Stabilization, propagation and instability of tribrachial triple flames

A tribrachial (or triple) flame is one kind of edge flame that can be encountered in nonpremixed mixing layers, consisting of a lean and a rich premixed flame wing together with a trailing diffusion flame all extending from a single point. The flame could play an important role on the characteristics of various flame behaviors including lifted flames in jets, flame propagation in two-dimensional mixing layers, and autoignition fronts. The structure of tribrachial flame suggests that the edge is located along the stoichiometric contour in a mixing layer due to the coexistence of all three different types of flames. Since the edge has a premixed nature, it has unique propagation characteristics. In this review, the propagation speed of tribrachial flames will be discussed for flames propagating in mixing layers, including the effects of concentration gradient, velocity gradient, and burnt gas expansion. Based on the tribrachial edge structure observed experimentally in laminar lifted flames in jets, the flame stabilization characteristics including liftoff height, reattachment, and blowout behaviors and their buoyancy-induced instability will be explained. Various effects on liftoff heights in both free and coflow jets including jet velocity, the Schmidt number of fuel, nozzle diameter, partial premixing of air to fuel, and inert dilution to fuel are discussed. Implications of edge flames in the modeling of turbulent nonpremixed flames and the stabilization of turbulent lifted flames in jets are covered.     

Scaling relations for the length of coaxial oxy-flames with and without swirl

An extensive experimental study is carried out to analyze scaling laws for the length of methane oxy-flames stabilized on a coaxial injector. The central methane fuel stream is diluted with N₂, CO₂ or He. The annular air stream is enriched with oxygen and can be impregnated with swirl. Former studies have shown that the stoichiometric mixing length of relatively short flames is controlled by the mixing process taking place in the vicinity of the injector outlet. This property has been used to derive scaling laws at large values of the stoichiometric mixture fraction. It is shown here that the same relation can be extended to methane oxy-flames characterized by small values of the stoichiometric mixture fraction. Flame lengths are determined with OH* chemiluminescence measurements over more than 1000 combinations of momentum ratio, annular swirl level and composition of the inner and outer streams of the coaxial injector. It is found that the lengths of all the flames investigated without swirl collapse on a single line, whose coefficients correspond to within 15% of flame lengths obtained for fuel and oxidizer streams at much larger stoichiometric mixture fractions. This relation is then extended to the case of swirling flames by including the contribution of the tangential velocity in the flow entrainment rate and is found to well reproduce the mixing degree of the two co-axial streams as long as the flow does not exhibit a vortex breakdown bubble. At higher swirl levels, when the flow features a central recirculation region, the flame length is found to also directly depend on the oxygen enrichment in the oxidizer stream.     

A numerical study on the formation of diffusion flame islands in a turbulent hydrogen jet lifted flame

This paper presents a numerical study on the formation of diffusion flame islands in a hydrogen jet lifted flame. A real size hydrogen jet lifted flame is numerically simulated by the DNS approach over a period of about 0.5 ms. The diameter of hydrogen injector is 2 mm, and the injection velocity is 680 m/s. The lifted flame is composed of a stable leading edge flame, a vigorously turbulent inner rich premixed flame, and a number of outer diffusion flame islands. The relatively long-term observation makes it possible to understand in detail the time-dependent flame behavior in rather large time scales, which are as large as the time scale of the leading edge flame unsteadiness. From the observation, the following three findings are obtained concerning the formation of diffusion flame islands. (1) A thin oxygen diffusion layer is developed along the outer boundary of the lifted flame, where the diffusion flame islands burn in a rather flat shape. (2) When a diffusion flame island comes into contact with the fluctuating inner rich premixed flame, combustion is intensified due to an increase in the hydrogen supply by molecular diffusion. This process also works for the production of the diffusion flame islands in the oxygen diffusion layer. (3) When a large unburned gas volume penetrates into the leading edge flame, the structure of the leading edge flame changes. In this transformation process, a diffusion flame island comes near the leading edge flame. The local deficiency of oxygen plays an important role in this production process.     

