Locked nucleic acid (LNA) recognition of RNA: NMR solution structures of LNA:RNA hybrids

Locked nucleic acids (LNAs) containing one or more 2'-O,4'-C-methylene-linked bicyclic ribonucleoside monomers possess a number of the prerequisites of an effective antisense oligonucleotide, e.g. unprecedented helical thermostability when hybridized with cognate RNA and DNA. To acquire a detailed understanding of the structural features of LNA giving rise to its remarkable properties, we have conducted structural studies by use of NMR spectroscopy and now report high-resolution structures of two LNA:RNA hybrids, the LNA strands being d(5'-CTGAT(L)ATGC-3') and d(5'-CT(L)GAT(L)AT(L)GC-3'), respectively, T(L) denoting a modified LNA monomer with a thymine base, along with the unmodified DNA:RNA hybrid. In the structures, the LNA nucleotides are positioned as to partake in base stacking and Watson-Crick base pairing, and with the inclusion of LNA nucleotides, we observe a progressive change in duplex geometry toward an A-like duplex structure. As such, with the inclusion of three LNA nucleotides, the hybrid adopts an almost canonical A-type duplex geometry, and thus it appears that the number of modifications has reached a saturation level with respect to structural changes, and that further incorporations would furnish only minute changes in the duplex structure. We attempt to rationalize the conformational steering induced by the LNA nucleotides by suggesting that the change in electronic density at the brim of the minor groove, introduced by the LNA modification, is causing an alteration of the pseudorotational profile of the 3'-flanking nucleotide, thus shifting this sugar equilibrium toward N-type conformation.     

The structure of a mixed LNA/DNA:RNA duplex is driven by conformational coupling between LNA and deoxyribose residues as determined from 13C relaxation measurements

A study of the internal dynamics of an LNA/DNA:RNA duplex has been performed to further characterize the conformational changes associated with the incorporation of locked nucleic acid (LNA) nucleotides in a DNA:RNA duplex. In general, it was demonstrated that the LNA/DNA:RNA duplex has a very high degree of order compared to dsDNA and dsRNA duplexes. The order parameters of the aromatic carbon atoms in the LNA/DNA strand are uniformly high, whereas a sharp drop in the degree of order was seen in the RNA strand in the beginning of the AUAU stretch in the middle of the strand. This can be related to a return to normal dsRNA dynamics for the central A:U base pair. The high order of the heteroduplex is consistent with preorganization of the chimera strand for an A-form duplex conformation. These results partly explain the dramatic increase in T(m) of the chimeric heteroduplex over dsDNA and DNA:RNA hybrids of the same sequence.     

alpha-L-LNA (alpha-L-ribo configured locked nucleic acid) recognition of DNA: an NMR spectroscopic study

We have used NMR and CD spectroscopy to study and characterise two alpha-L-LNA:DNA duplexes, a nonamer that incorporates three alpha-L-LNA nucleotides and a decamer that incorporates four alpha-L-LNA nucleotides, in which alpha-L-LNA is alpha-L-ribo-configured locked nucleic acid. Both duplexes adopt right-handed helical conformations and form normal Watson-Crick base pairing with all nucleobases in the anti conformation. Deoxyribose conformations were determined from measurements of scalar coupling constants in the sugar rings, and for the decamer duplex, distance information was derived from 1H-1H NOE measurements. In general, the deoxyriboses in both of the alpha-L-LNA:DNA duplexes adopt S-type (B-type structure) sugar puckers, that is the inclusion of the modified alpha-L-LNA nucleotides does not perturb the local native B-like double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) structure. The CD spectra of the duplexes confirm these findings, as these display B-type characteristic features that allow us to characterise the overall duplex type as B-like. The 1H-1H NOE distances which were determined for the decamer duplex were employed in a simulated annealing protocol to generate a model structure for this duplex, thus allowing a more detailed inspection of the impact of the alpha-L-ribo-configured nucleotides. In this structure, it is evident that the malleable DNA backbone rearranges in the vicinity of the modified nucleotides in order to accommodate them and present their nucleobases in a geometry suitable for Watson-Crick base pairing.     

