Effect of chloride on heavy metal mobility of harbour sediments

To evaluate the environmental impact of polluted sediments, several operationally defined sequential extraction procedures (SEPs) have been described. Salinity has long been recognised as an important variable determining the physicochemical behaviour of heavy metals in marine sediments. Thus, in the present paper, the modified BCR-SEP has been applied to harbour sediments in order to assess to what extent trace metal mobility (Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn) could be influenced by chloride content in sediments. For this, washed (W) and non-washed (NW) sediments were compared. The relative mobility order observed for the six trace metals studied was not seen to be influenced by the presence of chloride in the sediments, but an increase of mobility was observed for Cd and Zn (the most mobile metals) when chloride was present in the sediments. Characterisation of the sediments and of the pseudo-total metal contents by means of an aqua regia extraction was also assessed.     

Metal Speciation - General Concepts and Applications

Abstract

Several aspects of metal speciation in sediments are reviewed: (1) Due to the instability of polluted solid materials, sample handling and storage prior to analysis is problematic. In particular, changes from reducing to oxidizing conditions, which involve transformations of sulfides and a shift to more acid conditions, increase the mobility of critical metals. (2) Simple “standard” leaching tests can be used for easily soluble components such as halides or sulfates, but in most cases are not adequate for assessing mobility of trace metals. With sequential extraction procedures rearrangements of specific solid “phases” can be evaluated prior to their actual remobilisation. (3) Estimation of long-term release of metals from solids can be made using a test procedure, which combines data from column experiments applying controlled intensivation of parameters such as pH-value, redox potential and temperature with results from sequential extraction of the contaminated solids before and after exposure. (4) Partitioning studies on materials from core profiles are particularly useful, since they provide information on relative variations of elemental phases irrespective of the method applied, and thereby an insight into diagenetic processes taking place after deposition of the sediment components. (5) The leachable fraction does not necessarily correspond to the amount available to biota. Studies on the prediction of the trace metal levels in benthic organisms have shown, that the prognostic value of sequential extraction data is improved, when the trace metal concentrations are normalized with respect to the iron (hydrous oxide) and/or organic content of the sediments.     

Comparison of original and modified BCR sequential extraction procedures for the fractionation of copper, iron, lead, manganese and zinc in soils and sediments

This article describes a detailed comparison between the original BCR sequential extraction procedure, step 2 of which involves treatment with 0.1 mol l⁻¹ hydroxylammonium chloride at pH 2, and the revised BCR procedure (step 2: 0.5 mol l⁻¹ hydroxylammonium chloride at pH 1.5). An intermediate protocol was also evaluated in which 0.5 mol l⁻¹ hydroxylammonium chloride at pH 2 was used. The procedures were applied to five soil and sediment substrates: a sewage sludge-amended soil, two different industrially contaminated soils, a river sediment and an inter-tidal sediment. Extractable iron and manganese concentrations were measured to assess the effects of the procedural modifications on dissolution of the reducible matrix components. Trace elements copper, lead and zinc were also determined. Statistical analysis (two-tailed t-tests at 95% confidence interval) indicated that recovery of iron in step 2 was not markedly enhanced when the intermediate protocol was used. However, significantly greater amounts were isolated with the revised BCR scheme than with the original procedure. Copper behaved similarly to iron. Lead recoveries were increased by use of both modified protocols, with the greatest effect occurring for the revised BCR extraction. In contrast, manganese and zinc extraction did not vary markedly between procedures. The work indicates that the revised BCR sequential extraction provides better attack on the iron-based components of the reducible matrix for a wide range of soils and sediments.     

Extraction procedures for the determination of heavy metals in contaminated soil and sediment

Extraction tests are commonly used to study the mobility of metals in soils and sediments by mimicking different environmental conditions or dramatic changes on them. The results obtained by determining the extractable elements are dependent on the extraction procedure applied. The paper summarises state of the art extraction procedures used for heavy metal determination in contaminated soil and sediments. Two types of extraction are considered: single and sequential. Special attention is paid to the Standard, Measurement and Testing projects from the European Commission which focused on the harmonisation of the extraction procedures and on preparing soil and sediment certified reference materials for extractable heavy metal contents.     

