Review of aqueous chiral electrokinetic chromatography (EKC) with an emphasis on chiral microemulsion EKC

The separation of enantiomers using electrokinetic chromatography (EKC) with chiral microemulsions is comprehensively reviewed through December 1, 2006. Aqueous chiral EKC separations based on other pseudostationary phases such as micelles and vesicles or on other chiral selectors such as CDs, crown ethers, glycopeptides, ligand exchange moeities are also reviewed from both mechanistic and applications perspective for the period of January 2005 to December 1, 2006.     

Marker compounds for the determination of retention factors in EKC

EKC and its sub‐techniques, such as MEKC and microemulsion EKC, have attracted wide interest in recent years. Investigations on this topic have covered several analytical applications, but attention has also been paid more and more to basic studies. This review provides an overview of the different approaches to calculating retention factors, which express the ratio of the amount of sample component in the pseudostationary and mobile phases. Special attention is given to the selection of markers for the determination of the electrophoretic mobility or migration time of a marker describing the behavior of the pseudostationary phase in EKC. Introduction of a hydrophobic marker is by far the most common approach, but the use of a homologous series of compounds is also quite popular. In addition, other possible approaches found in the literature will be described.     

Dual-opposite injection electrokinetic chromatography for the unbiased, simultaneous separation of cationic and anionic compounds

The concept of dual opposite injection in capillary electrophoresis (DOI-CE) for the simultaneous separation, under conditions of suppressed electroosmotic flow, of anionic and cationic compounds with no bias in resolution and analysis time, is extended to a higher pH range in a zone electrophoresis mode (DOI-CZE). A new DOI-CE separation mode based on electrokinetic chromatography is also introduced (DOI-EKC). Whereas conventional CZE and DOI-CZE are limited to the separation of charged compounds with different electrophoretic mobilities, DOI-EKC is shown to be capable of separating compounds with the same or similar electrophoretic mobilities. In contrast to conventional EKC with charged pseudostationary phases that often interact too strongly with analytes of opposite charge, the neutral pseudostationary phases appropriate for DOI-EKC are simultaneously compatible with anionic and cationic compounds. This work describes two buffer additives that dynamically suppress electroosmotic flow (EOF) at a higher pH (6.5) than in a previous study (4.4), thus allowing DOI-CZE of several pharmaceutical bases and weakly acidic positional isomers. Several DOI-EKC systems based on nonionic (10 lauryl ether, Brij 35) or zwitterionic (SB-12, CAS U) micelles, or nonionic vesicles (Brij 30) are examined using a six-component test mixture that is difficult to separate by CZE or DOI-CZE. The effect of electromigration dispersion on peak shape and efficiency, and the effect of surfactant concentration on retention, selectivity, and efficiency are described.     

Evaluation of the performance of single‐walled carbon nanohorns in capillary electrophoresis

This paper describes for the first time the use of single‐walled carbon nanohorns (SWNHs) as pseudostationary and stationary phases for EKC and CEC, respectively, taking advantage of their characteristic features, such as conical‐end termination, formation of spherical assemblies dahlia‐flower like superstructure and easy functionalization. The use of SWNHs as pseudostationary phase for EKC required the study of their dispersion in different surfactants as well as their compatibility with the electrophoretic system. The carboxylation and subsequent immobilization of carboxylated SWNHs in fused‐silica capillary to obtain useful, reproducible and stable stationary phases for CEC has also been investigated, with promising results. The electrophoretic separations obtained for water‐soluble vitamins in both modalities (EKC and CEC) have been systematically compared with those obtained with single‐walled carbon nanotubes.     

Recent progress in the use of ionic polymers as pseudostationary phases for EKC

This review concerns the introduction, characterization, and application of polymeric pseudostationary phases (PSPs) for EKC since 2004. Achiral and chiral polymers and separations are reviewed, as is the application of polymeric PSPs for the combination of EKC with mass spectrometric detection.     

