Crystal structure of a B-form DNA duplex containing (L)-alpha-threofuranosyl (3'-->2') nucleosides: a four-carbon sugar is easily accommodated into the backbone of DNA

(L)-alpha-Threofuranosyl-(3'-->2')-oligonucleotides (TNA) containing vicinally connected phosphodiester linkages undergo informational base pairing in an antiparallel strand orientation and are capable of cross-pairing with RNA and DNA. TNA is derived from a sugar containing only four carbon atoms and is one of the simplest potentially natural nucleic acid alternatives investigated thus far in the context of a chemical etiology of nucleic acid structure. Compared to DNA and RNA that contain six covalent bonds per repeating nucleotide unit, TNA contains only five. We have determined the atomic-resolution crystal structure of the B-form DNA duplex [d(CGCGAA)Td(TCGCG)](2) containing a single (L)-alpha-threofuranosyl thymine (T) per strand. In the modified duplex base stacking interactions are practically unchanged relative to the reference DNA structure. The orientations of the backbone at the TNA incorporation sites are slightly altered in order to accommodate fewer atoms and covalent bonds. The conformation of the threose is C4'-exo with the 2'- and 3'-substituents assuming quasi-diaxial orientation.     

Highly Stable Duplex Formation by Artificial Nucleic Acids Acyclic Threoninol Nucleic Acid (aTNA) and Serinol Nucleic Acid (SNA) with Acyclic Scaffolds

The stabilities of duplexes formed by strands of novel artificial nucleic acids composed of acyclic threoninol nucleic acid (aTNA) and serinol nucleic acid (SNA) building blocks were compared with duplexes formed by the acyclic glycol nucleic acid (GNA), peptide nucleic acid (PNA), and native DNA and RNA. All acyclic nucleic acid homoduplexes examined in this study had significantly higher thermal stability than DNA and RNA duplexes. Melting temperatures of homoduplexes were in the order of aTNA>PNA≈GNA≥SNA?RNA>DNA. Thermodynamic analyses revealed that high stabilities of duplexes formed by aTNA and SNA were due to large enthalpy changes upon formation of duplexes compared with DNA and RNA duplexes. The higher stability of the aTNA homoduplex than the SNA duplex was attributed to the less flexible backbone due to the methyl group of D ‐threoninol on aTNA, which induced clockwise winding. Unlike aTNA, the more flexible SNA was able to cross‐hybridize with RNA and DNA. Similarly, the SNA/PNA heteroduplex was more stable than the aTNA/PNA duplex. A 15‐mer SNA/RNA was more stable than an RNA/DNA duplex of the same sequence.     

An in vitro selection system for TNA

(3'-2')-alpha-l-Threose nucleic acid (TNA) is an unnatural polymer that possesses the rare ability to base-pair with RNA, DNA, and itself. This feature, coupled with its chemical simplicity, makes TNA of interest as a possible progenitor of RNA during the early history of life. To evaluate the functional potential of TNA, we have developed a system for the in vitro selection of TNA. We identified the Therminator DNA polymerase as a remarkably efficient DNA-dependent TNA polymerase capable of polymerizing more than 50 tNTPs. We have also developed a method of covalently linking a DNA template to the TNA strand that it encodes, thus obviating the need for a TNA-dependent DNA polymerase during cycles of selection.     

TNA synthesis by DNA polymerases

Threose nucleic acid (TNA), which has a repeat unit one atom shorter than that of DNA, is capable of Watson-Crick base pairing with DNA, RNA, and TNA. Because of its chemical simplicity, TNA is considered to be a possible progenitor of RNA. As an initial step toward developing the molecular tools necessary to investigate the functional capabilities of TNA by in vitro selection, we have screened a variety of DNA polymerases for TNA synthesis activity on a DNA template. We wish to report that several polymerases show surprisingly good ability to synthesize TNA using alpha-l-threofuranosyl thymidine-3'-triphosphate as a substrate.     

