A simple subcritical chromatographic test for an extended ODS high performance liquid chromatography column classification

This paper describes a new test designed in subcritical fluid chromatography (SFC) to compare the commercial C18 stationary phase properties. This test provides, from a single analysis of carotenoid pigments, the absolute hydrophobicity, the silanol activity and the steric separation factor of the ODS stationary phases. Both the choice of the analytical conditions and the validation of the information obtained from the chromatographic measurements are detailed. Correlations of the carotenoid test results with results obtained from other tests (Tanaka, Engelhard, Sander and Wise) performed both in SFC and HPLC are discussed. Two separation factors, calculated from the retention of carotenoid pigments used as probe, allowed to draw a first classification diagram. Columns, which present identical chromatographic behaviors are located in the same area on this diagram. This location can be related to the stationary phase properties: endcapping treatments, bonding density, linkage functionality, specific area or silica pore diameter. From the first classification, eight groups of columns are distinguished. One group of polymer coated silica, three groups of polymeric octadecyl phases, depending on the pore size and the endcapping treatment, and four groups of monomeric stationary phases. An additional classification of the four monomeric groups allows the comparison of these stationary phases inside each group by using the total hydrophobicity. One hundred and twenty-nine columns were analysed by this simple and rapid test, which allows a comparison of columns with the aim of helping along their choice in HPLC.     

How to select equivalent and complimentary reversed phase liquid chromatography columns from column characterization databases

Three RP-LC column characterization protocols [Tanaka et al. (1989), Snyder et al. (PQRI, 2002), and NIST SRM 870 (2000)] were evaluated using both Euclidian distance and Principal Components Analysis to evaluate effectiveness at identifying equivalent columns. These databases utilize specific chromatographic properties such as hydrophobicity, hydrogen bonding, shape/steric selectivity, and ion exchange capacity of stationary phases. The chromatographic parameters of each test were shown to be uncorrelated. Despite this, the three protocols were equally successful in identifying similar and/or dissimilar stationary phases.     

Comparison of C18 silica bonded phases selectivity in micellar liquid chromatography

The paper describes a new test designed in micellar LC (MLC) to compare the commercial C18 stationary phase properties. This test provides the total hydrophobicity, hydrophilicity, steric selectivity, hydrogen bonding, and ion‐exchange capacity properties calculation of the ODS stationary phases. Both the test compounds and chromatographic separation conditions choice for column characterization in MLC are detailed. The chromatographic performance of several stationary phases that are used in MLC was evaluated with specific chromatographic test comprising nine test compounds, possessing different physico‐chemical properties, which were injected on different supports with two micellar mobile phases: one at pH 7.0 (0.075 mol/L SDS and 1.5% v/v 1‐pentanol), and other at pH 2.7 (0.075 mol/L SDS and 1.5% v/v 1‐pentanol adjusted to pH by TFA). Fundamental column chromatographic properties were obtained under these conditions and were treated by hierarchical cluster analysis. From the results of cluster analysis, two closely related groups of columns are distinguished, and it was shown that the chosen column characteristic parameters allow characterizing both sorbent and micellar chromatographic system properties. Eleven columns were analyzed by this test, which allows a comparison of columns with the aim of the selection of suitable and analogous column for the analysis with MLC.     

Facilitated column selection in pharmaceutical analyses using a simple column classification system

In this paper, the performance of a previously developed classification system applied to pharmaceutical chromatographic analyses, is investigated. The separation of seven different drug substances from their respective impurities was studied. The chromatographic procedure for acetylsalicylic acid, clindamycin hydrochloride, buflomedil hydrochloride, chloramphenicol sodium succinate, nimesulide and phenoxymethylpenicillin was performed according to the corresponding European Pharmacopoeia (Ph. Eur.) monograph. The separation of dihydrostreptomycin sulphate was performed according to the literature. It is shown that the column ranking system is a helpful tool in the selection of a suitable column in these analyses.     

