Theoretical (DFT) insights into the mechanism of copper-catalyzed cyclopropanation reactions. Implications for enantioselective catalysis

The mechanism of the copper(I)-catalyzed cyclopropanation reaction has been extensively investigated for a medium-size reaction model by means of B3LYP/6-31G(d) calculations. The starting ethylene complex of the N,N'-dimethylmalonaldiimine--copper (I) catalyst undergoes a ligand exchange with methyl diazoacetate to yield a reaction intermediate, which subsequently undergoes nitrogen extrusion to generate a copper--carbene complex. The cyclopropanation step takes place through a direct carbene insertion of the metal--carbene species to yield a catalyst--product complex, which can finally regenerate the starting complex. The stereochemical predictions of a more realistic model (by considering a chiral bis(oxazoline)--copper (I) catalyst) have been rationalized in terms of steric repulsions, showing good agreement with experimental data.     

Quantitative Description of Structural Effects on the Stability of Gold(I) Carbenes

The gas‐phase bond‐dissociation energies of a SO₂–imidazolylidene leaving group of three gold(I) benzyl imidazolium sulfone complexes are reported (E₀=46.6±1.7, 49.6±1.7, and 48.9±2.1 kcal mol^?1). Although these energies are similar to each other, they are reproducibly distinguishable. The energy‐resolved collision‐induced dissociation experiments of the three [L]–gold(I) (L=ligand) carbene precursor complexes were performed by using a modified tandem mass spectrometer. The measurements quantitatively describe the structural and electronic effects a p‐methoxy substituent on the benzyl fragment, and trans [NHC] and [P] gold ligands, have towards gold carbene formation. Evidence for the formation of the electrophilic gold carbene in solution was obtained through the stoichiometric and catalytic cyclopropanation of olefins under thermal conditions. The observed cyclopropane yields are dependent on the rate of gold carbene formation, which in turn is influenced by the ligand and substituent. The donation of electron density to the carbene carbon by the p‐methoxy benzyl substituent and [NHC] ligand stabilizes the gold carbene intermediate and lowers the dissociation barrier. Through the careful comparison of gas‐phase and solution chemistry, the results suggest that even gas‐phase leaving‐group bond‐dissociation energy differences of 2–3 kcal mol^?1 enormously affect the rate of gold carbene formation in solution, especially when there are competing reactions. The thermal decay of the gold carbene precursor complex was observed to follow first‐order kinetics, whereas cyclopropanation was found to follow pseudo‐first‐order kinetics. Density‐functional‐theory calculations at the M06‐L and BP86‐D3 levels of theory were used to confirm the observed gas‐phase reactivity and model the measured bond‐dissociation energies.     

Reactivity and selectivity of 1,3-diyn-6-enes in electrophilic transition metal-catalyzed reactions

[Structure: see text] 1,3-diyne is an excellent source of alkynyl metal carbene species upon activation with an electrophilic metal catalyst. The products from this bond reorganization process suggest that the metal carbene species, generated from the preferential participation of an acetate over an alkene in the first step, undergo an efficient metallotropic [1,3]-shift followed by termination via cyclopropanation.     

The synthesis of S-(+)-2,2-dimethylcyclopropane carboxylic acid: a precursor for cilastatin

S-(+)-2,2-Dimethylcyclopropane carboxylic acid, a precursor for cilastatin, was prepared from 2-methylpropene and chiral iron carbene in three steps. Asymmetric cyclopropanation reaction of 2-methylpropene with iron carbene complex having chirality at the carbene ligand, followed by exhaustive ozonolysis, produced S-(+)-2,2-dimethylcyclopropanecarboxylic acid of up to 92% ee. The absolute configuration of complexed chiral cyclopropane (−)-8 was determined by X-ray crystallographic analysis.     

Theoretical insights into the role of a counterion in copper-catalyzed enantioselective cyclopropanation reactions

The effect of a coordinating counteranion on the mechanism of Cu(I)-catalyzed cyclopropanation has been investigated extensively for a medium-sized reaction model by means of theoretical calculations at the B3LYP/6-31G(d) level. The main mechanistic features are similar to those found for the cationic (without a counteranion) mechanism, the rate-limiting step being nitrogen extrusion from a catalyst-diazoester complex to generate a copper-carbene intermediate. The cyclopropanation step takes place through a direct carbene insertion of the metal-carbene species to yield a catalyst-product complex, which can finally regenerate the starting complex. However, the presence of the counteranion has a noticeable influence on the calculated geometries of all the intermediates and transition structures. Furthermore, the existence of a preequilibrium with a dimeric form of the catalyst, together with a higher activation barrier in the insertion step, explains the lower yield of cyclopropane products observed experimentally in the presence of chloride counterion. The stereochemical predictions of a more realistic model (made by considering a chiral bis(oxazoline)-copper(i) catalyst) have been rationalized in terms of the lack of significant steric repulsions, and the model shows good agreement with the low enantioselectivities observed experimentally for these kinds of catalytic systems.     

