Chiral recognition in the solid state: crystallographically characterized diastereomeric co-crystals between a synthetic chiral selector (Whelk-O1) and a representative chiral analyte

Designed to distinguish between the enantiomers of compounds possessing commonly occurring structural features, the chiral selector used in the chiral stationary phase (CSP) 1 (Whelk-O1) is broadly applicable. In an effort to further the understanding of the mechanism of chiral recognition with this chiral selector, both diastereomeric combinations of selector 1 and a representative analyte, the pivalamide of p-bromo-α-phenylethylamine, 2, were successfully co-crystallized and characterized by single crystal X-ray diffraction. The crystal corresponding to the complex that is more stable in solution is consistent with our previously reported chiral recognition model. The aromatic portion of 2 is in the cleft of selector 1, displaying both face-to-face and face-to-edge π–π interactions as well as a hydrogen bond between the benzamide proton of the selector and the carbonyl oxygen of the analyte. For the crystal corresponding to the complex, which is less stable in solution, the aromatic portion of 2 is not in the cleft of selector 1, having approached from the opposite face of the π-acidic dinitrobenzamide moiety so as to undergo face-to-face π–π and hydrogen bonding interactions. Comparisons of these structures and their relevance to enantioselective chromatography are also discussed.     

Enantiodifferentiation of multifunctional tertiary alcohols by NMR spectroscopy with a Whelk-O type chiral solvating agent

A Whelk-O type chiral solvating agent (CSA) allows NMR enantioresolution of multifunctional tertiary alcohols. Crystallographic analysis of the CSA revealed two conformers, which can be expected to coexist in solution. One conformation affords a chiral cleft that can engage a single enantiomer in simultaneous hydrogen bonding, π–π stacking, and CH/π interactions. This chiral recognition process yields nonequivalent NMR signals for the enantiomers of eighteen substrates even when substoichiometric amounts of the CSA are used.     

Rational optimization of the Whelk-O1 chiral stationary phase using molecular dynamics simulations

Rational in silico optimization of the Whelk-O1 chiral stationary phase (CSP) has been carried out based on the chiral recognition mechanism extracted from previous molecular dynamics simulations [C.F. Zhao, N.M. Cann, Anal. Chem. 80 (2008) 2426] of this CSP. Three modified CSPs have been examined. The first two are designed to increase selectivity by reducing the docking probability of the less retained analyte. The third modified selector reverses the amide bridge to introduce a structural motif found in the popular carbamate-derivatized polysaccharide CSPs [Y. Okamoto, M. Kawashima, K. Hatada, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 106 (1984) 5357]. For each modified selector, an atomistic model has been obtained through extensive ab initio calculations. The effect of selector modification is then evaluated via simulations of the modified interface in the presence of target analytes. Simulation results show that the separation factors are increased for the modified CSPs but in some cases elution orders are reversed. The Whelk-O1 CSP was originally designed to separate naproxen [W.H. Pirkle, C.J. Welch, B. LAmm, J. Org. Chem. 57 (1992) 3854]. With this in mind, molecular dynamics simulations of naproxen are compared for the original, and the modified, selectors.     

Synthesis of novel chiral imidazolium stationary phases and their enantioseparation evaluation by high-performance liquid chromatography

