In vitro evolution of a ribozyme that contains 5-bromouridine.

The Tetrahymena group I ribozyme was modified by replacing all 99 component uridine residues with 5-bromouridine. This resulted in a 13-fold reduction in catalytic efficiency in the RNA-catalyzed phosphoester-transfer reaction compared to the behavior of the unmodified ribozyme. A population of 10(13) variant ribozymes was constructed, each containing 5-bromouridine in place of uridine. Five successive 'generations' of in vitro evolution were carried out, selecting for improved phosphoester transferase activity. The evolved molecules exhibited a 27-fold increase in catalytic efficiency compared to the wild-type bromouridine-containing ribozyme, even exceeding that of the wild-type ribozyme in the non-brominated form. Three specific mutations were found to be responsible for this altered behavior. These mutations enhanced activity in the context of 5-bromouridine, but were detrimental in the context of unmodified uridine. The evolved RNAs not only tolerated but came to exploit the presence of the nucleotide analogue in carrying out their catalytic function.     

In Vitro Selection of Specific Ligand-binding Nucleic Acids

In vitro selection is a method that allows the simultaneous screening of very large numbers of nucleic acid molecules for a wide range of properties from binding characteristics to catalytic properties; moreover, the isolation of the very rare functional molecules becomes possible. Binding sites between proteins and nucleic acids, for example, have been evaluated by this methodology in order to gain information about protein/nucleic acid interactions. Structure and function of catalytic RNA (“ribozymes”) has been studied by in vitro selection and has led to new ribozymes with improved catalytic function. Substrate specificity of catalytic RNA has been changed and has led to a ribozyme that cleaves DNA. Other applications include the isolation of nucleic acids that bind specifically to small organic molecules and of RNA molecules that form triple helices with double-stranded DNA. In this article we discuss the background, design, and results of in vitro genetic experiments, which bridge biochemical/molecular biological and organic chemical approaches to molecular recognition.     

Continuous in vitro evolution of a ribozyme that catalyzes three successive nucleotidyl addition reactions

Variants of the class I ligase ribozyme, which catalyzes joining of the 3' end of a template bound oligonucleotide to its own 5' end, have been made to evolve in a continuous manner by a simple serial transfer procedure that can be carried out indefinitely. This process was expanded to allow the evolution of ribozymes that catalyze three successive nucleotidyl addition reactions, two template-directed mononucleotide additions followed by RNA ligation. During the development of this behavior, a population of ribozymes was maintained against an overall dilution of more than 10(406). The resulting ribozymes were capable of catalyzing the three-step reaction pathway, with nucleotide addition occurring in either a 5'-->3' or a 3'-->5' direction. This purely chemical system provides a functional model of a multi-step reaction pathway that is undergoing Darwinian evolution.     

Conversion of a ribozyme to a deoxyribozyme through in vitro evolution

An RNA ligase ribozyme was converted to a corresponding deoxyribozyme through in vitro evolution. The ribozyme was prepared as a DNA molecule of the same sequence, and had no detectable activity. A population of randomized variants of this DNA was constructed and evolved to perform RNA ligation at a rate similar to that of the starting ribozyme. When the deoxyribozyme was prepared as an RNA molecule of the same sequence, it had no detectable activity. Thus, the evolutionary transition from an RNA to a DNA enzyme represents a switch, rather than a broadening, of the chemical basis for catalytic function. This transfer of both information and function is relevant to the transition between two different genetic systems based on nucleic acid-like molecules, as postulated to have occurred during the early history of life on Earth.     

Novel RNA catalysts for the Michael reaction

BACKGROUND: In vitro selected ribozymes with nucleotide synthase, peptide and carbon-carbon bond forming activity provide insight into possible scenarios on how chemical transformations may have been catalyzed before protein enzymes had evolved. Metabolic pathways based on ribozymes may have existed at an early stage of evolution. RESULTS: We have isolated a novel ribozyme that mediates Michael-adduct formation at a Michael-acceptor substrate, similar to the rate-limiting step of the mechanistic sequence of thymidylate synthase. The kinetic characterization of this catalyst revealed a rate enhancement by a factor of approximately 10(5). The ribozyme shows substrate specificity and can act as an intermolecular catalyst which transfers the Michael-donor substrate onto an external 20-mer RNA oligonucleotide containing the Michael-acceptor system. CONCLUSION: The ribozyme described here is the first example of a catalytic RNA with Michael-adduct forming activity which represents a key mechanistic step in metabolic pathways and other biochemical reactions. Therefore, previously unforeseen RNA-evolution pathways can be considered, for example the formation of dTMP from dUMP. The substrate specificity of this ribozyme may also render it useful in organic syntheses.     

