Boron‐functionalized poly(3‐hydroxybutyrate)s from hydroboration of poly(allyl‐β‐hydroxyalkanoate)s: Synthesis and insights into the microstructure

The controlled ring‐opening polymerization of racemic allyl‐β‐butyrolactone (rac‐BL^allyl) in toluene or in bulk, catalyzed by the discrete β‐diiminate zinc amido [(BDI^iPr)Zn(N(SiMe₃)₂)] ( 1 ) or {amino‐methoxy‐bis(phenolate)}yttrium amido [(ONOO^tBu)Y(N(SiHMe₂)₂)(THF)] ( 2 ) complexes, in association with an alcohol, gave poly(β‐hydroxyalkanoate)s (PHAs) with allylic side chains. These PHAs^allyl exhibit either a slightly isotactic‐enriched (P_m = 0.61) or highly syndiotactic‐enriched (P_r = 0.82) backbone structure, respectively, with high molar mass (M _n up to 21,100 g mol^?1) and narrow molar mass distribution values (1.05 < M _w/M _n < 1.28), as evidenced by detailed ¹³C NMR and size exclusion chromatography analyses. Postpolymerization rhodium‐catalyzed hydroboration of the resulting PHAs^allyl with pinacolborane quantitatively afforded the corresponding PHAs^boron. Introduction of boron into the pendant chains did not alter neither the structure of the polymer backbone nor the macromolecular features (M _n, M _w/M _n, and stereoregularity). However, differential scanning calorimetry analyses revealed a significant increase of the glass transition temperature on modifying the allyl for the boron function in these PHAs. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem, 2011     

Titanium complexes based on aminodiol ligands for the ring‐opening polymerization of ε‐caprolactone,rac‐β‐butyrolactone,and trimethylene carbonate

Several titanium complexes based on aminodiol ligands were tested as initiators for the ring‐opening polymerization (ROP) of ε‐caprolactone under solution and bulk conditions. All complexes were found to be efficient under both conditions. For bulk polymerization at 70 °C, high activities were observed (113.3–156.2 g_poly mmol_cat^?1 h^?1) together with controlled molar mass distribution. Kinetic studies revealed controlled polymerization, and the chain propagation was first order with respect to monomer conversion. One complex was also tested for the ROP of rac‐β‐butyrolactone and the end‐group analysis suggested that ring opening occurs through acyl‐oxygen bond cleavage via coordination–insertion mechanism. The microstructure analysis of polymer by ¹³C NMR indicates atactic polymer. Another complex was also found to be efficient initiator for the ROP of trimethylene carbonate under solution and bulk conditions. Again, end‐group analysis suggests coordination–insertion mechanism. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem, 2011     

Synthesis,kinetic study,and application of Ti[O(CH2)4OCHCH2]4 in ring‐opening polymerization of ε‐caprolactone and radical polymerization

Ti[O(CH₂)₄OCH?CH₂]₄, used for the ring‐opening polymerization (ROP) of ε‐caprolactone, was synthesized through the ester‐exchange reaction of titanium n‐propoxide and 1,4‐butanediol vinyl ether, and its chemical structure was confirmed by nuclear magnetic resonance (¹H NMR) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA). The mechanism and kinetics of Ti[O(CH₂)₄OCH?CH₂]₄‐initiated bulk polymerization of ε‐caprolactone were investigated. The results demonstrate that Ti[O (CH₂)₄OCH?CH₂]₄‐initiated polymerization of ε‐caprolactone proceeds through the coordination‐insertion mechanism, and all the four alkoxide arms in Ti[O (CH₂)₄OCH?CH₂]₄ share a similar activity in initiating ROP of ε‐caprolactone. The polymerization process can be well predicted by the obtained kinetic parameters, and the activation energy is 106 KJ/mol. Then, the rheological method was employed to investigate the feasibility of producing the crosslinked poly(ε‐caprolactone)‐poly (n‐butyl acrylate) network by using Ti[O(CH₂)₄OCH?CH₂]₄ as the ROP initiator. The tensile test demonstrates that the in situ generated crosslinked PCL‐PBA network in PMMA matrix provides the possibility of ameliorating the tensile properties of PMMA. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 46: 7773–7784, 2008     