Two novel chiral stationary phases (CSPs) were prepared by bonding chiral imidazoliums on the surface of silica gel. The chiral imidazoles were derivatized from chiral amines, 1-phenylethylamine and 1-(1-naphthyl)ethylamine. The obtained CSPs were characterized by Fourier Transform Infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy and elemental analysis (EA), demonstrating the bonding densities of CSP 1 and CSP 2 were 0.43 mmol g⁻¹ and 0.40 mmol g⁻¹, respectively. These two CSPs could be used to availably separate 8 pharmaceuticals, 7 mandelic acid/its derivatives, 2 1-phenylethylamine derivatives, 1 1,1′-bi-2-naphthol, and 1 camphorsulfonic acid in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). It is found that CSP 1 could effectively enantioseparate most chiral analytes, especially the acidic components, while CSP 2 could enantiorecognize all chiral analytes, although a number of components did not achieve baseline separation. Additionally, the effects of mobile phase composition, mobile phase pH and salt content, chiral selector structures, and analyte structures on the enantiorecognitions of the two CSPs were investigated. It is found that high acetonitrile content in mobile phases was conducive to enantiorecognition. Mobile phase pH and salt content could alter the retention behaviors of different enantiomers of the same chiral compound, resulting in better enantioresolution. Moreover, both chiral selector structures and substituted groups of analytes played a significant role in the separation of chiral solutes.     

Comparison of enantiomer separation on two chiral stationary phases derived from (+)-18-crown-6-2,3,11,12-tetracarboxylic acid of the same chiral selector

Liquid chromatographic comparisons for enantiomer resolution of α-amino acids and chiral primary amino compounds were made using chiral stationary phases (CSPs) prepared by covalently bonding (+)-(18-crown-6)-2,3,11,12-tetracarboxylic acid (18-C-6-TA) of the same chiral selector. The resolution of all α-amino acids on CSP 1 developed in our group was found to be better than that on CSP 2 reported by Machida et al. All α-amino acids examined in this study were well enantioseparated on CSP 1 (α=1.22–2.47), while four analytes were not resolved or all the other analytes were poorly resolved on CSP 2 than on CSP 1. However, in resolving the primary amino compounds without a carbonyl group, CSP 1 was comparable with CSP 2. Although (+)-18-C-6-TA of the same chiral selector was used to prepare CSP 1 and CSP 2, this study showed that different connecting methods for the CSPs might influence their ability to resolve the analytes depending on their structures related to the chiral recognition mechanism.     

Comparison of vancomycin-based stationary phases with different chiral selector coverage for enantioselective separation of selected drugs in high-performance liquid chromatography

Two vancomycin-based chiral stationary phases (CSPs) with different coverage of the chiral selector vancomycin (Chirobiotic V and Chirobiotic V2) were compared. beta-Blockers and profens, as structurally diverse groups of drugs, were chosen as analytes. Retention and enantioseparation of beta-blockers were studied in reversed-phase (RP) and polar-organic (PO) separation modes. Higher retention and better enantioresolution were obtained on the CSP with higher coverage of vancomycin in the both separation modes. Baseline separation of four beta-blockers (eight enantiomers) in the PO mode was achieved on the Chirobiotic V2 column within 15 min. The enantioseparation of profens did not bring so excellent and easy to interpret results. Higher retention of profens on the Chirobiotic V2 column was not always accompanied by an improvement of their chiral separation in the RP mode. The polar-organic mode was not suitable for these derivatives at all. The most interesting result was obtained with flobufen; its chiral center is further away from the rigid part of the molecule, which mostly causes difficulties in enantioselective recognition. Nevertheless, the enantiomers of flobufen were shown to be much better (baseline) resolved on the CSP with lower coverage of the chiral selector (Chirobiotic V).     

Molecular Recognition and Enantiomer Separations on a novel chiral stationary phase based on a 9,9′-spirobi[9H-fluorene]-derived molecular cleft