On-line coupling of electrokinetic chromatography and mass spectrometry

The use of pseudostationary phases (PSPs) in capillary electrophoresis provides powerful separation systems of high efficiency, selectivity and flexibility. Such electrokinetic chromatographic (EKC) systems are particularly useful for chiral analysis or for the analysis of samples containing a broad range of compounds. As the availability of mass and/or structural data on (unknown) sample constituents is increasingly important, the on-line coupling of EKC and mass spectrometry (MS) has gained attention. However, commonly used PSPs, such as micelles and cyclodextrines, may strongly interfere with electrospray ionization (ESI), making on-line EKC–MS quite a challenging task. This review covers the various approaches that have been proposed and developed to combine EKC and MS. A distinction is made between methodologies that prevent the PSP from entering the MS system, and methodologies that allow introduction of PSPs into the ion source. Various approaches such as partial filling of the separation capillary with PSP, use of reverse-migrating PSPs, employment of volatile PSPs, and alternative ionization modes, are outlined. Specific applications are described and overview tables are provided. It is concluded that there is no general solution for EKC–MS available yet, but new ionization techniques like atmospheric pressure photoionization may offer attractive perspectives for achieving full compatibility.     

Influences of the concentration and the molar ratio of mixed surfactants on the performance of vesicle pseudostationary phase

In our previous work, it was found that the vesicles were formed spontaneously by mixing octyltriethylammonium bromide (C₈NE₃Br) with sodium dodecyl benzene sulfonate (SDBS), and the vesicles have been developed as a pseudostationary phase (PSP) in EKC. In the present work, the effects of the concentration and the molar ratio of cationic to anionic surfactant on the vesicle properties and the performances of vesicle PSP in EKC have been investigated. The aggregates at all mixing ratio were negatively charged regardless of which surfactant surplus. As C₈NE₃Br proportion increased, the microviscosity of the vesicle became larger. With the increase in the total surfactant concentration, the migration time window broadened at the molar ratio of C₈NE₃Br to SDBS of 3:7. Unexpectedly, the window became narrowed at molar ratio of 5:5 and 6:4. However, the methylene selectivity of vesicle PSP at all above‐mentioned molar ratios enhanced as the total surfactant concentration increased, no matter whether the migration time window enlarged or narrowed. It implied that the vesicle PSP at molar ratio of 5:5 and 6:4 made it possible to obtain a better separation in a shorter time. When the total surfactant concentration was fixed at 20 mM, the methylene selectivity of the vesicle PSP of molar ratio of 5:5 was comparable to that of 3:7, but the migration time shortened by a half.     

New Pseudostationary Phases for Electrokinetic Chromatography: A High-Molecular Surfactant and Proteins

To extend the applicability of electrokinetic chromatography (EKC), two new types of pseudostationary phases have been introduced. A high-molecular surfactant, butyl acrylate/butyl methacrylate/methacrylic acid copolymer (BBMA) is employed as a micellar forming surfactant for miccllar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC). The critical micelle concentration of BBMA is essentially zero, which means the micellar concentration is constant irrespective of temperature and buffer. Some characteristic features of BBMA as the pseudostationary phase for MEKC is investigated in comparison with conventional ionic surfactants. Ovomucoid and avidin, which are proteins isolated from egg white, have been found to be useful chiral selectors in affinity EKC. A few examples of the separation of enantiomers with these proteins are shown.     

Effect of class I and II organic modifiers on retention and selectivity in vesicle electrokinetic chromatography

Vesicles are large aggregates of surfactant monomers consisting of a spherical bilayer surrounding an internal cavity of solvent. The bilayer structure allows vesicles to be attractive models for the study of various transmembrane and binding processes. The use of thermodynamically stable vesicles (TSV) formed from oppositely charged surfactants for use as a pseudostationary phase in electrokinetic chromatography (EKC) was first accomplished using dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide and sodium dodecyl sulfate (DTAB/SDS). Surfactant vesicles have demonstrated enhanced separation characteristics compared to conventional micelles in EKC, although only investigated in aqueous media. Organic modifiers have been widely studied and used in EKC to enhance separation conditions. In this study, vesicles formed from cetyltrimethylammonium bromide and sodium octyl sulfate (CTAB/SOS) were investigated in the presence of "class I and II" organic modifiers. Electrophoretic and chromatographic parameters were examined as well as linear solvation energy relationship analysis (LSER) to characterize the effects of the modifiers on retention and selectivity in EKC. LSER analysis is a useful way to quantitatively investigate solute/solvent interactions responsible for retention and selectivity.     

