Recent advances in enhancing the sensitivity of electrophoresis and electrochromatography in capillaries and microchips (2008-2010)

Capillary electrophoresis has been alive for over two decades now; yet, its sensitivity is still regarded as being inferior to that of more traditional methods of separation such as HPLC. As such, it is unsurprising that overcoming this issue still generates much scientific interest. This review continues to update this series of reviews, first published in Electrophoresis in 2007, with an update published in 2009 and covers material published through to June 2010. It includes developments in the fields of stacking, covering all methods from field-amplified sample stacking and large volume sample stacking, through to ITP, dynamic pH junction and sweeping. Attention is also given to on-line or in-line extraction methods that have been used for electrophoresis.     

Ionic liquids based on imidazole for online concentration of catecholamines in capillary electrophoresis

Potential possibilities of long‐chain ionic liquids based on imidazole (1‐dodecyl‐3‐methylimidazolium chloride and 1‐cetyl‐3‐methylimidazolium chloride) for online sample concentration techniques (field‐amplified sample stacking, head‐column field‐amplified sample stacking, and sweeping) of catecholamines were studied in both capillary zone electrophoresis and micellar electrokinetic chromatography. The use of a high‐conductivity sample matrix in sweeping was found to significantly increase the separation efficiency of analyte up to 2 × 10⁶ theoretical plates per meter and remarkably reduce limits of detection for catecholamines up to 50 ng/mL. This approach was shown to be suitable for the determination of trace amounts of catecholamines in biological fluids.     

On‐line synergistic stacking in capillary zone electrophoresis featuring field‐amplified sample stacking and micelle to cyclodextrin stacking in the determination of two alkaloids in complicated matrix samples

A novel on‐line synergistic proconcentration strategy coupling field‐amplified sample stacking and micelle to cyclodextrin stacking for cationic analytes in capillary zone electrophoresis has been proposed and applied for the separation and determination of two alkaloids, matrine, and oxymatrine in complicated matrix samples. The approach was performed by the long injection of sample in a low‐conductivity sodium dodecyl benzene sulfonate solution followed by the injection of hydroxypropyl‐β‐cyclodextrin solution in higher conductivity. The stacking mechanism of this method has been expounded and parameters affecting stacking effect have been optimized in our study. Under the optimum experimental conditions, 169‐ and 218‐fold sensitivity improvements were achieved for matrine and oxymatrine when compared with normal injection. Analytical indicators including linearity, limits of detection, and reproducibility (intra‐ and inter‐day relative standard deviations) were evaluated. Moreover, sample matrix effect was studied using compound flavescent sophora and salicylic acid powder and spiked urine samples. The developed method is an attempt for the combination of micelle to cyclodextrin stacking with other stacking methods. It could be a good alternative choice for the determination of alkaloids in a complex sample matrix.     

Extraction Properties of Modified Silica Gel for Metal Analysis by Energy Dispersive X-Ray Fluorescence

Abstract

The separation of water‐soluble vitamins by capillary zone electrophoresis was developed, in which on‐line concentration methods, namely field‐enhanced sample stacking and dynamic pH junction, were utilized to improve the detection sensitivity. The effects of some critical parameters, including pH and concentration of background electrolyte, sample matrix pH and concentration, and injection volume were examined. The effects of field‐enhanced sample stacking and dynamic pH junction on the separation resolution and concentration efficiency were compared. The limits of detection of the vitamins were from 6 to 119 ng ml^?1 (2.7×10^?8 to 53.4×10^?8 M) based on the signal‐to‐noise ratio of 3 and the relative standard deviations of migration time and peak area for each vitamin (1 µg ml^?1) were less than 3.5% using the field‐enhanced sample stacking as an on‐line concentration method. The developed method was applied to the analysis of water‐soluble vitamins in corns.     

On.column pre‐concentration of alcohol dehydrogenase in capillary electrophoresis

The analysis of alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) at low concentration using capillary electrophoresis is described. Several simple and effective ways to improve detection limits and sensitivity are investigated. These include large volume sample stacking, head column field amplified sample stacking, and sweeping. Results indicate that by using a combination of head‐column field amplified sample stacking and sweeping, fluorescently labelled alcohol dehydrogenase can be pre‐concentrated online by dissolving samples in water or other low conductivity matrices, and injecting into a high conductivity micellar buffer. The abrupt changes in conductivity cause narrowing of the analyte length and thus enhance the detection sensitivity. Combination of this approach with laser induced fluorescence detection yields a limit of detection of 5×10^–13 M. Both qualitative and quantitative aspects of this method are investigated.     