Structural and kinetic characterization of an acyl transferase ribozyme

We have previously isolated, by in vitro selection, an acyl-transferase ribozyme that is capable of transferring a biotinylated methionyl group from the 3' end of a hexanucleotide substrate to its own 5'-hydroxyl. Comparison of the sequences of a family of evolved derivatives of this ribozyme allowed us to generate a model of the secondary structure of the ribozyme. The predicted secondary structure was extensively tested and confirmed by single-mutant and compensatory double-mutant analyses. The role of the template domain in aligning the acyl-donor oligonucleotide and acyl-acceptor region of the ribozyme was confirmed in a similar manner. The significance of different domains of the ribozyme structure and the importance of two tandem G:U wobble base pairs in the template domain were studied by kinetic characterization of mutant ribozymes. The wobble base pairs contribute to the catalytic rate enhancement, but only in the context of the complete ribozyme; the ribozyme in turn alters the metal binding properties of this site. Competitive inhibition experiments with unacylated substrate oligonucleotide are consistent with the ribozyme acting to stabilize substrate binding to the template, while negative interactions with the aminoacyl portion of the substrate destabilize binding.     

A phosphoramidate substrate analog is a competitive inhibitor of the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme

BACKGROUND: Phosphoramidate oligonucleotide analogs containing N3'-P5' linkages share many structural properties with natural nucleic acids and can be recognized by some RNA-binding proteins. Therefore, if the N-P bond is resistant to nucleolytic cleavage, these analogs may be effective substrate analog inhibitors of certain enzymes that hydrolyze RNA. We have explored the ability of the Tetrahymena group I intron ribozyme to bind and cleave DNA and RNA phosphoramidate analogs. RESULTS: The Tetrahymena group I ribozyme efficiently binds to phosphoramidate oligonucleotides but is unable to cleave the N3'-P5' bond. Although it adopts an A-form helical structure, the deoxyribo-phosphoramidate analog, like DNA, does not dock efficiently into the ribozyme catalytic core. In contrast, the ribo-phosphoramidate analog docks similarly to the native RNA substrate, and behaves as a competitive inhibitor of the group I intron 5' splicing reaction. CONCLUSIONS: Ribo-N3'-P5' phosphoramidate oligonucleotides are useful tools for structural and functional studies of ribozymes as well as protein-RNA interactions.     

Construction of Multi-ribozyme Expression System and Its Characterization of Cleavage on the MDR1/MRP1 Double Target Substrate in vitro

To improve catalytic activity of ribozyme on its substrate,the multi-ribozyme expression system was designed and constructed from 20 cis-acting hammerhead ribozymes undergoing self-cleavage with 10 trans-acting hammerhead ribozymes inserted altematively regularly and the plasmid of pGEM-MDRI/MRPI used to transcribe the M DRI/MRPI(196/210) substrate containing double target sites was also constructed by DNA recombination.Endonuclease digestion analysis and DNA sequencing indicate all the recombinant plasmids were correct.The cleavage activities were evaluated for the multi-ribozyme expression system on the MDR1/MRP1 substrate in the cell free system.The results demonstrate that the cis-acting hammerhead ribozymes in the multi-ribozyme expression system were able to cleave themselves and the 72 nt of 196Rz and the 71 nt of 210Rz trans-acting hammerhead ribozymes were liberated effectively,and the trans-acting hammerhead ribozymes released were able to act on the MDR1/MRP1 double target RNA substrate and cleave the target RNA at specific sites effectively.The multiribozyme expression system of the [Coat'A196Rz/Coat'B210Rz]5 is more significantly superior to that of the [Coat'A 196Rz/Coat'B210Rz]1 in cleavage of RNA substrate.The fractions cleaved by [Coat'A196Rz/Coat'B210Rz]5 on the MDR1/MRP1 substrate for 8 h at observed temperatures showed no marked difference.The studies of Mg2+ on cleavage efficiency indicate that cleavage reaction is dependent on Mg2+ ions concentration.The plot of Ig(kobs) vs.Igc(Mg2+) displays a linear relationship between 2.5 mmol/L and 20 mmol/L Mg2..It suggests that Mg2+ ions play a crucial role in multi-ribozyme cleavage on the substrate.     

