Micro-high-performance liquid chromatography platform for the depletion of high-abundance proteins and subsequent on-line concentration/capturing of medium and low-abundance proteins from serum. Application to profiling of protein expression in healthy and osteoarthritis sera by 2-D gel electrophoresis

In this investigation, an integrated microcolumn-based fluidic platform for the simultaneous depletion of high-abundance proteins and the subsequent on-line concentration/capturing of medium- and low-abundance proteins from human serum has been introduced. The platform consists of on-line coupling of tandem affinity micorcolumns to an RP microcolumn to achieve first the depletion of high-abundance proteins by the tandem affinity microcolumns followed by the concentration and capturing of medium- and low-abundance proteins by the RP microcolumn. The tandem affinity microcolumns are based on macroporous monoliths characterized by their relatively high permeability in pressure-driven flow while the RP microcolumn is packed with polymeric particles with an average particle diameter of 20 microm giving rise to a very little back pressure, thus allowing fast flow velocity across the coupled columns format and consequently short processing time of serum samples prior to analysis by 2-DE. The microcolumn-based fluidic platform was applied to serum samples from osteoarthritis (OA) donors before and after soy protein (SP) supplementation, and from healthy donors, and the resulting depleted serum samples from high-abundance proteins were profiled for protein expression by 2-DE. In general, the protein expression was lower in serum of the same OA patient after soy treatment than before soy treatment. Several proteins were down-regulated after soy treatment with transthyretin being the most affected by the SP supplementation. In addition, with respect to serum from healthy donors, the sera from OA patients showed difference in proteins expression.     

Optimizing protein recovery yield from serum samples treated with beads technology

Proteomics studies are often complicated by the wide dynamic range of the biological fluids, in which few highly abundant proteins obscure the signal of low abundant ones. To overcome this problem, several techniques have been developed on the basis of "depletion principles," namely immuno-subtraction with specific antibodies against the most-abundant proteins. Unfortunately, the probability of codepletion is a noteworthy drawback associated with these strategies. The ProteoMiner (PM) technology is a novel approach, consisting of a combinatorial library of hexapeptide ligands coupled to beads, that allows the capture of all species present in a proteome, but at much reduced protein concentration differences, simultaneously enhancing the concentration of the most dilute species. In this study, we evaluated the compatibility of the PM kit's elution reagent with 2-DE analysis, comparing five different purification methods on serum samples eluted from the beads: the "ReadyPrep 2-D Clean-up kit" and precipitation with organic solvents, as acetone/methanol, TCA/acetone, ACN, and chloroform/methanol. Considering protein recovery yield (quantity) and 2-DE spot pattern (quality), precipitation with ACN offered the most promising approach, showing the best spot resolution in all regions of the pH gradient and the greatest number of protein spots visualized on 2-D gels.     

Quantitative assessment of human serum high-abundance protein depletion

The aim of this study is to quantify the effectivity of the depletion of human high-abundance serum and plasma proteins for improved protein identification and disease marker candidate discovery and to assess the risk of concomitant removal of relevant marker proteins. 2-DE and bottom-up shotgun MS combining 2-D capillary chromatography with MS/MS were applied in parallel for the analysis of fractions resulting from the depletion procedure. For many proteins the factors of enrichment by the depletion were obvious allowing their enhanced detection and identification upon high-abundance protein depletion. Nano-liquid chromatography linked MS allowed the efficient identification of several low-abundant proteins that were not identified on the 2-DE gels. Resolving the fractions that were eluted from the matrix upon depletion indicated unspecific binding of disease relevant proteins in plasma samples from acute myocardial infarction patients. The unspecific binding to the depletion matrix of inflammatory markers spiked into the serum was found to depend on the type of capturing agent used. Polyclonal avian antibodies (IgY) displayed the least unspecific binding due to the high immunogenicity of mammalian proteins in avian hosts.     

Reduction of protein concentration range difference followed by multicolumn fractionation prior to 2-DE and LC-MS/MS profiling of serum proteins

This article is concerned with the reduction of protein concentration range differences by the peptide beads library technology (ProteoMiner? or "equalizer" technology), which in principle allows the enrichment of proteins to the same concentration level (i.e. protein equalizer) regardless of the original protein abundance in a given biological fluid such as human serum, which is the subject of our investigation. After the equalization step, the captured proteins from human serum were fractionated on a series of tandem monolithic columns with surface-bound iminodiacetic acid ligands to which three different metal ions, namely, Zn2+, Ni2+ and Cu2+ were immobilized to yield the so-called immobilized metal affinity chromatography columns. These three monolithic columns were connected to a reversed-phase column packed with polystyrene divinyl benzene beads. Aliquots taken from the four collected fractions from the four tandem columns were subsequently fractionated by 2-DE. Also, aliquots from the four collected fractions were tryptically digested and analyzed by LC-MS/MS. The strategy of subsequent fractionation on the four tandem columns after equalization allowed the identification of more proteins than simply using the equalization by ProteoMiner? . The equalizer technology was compared to the immuno-subtraction approach. While the ProteoMiner? technology is superior in terms of the overall number of captured proteins, it only complements the immuno-subtraction approach since the latter can capture the proteins that were not captured by the former.     