色谱柱选择对23种防腐剂测定结果的影响

以化妆品中23种防腐剂检测方法为例,探讨色谱柱选择对液相色谱方法测定结果的影响。参照《化妆品安全技术规范》甲基异噻唑啉酮等23个组分的检验方法,在2台不同的高效液相色谱仪上用15款不同品牌、型号的C₁₈色谱柱检测23种防腐剂,计算色谱峰的理论塔板数和分离度,对23种组分的分离效果进行分析,并应用USP (United States Pharmacopeia)数据库和PQRI (Product Quality Research Institute)数据库等2种等效色谱柱选择方法,对不同色谱柱的分离效果及等效性进行评价和预测。实验结果表明,15款色谱柱对23种防腐剂的分离效果差异显著,仅有2款色谱柱可以实现23种组分的完全分离。USP和PQRI数据库中2种等效色谱柱选择方法均无法预测出合适的等效色谱柱,对23种防腐剂的液相色谱分析参考价值均较小。色谱柱是影响23种防腐剂液相色谱法测定结果准确性的关键因素,有关实验室在应用该方法时,应考虑色谱柱选择性差异。化妆品基质复杂,如何在现有研究成果的基础上,开发色谱柱的筛选和预测评价体系,进而指导实际样品的分离是下一步研究的重点、难点。建议有关部门在制修订检测方法时,注重色谱柱的耐用性考察,完善系统适应性指标,细化色谱柱分类和增加描述信息,指导色谱柱的合理选择,从而规避由于色谱柱使用过程中选择依据缺失而导致测定结果不准确的风险。     

Chromatographic characterisation of a novel type of monolithic methylsilsesquioxane-based HPLC column

A novel monolithic methylsilsesquioxane-based material with hierarchical pore structure was prepared and tested for its applicability as stationary phase for RP-HPLC. The monolithic material is produced using sol-gel chemistry according to a proprietary protocol developed in our working group. A procedure for the production of HPLC columns from the self-contained monolithic material is described. The chromatographic performance and the reproducibility of the column production was tested using the procedures of the widely accepted Tanaka test and suitable parts of the Engelhardt test which were applied to a set of four monolithic columns produced under identical conditions. The test proved the excellent hydrophobic selectivity and silanophilic behaviour of the new stationary phase material. According to the tests on steric and shape selectivity, there are strong indications that this type of material also acts as restricted access material. This assumption is further supported by the presence of a high fraction of micropores as was evidenced by physical characterisation of the material. The novel stationary phase material showed great potential for the separation of small apolar substances and was found to be particularly useful in the separation of basic compounds due its excellent silanophilic interaction.     

The comparison of two column classification systems during the chromatographic analysis of steroids

Nowadays, due to the availability of hundreds of brands of reversed-phase liquid chromatographic columns, the selection of suitable columns can be difficult. Therefore, a good characterization and classification system is very important. Among published papers, the classification system based on quantitative structure-retention relationships and a method developed at the Katholieke Universiteit Leuven also exist. In quantitative structure-retention relationships, retention is evaluated in terms of the chemical structure of the analytes and the physicochemical properties of both the stationary and mobile phase. The second system allows to rank columns due to the values of four parameters and the calculation of specific F(KUL)-values for a reference column and to be compared with others. In this paper, the classification systems based both on quantitative structure-retention relationships and the F(KUL)-values using principal components analysis were compared. Moreover, the proposed column ranking systems have been checked in clinical practice case considering liquid chromatography determination of six steroid hormones in urine samples. Despite that the matching of both methods is not exactly the same, both classification systems provide simple, reliable and comparable results.     

Development and validation of an improved liquid chromatographic method for the analysis of dirithromycin

The official method for the determination of dirithromycin and related substances in the European Pharmacopoeia (Ph. Eur.) and in the United States Pharmacopeia (USP) is an isocratic liquid chromatographic (LC) method using an ODS column. With this method, the separation of the main component dirithromycin from its epimer is not complete. Moreover, this method suffers sometimes from drift of the baseline and from subsequent quantitation problems. The required resolution is not easy to obtain.

Using an adapted method derived from the one prescribed in the pharmacopoeias, the selectivity of a set of more than 40 reversed-phase columns towards dirithromycin components was investigated. The selection of the most suitable column was achieved by the chromatographic response function (CRF) approach. Several changes were introduced to the method in order to improve the separation and to overcome the baseline drift problem. The resulting method uses a Zorbax Extend column maintained at 30 °C and a mobile phase containing acetonitrile, methanol, 2-propanol, water and a phosphate buffer at pH 7.5. The method allows a good separation of dirithromycin components, which is much better than that obtained with the existing methods. Several impurities of unknown identity are also separated. The method shows good repeatability, linearity and sensitivity, and it is robust. In addition, it proved to be applicable to a wide number of C18 reversed-phase columns.     