Deactivation of Ru-benzylidene Grubbs catalysts active in olefin metathesis

In this work, we explore the reactivity induced by coordination of a CO molecule trans to the Ru-benzylidene bond of a prototype Ru-olefin metathesis catalyst bearing a N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligand. DFT calculations indicate that CO binding to the Ru center promotes a cascade of reactions with very low-energy barriers that lead to the final crystallographically characterized product, in which the original benzylidene group has attacked the proximal aromatic ring of the ligand leading to a cycloheptatriene ring through a Buchner ring expansion. In conclusion, the overall mechanism is best described as a carbene insertion into a C–C bond of the aromatic N-substituent of the NHC ligand, forming a cyclopropane ring. This cyclopropanation step is followed by a Buchner ring expansion reaction, leading to the experimentally observed product presenting a cycloheptatriene ring.     

Redox noninnocence of carbene ligands: carbene radicals in (catalytic) C-C bond formation

In this Forum contribution, we highlight the radical-type reactivities of one-electron-reduced Fischer-type carbenes. Carbene complexes of group 6 transition metals (Cr, Mo, and W) can be relatively easily reduced by an external reducing agent, leading to one-electron reduction of the carbene ligand moiety. This leads to the formation of "carbene-radical" ligands, showing typical radical-type reactivities. Fischer-type carbene ligands are thus clearly redox-active and can behave as so-called "redox noninnocent ligands". The "redox noninnocence" of Fischer-type carbene ligands is most clearly illustrated at group 9 transition metals in the oxidation state II+ (Co(II), Rh(II), and Ir(II)). In such carbene complexes, the metal effectively reduces the carbene ligand by one electron in an intramolecular redox process. As a result, the thus formed "carbene radicals" undergo a variety of radical-type C-C and C-H bond formations. The redox noninnocence of Fischer-type carbene ligands is not just a chemical curiosity but, in fact, plays an essential role in catalytic cyclopropanation reactions by cobalt(II) porphyrins. This has led to the successful development of new chiral cobalt(II) porphyrins as highly effective catalysts for asymmetric cyclopropanation with unprecedented reactivity and stereocontrol. The redox noninnocence of the carbene intermediates results in the formation of carbene-radical ligands with nucleophilic character, which explains their effectiveness in the cyclopropanation of electron-deficient olefins and their reduced tendency to mediate carbene dimerization. To the best of our knowledge, this represents the first example in which the redox noninnocence of a reacting ligand plays a key role in a catalytic organometallic reaction. This Forum contribution ends with an outlook on further potential applications of one-electron-activated Fischer-type carbenes in new catalytic reactions.     

Non-metathesis reactions of ruthenium carbene catalysts and their application to the synthesis of nitrogen-containing heterocycles

Non-metathesis reactions of ruthenium carbene catalysts, such as olefin isomerization, hydrogenation, radical reaction, activation of silane, cyclopropanation, epimerization cocyclopropane, [3 + 2] cycloaddition, and cycloisomerization, are summarized. The utility of these reactions was demonstrated by the synthesis of indole using olefin isomerization and subsequent ring-closing metathesis, the synthesis of indoline using cycloisomerization, and the synthesis of the putative structure of fistulosin using cycloisomerization as a key step.     

Gas‐Phase Energetics of Reductive Elimination from a Palladium(II) N‐Heterocyclic Carbene Complex

Energy‐resolved collision‐induced dissociation experiments using tandem mass spectrometry are reported for an phenylpalladium N‐heterocyclic carbene (NHC) complex. Reductive elimination of an NHC ligand as a phenylimidazolium ion involves a barrier of 30.9(14) kcal mol^?1, whereas competitive ligand dissociation requires 47.1(17) kcal mol^?1. The resulting three‐coordinate palladium complex readily undergoes reductive C? C coupling to give the phenylimidazolium π complex, for which the binding energy was determined to be 38.9(10) kcal mol^?1. Density functional calculations at the M06‐L//BP86/TZP level of theory are in very good agreement with experiment. In combination with RRKM modeling, these results suggest that the rate‐determining step for the direct reductive elimination process switches from the C? C coupling step to the fragmentation of the resulting σ complex at low activation energy.     