An optically active molecular cleft incorporating a 9,9′-spirobi[9H-fluorene] spacer and two N-(5,7-dimethyl-1,8-naphthyridin-2-yl)carboxamide: (CONH(naphthyr)) moieties as H-bonding sites was covalently bound to silica gel to provide the new chiral stationary phase (CSP) (R)- 16 (Scheme 2). Previous solution-binding studies in CDCl₃ had shown that the anchored molecular cleft was capable of complexing optically active dicarboxylic acids with differences in free energy of the formed diastereoisomeric complexes (Δ(ΔG⁰)) between 0.5 and 1.6 kcal mol^?1 (T = 300 K). The optical resolution of racemic dicarboxylic acids, that are bound with a high degree of enantioselectivity in the liquid phase, was now achieved by HPLC on the CSP (R)- 16. The order of enantiomer elution was as predicted from the solution studies, and the separation factor α varied between 1.18 and 1.24. A series of 1,1′-binaphthalene-2,2′-diol derivatives were also resolved on the new CSP, in some cases with baseline separation. The order of enantiomer elution under normal-phase chromatographic conditions was rationalized by computer modeling of the association between the solute enantiomers and the immobilized molecular cleft. HPLC Separations with eluents of different polarity suggested that the attractive interactions between solute and immobilized chiral selector are a combination of H-bonding, which prevails in apolar eluents, and aromatic π--π stacking, which dominates in polar eluents.     

双选择体手性固定相中选择体的构型对分离性能的影响

为研究选择体的构型对双选择体固定相手性识别的影响,以(1S,2S)-(~)-二苯基乙二胺及L-(~)-二苯甲酰酒石酸为手性源,合成了一种新的双选择体固定相,并用不同结构的手性样品测试了其手性分离能力。结果表明,这种固定相与以(1R,2R)-(+)-二苯基乙二胺及L(~)-二苯甲酰酒石酸为手性源制备的双选择体固定相有相当的手性分离能力,但这两种固定相所能分离的化合物不尽相同。对双选择体固定相中两个选择体的构型对固定相手性识别的影响进行了探讨。在手性识别中,以不同手性源制备的两个选择体的立体构型不能同时与一个手性样品的立体构型相匹配,从而导致相应的双选择体固定相手性分离能力的下降。     

Assessment of chiral stationary phases for suitability for combined enantiomeric impurity/related substances assays

Chiral stationary phases (CSP) for LC had a major impact on pharmaceutical R&D when they first became commercially available in the 1980s. Even although the use of CSP in pharmaceutical R&D is now very much a mature area, there is still scope for using CSP more effectively to bring about efficiencies. One such instance is the possibility of combining the chiral LC test for the level of a trace enantiomeric impurity in a chiral drug substance and the LC test for related substances into one test. It was envisaged that this could be achieved by carrying out reversed-phase LC on an ODS silica/CSP coupled column system. In evaluating Chiralpak QD-AX, Cyclobond I 2000 DNP and Whelk-O1 CSP using a polar organic - aqueous mobile phase it was found that the Whelk-O1 CSP had good achiral selectivity, the required match of retentivity with the ODS silica material, ACE 5 C18 and also exhibited an encouraging degree of enantioselectivity in the reversed-phase mode. Following consideration of the selectivity of the ACE 5 C18 and Whelk-O1 phases it became apparent that it might be possible to achieve the desired goal of achieving both the enantiomeric impurity and related substances separations in one system by using the Whelk-O1 CSP on its own. This was subsequently demonstrated to be the case using S-naproxen, laevokalim and S-flurbiprofen as illustrative examples.     

Solvation of the Whelk-O1 chiral stationary phase: a molecular dynamics study

Density functional theory calculations and molecular dynamics simulations are employed to explore the solvation of the Whelk-O1 chiral stationary phase. First, a semi-flexible representation of the Whelk-O1 selective molecule is extracted from an extensive series of B3LYP/6-311+ G(2d,p) calculations. The resulting model is used to build a chiral surface, including end-caps, for molecular dynamics study of the interface between solvent and Whelk-O1. Three solvent environments in common use for Whelk-O1 HPLC have been examined: a normal-phase solvent of n-hexane/2-propanol; a reversed-phase solvent of water/methanol; and a supercritical solvent of CO(2) and methanol. In each case, we analyze the interface with an emphasis on solvent composition and solvent hydrogen bonding to the Whelk-O1 selector.     

