A Hybrid Metaheuristic for the Quadratic Assignment Problem

The quadratic assignment problem (QAP) is known to be NP-hard. We propose a hybrid metaheuristic called ANGEL to solve QAP. ANGEL combines the ant colony optimization (ACO), the genetic algorithm (GA) and a local search method (LS). There are two major phases in ANGEL, namely ACO phase and GA phase. Instead of starting from a population that consists of randomly generated chromosomes, GA has an initial population constructed by ACO in order to provide a good start. Pheromone acts as a feedback mechanism from GA phase to ACO phase. When GA phase reaches the termination criterion, control is transferred back to ACO phase. Then ACO utilizes pheromone updated by GA phase to explore solution space and produces a promising population for the next run of GA phase. The local search method is applied to improve the solutions obtained by ACO and GA. We also propose a new concept called the eugenic strategy intended to guide the genetic algorithm to evolve toward a better direction. We report the results of a comprehensive testing of ANGEL in solving QAP. Over a hundred instances of QAP benchmarks were tested and the results show that ANGEL is able to obtain the optimal solution with a high success rate of 90%. This work was supported in part by the National Science Council, R.O.C., under Contract NSC 91-2213-E-005-017.     

Applying an Extended Guided Local Search to the Quadratic Assignment Problem

In this paper, we show how an extended Guided Local Search (GLS) can be applied to the Quadratic Assignment Problem (QAP). GLS is a general, penalty-based meta-heuristic, which sits on top of local search algorithms, to help guide them out of local minima. We present empirical results of applying several extended versions of GLS to the QAP, and show that these extensions can improve the range of parameter settings within which Guided Local Search performs well. Finally, we compare the results of running our extended GLS with some state of the art algorithms for the QAP.     

Extensive Testing of a Hybrid Genetic Algorithm for Solving Quadratic Assignment Problems

A robust search algorithm should ideally exhibit reasonable performance on a diverse and varied set of problems. In an earlier paper Lim et al. (Computational Optimization and Applications, vol. 15, no. 3, 2000), we outlined a class of hybrid genetic algorithms based on the k-gene exchange local search for solving the quadratic assignment problem (QAP). We follow up on our development of the algorithms by reporting in this paper the results of comprehensive testing of the hybrid genetic algorithms (GA) in solving QAP. Over a hundred instances of QAP benchmarks were tested using a standard set of parameters setting and the results are presented along with the results obtained using simple GA for comparisons. Results of our testing on all the benchmarks show that the hybrid GA can obtain good quality solutions of within 2.5% above the best-known solution for 98% of the instances of QAP benchmarks tested. The computation time is also reasonable. For all the instances tested, all except for one require computation time not exceeding one hour. The results will serve as a useful baseline for performance comparison against other algorithms using the QAP benchmarks as a basis for testing.     

A Tabu Search Algorithm for the Quadratic Assignment Problem

Tabu search approach based algorithms are among the widest applied to various combinatorial optimization problems. In this paper, we propose a new version of the tabu search algorithm for the well-known problem, the quadratic assignment problem (QAP). One of the most important features of our tabu search implementation is an efficient use of mutations applied to the best solutions found so far. We tested this approach on a number of instances from the library of the QAP instances—QAPLIB. The results obtained from the experiments show that the proposed algorithm belongs to the most efficient heuristics for the QAP. The high efficiency of this algorithm is also demonstrated by the fact that the new best known solutions were found for several QAP instances.     

On the Hardness of the Quadratic Assignment Problem with Metaheuristics

Meta-heuristics are a powerful way to approximately solve hard combinatorial optimization problems. However, for a problem, the quality of results can vary considerably from one instance to another. Understanding such a behaviour is important from a theoretical point of view, but also has practical applications such as for the generation of instances during the evaluation stage of a heuristic.In this paper we propose a new complexity measure for the Quadratic Assignment Problem in the context of metaheuristics based on local search, e.g. simulated annealing. We show how the ruggedness coefficient previously introduced by the authors, in conjunction with the well known concept of dominance, provides important features of the search space explored during a local search algorithm, and gives a rather precise idea of the complexity of an instance for these heuristics. We comment previous experimental studies concerning tabu search methods and genetic algorithms with local search in the light of our complexity measure. New computational results with simulated annealing and taboo search are presented.     

二次分配问题的大洪水算法求解

大洪水算法是一种求解组合优化问题的独特方法,该方法通过模拟洪水上涨的过程来达到求解一些组合优化难题的目的.本文运用该方法求解二次分配问题(QAP),设计了相应的算法程序,并对QAPLIB(二次分配基准问题库)中的算例进行了实验测试,结果表明,大洪水算法可以快速有效地求得二次分配问题的优化解,是求解二次分配问题的一个新的较好方案.     