Microwave‐assisted synthesis and characterization of biodegradable block copolyesters based on poly(3‐hydroxyalkanoate)s and poly(D,L‐lactide)

Microwave (MW)‐assisted ring‐opening polymerization (ROP) provides a rapid and straightforward method for engineering a wide array of well‐defined poly(3‐hydroxyalkanoate)‐b‐poly(D,L ‐lactide) (PHA‐b‐PLA) diblock copolymers. On MW irradiation, the bulk ROP of D,L ‐lactide (LA) could be efficiently triggered by a series of monohydroxylated PHA‐based macroinitiators previously produced via acid‐catalyzed methanolysis of corresponding native PHAs, thus affording diblock copolyesters with tunable compositions. The dependence of LA polymerization on temperature, macroinitiator structure, irradiation time, and [LA]₀/[PHA]₀ molar ratio was carefully investigated. It turned out that initiator efficiency values close to 1 associated with conversions ranging from 50 to 85% were obtained only after 5 min at 115 °C. A kinetic investigation of the MW‐assisted ROP of LA gave evidence of its “living”/controlled character under the experimental conditions selected. Structural analyses and thermal properties of biodegradable diblock copolyesters were also performed. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem, 2012     

Bis(4‐nitrophenyl) phosphate as an efficient organocatalyst for ring‐opening polymerization of β‐butyrolactone leading to end‐functionalized and diblock polyesters

The ring‐opening polymerization (ROP) of β‐butyrolactone (β‐BL) has been studied using the organocatalysts of diphenyl phosphate (DPP) and bis(4‐nitrophenyl) phosphate (BNPP). The controlled ROP of β‐BL was achieved using BNPP, whereas that of using DPP was insufficient because of its low acidity. For the BNPP‐catalyzed ROP of β‐BL, the dual activation property for β‐BL and the chain‐end models of poly(β‐butyrolactone) (PBL) were confirmed by NMR measurements. The optimized polymerization condition for the ROP of β‐BL proceeded through an O‐acyl cleavage to produce the well‐defined PBLs with molecular weights up to 10,650 g mol^?1 and relatively narrow polydispersities of 1.19–1.39. Functional initiators were utilized for producing the end‐functionalized PBLs with the ethynyl, maleimide, pentafluorophenyl, methacryloyl, and styryl groups. Additionally, the diblock copolymers consisting of the PBL segment with the polyester or polycarbonate segments were prepared by the BNPP‐catalyzed ROPs of ε‐caprolactone or trimethylene carbonate without quenching. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 2014 , 52, 2032–2039     

Polyester from dimethylketene and acetaldehyde: Direct copolymerization and β‐lactone ring‐opening polymerization

Two ways to obtain aliphatic polyesters (PEs) from dimethylketene and acetaldehyde were investigated. On the one hand, a direct anionic copolymerization was carried out in toluene at ?60 °C. The resulting polymer was mainly composed of PE units. On the other hand, a two‐step process involving the synthesis of 3,3,4‐trimethyl‐2‐oxetanone by [2+2] cycloaddition, followed by its ring‐opening polymerization, with various initiators and solvents, led to the expected PE. Molecular weights up to 9000 g mol^?1 (measured by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR)), with narrow polydispersity around 1.2, were obtained. These polymers were found stable up to 274 °C under nitrogen and a broad and complex endothermic peak attributed to crystallinity was observed near 139 °C by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The crystallinity, measured by X‐ray diffraction, was close to 0.45. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem, 2011     

Controlled ring‐opening homo‐ and copolymerization of ɛ‐caprolactone and d,l‐lactide by iminophenolate aluminum complexes: An efficient approach toward well‐defined macromonomers