Enantioselective separation in capillary electrophoresis using a novel mono-6-propylammonium-β-cyclodextrin as chiral selector

The chiral resolving ability of a novel single-isomer cationic β-cyclodextrin (CD), mono-6^A-propylammonium-6^A-deoxy-β-cyclodextrin chloride (PrAMCD), as a chiral selector in capillary electrophoresis (CE) is reported in this work for the enantioseparation of hydroxy, carboxylic acids and amphoteric analytes. The effect of chiral selector concentration on the resolution was studied. Good resolutions were achieved for hydroxy acids. Optimum resolutions were obtained even at 3.5 mM CD concentration for carboxylic acids. The electrophoretic method showed good linearity and reproducibility in terms of migration times and peak areas, which should make it suitable for routine analysis. In addition, baseline chiral separation of a six-acid mixture was achieved within 20 min. PrAMCD proved to be an effective chiral selector for acidic analytes.     

Evaluation of the enantioselectivity of glycogen-based dual chiral selector systems towards basic drugs in capillary electrophoresis

Several chiral reagents including cyclodextrins (CDs) and derivatives, crown ethers, proteins, chiral surfactants and polymers have been involved in dual selector systems for enantioseparation of a series of chiral compounds by capillary electrophoresis (CE). In comparison to the chiral reagents above-mentioned, there is no report concerning the use of polysaccharides in dual chiral CE system. In this paper we first investigate the enantioselectivity of polysaccharide-based dual selector systems towards some chiral drugs. During our recent work, glycogen belonging to the class of branched polysaccharides has been used as a novel chiral selector in CE. In this study, three glycogen-based dual chiral CE systems have been established for enantiomeric separations of several racemic basic drugs consisting of duloxetine, cetirizine, citalopram, sulconazole, laudanosine, amlodipine, propranolol, atenolol and nefopam. These three dual systems combined glycogen (neutral polysaccharide) with chondroitin sulfate A (CSA, ionic polysaccharide), β-CD and HP-β-CD, respectively. It was found that the dual system of glycogen/CSA exhibited good enantioselective properties toward the tested drugs. More importantly, compared to the single selector systems, synergistic effect was observed when glycogen was used with CSA for most of the analytes. This indicated the enhancement of enantioseparation observed for these analytes in glycogen/CSA system might be due to some favorable interaction effects between glycogen and CSA. Moreover, in order to evaluate the stereoselectivity of glycogen/CSA, the influences of buffer pH and selector concentration on enantioseparation of the studied drugs were also investigated.     

The docking of chiral epoxides on the Whelk-O1 stationary phase: a molecular dynamics study

The docking of analytes on the Whelk-O1 chiral stationary phase is explored for two chiral epoxides in a hexane solvent. Density functional theory calculations are employed to develop flexible models for R/S-styrene oxide (phenyl oxirane) and (R,R/S,S)-stilbene oxide (2,3-diphenyl oxirane). Molecular dynamics simulations of the racemates in the presence of the Whelk-O1 chiral stationary phase reveal the distribution of the enantiomers at the interface. The importance of hydrogen bonding and ring-ring interactions is explored along with an examination of the major docking arrangements. The interactions between the Whelk-O1 molecules and the chiral epoxide enantiomers are quite distinct and consistent with the experimental elution orders [S.E. Schaus, B.D. Brandes, J.F. Larrow, M. Tokunage, K.B. Hansen, A.E. Gould, M.E. Furrow, E.N. Jacobsen, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 124 (2001) 1307] and separation factors [W.H. Pirkle, C.J. Welch, Tetrahedron: Asymm. 5 (1994) 777]. The impact of a polar solvent modifier is examined for R/S-styrene oxide where selectivity in 80:20 n-hexane:2-propanol is assessed.     

