Advantages and drawbacks of popular supercritical fluid chromatography/mass interfacing approaches--a user's perspective

Mobile phases in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) have low viscosities and high diffusion coefficients with respect to those of traditional high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). These properties allow higher mobile phase flow rates and/or longer columns in SFC, resulting in rapid analyses and high efficiency separations. In addition, chiral SFC is becoming especially popular. Mass spectrometry (MS) is arguably the most popular "informative" detector for chromatographic separations. Most SFC/MS is performed with atmospheric pressure ionization (API) sources. Unlike LC/MS, the interface between the SFC column and the API source must allow control of the downstream (post-column) pressure while also providing good chromatographic fidelity. Here we compare and contrast the popular interfacing approaches. Some are simple, such as direct effluent introduction with no active back-pressure-regulator (BPR) in high speed bioanalytical applications. The pressure-regulating-fluid interface is more versatile and provides excellent chromatographic fidelity, but is less user friendly. The pre-BPR- split interface and an interface which provides total-flow-introduction with a mechanical BPR are good compromises between user friendliness and performance, and have become the most popular among practitioners. Applications of SFC/MS using these various interfaces are also discussed.     

Reviews on recent trends in chromatography/mass spectrometry coupling. Part IV. Reasons why supercritical fluid chromatography is not so easily coupled with mass spectrometry as originally assessed

Summary When SFC was rediscovered in the early 1980s, it was frequently estimated that a strong driving force to its development would be the ease of devising a simple SFC/MS interface. This was believed to be easily achieved if analytical conditions were limited to capillary SFC columns as a general separation tool, and to the choice of neat CO₂ as the unique supercritical fluid. The low flow rate of mobile phase delivered by capillary columns was easy to accommodate by the vacuum equipment of standard mass spectrometers, and the specific physical properties of CO₂ made possible solute ionization by different ion-molecule reactions, especially charge exchange ionization. This approach has lived up to all of its promises. The major causes of the observed mismatch are the large variations of the MS source pressure as a result of the CO₂ pressure gradient at the SFC column inlet, the low sensitivity of charge exchange ionization at these high MS source pressures, and the inability to handle polar and nonvolatile molecules. Adaptation of LC/MS interfaces, such as the thermospray interface or the particle beam interface, to SFC/MS conditions was a step forward, but these devices have their own limitations. Alternative methods to direct SFC/MS coupling have been investigated recently. They are based on the use of packed columns rather than capillaries, and on solute ionization at atmospheric pressure rather than under a vacuum, by means of either gas-phase corona discharge ionization or liquidphase electrospray ionization. These new developments may revive research into the design of reproducible and sensitive SFC/MS systems where the number of recent studies is still low compared with other chromatography/mass spectrometry coupling studies.See [1] for part III     

Development of capillary supercritical fluid chromatography/Fourier transform infrared spectrometry

Summary The feasibility of a new technique, supercritical fluid chromatography/Fourier transform infrared spectrometry (SFC/FTIR), for separation and identification of nonvolatile and labile compounds in complex mixtures is discussed in this report. The design of a high pressure (flow cell) interface is described. The results of a continuing study of possible mobile phases for SFC/FTIR are presented. Finally, SFC/FTIR was applied to a standard test mixture. The current detection limits of one component of the mixture, 2,6-di-t-butylphenol, are presented.     

On-line supercritical fluid chromatography with Fourier transform infrared spectrometric detection employing packed columns and a high pressure lightpipe flow cell

Summary The coupling of packed-column supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) with Fourier-transform infrared spectrometry (FTIR) is demonstrated. The interface used for SFC-FTIR experiments is based on the lightpipe used for GC-FTIR, but it has been designed to withstand the high-pressure constraints of SFC. When used with beam condensing optics, this SFC-FTIR lightpipe flow cell has allowed detection limits as low as 270ng (3×N_p-p) of injected acetophenone. Separation of a seven-component model mixture is shown on a silica bondedphase phenyl column. The on-line infrared spectra obtained are high-quality and readily identifiable. Spectral features of high-pressure carbon dioxide (subcritical vs. supercritical) are discussed with respect to infrared transparency in the flow cell SFC-FTIR experiment.     