The aluminum complexes containing two iminophenolate ligands of the type (p‐XC₆H₄NCHC₆H₄O‐o)₂AlR' (R′=Me ( 3, 4 ) or R′=O(CH₂)₄OCH=CH₂ ( 5, 6 ), X=H ( 3, 5 ), F( 4, 6 )) were synthesized and characterized by ¹H, ¹³C NMR spectroscopy, and X‐ray crystallography. The reaction of AlMe₃ with two equivalents of substituted iminophenols gave five‐coordinated {ONR}₂AlMe ( 3, 4 ) complexes. Subsequent reaction of these methyl complexes with unsaturated alcohol, HO(CH₂)₄OCH=CH₂, resulted in target compounds 5 and 6 in a good yield. It was shown that the complexes ( 3 ‐ 6 ) are monomeric in solution (NMR) and in solid state (X‐ray analysis). The catalytic activity of the complexes 5 and 6 towards ring‐opening polymerization (ROP) of ?‐caprolactone and d,l ‐lactide was assessed. Complex 5 showed higher activity as compared with 6 , while both of these catalysts induced controlled homo‐ and copolymerization to afford the macromonomers with high content of vinyl ether end groups (F_n > 80%) in a broad range of molecular weights (M_n = 4000–30,000 g mol^?1) with relatively narrow MWD (M_w/M_n = 1.1–1.5). © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 2014 , 52, 1237–1250     

Controlled synthesis and chemical modification of unsaturated aliphatic (Co)polyesters based on 6,7‐dihydro‐2(3H)‐oxepinone

A pure unsaturated cyclic ester, 6,7‐dihydro‐2(3H)‐oxepinone (DHO2), was prepared by a new synthetic route. The copolymerization of DHO2 with ?‐caprolactone (?CL) was initiated by aluminum isopropoxide [Al(OⁱPr)₃] at 0 °C as an easy way to produce unsaturated aliphatic polyesters with nonconjugated C?C double bonds in a controlled manner. The chain growth was living, as certified by the agreement between the experimental molecular weight at total monomer conversion and the value predicted from the initial monomer/initiator molar ratio. The polydispersity was reasonably low (weight‐average molecular weight/number‐average molecular weight ≤ 1.2). The homopolymerization of DHO2 was, however, not controlled because of fast intramolecular transesterification. Copolymers of DHO2 and ?CL were quantitatively oxidized with the formation of epoxides containing chains. The extent of the epoxidation allowed the thermal properties and thermal stability of the copolyesters to be modulated. The epoxidized copolyesters were successfully converted into thioaminated chains, which were then quaternized into polycations. No degradation occurred during the chemical modification. © 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 40: 2286–2297, 2002     

Synthesis of block and end‐functionalized polyesters by triflimide‐catalyzed ring‐opening polymerization of ε‐caprolactone, 1,5‐dioxepan‐2‐one,and rac‐lactide

The ring‐opening polymerization (ROP) of cyclic esters, such as ε‐caprolactone, 1,5‐dioxepan‐2‐one, and racemic lactide using the combination of 3‐phenyl‐1‐propanol as the initiator and triflimide (HNTf₂) as the catalyst at room temperature with the [monomer]₀/[initiator]₀ ratio of 50/1 was investigated. The polymerizations homogeneously proceeded to afford poly(ε‐caprolactone) (PCL), poly(1,5‐dioxepan‐2‐one) (PDXO), and polylactide (PLA) with controlled molecular weights and narrow polydispersity indices. The molecular weight determined from an ¹H NMR analysis (PCL, M_n,NMR = 5380; PDXO, M_n,NMR = 5820; PLA, M_n,NMR = 6490) showed good agreement with the calculated values. The ¹H NMR and matrix‐assisted laser desorption ionization time‐of‐flight mass spectrometry analyses strongly indicated that the obtained compounds were the desired polyesters. The kinetic measurements confirmed the controlled/living nature for the HNTf₂‐catalyzed ROP of cyclic esters. A series of functional alcohols, such as propargyl alcohol, 6‐azido‐1‐hexanol, N‐(2‐hydroxyethyl)maleimide, 5‐hexen‐1‐ol, and 2‐hydroxyethyl methacrylate, successfully produced end‐functionalized polyesters. In addition, poly(ethylene glycol)‐block‐polyester, poly(δ‐valerolactone)‐block‐poly(ε‐caprolactone), and poly(ε‐caprolactone)‐block‐polylactide were synthesized using the HNTf₂‐catalyzed ROP. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 2013, 51, 2455–2463     