Expression of high-abundance proteins in sera of patients with endometrial and cervical cancers: analysis using 2-DE with silver staining and lectin detection methods

The expression of high-abundance serum proteins in newly diagnosed patients with endometrial adenocarcinoma (EACa), squamous cell cervical carcinoma (SCCa) and cervical adenocarcinoma (ACCa), relative to control female subjects, was analyzed by subjecting serum samples to 2-DE followed by image analysis of the silver-stained protein profiles. The three cohorts of cancer patients demonstrated different altered expression of serum high-abundance proteins compared to negative control women. The expression of alpha1-antitrypsin, alpha1-B glycoprotein, cleaved high-molecular-weight kininogen (light chain) and antithrombin III were consistently altered in all the patients. However, clusterin was upregulated only in the patients with EACa, while those with SCCa and ACCa were typically characterized by the upregulated expression of zinc alpha-2-glycoprotein. The aberrant expression of selective serum proteins in the various cohorts of cancer patients was validated by competitive ELISA as well as by lectin detection. Analysis by using the champedak galactose binding lectin further highlighted an unidentified protein that may be differently glycosylated in the sera of the EACa patients that were studied.     

Application of thiophilic chromatography to deplete serum immunoglobulins in sample preparation for bidimensional electrophoresis

Serum is a typical sample for non-invasive studies in clinical research. Its proteome characterization is challenging, since requires extensive protein depletion. Methods used nowadays for removal of high-abundance proteins are expensive or show quite often a low loading capacity, which has strong repercussions on the number of samples and replicates per analysis.In order to deplete immunoglobulins (Igs) and albumin (HSA) from 1 mL serum samples, we have developed a protocol based on a combination of thiophilic chromatography, not previously used in clinical proteomics, and a HSA-specific resin. Ig/HSA-depleted samples, immunoglobulinome and albuminone were analyzed by 2-DE. Thiophilic chromatography, coupled with HSA-depletion, allows a good 2-DE resolution as well as the visualization of new spots. Moreover, it yields enough protein to evaluate technical variability and facilitate subsequent protein identification. To validate the protocol, we carried out a preliminary comparative study between triplicate Igs/HSA-depleted serum samples from healthy control individuals and recently diagnosed/untreated rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients. RA patients showed several acute phase proteins, as well as additional serum proteins, differentially and significantly regulated.Therefore, thiophilic chromatography can be used as an efficient and economical method in 2-DE to deplete immunoglobulins from large human serum samples before a more extensive fractioning.     

Impact of prefractionation using Gradiflow on two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and protein identification by matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry

Prefractionation of protein samples prior to two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) has the potential to increase the dynamic detection range for proteomic analysis. We evaluated a membrane-based electrophoretic separation technique (Gradiflow) for its ability to fractionate an exoproteome sample from the filamentous fungus Trichoderma reesei. The sample was separated on the basis of size and charge. Buffer optimization was found to be necessary for successful size fractionation. Fractionation by charge was used to resolve the sample into four fractions that were subjected to analysis by two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE). Enhanced detection of low-abundance proteins with selective removal of high-abundance species was achieved. Fractionated and unfractionated samples were examined for differences in the ability to identify proteins following 2-DE using trypsin in-gel digestion followed by peptide mass fingerprinting using matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight-mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS). Fractionated samples showed marked improvement in protein identification ability and sequence coverage. This study demonstrates the utility of the Gradiflow for fractionation, resulting in an enhancement of resolution and characterization of a moderately complex proteome.     

