Comparison of original and modified BCR sequential extraction procedures for the fractionation of copper, iron, lead, manganese and zinc in soils and sediments

This article describes a detailed comparison between the original BCR sequential extraction procedure, step 2 of which involves treatment with 0.1 mol l⁻¹ hydroxylammonium chloride at pH 2, and the revised BCR procedure (step 2: 0.5 mol l⁻¹ hydroxylammonium chloride at pH 1.5). An intermediate protocol was also evaluated in which 0.5 mol l⁻¹ hydroxylammonium chloride at pH 2 was used. The procedures were applied to five soil and sediment substrates: a sewage sludge-amended soil, two different industrially contaminated soils, a river sediment and an inter-tidal sediment. Extractable iron and manganese concentrations were measured to assess the effects of the procedural modifications on dissolution of the reducible matrix components. Trace elements copper, lead and zinc were also determined. Statistical analysis (two-tailed t-tests at 95% confidence interval) indicated that recovery of iron in step 2 was not markedly enhanced when the intermediate protocol was used. However, significantly greater amounts were isolated with the revised BCR scheme than with the original procedure. Copper behaved similarly to iron. Lead recoveries were increased by use of both modified protocols, with the greatest effect occurring for the revised BCR extraction. In contrast, manganese and zinc extraction did not vary markedly between procedures. The work indicates that the revised BCR sequential extraction provides better attack on the iron-based components of the reducible matrix for a wide range of soils and sediments.     

Sono-extraction as a pretreatment approach for the screening evaluation of element mobility of sediment samples

Application of economically important and time saving pretreatment for the screening element mobility evaluation of contaminated sediments is presented. Ultrasonically-assisted single-step extraction (USAE) was carried out by EDTA solution. The extraction time of USAE was optimized and obtained results were compared with results estimated by conventional (EDTA extraction) and by sequential extraction (modified BCR protocol). The original three step BCR protocol was modified by addition of the first step (water leaching) and the fifth step, total digestion of sediment residue (acid mixture with HF). Zn, Cu and Pb have been determined in extracts by ICP-OES. Good conformity of the ultrasonically-extracted element contents and sum of contents, extracted during first three steps (water-soluble, acid-extractable, reducible — i.e., the most mobile fractions) of sequential extraction, was found. The sono-extraction reduced operating time of the first three steps of sequential extraction from 48 h to 15 min. Thus, USAE can serve as a rapid screening assessment of the mobile and potentially mobile element portions in sediments and other similar solid state environmental media. Analytical quality control was realized by comparison of the sums of element contents obtained at individual (five) extraction steps. Total element contents were also determined by an independent method (XRF).     

Development of a standardized sequential extraction protocol for simultaneous extraction of multiple actinide elements

Sequential extraction is a useful technique for assessing the potential to leach actinides from soils; however, current literature lacks uniformity in experimental details, making direct comparison of results impossible. This work continued development toward a standardized five-step sequential extraction protocol by analyzing extraction behaviors of ²³²Th, ²³⁸U, ^239,240Pu and ²⁴¹Am from lake and ocean sediment reference materials. Results produced a standardized procedure after creating more defined reaction conditions to improve method repeatability. A NaOH fusion procedure is recommended following sequential leaching for the complete dissolution of insoluble species.     

Evaluation of As and Sb Mobility in Contaminated Stream Sediments

Single and sequential extraction procedures were applied to four sediment samples collected from an industrially polluted region of Eastern Slovakia. A sequential extraction procedure (SEP) for sediments recommended by the IRMM (Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements) – was applied and used as a reference extraction method. Single-step extraction (for soils) with 0.05 mol L⁻¹ ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) was slightly modified for this study of sediments. The removal ability of “Na₂EDTA extraction” was compared with the SEP recommended by the IRMM. After optimisation, the elements’ contents extracted into Na₂EDTA were in good agreement with the sum of the 1^st, 2^nd, 3^rd and 4^th step of SEP for As and Sb. Therefore Na₂EDTA extraction can serve as a supplementary test to the SEP recommended by the IRMM (under locally tested conditions). Alternatively, optimised extraction of sediments in chelating agents could be applied as an economically interesting and time-saving supplementary test to routinely used SEPs. This paper describes the sample preparation and the analytical results for each extraction step and compares the results with those of total element analyses (performed by an independent method) for As and Sb.     