Speciation of Heavy Metals in Soils and Sediments. An Account of the Improvement and Harmonization of Extraction Techniques Undertaken Under the Auspices of the BCR of the Commission of the European Communities

Abstract

An account is presented of a series of investigations and collaborative studies, initiated by BCR, on current methods of metal speciation by extraction of soils and sediments with chemical reagents. It was established by extensive consultation with European experts that the diverse procedures used could be harmonized into agreed methods. These methods, including both single extractant and sequential extraction procedures were subjected to collaborative, interlaboratory trials and the results, presented briefly here, showed that it was both possible and desirable that reference soils and sediments, characterised by certified values for extractable contents, be prepared. As a consequence of these studies two soils have been prepared and will shortly be the subject of interlaboratory analysis with a view to certification of their EDTA and acetic acid extractable contents of some heavy metals. Following this workshop a feasibility study of the agreed sequential extraction procedure will, it is believed, shortly lead to certification of sediments for contents extractable by a defined sequential extraction procedure.     

Speeding up of a three-stage sequential extraction method for metal speciation using focused ultrasound

The three-stage sequential extraction procedure, proposed by the European Community Bureau of Reference (BCR), has been applied for speciation of copper, chromium, nickel, lead and zinc in a sludge sample collected from an urban wastewater treatment plant. The conventional BCR sequential extraction method has been modified, in each stage, applying ultrasonic energy by means of a probe (handling at an adequate sonication power and time) in order to shorten the required operation time. Extractable metal contents obtained by both the conventional and the accelerated ultrasonic extraction method, were measured by Flame-Atomic Absorption Spectrometry. Results obtained in each fraction by both methods were statistically compared (P=0.95) for all the studied elements and no significant differences were found except for chromium and zinc in the third fraction (oxidisable). For all metals the extraction percentage was>95%. The proposed accelerated sequential extraction method could be a valid alternative to the conventional shaking with a much shorter operating time.     

Speciation of heavy metals in sediments of the lagoon of Venice collected in the industrial area

In this study a procedure of sequential extraction of metals from sediments was applied to samples from the lagoon of Venice. Compared to the measurement of total concentrations, the knowledge of metal partitioning among sediment phases can help in estimating the risk posed by metal polluted sediments and give information on contamination sources and on the factors that influence metal enrichment in sediments. The results permitted to estimate for each metal the percentage of the total content that could be potentially remobilized from sediments, owing to changes in environmental conditions. The immediately available fraction represented in general a low proportion of the total content. An important proportion of most metals (except for Zn, Cd and Cu) was associated to residual phases and therefore was not expected to be released under the normal environmental conditions. The large amounts of metals bound to Fe-Mn oxides/hydroxides confirmed the strong scavenging efficiency of this phase. The carbonate phase was the preferential associative form for Pb, Cd and Zn, whereas Cu was bound in prevalence to the organic matter/sulphide phase.     

Comparison of three sequential extraction procedures (original and modified 3 steps BCR procedure) applied to sediments of different origin

The 3 steps sequential extraction procedure proposed by the Standards Measurements and Testing program (SM&T--formerly BCR) of the European Union has been applied for the speciation of metals in sediments. Results obtained by the application of the BCR standardized procedure were compared to those of two four step sequential extraction procedures, which are different from the BCR procedure only for the introduction of an additional step with NaOCl, as 2nd and 3rd step respectively. Five different metals have been taken into consideration: Cd, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn. The analytical performances of the laboratory have been evaluated using three certified reference materials: the BCR 601 lake sediment for the BCR sequential extraction procedure, PACS-1 and MESS-1 for total metal concentration. Results showed that the efficiency of NaOCl treatment is higher or at least equal to that of H2O2 treatment and that its selectivity is quite satisfying. Moreover the NaOCl treatment doesn't significantly influence the extraction of the easily reducible fraction.     