Analysis of human serum by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry: improved sample preparation and data analysis

Discovery of biomarkers is a fast developing field in proteomics research. Liquid chromatography coupled on line to mass spectrometry (LC-MS) has become a powerful method for the sensitive detection, quantification and identification of proteins and peptides in biological fluids like serum. However, the presence of highly abundant proteins often masks those of lower abundance and thus generally prevents their detection and identification in proteomics studies. To perform future comparative analyses of samples from a serum bank of cervical cancer patients in a longitudinal and cross-sectional manner, methodology based on the depletion of high-abundance proteins followed by tryptic digestion and LC-MS has been developed. Two sample preparation methods were tested in terms of their efficiency to deplete high-abundance serum proteins and how they affect the repeatability of the LC-MS data sets. The first method comprised depletion of human serum albumin (HSA) on a dye ligand chromatographic and immunoglobulin G (IgG) on an immobilized Protein A support followed by tryptic digestion, fractionation by cation-exchange chromatography, trapping on a C18 column and reversed-phase LC-MS. The second method included depletion of the six most abundant serum proteins based on multiple immunoaffinity chromatography followed by tryptic digestion, trapping on a C18 column and reversed-phase LC-MS. Repeatability of the overall procedures was evaluated in terms of retention time and peak area for a selected number of endogenous peptides showing that the second method, besides being less time consuming, gave more repeatable results (retention time: <0.1% RSD; peak area: <30% RSD). Application of an LC-MS component detection algorithm followed by principal component analysis (PCA) enabled discrimination of serum samples that were spiked with horse heart cytochrome C from non-spiked serum and the detection of a concentration trend, which correlated to the amount of spiked horse heart cytochrome C to a level of 5 pmol cytochrome C in 2 microl original serum.     

An analysis of protein abundance suppression in data dependent liquid chromatography and tandem mass spectrometry with tryptic peptide mixtures of five known proteins

Reverse phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) has been widely used in proteomics research for peptide separation. When protein samples are separated by RPLC and identified with electrospray ion trap mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), the signals of high-abundance proteins may suppress those of low-abundance proteins, a phenomenon known as abundance suppression. To what degree the abundance suppression correlates to the number of tryptic peptides in the high-abundance proteins has not been carefully investigated. We tried to answer this question by studying the mixtures digested from five known proteins. The numbers of identified tryptic peptides (longer than five amino acids) of the five proteins ranged from 12 to 47. Four different peptide mixtures with 10- to 100-fold abundance differences of five known proteins were separated by RPLC and identified by ESI-MS. Our results showed that abundance suppression was related to the tryptic peptide numbers in the high-abundance protein. Within a 100-fold protein abundance difference range, tryptic peptide number in the low-abundance proteins could be suppressed up to seven times by high-abundance proteins. The procedure we suggest here can help to identify low-abundance proteins co-purified with their high-abundance binding protein. The result can also help to identify specific high-abundance proteins for removal by immunoaffinity.     

The dynamic range of protein expression: a challenge for proteomic research

Proteomic research, for its part, is benefiting enormously from the last decade of genomic research as we now have archived, annotated and audited sequence databases to correlate and query experimental data. While the two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) gels are still a central part of proteomics, we reflect on the possibilities and realities of the current 2-DE technology with regard to displaying and analysing proteomes. Limitations of analysing whole cell/tissue lysates by 2-DE alone are discussed, and we investigate whether extremely narrow p/ranges (1 pH unit/25 cm) provide a solution to display comprehensive protein expression profiles. We are confronted with a challenging task: the dynamic range of protein expression. We believe that most of the existing technology is capable of displaying many more proteins than is currently achievable by integrating existing and new techniques to prefractionate samples prior to 2-DE display or analysis. The availability of a "proteomics toolbox", consisting of defined reagents, methods, and equipment, would assist a comprehensive analysis of defined biological systems.     

Proteomics of snake venoms from Elapidae and Viperidae families by multidimensional chromatographic methods

Snake venoms contain a large number of biologically active substances and the venom components are very useful for pharmaceutical applications. Our goal is to separate and identify components of snake venoms in ten snake species from the Elapidae and Viperidae families using multidimensional chromatographic methods. The multidimensional chromatographic methods include reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC), sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE), lab-on-a-chip, two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE), and mass spectrometry. The venoms of eight snake species demonstrated major differences in hydrophobicity, molecular weight separations, and 2-DE protein distribution patterns. The 2-DE images showed major differences between families, within each family and even between the same species. Venoms of the Elapidae family showed many basic proteins with a wide range of molecular weights, while venoms of the Viperidae family showed wide ranges of pI and molecular weights, especially for Trimeresurus sp. The multidimensional chromatographic methods revealed specific differences in venom proteins intra-species as well as between species and families. We have isolated and identified proteins that may be unique for each species for further studies in the proteome of snake venoms and their potentially use in the pharmaceutical applications.     