Rational modification of a selection strategy leads to deoxyribozymes that create native 3'-5' RNA linkages

We previously used in vitro selection to identify several classes of deoxyribozymes that mediate RNA ligation by attack of a hydroxyl group at a 5'-triphosphate. In these reactions, the nucleophilic hydroxyl group is located at an internal 2'-position of an RNA substrate, leading to 2',5'-branched RNA. To obtain deoxyribozymes that instead create linear 3'-5'-linked (native) RNA, here we strategically modified the selection approach by embedding the nascent ligation junction within an RNA:DNA duplex region. This approach should favor formation of linear rather than branched RNA because the two RNA termini are spatially constrained by Watson-Crick base pairing during the ligation reaction. Furthermore, because native 3'-5' linkages are more stable in a duplex than isomeric non-native 2'-5' linkages, this strategy is predicted to favor the formation of 3'-5' linkages. All of the new deoxyribozymes indeed create only linear 3'-5' RNA, confirming the effectiveness of the rational design. The new deoxyribozymes ligate RNA with k(obs) values up to 0.5 h(-1) at 37 degrees C and 40 mM Mg2+, pH 9.0, with up to 41% yield at 3 h incubation. They require several specific RNA nucleotides on either side of the ligation junction, which may limit their practical generality. These RNA ligase deoxyribozymes are the first that create native 3'-5' RNA linkages, which to date have been highly elusive via other selection approaches.     

Base-pairing systems related to TNA: alpha-threofuranosyl oligonucleotides containing phosphoramidate linkages

(3'NH)- and (2'NH)-TNA, two isomeric phosphoramidate analogues of TNA (alpha-threofuranosyl-(3'-->2') oligonucleotides), are shown to be efficient Watson-Crick base-pairing systems and to undergo intersystem cross-pairing with TNA, RNA, and DNA. [reaction: see text]     

Remarkable stability of hairpins containing 2',5'-linked RNA loops.

We report here the results of a comparative study of hairpin loops that differ in the connectivity of phosphodiester linkages (3',5'- versus 2',5'-linkages). In addition, we have studied the effect of changing the stem composition on the thermodynamic stability of hairpin loops. Specifically, we constructed hairpins containing one of six stem duplex combinations, i.e., DNA:DNA ("DD"), RNA:RNA ("RR"), DNA:RNA ("DR"), 2',5'-RNA:RNA ("RR"), 2',5'-RNA:DNA ("RD"), and 2',5'-RNA:2',5'-RNA ("RR"), and one of three tetraloop compositions, i.e., 2',5'-RNA ("R"), RNA ("R"), and DNA ("D"). All hairpins contained the conserved and well-studied loop sequence 5'-...C(UUCG)G...-3' [Cheong et al. Nature 1990, 346, 680-682]. We show that the 2',5'-linked loop C(UUCG)G, i.e.,...C(3'p5')U(2'p5')U(2'p5')C(2'p5')G(2'p5')G(3'p5')..., like its "normal" RNA counterpart, forms an unusually stable tetraloop structure. We also show that the stability imparted by 2',5'-RNA loops is dependent on base sequence, a property that is shared with the regioisomeric 3',5'-RNA loops. Remarkably, we find that the stability of the UUCG tetraloop is virtually independent of the hairpin stem composition (DD, RR, RR, etc.), whereas the native RNA tetraloop exerts extra stability only when the stem is duplex RNA (R:R). As a result, the relative stabilities of hairpins with a 2',5'-linked tetraloop, e.g. ggac(UUCG)gtcc (T(m) = 61.4 degrees C), are often superior to those with RNA tetraloops, e.g. ggac(UUCG)gtcc (T(m) = 54.6 degrees C). In fact, it has been possible to observe the formation of a 2',5'-RNA:DNA hybrid duplex by linking the hybrid's strands to a (UUCG) loop. These duplexes (RD), which are not stable enough to form in an intermolecular complex [Wasner et al. Biochemistry 1998, 37, 7478-7486], were stable at room temperature (T(m) approximately 50 degrees C). Thus, 2',5'-loops have potentially important implications in the study of nucleic acid complexes where structural data are not yet available. Furthermore, they may be particularly useful as structural motifs for synthetic ribozymes and nucleic acid "aptamers".     

DNA polymerase-mediated DNA synthesis on a TNA template

TNA, or threose nucleic acid, is capable of Watson-Crick base pairing with DNA, RNA, and TNA; coupled with its chemical simplicity, this suggests that TNA is a possible progenitor of RNA. As an initial step toward developing the molecular tools necessary to investigate the functional capabilities of TNA by in vitro selection, we have screened a variety of DNA polymerases for activity on a TNA template. We report that despite having a repeating unit that is one atom shorter than that of DNA, several polymerases showed surprisingly good ability to copy limited stretches of TNA.     