Control of oscillating combustion and noise based on local flame structure

To control combustion oscillations, the characteristics of an oscillating swirl injection premixed flame have been investigated, and control of oscillating combustion and noise based on local flame structure has been conducted. The r.m.s. value of pressure fluctuations and noise level show significantly large values between = 0.8 and 1.1. The beating of pressure fluctuations is observed for the large oscillating flame conditions in this combustor. Relationship between beating of pressure fluctuations and local flame structure was observed by the simultaneous measurement of CH/OH planar laser induced fluorescence and pressure fluctuations. The local flame structure and beating of pressure fluctuations are related and the most complicated flame is formed in the middle pressure fluctuating region of beating. The beating of pressure fluctuations, which plays important roles in noise generation and nitric oxide emission in this combustor, could be controlled by injecting secondary fuel into the recirculating region of oscillating flames. Injecting secondary fuel prevented lean blowout, and low NO_x combustion was also achieved even for the case of pure methane injection as a secondary fuel. By injecting secondary fuel into the recirculating region near the swirl injector, the flame lifted from the swirl injector and its reaction region became uniform and widespread, hence resulting in low nitric oxide emission. Secondary mixture injection, fuel diluted with air, is not effective for control of combustion oscillations suppression and lean blowout prevention.     

Experimental investigation of combustion instabilities of a mesoscale multinozzle array in a lean-premixed combustor

Self-excited combustion instabilities in a mesoscale multinozzle array, also referred to as a micromixer-type injector, have been experimentally investigated in a lean-premixed tunable combustor operating with preheated methane and air. The injector assembly consists of sixty identical swirl injectors of 6.5 mm inner diameter, which are evenly distributed across the combustor dump plane. Their flow paths are divided into two groups – inner and outer stages – to form radially stratified reactant stoichiometry for the control of self-excited instabilities. OH PLIF measurements of stable flames reveal that the presence of radial staging has a remarkable influence on stabilization mechanisms, reactant jet penetration/merging, and interactions between adjacent flame fronts. In an inner enrichment case, two outer (leaner) streams merge into a single jet structure, whereas the inner (richer) reactant jets penetrate far downstream without noticeable interactions between neighboring flames. The constructed stability map in the 〈?_i, ?_o〉 domain indicates that strong self-excited instabilities occur under even split and outer enrichment conditions at relatively high global equivalence ratios. This is attributed to large-scale flame surface deformation in the streamwise direction, as manifested by vigorous detachment/attachment movements. The use of the inner fuel staging method was found, however, to limit the growth of large-amplitude heat release rate fluctuations, because the center flames are securely anchored during the whole period of oscillation, giving rise to a moderate lateral motion. We demonstrate that the collective motion of sixty flames – rather than the individual local flame dynamics – play a central role in the development of limit cycle oscillations. This suggests that the distribution pattern of the injector array, in combination with the radial fuel staging scheme, is the key to the control of the instabilities.     

Impact of co- and counter-swirl on flow recirculation and liftoff of non-premixed oxy-flames above coaxial injectors

Controlling the flame shape and its liftoff height is one of the main issues for oxy-flames to limit heat transfer to the solid components of the injector. An extensive experimental study is carried out to analyze the effects of co- and counter-swirl on the flow and flame patterns of non-premixed oxy-flames stabilized above a coaxial injector when both the inner fuel and the annular oxidizer streams are swirled. A swirl level greater than 0.6 in the annular oxidizer stream is shown to yield compact oxy-flames with a strong central recirculation zone that are attached to the rim of central fuel tube in absence of inner swirl. It is shown that counter-swirl in the fuel tube weakens this recirculation zone leading to more elongated flames, while co-swirl enhances it with more compact flames. These results obtained for high annular swirl levels contrast with previous observations made on gas turbine injectors operated at lower annular swirl levels in which central recirculation of the flow is mainly achieved with counter-rotating swirlers. Imparting a high inner swirl to the central fuel stream leads to lifted flames due to the partial blockage of the flow at the injector outlet by the central recirculation zone that causes high strain rates in the wake of the injector rim. This partial flow blockage is more influenced by the level of the inner swirl than its rotation direction. A global swirl number is then introduced to analyze the structure of the flow far from the burner outlet where swirl dissipation takes place when the jets mix. A model is derived for the global swirl number which well reproduces the evolution of the mass flow rate of recirculating gases measured in non-reacting conditions and the flame liftoff height when the inner and outer swirl levels and the momentum flux ratio between the two streams are varied.     

