Theoretical models of separation selectivity for charged compounds in micellar electrokinetic chromatography

Equations and theoretical models for MEKC separation selectivity (α(MEKC) ) were established to explain a change in separation and electrophoretic mobility order of fully charged analytes, in which α(MEKC) is related to the dimensionless values of mobility selectivity in CZE (α(CZE)) and retention selectivity (α(k)) in MEKC, and where α(CZE) and α(k) are defined as the ratio of electrophoretic mobility in CZE and the ratio of retention factor (k) in MEKC for two charged analytes, respectively. Using four alkylparabens as test analytes, excellent agreement was found between the observed α(MEKC) and the proposed α(MEKC) models of test analytes in MEKC over a wide range of SDS concentrations and values of k. For example, in comparison with CZE separation of charged analytes, MEKC separation can enhance separation selectivity up to the maximum value when the selectivity ratio (ρ) is greater than 1.0 (ρ=α(k)/α(CZE)), while lower separation selectivity is obtained with ρ<1.0 (α(CZE) >α(k) >1).     

Investigation of the ion-exchange properties of methacrylate-based mixed-mode monolithic stationary phases employed as stationary phases in capillary electrochromatography

The potential of methacrylate-based mixed-mode monolithic stationary phases bearing sulfonic acid groups for the separation of positively charged analytes (alkylanilines, amino acids, and peptides) by capillary electrochromatography (CEC) is investigated. The retention mechanism of protonated alkylanilines as positively charged model solutes on these negatively charged mixed-mode stationary phases is investigated by studying the influence of mobile phase and stationary phase parameters on the corrected retention factor which was calculated by taking the electrophoretic mobility of the solutes into consideration. It is shown that both solvophobic and ion-exchange interactions contribute to the retention of these analytes. The dependence of the corrected retention factor on (1) the concentration of the counter ion ammonium and (2) the number of methylene groups in the alkyl chain of the model analytes investigated shows clearly that a one-site model (solvophobic and ion-exchange interactions take place simultaneously at a single type of site) has to be taken to describe the retention behaviour observed. Comparison of the CEC separation of these charged analytes with electrophoretic mobilities determined by open-tubular capillary electrophoresis shows that mainly chromatographic interactions (solvophobic and ion-exchange interactions) are responsible for the selectivity observed in CEC, while the electrophoretic migration of these analytes plays only a minor role.     

Enhancement of selectivity and resolution in the enantioseparation of uncharged compounds using mixtures of oppositely charged cyclodextrins in capillary electrophoresis

The enantiomeric separation of some nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) was investigated in capillary electrophoresis (CE) using dual systems with mixtures of charged cyclodextrin (CD) derivatives. A significant enhancement of selectivity and resolution could be achieved in the enantioseparation of these analytes in their uncharged form by the simultaneous addition of two oppositely charged CD derivatives to the background electrolyte. The combination of the single-isomer cationic CD, permethyl-6-monoamino-6-monodeoxy-beta-CD (PMMAbetaCD) and the single-isomer polyanionic CD, heptakis-6-sulfato-beta-cyclodextrin (HSbetaCD) in a pH 2.5 phosphoric acid-triethanolamine buffer, was designed and employed for the enantioseparation of profens. The improvement in selectivity and resolution can be attributed to the fact that the two CDs, which lead to independent and enantioselective complexation with the analyte enantiomers, have not only opposite effects on the electrophoretic mobility of these compounds but also opposite affinity patterns towards the enantiomers of these compounds. Binding constants for these enantiomers with each CD were determined using linear regression approach, in order to be able to predict the effect of the concentrations of the two CDs on enantiomeric selectivity and resolution in such dual systems.     