Crystal structure of homo-DNA and nature's choice of pentose over hexose in the genetic system

An experimental rationalization of the structure type encountered in DNA and RNA by systematically investigating the chemical and physical properties of alternative nucleic acids has identified systems with a variety of sugar-phosphate backbones that are capable of Watson-Crick base pairing and in some cases cross-pairing with the natural nucleic acids. The earliest among the model systems tested to date, (4' --> 6')-linked oligo(2',3'-dideoxy-beta-d-glucopyranosyl)nucleotides or homo-DNA, shows stable self-pairing, but the pairing rules for the four natural bases are not the same as those in DNA. However, a complete interpretation and understanding of the properties of the hexapyranosyl (4' --> 6') family of nucleic acids has been impeded until now by the lack of detailed 3D-structural data. We have determined the crystal structure of a homo-DNA octamer. It reveals a weakly twisted right-handed duplex with a strong inclination between the hexose-phosphate backbones and base-pair axes, and highly irregular values for helical rise and twist at individual base steps. The structure allows a rationalization of the inability of allo-, altro-, and glucopyranosyl-based oligonucleotides to form stable pairing systems.     

Optimized DNA targeting using N,N-bis(2-pyridylmethyl)-beta-alanyl 2'-amino-LNA

Incorporation of N,N-bis(2-pyridylmethyl)-beta-alanyl 2'-amino-LNA (bipyridyl-functionalized 2'-amino locked nucleic acid) monomers into DNA strands enables high-affinity targeting of complementary DNA with excellent Watson-Crick selectivity in the presence of divalent metal ions. Positioning of bipyridyl-functionalized 2'-amino-LNA monomers in two complementary DNA strands in a "3'-end zipper" constitution allows modulation of duplex stability, i.e., a strong stabilizing effect with one equivalent of divalent metal ion per bipyridyl pair, or a strong destabilizing effect with an excess of divalent metal ions.     

Synthesis and pairing properties of alpha-tricyclo-DNA

We describe the synthesis of the phosphoramidite building blocks of alpha-tricyclo-DNA (alpha-tc-DNA) covering all four natural bases, starting from the already known corresponding alpha-tc-nucleosides. These building blocks were used for the preparation of three alpha-tc-oligonucleotide 10-mers representing a homopurine, a homopyrimidine, and a mixed purine/pyrimidine base sequence. The base-pairing properties with complementary parallel and antiparallel oriented DNA and RNA were studied by UV-melting analysis and CD spectroscopy. We found that alpha-tc-DNA binds preferentially to parallel nucleic acid complements through Watson-Crick duplex formation, with a preference for RNA over DNA. In comparison with natural DNA, alpha-tc-DNA shows equal to enhanced affinity to RNA and also pairs to antiparallel DNA or RNA complements, although with much lower affinity. In the mixed-base sequence these antiparallel duplexes are of the reversed Watson-Crick type, while in the homopurine/homopyrimidine sequences Hoogsteen and/or reversed Hoogsteen pairing is observed. Antiparallel duplex formation of two alpha-tc-oligonucleotides was also observed, although the thermal stability of this duplex was surprisingly low. The base-pairing properties of alpha-tc-DNA are discussed in the context of alpha-DNA, alpha-RNA, and alpha-LNA.     

Locked nucleic acid (LNA) recognition of RNA: NMR solution structures of LNA:RNA hybrids

Locked nucleic acids (LNAs) containing one or more 2'-O,4'-C-methylene-linked bicyclic ribonucleoside monomers possess a number of the prerequisites of an effective antisense oligonucleotide, e.g. unprecedented helical thermostability when hybridized with cognate RNA and DNA. To acquire a detailed understanding of the structural features of LNA giving rise to its remarkable properties, we have conducted structural studies by use of NMR spectroscopy and now report high-resolution structures of two LNA:RNA hybrids, the LNA strands being d(5'-CTGAT(L)ATGC-3') and d(5'-CT(L)GAT(L)AT(L)GC-3'), respectively, T(L) denoting a modified LNA monomer with a thymine base, along with the unmodified DNA:RNA hybrid. In the structures, the LNA nucleotides are positioned as to partake in base stacking and Watson-Crick base pairing, and with the inclusion of LNA nucleotides, we observe a progressive change in duplex geometry toward an A-like duplex structure. As such, with the inclusion of three LNA nucleotides, the hybrid adopts an almost canonical A-type duplex geometry, and thus it appears that the number of modifications has reached a saturation level with respect to structural changes, and that further incorporations would furnish only minute changes in the duplex structure. We attempt to rationalize the conformational steering induced by the LNA nucleotides by suggesting that the change in electronic density at the brim of the minor groove, introduced by the LNA modification, is causing an alteration of the pseudorotational profile of the 3'-flanking nucleotide, thus shifting this sugar equilibrium toward N-type conformation.     

