Electron Transfer Dissociation Reveals Changes in the Cleavage Frequencies of Backbone Bonds Distant to Amide-to-Ester Substitutions in Polypeptides

Interrogation of electron transfer dissociation (ETD) mass spectra of peptide amide-to-ester backbone bond substituted analogues (depsipeptides) reveals substantial differences in the entire backbone cleavage frequencies. It is suggested that the point permutation of backbone bonds leads to changes in the predominant ion structures by removal/weakening of specific hydrogen bonding. ETD responds to these changes by redistributing the cleavage frequencies of the peptide backbone bonds. In comparison, no distinction between depsi-/peptide was observed using collision-activated dissociation, which is consistent with a general unfolding and elimination of structural information of these ions. These results should encourage further exploration of depsipeptides for gas-phase structural characterization.     

Electron Capture Dissociation of Hydrogen-Deficient Peptide Radical Cations

Hydrogen-deficient peptide radical cations exhibit fascinating gas phase chemistry, which is governed by radical driven dissociation and, in many cases, by a combination of radical and charge driven fragmentation. Here we examine electron capture dissociation (ECD) of doubly, [M + H]^2+?, and triply, [M + 2H]^3+?, charged hydrogen-deficient species, aiming to investigate the effect of a hydrogen-deficient radical site on the ECD outcome and characterize the dissociation pathways of hydrogen-deficient species in ECD. ECD of [M + H]^2+? and [M + 2H]^3+? precursor ions resulted in efficient electron capture by the hydrogen-deficient species. However, the intensities of c- and z-type product ions were reduced, compared with those observed for the even electron species, indicating suppression of N?CC_?? backbone bond cleavages. We postulate that radical recombination occurs after the initial electron capture event leading to a stable even electron intermediate, which does not trigger N?CC_?? bond dissociations. Although the intensities of c- and z-type product ions were reduced, the number of backbone bond cleavages remained largely unaffected between the ECD spectra of the even electron and hydrogen-deficient species. We hypothesize that a small ion population exist as a biradical, which can trigger N?CC_?? bond cleavages. Alternatively, radical recombination and N?CC_?? bond cleavages can be in competition, with radical recombination being the dominant pathway and N?CC_?? cleavages occurring to a lesser degree. Formation of b- and y-type ions observed for two of the hydrogen-deficient peptides examined is also discussed.     

Dissociation Channel Dependence on Peptide Size Observed in Electron Capture Dissociation of Tryptic Peptides

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) of a series of five residue peptides led to the observation that these small peptides did not lead to the formation of the usual c/z ECD fragments, but to a, b, y, and w fragments. In order to determine how general this behavior is for small sized peptides, the effect of peptide size on ECD fragments using a complete set of ECD spectra from the SwedECD spectra database was examined. Analysis of the database shows that b and w fragments are favored for small peptide sizes and that average fragment size shows a linear relationship to parent peptide size for most fragment types. From these data, it appears that most of the w fragments are not secondary fragments of the major z ions, in sharp contrast with the proposed mechanism leading to these ions. These data also show that c fragment distributions depend strongly on the nature of C-terminal residue basic site: arginine leads to loss of short neutral fragments, whereas lysine leads to loss of longer neutral fragments. It also appears that b ions might be produced by two different mechanisms depending on the parent peptide size. A model for the fragmentation pathways in competition is proposed. These relationships between average fragment size and parent peptide size could be further exploited also for CID fragment spectra and could be included in fragmentation prediction algorithms.     

Photoleucine Survives Backbone Cleavage by Electron Transfer Dissociation. A Near-UV Photodissociation and Infrared Multiphoton Dissociation Action Spectroscopy Study

We report a combined experimental and computational study aimed at elucidating the structure of N-terminal fragment ions of the c type produced by electron transfer dissociation of photo-leucine (L*) peptide ions GL*GGKX. The c ₄ ion from GL*GGK is found to retain an intact diazirine ring that undergoes selective photodissociation at 355 nm, followed by backbone cleavage. Infrared multiphoton dissociation action spectra point to the absence in the c ₄ ion of a diazoalkane group that could be produced by thermal isomerization of vibrationally hot ions. The c ₄ ion from ETD of GL*GGK is assigned an amide structure by a close match of the IRMPD action spectrum and calculated IR absorption. The energetics and kinetics of c ₄ ion dissociations are discussed.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract ?

