Stability and selectivity of unnatural DNA with five-membered-ring nucleobase analogues

In an effort to develop an orthogonal third base pair for the storage of genetic information, thiophene and furan heterocycles have been examined as nucleobase analogues. The stability of the unnatural bases was evaluated in duplex DNA paired opposite other unnatural bases as well as opposite the natural bases. Several unnatural base pairs are identified that are both reasonably stable and strongly selective against mispairing with native bases. These results expand the potential nucleobase analogues with which the genetic alphabet may be expanded to include five-membered-ring heterocycles.     

Fluorous base-pairing effects in a DNA polymerase active site

We describe selective "fluorous" effects in the active site of a DNA polymerase, by using nucleotide analogues whose pairing edges are perfluorinated. The 5'-triphosphate deoxynucleotide derivatives of DNA base analogues 2,3,4,5-tetrafluorobenzene ((F)B) and 4,5,6,7-tetrafluoroindole ((F)I), as well as hydrocarbon controls benzene (B) and indole (I), were synthesized and studied as substrates for the DNA Polymerase I Klenow fragment (KF exo-). Modified nucleotides were present in the DNA template or were supplied as nucleoside triphosphates in studies of the steady-state kinetics of single nucleotide insertion. When supplied opposite the non-natural bases in the template strand, the hydrophobic nucleoside triphosphates were incorporated by up to two orders of magnitude more efficiently than the natural deoxynucleoside triphosphates. The purine-like fluorinated indole nucleotide ((F)I) was the most efficiently inserted of the four hydrophobic analogues, with the most effective incorporation occurring opposite the pyrimidine-like tetrafluorobenzene ((F)B). In all cases, the polyfluorinated base pairs were more efficiently processed than the analogous hydrocarbon pairs. A preliminary test of polymerase extension beyond these pairs showed that only the (F)B base is appreciably extended; the inefficient extension is consistent with recently published data regarding other nonpolar base pairs. These results suggest the importance of hydrophobicity, stacking, and steric interactions in the polymerase-mediated replication of DNA base pairs that lack hydrogen bonds. These findings further suggest that the enhanced hydrophobicity of polyfluoroaromatic bases could be employed in the design of new, selective base pairs that are orthogonal to the natural Watson-Crick pairs used in replication.     

Hydrophobic, Non-Hydrogen-Bonding Bases and Base Pairs in DNA

We report the properties of hydrophobic isosteres of pyrimidines and purines in synthetic DNA duplexes. Phenyl nucleosides 1 and 2 are nonpolar isosteres of the natural thymidine nucleoside, and indole nucleoside 3 is an analog of the complementary purine 2-aminodeoxyadenosine. The nucleosides were incorporated into synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides and were paired against each other and against the natural bases. Thermal denaturation experiments were used to measure the stabilities of the duplexes at neutral pH. It is found that the hydrophobic base analogs are nonselective in pairing with the four natural bases but selective for pairing with each other rather than with the natural bases. For example, compound 2 selectively pairs with itself rather than with A, T, G, or C; the magnitude of this selectivity is found to be 6.5-9.3 °C in Tm or 1.5-1.8 kcal/mol in free energy (25 °C). All possible hydrophobic pairing combinations of 1, 2, and 3 were examined. Results show that the pairing affinity depends on the nature of the pairs and on position in the duplex. The highest affinity pairs are found to be the 1-1 and 2-2 self-pairs and the 1-2 heteropair. The best stabilization occurs when the pairs are placed at the ends of duplexes rather than internally; the internal pairs may be destabilized by imperfect steric mimicry which leads to non-ideal duplex structure. In some cases the hydrophobic pairs are significantly stabilizing to the DNA duplex; for example, when situated at the end of a duplex, the 1-1 pair is more stabilizing than a T-A pair. When situated internally, the affinity of the 1-1 pair is the same as, or slightly better than, the analogous T-T mismatch pair, which is known to have two hydrogen bonds. The studies raise the possibility that hydrogen bonds may not always be required for the formation of stable duplex DNA-like structure. In addition, the results point out the importance of solvation and desolvation in natural base pairing, and lend new support to the idea that hydrogen bonds in DNA may be more important for specificity of pairing than for affinity. Finally, the study raises the possibility of using these or related base pairs to expand the genetic code beyond the natural A-T and G-C pairs.     