An unusual pH-independent and metal-ion-independent mechanism for hairpin ribozyme catalysis

Background: Hairpin ribozymes (RNA enzymes) catalyze the same chemical reaction as ribonuclease A and yet RNAs do not usually have functional groups analogous to the catalytically essential histidine and lysine sidechains of protein ribonucleases. Some RNA enzymes appear to recruit metal ions to act as Lewis acids in charge stabilization and metal-bound hydroxide for general base catalysis, but it has been reported that the hairpin ribozyme functions in the presence of metal ion chelators. This led us to investigate whether the hairpin ribozyme exploits a metal-ion-independent catalytic strategy.Results: Substitution of sulfur for nonbridging oxygens of the reactive phosphate of the hairpin ribozyme has small, stereospecific and metal-ionindependent effects on cleavage and ligation mediated by this ribozyme. Cobalt hexammine, an exchange-inert metal complex, supports full hairpin ribozyme activity, and the ribozyme's catalytic rate constants display only a shallow dependence on pH.Conclusions: Direct metal ion coordination to phosphate oxygens is not essential for hairpin ribozyme catalysis and metal-bound hydroxide does not serve as the general base in this catalysis. Several models might account for the unusual pH and metal ion independence: hairpin cleavage and ligation might be limited by a slow conformational change; a pH-independent or metalcation-independent chemical step, such as breaking the 5′ oxygen-phosphorus bond, might be rate determining; or finally, functional groups within the ribozyme might participate directly in catalytic chemistry. Whichever the case, the hairpin ribozyme appears to employ a unique strategy for RNA catalysis.     

Rational design of allosteric ribozymes

Background: Efficient operation of cellular processes relies on the strict control that each cell exerts over its metabolic pathways. Some protein enzymes are subject to allosteric regulation, in which binding sites located apart from the enzyme's active site can specifically recognize effector molecules and alter the catalytic rate of the enzyme via conformational changes. Although RNA also performs chemical reactions, no ribozymes are known to operate as true allosteric enzymes in biological systems. It has recently been established that small-molecule receptors can readily be made of RNA, as demonstrated by the in vitro selection of various RNA aptamers that can specifically bind corresponding ligand molecules. We set out to examine whether the catalytic activity of an existing ribozyme could be brought under the control of an effector molecule by designing conjoined aptamer-ribozyme complexes.Results: By joining an ATP-binding RNA to a self-cleaving ribozyme, we have created the first example of an allosteric ribozyme that has a catalytic rate that can be controlled by ATP. A 180-fold reduction in rate is observed upon addition of either adenosine or ATP, but no inhibition is detected in the presence of dATP or other nucleoside triphosphates. Mutations in the aptamer domain that are expected to eliminate ATP binding or that increase the distance between aptamer and ribozyme domains result in a loss of ATP-specific allosteric control. Using a similar design approach, allosteric hammerhead ribozymes that are activated in the presence of ATP were created and another ribozyme that can be controlled by theophylline was created.Conclusions: The catalytic features of these conjoined aptamer-ribozyme constructs demonstrate that catalytic RNAs can also be subject to allosteric regulation — a key feature of certain protein enzymes. Moreover, by using simple rational design strategies, it is now possible to engineer new catalytic polynucleotides which have rates that can be tightly and specifically controlled by small effector molecules.     

