service teachers possessed relevant mathematical knowledge for percentage change problems. Furthermore, the inclusion of the equation approach in mathematics textbooks would provide an alternative perspective regarding the teaching and learning of percentage change problems.     

A revised theorization of the relationship between teachers’ conceptions of mathematics and its teaching

We assembled the ideas about mathematics and about its teaching which were expressed by mathematicians and mathematics educators into two pairs of ‘official’ (collective) conceptions: mathematics is either static or dynamic, and mathematics teaching is either closed or open. These polar conceptions produce a 4-pair relationship between the conceptions of mathematics and its teaching. The adherence to official conceptions was tapped by a questionnaire encompassing 176 Israeli high school mathematics teachers, aimed at examining the relationship between their conceptions of mathematics and its teaching. The majority of these teachers either hold a single conception in one of the domains or do not adhere to any conception, and a quarter of them hold either the static-closed or dynamic-open pairs of conceptions that prevail among teachers in other countries. Consequently, we define a conception of an entity as a comprehensive and homogenous set of ideas about a particular characteristic or feature of that entity. Reality is that teachers practice their profession without adhering to any official conception, and perhaps are (/to be?/) praised for their reluctance to blindly adopt the clear-cut rigid official conceptions of mathematics and its teaching while maintaining their individual and independent blends of ideas.     

‘I Finally Get It!’: developing mathematical understanding during teacher education

A deep conceptual understanding of elementary mathematics as appropriate for teaching is increasingly thought to be an important aspect of elementary teacher capacity. This study explores preservice teachers’ initial mathematical understandings and how these understandings developed during a mathematics methods course for upper elementary teachers. The methods course was supplemented by a newly designed optional course in mathematics for teaching. Teacher candidates choosing the optional course were initially weaker in terms of mathematical understanding than their peers, yet showed stronger mathematical development after engaging in the extra hours the optional course provided.     

The mathematical background of Lomonosov’s contribution

This is a short overview of the influence of the mathematicians of the Enlightenment on the creative contribution of Mikhaĭlo Lomonosov.     

Classroom interactions that shape the nature of students’ appropriation of a complex mathematical practice

Scholars continue to emphasize the importance of fostering proficiency with mathematical practices as an educational outcome. As teachers attempt to support students in developing these practices, they communicate subtle messages about their nature. However, researchers lack a detailed understanding of the classroom interactions that communicate these messages. To begin to address this gap in the literature, we investigated the relationship between the types of classroom interactions around the mathematical practice of imposing structure and the ways students subsequently engaged in that practice. This led to the identification of three types of classroom interactions that shaped the nature of students’ appropriation of imposing structure: (a) engaging students in the practice, (b) providing different representations of the practice, and (c) reflecting on different instantiations of the practice. Our examination of the nature of these interactions suggests teachers must attend to details as they support students to appropriate mathematical practices in formal learning environments.