On-line packed column supercritical fluid chromatography--microwave-induced plasma atomic emission

Interfacing and evaluation of packed column supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC)-microwave-induced plasma atomic emission detection (AED) is described. Via a flow splitter and an integral restrictor, efficient transfer of solutes from column to detector without band broadening is obtained. Variation of CO2 flow-rate during pressure gradients has little influence on both AED signal and baseline drift while it provides similar sensitivity as in capillary SFC. Continuous introduction of CO2 in the plasma reduces the available range of emission domains; nevertheless the region of detection which is free of CO2 interferences allows selective detection of C1 and Br as reported in this paper. reserved.     

An attempt to extend ordinary capillary gas chromatography to supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC)

Since capillary columns with well immobilized stationary phases are expected to withstand contact with supercritical fluids, we wished to study their amenability to SFC. Simultaneously, we wished to learn how far SFC can be accomplished with the ordianary tools of capillary GC. The study demonstrates that truly supercritical, not just relatively high, pressure is required to ensure the typical effects of SFC. Results obtained with sub-and supercritical pressure are compared and discussed. A comprehenshive study of the parameters permitting SFC with capillary GC equipment showed a clear preference for CO₂ as a carrier, FID detection, and oncolumn sampling. While no additional equipment is required, a critical feature is the flow restrictor to be mounted on the end of the column. The production and properties of this restrictor are discussed in detail. It is reasonable to hope that SFC with 0.1 mm id capillary columns can be realized in the pressure range of 100–150 bar, where substances which cannot be eluted from a capillary colum under GC donditions are expected to be analyzed.     

Screening for antioxidants in complex matrices using high performance liquid chromatography with acidic potassium permanganate chemiluminescence detection

The use of high performance liquid chromatography with acidic potassium permanganate chemiluminescence detection to screen for antioxidants in complex plant-derived samples was evaluated in comparison with two conventional post-column radical scavenging assays (2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl radical (DPPH) and 2,2'-azinobis-(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonic acid) radical cation (ABTS(+))). In this approach, acidic potassium permanganate can react with readily oxidisable compounds (potential antioxidants), post-column, to produce chemiluminescence. Using flow injection analysis, experimental parameters that afforded the most suitable permanganate chemiluminescence signal for a range of known antioxidants were studied in a univariate approach. Optimum conditions were found to be: 1×10(-3)M potassium permanganate solution containing 1% (w/v) sodium polyphosphates adjusted to pH 2 with sulphuric acid, delivered at a flow rate of 2.5 mL min(-1) per line. Further investigations showed some differences in detection selectivity between HPLC with the optimised post-column permanganate chemiluminescence detection and DPPH and ABTS(+) assays towards antioxidant standards. However, permanganate chemiluminescence detection was more sensitive. Moreover, screening for antioxidants in green tea, cranberry juice and thyme using potassium permanganate chemiluminescence offers several advantages over the traditional DPPH and ABTS(+) assays, such as faster reagent preparation and superior stability; simpler post-column reaction manifold; and greater compatibility with fast chromatographic separations using monolithic columns.     

Pressure drop effects on selectivity and resolution in packed column supercritical fluid chromatography

The influence of pressure drop on retention, selectivity, plate height and resolution was investigated systematically in packed supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) using pure carbon dioxide as the mobile phase. Numerical methods developed previously which enabled the prediction of pressure gradients, diffusivities, capacity factors, plate heights and resolutions along the length of the column were used for the model calculations. The effects of inlet pressure and supercritical fluid flow rate on selectivity and resolution are studied. In packed column SFC with pure carbon dioxide as the mobile phase, the pressure drop can have a significant effect on resolution. The flow rate is shown to have a larger effect than generally realized. The calculated data are shown to be in good agreement with the experimental results. Finally, the variation of the chromatographic parameters along a 5.5 meter long model SFC column is illustrated. The possibilities and limitations of using long packed columns in SFC are discussed. It is demonstrated that long columns with large plate numbers do not necessarily yield better separations.     