Effect of the residual silanol group protection on the liquid chromatographic resolution of α‐amino acids and proton pump inhibitors on a ligand exchange chiral stationary phase

A new ligand exchange chiral stationary phase (new CSP) containing residual silanol group‐protecting n‐octyl groups on the silica surface was prepared by treating a ligand exchange CSP (original CSP) based on sodium N‐[(R)‐2‐hydroxy‐1‐phenylethyl]‐N‐undecylaminoacetate bonded to silica gel with excess n‐octyltriethoxysilane. The new and original CSPs containing an identical amount of chiral selector were applied to the resolution of α‐amino acids and proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) including omeprazole, pantoprazole, lansoprazole, and rabeprazole. The separation factors (α) and resolutions (R_S) were greater on the new CSP than on the original CSP except for the resolution of asparagine. The trends of the retention factors (k₁) for the resolution of α‐amino acids on the new and original CSPs with the variation of the organic modifier content in aqueous mobile phase were opposite to those for the resolution of PPIs. Removal of the nonenantioselective interactions between the residual silanol groups and the analytes and the improved lipophilicity of the new CSP were proposed to be responsible for the improved chiral recognition ability of the new CSP and the different retention behaviors of the enantiomers between the new and original CSPs.     

HPLC enantioseparation of β2‐homoamino acids using crown ether‐based chiral stationary phase

RP high‐performance liquid chromatographic methods were developed for the enantioseparation of eleven unusual β²‐homoamino acids. The underivatized analytes were separated on a chiral stationary phase containing (+)‐(18‐crown‐6)‐2,3,11,12‐tetracarboxylic acid as chiral selector. The effects of organic (alcoholic) and acidic modifiers, the mobile phase composition and temperature on the separation were investigated. The structures of the substituents in the α‐position of the analytes substantially influenced the retention and resolution. The elution sequence was determined in some cases: the S enantiomers eluted before the R enantiomers.     

Improved chiral stationary phase for ß-blocker enantioseparations

The previously described -Burke 1 chiral stationary phase (CSP) was designed for the chromatographic separation of the enantiomers of ß-blockers. Difficulties with the reproducibility of the free radical addition reaction, used in the attachment of the chiral selector to the chromatographic support, have required the development of an alternative silane immobilization process (-Burke 2 CSP). While the enantioselectivity afforded by this new CSP is generally equivalent to that of the original CSP, the -Burke 2 CSP demonstrates longer analyte retention, necessitating the use of mobile phases of greater eluotropic strength. The increased retention of the new CSP presumably results from a greater surface density of functional selectors, an interpretation which is supported by the observation that the preparative capacity of the -Burke 2 CSP is greater than that of the original. Some of the factors influencing the retention and separation of a group of 23 ß-blockers on the -Burke 2 CSP are discussed.     

Azithromycin as a new chiral selector in capillary electrophoresis

In capillary electrophoresis (CE), separation of enantiomers of a chiral compound can be achieved through the chiral interactions and/or complex formation between the chiral selector and the enantiomeric analytes on leaving their diastereomeric forms with different stability constants and hence different mobilities. A great number of chiral selectors have been employed in CE and among them macrocyclic antibiotics exhibited excellent enantioselective properties towards a wide number of racemic compounds. The use of azithromycin (AZM) as a chiral selector has not been reported previously. This work reports the use of AZM as a chiral selector for the enantiomeric separations of five chiral drugs and one amino acid (tryptophan) in CE. The enantioseparation is carried out using polar organic mixtures of acetonitrile (ACN), methanol (MeOH), acetic acid and triethylamine as run buffer. The influences of the chiral selector concentration, ACN/MeOH ratio, applied voltage and capillary temperature on enantioseparation are investigated. The results show that AZM is a viable chiral selector in CE for the enantioseparation of the type of chiral drugs investigated.     