Ultrafiltration for proteomic sample preparation

Proteome analysis represents significant challenges to the existing sample preparation techniques. Traditional methods, such as two-dimensional electrophoresis, typically separate high-molecular-weight proteins while discarding low-molecular-weight species. This approach is well justified considering the complexity of any proteome. However, it is desirable to extract the maximum amount of information from each sample to investigate the entire range of biomolecules. We have demonstrated that ultrafiltration not only improves two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) resolution of the protein fraction but also yields the low-molecular-weight fraction amenable for further analysis by high-resolution mass spectrometry. This approach was successfully adapted to the variety of biological samples including cell and tissue lysates and serum. Therefore, ultrafiltration offers an alternative sample preparation technique that enables more thorough analysis of a proteome.     

Proteome investigation of the non-model plant pomegranate (Punica granatum L.)

A gel-free, shotgun proteomics approach was used to characterize pomegranate aril proteome by nanoliquid chromatography–high-resolution tandem mass spectrometry. To identify both high-abundance and low-abundance proteins, we applied two distinct sample preparation protocols, i.e., a classical one widely applied in literature and a second one able to reduce the dynamic range of protein concentration of the sample, based on combinatorial hexapeptide ligand library technology. However, the proteins identified with the latter protocol were only a small minority. Because pomegranate is a non-model plant species, i.e., information of its genome sequence are lacking, only a few protein sequences are included in the most widely known protein sequence databases. To improve both the number of identified proteins and data reliability, identification was performed integrating the results obtained with three distinct plant protein databases, since the majority of proteins could only be attributed by homology with other plant species. Nevertheless, many proteins had assigned only one unique peptide, because of the phylogenetic distance of pomegranate from the main model plants. After manual revision of the identified proteins to eliminate the redundant or ambiguous identifications, a list of 1,488 proteins was obtained, only six of which belonging to pomegranate species. To the author's best knowledge, this is the first work aimed at the proteomic characterization of Punica granatum.     

Systematic analysis of the total proteins of a mammalian organism: principles, problems and implications for sequencing the human genome

High-resolution two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) has reached a technological level that allows us to resolve most of the numerous unknown protein species of a mammalian organism if appropriate strategies are used. We will discuss the problems of classification and characterization of proteins and propose a systematic approach to the analysis of the total protein complex. Both a comprehensive as well as a pragmatic approach towards systematic analysis have been considered. A "complex protein database" is suggested and considered with regard to various uses. A systematic analysis of the mouse proteins has been started and some of the preliminary results are summarized here. In particular, genetic properties of the proteins were investigated and are presented in order to demonstrate the significance of a systematic analysis of proteins for research and practical application (e.g. mutagenicity testing). A concept is presented for sequencing the coding DNA of mouse and man, starting with a systematic analysis of mouse proteins and then using two recently developed methods - microsequencing of proteins from spots of 2-DE protein patterns, and utilization of the relatively short N-terminal sequences obtained - to produce the corresponding cDNA's of these proteins.     

Prefractionation techniques in proteome analysis: the mining tools of the third millennium

The present review deals with prefractionation protocols used in proteomic investigation in preparation for mass spectrometry (MS) or two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) map analysis. Briefly, reported methods focus on cell organelle differential centrifugation and on chromatographic approaches, to continue in extenso with a panoply of electrophoretic methods. In the case of chromatography, procedures useful as a prefractionation step, including affinity, ion-exchange, and reversed-phase resins, revealed several hundreds of new species, previously undetected in unfractionated samples. Novel chromatographic prefractionation methods are also discussed such as a multistaged fractionation column, consisting in a set of immobilized chemistries, serially connected in a stack format (an assembly of seven blocks), each capable of harvesting a given protein population. Such a method significantly simplifies the complexity of treated samples while concentrating species, all resulting in a larger number of visible proteins by MS or 2-DE. Electrophoretic prefractionation protocols include all those electrokinetic methodologies which are performed in free solution, essentially all relying on isoelectric focusing steps (although some approaches based on gels and granulated media are also discussed). Devices associated with electrophoretic separation are multichamber apparatus, such as the multicompartment electrolyzers equipped with either isoelectric membranes or with isoelectric beads. Multicup device electrophoresis and several others, exploiting the conventional technique of carrier ampholyte focusing, are reviewed. This review also reports approaches for sample treatments in order to detect low-abundance species. Among others, a special emphasis is made on the reduction of concentration difference between proteins constituting a sample. This latter consists in a library of combinatorial ligands coupled to small beads. Such a library comprises hexameric ligands composed of 20 amino acids, resulting in millions of different structures. When these beads are impregnated with complex proteomes (e.g., human sera) of widely differing protein compositions, they are able to significantly reduce the concentration differences, thus greatly enhancing the possibility to evidence low-abundance species. It is felt that this panoply of methods could offer a strong step forward in "mining below the tip of the iceberg" for detecting the "unseen proteome".     