     

Electron Capture Dissociation and Collision Induced Dissociation of S-Dipalmitoylated Peptides

Here we investigate the effect of S-dipalmitoylation on the electron capture dissociation (ECD) behavior of peptides. The ECD and collision induced dissociation (CID) of peptides modified by covalent attachment of [(RS)-2,3-di(palmitoyloxy)-propyl] (PAM2) group to cysteine residues [C(PAM2)LEYDTGFK and RPPGC(PAM2)SPFK] were examined. The results suggest that ECD of S-dipalmitoylated peptides can provide both primary sequence information and structural information regarding the modification. The structural information provided by CID is complementary to that provided by ECD.

电子捕获裂解质谱研究进展

过去的二十年中，以电子捕获裂解为代表的离子反应技术，极大地推动了气相自由基离子化学的研究.该领域的发展是现代质谱的前沿问题，同时也是后基因组时代生物分析的重要技术手段.总结了电子捕获裂解的研究进展，并对其产生、裂解规律以及机理的研究进行了详细的综述.     

Electron Capture,Collision-Induced,and Electron Capture-Collision Induced Dissociation in Q-TOF

Recently, we demonstrated that a radio-frequency-free electromagnetostatic (rf-free EMS) cell could be retrofitted into a triple quad mass spectrometer to allow electron-capture dissociation (ECD) without the aid of cooling gas or phase-specific electron injection into the cell (Voinov et al., Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 22, 3087–3088, 2008; Voinov et al., Anal Chem 81, 1238–1243, 2009). Subsequently, we used our rf-free EMS cell in the same instrument platform to demonstrate ECD occurring in the same space and at the same time with collision-induced dissociation (CID) to produce golden pairs and even triplets from peptides (Voinov et al., Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 23, 3028–3030, 2009). In this report, we demonstrate that ECD and CID product-ion mass spectra can be recorded at high resolution with flexible control of fragmentation processes using a newly designed cell installed in a hybrid Q-TOF tandem mass spectrometer.     

Electron Capture Dissociation of Trivalent Metal Ion-Peptide Complexes

With electrospray ionization from aqueous solutions, trivalent metal ions readily adduct to small peptides resulting in formation of predominantly (peptide + M_T ? H)²⁺, where M_T = La, Tm, Lu, Sm, Ho, Yb, Pm, Tb, or Eu, for peptides with molecular weights below ~1000 Da, and predominantly (peptide + M_T)³⁺ for larger peptides. ECD of (peptide + M_T ? H)²⁺ results in extensive fragmentation from which nearly complete sequence information can be obtained, even for peptides for which only singly protonated ions are formed in the absence of the metal ions. ECD of these doubly charged complexes containing M_T results in significantly higher electron capture efficiency and sequence coverage than peptide-divalent metal ion complexes that have the same net charge. Formation of salt-bridge structures in which the metal ion coordinates to a carboxylate group are favored even for (peptide + M_T)³⁺. ECD of these latter complexes for large peptides results in electron capture by the protonation site located remotely from the metal ion and predominantly c/z fragments for all metals, except Eu³⁺, which undergoes a one electron reduction and only loss of small neutral molecules and b/y fragments are formed. These results indicate that solvation of the metal ion in these complexes is extensive, which results in the electrochemical properties of these metal ions being similar in both the peptide environment and in bulk water.      