Aminoglycoside complexation with a DNA.RNA hybrid duplex: the thermodynamics of recognition and inhibition of RNA processing enzymes

Spectroscopic and calorimetric techniques were employed to characterize and contrast the binding of the aminoglycoside paromomycin to three octamer nucleic acid duplexes of identical sequence but different strand composition (a DNA.RNA hybrid duplex and the corresponding DNA.DNA and RNA.RNA duplexes). In addition, the impact of paromomycin binding on both RNase H- and RNase A-mediated cleavage of the RNA strand in the DNA.RNA duplex was also determined. Our results reveal the following significant features: (i) Paromomycin binding enhances the thermal stabilities of the RNA.RNA and DNA.RNA duplexes to similar extents, with this thermal enhancement being substantially greater in magnitude than that of the DNA.DNA duplex. (ii) Paromomycin binding to the DNA.RNA hybrid duplex induces CD changes consistent with a shift from an A-like to a more canonical A-conformation. (iii) Paromomycin binding to all three octamer duplexes is linked to the uptake of a similar number of protons, with the magnitude of this number being dependent on pH. (iv) The affinity of paromomycin for the three host duplexes follows the hierarchy, RNA.RNA > DNA.RNA > DNA.DNA. (v) The observed affinity of paromomycin for the RNA.RNA and DNA.RNA duplexes decreases with increasing pH. (vi) The binding of paromomycin to the DNA.RNA hybrid duplex inhibits both RNase H- and RNase A-mediated cleavage of the RNA strand. We discuss the implications of our combined results with regard to the specific targeting of DNA.RNA hybrid duplex domains and potential antiretroviral applications.     

The structure of LNA:DNA hybrids from molecular dynamics simulations: the effect of locked nucleotides

Locked nucleic acids (LNAs) exhibit a modified sugar fragment that is restrained to the C3'-endo conformation. LNA-containing duplexes are rather stable and have a more rigid structure than DNA duplexes, with a propensity for A-conformation of the double helix. To gain detailed insight into the local structure of LNA-modified DNA oligomers (as a foundation for subsequent exploration of the electron-transfer capabilities of such modified duplexes), we carried out molecular dynamics simulations on a set of LNA:DNA 9-mer duplexes and analyzed the resulting structures in terms of base step parameters and the conformations of the sugar residues. The perturbation introduced by a single locked nucleotide was found to be fairly localized, extending mostly to the first neighboring base pairs; such duplexes featured a B-type helix. With increasing degree of LNA modification the structure gradually changed; the duplex with one complete LNA strand assumed a typical A-DNA structure. The relative populations of the sugar conformations agreed very well with NMR data, lending credibility to the validity of the computational protocol.     

Synthesis, gene silencing, and molecular modeling studies of 4'-C-aminomethyl-2'-O-methyl modified small interfering RNAs

The linear syntheses of 4'-C-aminomethyl-2'-O-methyl uridine and cytidine nucleoside phosphoramidites were achieved using glucose as the starting material. The modified RNA building blocks were incorporated into small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) by employing solid phase RNA synthesis. Thermal melting studies showed that the modified siRNA duplexes exhibited slightly lower T(m) (～1 °C/modification) compared to the unmodified duplex. Molecular dynamics simulations revealed that the 4'-C-aminomethyl-2'-O-methyl modified nucleotides adopt South-type conformation in a siRNA duplex, thereby altering the stacking and hydrogen-bonding interactions. These modified siRNAs were also evaluated for their gene silencing efficiency in HeLa cells using a luciferase-based reporter assay. The results indicate that the modifications are well tolerated in various positions of the passenger strand and at the 3' end of the guide strand but are less tolerated in the seed region of the guide strand. The modified siRNAs exhibited prolonged stability in human serum compared to unmodified siRNA. This work has implications for the use of 4'-C-aminomethyl-2'-O-methyl modified nucleotides to overcome some of the challenges associated with the therapeutic utilities of siRNAs.     

NMR solution structure of an oligonucleotide hairpin with a 2'F-ANA/RNA stem: implications for RNase H specificity toward DNA/RNA hybrid duplexes.