Evaluation of an ion mobility detector for supercritical fluid chromatography with solvent-modified carbon dioxide mobile phases

Summary An ion mobility detector (IMD) was evaluated for open tubular column supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) when organic solvent-modified supercritical CO₂ was used as mobile phase. It was found that the SFC/IMD interface design in which the SFC capillaray restrictor was directly inserted into the ionization region of the IMD was not acceptable because of low sensitivity that resulted from the effect of the modifier on detector temperature and mechanism of detection. A new interface utilizing a heated nebulizer gas to provide heat to the restrictor and to minimize the formation of ion clusters, and a bent nozzle for enhancing the ionization efficiency of the solute in the IMD ion source are described. Using 5% acetonitrile in CO₂, the minimum detectable quantity (S/N=3) for pyrene was improved from 25.2 ng to 2.1 ng with the new detector design. This compares to a minimum detectable quantity of 0.1 ng when using neat CO₂ as mobile phase. The use of molecular connectivity calculations to predict the drift times of selected analytes is also successfully demonstrated.     

Correlation of supercritical-fluid extraction recoveries with supercritical-fluid chromatographic retention data: A fundamental study

The possibility of using supercritical-fluid chromatographic retention data for examining the effects of operational parameters, such as pressure and flow rate, on the extraction characteristics in supercritical-fluid extraction (SFE) was investigated. A model was derived for calculating the extraction efficiency in SFE from retention data and peak shapes measured in supercritical-fluid chromatography (SFC). By performing the SFC experiments at the same pressure and temperature as the SFE extractions using the SFE extraction cell as the SFC column, an accurate prediction of extraction efficiencies could be made. Finally, the effects of matrix composition and analyte concentration on extraction efficiency were studied.     

Oxalate ester addition from a solid reagent bed for chemiluminescence detection in HPLC

Summary The combination of solid-state peroxyoxalate chemiluminescence detection and post-column chemical reaction systems in liquid chromatography is investigated. Bis-2,4,6-trichlorophenyloxalate (TCPO) is added from a solid reagent bed with the fluorophore, 3-aminofluoranthene, immobilized on glass beads. Hydrogen peroxide generated photochemically by quinone analytes is measured. Flow splitting is shown to be a simple means of reagent addition with a negligible band broadening effect. This system is compared to a more flexible dualpump design. To minimize band broadening in both systems, the reagent bed is located out of the path of the chromatographic effluent. Detection limits are in the sub-picomole range, an imporvement relative to those previously reported with TCPO added in the liquid phase. These systems can be easily be adapted for detection of peroxide generated by other post-column reactions.     

Separation and purification of six components from the roots of Rheum officinale Baill. by supercritical fluid chromatography

The dried roots of Rheum officinale Baill., named Dahuang in Chinese, has many pharmacological effects and has been widely used for the treatment of many diseases. To develop a harmless and eco-friendly method for the separation of components in Dahuang is of great interest for quality control and pharmacological study of Dahuang. A method for separation and purification of components in Dahuang using supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) is established in this work. Samples were prepared by extraction of Dahuang powders with 20% H₂SO₄ and benzene under reflux. The extracts were obtained by evaporating benzene extracts and separating by SFC on YMC-Diol column using supercritical CO₂ with CH₃OH 4% (v/v) as the modifier. The flow rate of the mobile phase was 15?mL/min, the column pressure was 13?MPa, and the column temperature was 318?K. Cinnamic acid and five kinds of hydroxyanthraquinones including rhein, emodin, aloe emodin, chrysophanol, and physcion were obtained by SFC. The purities of the obtained compounds were all above 97% as determined by high performance liquid chromatography and their chemical structures were identified by nuclear magnetic resonance and mass spectrum. The thermodynamics of chromatographic process was also studied and it revealed that the SFC separation process of these compounds on YMC-Diol column was controlled by enthalpy.     