Electron Capture by the Thiyl Radical and Disulfide Bond: Ligand Effects on the Reduction Potential

The effect of non‐polar and polar ligands and of monovalent cations on the one‐electron reduction potential of the thiyl radical and the disulfide bond was evaluated. The reduction potentials E° for the CH₃S^.–n L/CH₃S^?–n L and CH₃SSCH₃–L/CH₃SSCH₃^.?–L redox couples were calculated at the B3LYP, M06‐2X and MP2 levels of theory, with n=1, 2 and L=CH₄, C₂H₄, H₂O, CH₃OH, NH₃, CH₃COOH, CH₃CONH₂, NH₄⁺, Na⁺, K⁺ and Li⁺. Non‐polar ligands decrease the E° value of the thiyl radical and disulfide bond, while neutral polar ligands favour electron uptake. Charged polar ligands and cations favour electron capture by the thiyl radical while disfavouring electron uptake by the disulfide bond. Thus, the same type of ligand can have a different effect on E° depending on the redox couple. Therefore, properties of an isolated ligand cannot uniquely determine E°. The ligand effects on E° are discussed in terms of the vertical electron affinity and reorganization energy, as well as molecular orbital theory. For a given redox couple, the ligand type influences the nature of the anion formed upon electron capture and the corresponding reorganization process towards the reduced geometry.     

Mechanistic Study on Electron Capture Dissociation of the Oligosaccharide-Mg2+ Complex

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) has shown great potential in structural characterization of glycans. However, our current understanding of the glycan ECD process is inadequate for accurate interpretation of the complex glycan ECD spectra. Here, we present the first comprehensive theoretical investigation on the ECD fragmentation behavior of metal-adducted glycans, using the cellobiose-Mg₂₊ complex as the model system. Molecular dynamics simulation was carried out to determine the typical glycan-Mg₂₊ binding patterns and the lowest-energy conformer identified was used as the initial geometry for density functional theory-based theoretical modeling. It was found that the electron is preferentially captured by Mg₂₊ and the resultant Mg_+? can abstract a hydroxyl group from the glycan moiety to form a carbon radical. Subsequent radical migration and α-cleavage(s) result in the formation of a variety of product ions. The proposed hydroxyl abstraction mechanism correlates well with the major features in the ECD spectrum of the Mg₂₊-adducted cellohexaose. The mechanism presented here also predicts the presence of secondary, radical-induced fragmentation pathways. These secondary fragment ions could be misinterpreted, leading to erroneous structural determination. The present study highlights an urgent need for continuing investigation of the glycan ECD mechanism, which is imperative for successful development of bioinformatics tools that can take advantage of the rich structural information provided by ECD of metal-adducted glycans.

The Impact of Phosphorylation on Electron Capture Dissociation of Proteins: A Top-Down Perspective

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) is well suited for the characterization of phosphoproteins, with which labile phosphate groups are generally preserved during the fragmentation process. However, the impact of phosphorylation on ECD fragmentation of intact proteins remains unclear. Here, we have performed a systematic investigation of the phosphorylation effect on ECD of intact proteins by comparing the ECD cleavages of mono-phosphorylated α-casein, multi-phosphorylated β-casein, and immunoaffinity-purified phosphorylated cardiac troponin I with those of their unphosphorylated counterparts, respectively. In contrast to phosphopeptides, phosphorylation has significantly reduced deleterious effects on the fragmentation of intact proteins during ECD. On a global scale, the fragmentation patterns are highly comparable between unphosphorylated and phosphorylated precursors under the same ECD conditions, despite a slight decrease in the number of fragment ions observed for the phosphorylated forms. On a local scale, single phosphorylation of intact proteins imposes minimal effects on fragmentation near the phosphorylation sites, but multiple phosphorylations in close proximity result in a significant reduction of ECD bond cleavages.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract ?

     

Solvent Effects on the Energetics of Prolyl Peptide Bond Isomerization

Racemic Ac-Gly-[β,δ-(13)C]Pro-OMe was synthesized, and the kinetics and thermodynamics of the isomerization of its prolyl peptide bond were determined in nine solvents by using NMR and IR spectroscopy. The free energy of activation is 1.3 kcal/mol larger in water than in aprotic solvents, and correlates with the ability of a solvent to donate a hydrogen bond but not with solvent polarity. These results are consistent with conventional pictures of amide resonance, which require transfer of charge between oxygen and nitrogen during isomerization. Similar medium effects may modulate the stability of planar peptide bonds in the active site of peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerases (PPIases) and during the folding, function, or lysis of proteins.     