The first structure of a 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-D-arabinose nucleic acid (2'F-ANA)/RNA duplex is presented. We report the structural characterization by NMR spectroscopy of a small hybrid hairpin, r(GGAC)d(TTCG)2'F-a(GTCC), containing a 2'F-ANA/RNA stem and a four-residue DNA loop. Complete (1)H, (13)C, (19)F, and (31)P resonance assignments, scalar coupling constants, and NOE constraints were obtained from homonuclear and heteronuclear 2D spectra. In the chimeric duplex, the RNA strand adopts a classic A-form structure having C3' endo sugar puckers. The 2'F-ANA strand is neither A-form nor B-form and contains O4' endo sugar puckers. This contrasts strongly with the dynamic sugar conformations previously observed in the DNA strands of DNA/RNA hybrid duplexes. Structural parameters for the duplex, such as minor groove width, x-displacement, and inclination, were intermediate between those of A-form and B-form duplexes and similar to those of DNA/RNA duplexes. These results rationalize the enhanced stability of 2'F-ANA/RNA duplexes and their ability to elicit RNase H activity. The results are relevant for the design of new antisense drugs based on sugar-modified nucleic acids.     

Probing the furanose conformation in the 2'-5'strand of isoDNA : RNA duplexes by freezing the nucleoside conformations

Sugar conformations in the isoDNA strand of isoDNA : RNA duplexes are preferred S-type locked/frozen in contrast to N-type locked conformations preferred in DNA : RNA duplexes.     

Atomic detail investigation of the structure and dynamics of DNA.RNA hybrids: a molecular dynamics study

DNA.RNA hybrid duplexes are biologically important molecules and are shown to have potential therapeutic properties. To investigate the relationship between structures, energetics, solvation and RNase H activity of hybrid duplexes in comparison with pure DNA and RNA duplexes, a molecular dynamics study using the CHARMM27 force field was undertaken. The structural properties of all four nucleic acids considered are in very good agreement with the experimental data. The backbone dihedral angles and the puckering of the (deoxy)ribose indicate that the purine rich strands retain their A-/B-like properties but the pyrimidine rich DNA strand undergoes A-B conformational transitions. The minor groove widths of the hybrid structures are narrower than those in the RNA duplex, a requirement for RNase H binding. In addition, sampling of noncanonical phosphodiester backbone dihedrals by the DNA strands, differential solvation properties and helical properties, most notably rise, are suggested to contribute to hybrids being RNase H substrates. Differential RNase H activity toward hybrids containing purine versus pyrimidine rich RNA strands is suggested to be due to sampling of values of the phosphodiester backbone dihedrals in the DNA strands. Notably, the present results indicate that hybrids have decreased flexibility as compared to RNA, in contrast to previous reports.     

Determination of affinity constants of locked nucleic acid (LNA) and DNA duplex formation using label free sensor technology

Locked nucleic acid (LNA) is a nucleic acid analogue containing 2'-O,4'-C-methylene-beta-D-ribofuranosyl nucleotides, which have a bicyclic furanose unit locked in a RNA mimicking sugar conformation. Oligonucleotides containing LNA monomers show an enhanced thermal stability and robustness against nuclease mediated cleavage. Therefore special tailored LNA is a versatile tool for gene array analysis and single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) analysis. The higher melting temperatures result from a higher affinity between the LNA and its complementary base. This was verified by the determination of the affinity constants of the duplex formation of 3 oligonucleotides: DNA, L-DNA, in which all thymidines are substituted by LNA, and a fully modified LNA, to their complementary DNA strand. Affinity constants were calculated to be 1.5 x 10(9), 4.0 x 10(9) and >10(12) L mol(-1). This was done using the label free and time resolved sensing technology reflectometric interference spectroscopy (RIfS), in an assay format similar to a titration called binding inhibition assay.     

Spermine moiety attached to the C-5 position of deoxyuridine enhances the duplex stability of the phosphorothioate DNA/complementary DNA and shows the susceptibility of the substrate to RNase H

Novel phosphorothioate-modified oligodeoxynucleotides (S-ODNs) containing a deoxyuridine derivative bearing a spermine moiety at the C-5 position were synthesized. The study of the thermal stability and the thermodynamic stability showed that the modified S-ODNs have been able to form the stable duplexes with the complementary DNA. It was also found that the duplex composed of the modified S-ODN and its complementary RNA strand is the substrate for Escherichia coli RNase H, and the cleavage of the RNA strand by the enzyme was almost similar as in the case of the unmodified one.     