Recent Advances for the Quadratic Assignment Problem with Special Emphasis on Instances that are Difficult for Meta-Heuristic Methods

This paper reports heuristic and exact solution advances for the Quadratic Assignment Problem (QAP).QAPinstances most often discussed in the literature are relatively well solved by heuristic approaches. Indeed, solutions at a fraction of one percent from the best known solution values are rapidly found by most heuristic methods. Exact methods are not able to prove optimality for these instances as soon as the problem size approaches 30 to 40. This article presents new QAP instances that are ill conditioned for many metaheuristic-based methods. However, these new instances are shown to be solved relatively well by some exact methods, since problem instances up to a size of 75 have been exactly solved.     

On the Applicability of Lower Bounds for Solving Rectilinear Quadratic Assignment Problems in Parallel

The quadratic assignment problem (QAP) belongs to the hard core of NP-hard optimization problems. After almost forty years of research only relatively small instances can be solved to optimality. The reason is that the quality of the lower bounds available for exact methods is not sufficient. Recently, lower bounds based on decomposition were proposed for the so called rectilinear QAP that proved to be the strongest for a large class of problem instances. We investigate the strength of these bounds when applied not only at the root node of a search tree but as the bound function used in a Branch-and-Bound code solving large scale QAPs.     

Greedy and Local Search Heuristics for Unconstrained Binary Quadratic Programming

In this paper, a greedy heuristic and two local search algorithms, 1-opt local search and k-opt local search, are proposed for the unconstrained binary quadratic programming problem (BQP). These heuristics are well suited for the incorporation into meta-heuristics such as evolutionary algorithms. Their performance is compared for 115 problem instances. All methods are capable of producing high quality solutions in short time. In particular, the greedy heuristic is able to find near optimum solutions a few percent below the best-known solutions, and the local search procedures are sufficient to find the best-known solutions of all problem instances with n 100. The k-opt local searches even find the best-known solutions for all problems of size n 250 and for 11 out of 15 instances of size n = 500 in all runs. For larger problems (n = 500, 1000, 2500), the heuristics appear to be capable of finding near optimum solutions quickly. Therefore, the proposed heuristics—especially the k-opt local search—offer a great potential for the incorporation in more sophisticated meta-heuristics.     

An Efficient Algorithm for the Knapsack Sharing Problem

The Knapsack Sharing Problem (KSP) is an NP-Hard combinatorial optimization problem, admitted in numerous real world applications. In the KSP, we have a knapsack of capacity c and a set of n objects, namely N, where each object j, j = 1,...,n, is associated with a profit p _j and a weight w _j. The set of objects N is composed of m different classes of objects J _i, i = 1,...,m, and N = ^m _i=1 J _i. The aim is to determine a subset of objects to be included in the knapsack that realizes a max-min value over all classes.In this article, we solve the KSP using an approximate solution method based upon tabu search. First, we describe a simple local search in which a depthparameter and a tabu list are used. Next, we enhance the algorithm by introducing some intensifying and diversifying strategies. The two versions of the algorithm yield satisfactory results within reasonable computational time. Extensive computational testing on problem instances taken from the literature shows the effectiveness of the proposed approach.     

一种基于匈牙利算法的二次分配问题求解方法

二次分配问题(Quadratic assignment problem,QAP)属于NP-hard组合优化难题.二次分配问题的线性化及下界计算方法,是求解二次分配问题的重要途径.以Frieze-Yadegar线性化模型和Gilmore-Lawler下界为基础,详细论述了二次分配问题线性化模型的结构特征,并分析了Gilmore-Lawler下界值往往远离目标函数最优值的原因.在此基础上,提出一种基于匈牙利算法的二次分配问题对偶上升下界求解法.通过求解QAPLIB中的部分实例,说明了方法的有效和可行性.     

一种基于局部搜索算子的遗传算法

为了提高遗传算法的收敛速度及局部搜索能力,设计了一种基于优良模式的局部搜索算子.同时对传统免疫算法中基于浓度的选择算子进行了改进,设计了一种基于适应度值和浓度的混合选择算子,从而有效的阻止了算法出现"早熟"现象.进一步给出了算法的步骤,并利用有限马尔可夫链证明了该算法的收敛性,最后通过对四个经典测试算法性能的函数的数字仿真,说明该算法对多峰值函数优化问题明显优于基本遗传算法.     