Multisyringe ion chromatography with chemiluminescence detection for the determination of oxalate in beer and urine samples

The first multisyringe-based low-pressure ion chromatographic method is presented. It is based on the use of short surfactant coated octadecyl-silica monolithic columns. As a first application, we have determined oxalate in beer and human urine via post-column chemiluminescence detection. Oxalate is separated from the sample matrix in the monolithic column by precise programmable fluid handling, and then detected by reaction with on-line generated tris(2,2??-bipyridyl)ruthenium(III). Column coating, un-coating, ion chromatography and chemiluminescence detection are quickly performed by using a simple low-pressure multi-burette. The factors influencing the separation of oxalate and its subsequent detection, including the column coating with surfactants and its stability have been studied. The chromatographic behavior of the oxalate in presence of potentially interfering species also was assessed. The method has limits of detection and quantification of 0.025 and 0.035?mg?L^?1, respectively, a relative standard deviation of 3.1% (for 10 consecutive measurements without column re-coating) and a throughput of 48?h^?1. The results obtained with real samples were validated by using an enzymatic spectrophotometric test. The method is critically compared to recent methods for the determination of oxalate.

Isolation and purification of osthole and imperatorin from Fructus Cnidii by semi-preparative supercritical fluid chromatography

Fructus Cnidii, the dried ripe fruit of Cnidium monnieri (L.) Cusson., has been widely used in traditional Chinese medicine. Osthole and imperatorin are the main active ingredients of Fructus Cnidii and had been found of antispasmodic, anti-HIV, anti-fungal, anti-viral, anti-tumor, anti-mutagenic, anti-arrhythmic, hypotensive, and broad-spectrum antimicrobial effects. A supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) method for isolation and purification of osthole and imperatorin from Fructus Cnidii was established in this work. The separation conditions, including the stationary phase, the organic modifier, the composition and the flow rate of the mobile phase, column backpressure and column temperature, were optimized on analytical scale at first. And then a semi-preparative SFC (SP-SFC) method was developed based on the conditions of analytical scale SFC. SP-SFC was accomplished on YMC-Pack NH₂ column. Ethanol was used as the modifier and its percentage in the mobile phase was 3%. The flow rate of the mobile phase was 20?mL/min, column backpressure was 13?MPa, column temperature was 318?K, detection wavelength was 310?nm, and injection volume was 0.2?mL. Under the optimum conditions, osthole and imperatorin were obtained with high purities as determined by high performance liquid chromatography. The chemical structures of the obtained compounds were identified by nuclear magnetic resonance and mass spectrum analysis.     

Optimization and development of a high-performance liquid chromatography-based one-site immunometric assay with chemiluminescence detection

Various practical and theoretical considerations were examined in the creation and optimization of a high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)-based one-site immunometric assay. This method used an HPLC analyte analog column and post-column chemiluminescence detection. The specific analyte chosen as the model for this study was l-thyroxine (also known as T₄). In this technique, a sample containing thyroxine was first combined with an excess of anti-T₄ antibody Fab fragments that had earlier been conjugated with chemiluminescent acridinium ester labels. After incubation, the mixture was injected onto a column that contained immobilized T₄. The amount of thyroxine in the original sample was then determined by measuring the labeled Fab fragments that appeared in the non-retained fraction, or the decrease in excess Fab fragments that were bound to and later eluted from the column. Items considered in creating this assay included the preparation of acridinium ester-labeled Fab fragments, the detection of these fragments with a post-column reactor, and the creation of a suitable immobilized analog column for capturing excess labeled Fab fragments. The final method could measure T₄ in standards at clinically-relevant concentrations and provided a response within 1.5 min of sample injection, following a 20-45 min incubation with the labeled Fab fragments. Possible applications of this method include its use in clinical chemistry and the screening of proteomic or combinatorial libraries.     