Evalution of sequential extractions on dry and wet sediments

A five-step sequential extraction procedure was applied on dried and wet Ballastplaat Scheldt estuary sediments. When wet (fresh) sediments were used, all sample handling up to the 3rd extraction step, inclusive, was carried out under inert atmosphere. The repeatability of the procedure was very good on dry samples. For Fe as for Mn, RSD values are lower than 4%, except for Mn in the fifth extraction step where a spread of 10% is observed. The observed RSDs for Pb are of the same order of magnitude as those for Mn. On wet samples the spread of the results is higher than on dried ones. The highest RSDs observed for Fe amount to 20%, for Mn to 15% but for Pb an RSD of up to 44% was found. Better homogenization of the solid sediment part of lyophilized sediments and different porosities of wet sediment sub-samples may be the explanation. These results also indicated that drying/oxidizing of the sediment sample causes a shift from less available/mobile metal fractions to more available/mobile fractions. The Mn and Fe oxyhydroxide spikes added to a wet sediment sample were recovered between 100±10%. The results obtained after changing the sequence of the extraction steps (multiple rotations and inversions were tested) corroborated the progressive increase in the aggressive nature of the extraction solutions in our standard scheme. Although there is also no need to change the ratio volume of extractant to amount of sediment, increasing the number of extraction repetitions in steps 1 to 3 resulted, for some of those extraction steps, in a partially modified analyte distribution. Finally the method was applied to sandy and muddy sediment cores of the Scheldt estuary and revealed clear differences between metal distributions in both types of sediment.     

A Comparison on Five Sediment Decomposition Procedures for Determining Anthropogenic Trace Metal Pollution

Abstract

Five different procedures of sediment decomposition were compared, for evaluating the one more appropriated for assessing anthropogenic metal pollution. Exchangeable-metal extraction in sodium acetate, weak extraction in hydroxylamine hydrochloride/acetic acid, moderate extraction in diluted hydrochloric acid, oxidising strong acid digestion and total decomposition with hydrofluoric acid were tested. The mildest sodium acetate attack, which gives also better account for the bioavailable metal fraction, is the more effective in enhancing differences between polluted sediments and nonpolluted ones. Copper, lead and zinc are the best indicators of trace metal pollution of surface sediments.     

Comparison of Two Sequential Extraction Procedures for Trace Metal Partitioning in Sediments

Abstract

Two sequential extraction schemes (a modified Tessier procedure with five steps and a three steps protocol designed by BCR) are applied to four sediment samples with different heavy metal contents. The results obtained for Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb and Zn partitioning show that the metal distribution obtained with both procedures are significantly different. With the second procedure amounts of all the heavy metals are extracted with the oxidizing reagent (third fraction) whereas with the first one the non residual metals are distributed among the second, third and fourth fractions (acetic acid-acetate buffer (pH=5), reducing and oxidizing reagents respectively). The residual fraction obtained applying the three steps procedure is in general higher than that obtained using the five steps procedure, except for cadmium.     

Should acid ammonium oxalate replace hydroxylammonium chloride in step 2 of the revised BCR sequential extraction protocol for soil and sediment?

The revised, four-step BCR sequential extraction for soil or sediment has been compared with an alternative procedure in which 0.2 mol l⁻¹ ammonium oxalate (pH 3) replaced 0.5 mol l⁻¹ hydroxylammonium chloride (pH 1.5) in step 2, the reducible step. A variety of substrates were studied: BCR CRM601, a sewage sludge amended soil, two industrial soils, and a steel manufacturing by-product (basic oxygen furnace filter cake). Greater amounts of iron were recovered in step 2 when acid ammonium oxalate was used, for all substrates. Similar trends were observed for copper. Manganese and zinc were not strongly affected by the procedural modification, except for zinc in the two industrial soils, where oxalate extraction proved more efficient than use of hydroxylammonium chloride. A large proportion of the calcium and lead isolated in step 2 of the BCR procedure was not released until step 3 when the alternative procedure with oxalate in step 2 was used. This is probably due to rapid precipitation of analyte oxalates from solution. Thus, whilst oxalate offers superior dissolution of iron-containing matrix components, it should not be used if calcium or lead concentrations are to be measured. Selection of the most appropriated sequential extraction protocol for use in a particular study must always be carried out on the basis of “fitness for purpose” criteria. However, the revised BCR protocol, involving use of 0.5 mol l⁻¹ NH₂OH·HCl in the reducible step, appears to be more generally applicable than procedures involving acid ammonium oxalate.     