Separation of phenolic acids by capillary electrophoresis with indirect contactless conductometric detection

A new method for the electrophoretic separation of nine phenolic acids (derivatives of benzoic and cinnamic acids) with contactless conductometric detection is presented. Based on theoretical calculations, in which the mobility of the electrolyte co- and counterions and mobility of analytes are taken into consideration, the electrolyte composition and detection mode was selected. This approach was found to be especially valuable for optimization of the electrolyte composition for the separation of analytes having medium mobility. Indirect conductometric detection mode was superior to the direct mode as predicted theoretically. The best performance was achieved with 150 mM 2-amino-2-methylpropanol electrolyte at pH 11.6. The separation was carried out in a counter-electroosmotic mode and completed in less than 6 min. The LODs achieved were about 2.3-3.3 microM and could be further improved to 0.12-0.17 microM by using a sample stacking procedure. The method compares well to the UV-Vis detection.     

Comparison of the chromatographic behavior of monolithic capillary columns in capillary electrochromatography and nano-high-performance liquid chromatography

Porous monoliths based on N,N-dimethylacrylamide (DMAA) or methacrylamide (MAA) were prepared inside fused silica capillaries as stationary phases for nano-chromatography. The columns were characterized in terms of flow rate and backpressure and showed, e.g. differences as a function of the salt concentration added to the polymerization mixture. When the columns were investigated for the separation of uncharged (polar hydroxylated aromatic compounds) and charged (amino acids) analytes under pressure driven conditions (pLC), differences to the previously observed behavior under voltage driven conditions (CEC) were observed. Whereas the non-charged analytes showed similar behavior in both cases--thus, corroborating the previous assumption of a mainly chromatographic separation mode driven by hydrophilic interactions in CEC--the charged amino acids did not. Assuming that the separation was governed by chromatographic phenomena in the pLC mode and by both chromatographic and electrophoretic effects in the CEC mode, the experiments allowed deconvoluting the two contributions. In particular, the charged amino acids appeared to interact with the stationary phases mainly by electrostatic interactions modified by some hydrophilic effects.     

Mobility-based selective on-line preconcentration of proteins in capillary electrophoresis by controlling electroosmotic flow

A simple method to perform selective on-line preconcentration of protein samples in capillary electrophoresis (CE) is described. The selectivity, based on protein electrophoretic mobility, was achieved by controlling electroosmotic flow (EOF). A short section of dialysis hollow fiber, serving as a porous joint, was connected between two lengths of fused silica capillary. High voltage was applied separately to each capillary, and the EOF in the system was controlled independently of the local electric field intensity by controlling the total voltage drop. An equation relating the EOF with the total voltage drop was derived and evaluated experimentally. On-line preconcentration of both positively charged and negatively charged model proteins was demonstrated without using discontinuous background electrolytes, and protein analytes were concentrated by approximately 60-200-fold under various conditions. For positively charged proteins, positive voltages of the same magnitude were applied at the free ends of the connected capillaries while the porous joint was grounded. This provided a zero EOF in the system and a non-zero local electric field in each capillary to drive the positively charged analytes to the porous joint. CE separation was then initiated by switching the polarity of the high voltage over the second capillary. For negatively charged proteins, the procedure was the same except negative voltages were applied at the free ends of the capillaries. Mobility-based selective on-line preconcentration was also demonstrated with two negatively charged proteins, i.e. beta-lactoglobulin B and myoglobin. In this case, negative voltages of different values were applied at the free ends of the capillaries with different values, which provided a non-zero EOF in the system. The direction of EOF was the same as that of the electrophoretic migration velocities of the protein analytes in the first capillary and opposite in the second capillary. By controlling the EOF, beta-lactoglobulin B, which has a higher mobility, could be concentrated over 150-fold with a 15 min injection while myoglobin, which has a lower mobility, was eliminated from the system.     