In vitro evolution of an RNA-cleaving DNA enzyme into an RNA ligase switches the selectivity from 3'-5' to 2'-5'

Deoxyribozymes that ligate RNA expand the scope of nucleic acid catalysis and allow preparation of site-specifically modified RNAs. Previously, deoxyribozymes that join a 5'-hydroxyl and a 2',3'-cyclic phosphate were identified by in vitro selection from random DNA pools. Here, the alternative strategy of in vitro evolution was used to transform the 8-17 deoxyribozyme that cleaves RNA into a family of DNA enzymes that ligate RNA. The parent 8-17 DNA enzyme cleaves native 3'-5' phosphodiester linkages but not 2'-5' bonds. Surprisingly, the new deoxyribozymes evolved from 8-17 create only 2'-5' linkages. Thus, reversing the direction of the DNA-mediated process from ligation to cleavage also switches the selectivity in forming the new phosphodiester bond. The same change in selectivity was observed upon evolution of the 10-23 RNA-cleaving deoxyribozyme into an RNA ligase. The DNA enzymes previously isolated from random pools also create 2'-5' linkages. Therefore, deoxyribozyme-mediated formation of a non-native 2'-5' phosphodiester linkage from a 5'-hydroxyl and a 2',3'-cyclic phosphate is strongly favored in many different contexts.     

Ethidium and proflavine binding to a 2',5'-linked RNA duplex

Despite over 40 years of physical investigations, fundamental questions persist regarding the energetics of RNA and DNA intercalation. The dramatic unwinding of a nucleic acid duplex upon intercalation immediately suggests that the nucleic acid backbone should play a significant role in dictating the free energy of intercalation. However, the contribution of the backbone to intercalation free energy is difficult to appreciate given the intertwined energetics associated with intercalation (e.g., pi-pi stacking and solvent effects). Fluorescence titrations were used to determine the association constants of two known intercalators, proflavine and ethidium, for duplex 2',5'-linked RNA. Proflavine was found to bind 2',5' RNA with an association constant 25-fold greater than that measured for standard, 3',5'-linked RNA. In contrast, ethidium binds 2',5' RNA less favorably than standard RNA.     

Long-range cooperativity in molecular recognition of RNA by oligodeoxynucleotides with multiple C5-(1-propynyl) pyrimidines.

A heptamer composed of C5-(1-propynyl) pyrimidines (Y(p)'s) is a potent and specific antisense agent against the mRNA of SV40 large T antigen (Wagner, R. W.; Matteucci, M. D.; Grant, D.; Huang, T.; Froehler, B. C. Nat. Biotechnol. 1996, 14, 840-844). To characterize the role of the propynyl groups in molecular recognition, thermodynamic increments associated with substitutions in DNA:RNA duplexes, such as 5'-dCCUCCUU-3':3'-rGAGGAGGAAAU-5', have been measured by UV melting experiments. For nucleotides tested, an unpaired dangling end stabilizes unmodified and propynylated duplexes similarly, except that addition of a 5' unpaired rA is 1.4 kcal/mol more stabilizing on the propynylated, PODN:RNA, duplex than on the DNA:RNA duplex. Free energy increments for addition of single propynyl groups range from 0 to -4.0 kcal/mol, depending on the final number and locations of substitutions. A preliminary model for predicting the stabilities of Y(p)-containing hybrid duplexes is presented. Eliminating one amino group, and therefore a hydrogen bond, by substituting inosine (I) for guanosine (G), to give 5'-dC(p)C(p)U(p)C(p)C(p)U(p)U(p)-3':3'-rGAGIAGGAAAU-5', destabilizes the duplex by 3.9 kcal/mol, compared to 1.7 kcal/mol for the same change within the unpropynylated duplex. This 2.2 kcal/mol difference is eliminated by removing a single propynyl group three base pairs away. CD spectra suggest that single propynyl deletions within the PODN:RNA duplex have position-dependent effects on helix geometry. The results suggest long-range cooperativity between propynyl groups and provide insights for rationally programming oligonucleotides with enhanced binding and specificity. This can be exploited in developing technologies that are dependent upon nucleic acid-based molecular recognition.     

The α‐L‐Threofuranosyl‐(3′→2′)‐oligonucleotide System (‘TNA'): Synthesis and Pairing Properties

Our studies of α‐L ‐Threofuranosyl‐(3′→2′)‐oligonucleotides (‘TNA') are part of a systematic experimental inquiry into the base‐pairing properties of potentially natural nucleic acid alternatives taken from RNA's close structural neighborhood. TNA is an efficient Watson‐Crick base‐pairing system and has the capability of informational cross‐pairing with both RNA and DNA. This property, together with the system's constitutional and (presumed) generational simplicity, warrants special scrutiny of TNA in the context of the search for chemical clues to RNA's origin.     