Electron Capture Dissociation Studies of the Fragmentation Patterns of Doubly Protonated and Mixed Protonated-Sodiated Peptoids

The fragmentation patterns of a group of doubly protonated ([P + 2H]²⁺) and mixed protonated-sodiated ([P + H + Na]²⁺) peptide-mimicking oligomers, known as peptoids, have been studied using electron capturing dissociation (ECD) tandem mass spectrometry techniques. For all the peptoids studied, the primary backbone fragmentation occurred at the N-C_α bonds. The N-terminal fragment ions, the C-ions (protonated) and the C′-ions (sodiated) were observed universally for all the peptoids regardless of the types of charge carrier. The C-terminal ions varied depending on the type of charge carrier. The doubly protonated peptoids with at least one basic residue located at a position other than the N-terminus fragmented by producing the Z^?-series of ions. In addition, most doubly protonated peptoids also produced the Y-series of ions with notable abundances. The mixed protonated-sodiated peptoids fragmented by yielding the Z^?′-series of ions in addition to the C′-series. Chelation between the sodium cation and the amide groups of the peptoid chain might be an important factor that could stabilize both the N-terminal and the C-terminal fragment ions. Regardless of the types of the charge carrier, one notable fragmentation for all the peptoids was the elimination of a benzylic radical from the odd-electron positive ions of the protonated peptoids ([P + 2H]^?+) and the sodiated peptoids ([P + H + Na]^?+). The study showed potential utility of using the ECD technique for sequencing of peptoid libraries generated by combinatorial chemistry.

Electron Transfer Dissociation of Photolabeled Peptides. Backbone Cleavages Compete with Diazirine Ring Rearrangements

Gas-phase conformations and electron transfer dissociations of pentapeptide ions containing the photo-Leu residue (L*) were studied. Exhaustive conformational search including molecular dynamics force-field, semi-empirical, ab initio, and density functional theory calculations established that the photo-Leu residue did not alter the gas-phase conformations of (GL*GGK? + ?2H)²⁺ and (GL*GGK-NH₂?+?H)⁺ ions, which showed the same conformer energy ranking as the unmodified Leu-containing ions. This finding is significant in that it simplifies conformational analysis of photo-labeled peptide ions. Electron transfer dissociation mass spectra of (GL*GGK? + ?2H)²⁺, (GL*GGK-NH₂?+?2H)²⁺,(GL*GGKK?+?2H)²⁺, (GL*GLK?+?2H)²⁺, and (GL*LGK?+?2H)²⁺ showed 16 %–21 % fragment ions originating by radical rearrangements and cleavages in the diazirine ring. These side-chain dissociations resulted in eliminations of N₂H₃, N₂H₄, [N₂H₅], and [NH₄O] neutral fragments and were particularly abundant in long-lived charge-reduced cation-radicals. Deuterium labeling established that the neutral hydrazine molecules mainly contained two exchangeable and two nonexchangeable hydrogen atoms from the peptide and underwent further H/D exchange in an ion–molecule complex. Electron structure calculations on the charge-reduced ions indicated that the unpaired electron was delocalized between the diazirine and amide π* electronic systems in the low electronic states of the cation-radicals. The diazirine moiety in GL*GGK-NH₂was calculated to have an intrinsic electron affinity of 1.5 eV, which was further increased by the Coulomb effect of the peptide positive charge. Mechanisms are proposed for the unusual elimination of hydrazine from the photo-labeled peptide ions.