Analysis of the lipophilic peptaibol alamethicin by nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis-electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry

The microheterogeneous peptaibol alamethicin F30 isolated from the culture broth of Trichoderma viride was analyzed by nonaqueous CE-electrospray-MS using an IT and a TOF mass analyzer. Compared to aqueous buffers, higher separation selectivity was observed for methanolic BGE allowing the detection of more minor components. The low electrophoretic mobility observed for neutral analytes under nonaqueous conditions may be explained by ion-dipole interactions between the peptide analytes and electrolyte ions. The amino acid sequences of the individual components were derived from MS(n) using the doubly or triply charged pseudomolecular ions as well as characteristic fragments as precursor ions. The exchange of Ala by alpha-aminoisobutyric acid (Aib) which is frequently observed for peptaibols was detected for several components. Additional variations included the exchange of Gln to Glu, and the loss of the C-terminal amino alcohol or of the first six amino acids from the N-terminus with concomitant formation of pyroglutamyl residues. In most cases comigration of the Aib peptaibols with the respective Ala component was observed as the mass difference of 14 Da as the result of the amino acid exchange was not sufficient to translate into an electrophoretic separation under the conditions applied. However, proper selection of the precursor ions allowed the unequivocal analysis of the components. Additional TOF-MS measurements were performed in order to resolve the ammonium adducts from comigrating compounds (i.e., Aib-Ala exchange) and to confirm the amino acid composition of the individual components. Except for neutral compounds migrating close to the EOF the mass accuracy was better than 4 ppm for the doubly charged pseudomolecular ions and better than 2 ppm for triply charged ions.     

Discontinuous electrokinetic chromatography of parabens using different substituted resonances as pseudostationary phases

Resorcarene derivatives, negatively charged even at moderate pH, were synthesized and employed as pseudostationary phases to achieve mobilities exceeding that of the electroosmotic flow. Under these conditions, a discontinuous electrolyte system was developed which allows the separation of four uncharged homologous 4-hydroxybenzoic esters (parabens) within a zone of resorcarene electrolyte, and the detection of these UV active compounds in a resorcarene-free zone, free from the high UV background absorbance of the resorcarenes. Resorcarenes, with differently charged functionalities (carboxylate and phosphate groups) to provide the electrophoretic mobility and with alkyl residues of different chain lengths responsible for the chromatographic interactions with the analytes, were tested and compared in terms of mobility and selectivity. Only the resorcarene phosphates exhibited sufficient mobilities at low pH exceeding the mobility of the electroosmotic flow (EOF). Retention factors of the parabens were found to increase with increasing chain length of the alkyl residues attached to the resorcarene. However, maximum selectivity was observed for an intermediate chain length (C8). An equation for the calculation of retention factors in discontinuous electrokinetic chromatography (EKC) is presented.     

Preparation of a neutral porous monolith and its evaluation in pressurized capillary electrochromatography with neutral and charged solutes

A neutral, nonpolar monolithic capillary column was evaluated as a hydrophobic stationary phase in pressurized CEC system for neutral, acidic and basic solutes. The monolith was prepared by in situ copolymerization of octadecyl methacrylate and ethylene dimethacrylate in a binary porogenic solvent consisting of cyclohexanol/1,4‐butanediol. EOF in this hydrophobic monolithic column was poor; even the pH value of the mobile phase was high. Because of the absence of fixed charges, the monolithic capillary column was free of electrostatic interactions with charged solutes. Separations of neutral solutes were based on the hydrophobic mechanism with the pressure as the driving force. The acidic and basic solutes were separated under pressurized CEC mode with the pressure and electrophoretic mobility as the driving force. The separation selectivity of charged solutes were based on their differences in electrophoretic mobility and hydrophobic interaction with the stationary phase, and no obvious peak tailing for basic analytes was observed. Effects of the mobile phase compositions on the retention of acidic compounds were also investigated. Under optimized conditions, high plate counts reaching 82 000 plates/m for neutral compounds, 134 000 plates/m for acid compounds and 150 000 plates/m for basic compounds were readily obtained.     