An evaluation of the modified BCR sequential extraction procedure to assess the potential mobility of copper and zinc in MSW

Copper and zinc were determined in municipal solid waste (MSW) samples with different deposit ages from Tianziling landfill site. The pseudototal metal contents of the MSW samples were determined following an aqua regia digestion. Operational speciation was performed using the modified BCR sequential extraction procedure. Analyses were carried out by AAS. Agreement between most of triplicate samples was acceptable. The amount of copper and zinc extracted in the sequential procedure (i.e. Step 1, Step 2, Step 3, residual) did not generally agree well with pseudototal digestion. Various MSW samples contained significant different levels of copper and zinc, but these were with different potential migrations. For example, 49.88%-76.34% of copper existed in five MSW samples was present as oxidable fraction while ~ 40% of zinc was present as acid soluble fraction. The study illustrates the feasibility and importance of modified BCR sequential extraction procedure used as evaluation method when assessing the potential mobility of heavy metal in MSW landfill.     

Mercury and trace element fractionation in Almaden soils by application of different sequential extraction procedures

A comparative evaluation of the mercury distribution in a soil sample from Almaden (Spain) has been performed by applying three different sequential extraction procedures, namely, modified BCR (three steps in sequence), Di Giulio–Ryan (four steps in sequence), and a specific SEP developed at CIEMAT (six steps in sequence). There were important differences in the mercury extraction results obtained by the three procedures according to the reagents applied and the sequence of their application. These findings highlight the difficulty of setting a universal SEP to obtain information on metal fractions of different mobility for any soil sample, as well as the requirement for knowledge about the mineralogical and chemical characteristics of the samples. The specific six-step CIEMAT sequential extraction procedure was applied to a soil profile (Ap, Ah, Bt1, and Bt2 horizons). The distribution of mercury and major, minor, and trace elements in the different fractions were determined. The results indicate that mercury is mainly released with 6 M HCl. The strong association of mercury with crystalline iron oxyhydroxides, present in all the horizons of the profile, and/or the solubility of some mercury compounds in such acid can explain this fact. Minor mercury is found in the fraction assigned to oxidizable matter and in the final insoluble residue (cinnabar).     

Single and Sequential Extraction in Sediments and Soils

Abstract

The determination of extractable trace metal contents in soils and sediments is currently performed in many laboratories to assess the bioavailable metal fraction (and related potential phyto-toxic effects) and the importance and possibility of mobilization of trace metals from polluted soil, sludge and sediment upon landfill application. Single and sequential extraction schemes are used for the assessment of the different “forms” of trace metals (e.g. “mobile/bioavailable”, “carbonate-bound” etc.). The lack of uniformity in the different extraction procedures used throughout the world does not allow the results to be compared or the procedures to be validated which has led to many criticisms in the past few years. Moreover, the lack of suitable reference materials for this type of operationally defined determinations did not enable the quality of the measurements to be controlled. Owing to the need for establishing common schemes for single and sequential extractions as well as for the improvement of the quality of extractable trace metal determinations in soil and sediments, the Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) has organised a project which results along with the state of the art of extractable trace metal determinations, use and applicability of extraction schemes and analytical limitations were decided to be thoroughly discussed in a workshop. This paper presents its main conclusions.     

Extraction efficiencies for hydrocarbons from sediments polluted by oily drill cuttings

Alkaline digestion with sodium hydroxide/methanol/pentane, Soxhlet extraction with methanol/dichloromethane, and ultrasonication with methanol/dichloromethane were applied to subsamples of three surface sediments polluted by oily drill cuttings to different levels (about 50, 1000 and 25 000 mg kg^?1 hydrocarbon pollution). For the two most polluted sediments the three methods were not significantly different in their ability to extract petroleum hydrocarbons from the sediments, at a 90% confidence level. The amounts extracted from the least polluted sediments using ultrasonication was, however, significantly above the amounts obtained by the other two methods. The average relative standard deviations increased in the order Soxhlet method (4.5%), alkaline digestion (12.4%) and ultrasonication (16.1%). Small differences in the relative amounts of some individual components were observed in the moderately polluted sediment.     