Gas-phase synthesis and reactivity of a gold carbene complex

Electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry of a phosphonium ylid complex of gold produces an ion whose mass and gas-phase chemical reactivity indicate that it is a gold benzylidene complex. The complex, with a supporting NHC ligand, corresponds to a type of reactive intermediates which have been presumed to act in gold-catalyzed cyclopropanation reactions, but which have not been observed to date in solution or gas-phase experiments. A threshold CID experiment also yields thermochemical information on the formation of the gold carbene from the ylid complex precursor.     

Mechanism of C[bond]H bond activation/C[bond]C bond formation reaction between diazo compound and alkane catalyzed by dirhodium tetracarboxylate

The B3LYP density functional studies on the dirhodium tetracarboxylate-catalyzed C-H bond activation/C-C bond formation reaction of a diazo compound with an alkane revealed the energetics and the geometry of important intermediates and transition states in the catalytic cycle. The reaction is initiated by complexation between the rhodium catalyst and the diazo compound. Driven by the back-donation from the Rh 4d(xz) orbital to the C[bond]N sigma*-orbital, nitrogen extrusion takes place to afford a rhodium[bond]carbene complex. The carbene carbon of the complex is strongly electrophilic because of its vacant 2p orbital. The C[bond]H activation/C[bond]C formation proceeds in a single step through a three-centered hydride transfer-like transition state with a small activation energy. Only one of the two rhodium atoms works as a carbene binding site throughout the reaction, and the other rhodium atom assists the C[bond]H insertion reaction. The second Rh atom acts as a mobile ligand for the first one to enhance the electrophilicity of the carbene moiety and to facilitate the cleavage of the rhodium[bond]carbon bond. The calculations reproduce experimental data including the activation enthalpy of the nitrogen extrusion, the kinetic isotope effect of the C[bond]H insertion, and the reactivity order of the C[bond]H bond.     

Enantioselective Oxidative Gold Catalysis Enabled by a Designed Chiral P,N‐Bidentate Ligand

A newly developed P,N‐bidentate ligand enables enantioselective intramolecular cyclopropanation by a reactive α‐oxo gold carbene intermediate generated in situ. The ligand design is based on our previously proposed structure (with a well‐organized triscoordinated gold center) of the carbene intermediate in the presence of a P,N‐bidentate ligand. A C₂‐symmetric piperidine ring was incorporated in the ligand as the nitrogen‐containing moiety. A range of racemic transformations of α‐oxo gold carbene intermediates have been developed recently, and this new class of chiral ligands could enable their modification for asymmetric synthesis, as demonstrated in this study.     

Molecular modeling of the olefin metathesis by tungsten(0) carbene complexes

Density functional and second-order Moller–Plesset theory were used to model W(0) carbene mediated homogeneous metathesis reaction of propylene. The calculations show that the rate determining step of the metathesis is the initiation. After the initiation has been completed the rate determining step becomes dissociation of olefin–metallocarbene complex. The low stereoselectivity of the olefin metathesis reaction is due to the close matching of activation energies for cis and trans isomer formation and the fast cis–trans isomerization caused by the catalysts. The non-productive olefin metathesis reaction always dominates the reaction mixture owing to its very low activation energy. The electronic structure of metal carbene olefin complexes can be described as a combination of donor–acceptor interactions between HOMO of the olefin and LUMO of metal carbene located at carbene carbon on the one hand, and the Dewar, Chatt and Duncanson back donation scheme on the other.     

Reaction pathway and stereoselectivity of asymmetric synthesis of chrysanthemate with the aratani C1-symmetric salicylaldimine-copper catalyst

The reaction pathway and the mechanism of asymmetric induction in the synthesis of (+)-trans-(1R,3R)-chrysanthemic acid methyl ester from methyl diazoacetate and 2,5-dimethyl-2,4-hexadiene in the presence of a C(1)-chiral salicylaldimine Cu(I) complex has been probed with the aid of hybrid density functional calculations. The key finding is that the alkoxycarbonyl carbene complex intermediate is intrinsically chiral and that the intramolecular hydrogen bonding in the carbene complex transmits the chirality information from the side chain to the carbene complex. Molecular orbital backgrounds of the structure of the carbene complex and the transition state of the cyclopropanation have been elucidated.     