Peptidyl-transferase ribozymes: trans reactions,structural characterization and ribosomal RNA-like features

Background: One of the most significant questions in understanding the origin of life concerns the order of appearance of DNA, RNA and protein during early biological evolution. If an ‘RNA world’ was a precursor to extant life, RNA must be able not only to catalyze RNA replication but also to direct peptide synthesis. Iterative Iterative RNA selection previously identified catalytic RNAs (ribozymes) that form amide bonds between RNA and an amino acid or between two amino acids.Results: We characterized peptidyl-transferase reactions catalyzed by two different families of ribozymes that use substrates that mimic A site and P site tRNAs. The family II ribozyme secondary structure was modeled using chemical modification, enzymatic digestion and mutational analysis. Two regions resemble the peptidyl-transferase region of 23S ribosomal RNA in sequence and structural context; these regions are important for peptide-bond formation. A shortened form of this ribozyme was engineered to catalyze intermolecular (‘trans’) peptide-bond formation, with the two amino-acid substrates binding through an attached AMP or oligonucleotide moiety.Conclusions: An in vitro-selected ribozyme can catalyze the same type of peptide-bond formation as a ribosome; the ribozyme resembles the ribosome because a very specific RNA structure is required for substrate binding and catalysis, and both amino acids are attached to nucleotides. It is intriguing that, although there are many different possible peptidyl-transferase ribozymes, the sequence and secondary structure of one is strikingly similar to the ‘helical wheel’ portion of 23S rRNA implicated in ribosomal peptidyl-transferase activity.     

In vitro selection of a novel nuclease-resistant RNA phosphodiesterase

BACKGROUND: Ribonucleotide-based enzymes (ribozymes) that cleave pathological RNAs are being developed as therapeutic agents. Chemical modification of the hammerhead ribozyme has produced nuclease-resistant catalysts that cleave targeted mRNAs in cell culture and exhibit antitumor activity in animals. Unfortunately, stabilizing modifications usually reduce the catalytic rate in vitro. An alternative to rationally designed chemical modifications of existing ribozymes is to identify novel motifs through in vitro selection of nuclease-stable sequence space. This approach is desirable because the catalysts can be optimized to function under simulated physiological conditions. RESULTS: Utilizing in vitro selection, we have identified a nuclease-stable phosphodiesterase that demonstrated optimal activity at simulated physiological conditions. The initial library of 10(14) unique molecules contained 40 randomized nucleotides with all pyrimidines in a nuclease-stabilized 2'-deoxy-2'-amino format. The selection required trans-cleaving activity and base-pairing specificity towards a resin-bound RNA substrate. Initial selective pressure was permissive, with a 30 min reaction time and 25 mM Mg(2+). Stringency of selection pressure was gradually increased until final conditions of 1 mM Mg(2+) and less than 1 min reaction times were achieved. The resulting 61-mer catalyst required the 2'-amino substitutions at selected pyrimidine positions and was stable in human serum (half-life of 16 h). CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrated that it is possible to identify completely novel, nuclease-resistant ribozymes capable of trans-cleaving target RNAs at physiologically relevant Mg(2+) concentrations. The new ribozyme motif has minimal substrate requirements, allowing for a wide range of potential RNA targets.     

Cross-catalytic replication of an RNA ligase ribozyme

A self-replicating RNA ligase ribozyme was converted to a cross-catalytic format whereby two ribozymes direct each other's synthesis from a total of four component substrates. Each ribozyme binds two RNA substrates and catalyzes their ligation to form the opposing ribozyme. The two ribozymes are not perfectly complementary, as is the case for replicating nucleic acid genomes in biology. Rather, the ribozymes contain both template elements, which are complementary, and catalytic elements, which are identical. The specificity of the template interactions allows the cross-catalytic pathway to dominate over all other reaction pathways. As the concentration of the two ribozymes increases, the rate of formation of additional ribozyme molecules increases, consistent with the overall autocatalytic behavior of the reaction system.     