Speciation of Heavy Metals in Soils and Sediments. An Account of the Improvement and Harmonization of Extraction Techniques Undertaken Under the Auspices of the BCR of the Commission of the European Communities

Abstract

An account is presented of a series of investigations and collaborative studies, initiated by BCR, on current methods of metal speciation by extraction of soils and sediments with chemical reagents. It was established by extensive consultation with European experts that the diverse procedures used could be harmonized into agreed methods. These methods, including both single extractant and sequential extraction procedures were subjected to collaborative, interlaboratory trials and the results, presented briefly here, showed that it was both possible and desirable that reference soils and sediments, characterised by certified values for extractable contents, be prepared. As a consequence of these studies two soils have been prepared and will shortly be the subject of interlaboratory analysis with a view to certification of their EDTA and acetic acid extractable contents of some heavy metals. Following this workshop a feasibility study of the agreed sequential extraction procedure will, it is believed, shortly lead to certification of sediments for contents extractable by a defined sequential extraction procedure.     

Heavy metal mobility assessment in sediments based on a kinetic approach of the EDTA extraction: search for optimal experimental conditions

The feasibility of kinetic extraction studies using EDTA as the complexing agent is evaluated for the extraction of Cd²⁺, Cu²⁺, Pb²⁺ and Fe³⁺ from contaminated sediments. In the first approach, the study was carried out in batch equilibrium conditions in order to determine optimal ranges for operational parameters, such as pH, concentration of EDTA and the ratio of mass of sediment to volume of EDTA, m/V. It has been concluded that the quantities of metal extracted by EDTA do not depend on the m/V ratio and that an EDTA concentration of 0.05 M ensures an excess of extractant. The kinetic studies were performed with the optimised experimental conditions. Two extraction protocols were used and compared in terms of experimental performance. The main difference between these two protocols is the use, in protocol I of a single sediment/EDTA mixture in which aliquots are collected at different times, whereas in protocol II several mixtures are stirred, each one for a different time. It has been shown that results of EDTA extractions can be influenced by the protocol used and we recommend protocol II for kinetic studies.     

Development of a slurry-extraction procedure for direct determination of cobalt by electrothermal atomic absorption spectrometry in complex environmental samples

A new procedure for Co determination in a complex matrix (coal fly ash) by slurry extraction-electrothermal atomic absorption spectrometry (ETAAS) is presented. Fractional experimental designs were applied to find the most important variables affecting Co extraction. Two liquid media (HCl + HNO₃ and HF) and three agitation modes (ultrasonic probe, ultrasonic bath and manual shaking) were assayed. HF revealed as the most suitable medium for Co extraction, being its concentration and time of contact the most significant variables. Quantitative extraction was obtained after their optimisation (16%, v/v HF; 5 min), with good accuracy (coal fly ash SRM 1633a and SRM 1633b) and precision (R.S.D. < 11.5%). The limit of detection of the method was 0.02 μg g⁻¹ (100 mg mL⁻¹ slurry), and the characteristic mass was 15 ± 1 pg. The ‘slurry-extraction procedure’ established is simple, fast, cheap and was also validated for soil and sediment analysis. As far as we know, a slurry-extraction procedure has not yet been applied to quantify cobalt by ETAAS in such matrices. Moreover, nine coal fly ashes, 12 sediments and 18 soils were analysed by the proposed method and also by a direct slurry sampling-ETAAS procedure in order to compare their performance. In general, the HF-extraction slurry procedure revealed superior.     

Radioactive impact of a bauxite beneficiation plant in the Itea Gulf (Gulf of Corinth, Greece)

Activity concentration measurements of natural radionuclides performed by γ-ray spectrometry and ICP-MS in sediment samples from the Gulf of Itea and in surface soil samples collected from the surrounding area of a bauxite beneficiation plant, showed that (1) the breaker zone of the Itea Gulf, in the vicinity of the bauxite beneficiation plant, is contaminated with ²³⁸U, ²³²Th and ²²⁶Ra, (2) the activities in sediment samples from the rest of the Gulf were at the background level, and (3) enhanced activities of the ²³⁸U, ²³²Th and ²²⁶Ra were found in a number of soil samples due to bauxite dust deposition from the nearby beneficiation plant. The application of the optimized BCR sequential extraction procedure on the surface sediment samples showed that the U and Th were strongly bound to the sediments.     

Geochemical partitioning of actinides using sequential chemical extractions: Comparison to stable elements

We have developed a sequential extraction technique for determining the geochemical partitioning of Am, Pu, and U in soils and sediments. Stable element analyses were combined with radiometric measurements to determine the most probable geochemical host phases of these actinides in reference sediment IAEA-135.²⁴¹ Am results indicate an association with carbonate minerals and organic matter. The extraction profile of²³⁸U was similar to that of refractory elements Al, Ti, and K.^239/240Pu data suggest a fractionation of Pu into Fe-bearing phases of varying solubility. The reproducibility of the method was quite good (replicates agreed to within 10% at a 95% confidence level).     