A new method of evaluation of element pollutant mobility in sediments

The application of a strong chelating agent for the screening test of element mobility in sedimentary systems was investigated. Single-step and sequential extraction procedures were applied to four sediment samples collected from an industrially polluted region of Eastern Slovakia. A sequential extraction procedure (SEP), recommended by the Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements (IRMM), was applied and used as a reference extraction method. A single-step extraction with 0.05 mol dm⁻³ ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) was adapted for sediments when extraction conditions were optimised. The extraction efficiency of the single-step procedure was compared with that of SEP. The contents of elements extracted by Na2EDTA were in good agreement with the sum of the first three steps of the SEP for Fe, Mn, and Co. Na₂EDTA can therefore be considered capable to extract the majority of elements associated with the reducible sedimentary phase — bound to Fe and Mn oxides in the regional geological conditions of the monitored region. Thus, Na₂EDTA extraction of Fe and Mn can serve as an economical, time-saving supplementary test for the IRMM procedure. This paper is dedicated to the memory of Erika Krakovská Presented at the XVIIIth Slovak Spectroscopic Conference, Spišská Nová Ves, 15–18 October 2006.     

Fractionation of potentially toxic elements in urban soils from five European cities by means of a harmonised sequential extraction procedure

The revised (four-step) BCR sequential extraction procedure has been applied to fractionate the chromium, copper, iron, manganese, nickel, lead and zinc contents in urban soil samples from public-access areas in five European cities. A preliminary inter-laboratory comparison was conducted and showed that data obtained by different laboratories participating in the study were sufficiently harmonious for comparisons to be made between cities and land types (e.g. parks, roadside, riverbanks, etc.). Analyte recoveries by sequential extraction, with respect to direct aqua regia digestion, were generally acceptable (100 ± 15%). Iron, nickel and, at most sites, chromium were found mainly in association with the residual phase of the soil matrix. Copper was present in the reducible, oxidisable and residual fractions, whilst zinc was found in all four sequential extracts. Manganese was strongly associated with reducible material as, in some cities, was lead. This is of concern because high lead concentrations were present in some soils (>500 mg kg⁻¹) and the potential exists for remobilisation under reducing conditions. As would be expected, extractable metal contents were generally highest in older, more heavily industrialised cities. Copper, lead and zinc showed marked (and often correlated) variations in concentrations between sites within the same city whereas manganese and, especially, iron, did not. No overall relationships were, however, found between analyte concentrations and land use, nor between analyte partitioning and land use.     

Mercury determination in solid phases from application of the modified BCR-sequential extraction procedure: a valuable tool for assessing its mobility in sediments

The present paper presents a feasibility study for the evaluation of mercury mobility in sediments by application of the modified BCR three-step sequential extraction procedure (BCR-SEP). The aim of the study was to evaluate the effect of acidification, reduction and oxidation processes on mercury mobility from sediments, once the SEP was validated with other trace metals.As extractable mercury amounts were mostly found below detection limits of the advanced mercury analyser (AMA-254) used for measuring the extracts (L.D.<0.5 ng), the use of a solid sampling atomic absorption spectrometer with a specially designed furnace for Hg atomisation was found to be an optimal technique to quantify Hg in the solid residues coming from the SEP.With this approach, mercury was found to be hardly mobile and only for one of the moderately polluted sediments (BCR CRM 320), extractable mercury (exchangeable fraction, BCR procedure step 1) has been found. An oxidation step with H(2)O(2) was required to obtain extractability up to 64% of the total content in a highly polluted lagoon sediment.     

Treatment of the solution extracted from metal contaminated soils by reverse osmosis and chemical precipitation

In this study a process for the remediation of soils contaminated by lead or copper is proposed, consisting of the operations in sequence: soil flushing, membrane treatment, acidification, and metal precipitation. Pb(II) and Cu(II) extraction from a synthetically contaminated soil using a 0.05 M EDTA aqueous solution were investigated in column. The metal removal efficiencies and the final soil metal concentration were 98.2% and 37.96 mg/g respectively for lead and 95.4% and 59.20 mg/kg for copper. The extracted solutions were concentrated through a membrane treatment to reduce the water content up to the 75% and to obtain a permeate metal concentration in compliance with the Italian Environmental Regulation. The recovery of the used EDTA from the retentate solution, with recovery yield of at least 85.4%, was also obtained through acidification. Metal precipitation from the filtered solution was then performed according two different methods, achieving metal removal yield of more than 99.4%.