Selection of reversed-phase liquid chromatographic columns with diverse selectivity towards the potential separation of impurities in drugs

To select appropriate stationary phases from the continuously expanding supply of potentially suitable HPLC columns, the properties of 28 frequently applied stationary phases were determined by measuring several chromatographic parameters. From these results, based on chromatographic expertise, eight stationary phases with different properties and selectivities were selected. The aim of this study is to apply chemometric tools to evaluate the initially selected set of columns, i.e. a more systematic approach for making such a selection is examined. Starting from the information obtained on the 28 stationary phases, the re-evaluation was performed independently based on the chemometric techniques Pareto-optimality, principal component analysis (PCA), and Derringer's desirability functions. The aim was to select a set of efficient columns exhibiting large selectivity differences. The chemometrically selected stationary phases were divided in groups based on hydrophobicity, a critical retention-determining property in reversed-phase chromatography. This allowed to further reducing the selection to three columns. It is demonstrated that the selection by the chemometric approaches in general is fairly comparable with the initial selection.     

Reversed-phase liquid chromatography column testing: robustness study of the test

Choosing the right RPLC column for an actual separation among the more than 600 commercially available ones still represents a real challenge for the analyst particularly when basic solutes are involved. Many tests dedicated to the characterization and the classification of stationary phases have been proposed in the literature and some of them highlighted the need of a better understanding of retention properties to lead to a rational choice of columns. However, unlike classical chromatographic methods, the problem of their robustness evaluation has often been left unaddressed. In the present study, we present a robustness study that was applied to the chromatographic testing procedure we had developed and optimized previously. A design of experiment (DoE) approach was implemented. Four factors, previously identified as potentially influent, were selected and subjected to small controlled variations: solvent fraction, temperature, pH and buffer concentration. As our model comprised quadratic terms instead of a simple linear model, we chose a D-optimal design in order to minimize the experiment number. As a previous batch-to-batch study [K. Le Mapihan, Caractérisation et classification des phases stationnaires utilisées pour l'analyse CPL de produits pharmaceutiques, Ph.D. Thesis, Pierre and Marie Curie University, 2004] had shown a low variability on the selected stationary phase, it was then possible to split the design into two parts, according to the solvent nature, each using one column. Actually, our testing procedure involving assays both with methanol and with acetonitrile as organic modifier, such an approach enabled to avoid a possible bias due to the column ageing considering the number of experiments required (16 + 6 center points). Experimental results were computed thanks to a Partial Least Squares regression procedure, more adapted than the classical regression to handle factors and responses not completely independent. The results showed the behavior of the solutes in relation to their physico-chemical properties and the relevance of the second term degree of our model. Finally, the robust domain of the test has been fairly identified, so that any potential user precisely knows to which extend each experimental parameter must be controlled when our testing procedure is to be implemented.     

Chemometric evaluation of the column classification system during the pharmaceutical analysis of lamotrigine and its related substances

This paper investigates the performance of a column classification system developed at the Katholieke Universiteit Leuven applied to pharmaceutical chromatographic analyses. The liquid chromatography assay of lamotrigine and related compounds was carried out according to the method prescribed in the European Pharmacopoeia monograph, using 28 brands of stationary phases. A ranking was built based on the F _KUL value calculated against the selected reference column, then compared with the column test performance established for the stationary phases studied. Therefore, the system suitability test prescribed by the European Pharmacopoeia in order to distinguish between suitable or unsuitable columns for this analysis was evaluated. Moreover, it was examined whether the classes of the stationary phases, determined using test parameter results, contain either suitable or unsuitable supports for the lamotrigine separation. This assay was performed using chemometric a technique, namely factor analysis.

Development of the HPLC Method for Simultaneous Determination of Lidocaine Hydrochloride and Tribenoside Along with Their Impurities Supported by the QSRR Approach

A new liquid chromatographic (LC) method for simultaneous determination of lidocaine hydrochloride (LH) and tribenoside (TR) along with their related compounds in pharmaceutical preparations is described. Satisfactory LC separation of all analytes after the liquid–liquid extraction (LLE) procedure with ethanol was performed on a C₁₈ column using a gradient elution of a mixture of acetonitrile and 0.1 % orthophosphoric acid as the mobile phase. The procedure was validated according to the ICH guidelines. The limits of detection (LOD) and quantification (LOQ) were 4.36 and 13.21 μg mL^?1 for LH, 7.60 and 23.04 μg mL^?1 for TR, and below 0.11 and 0.33 μg mL^?1 for their impurities, respectively. Intra- and inter-day precision was below 1.97 %, whereas accuracy for all analytes ranged from 98.17 to 101.94 %. The proposed method was sensitive, robust, and specific allowing reliable simultaneous quantification of all mentioned compounds. Moreover, a comparative study of the RP-LC column classification based on the quantitative structure-retention relationships (QSRR) and column selectivity obtained in real pharmaceutical analysis was innovatively applied using factor analysis (FA). In the column performance test, the analysis of LH and TR in the presence of their impurities was carried out according to the developed method with the use of 12 RP-LC stationary phases previously tested under the QSRR conditions. The obtained results confirmed that the classes of the stationary phases selected in accordance with the QSRR models provided comparable separation for LH, TR, and their impurities. Hence, it was concluded that the proposed QSRR approach could be considered a supportive tool in the selection of the suitable column for the pharmaceutical analysis.     