Optimization of unnatural base pair packing for polymerase recognition

As part of an effort to expand the genetic alphabet, we have been examining the ability of predominately hydrophobic nucleobase analogues to pair in duplex DNA and during polymerase-mediated replication. We previously reported the synthesis and thermal stability of unnatural base pairs formed between nucleotides bearing simple methyl-substituted phenyl ring nucleobase analogues. Several of these pairs are virtually as stable and selective as natural base pairs in the same sequence context. Here, we report the characterization of polymerase-mediated replication of the same unnatural base pairs. We find that every facet of replication, including correct and incorrect base pair synthesis, as well as continued primer extension beyond the unnatural base pair, is sensitive to the specific methyl substitution pattern of the nucleobase analogue. The results demonstrate that neither hydrogen bonding nor large aromatic surface area is required for polymerase recognition, and that interstrand interactions between small aromatic rings may be optimized for replication. Combined with our previous results, these studies suggest that appropriately derivatized phenyl nucleobase analogues represent a promising approach toward developing a third base pair and expanding the genetic alphabet.     

C-F...H-C hydrogen bonds in ribonucleic acids

We report the synthesis of 1'-deoxy-1'-(benzimidazol-1-yl)-beta-D-ribofuranose 7 and 1'-deoxy-1'-phenyl-beta-D-ribofuranose 2. With these two ribonucleoside analogues we have a set of nine different RNA building blocks in hand, which are isostere to the natural bases. Now it is possible to investigate their duplex stabilizing forces. These forces are hydrogen bonds, base stacking, and solvation. The phosphoramidites of all building blocks were incorporated into a 12mer RNA, and the resulting RNA duplexes were investigated by UV- and CD-spectroscopy. We found that some of the RNA analogues are universal bases. The best universal bases with the lowest destabilization and the smallest discrimination between the natural bases are 1 (B) and 9 (E). On the basis of UV measurements we determined the melting points and the thermodynamic data. We were able to show that there are no hydrogen bonds between the natural bases and the RNA analogues. From thermodynamic data we calculated the contributions for base stacking and solvation of all modified building blocks. Comparison of calculated and measured data of double modified base pairs in 12mer RNA duplexes showed a further duplex stabilizing force in base pairs containing fluorine atoms at the Watson-Crick binding site. This stabilizing force can be defined as C-F.H-C hydrogen bond as is observed in crystal structures of 1'-deoxy-1'-(4-fluorophenyl)-beta-D-ribofuranose.     

Efforts toward expansion of the genetic alphabet: structure and replication of unnatural base pairs

Expansion of the genetic alphabet has been a long-time goal of chemical biology. A third DNA base pair that is stable and replicable would have a great number of practical applications and would also lay the foundation for a semisynthetic organism. We have reported that DNA base pairs formed between deoxyribonucleotides with large aromatic, predominantly hydrophobic nucleobase analogues, such as propynylisocarbostyril (dPICS), are stable and efficiently synthesized by DNA polymerases. However, once incorporated into the primer, these analogues inhibit continued primer elongation. More recently, we have found that DNA base pairs formed between nucleobase analogues that have minimal aromatic surface area in addition to little or no hydrogen-bonding potential, such as 3-fluorobenzene (d3FB), are synthesized and extended by DNA polymerases with greatly increased efficiency. Here we show that the rate of synthesis and extension of the self-pair formed between two d3FB analogues is sufficient for in vitro DNA replication. To better understand the origins of efficient replication, we examined the structure of DNA duplexes containing either the d3FB or dPICS self-pairs. We find that the large aromatic rings of dPICS pair in an intercalative manner within duplex DNA, while the d3FB nucleobases interact in an edge-on manner, much closer in structure to natural base pairs. We also synthesized duplexes containing the 5-methyl-substituted derivatives of d3FB (d5Me3FB) paired opposite d3FB or the unsubstituted analogue (dBEN). In all, the data suggest that the structure, electrostatics, and dynamics can all contribute to the extension of unnatural primer termini. The results also help explain the replication properties of many previously examined unnatural base pairs and should help design unnatural base pairs that are better replicated.     