Synthesis and ring‐opening polymerization of new monoalkyl‐substituted lactides

New monoalkyl‐substituted lactides were synthesized by reaction of α‐hydroxy acids with 2‐bromopropionyl bromide, and polymerized with various catalysts in the presence of benzyl alcohol by ring‐opening polymerization (ROP). The classic tin(II) 2‐ethylhexanoate (Sn(Oct)₂) catalyst was leading to polymers with narrow distribution and predictable molecular weights, in polymerizations in bulk or toluene at 100 °C. The polymerization rate was corresponding to the steric hindrance of the alkyl substituents, such as butyl, hexyl, benzyl, isopropyl, and dimethyl groups. A yield of 83% was obtained with the hexyl‐substituted lactide after 1 h of polymerization. Excellent conversions (97%) could be achieved by using the alternative catalyst 4‐(dimethylamino)pyridine (DMAP). This latter organic catalyst was most efficient in polymerizing the more steric‐hindered lactides with good molecular weight and polydispersity control, in comparison to the tin(II) 2‐ethylhexanoate and tin(II) trifluoromethane sulfonate [Sn(OTf)₂] catalysts. The efficiency of the DMAP catalyst and the variability of the monomer synthesis route for new alkyl‐substituted lactides allow to prepare and to envision a wide range of new functionalized polylactides for the elaboration of tailored materials. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 42: 4379–4391, 2004     

Synthesis of poly(ω‐pentadecalactone)‐b‐poly(acrylate) diblock copolymers via a combination of enzymatic ring‐opening and RAFT polymerization techniques

Herein the first reported preparation of diblock copolymers of the polyethylene‐like polyester poly(ω‐pentadecalactone) (PPDL) via a combination of enzymatic ring‐opening polymerization (eROP) and reversible addition‐fragmentation chain‐transfer (RAFT) polymerization techniques is described. PPDL was synthesized via eROP using Novozyme 435 as a catalyst and a bifunctional initiator/chain transfer agent (CTA) appropriate for the eROP of ω‐pentadecalactone (PDL) and RAFT polymerization of acrylic and styrenic monomers. Chain growth of the PPDL macro‐CTA was performed to prepare acrylic and styrenic diblock copolymers of PPDL, and demonstrates a facile, metal‐free, and “greener” alternative to preparing acrylic diblock copolymers of polyethylene (PE). Diblock copolymer architecture was substantiated via analysis of ¹H NMR spectroscopic, UV‐GPC chromatographic, DSC onset crystallization (T_c), and MALDI‐ToF mass spectrometric data. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 2016 , 54, 3326–3335     

Synthesis and properties of poly(carbonate‐co‐ester)s obtained by cationic ring‐opening copolymerization of spiroorthocarbonate and ε‐caprolactone

Cationic ring‐opening copolymerization behavior of 1,5,7,11‐tetraoxaspiro[5.5]undecane (SOC1) and ε‐caprolactone (CL), and the thermal behavior of the obtained copolymers are described. When SOC1 and CL were cationically copolymerized under various feed ratios using BF₃OEt₂ as the initiator in CH₂Cl₂ at 25 °C, the corresponding copolymers were obtained in 77–99% yields. The ¹H NMR spectroscopic analysis of the copolymers revealed that the copolymer compositions were almost identical to the feed ratios, and the diad ratios of SOC1–SOC1/SOC1–CL and CL–SOC1/CL–CL are 48.0/52.0 and 54.3/45.7. These observations proved the random structures of the copolymers without containing the long blocks of the homopolymer sequences. Differential scanning calorimetric (DSC) analysis revealed that the melting points and melting entharpies decreased with the increase of the SOC1 unit compositions, suggesting that the copolymers gain flexibility as the SOC1 unit increases. © 2006 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 44: 2937–2942, 2006     