Study of a monolithic silica capillary column coated with poly(octadecyl methacrylate) for the reversed-phase liquid chromatographic separation of some polar and non-polar compounds

The performance of a monolithic silica capillary column coated with poly(octadecyl methacrylate) (ODM column) for the reversed-phase liquid chromatographic separation of some polar and non-polar compounds was studied, and the results were compared to those obtained by using a monolithic silica capillary column modified with octadecylsilyl-(N,N-diethylamino)silane (ODS column). Benzene and naphthalene derivatives, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), steroids, alkyl phthalates, and tocopherol homologues were used as test samples. In general, compounds with aromatic character, rigid and planar structures, and lower length-to-breadth ratios (more compacted structures) seem to have more preference for the polymer coated stationary phase (ODM). Compounds with acidic character have also a higher retention on ODM columns because of the presence of ester groups in the stationary phase. The polymer coated column allowed the separation of some PAHs, alkyl phthalates, steroids, and of beta- and gamma-tocopherol isomers which cannot be separated under the same conditions on ODS columns, while keeping similar column efficiency. These results allowed to suggest ODM columns as a good alternative to conventional ODS columns for reversed-phase liquid chromatography.     

Influence of column characteristics on retention and selectivity in RP-HPLC

Summary Eight commercially available reversed-phase (RP) columns of widely different characteristics were evaluated and compared using the linear solvation energy relationships (LSER). Retention factors of 32 solutes of different types were determined under isocratic conditions using an acetonitrile-water (30∶70) mobile phase. Stationary phase properties were compared by the fitting coefficients of the LSER-based regression equations which are characteristic of the individual stationary phases and represent the extent of various molecular interactions contributing to the retention process. The good agreement between the calculated and measured logk values for different type of compounds support the adequacy and applicability of the LSER model to describe chromatographic retention. Characterization of column performance for the separation of various type of compounds was established by the determination of the different selectivity factors representing hydrophobic selectivity, polar selectivity and specific selectivity.     

Comparison of column properties in reversed-phase chromatography: monolithic, cholesterolic and mixed bonded stationary phases

A commercial Chromolith C18 column and two new stationary phases with mixed ligands bonded on the Kromasil silica gel support, SG-MIX and SG-Chol, were characterized using simple tests based on the retention of non-polar, basic and acidic compounds. Polar and methylene selectivity tests in acetonitrile-water and methanol-water mobile phases revealed lower hydrophobicities of the SG-MIX and SG-Chol columns in comparison to the Chromolith column. The columns were further characterized using new test criteria - gradient oligomer capacity and isomeric selectivity and peak symmetry of naphthalene di-sulphonic acids in aqueous mobile phases. The cholesterolic column shows greater gradient oligomer selectivity for the separation of oligoethylene glycol samples than the SG-MIX and the Chromolith columns. Increased retention and peak tailing, but decreased isomeric selectivity for naphthalene-di-sulphonic acids was observed with the SG-MIX column, because of interactions with various polar bonded groups.     

Temperature effects on nano-LC column packing technology

We investigated the effect of temperature on the packing procedure of nano-LC columns (up to 50 cm) and on their performance. Several slurries of stationary phase were prepared using different solvent mixtures. Their stability was evaluated at several temperatures: 70°C, 50°C, and room temperature. At the higher temperature (70°C) the suspensions resulted to be stable for a longer time. For each slurry, we compared nano-LC columns packed with ultrasounds at 70°C and at room temperature. All the columns were tested with a standard mixture at 70°C, to reduce the solvent viscosity and the backpressure. Main chromatographic parameters such as the asymmetry factor, As, the reduced plate high, h, pattern in a Van Deemter plot, the total porosity, ε(t), and the permeability, k, were calculated and discussed. One of the nano-LC columns was used to separate a mixture of pesticides in a LC-MS system with an electron ionization LC-MS interface (Direct-EI). From our knowledge, this is the first study on the role of temperature in the efficiency of slurry-packing procedure.