A pyrazolato-bridged dinuclear platinum(II) complex induces only minor distortions upon DNA-binding

The cytotoxic, pyrazolato-bridged dinuclear platinum(II) complex [(cis-{Pt(NH3)2})2(mu-OH)(mu-pz)]2+ (pz=pyrazolate) has been found to cross-link two adjacent guanines of a double-stranded DNA decamer without destabilizing the duplex and without changing the directionality of the helix axis. A 1H NMR study of the oligonucleotide d(CTCTG*G*TCTC)-d(GAGACCAGAG), cross-linked at the two G* guanines by [(cis-{Pt(NH3)2})2(mu-pz)]3+, and molecular dynamics simulations of the explicitly solvated duplex were performed to characterize the structural details of the adduct. The dinuclear platinum cross-link unwinds the helix by approximately 15 degrees , that is, to a similar extent as the widely used antitumor drug cisplatin, but, in contrast to the latter, induces no significant bend in the helix axis. The Watson-Crick base-pairing remains intact, and the melting temperature of the duplex is unaffected by the cross-link. The helical twist is considerably reduced between the two platinated bases, as becomes manifest in an unusually short sequential H1'-H1' distance. This unwinding also affects the sugar ring of the guanosine in the 3'-position to the cross-link, which presents an N<-->S equilibrium. This is the first cytotoxic platinum complex that has been successfully designed by envisioning the structural consequences of its binding to DNA.     

Substituted 1,8-naphthyridin-2(1H)-ones are superior to thymine in the recognition of adenine in duplex as well as triplex structures

The synthesis and evaluation of a series of novel nucleobases based on substituted 1,8-naphthyridin-2(1H)-ones are reported. The nucleobases were designed to meet the requirements for incorporation into peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) and were evaluated as part of PNA duplex and triplex nucleic acid recognition systems. Of the various nucleobases tested, only the 7-chloro-1,8-naphthyridin-2(1H)-one (7-Cl-bT) nucleobase led to consistently increased affinity in all recognition systems, duplex (Watson-Crick) as well as triplex (Hoogsteen). For multiply modified systems, the increase in thermal stability per modification was dependent on the sequence context, ranging from 2.0 degrees C (in separate positions) to 3.5 degrees C (in adjacent positions) in PNA-DNA duplexes and from 1.2 degrees C (in separate positions) to 3.2 degrees C (in adjacent positions) in PNA-RNA duplexes. Singly mismatched oligonucleotide targets were employed to demonstrate uncompromised sequence discrimination. When part of multiply modified triplex (Hoogsteen) recognition systems, the 7-Cl-bT unit gave rise to increases in the thermal stability ranging from 2.7 to 3.5 degrees C when incorporated into separated and adjacent positions, respectively. Our results furthermore indicate that the duplex stabilization is predominantly enthalpic and therefore most likely not a consequence of single-strand preorganization. Finally, and most surprisingly, we find no direct correlation between the end-stacking efficiency of this type of nucleobase and its helix stabilization when involved in Watson-Crick base pairing within a helix.     

NMR solution structure of an oligonucleotide hairpin with a 2'F-ANA/RNA stem: implications for RNase H specificity toward DNA/RNA hybrid duplexes.

The first structure of a 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro-D-arabinose nucleic acid (2'F-ANA)/RNA duplex is presented. We report the structural characterization by NMR spectroscopy of a small hybrid hairpin, r(GGAC)d(TTCG)2'F-a(GTCC), containing a 2'F-ANA/RNA stem and a four-residue DNA loop. Complete (1)H, (13)C, (19)F, and (31)P resonance assignments, scalar coupling constants, and NOE constraints were obtained from homonuclear and heteronuclear 2D spectra. In the chimeric duplex, the RNA strand adopts a classic A-form structure having C3' endo sugar puckers. The 2'F-ANA strand is neither A-form nor B-form and contains O4' endo sugar puckers. This contrasts strongly with the dynamic sugar conformations previously observed in the DNA strands of DNA/RNA hybrid duplexes. Structural parameters for the duplex, such as minor groove width, x-displacement, and inclination, were intermediate between those of A-form and B-form duplexes and similar to those of DNA/RNA duplexes. These results rationalize the enhanced stability of 2'F-ANA/RNA duplexes and their ability to elicit RNase H activity. The results are relevant for the design of new antisense drugs based on sugar-modified nucleic acids.