Micellar proportion: a parameter to compare the hydrophobicity of the pseudostationary phases or that of the analytes in micellar electrokinetic chromatography

Micellar proportion, t(prop,mic) = t(mic)/t(m), a quantity expressing how much time is spent by the analyte in the micellar phase related to its whole migration time (t(m)) has been introduced by utilizing the micellar phase residence time (t(mic)). The t(prop,mic) values have been determined for analytes of different chemical structures (alkyl benzene and alkyl phenone homologous series, alcohols, strongly hydrophobic peptides) studied by micellar elektrokinetic chromatography (MEKC) using various cationic and anionic pseudostationary phases. A good linear correlation was obtained between t(prop,mic) and the calculated hydrophobicity (CLOGP) of the analytes for all pseudostationary phases (CLOGP = A.logt(prop,mic) + B). Considering a given pseudostationary phase, t(prop,mic) as a relative quantity is a suitable parameter to characterize and compare experimentally the behavior of the various analytes in MEKC. Applying a set of probe molecules with known hydrophobicity, the CLOGP(50) value (showing the value of hydrophobicity of a virtual molecule spending exactly 50% of its migration time in the pseudostationary phase) has been calculated for each pseudostationary phase applied here. This experimentally determinable numerical value (characterizing the pseudostationary phase) can be utilized to compare the hydrophobicity and hence retention ability of the pseudostationary phases. The t(prop,mic) value was found to be applicable to compare the methylene selectivity of the different pseudostationary phases as well: logt(prop,mic) = A.Z + B, where Z is the number of carbon atoms of the alkyl chain in the alkyl benzene homologous series.     

Recent innovation in capillary electrokinetic chromatography with replaceable charged pseudostationary phases or additives

Recent developments of separation of neutral analytes in capillary systems with the mobile phase driven by the electroosmotic flow (EOF) and charged additives acting as a pseudostationary phase are reviewed. As pseudostationary phases a number of additives are used. Soluble polymers, either anionic or cationic, were applied as alternatives to micelles. Monomeric charged additives are also intended to form associates with the analytes, leading to selective retention and separation in a similar way as the polymeric pseudostationary phases. Dendrimers, spherical macromolecules with highly branched chains and charged terminal groups, are successfully applied for the separation of lipophilic analytes. Polymers with covalently stabilized structures are introduced in the form of permanent micelles and are therefore insensitive to the mobile phase composition, enlarging the applicability of micellar electrokinetic capillary chromatography (MEKC).     

Evaluation of polymers based on a silicone backbone as pseudostationary phases for electrokinetic chromatography.

The feasibility of polymeric phases based on a silicone polymer backbone as pseudostationary phases for electrokinetic chromatography has been investigated. Silicone phases were studied because of the range of chemistries that could be developed based on these backbones, and because successful development of silicone phases would make it possible to employ much of the stationary phase chemistry developed in the past thirty years. Three silicone polymer structures have been investigated, but only one had sufficient aqueous solubility to permit application in electrokinetic chromatography. This phase was characterized by a variety of methods and was shown to be a mixture of partially hydrolyzed poly(bis-(3-cyanopropyl) siloxanes. When employed as a pseudostationary phase, this material provided selective and efficient separations. The electrophoretic mobility of the silicone polymer is greater than that of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles and poly(sodium 10-undecenylsulfate), providing an extended migration time range. A striking characteristic of the polymer is that the electrophoretic mobility is greater than typical electroosmotic mobilities. The chemical selectivity of the phase is significantly different from that of SDS micelles or poly(sodium 10-undecenylsulfate). The silicone phase is a more cohesive, basic and polar phase than SDS micelles. In buffers modified with a high concentration of organic solvents, the chromatographic properties of the silicone polymer are inferior to those of the poly(sodium 10-undecenylsulfate). The greatest limitation of silicone polymers for this application appears to be limited aqueous solubility, which will make it difficult to realize a family of such polymers with different chemical selectivities.     