Cyclohexyl "base pairs" stabilize duplexes and intensify pyrene fluorescence by shielding it from natural base pairs

In this study, we investigated the stability and structure of artificial base pairs that contain cyclohexyl rings. The introduction of a single pair of isopropylcyclohexanes into the middle of DNA slightly destabilized the duplex. Interestingly, as the number of the "base pairs" increased, the duplex was remarkably stabilized. A duplex with six base pairs was even more stable than one containing six A-T pairs. Thermodynamic analysis revealed that changes in entropy and not enthalpy contributed to duplex stability, demonstrating that hydrophobic interactions between isopropyl groups facilitated the base pairing, and thus stabilized the duplex. NOESY of a duplex containing an isopropylcyclohexane-methylcyclohexane pair unambiguously demonstrated its "pairing" in the duplex because distinct NOEs between the protons of cyclohexyl moieties and imino protons of both of the neighboring natural base pairs were observed. CD spectra of duplexes tethering cyclohexyl moieties also showed a positive-negative couplet that is characteristic of the B-form DNA duplex. Taken together, these results showed that cyclohexyl moieties formed base pairs in the DNA duplex without severely disturbing the helical structure of natural DNA. Next, we introduced cyclohexyl base pairs between pyrene and nucleobases as an "insulator" that suppresses electron transfer between them. We found a massive increase in the quantum yield of pyrene due to the efficient shielding of pyrene from nucleobases. The cyclohexyl base pairs reported here have the potential to prepare highly fluorescent labeling agents by multiplying fluorophores and insulators alternately into DNA duplexes.     

Solution structure of xDNA: a paired genetic helix with increased diameter

We describe the structure in aqueous solution of an extended-size DNA-like duplex with base pairs that are approximately 2.4 A longer than those of DNA. Deoxy-lin-benzoadenosine (dxA) was employed as a dA analogue to form hydrogen-bonded base pairs with dT. The 10mer self-complementary extended oligodeoxynucleotide 5'-d(xATxAxATxATTxAT) forms a much more thermodynamically stable duplex than the corresponding DNA sequence, 5'-d(ATAATATTAT). NMR studies show that this extended DNA (xDNA) retains many features of natural B-form DNA, but with a few structural alterations due to its increased helical diameter. The results give insight into the structural plasticity of the natural DNA backbone and lend insight into the evolutionary origins of the natural base pairs. Finally, this structural study confirms the hypothesis that extended nucleobase analogues can form stable DNA-like structures, suggesting that alternative genetic systems might be viable for storage and transfer of genetic information.     

Theoretical Study of the Stability of the DNA Duplexes Modified by a Series of Hydrophobic Base Analogues

The geometries of a 13 mer of a DNA double helix (5′‐GCGTAC A CATGCG‐3′) were determined by molecular dynamics simulations using a Cornell et al. empirical force field. The bases in the central base pair (shown in bold) were replaced (one or both) by a series of hydrophobic base analogues (phenyl, biphenyl, phenylnaphathalene, phenylanthracene and phenylphenanthrene). Due to the large fluctuations of the systems, an average geometry could not be determined. The interaction energies of the Model A, which consisted of three central steps of a duplex without a sugar phosphate backbone, taken from molecular dynamics simulations (geometry sampled every 1 ps), were calculated by the self‐consistent charge density functional based tight‐binding (SCC‐DFTB‐D) method and were subsequently averaged. The higher the stability of the systems the higher the aromaticity of the base analogues. To estimate the desolvation energy of the duplex, the COSMO continuum solvent model was used and the calculations were provided on a larger model, Model B (the three central steps of the duplex with a sugar phosphate backbone neutralised by H atoms), taken from molecular dynamics simulations (geometry sampled every 200 ps) and subsequently averaged. The selectivity of the base analogue pairs was ascertained (Model B) by including the desolvation energy and the interaction energy of both strands, as determined by the SCC‐DFTB‐D method. The highest selectivity was found for a phenylphenanthrene. Replacing the nucleic acid bases with a base analogue leads to structural changes of the central pair. Only with the smallest base analogues (phenyl) does the central base pair stay planar. When passing to larger base analogues the central base pair is usually stacked.     