HPLC separation of the enantiomers of racemic benzergoline derivatives on a chiral binaphthalene covalently bonded to silica gel

A novel chiral stationary phase (CSP) derived from the atropisomeric enantiomer S-3,3′-dicarboxy-2,2′-dihydroxy-1,1′-binaphthyl (S-DDBN) has been synthesized and its use for the separation of enantiomers demonstrated. The chiral selector is covalently bonded to amino-functionalized silica gel, thus enabling the use of alcohols as mobile phases. Good chiral discrimination was obtained for the pharmacologically interesting class of benzergoline derivatives which act as selective dopamine D₁ receptor agonists. This paper reports the successful separtion of fifteen structurally related benzergoline racemates with separation factors up to 3.5. The influence of small differences in molecular structure on chiral discrimination was examined.     

Preparation of a positively charged cellulose derivative chiral stationary phase with copolymerization reaction for capillary electrochromatographic separation of enantiomers

A positively charged chiral stationary phase (CSP) was prepared by chemically immobilizing cellulose 3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate onto methacryloyldiethylenetriaminopropylated silica (MCDEAPS) via a radical copolymerization reaction. The prepared CSP was evaluated for enantiomer separation in nonaqueous capillary electrochromatography (CEC). Electroosmotic flow (EOF) generated on the prepared CSP could be significantly improved with introduction of positive charges into the CSP, and separation of enantiomers in CEC has been achieved with mobile phases of ethanol and hexane-ethanol, respectively. In addition, we investigated the solvent versatility of the immobilized CSP on enantioseparations in CEC and capillary liquid chromatography (CLC) due to the elimination of dissolution of chiral selector in a number of solvents. Chiral resolution of some enantiomers was improved by adopting tetrahydrofuran (THF) and chloroform as mobile-phase modifiers, respectively.     

Enantioseparation of chiral organochlorines on permethylated beta- and gamma-cyclodextrin, as well as 1:1 mixtures of them

Gas chromatography columns coated with 10% permethylated beta- and gamma-cyclodextrin in 85% dimethyl-15% diphenyl polysiloxane (beta- and gamma-PMCD, respectively) and 1:1 mixures are prepared and tested with regard to the enantioseparation of chiral chloropesticides. On the columns with the individual O-methylated cyclodextrins (O-tCDs), the enantiomers of aaeeee-hexachlorocyclohexane (alpha-HCH), e-aeee-1,3,4,5,6-pentachlorocyclohex-1-ene (beta-PCCH), and e-aaee-1,3,4,5,6-pentachlorocyclohex-1-ene (gamma-PCCH), cis- and trans-chlordane, and cis-heptachlor epoxide are separated on both columns, with the exception of the latter being separated only on beta-PMCD. On the column coated with 5% beta- and 5% gamma-PMCD, the resulting separation factor (a) is virtually 1/2 of the arithmetric mean of the elution-dependent separation factors on the individual O-tCDs. In case of reversed elution order on beta- and gamma-PMCD, the enantiomers are not resolved on the mixed columns as is the case with cis-chlordane. Likewise, the lower resolution of the gamma-PCCH enantiomers on the mixed columns prove the reversed elution order on beta- and gamma-PMCD without having enantioenriched standards available. On the column coated with 5% beta- and 5% gamma-PMCD, similar retention times to those observed on both 10% beta-PMCD and 10% gamma-PMCD are obtained. On the column coated with 10% beta- and 10% gamma-PMCD, significantly longer retention times are obtained compared with the columns that contain a total of 10% chiral stationary phase (CSP). This indicates that a relevant part of the interaction of the analytes with the chiral selector is non-enantioselective and, thus, only delays the elution of both enantiomers. Moreover, these non-enantioselective interactions prevent a direct comparison of CSPs with different amounts of the chiral selector. However, this is possible by using mixed phases of two CSPs with similar properties. Using this system, it is demonstrated that for the organochlorine compounds studied, no higher separation factor is observed on the mixed CSPs than on the individual O-tCD with the higher separation factor. Estimations allow a prediction that enantioseparations of organohalogen compounds can be achieved on columns coated with as little as 1% of the CSP.