The stabilization mechanism and structure of turbulent hydrocarbon lifted flames

The structure and stabilization mechanism of turbulent lifted non-premixed hydrocarbon flames have been investigated using combined laser imaging techniques. The techniques include Rayleigh scattering, laser induced predissociation fluorescence of OH, LIF of PAH, LIF of CH₂O, and planar imaging velocimetry. The geometrical structure of multi-reaction zones and flow field at the stabilization region have been simultaneously measured in 16 hydrocarbon flames. The data reveal the existence of triple flame structure at the stabilization region of turbulent lifted flames. Increasing the jet velocity leads to an increase of the lift-off height and to a broadening of the lift-off region. Further analysis of the stabilization criterion at the lift-off height based on the premixed nature of triple-flame propagation and flow field data has been presented and discussed.     

Aspects of oscillating flames

Photography and chemieluminescence from CH radicals have been used to identify the reaction zones and quantify the areas and shapes of kerosene-fuelled flames with swirl numbers of 0.7 and 0.8 and an overall equivalence ratio of 0.25. The air flow was oscillated at a frequency of 350 Hz and the results suggest that the oscillations caused a sequence of vortex rings at the burner exit and that these distorted the reaction zone and increased its area in the near burner region leading to an overall shorter flame. For the swirl number of 0.7, the flame was lifted and the oscillations led to an increase in the average lift off length whereas the higher swirl number caused an attached flame with and without oscillations. The stretch rate, evaluated from the variation of the flame area in time, was higher for the lifted flame suggesting that lift off was caused by local extinction.     

Measurements of local mixture fraction of reacting mixture in swirl-stabilised natural gas-fuelled burners

Local, time-dependent measurements of mixture fraction of the reacting mixture were obtained in a swirl-stabilised natural gas-fuelled, nominally non-premixed burner using the intensity of chemiluminescence from OH^∗ and CH^∗ radicals. The measurements quantified the mean, rms of fluctuations and probability density functions of local mixture fraction at the stabilisation region of the flame. In addition, the probability of flame presence and the degree of lean or rich versus stoichiometric reaction is reported. The burner was operated for three air flow Reynolds numbers (Re=18970, 29100 and 57600), at an overall equivalence ratio of 0.32, without and with imposed oscillations to the air flow of the burner at the resonance frequency of 350 Hz. Results show that combustion occurred in a partially premixed mode for all flow conditions, although fuel and air were injected separately in the reaction zone. The mean local mixture fraction was nearly stoichiometric at the base of the flame without imposed air oscillations, but with large fluctuations leading to around 80% of lean or rich reaction. The degree of non-stoichiometric reaction increased with axial distance from the burner exit and Reynolds number and lean reaction dominated. Imposed air oscillations led to lifted flames and increased the degree of non-stoichiometric reaction for Re=18970 and 29100, whereas the flame remained attached onto the injector for Re=57600 and little modification of the mixture fraction was observed.     

Lift-off characteristics of triple flame with concentration gradient

The concentration gradient and uniform mean velocity of a triple flame in a mixing layer were studied using a multi-slot burner, which can stabilize the lift-off flame especially at a very small concentration gradient. Flame stabilization conditions were examined, and the lift-off heights of the triple flame were measured for methane and propane flames. A hot-wire anemometer was used to measure the velocity distributions. Mass spectroscopy (for methane) and Rayleigh scattering (for propane) were used to measure the concentration gradients. OH radical distribution was measured by laser-induced fluorescence (LIF), and in-stream velocity variation was measured with particle-image velocimetry (PIV). Maximum in-stream temperatures were measured using the coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (CARS) technique. Lift-off heights of triple flames have minimum values during the increase of concentration gradient, and the propagation velocity of triple flames reaches its maximum at a critical concentration gradient. This is caused by three factors: velocity distribution upstream, flammable limit of premixed gas, and reaction of diffusion flame. The critical concentration gradient, which maximizes the propagation velocity is suggested as a new criterion of transition from a premixed flame to a triple flame.     