Influences of ribonucleotide on a duplex conformation and its thermal stability: study with the chimeric RNA-DNA strands

To understand the influences of the ribonucleotide on a duplex conformation and its stability, we systematically studied the CD spectra and the thermodynamics of nucleic acid duplexes formed by the chimeric RNA-DNA strand in which ribonucleotides and deoxyribonucleotides were covalently attached. It was found that the duplex stability was context-dependent and independent of the number of ribonucleotides in the chimeric strand, whereas the CD spectra showed less overall structural perturbation by the chimeric junctions. Combining the results of the CD and the thermodynamic data revealed a stability-structure relationship for the duplexes. Importantly, DeltaG(o)37 values estimated for the chimeric junction formation in the RNA-DNA/DNA and the RNA-DNA/RNA duplexes were close to those of RNA/DNA and RNA/RNA interactions, respectively. Furthermore, DeltaG(o)37s of the DNA-RNA/DNA and DNA-RNA/DNA-RNA junctions were similar to those of the DNA duplex, and the values of DNA-RNA/RNA-DNA were similar to those of the DNA/RNA. The thermodynamic analyses suggest that the 5'-nucleotide may be the crucial factor that determines the stability at the chimeric junction. Our results not only suggest influences of the ribonucleotide on a duplex conformation and its stability but also are useful for the design of RNA-DNA chimeric strands applicable to biotechnology.     

Structural and binding study of modified siRNAs with the Argonaute 2 PAZ domain by NMR spectroscopy

By using high-resolution NMR spectroscopy, the structures of a natural short interfering RNA (siRNA) and of several altritol nucleic acid (ANA)-modified siRNAs were determined. The interaction of modified siRNAs with the PAZ domain of the Argonaute 2 protein of Drosophila melanogaster was also studied. The structures show that the modified siRNA duplexes (ANA/RNA) adopt a geometry very similar to the naturally occurring A-type siRNA duplex. All ribose residues, except for the 3' overhang, show 3'-endo conformation. The six-membered altritol sugar in ANA occurs in a chair conformation with the nucleobase in an axial position. In all siRNA duplexes, two overhanging nucleotides at the 3' end enhance the stability of the first neighboring base pair by a stacking interaction. The first overhanging nucleotide has a rather fixed position, whereas the second overhanging nucleotide shows larger flexibility. NMR binding studies of the PAZ domain with ANA-modified siRNAs demonstrate that modifications in the double-stranded region of the antisense strand have some small effects on the binding affinity as compared with the unmodified siRNA. Modification of the 3' overhang with thymidine (dTdT) residues shows a sixfold increase in the binding affinity compared with the unmodified siRNA (relative binding affinity of 17% compared with dTdT-modified overhang), whereas modification of the 3' overhang with ANA largely decreases the binding affinity.     

Role of locked nucleic acid modified complementary strand in quadruplex/Watson-Crick duplex equilibrium

In the human genome, the G-rich sequences that form quadruplexes are present along with their C-rich complementary strands; this suggests the existence of equilibrium between a quadruplex and a Watson-Crick duplex which allows the execution of their respective biological functions. We have investigated the sensitivity of this equilibrium to pharmacological agents by employing locked nucleic acid (LNA) modified complementary strands, and demonstrated successful invasion of the stable telomeric quadruplex d[(G(3)TTA)(3)G(3)]. Fluorescence, UV, ITC, and SPR studies were performed to understand the binding process involving the preformed quadruplex and LNA-modified complementary strands compared with that involving the unmodified complementary strand. Our data indicate that LNA modifications in the complementary strand shift the equilibrium toward the duplex state. These modifications confer increased thermodynamic stability to the duplex and increase the magnitude of relative free energy (DeltaDeltaG degrees) difference between duplex and quadruplex, thus favoring the predominance of duplex population over quadruplex. This superior ability of LNA-modified complementary strand can be exploited to pave an exploratory approach in which it hybridizes to a telomeric quadruplex and drives duplex formation, and inhibits the recognition of 3' G-rich overhang by RNA template of telomerase which guides telomere extension.     