The effect of minor-groove hydrogen-bond acceptors and donors on the stability and replication of four unnatural base pairs

The stability and replication of DNA containing self-pairs formed between unnatural nucleotides bearing benzofuran, benzothiophene, indole, and benzotriazole nucleobases are reported. These nucleobase analogues are based on a similar scaffold but have different hydrogen-bond donor/acceptor groups that are expected to be oriented in the duplex minor groove. The unnatural base pairs do not appear to induce major structural distortions and are accommodated within the constraints of a B-form duplex. The differences between these unnatural base pairs are manifest only in the polymerase-mediated extension step, not in base-pair stability or synthesis. The benzotriazole self-pair is extended with an efficiency that is only 200-fold less than a correct natural base pair. The data are discussed in terms of available polymerase crystal structures and imply that further modifications may result in unnatural base pairs that can be both efficiently synthesized and extended, resulting in an expanded genetic alphabet.     

Optimization of interstrand hydrophobic packing interactions within unnatural DNA base pairs

As part of an effort to expand the genetic alphabet, we have evaluated a large number of predominantly hydrophobic unnatural base pairs. We now report the synthesis and stability of unnatural base pairs formed between simple phenyl rings modified at different positions with methyl groups. Surprisingly, several of the unnatural base pairs are virtually as stable as a natural base pair in the same sequence context. The results show that neither hydrogen-bonding nor large aromatic surface area are required for base pair stability within duplex DNA and that interstrand interactions between small aromatic rings may be optimized for both stability and selectivity. These smaller nucleobases are not expected to induce the distortions in duplex DNA or at the primer terminus that seem to limit replication of larger unnatural base pairs, and they therefore represent a promising approach to the expansion of the genetic alphabet.     

Hetero‐Selective DNA‐Like Duplex Stabilized by Donor–Acceptor Interactions

We report on the characterization of a novel hetero‐selective DNA‐like duplex of pyrene and anthraquinone pseudo base pairs. The pyrene/anthraquinone pairs showed excellent selectivity in hetero‐recognition and even trimers were found to form a hetero‐duplex. Pyrene and anthraquinone moieties were tethered on acyclic D ‐threoninol linkers and linked to adjacent residues by using standard phosphoramidite chemistry. When pyrene and anthraquinone were incorporated at pairing positions in complementary strands of natural DNA oligonucleotides, the duplex was stabilized significantly. Moreover, a pyrene hexamer and an anthraquinone hexamer formed a stable artificial hetero‐duplex without the assistance of natural base pairs. The pyrene/anthraquinone pair was so stable that even trimers formed a hetero‐duplex under conditions in which natural DNA strands of three residues do not.     

The Structural Basis for Processing of Unnatural Base Pairs by DNA Polymerases

Unnatural base pairs (UBPs) greatly increase the diversity of DNA and RNA, furthering their broad range of molecular biological and biotechnological approaches. Different candidates have been developed whereby alternative hydrogen-bonding patterns and hydrophobic and packing interactions have turned out to be the most promising base-pairing concepts to date. The key in many applications is the highly efficient and selective acceptance of artificial base pairs by DNA polymerases, which enables amplification of the modified DNA. In this Review, computational as well as experimental studies that were performed to characterize the pairing behavior of UBPs in free duplex DNA or bound to the active site of KlenTaq DNA polymerase are highlighted. The structural studies, on the one hand, elucidate how base pairs lacking hydrogen bonds are accepted by these enzymes and, on the other hand, highlight the influence of one or several consecutive UBPs on the structure of a DNA double helix. Understanding these concepts facilitates optimization of future UBPs for the manifold fields of applications.     