Multiresidue method for the determination of 32 human and veterinary pharmaceuticals in soil and sediment by pressurized-liquid extraction and LC-MS/MS

An analytical chemical method has been developed for the simultaneous determination of 32 different pharmaceuticals in soils and sediments. The pharmaceuticals cover a varity of different compound groups. Soil samples were extracted with different solvents with the help of pressurized-liquid extraction (PLE) followed by clean-up using a solid-phase extraction (SPE) procedure. The purified extracts were analyzed by LC-MS/MS. The extraction method was evaluated by testing the following variables: extraction solvents, solvent pH, and temperature. Applying 20 g of soil/sediment and extracting with a mixture of methanol with aqueous ammonia solution (0.1 mol L^?1) at 80?°C for 5 min in five cycles provided satisfactory recoveries between 66 and 114% with SD of between 1 and 14%. For preconcentration and purification tandem MAX-HLB cartridges were used. The volume and composition was optimized and the highest recoveries were obtained with a combination of methanol—aqueous ammonia solution. The limits of quantification (LOQs) were between 0.2 and 2 ng g^?1 and linearity higher than 0.98 for the majority of the selected pharmaceuticals. The method was successfully applied to soil samples collected from the Jerez de la Frontera agricultural region, irrigated with treated wastewater, and to sediment samples from the River Guadalete. The detection of nine pharmaceuticals including stimulants, antirheumatics, analgesics, anti-inflammatories, tranquilizers, and veterinary medicines at ng g^?1 concentration levels was achieved.     

Chromium available fractions in arousa sediments using a modified microwave BCR protocol based on microwave assisted extraction

In a research of chromium availability, the three-stage sequential extraction procedure, proposed by European Community Bureau of Reference (BCR), has been applied for the metal fractionation in marine sediment samples. The procedure has been modified, evaluating the effect of microwave energy to perform the sequential method. Results achieved a substantial reduction in time in comparison to the traditional shaking technique. The time of the first and the second extractions were reduced to 30 s in both steps using microwave heating and working at 66 W of power. To the third extraction, higher power was necessary so it was chosen to work at 198 W. In the last step investigated, time was reduced to 1 min, being a great improvement respect to the conventional BCR sequential extraction protocol.Chromium determinations in these extracts were carried out by Electrothermal Atomic Absorption Spectrometry (ETAAS). The developed method was applied for chromium determination in marine sediment samples from Ria de Arousa (Galicia, NW of Spain). The values obtained by our laboratory ranged from 0.10 to 1.02 μg g⁻¹ for soluble and reducible fractions, and from 5.5 to 60.0 μg g⁻¹ for the oxidisable fraction. The higher concentrations obtained were the chromium associated with the organic fraction of the marine sediments.     

Elemental fractionation of Si, Al, Ti, Fe, Ca, Mn, P, and Ba in five marine sedimentary reference materials: results from sequential extractions

We report on the elemental results from sequential extractions of BCSS-1 (marine sediment), MESS-1 (estuarine sediment), MAG-1 (marine mud), SCo-1 (Cody shale), and NIST-1c (argillaceous limestone) to encourage future comparisons of sequential extraction results within the marine geochemical and paleoceanographic communities. We measured Si, Al, Ti, Fe, Mn, Ca, P, and Ba in sequential de-ionized water (loosely-bound), MgCl₂ (exchangeable), acetic acid (carbonate), hydroxylammonium hydrochloride (oxide), H₂O₂ (organic), Na₂CO₃ (opal), and residual (lithogenic) leaches. The protocol and selected elements were tailored to be most relevant to paleoceanographic geochemical studies instead of to environmental studies. Our results show that the sequential extraction procedure faithfully yields elemental distributions that are consistent with individual SRM lithologies. Our results also show that the procedure is typically reproducible within approximately 15%. However, in almost all cases, the procedure suffers from a systematic under-recovery of material when compared with the certified, bulk chemical analysis, and the under-recovery appears to be related to the lithology of the SRM. Similar under-recovery appears to be typical of sequential extraction procedures as reported by other previous studies. While this is problematic in assessing closure, it does not diminish the potential of inter-lab comparisons and first-order accuracy comparisons. We found that the elemental totals for the sequential extractions of MAG-1 compared best with the certified, bulk totals, and we recommend using this SRM to facilitate future accuracy assessments and inter-lab comparisons.     