On the structure and dynamics of duplex GNA

Glycol nucleic acid (GNA), with a nucleotide backbone comprising of just three carbons and the stereocenter derived from propylene glycol (1,2-propanediol), is a structural analog of nucleic acids with intriguing biophysical properties, such as formation of highly stable antiparallel duplexes with high Watson-Crick base pairing fidelity. Previous crystallographic studies of double stranded GNA (dsGNA) indicated two forms of backbone conformations, an elongated M-type (containing metallo-base pairs) and the condensed N-type (containing brominated base pairs). A herein presented new crystal structure of a GNA duplex at 1.8 ? resolution from self-complementary 3'-CTC(Br)UAGAG-2' GNA oligonucleotides reveals an N-type conformation with alternating gauche-anti torsions along its (O3'-C3'-C2'-O2') backbone. To elucidate the conformational state of dsGNA in solution, molecular dynamic simulations over a period of 20 ns were performed with the now available repertoire of structural information. Interestingly, dsGNA adopts conformational states in solution intermediate between experimentally observed backbone conformations: simulated dsGNA shows the all-gauche conformation characteristic of M-type GNA with the higher helical twist common to N-type GNA structures. The so far counterintuitive, smaller loss of entropy upon duplex formation as compared to DNA can be traced back to the conformational flexibility inherent to dsGNA but missing in dsDNA. Besides extensive interstrand base stacking and conformational preorganization of single strands, this flexibility contributes to the extraordinary thermal stability of GNA.     

Synthesis and RNA-selective hybridization of α-l-ribo- and β-d-lyxo-configured oligonucleotides

Three α-l-ribofuranosyl analogues of RNA nucleotides (α-l-RNA analogues) have been synthesized and incorporated into oligonucleotides using the phosphoramide approach on an automated DNA synthesizer. The 4′-C-hydroxymethyl-α-l-ribofuranosyl thymine monomer was furthermore synthesized. Relative to the unmodified duplexes, incorporation of a single α-l-RNA monomer into a DNA strand leads to reduced thermal stability of duplexes with DNA complements but unchanged thermal stability of duplexes with RNA complements, whereas incorporation of more than one α-l-RNA monomer lead to moderately decreased thermal stability also of duplexes with RNA complements. Efficient hybridization with an RNA complement and no melting transition with a DNA complement were observed with stereoregular chimeric oligonucleotides composed of a mixture of α-l-RNA and affinity enhancing α-l-LNA monomers (α-l-ribo-configured locked nucleic acid). Furthermore, duplexes formed between oligodeoxynucleotides containing an α-l-RNA monomer and complementary RNA were good substrates for Escherichia coli RNase H. RNA-selective hybridization was also achieved by the incorporation of 1-(4-C-hydroxymethyl-β-d-lyxofuranosyl)thymine monomers into a DNA strand, whereas stable duplexes were formed with both complementary DNA and RNA when these monomers were incorporated into an RNA strand.     

Comparison of the fragmentation behavior of DNA and LNA single strands and duplexes

DNA and locked nucleic acid (LNA) were characterized as single strands, as well as double stranded DNA‐DNA duplexes and DNA‐LNA hybrids using tandem mass spectrometry with collision‐induced dissociation. Additionally, ion mobility spectrometry was carried out on selected species. Oligonucleotide duplexes of different sequences — bearing mismatch positions and abasic sites of complementary DNA 15‐mers — were investigated to unravel general trends in their stability in the gas phase. Single‐stranded LNA oligonucleotides were also investigated with respect to their gas phase behavior and fragmentation upon collision‐induced dissociation. In contrast to the collision‐induced dissociation of DNA, almost no base loss was observed for LNAs. Here, backbone cleavages were the dominant dissociation pathways. This finding was further underlined by the need for higher activation energies. Base losses from the LNA strand were also absent in fragmentation experiments of the investigated DNA‐LNA hybrid duplexes. While DNA‐DNA duplexes dissociated easily into single stranded fragments, the high stability of DNA‐LNA hybrids resulted in predominant fragmentation of the DNA part rather than the LNA, while base losses were only observed from the DNA single strand of the hybrid.     