Enantiomeric separation of a group of chiral dihydropyridines by electrokinetic chromatography

Electrokinetic chromatography (EKC) was employed to achieve the enantiomeric separation of a group of chiral 1,4-dihydropyridines (DHPs) with pharmacological activity. Micelles of bile salts alone or mixed with neutral cyclodextrins, micelles of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) mixed with neutral cyclodextrins, and anionic cyclodextrin derivatives, i.e., carboxymethyl-gamma-cyclodextrin (CM-gamma-CD), carboxymethyl-beta-cyclodextrin (CM-beta-CD), and succinylated beta-cyclodextrin (Succ-beta-CD), were employed as pseudostationary phases. The enantiomeric separation ability of these chiral selectors with respect to DHPs was studied in different experimental conditions. CM-beta-CD was shown to be the best chiral selector to perform the enantiomeric separation of DHPs by EKC. Next, the influence of the CM-beta-CD concentration, the pH and nature of the buffer, the temperature, and the applied voltage on the enantiomeric resolution of DHPs was studied. The use of a 50 mM ammonium acetate buffer, pH 6.7, 25 mM in CM-beta-CD together with an applied voltage of 15 or 20 kV, and a temperature of 15 degrees C enabled the individual enantiomeric separation of twelve DHPs, each one into its two enantiomers, and their separation in multicomponent mixtures of up to six DHPs into all their enantiomers.     

Effect of Micelle Composition on Acidic Drugs Separation Behavior by Micellar Electrokinetic Capillary Chromatography

Micellar electrokinetic capillary chromatography (MECC) is a branch of capillary electrophoretic techniques, in which surfactant micelles are added to the electrolyte solution as pseudostationary phase. Separation in MECC is based on electrophoretic mobilities of the analytes when partitioned into micelles1. In this work, four acidic drugs similar in structure with aryl carboxylic acid were separated by MECC. The effects of type of surfactant, such as anionic surfactant SDS, nonionic …     

Polymeric and polymer-supported pseudostationary phases in micellar electrokinetic chromatography: performance and selectivity

Several types of synthetic ionic polymers have been employed as pseudostationary phases in electrokinetic chromatography. The polymers have been shown to have some significant advantages and different chemical selectivity relative to conventional surfactant micelles. Polymeric phases are effective for the separation and analysis of hydrophobic and chiral compounds, and may be useful for the application of mass spectrometric detection. Additionally, the polymeric phases often demonstrate unique selectivity relative to micellar phases, and can be designed and synthesized to provide desired selectivity. This review covers efforts to develop and characterize the performance, characteristics, and selectivity of synthetic polymeric pseudostationary phases since their introduction in 1992. Some ideas for the future development of polymeric pseudostationary phases and the role they may play in electrokinetic separations are presented.     

Characterization of solvation properties of lipid bilayer membranes in liposome electrokinetic chromatography

The nature of solute interactions with biomembrane-like liposomes, made of naturally occurring phospholipids and cholesterol, was characterized using electrokinetic chromatography (EKC). Liposomes were used as a pseudo-stationary phase in EKC that provided sites of interactions for uncharged solutes. The retention factors of uncharged solutes in liposome EKC are directly proportional to their liposome-water partition coefficients. Linear solvation energy relationship (LSER) models were developed to unravel the contributions from various types of interactions for solute partitioning into liposomes. Size and hydrogen bond acceptor strength of solutes are the main factors that determine partitioning into lipid bilayers. This falls within the general behavior of solute partitioning from an aqueous into organic phases such as octanol and micelles. However, there exist subtle differences in the solvation properties of liposomes as compared to those of octanol and various micellar pseudo-phases such as aggregates of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), sodium cholate (SC), and tetradecylammonium bromide (TTAB). Among these phases, the SDS micelles are the least similar to the liposomes, while octanol, SC, and TTAB micelles exhibit closer solvation properties. Subsequently, higher correlations are observed between partitioning into liposomes and the latter three phases than that into SDS.     