Atom‐Specific Mutagenesis Reveals Structural and Catalytic Roles for an Active‐Site Adenosine and Hydrated Mg2+ in Pistol Ribozymes

The pistol RNA motif represents a new class of self‐cleaving ribozymes of yet unknown biological function. Our recent crystal structure of a pre‐catalytic state of this RNA shows guanosine G40 and adenosine A32 close to the G53–U54 cleavage site. While the N1 of G40 is within 3.4 Å of the modeled G53 2′‐OH group that attacks the scissile phosphate, thus suggesting a direct role in general acid–base catalysis, the function of A32 is less clear. We present evidence from atom‐specific mutagenesis that neither the N1 nor N3 base positions of A32 are involved in catalysis. By contrast, the ribose 2′‐OH of A32 seems crucial for the proper positioning of G40 through a H‐bond network that involves G42 as a bridging unit between A32 and G40. We also found that disruption of the inner‐sphere coordination of the active‐site Mg²⁺ cation to N7 of G33 makes the ribozyme drastically slower. A mechanistic proposal is suggested, with A32 playing a structural role and hydrated Mg²⁺ playing a catalytic role in cleavage.     

Generation and development of RNA ligase ribozymes with modular architecture through "design and selection"

In vitro selection with long random RNA libraries has been used as a powerful method to generate novel functional RNAs, although it often requires laborious structural analysis of isolated RNA molecules. Rational RNA design is an attractive alternative to avoid this laborious step, but rational design of catalytic modules is still a challenging task. A hybrid strategy of in vitro selection and rational design has been proposed. With this strategy termed "design and selection," new ribozymes can be generated through installation of catalytic modules onto RNA scaffolds with defined 3D structures. This approach, the concept of which was inspired by the modular architecture of naturally occurring ribozymes, allows prediction of the overall architectures of the resulting ribozymes, and the structural modularity of the resulting ribozymes allows modification of their structures and functions. In this review, we summarize the design, generation, properties, and engineering of four classes of ligase ribozyme generated by design and selection.     

Generalized RNA-directed recombination of RNA

RNA strand exchange through phosphor-nucleotidyl transfer reactions is an intrinsic chemistry promoted by group I intron ribozymes. We show here that Tetrahymena and Azoarcus ribozymes can promote RNA oligonucleotide recombination in either two-pot or one-pot schemes. These ribozymes bind one oligonucleotide, cleave following a guide sequence, transfer the 3' portion of the oligo to their own 3' end, bind a second oligo, and catalyze another transfer reaction to generate recombinant oligos. Recombination is most effective with the Azoarcus ribozyme in a single reaction vessel in which over 75% of the second oligo can be rapidly converted to recombinant product. The Azoarcus ribozyme can also create a new functional RNA, a hammerhead ribozyme, which can be constructed via recombination and then immediately promote its own catalysis in a homogeneous milieu, mimicking events in a prebiotic soup.     

DNAzymes for sensing, nanobiotechnology and logic gate applications

Catalytic nucleic acids (DNAzymes or ribozymes) are selected by the systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment process (SELEX). The catalytic functions of DNAzymes or ribozymes allow their use as amplifying labels for the development of optical or electronic sensors. The use of catalytic nucleic acids for amplified biosensing was accomplished by designing aptamer-DNAzyme conjugates that combine recognition units and amplifying readout units as in integrated biosensing materials. Alternatively, "DNA machines" that activate enzyme cascades and yield DNAzymes were tailored, and the systems led to the ultrasensitive detection of DNA. DNAzymes are also used as active components for constructing nanostructures such as aggregated nanoparticles and for the activation of logic gate operations that perform computing.     

Non-unity molecular heritability demonstrated by continuous evolution in vitro

INTRODUCTION: When catalytic RNA is evolved in vitro, the molecule's chemical reactivity is usually the desired selection target. Sometimes the phenotype of a particular RNA molecule cannot be unambiguously determined from its genotype, however. This can occur if a nucleotide sequence can adopt multiple folded states, an example of non-unity heritability (i.e. one genotype gives rise to more than one phenotype). In these cases, more rounds of selection are required to achieve a phenotypic shift. We tested the influence of non-unity heritability at the molecular level by selecting for variants of a ligase ribozyme via continuous evolution. RESULTS: During 20 bursts of continuous evolution of a 152-nucleotide ligase ribozyme in which the Mg2+ concentration was periodically lowered, a nine-error variant of the starting 'wild-type' molecule became dominant in the last eight bursts. This variant appears to be more active than the wild type. Kinetic analyses of the mutant suggest that it may not possess a higher first-order catalytic rate constant, however. Examination of the multiple RNA conformations present under the continuous evolution conditions suggests that the mutant is superior to the wild type because it is less likely to misfold into inactive conformers. CONCLUSIONS: The evolution of genotypes that are more likely to exhibit a particular phenotype is an epiphenomenon usually ascribed only to complex living systems. We show that this can occur at the molecular level, demonstrating that in vitro systems may have more life-like characteristics than previously thought, and providing additional support for an RNA world.     