Systematic Comparison of Ultraviolet Photodissociation and Electron Transfer Dissociation for Peptide Anion Characterization

Ultraviolet photodissociation at 193?nm (UVPD) and negative electron transfer dissociation (NETD) were compared to establish their utility for characterizing acidic proteomes with respect to sequence coverage distributions (a measure of product ion signals across the peptide backbone), sequence coverage percentages, backbone cleavage preferences, and fragmentation differences relative to precursor charge state. UVPD yielded significantly more diagnostic information compared with NETD for lower charge states (n????2), but both methods were comparable for higher charged species. While UVPD often generated a more heterogeneous array of sequence-specific products (b-, y-, c-, z-, Y-, d-, and w-type ions in addition to a- and x- type ions), NETD usually created simpler sets of a/x-type ions. LC-MS/UVPD and LC-MS/NETD analysis of protein digests utilizing high pH mobile phases coupled with automated database searching via modified versions of the MassMatrix algorithm was undertaken. UVPD generally outperformed NETD in stand-alone searches due to its ability to efficiently sequence both lower and higher charge states with rapid activation times. However, when combined with traditional positive mode CID, both methods yielded complementary information with significantly increased sequence coverage percentages and unique peptide identifications over that of just CID alone.     

Transition Metal Ions: Charge Carriers that Mediate the Electron Capture Dissociation Pathways of Peptides

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) of model peptides adducted with first row divalent transition metal ions, including Mn²⁺, Fe²⁺, Co²⁺, Ni²⁺, Cu²⁺, and Zn²⁺, were investigated. Model peptides with general sequence of ZGGGXGGGZ were used as probes to unveil the ECD mechanism of metalated peptides, where X is either V or W; and Z is either R or N. Peptides metalated with different divalent transition metal ions were found to generate different ECD tandem mass spectra. ECD spectra of peptides metalated by Mn²⁺ and Zn²⁺ were similar to those generated by ECD of peptides adducted with alkaline earth metal ions. Series of c-/z-type fragment ions with and without metal ions were observed. ECD of Fe²⁺, Co²⁺, and Ni²⁺ adducted peptides yielded abundant metalated a-/y-type fragment ions; whereas ECD of Cu²⁺ adducted peptides generated predominantly metalated b-/y-type fragment ions. From the present experimental results, it was postulated that electronic configuration of metal ions is an important factor in determining the ECD behavior of the metalated peptides. Due presumably to the stability of the electronic configuration, metal ions with fully-filled (i.e., Zn²⁺) and half filled (i.e., Mn²⁺) d-orbitals might not capture the incoming electron. Dissociation of the metal ions adducted peptides would proceed through the usual ECD channel(s) via “hot-hydrogen” or “superbase” intermediates, to form series of c-/z ^•- fragments. For other transition metal ions studied, reduction of the metal ions might occur preferentially. The energy liberated by the metal ion reduction would provide enough internal energy to generate the “slow-heating” type of fragment ions, i.e., metalated a-/y- fragments and metalated b-/y- fragments.     

Chemical Derivatization of Peptide Carboxyl Groups for Highly Efficient Electron Transfer Dissociation

The carboxyl groups of tryptic peptides were derivatized with a tertiary or quaternary amine labeling reagent to generate more highly charged peptide ions that fragment efficiently by electron transfer dissociation (ETD). All peptide carboxyl groups—aspartic and glutamic acid side-chains as well as C-termini—were derivatized with an average reaction efficiency of 99 %. This nearly complete labeling avoids making complex peptide mixtures even more complex because of partially-labeled products, and it allows the use of static modifications during database searching. Alkyl tertiary amines were found to be the optimal labeling reagent among the four types tested. Charge states are substantially higher for derivatized peptides: a modified tryptic digest of bovine serum albumin (BSA) generates ~90% of its precursor ions with z? > ?2, compared with less than 40 % for the unmodified sample. The increased charge density of modified peptide ions yields highly efficient ETD fragmentation, leading to many additional peptide identifications and higher sequence coverage (e.g., 70 % for modified versus only 43 % for unmodified BSA). The utility of this labeling strategy was demonstrated on a tryptic digest of ribosomal proteins isolated from yeast cells. Peptide derivatization of this sample produced an increase in the number of identified proteins, a >50 % increase in the sequence coverage of these proteins, and a doubling of the number of peptide spectral matches. This carboxyl derivatization strategy greatly improves proteome coverage obtained from ETD-MS/MS of tryptic digests, and we anticipate that it will also enhance identification and localization of post-translational modifications.