Enantiomeric separations by use of polymeric surfactant electrokinetic chromatography

This review surveys the enantiomeric separation of drugs by electrokinetic chromatography using polymeric chiral surfactant pseudostationary phases. These phases have recently been shown to provide better mass transfer and increased rigidity and stability than regular micelles in micellar capillary electrophoresis. Characterization of the polymeric chiral surfactants is presented. Solution interactions of the pseudostationary phases via thermodynamics and fluorescence probe studies are evaluated. Also, case studies of enantiomeric separation of drugs using a single amino acid surfactant and the synergistic effect of the addition of gamma-cyclodextrin to the buffer is discussed. The use of dipeptide surfactants for chiral drug separations is described as well.     

Determination of cationic neurotransmitters and metabolites in brain homogenates by microchip electrophoresis and carbon nanotube-modified amperometry

An electrophoretic method for simultaneous determination of catecholamines and their O-methoxylated metabolites on the microchip as well as in the capillary is presented. A complex separation system employing sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles, dendrimers forming a second pseudostationary phase and borate complexation is needed for the satisfactory separation of the selected compounds on the short migration length. A carbon nanotube-modified working electrode has been applied for the sensitive amperometric detection with submicromolar detection limits. The applicability of this new method for the analytics of real samples is demonstrated by analysis of mouse brain homogenate on the microchip and human urine by capillary electrophoresis.     

Selectivity of single, mixed, and modified pseudostationary phases in electrokinetic chromatography

The selectivity of a compilation of single, mixed, and modified EKC pseudostationary phases, described in the literature and characterized through the solvation parameter model, is analyzed. Not only have micellar systems of different nature been included but also microemulsions, polymeric, and liposomial phases. In order to compare the systems, a principal component analysis of the coefficients of the solvation equation is performed. From this analysis, direct information of the system properties, differences in selectivity, as well as evidence of lack of accuracy in some system characterizations are obtained. These results become a very useful tool to perform separations with mixtures of surfactants, since it is possible to know which mixtures will provide a greater selectivity variation by changing only the composition of the pseudostationary phases. Furthermore, the variation of the selectivity of some mixtures, as well as the effect of the addition of organic solvents on selectivity, is also discussed.     

Past,present, and future developments in enantioselective analysis using capillary electromigration techniques

Enantioseparation of chiral products has become increasingly important in a large diversity of academic and industrial applications. The separation of chiral compounds is inherently challenging and thus requires a suitable analytical technique that can achieve high resolution and sensitivity. In this context, CE has shown remarkable results so far. Chiral CE offers an orthogonal enantioselectivity and is typically considered less costly than chromatographic techniques, since only minute amounts of chiral selectors are needed. Several CE approaches have been developed for chiral analysis, including chiral EKC and chiral CEC. Enantioseparations by EKC benefit from the wide variety of possible pseudostationary phases that can be employed. Chiral CEC, on the other hand, combines chromatographic separation principles with the bulk fluid movement of CE, benefitting from reduced band broadening as compared to pressure-driven systems. Although UV detection is conventionally used for these approaches, MS can also be considered. CE-MS represents a promising alternative due to the increased sensitivity and selectivity, enabling the chiral analysis of complex samples. The potential contamination of the MS ion source in EKC-MS can be overcome using partial-filling and counter-migration techniques. However, chiral analysis using monolithic and open-tubular CEC-MS awaits additional method validation and a dedicated commercial interface. Further efforts in chiral CE are expected toward the improvement of existing techniques, the development of novel pseudostationary phases, and establishing the use of chiral ionic liquids, molecular imprinted polymers, and metal-organic frameworks. These developments will certainly foster the adoption of CE(-MS) as a well-established technique in routine chiral analysis.