Recent advances in capillary electrophoresis and capillary electrochromatography of pollutants

An overview of major developments in capillary electrophoresis and capillary electrochromatography systems in the environmental field is presented, covering relevant publications between the second half of 1999 and early 2001. Contributions are reviewed in relation to developments in detection, sample preparation/preconcentration, precision and applications. Many interesting examples are shown and the influence of important parameters on the performance of developed methods is discussed.     

Progress in stacking techniques based on field amplification of capillary electrophoresis

Numerous strategies have been developed to mitigate the intrinsic low detection sensitivity that is a limitation of capillary electrophoresis. Among them, in-line stacking is an effective strategy to address the sensitivity challenge, and among the different stacking techniques, stacking based on field amplification is the most effective and simplest method of achieving high sensitivity without special complicated mechanisms or operations. This review introduces several stacking techniques based on field amplification. Field-amplified sample stacking, large-volume sample stacking, matrix field-amplified stacking injection (FASI), head-column FASI, matrix FASI combined with head-column FASI, FASI coupled with extraction and clean-up methods, electrokinetic supercharging, cation–anion selective exhaustive injection-sweeping-micellar electrokinetic chromatography, and newly developed techniques based on field amplification combined with other methods are included, and examples of straightforward methods for solving the sensitivity problem are provided. We also present a brief overview of the advantages, limitations, and future developments of these techniques. Graphical Abstract

?     

Rapid quantification of quinine by multi‐stacking in a portable microchip electrophoresis system

A new multi‐stacking pre‐concentration procedure based on field‐enhanced sample injection (FESI), field‐amplified sample stacking, and transient isotachophoresis was developed and implemented in a compact microchip electrophoresis (MCE) with a double T‐junction glass chip, coupled with an on‐chip capacitively coupled contactless conductivity detection (C⁴D) system. A mixture of the cationic target analyte and the terminating electrolyte (TE) from the two sample reservoirs was injected under FESI conditions within the two sample‐loading channels. At the double T‐junction, the stacked analyte zones were further concentrated under field‐amplified stacking conditions and then subsequently focused by transient‐isotachophoresis and separated along the separation channels. The proposed multi‐stacking strategy was verified under a Universal Serial Bus (USB) fluorescence microscope employing Rhodamine 6G as the model analyte. This developed approach was subsequently used to monitor the target quinine present in human plasma samples. The total analysis time for quinine was approximately 200 s with a sensitivity enhancement factor of approximately 61 when compared to the typical gated injection. The detection and quantification limits of the developed approach for quinine were 3.0 μg/mL and 10 μg/mL, respectively, with intraday and interday repeatability (%RSDs, n = 5) of 3.6 and 4.4%. Recoveries in spiked human plasma were 98.1–99.8%.     

Recent progress of online sample preconcentration techniques in microchip electrophoresis

Microchip electrophoresis (MCE) has been advanced remarkably by the applications of several separation modes and the integration with several chemical operations on a single planer substrate. MCE shows superior analytical performance, e.g., high-speed analysis, high resolution, low consumption of reagents, and so on, whereas low-concentration sensitivity is still one of the major problems. To overcome this drawback, various online sample preconcentration techniques have been developed in MCE over the past 15 years, which have successfully enhanced the detection sensitivity in MCE. This review highlights recent developments in online sample preconcentration in MCE categorized on the basis of "dynamic" and "static" methods. The dynamic techniques including field amplified stacking, ITP, sweeping, and focusing have been easily applied to MCE, which provide effective enrichments of various analytes. The static techniques such as SPE and filtration have also been combined with MCE. In the static techniques, extremely high preconcentration efficiency can be obtained, compared to the dynamic methods. This review provides comprehensive tables listing the applications and sensitivity enhancement factors of these preconcentration techniques employed in MCE.     