Capillary column SFC instrumentation based on piston pumps with a programmable back-pressure regulator for on-line mixing of mobile phases

An alternative phase delivery system based on piston pumps and a back-pressure regulator has been developed for capillary column SFC. The chromatography is not affected by the fast piston pump refill. A homogeneous on-line mixing of binary phases with simultaneous pressure programming is easily accessible without any additional computing. Acceptable reproducibilities (< 3.5% RSD for external and < 2.0% RSD for internal standard methods) were found with mixtures of 2-propanol/CO₂ as mobile phases using UV detection and split ratios of 1:60 and 1:120. Variation and control of the split are easily done by simple flow rate volumetric changes.     

Compressibility effects in packed and open tubular gas and supercritical fluid chromatography

The influence of the pressure drop on the efficiency and speed of analysis in packed and open tubular supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) is described: methods previously developed to describe the effects of mobile phase compressibility on the performance of open tubular columns in SFC have been extended to packed columns. The Horvath and Lin equation has been used to elucidate the influence of variations in velocity, diffusivity, and capacity factor along the column on the overall efficiency of packed column SFC. In packed columns, in contrast with the situation in open tubular columns, because the increase in velocity is no longer compensated by an increase in diffusion coefficients, the increase in both linear velocity and capacity factor which result from a significant pressure drop cause the plate height to increase along the column. The effect of fluid decompression along the length of the column on the speed of analysis in SFC has been studied and numerical expressions derived which enable calculation of compressibility correction factors for the plate height. Both the f₁ and f₂ correction factors remain very close to unity for acceptable pressure drops, which means that the pressure drop has virtually no effect on the number of plates generated per unit time for an unretained component. For retained species, the decompression of the mobile phase across the column causes the capacity factor to increase and hence leads to increased analysis times.     

Automated pre-column derivatization of amines in biological samples with dansyl chloride and with or without post-column chemiluminescence formation by using TCPO-H2O2.

On-line automation of two different liquid chromatographic procedures, a pre-column derivatization system and a pre- and post-column system, in order to generate chemiluminescence is reported. Dansyl chloride (Dns-Cl) was used as a pre-column reagent to form fluorophores and bis(2,4,6-trichlorophenyl) oxalate (TCPO) and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) as a post-column reagent to generate chemiluminescence. This procedure is based on the employment of a primary column packed with C18 material inserted in a multi-dimensional assembly for sample clean-up and derivatization with Dns-Cl. The dansyl derivatives formed are transferred and separated in a LiChrospher 100 RP18 analytical column (125 x 4 mm id, 5 microns film thickness) using acetonitrile-imidazole buffer (pH 6.8) (70 + 30) as eluent. The separated derivatives were transferred to the detector for fluorescence detection or to the post-column system where the chemiluminescence response was generated by using TCPO-H2O2 and the products were detected by chemiluminescence. The procedure was optimised for amphetamine and related compounds. A comparison between the on-line pre-column and pre- and post-column systems was performed. The results show that the sensitivity of chemiluminescence detection can be higher than that of fluorescence detection. The recoveries obtained ranged from 98 +/- 8 up to 108 +/- 8% for amphetamine and methamphetamine, respectively. The accuracy and precision of these methods were evaluated.     

The plasma emission detector (PED) as an element-selective detector for supercritical fluid chromatography

The plasma emission detector (PED) has been shown to be an element specific detector for supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC). The commonly used eluents (CO₂ and N₂O) tend to disturb the He plasma; two different discharge tubes were tested in an attempt to overcome this problem. Promising results were obtained with a concentric dual flow torch design for the element specific detection of Cl, H, and C containing analytes using N₂O as SFC mobile phase.