Evidence for the metal-cofactor independence of an RNA phosphodiester-cleaving DNA enzyme

Background: RNA and DNA are polymers that lack the diversity of chemical functionalities that make proteins so suited to biological catalysis. All naturally occurring ribozymes (RNA catalysts) that catalyze the formation, transfer and hydrolysis of phosphodiesters require metal-ion cofactors for their catalytic activity. We wished to investigate whether, and to what extent, DNA molecules could catalyze the cleavage (by either hydrolysis or transesterification) of a ribonucleotide phosphodiester in the absence of divalent or higher-valent metal ions or, indeed, any other cofactors.Results: We performed in vitro selection and amplification experiments on a library of random-sequence DNA that incorporated a single ribonucleotide, a suitable site for cleavage. Following 12 cycles of selection and amplification, a ‘first generation’ of DNA enzymes (DNAzymes) cleaved their internal ribonucleotide phosphodiesters at rates ∼ 10⁷-fold faster than the spontaneous rate of cleavage of the dinucleotide ApA in the absence of divalent cations. Re-selection from a partially randomized DNA pool yielded ‘second generation’ DNAzymes that self-cleaved at rates of ∼ 0.01 min⁻¹ (a 10⁸-fold rate enhancement over the cleavage rate of ApA). The properties of these selected catalysts were different in key respects from those of metal-utilizing ribozymes and DNAzymes. The catalyzed cleavage took place in the presence of different chelators and ribonuclease inhibitors. Trace-metal analysis of the reaction buffer (containing very high purity reagents) by inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrophotometry indicated that divalent or higher-valent metal ions do not mediate catalysis by the DNAzymes.Conclusions: Our results indicate that, although ribozymes are sometimes regarded generically to be metalloenzymes, the nucleic acid components of ribozymes may play a substantial role in the overall catalysis. Given that metal cofactors increase the rate of catalysis by ribozymes only ∼ 10²−10³-fold above that of the DNAzyme described in this paper, it is conceivable that substrate positioning, transition-state stabilization or general acid/base catalysis by the nucleic acid components of ribozymes and DNAzymes may contribute significantly to their overall catalytic performance.     

In vitro selection of self-cleaving DNAs

Background: Ribozymes catalyze an important set of chemical transformations in metabolism, and ‘engineered’ ribozymes have been made that catalyze a variety of additional reactions. The possibility that catalytic DNAs or ‘deoxyribozymes’ can be made has only recently been addressed. Specifically, it is unclear whether the absence of the 2′ hydroxyl renders DNA incapable of exhibiting efficient enzyme-like activity, making it impossible to discover natural or create artificial DNA biocatalysts.Results: We report the isolation by in vitro selection of two distinct classes of self-cleaving DNAs from a pool of random-sequence oligonucleotides. Individual catalysts from ‘class I’ require both Cu²⁺ and ascorbate to mediate oxidative self-cleavage. Individual catalysts from class II use Cu²⁺ as the sole cofactor. Further optimization of a class II individual by in vitro selection yielded new catalytic DNAs that facilitate Cu²⁺-dependent self-cleavage with rate enhancements exceeding 1000 000-fold relative to the uncatalyzed rate of DNA cleavage.Conclusions: Despite the absence of 2′ hydroxyls, single-stranded DNA can adopt structures that promote divalent-metal-dependent self-cleavage via an oxidative mechanism. These results suggest that an efficient DNA enzyme might be made to cleave DNA in a biological context.