A sequential extraction scheme to ascertain the role of organic matter in radionuclide retention in Mediterranean soils

A sequential extraction scheme which indicates the role of organic matter in radionuclide retention was applied to two types of Mediterranean soil (sandy-loam and sandy), with low percentages of organic matter and with different contents of clay mineral, which had been previously contaminated with a radioactive aerosol, containing⁸⁵Sr,¹³⁴Cs and^110mAg. Different distributions were obtained for the three radionuclides, depending on the type of soil.⁸⁵Sr was the most available radionuclide for both types of soil, showing significant binding to organic matter in sandy-loam soil.¹³⁴Cs was the most retained radionuclide: for low-organic-matter soils, its availability seemed to depend on clay mineral content.^110mAg associated with available organic sites showed a positive correlation with organic matter content.     

Two Approaches for Sequential Extraction of Radionuclides in Soils: Batch and Column Methods

Abstract

A three-step sequential extraction protocol designed by Community Bureau of Reference (BCR) is applied to two types of soil (sandy and sandy-loam) which had been previously contaminated with a radionuclide aerosol containing ¹³⁴Cs, ⁸⁵Sr and ^110mAg. This scheme is applied using both batch and column methods. The radionuclide distribution obtained with this scheme depends both on the method and on soil type. Compared with the batch method, column extraction is an inadvisable method. Kinetic aspects seem to be important, especially in the first and third fractions. The radionuclide distribution shows that radiostrontium has high mobility, radiocaesium is highly retained by clay minerals whereas Fe/Mn oxides and organic matter have an important role in radiosilver retention.     

The226Ra/Ba-ratio as indicator for phosphogypsum contributions to226Ra levels in sediments

Phosphogypsum discharges by phosphate-ore processing industries pollute sediments of the Rotterdam harbour area with²²⁶Ra. Direct measurement of this radionuclide in sediments does not provide a reliable indication of the elevation of the levels, since²²⁶Ra levels in sediments depend on the particle size. To eliminate the size effect, the²²⁶Ra/Ba ratio in sediments was tested as a possible indicator for the²²⁶Ra in the discharges. The results indicate almost a doubling of the²²⁶Ra levels in sediment samples due to phosphogypsum discharges. The contribution of phosphogypsum to the sediment mass was calculated in the order of a few percent equivalent.     

A comparison of an optimised sequential extraction procedure and dilute acid leaching of elements in anoxic sediments, including the effects of oxidation on sediment metal partitioning

The effect of oxidation of anoxic sediment upon the extraction of 13 elements (Cd, Sn, Sb, Pb, Al, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, As) using the optimised Community Bureau of Reference of the European Commission (BCR) sequential extraction procedure and a dilute acid partial extraction procedure (4 h, 1 mol L⁻¹ HCl) was investigated. Elements commonly associated with the sulfidic phase, Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn and Fe exhibited the most significant changes under the BCR sequential extraction procedure. Cd, Cu, Zn, and to a lesser extent Pb, were redistributed into the weak acid extractable fraction upon oxidation of the anoxic sediment and Fe was redistributed into the reducible fraction as expected, but an increase was also observed in the residual Fe. For the HCl partial extraction, sediments with moderate acid volatile sulfide (AVS) levels (1-100 μmol g⁻¹) showed no significant difference in element partitioning following oxidation, whilst sediments containing high AVS levels (>100 μmol g⁻¹) were significantly different with elevated concentrations of Cu and Sn noted in the partial extract following oxidation of the sediment. Comparison of the labile metals released using the BCR sequential extraction procedure (ΣSteps 1-3) to labile metals extracted using the dilute HCl partial extraction showed that no method was consistently more aggressive than the other, with the HCl partial extraction extracting more Sn and Sb from the anoxic sediment than the BCR procedure, whilst the BCR procedure extracted more Cr, Co, Cu and As than the HCl extraction.     

Determination of Al, Cu, Fe, Mn, Pb and Zn in certified reference materials using the optimized BCR sequential extraction procedure

Sequential extraction procedures are widely used to characterize the fractionation of metal species in solid media. With the variety of different sequential procedures used in environmental and geochemical exploration studies, it is difficult to compare results between studies. Thus, harmonization and standardization are required to provide greater inter-study comparability for fraction-specific metals. In this study, the optimized BCR three-step sequential extraction procedure is applied to five certified reference materials (SRM 2710, SRM 2711, CRM 483, CRM 601 and CW 7). Four fractions are reported, acid extractable, reducible, oxidizable, and residual for Al, Cu, Fe, Mn, Pb and Zn. The objectives of this study were to characterize experimental precision and/or accuracy and to establish baseline data of fraction-specific element concentrations for future studies applying the optimized BCR three-step extraction procedure. The optimized procedure was found to be precise (typically <5%) for all metals in all fractions. Accuracy was acceptable (typically ±15% relative to published indicative values for Cu, Pb and Zn for CRM 483 and CRM 601) for all individual fractions. Detailed fraction-specific concentration data are presented, based on five replicates, for the first time using the optimized procedure for Al, Fe and Mn in CRM 483 and CRM 601, and for Al, Cu, Fe, Mn, Pb and Zn in SRM 2710, SRM 2711 and CW 7.     