Parameters influencing separation and detection of anions by capillary electrophoresis

Electrolyte composition is critical in optimizing separation and detection of ions by capillary electrophoresis. The parameters which must be considered when designing an electrolyte system for capillary electrophoresis include electrophoretic mobility of electrolyte constituents and analytes, detection mode, and compatibility of electrolyte constituents with one another. An electrolyte system based on pyromellitic acid is well suited for use with indirect photometric detection, and provides excellent separations of anions. The ability to modify the electrophoretic mobility of pyromellitic acid as a function of ph provides flexibility in matching electrophoretic mobilities of analytes. Additionally, the use of alkyl amines as electroosmotic flow modifiers allows the rapid separation of anions by reversing the direction of electroosmotic flow in a fused-silica capillary. The optimization of a capillary electrophoresis electrolyte for anion analysis is also discussed in terms of pH, ionic strength and applied voltage. The effect of organic solvent on separation selectivity is also discussed.     

Ionic liquids as electrolytes for nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis

Acetonitrile is a well-suited medium for nonaqueous capillary electroseparations and enables extending the range of applications of capillary electrophoresis (CE) techniques to more hydrophobic species. In this study, the dialkylimidazolium-based low temperature melting organic salts know as "ionic liquids" (ILs) are used as electrolytes. At room temperature these liquids are miscible with acetonitrile which makes it easy to use them for adjustment of analyte mobility and separation. The anionic part as well as the concentration of an IL influence the general electrophoretic mobility of the buffer system. The separation of different analytes is achieved because they become charged in the presence of ILs in separation media. There is also a possibility for a complex formation between the solute and the electrolyte which alters the mobility of the solute. A selected application of separations of phenols and aromatic acids will be discussed.     

Experimental verification of a predicted, hitherto unseen separation selectivity pattern in the nonaqueous capillary electrophoretic separation of weak base enantiomers by octakis (2,3-diacetyl-6-sulfato)-gamma-cyclodextrin

The capillary electrophoretic separation of cationic enantiomers with single-isomer multivalent anionic resolving agents was reexamined with the help of the charged resolving agent migration model. Three general model parameters were identified that influence the shape of the separation selectivity and enantiomer mobility difference curves: parameter b, the binding selectivity (K(RCD)/K(SCD)), parameter s, the size selectivity (mu0(RCD)/mu0(SCD)), and parameter a, the complexation-induced alteration of the analyte's mobility (mu0(RCD)/mu0). In addition to the previously observed discontinuity in separation selectivity that occurs as mu(eff) of the less mobile enantiomer changes from cationic to anionic, a new feature, a separation selectivity maximum was predicted to occur in the resolving agent concentration range where both enantiomers migrate cationically provided that (i) K(RCD)/K(SCD) <1 and mu0(RCD)/mu0(SCD) >1 and (K(RCD)mu0(RCD))/(K(SCD)mu0(SCD)) > 1, or (ii) K(RCD)/K(SCD) >1 and mu0(RCD)/mu0(SCD) <1 and (K(RCD)mu0(RCD))/(K(SCD)mu0(SCD)) <1. This hitherto unseen separation selectivity pattern was experimentally verified during the nonaqueous capillary electrophoretic separation of the enantiomers of four weak base analytes in acidic methanol background electrolytes with octakis(2,3-diacetyl-6-sulfato)-gamma-cyclodextrin (ODAS-gammaCD) as resolving agent.     

Deviation from Ohm's law in electric field assisted capillary liquid chromatography

Earlier studies of electric field assisted LC (EF-LC) have shown that the effect on charged analytes of the application of an electric field over a capillary LC column is relatively small. Charged analytes can only be affected by the electric field while present in the mobile phase, which makes the effective time for influence of the electric field t(0) independent of retention time. Because the charged analytes only can be affected for a short time the electric field strength ought to be high in order to increase the impact of the electric field on the separation. We have, however, found that only a relatively low electric field strength can be used in EF-LC when pressure is used as main driving force. The useful field strength was limited by a dramatic increase in the current. This increase in current was found to origin from an increased concentration of buffer ions that have an electrophoretic mobility towards the pumped flow.     