Toward a designed, functioning genetic system with expanded-size base pairs: solution structure of the eight-base xDNA double helix

We describe the NMR-derived solution structure of the double-helical form of a designed eight-base genetic pairing system, termed xDNA. The benzo-homologous xDNA design contains base pairs that are wider than natural DNA pairs by ca. 2.4 A (the width of a benzene ring). The eight component bases of this xDNA helix are A, C, G, T, xA, xT, xC, and xG. The structure was solved in aqueous buffer using 1D and 2D NMR methods combined with restrained molecular dynamics. The data show that the decamer duplex is right-handed and antiparallel, and hydrogen-bonded in a way analogous to that of Watson-Crick DNA. The sugar-phosphate backbone adopts a regular conformation similar to that of B-form DNA, with small dihedral adjustments due to the larger circumference of the helix. The grooves are much wider and more shallow than those of B-form DNA, and the helix turn is slower, with ca. 12 base pairs per 360 degrees turn. There is an extensive intra- and interstrand base stacking surface area, providing an explanation for the greater stability of xDNA relative to natural DNA. There is also evidence for greater motion in this structure compared to a previous two-base-expanded helix; possible chemical and structural reasons for this are discussed. The results confirm paired self-assembly of the designed xDNA system. This suggests the possibility that other genetic system structures besides the natural one might be functional in encoding information and transferring it to new complementary strands.     

Computational design of ring-expanded pyrimidine-based DNA motifs with improved conductivity

Motivated by a promising expansion of the genetic alphabet and a successful design of conductive DNA bases justified from the hetero-ring-expanded purine base (G and A) analogs, we extend our hetero-ring expansion scheme to the pyrimidine bases (C and T) to examine the ring-expansion effects on various properties of these single-ring bases with a comparison with those in the double-ring purine case. Four kinds of the hetero-rings are considered to expand C and T, forming the C and T analogs (nC and nT), respectively. The relevant structures and properties were investigated by means of quantum calculations and molecular dynamics simulations. The results reveal that all the modified bases can form base pairs specifically with their natural counterparts and assemble duplex helices which have comparable stability to native ones. The HOMO-LUMO gaps of G-nC and A-nT are smaller than those of the natural pairs, and the assembled duplex helices ((G-nC)(12) and (A-nT)(12)) are diameter-enlarged but with smaller rise and twist, both of which favor DNA-conduction, as confirmed by ionization potentials and spin density distributions. In addition, the hetero-ring expansion can lower the activation barriers and reduce the reaction heats of the inter-base double proton transfers. In particular, as evidenced by NMR parameters and the excited states, the hetero-ring expansion leads to an enhancement of the transverse electronic communication between two pairing bases, clearly facilitating the conduction along the helices. Furthermore, the hetero-ring expansion effect on the pyrimidine bases is larger than that on the purine bases. In summary, this work presents clear theoretical evidence for the possibility of hetero-ring expanded pyrimidine bases as promising candidates for the motifs of the genetic alphabet and DNA nanowires.     

Discovery, characterization, and optimization of an unnatural base pair for expansion of the genetic alphabet

DNA is inherently limited by its four natural nucleotides. Efforts to expand the genetic alphabet, by addition of an unnatural base pair, promise to expand the biotechnological applications available for DNA as well as to be an essential first step toward expansion of the genetic code. We have conducted two independent screens of hydrophobic unnatural nucleotides to identify novel candidate base pairs that are well recognized by a natural DNA polymerase. From a pool of 3600 candidate base pairs, both screens identified the same base pair, dSICS:dMMO2, which we report here. Using a series of related analogues, we performed a detailed structure-activity relationship analysis, which allowed us to identify the essential functional groups on each nucleobase. From the results of these studies, we designed an optimized base pair, d5SICS:dMMO2, which is efficiently and selectively synthesized by Kf within the context of natural DNA.     

Structural Basis for Expansion of the Genetic Alphabet with an Artificial Nucleobase Pair

Hydrophobic artificial nucleobase pairs without the ability to pair through hydrogen bonds are promising candidates to expand the genetic alphabet. The most successful nucleobase surrogates show little similarity to each other and their natural counterparts. It is thus puzzling how these unnatural molecules are processed by DNA polymerases that have evolved to efficiently work with the natural building blocks. Here, we report structural insight into the insertion of one of the most promising hydrophobic unnatural base pairs, the dDs–dPx pair, into a DNA strand by a DNA polymerase. We solved a crystal structure of KlenTaq DNA polymerase with a modified template/primer duplex bound to the unnatural triphosphate. The ternary complex shows that the artificial pair adopts a planar structure just like a natural nucleobase pair, and identifies features that might hint at the mechanisms accounting for the lower incorporation efficiency observed when processing the unnatural substrates.     