Comparison of hydrodynamically closed two‐dimensional capillary electrophoresis coupled with ultraviolet detection and hydrodynamically open capillary electrophoresis hyphenated with mass spectrometry in the bioanalysis of varenicline

Two capillary electrophoresis methods for monitoring renally excreted varenicline, a highly effective drug prescribed for smoking cessation, in human urine were developed and compared. A method combining capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry was proposed for the fast analysis of varenicline (analysis time up to 7 min). Here, mass spectrometry was a prerequisite for achieving high sensitivity and selectivity of the analysis suitable for the quantification of a 15 ng/mL level of varenicline in un‐pretreated urine matrices. An alternative approach, two‐dimensional (column‐coupled) capillary electrophoresis with enhanced sample load capacity and ultraviolet detection, was proposed as a low‐cost alternative to capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry. The isotachophoresis on‐line sample treatment included simple elimination of the major matrix constituents and stacking of the sample in a large volume so that threefold lower quantitation limits could be easily achieved in comparison to the capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry. On the other hand, longer analysis time (ca. 4.5‐fold) and more complex electrolyte system in the coupled zone electrophoresis step (including two additives enhancing separation selectivity, i.e. isopropanol and cyclodextrin) were prerequisites for the complete separation of varenicline from the sample matrix. Anyway, both the developed methods were validated according to the Food and Drug Administration guidelines showing favorable performance parameters, suitable for their routine biomedical use.     

Evaluation of sample injection precision in respect to sensitivity in capillary electrophoresis using various injection modes

A comparative study was conducted to assess the injection precision in capillary electrophoresis for cationic analytes (arecoline, codeine, papaverine). The precision was measured in respect to methods sensitivity in various injection modes in capillary electrophoresis: standard hydrodynamic injection (3.45 kPa for 6 s), large volume sample stacking (3.45 kPa for 40 s), and field‐amplified sample injection (10 kV for 65 s). All measurements were conducted for aqueous solutions of standards to minimize the errors linked to the sample preparation step. The methods were submitted to precision assessment at three concentration levels: at the limit of quantification, three‐fold and ten‐fold of limit of quantification. The results were compared to those from high‐performance liquid chromatography as a reference technique. The field‐amplified sample injection method was shown to provide greatest sensitivity (quantification limits down to 4 ng/mL for all three tested compounds) but the lowest precision. High‐performance liquid chromatography was established as the most reliable technique (coefficient of variation in all intraday experiments was below 1%). It was also shown that with a use of large volume sample injection technique, similar sensitivity as in high‐performance liquid chromatography can be easily reached.     

Fused silica capillaries with two segments of different internal diameters and inner surface roughnesses prepared by etching with supercritical water and used for volume coupling electrophoresis

In this work, single‐piece fused silica capillaries with two different internal diameter segments featuring different inner surface roughness were prepared by new etching technology with supercritical water and used for volume coupling electrophoresis. The concept of separation and online pre‐concentration of analytes in high conductivity matrix is based on the online large‐volume sample pre‐concentration by the combination of transient isotachophoretic stacking and sweeping of charged proteins in micellar electrokinetic chromatography using non‐ionogenic surfactant. The modified surface roughness step helped to the significant narrowing of the zones of examined analytes. The sweeping and separating steps were accomplished simultaneously by the use of phosphate buffer (pH 7) containing ethanol, non‐ionogenic surfactant Brij 35, and polyethylene glycol (PEG 10000) after sample injection. Sample solution of a large volume (maximum 3.7 μL) dissolved in physiological saline solution was injected into the wider end of capillary with inlet inner diameter from 150, 185 or 218 μm. The calibration plots were linear (R ² ∼ 0.9993) over a 0.060–1 μg/mL range for the proteins used, albumin and cytochrome c. The peak area RSDs from at least 20 independent measuremens were below 3.2%. This online pre‐concentration technique produced a more than 196‐fold increase in sensitivity, and it can be applied for detection of, e.g . the presence of albumin in urine (0.060 μg/mL).     