Marked dependence on carrier-ligand bulk but not on carrier-ligand chirality of the duplex versus single-strand forms of a DNA oligonucleotide with a series of G-Pt(II)-G intrastrand cross-links modeling cisplatin-DNA adducts

The N7-Pt-N7 adjacent G,G intrastrand DNA cross-link responsible for cisplatin anticancer activity is dynamic, promotes local "melting" in long DNA, and converts many oligomer duplexes to single strands. For 5'-d(A1T2G3G4G5T6A7C8C9C10A11T12)-3' (G3), treatment of the (G3)2 duplex with five pairs of [LPt(H2O)2]2+ enantiomers (L = an asymmetric diamine) formed mixtures of LPt-G3 products (1 Pt per strand) cross-linked at G3,G4 or at G4,G5 in all cases. L chirality exerted little influence. For primary diamines L with bulk on chelate ring carbons (e.g., 1,2-diaminocyclohexane), the duplex was converted completely into single strands (G3,G4 coils and G4,G5 hairpins), exactly mirroring results for cisplatin, which lacks bulk. In sharp contrast, for secondary diamines L with bulk on chelate ring nitrogens (e.g., 2,2'-bipiperidine, Bip), unexpectedly stable duplexes having two platinated strands (even a unique G3,G4/G4,G5 heteroduplex) were formed. After enzymatic digestion of BipPt-G3 duplexes, the conformation of the relatively nondynamic G,G units was shown to be head-to-head (HH) by HPLC/mass spectrometric characterization. Because the HH conformation dominates at the G,G lesion in duplex DNA and in the BipPt-G3 duplexes, the stabilization of the duplex form only when the L nitrogen adducts possess bulk suggests that H-bonding interactions of the Pt-NH groups with the flanking DNA lead to local melting and to destabilization of oligomer duplexes. The marked dependence of adduct properties on L bulk and the minimal dependence on L chirality underscore the need for future exploration of the roles of the L periphery in affecting anticancer activity.     

Duplex stability of DNA.DNA and DNA.RNA duplexes containing 3'-S-phosphorothiolate linkages

3'-S-Phosphorothiolate (3'-SP) linkages have been incorporated into the DNA strand of both a DNA.RNA duplex and a DNA.DNA duplex. Thermal melting (T(m)) studies established that this modification significantly stabilises the DNA.RNA duplex with an average increase in T(m) of about 1.4 degrees C per modification. For two or three modifications, the increase in T(m) was larger for an alternating, as compared to the contiguous, arrangement. For more than three modifications their arrangement had no effect on T(m). In contrast to the DNA.RNA duplex, the 3'-S-phosphorothiolate linkage destabilised the DNA.DNA duplex, irrespective of the arrangement of the 3'-SP linkages. The effect of ionic strength on duplex stability was similar for both the phosphorothiolate-substituted and the unmodified RNA.DNA duplexes. The results are discussed in terms of the influence that the sulfur atom has on the conformation of the furanose ring and comparisons are also drawn between the current study and those previously conducted with other modifications that have a similar conformational effect.     

Solution structure of a HNA-RNA hybrid

BACKGROUND: Synthetic nucleic acid analogues with a conformationally restricted sugar-phosphate backbone are widely used in antisense strategies for biomedical and biochemical applications. The modified backbone protects the oligonucleotides against degradation within the living cell, which allows them to form stable duplexes with sequences in target mRNAs with the aim of arresting their translation. The biologically most active antisense oligonucleotides also trigger cleavage of the target RNA through activation of endogenous RNase H. Systematic studies of synthetic oligonucleotides have also been conducted to delineate the origin of the chirality of DNA and RNA that are both composed of D-nucleosides. RESULTS: Hexitol nucleic acids (HNA) are the first example of oligonucleotides with a six-membered carbohydrate moiety that can bind strongly and selectively to complementary RNA oligomers. We present the first high resolution nuclear magnetic resonance structure of a HNA oligomer bound to a complementary RNA strand. The HNA-RNA complex forms an anti-parallel heteroduplex and adopts a helical conformation that belongs to the A-type family. Possibly, due to the rigidity of the rigid chair conformation of the six-membered ring both the HNA and RNA strand in the duplex are well defined. The observed absence of end-fraying effects also indicate a reduced conformational flexibility of the HNA-RNA duplex compared to canonical dsRNA or an RNA-DNA duplex. CONCLUSIONS: The P-P distance across the minor groove, which is close to A-form, and the rigid conformation of the HNA-RNA complex, explain its resistance towards degradation by Rnase H. The A-form character of the HNA-RNA duplex and the reduced flexibility of the HNA strand is possibly responsible for the stereoselectivity of HNA templates in non-enzymatic replication of oligonucleotides, supporting the theory that nucleosides with six-membered rings could have existed at some stage in molecular evolution.