Finding Robust Solutions Using Local Search

This paper investigates how a local search metaheuristic for continuous optimisation can be adapted so that it finds broad peaks, corresponding to robust solutions. This is relevant in problems in which uncertain or noisy data is present. When using a genetic or evolutionary algorithm, it is standard practice to perturb solutions once before evaluating them, using noise from a given distribution. This approach however, is not valid when using population-less techniques like local search and other heuristics that use local search. For those algorithms to find robust solutions, each solution needs to be perturbed and evaluated several times, and these evaluations need to be combined into a measure of robustness. In this paper, we examine how many of these evaluations are needed to reliably find a robust solution. We also examine the effect of the parameters of the noise distribution. Using a simple tabu search procedure, the proposed approach is tested on several functions found in the literature. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

几种基于匈牙利算法求解二次分配问题的方法及其分析比较

二次分配问题(Quadratic assignment problem,QAP)属于NP-hard组合优化难题。二次分配问题的线性化模型和下界计算方法,是求解二次分配问题的重要途径。本文以二次分配问题的线性化模型为基础,根据现有QAP对偶上升下界计算方法中的具体操作,提出几种可行的QAP对偶上升计算新方法。最后,通过求解QA-PLIB中的部分实例,深入分析其运行结果,详细讨论了基于匈牙利算法求解二次分配问题的对偶方法中哪些操作可较大程度地提高目标函数最优解的下界增长速度,这为基于匈牙利算法求解二次分配问题的方法的改进奠定了基础。     

一种求解物流设施二次分配问题的混合分布估计算法

为了求解物流设施二次分配问题,提出了一种混合分布估计算法(HEDA)。首先,根据QAP的距离和物流量矩阵信息,提出了一种基于假设物流中心启发式规则的种群初始化方法,用于提高初始种群的质量和算法的搜索效率;其次,针对HEDA的概率模型,提出了一种概率矩阵初始构型生成机制和扰动操作,用于提高算法的全局探索能力;最后,在分析QAP的结构性质的基础上,设计了一种基于快速评价的局部搜索策略,用于提高算法的局部开发能力。仿真计算实验和算法比较验证了HEDA的优化性能。     

A Reactive Local Search-Based Algorithm for the Multiple-Choice Multi-Dimensional Knapsack Problem

In this paper, we approximately solve the multiple-choice multi-dimensional knapsack problem. We propose an algorithm which is based upon reactive local search and where an explicit check for the repetition of configurations is added to the local search. The algorithm starts by an initial solution and improved by using a fast iterative procedure. Later, both deblocking and degrading procedures are introduced in order (i) to escape to local optima and, (ii) to introduce diversification in the search space. Finally, a memory list is applied in order to forbid the repetition of configurations. The performance of the proposed approaches has been evaluated on several problem instances. Encouraging results have been obtained.     

求解二次分配问题的新的流量模型

二次分配问题是具有广泛应用背景的经典组合优化难题之一。本文在二次分配问题已有线性化模型的基础上,提出了一种新的基于流量的线性化模型。数值试验结果表明,新模型无论从时间上还是计算节点数都更具有优势。     

双目标瓶颈指派问题的遗传算法

给出一种双目标瓶颈指派问题的新模型,本模型结合了决策者和工人两方面的因素,特别之处在于考虑到了工人对工作的排名偏好.进而,将双目标瓶颈指派问题转化为单目标规划,并设计了解此问题的遗传算法,算法的解均为双目标瓶颈指派问题的Pareto最优解.     

一类二次半定规划内点算法的搜索方向

利用牛顿法求解一类二次半定规划的扰动KKT方程组,得出这类二次半定规划原始-对偶路径跟踪算法搜索方向求解的统一形式,以及HKM搜索方向和NT搜索方向存在唯一的充分条件,最后给出了计算搜索方向的表达式,和特殊情况下搜索方向的计算方法.     

A study of exponential neighborhoods for the Travelling Salesman Problem and for the Quadratic Assignment Problem

This paper deals with exponential neighborhoods for combinatorial optimization problems. Exponential neighborhoods are large sets of feasible solutions whose size grows exponentially with the input length. We are especially interested in exponential neighborhoods over which the TSP (respectively, the QAP) can be solved in polynomial time, and we investigate combinatorial and algorithmical questions related to such neighborhoods.?First, we perform a careful study of exponential neighborhoods for the TSP. We investigate neighborhoods that can be defined in a simple way via assignments, matchings in bipartite graphs, partial orders, trees and other combinatorial structures. We identify several properties of these combinatorial structures that lead to polynomial time optimization algorithms, and we also provide variants that slightly violate these properties and lead to NP-complete optimization problems. Whereas it is relatively easy to find exponential neighborhoods over which the TSP can be solved in polynomial time, the corresponding situation for the QAP looks pretty hopeless: Every exponential neighborhood that is considered in this paper provably leads to an NP-complete optimization problem for the QAP. Received: September 5, 1997 / Accepted: November 15, 1999?Published online February 23, 2000