Highly sensitive analysis of catecholamines by counter‐flow electrokinetic supercharging in the constant voltage mode

Electrokinetic supercharging is one of the most powerful sample‐stacking methods that combines field amplified sample injection and transient ITP. In counter‐flow electrokinetic supercharging, a constant counter pressure is applied during sample injection in order to counterbalance the movement of the injected sample zone. As a result, there will be a pronounced increase in the amount of sample injected and the portion of the capillary available for electrophoresis. In this report, counter‐flow electrokinetic supercharging optimization factors such as the electric field application in the constant voltage and constant current modes, the magnitude of counter pressure, and the terminating electrolyte concentrations were investigated. The enrichments obtained with a 30 min injection of 10 nM catecholamines in 5 mM terminating electrolyte solution in the constant voltage mode applying a counter pressure of 1.3 psi were 41000‐fold for dopamine, 50 000‐fold for norepinephrine, and 32 000‐fold for epinephrine, yielding detection limits of 1.3, 1.4, and 1.2 nM, respectively, with absorbance detection at 200 nm.     

Advances in screening enzyme inhibitors by capillary electrophoresis

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) has attracted lots of attention due to its simplicity, low sample consumption, low solvent volume, high resolution, and high speed. Based on these advantages, it has been widely used in enzyme inhibitor screening. There are two main operation modes on enzyme inhibitor screening: off‐line (precapillary enzyme assays) in which process CE was used as an analytical tool; online (in‐capillary enzyme assays) which combined the sample injection, mix, reaction, separation, and detection within a single run. Additionally, diverse of new materials were introduced to immobilize enzyme, which has been coupled with CE for the study of enzyme activity and its inhibitor screening. This review gives an overview of the developments and applications for the CE‐based enzyme inhibitor screening.     

Rapid and direct determination of glyphosate,glufosinate, and aminophosphonic acid by online preconcentration CE with contactless conductivity detection

Rapid and direct online preconcentration followed by CE with capacitively coupled contactless conductivity detection (CE‐C⁴D) is evaluated as a new approach for the determination of glyphosate, glufosinate (GLUF), and aminophosphonic acid (AMPA) in drinking water. Two online preconcentration techniques, namely large volume sample stacking without polarity switching and field‐enhanced sample injection, coupled with CE‐C⁴D were successfully developed and optimized. Under optimized conditions, LODs in the range of 0.01–0.1 μM (1.7–11.1 μg/L) and sensitivity enhancements of 48‐ to 53‐fold were achieved with the large volume sample stacking‐CE‐C⁴D method. By performing the field‐enhanced sample injection‐CE‐C⁴D procedure, excellent LODs down to 0.0005–0.02 μM (0.1–2.2 μg/L) as well as sensitivity enhancements of up to 245‐ to 1002‐fold were obtained. Both techniques showed satisfactory reproducibility with RSDs of peak height of better than 10%. The newly established approaches were successfully applied to the analysis of glyphosate, glufosinate, and aminophosphonic acid in spiked tap drinking water.     

Sample stacking of cationic and anionic analytes in capillary electrophoresis

The behavior of charged species along concentration boundaries in capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) that was first described in detail by Everaerts et al. in 1979 assured the possibility of concentrating charged solutes inside the capillary. The concentration effect is based on the sudden change in analyte electrophoretic velocity brought about by the difference in the magnitude of the electric field. Furthermore, this on-line method could be the needed solution to the problem of low concentration sensitivity in CZE. Sample stacking, which is now its well known name, has then found valuable use in applying CZE in many fields, especially after the in-depth studies performed in the early 90s by Chien and Burgi. This article reviews the theory and methodological developments of sample stacking developed for charged analytes in CZE and also in electrokinetic chromatography. A table conveying the reported applications especially in the biomedical and environmental fields is given. On top of this, other on-line concentration methods for charged species, namely, sample self-stacking, acetonitrile stacking, sweeping, cation selective exhaustive injection-sweeping, and use of a pH junction, are briefly discussed.     

Quality evaluation of six bioactive constituents in goji berry based on capillary electrophoresis field amplified sample stacking

Goji berry, fruits of the plant Lycium barbarum L., has long been used as traditional medicine and functional food in China. In this work, a simple and easy‐operation on‐line concentration capillary electrophoresis (CE) for detection flavonoids in goji berry was developed by coupling of field amplified sample stacking (FASS) with an electroosmotic (EOF) pump driving water removal process. Due to the EOF pump and electrokinetic injection showing different influence on the concentration, the analytes injection condition should be systemically studied. Thereafter, the verification of the analytes injection conditions was achieved using response surface experimental design. Under the optimum conditions, 86–271 folds sensitivity enhancement upon normal capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE, 50 mbar × 5 s) were achieved for six flavonoids, and the detection limits ranged from 0.35 to 1.82 ng/mL; the LOQ ranged from 1.20 to 6.01 ng/mL. Eventually, the proposed method was applied to detect flavonoids in 30 goji berry samples from different habitats of China; and the results indicated that the flavonoids were rich in the eluent of 30–60% methanol, which provided a reference for extraction of goji berry flavonoids.     