Separation selectivity patterns in the capillary electrophoretic separation of anionic enantiomers by octakis-6-sulfato-gamma-cyclodextrin

The capillary electrophoretic separation of anionic enantiomers with multiply-charged, single-isomer, anionic resolving agents was reexamined with the help of the charged resolving agent migration model. Three general model parameters were identified that influence the shape of the separation selectivity and enantiomer mobility difference curves: parameter b, the binding selectivity (K(RCD)/K(SCD)), parameter s, the size selectivity (micro0RCD/micro0SCD), and parameter a, the complexation-induced alteration of the analyte's mobility (micro0SCD/micro0). Function analysis of the model indicates that there are six unique separation selectivity vs. resolving agent concentration patterns: in two of the patterns, separation selectivity asymptotically increases to the limiting value set by parameter b; in two other patterns, separation selectivity passes a local maximum and asymptotically decreases to the limiting value set by parameter b; and in the last two patterns, separation selectivity passes a local maximum, decreases to unity, then, after reversal of the intrinsic migration order, asymptotically increases to the limiting value set by parameter b. Though the patterns with asymptotically increasing selectivities were observed in earlier work, this paper reports the first experimental verification of the existence of the local selectivity maximum during the capillary electrophoretic separation of the enantiomers of several weak acids in high pH background electrolytes with octakis-6-sulfato-gamma-cyclodextrin as the resolving agent.     

Synthesis and application of a novel single-isomer mono-6-deoxy-6-(3R,4R-dihydroxypyrrolidine)-β-cyclodextrin chloride as a chiral selector in capillary electrophoresis

A novel positively charged single-isomer of β-cyclodextrin, mono-6-deoxy-6-(3R,4R-dihydroxypyrrolidine)-β-CD chloride (dhypy-CDCl), was synthesized and employed as a chiral selector for the first time in capillary electrophoresis (CE) for the enantioseparation of anionic and ampholytic acids. The effects of the running buffer pH, chiral selector concentration, analyte structure and organic modifier on the enantioseparation were studied in detail. The chiral selectivity and resolution for most of the studied analytes decreased as the buffer pH increased in the range of 6.0–9.0. Increasing selector concentration led to decreased effective mobility, increased chiral selectivity and resolution for most of the studied analytes. Moreover, the hydroxyl groups located on the dihydroxypyrrolidine substituent of the dhypy-CDCl could have influence on the chiral separation.     

Modeling and optimization of the chiral selectivity of basic analytes in chiral capillary electrophoresis with negatively charged cyclodextrins using electrochemical detection

A mathematical model concerning the separation selectivity of basic analytes in chiral capillary electrophoresis (CE) modified with negatively charged cyclodextrins (CDs) has been presented to describe the dependence of chiral selectivity on the buffer pH and the chiral selector concentration. The electrophoretic method to determine the parameters of the model has also been developed. The model has been tested with racemic epinephrine and isoproterenol as target analytes and sulfonated beta-CD as chiral selector. The agreements have been found between the calculated and the measured values. Some significant conclusions to optimize chiral CE separation have been derived from the model and proven by the experiments. Electrochemical detection was used to meet the requirement of the low introduced concentration of analytes.     

Enhancement of second-migrating enantiomer peak symmetry of basic drugs by using dual-cyclodextrin system in capillary electrophoresis

Today, chiral separations of cationic drugs by capillary electrophoresis are generally carried out by adding negatively charged cyclodextrins (CDs) to the running buffer while anionic or neutral drug separations require the use of dual-CD systems (mixtures of neutral and charged CDs). Chiral separation of some basic drugs (idazoxan, efaroxan, milnacipran) has been studied by using mixtures of sulfated-beta-CD (S-beta-CD) and hydroxypropyl-gamma-CD (HP-gamma-CD). The influence of the following parameters (nature and concentration of neutral CD, concentration of S-gamma-CD) on many separation factors (electrophoretic mobility, selectivity, efficiency, asymmetry factor, resolution) demonstrated that dual-CD systems are useful for chiral separation of basic drugs in order to improve the symmetry of the second-migrating enantiomer. Indeed, the neutral CD reduces the extent of electromigration dispersion by mobility tuning. Finally, the 0.5 mg/mL S-beta-CD/5 mg/mL HP-gamma-CD dual system has allowed the chiral separation of idazoxan, efaroxan and milnacipran enantiomers in less than 9 min.     