Discrete Metal Catalysts for Stereoselective Ring‐Opening Polymerization of Chiral Racemic β‐Lactones

Poly(β‐hydroxyalkanoate)s (PHAs) are a class of aliphatic polyesters that can be efficiently synthesized by ring‐opening polymerization (ROP) of β‐lactones. The case of chiral racemic β‐substituted β‐lactones is particularly appealing since these monomers open the way to original tacticities and materials different from those biotechnologically produced. In this overview, after briefly surveying general considerations associated to the ROP of β‐lactones and metal‐based catalysts used in stereoselective ROP of racemic β‐butyrolactone, special emphasis is given to discrete rare earth catalysts that have allowed the preparation of highly syndiotactic poly(3‐hydroxybutyrate)s. Recent developments – such as preparation of stereocontrolled PHAs with pendant structural groups via (co)polymerization of functional β‐substituted β‐lactones, and highly alternating copolymers obtained by ROP of mixtures of enantiomerically pure but different monomers – are also discussed.

     

Organic‐acid mediated bulk polymerization of ε‐caprolactam and its copolymerization with ε‐caprolactone

Polyamides (PA) constitute one of the most important classes of polymeric materials and have gained strong position in different areas, such as textiles, fibers, and construction materials. Whereas most PA are synthesized by step‐growth polycondensation, PA 6 is synthesized by ring opening polymerization (ROP) of ε‐caprolactam (ε‐CLa). The most popular ROP methods involve the use of alkaline metal catalyst difficult to handle at large scale. In this article, we propose the use of organic acids for the ROP of ε‐CLa in bulk at 180 °C (below the polymer's melting point). Among evaluated organic acids, sulfonic acids were found to be the most effective for the polymerization of ε‐CLa , being the Brønsted acid ionic liquid: 1‐(4‐sulfobutyl)?3‐methylimidazolium hydrogen sulfate the most suitable due to its higher thermal stability. End‐group analysis by ¹H nuclear magnetic resonance and model reactions provided mechanistic insights and suggested that the catalytic activity of sulfonic acids was a function of not only the acid strength, but of the nucleophilic character of conjugate base as well. Finally, the ability of sulfonic acid to promote the copolymerization of ε‐CLa and ε‐caprolactone is demonstrated. As a result, poly(ε‐caprolactam‐co‐ε‐caprolactone) copolymers with considerably randomness are obtained. This benign route allows the synthesis of poly(ester amide)s with different thermal and mechanical properties. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 2016 , 54, 2394–2402     

Aluminum salen and salan complexes in the ring‐opening polymerization of cyclic esters: Controlled immortal and copolymerization of rac‐β‐butyrolactone and rac‐lactide

Aluminum‐based salen and salan complexes mediate the ring‐opening polymerization (ROP) of rac‐β‐butyrolactone (β‐BL), rac‐lactide, and ε‐caprolactone. Al‐salen and Al‐salan complexes exhibit excellent control over the ROP of rac‐β‐butyrolactone, yielding atactic poly(3‐hydroxybutyrate) (PHB) with narrow PDIs of <1.15 for Al‐salen and <1.05 for Al‐salan. Kinetic studies reveal pseudo‐first‐order polymerization kinetics and a linear relationship between molecular weight and percent conversion. These complexes also mediate the immortal ROP of rac‐β‐BL and rac‐lactide, through the addition of excess benzyl alcohol of up to 50 mol eq., with excellent control observed. A novel methyl/adamantyl‐substituted Al‐salen system further improves control over the ROP of rac‐lactide and rac‐β‐BL, yielding atactic PHB and highly isotactic poly(lactic acid) (P_m = 0.88). Control over the copolymerization of rac‐lactide and rac‐β‐BL was also achieved, yielding poly(lactic acid)‐co‐poly(3‐hydroxybutyrate) with narrow PDIs of <1.10. ¹H NMR spectra of the copolymers indicate a strong bias for the insertion of rac‐lactide over rac‐β‐BL. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem, 2013     