A new unnatural base pair system between fluorophore and quencher base analogues for nucleic acid-based imaging technology

In the development of orthogonal extra base pairs for expanding the genetic alphabet, we created novel, unnatural base pairs between fluorophore and quencher nucleobase analogues. We found that the nucleobase analogue, 2-nitropyrrole (denoted by Pn), and its 4-substitutions, such as 2-nitro-4-propynylpyrrole (Px) and 4-[3-(6-aminohexanamido)-1-propynyl]-2-nitropyrrole (NH(2)-hx-Px), act as fluorescence quenchers. The Pn and Px bases specifically pair with their pairing partner, 7-(2,2'-bithien-5-yl)imidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (Dss), which is strongly fluorescent. Thus, these unnatural Dss-Pn and Dss-Px base pairs function as reporter-quencher base pairs, and are complementarily incorporated into DNA by polymerase reactions as a third base pair in combination with the natural A-T and G-C pairs. Due to the static contact quenching, the Pn and Px quencher bases significantly decreased the fluorescence intensity of Dss by the unnatural base pairings in DNA duplexes. In addition, the Dss-Px pair exhibited high efficiency and selectivity in PCR amplification. Thus, this new unnatural base pair system would be suitable for detection methods of target nucleic acid sequences, and here we demonstrated the applications of the Dss-Pn and Dss-Px pairs as molecular beacons and in real-time PCR. The genetic alphabet expansion system with the replicable, unnatural fluorophore-quencher base pair will be a useful tool for sensing and diagnostic applications, as well as an imaging tool for basic research.     

Encoding phenotype in bacteria with an alternative genetic set

An unnatural base-pair architecture with base pairs 2.4 ? larger than the natural DNA-based genetic system (xDNA) is evaluated for its ability to function like DNA, encoding amino acids in the context of living cells. xDNA bases are structurally analogous to natural bases but homologated by the width of a benzene ring, increasing their sizes and resulting in a duplex that is wider than native B-DNA. Plasmids encoding green fluorescent protein were constructed to contain single and multiple xDNA bases (as many as eight) in both strands and were transformed into Escherichia coli. Although they yielded fewer colonies than the natural control plasmid, in all cases in which a modified plasmid (containing one, two, three, or four consecutive size-expanded base pairs) was used, the correct codon bases were substituted, yielding green colonies. All four xDNA bases (xA, xC, xG, and xT) were found to encode the correct partners in the replicated plasmid DNA, both alone and in longer segments of xDNA. Controls with mutant cell lines having repair functions deleted were found to express the gene correctly, ruling out repair of xDNA and confirming polymerase reading of the unnatural bases. Preliminary experiments with polymerase deletion mutants suggested combined roles of replicative and lesion-bypass polymerases in inserting correct bases opposite xDNA bases and in bypassing the xDNA segments. These experiments demonstrate a biologically functioning synthetic genetic set with larger-than-natural architecture.     

Watson–Crick Base Pairing Controls Excited‐State Decay in Natural DNA

Excited‐state dynamics are essential to understanding the formation of DNA lesions induced by UV light. By using femtosecond IR spectroscopy, it was possible to determine the lifetimes of the excited states of all four bases in the double‐stranded environment of natural DNA. After UV excitation of the DNA duplex, we detected a concerted decay of base pairs connected by Watson–Crick hydrogen bonds. A comparison of single‐ and double‐stranded DNA showed that the reactive charge‐transfer states formed in the single strands are suppressed by base pairing in the duplex. The strong influence of the Watson–Crick hydrogen bonds indicates that proton transfer opens an efficient decay path in the duplex that prohibits the formation or reduces the lifetime of reactive charge‐transfer states.