运用NMR和DFT研究Michael加成反应的动力学行为及反应机理：(CO)5W=C(OEt)C2Ph作为底物

利用核磁共振方法研究了取代吡唑对炔基Fischer卡宾化合物的Michael加成的动力学行为，该反应为典型的二级反应。当吡唑的3，5-位由较大基团取代时，反应速率常数变小，而活化焓和活化熵明显增大。利用密度泛函理论研究了炔基钨卡宾为底物的Michael加成反应机理，发现吡唑上取代基团的增大可以导致第三步反应的活化能大于第一步，从而使反应的决速步骤由原来的第一步转变为第三步。     

Ruthenium-catalysed carbenoid cyclopropanation reactions with diazo compounds

The transition-metal catalysed cyclopropanation of olefinic bonds using diazo compounds as a carbene source is among the best developed and most useful transformations available to the synthetic organic chemist. Nevertheless, the quest for new catalyst/ligand systems continues in order to further extend the scope of this method and to identify more economical catalytic systems. In this tutorial review, several different ruthenium complexes are presented which have recently emerged as suitable catalysts for carbenoid cyclopropanation. For the model reaction--cyclopropanation of styrene(s) with diazoacetates--and also for some intramolecular cyclopropanation reactions highly remarkable results in terms of catalyst efficiency, product yields, dia- and enantioselectivity have been reported.     

The influence of N-substitution on the reductive elimination behaviour of hydrocarbyl-palladium-carbene complexes--a DFT study

The reductive elimination of 2-hydrocarbyl-imidazolium salts from hydrocarbyl-palladium complexes bearing N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) ligands represents an important deactivation route for catalysts of this type. We have explored the influence that carbene N-substituents have on both the activation energy and the overall thermodynamics of the reductive elimination reaction using density functional theory (DFT). Given the proximity of the N-substituent to the three-centred transition structure, steric bulk has little influence on the activation barrier and it is electronic factors that dominate the barriers' magnitude. Increased electron donation from the departing NHC ligand acts to stabilise the associated complex against reductive elimination, with stability following the trend: Cl < H < Ph < Me < Cy < iPr < neopentyl < tBu. The intimate involvement of the carbene p pi-orbital in determining the barrier to reductive elimination means N-substituents that are capable of removing pi-density (e.g. phenyl) act to promote a more facile reductive elimination.     

Cobalt(II)‐based Metalloradical Activation of 2‐(Diazomethyl)pyridines for Radical Transannulation and Cyclopropanation

A new catalytic method for the denitrogenative transannulation/cyclopropanation of in‐situ‐generated 2‐(diazomethyl)pyridines is described using a cobalt‐catalyzed radical‐activation mechanism. The method takes advantage of the inherent properties of a Co^III‐carbene radical intermediate and is the first report of denitrogenative transannulation/cyclopropanation by a radical‐activation mechanism, which is supported by various control experiments. The synthetic benefits of the metalloradical approach are showcased with a short total synthesis of (±)‐monomorine.     

Methandiide as a Non‐Innocent Ligand in Carbene Complexes: From the Electronic Structure to Bond Activation Reactions and Cooperative Catalysis

The synthesis of a ruthenium carbene complex based on a sulfonyl‐substituted methandiide and its application in bond activation reactions and cooperative catalysis is reported. In the complex, the metal–carbon interaction can be tuned between a Ru?C single bond with additional electrostatic interactions and a Ru?C double bond, thus allowing the control of the stability and reactivity of the complex. Hence, activation of polar and non‐polar bonds (O?H, H?H) as well as dehydrogenation reactions become possible. In these reactions the carbene acts as a non‐innocent ligand supporting the bond activation as nucleophilic center in the 1,2‐addition across the metal–carbon double bond. This metal–ligand cooperativity can be applied in the catalytic transfer hydrogenation for the reduction of ketones. This concept opens new ways for the application of carbene complexes in catalysis.     

Catalytic cyclopropanation of alkenes via (2-furyl)carbene complexes from 1-benzoyl-cis-1-buten-3-yne with transition metal compounds

The reaction of alkenes with conjugated ene-yne-ketones, such as 1-benzoyl-2-ethynylcycloalkenes, with a catalytic amount of Cr(CO)(5)(THF) gave 5-phenyl-2-furylcyclopropane derivatives in good yields. The key intermediate of this cyclopropanation is a (2-furyl)carbene complex generated by a nucleophilic attack of carbonyl oxygen to an internal alkyne carbon in pi-alkyne complex or sigma-vinyl cationic complex. A wide range of late transition metal compounds, such as [RuCl(2)(CO)(3)](2), [RhCl(cod)](2), [Rh(OAc)(2)](2), PdCl(2), and PtCl(2), also catalyzes the cyclopropanation of alkenes with ene-yne-ketones effectively. When the reactions were carried out with dienes as a carbene acceptor, the more substituted or more electron-rich alkene moiety was selectively cyclopropanated with the (2-furyl)carbenoid intermediate.