Sequence‐controlled cationic ring‐opening copolymerization of spiroorthocarbonate and oxetane

Pseudo block and triblock copolymers were synthesized by the cationic ring‐opening copolymerization of 1,5,7,11‐tetraoxaspiro[5.5]undecane (SOC1) with trimethylene oxide (OX) via one‐shot and two‐shot procedures, respectively. When SOC1 and OX were copolymerized cationically with boron trifluoride etherate (BF₃OEt₂) as an initiator in CH₂Cl₂ at 25 °C, OX was consumed faster than SOC1. SOC1 was polymerized from the OX‐rich gradient copolymer produced in the initial stage of the copolymerization to afford the corresponding pseudo block copolymer, poly [(OX‐grad‐SOC1)‐b‐SOC1]. We also succeeded in the synthesis of a pseudo triblock copolymer by the addition of OX during the course of the polymerization of SOC1 before its complete consumption, which provided the corresponding pseudo triblock copolymer, poly[SOC1‐b‐(OX‐grad‐SOC1)‐b‐SOC1]. © 2006 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 44: 3233–3241, 2006     

Effect of Cocatalysts on the Catalytic Activities of Tantalum‐ and Niobium‐Based Catalysts for Ring‐Opening Metathesis Polymerization of Norbornene

A series of pentavalent tantalum and niobium complexes with aryloxy ligands was prepared, and their catalytic behavior for the ROMP of norbornene was studied in the presence of an alkylaluminum cocatalyst. Tantalum complexes 1 – 4 showed very high activity for the ROMP of NBE in combination with ⁱBu₃Al to give high‐molecular‐weight polymers. In contrast, the niobium complexes 5 and 6 , as well as NbCl₅, exhibited very high activity upon activation with Me₃Al to give high‐molecular‐weight polymers.

     

Easy synthesis and ring‐opening polymerization of 5‐Z‐amino‐δ‐valerolactone: New degradable amino‐functionalized (Co)polyesters

Novel 5‐Z‐amino‐δ‐valerolactone (5‐NHZ‐VL) was synthesized with an aim to prepare degradable polyesters and copolyesters having amino pendant groups. Following a straightforward and efficient synthetic pathway, 5‐NHZ‐VL was obtained in only two steps and up to 50% yield. The monomer was fully characterized by ¹H NMR, ¹³C NMR, ESI mass spectrometry, and HPLC. Various conventional conditions were tested for this lactone ring‐opening polymerization and led to the novel corresponding poly(5‐NHZ‐VL) (M_n = 7000 g/mol; PD = 1.2). Following this homopolymerization, 5‐NHZ‐VL was copolymerized with ε‐caprolactone to generate a family of copolyesters with an amino‐group content ranging from 10 to 80%. Finally, the polyelectrolyte poly(5‐NH₃⁺‐VL) was recovered by removal of the protecting group under acidic conditions, and integrity of the polyester backbone was confirmed by ¹H NMR. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem, 2010     

Cationic copolymerization of racemic‐β‐butyrolactone with L,L‐lactide: One‐pot synthesis of block copolymers

Cationic copolymerization of racemic‐β‐butyrolactone (β‐BL) with l,l ‐lactide (LA) initiated by alcohol and catalyzed by trifluoromethanesulfonic acid proceeding by activated monomer (AM) mechanism was investigated. Although both comonomers were present from the beginning in the reaction mixture, polymerization proceeded in sequential manner, with poly‐BL formed at the first stage acting as a macroinitiator for the subsequent polymerization of LA. Such course of copolymerization was confirmed by following the consumption of both comonomers throughout the process as well as by observing the changes of growing chain‐end structure using ¹H NMR. ¹³C NMR analysis and thermogravimetry revealed the block structure of resulting copolymers. The proposed mechanism of copolymerization was confirmed by the studies of changes of ¹H NMR chemical shift of acidic proton in the course of copolymerization, providing an indication that indeed protonated species and hydroxyl groups are present throughout the process, as required for AM mechanism. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 2013 , 51, 4873–4884