Should acid ammonium oxalate replace hydroxylammonium chloride in step 2 of the revised BCR sequential extraction protocol for soil and sediment?

The revised, four-step BCR sequential extraction for soil or sediment has been compared with an alternative procedure in which 0.2 mol l⁻¹ ammonium oxalate (pH 3) replaced 0.5 mol l⁻¹ hydroxylammonium chloride (pH 1.5) in step 2, the reducible step. A variety of substrates were studied: BCR CRM601, a sewage sludge amended soil, two industrial soils, and a steel manufacturing by-product (basic oxygen furnace filter cake). Greater amounts of iron were recovered in step 2 when acid ammonium oxalate was used, for all substrates. Similar trends were observed for copper. Manganese and zinc were not strongly affected by the procedural modification, except for zinc in the two industrial soils, where oxalate extraction proved more efficient than use of hydroxylammonium chloride. A large proportion of the calcium and lead isolated in step 2 of the BCR procedure was not released until step 3 when the alternative procedure with oxalate in step 2 was used. This is probably due to rapid precipitation of analyte oxalates from solution. Thus, whilst oxalate offers superior dissolution of iron-containing matrix components, it should not be used if calcium or lead concentrations are to be measured. Selection of the most appropriated sequential extraction protocol for use in a particular study must always be carried out on the basis of “fitness for purpose” criteria. However, the revised BCR protocol, involving use of 0.5 mol l⁻¹ NH₂OH·HCl in the reducible step, appears to be more generally applicable than procedures involving acid ammonium oxalate.     

Dynamic fractionation of trace metals in soil and sediment samples using rotating coiled column extraction and sequential injection microcolumn extraction: A comparative study

Dynamic fractionation has been recognized as an appealing alternative to conventional equilibrium-based sequential extraction procedures (SEPs) for partitioning of trace elements (TE) in environmental solid samples. This paper reports the first attempt for harmonization of flow-through dynamic fractionation using two novel methods, the so-called sequential injection microcolumn (SIMC) extraction and rotating coiled column (RCC) extraction. In SIMC extraction, a column packed with the solid sample is clustered in a sequential injection system, while in RCC, the particulate matter is retained under the action of centrifugal forces. In both methods, the leachants are continuously pumped through the solid substrates by the use of either peristaltic or syringe pumps.A five-step SEP was selected for partitioning of Cu, Pb and Zn in water soluble/exchangeable, acid-soluble, easily reducible, easily oxidizable and moderately reducible fractions from 0.2 to 0.5 g samples at an extractant flow rate of 1.0 mL min⁻¹ prior to leachate analysis by inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrometry.Similarities and discrepancies between both dynamic approaches were ascertained by fractionation of TE in certified reference materials, namely, SRM 2711 Montana Soil and GBW 07311 sediment, and two real soil samples as well. Notwithstanding the different extraction conditions set by both methods, similar trends of metal distribution were in generally found. The most critical parameters for reliable assessment of mobilisable pools of TE in worse-case scenarios are the size-distribution of sample particles, the density of particles, the content of organic matter and the concentration of major elements. For reference materials and a soil rich in organic matter, the extraction in RCC results in slightly higher recoveries of environmentally relevant fractions of TE, whereas SIMC leaching is more effective for calcareous soils.     

Host phase of239,240Pu and241Am in deep-sea sediment

Host phases of fallout^239,240Pu and²⁴¹Am were studied in the surface sediments obtained in 1994 from abyssal basins of relatively small area of the western North Pacific. An analytical procedure involving sequential chemical extraction was employed for partitioning the host phases of the nuclides in sediment into five fractions: (1) exchangeable (2) bound to carbonate, (3) bound to hydrous Fe-Mn oxides, (4) bound to organic matter and (5) residual. Decrease of total^239,240Pu concentration with decreasing association of^239,240Pu with organic matter, high²⁴¹Am/^239,240Pu activity ratio in carbonate phase and somewhat high proportion of oxidized^239,240Pu in leachable phases suggest a possibility of post-depositional diagenetic remobilization of Pu from sediment to water column.