Enrichment of low-abundant serum proteins by albumin/immunoglobulin G immunoaffinity depletion under partly denaturing conditions

We present a simple protocol for affinity depletion to remove the two most abundant serum proteins, albumin and immunoglobulin G (IgG). Under native conditions, albumin/IgG were efficiently removed and several proteins were enriched as shown by two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE). Besides that, partly denaturing conditions were established by adding 5 or 20% acetonitrile (ACN) in order to disrupt the binding of low-molecular-weight (LMW) proteins to the carrier proteins albumin/IgG. 2-DE results showed that the total number of detected LMW proteins increased under denaturing conditions when compared to native conditions. Interestingly, the presence of 5% ACN in serum revealed better enrichment of LMW proteins when compared to 20% ACN condition. Seven randomly distributed spots in albumin/IgG depleted serum samples under 5% ACN condition were picked from the 2-DE gels and identified by mass spectrometry (MS). The intensity of five LMW protein spots increased under denaturing conditions when compared to native conditions. Three of the seven identified spots (serum amyloid P, vitamin D-binding protein, and transthyretin) belong to a group of relatively low-abundant proteins, which make up only 1% of all serum proteins. The method presented here improves the resolution of the serum proteome by increasing the number of visualized spots on 2-D gels and allowing the detection and MS identification of LMW proteins and proteins of lower abundance.     

Combination of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis with microsequencing and amino acid composition analysis: improvement of speed and sensitivity in protein characterization

High-resolution two-dimensional polyacrylamide electrophoresis (2-DE) is commonly used as an analytical approach to resolve and detect most of the numerous protein species of an organism. However, the isolation of microgram amounts of protein in a 2-DE spot in a form suitable for microsequence analysis and amino acid composition analysis is a key step in the chemical characterization of these proteins. With the development of chemically inert membranes it is now possible to retain proteins present in low quantities from the polyacrylamide matrix with high yields. The immobilized proteins are suitable for direct sequence analysis and amino acid composition analysis. The combination of protein chemical and electrophoretic techniques makes it possible to obtain chemical information from subpicomole quantities of protein, resulting in the availability of a new set of biologically important proteins for structural analysis. This paper summarizes the methods and strategies for the chemical protein analysis of 2-DE spots in our laboratory.     

Comprehensive proteome analysis of mouse liver by ampholyte-free liquid-phase isoelectric focusing

In this study, ampholyte-free liquid-phase IEF (LIEF) was combined with narrow pH range 2-DE and SDS-PAGE RP-HPLC for comprehensive analysis of mouse liver proteome. Because LIEF prefractionation was able to reduce the complexity of the sample and enhance the loading capacity of IEF strips, the number of visible protein spots on subsequent 2-DE gels was significantly increased. A total of 6271 protein spots were detected after integrating five narrow pH range 2-DE gels following LIEF prefractionation into a single virtual 2-DE gel. Furthermore, the pH 3-5 LIEF fraction and the unfractionated sample were separated by pH 3-6 2-DE and identified by MALDI-TOF/TOF MS, respectively. In parallel, the pH 3-5 LIEF fraction was also analyzed by SDS-PAGE RP-HPLC MS/MS. LIEF-2-DE and LIEF-HPLC could obviously improve the separation efficiency and the confidence of protein identification, which identified a higher number of low-abundance proteins and proteins with extreme physicochemical characteristics or post-translational modifications compared to conventional 2-DE method. Furthermore, there were 207 proteins newly identified in mouse liver in comparison with previously reported large-scale datasets. It was observed that the combination of LIEF-2-DE and LIEF-HPLC was effective in promoting MS-based liver proteome profiling and could be applied on similar complex tissue samples.     

Workshop on two-dimensional gel protein databases.

A workshop on two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) protein database, organized by the Committee on Data for Science and Technology (CODATA) of the International Council of Scientific Unions Task Group on Biological Macromolecules, was held at the CODATA Secretariat in Paris on March 9, 1992. Eleven scientists from eight different countries represented various aspects of 2-DE analysis--namely, cellular protein database development and protein microsequencing methodologies. The purpose of the workshop was to explore means of integrating the rapidly expanding body of information on 2-DE resolved proteins from different laboratories. A major proposal emanating from the workshop was the establishment of an intermediary or "relational" 2-DE gel protein database. This intermediary database, which would catalogue pertinent information on 2-DE resolved proteins (experimental source, 2-DE loci, biological information, etc.) could be an adjunct to, and accessed through, the existing international protein sequence databanks. It would function as a pointer for researchers to the individual 2-DE protein databases where primary and more specialized 2-DE data would be housed.