On-line preconcentration of perfluorooctanoic acid and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid by nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis

Separation of major environmental pollutants as perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) by capillary electrophoresis is reported for the first time. It is not possible to resolve the solutes in an aqueous media. However, the use of methanol and acetonitrile as the background electrolyte (BGE) solvents allowed their rapid separation in an uncoated capillary. A major effort was put into BGE optimization in respect to both separation efficiency and detection for further on‐line preconcentration. 5 mmol.L^?1 naphthalene‐1‐sulfonic acid and 10 mmol.L^?1 triethylamine dissolved in ACN/MeOH (50:50 v/v) provided best separation and detection conditions. Next, the large‐volume sample stacking and the field‐amplified sample injection were applied and compared. Large‐volume sample stacking improved limits of detection (LODs) with regard to the standard injection by 69 times for PFOA and 143 times for PFOS with LODs of 280 and 230 nmol.L^?1, respectively. Field‐amplified sample injection improved LODs 624 times for PFOAand 806 times for PFOS with LODs 31 and 40 nmol.L^?1, respectively. Both preconcentration methods showed repeatabilities of migration times less than 1.2% RSD intraday and 6.6% RSD interday. The method was applied on PFOA and PFOS analysis in a sample of river water treated with solid‐phase extraction, which further improved LOD toward 5.6 × 10^?10 mol.L^?1 for PFOS and 6.4 × 10^?10 mol.L^?1 for PFOA and allows the method to be used for river water contamination screening or decomposition studies.     

Recent advances in on-line concentration and separation of amino acids using capillary electrophoresis

This article highlights recent methodological developments in the on-line concentration and separation of amino acids and their enantiomers using capillary electrophoresis. Sections are dedicated to recent contributions to on-line concentration strategies such as field-amplified sample stacking, large-volume sample stacking, dynamic pH junction, transient isotachophoresis, sweeping, and the combination of two methods. The main applications, advantages, and limitations of these procedures in the biological, food, and pharmaceutical fields are addressed. Comprehensive tables listing on-line techniques for the concentration and separation of amino acids and their enantiomers, categorized by the stacking strategies used, background electrolytes, sample matrix, limit of detection, and enhancement factor, are provided.

Open microfluidic gel electrophoresis: Rapid and low cost separation and analysis of DNA at the nanoliter scale

Gel electrophoresis is one of the most applied and standardized tools for separation and analysis of macromolecules and their fragments in academic research and in industry. In this work we present a novel approach for conducting on‐demand electrophoretic separations of DNA molecules in open microfluidic (OM) systems on planar polymer substrates. The approach combines advantages of slab gel, capillary‐ and chip‐based methods offering low consumable costs (<0.1$) circumventing cost‐intensive microfluidic chip fabrication, short process times (5 min per analysis) and high sensitivity (4 ng/μL dsDNA) combined with reasonable resolution (17 bases). The open microfluidic separation system comprises two opposing reservoirs of 2–4 μL in volume, a semi‐contact written gel line acting as separation channel interconnecting the reservoirs and sample injected into the line via non‐contact droplet dispensing and thus enabling the precise control of the injection plug and sample concentration. Evaporation is prevented by covering aqueous structures with PCR‐grade mineral oil while maintaining surface temperature at 15°C. The liquid gel line exhibits a semi‐circular cross section of adaptable width (∼200–600 μm) and height (∼30–80 μm) as well as a typical length of 15–55 mm. Layout of such liquid structures is adaptable on‐demand not requiring time consuming and repetitive fabrication steps. The approach was successfully demonstrated by the separation of a standard label‐free DNA ladder (100–1000 bp) at 100 V/cm via in‐line staining and laser induced fluorescent end‐point detection using an automated prototype.