Sweeping of alprenolol enantiomers with an organic solvent and sulfated β‐cyclodextrin in capillary electrophoresis

Sweeping, an on‐line sample concentration technique in CE, is the picking and accumulation of analytes by the pseudostationary phase or complexing additive. In the presence of an electric field, the analytes concentrated at the additive front that initially penetrated the sample zone. Here, we describe the sweeping of cationic alprenolol enantiomers using sulfated β‐CD and organic solvent. The separation solution contained the anionic additive while ACN was in the sample solution. With fused silica capillaries, positive polarity, and solutions buffered at pH 3, the direction of the enantiomers' effective electrophoretic mobility was the same as the electrophoretic mobility (or electrophoretic mobility without additive). When the amount of ACN in the sample was increased (i.e. 60%), the interaction between the analytes and additive became negligible. This caused the sweeping boundary to shift from the electrophoretically moving β‐CD front to the zone between the sample and separation solution. The equation that described the narrowing of injected sample zone was derived. The performance of sweeping with 60% ACN in the sample was then studied under different operating conditions (e.g. type of injection, injection time, and CD concentration). The low interaction between enantiomers and additive gave only moderate increases in sensitivity (approximately tenfold), but was improved when field enhancement was used during electrokinetic injection. With a conductivity difference (separation/sample solution) of 70 and a short injection time of 30 s at 20 kV, peak improvements of >100‐fold was easily achieved.     

Investigation of the novel mixed-mode stationary phase for capillary electrochromatography. II. Separation of amino acids and peptides on sulfonated naphthalimido-modified silyl silica gel

The potential of 3-(4-sulfo-1,8-naphthalimido)propyl-modified silyl silica gel (SNAIP) as a mixed-mode stationary phase for capillary electrochromatography (CEC) was investigated for the separation of charged analytes, taking four amino acids (tyrosine, phenylalanine, tryptophan, histidine) as model analytes. The elution process of these charged analytes in CEC with SNAIP was dominated by a combination of both electrophoretic process and chromatographic process involving hydrophobic as well as electrostatic interactions. In order to study the retention mechanism, the CEC retention factor k* and the velocity factor ke* were measured for the amino acids, which allowed the assessment of the respective contribution from the differential processes underlying the separation. Migration and retention could be mediated by changing various mobile phase compositions, including buffer pH, buffer concentration, and concentration of organic solvent. Based on the results obtained by separation of the amino acids, the separation of eight peptides (Gly-Val, Gly-Phe, Gly-Ile, Gly-His, Gly-Lys, Lys-Lys, Gly-Gly-Gly, Gly-Gly-His) was attempted. A good separation was achieved under an isocratic elution with a mobile phase consisting of 35 mM phosphate buffer (pH 3.8) and 40% methanol.     

Dual-gradient capillary electrochromatography by varying the mobile phase composition and applied voltage.

Dual-gradient capillary electrochromatography (DG-CEC) was developed to provide superior performance with regard to the separation of ionized analytes; in this method, both the eluent composition and the applied voltage are varied during the separation procedure. As for the gradient in the eluent composition, a shift in the pH is employed to control not only the electrophoretic mobility, but also the retention factor of the analytes. The dual-gradient method was shown to be effective in increasing the resolution and reducing the chromatographic period of ionized analytes. Fourteen kinds of o-phthalaldehyde labeled amino acids were separated within 8 min using DG-CEC with multistage enlargement in the applied voltage. The separation efficiency increased particularly for highly retained amino acids in the dual-gradient, as compared to those in the ordinary single-gradient for the eluent.