Further investigation on the enhancement of flame speed in vortex ring combustion

Enhancement of flame speed in vortex ring combustion has been investigated experimentally. The flame speed and the maximum tangential velocity for each vortex ring were simultaneously measured with a PIV system and a high speed camera. To vary the extent of the enhancement, methane/hydrogen mixtures were used. Furthermore, rich mixtures were used as a source of vortex ring so that the situation of the experiment and the results could be applied more directly to practical use. Results have confirmed that enhancement of flame speed does occur in vortex ring combustion of rich methane/hydrogen mixtures in air. The extent of the enhancement becomes larger as the hydrogen content is increased. The flame speed reaches about twice as high as the maximum tangential velocity for pure hydrogen. Based on momentum conservation across the flame, a simple equation on the ratio of the flame speed to the maximum tangential velocity has been obtained, which has shown that the flame speed enhancement can be explained successfully by considering the spherically expanding type premixed combustion behind the flame. The pressure rise of a spherically expanding type premixed flame can explain the flame speed enhancement observed in the present rich methane/hydrogen vortex ring combustion.     

On the oscillating flame characteristics in nonpremixed laminar coflow-jets: An experimental and numerical study

This study investigates the characteristics of oscillating lifted flames in laminar coflow-jets experimentally and numerically by varying both fuel density (by varying propane and n-butane mixtures) and coflow density (by diluting air with N₂/He mixtures). Two different lifted flame oscillation behaviors are observed depending on these parameters: oscillating tribrachial lifted flame (OTLF) and oscillating mode-change lifted flame (OMLF), where a rapid increase in flame radius is observed. The regimes of the two flames are identified from experiments, which shows that OMLF occurs only when the effect of the negative buoyancy on the flow field by the fuel heavier than air becomes significant at low fuel jet velocity. OMLFs are also identified to distinguish OTLF regime from flame extinction, which implies that an OMLF can be extinguished when the positive buoyancy becomes weak, losing its stabilizing effect, or when the negative buoyancy becomes strong, further enhancing its destabilizing effect. Transient numerical simulations of both OTLF and OMLF reveal that the OMLF occurs by a strong toroidal vortex and a subsequent counterflow-like structure induced by relatively-strong negative buoyancy. Such a drastic flow redirection significantly changes the fuel concentration gradient such that the OMLF changes its mode from a tribrachial flame mode (decreasing edge speed with fuel concentration gradient) to the premixed flame-like transition mode when the fuel concentration gradient becomes very small (increasing edge speed with fuel concentration gradient). Again, a tribrachial flame mode is recovered during a rising period of flame edge and repeats an oscillation cycle.     

Stabilization mechanism of lifted flame edge in the near field of coflow jets for diluted methane

The stabilization mechanism of lifted flames in the near field of coflow jets has been investigated experimentally and numerically for methane fuel diluted with nitrogen. The lifted flames were observed only in the near field of coflow jets until blowout occurred in the normal gravity condition. To elucidate the stabilization mechanism for the stationary lifted flames of methane having the Schmidt number smaller than unity, the behavior of the flame in the buoyancy-free condition, and unsteady propagation characteristics after ignition were investigated numerically at various conditions of jet velocity. It has been found that buoyancy plays an important role for flame stabilization of lifted flames under normal gravity, such that the flame becomes attached to the nozzle in microgravity. The stabilization mechanism is found to be due to the variation of the propagation speed of the lifted flame edge with axial distance from the nozzle in the near field of the coflow as compared to the local flow velocity variation at the edge.     

Auto-ignition and flame stabilization of pulsed methane jets in a hot vitiated coflow studied with high-speed laser and imaging techniques

The auto-ignition of a pulsed methane jet issuing into a laminar coflow of hot exhaust products of a lean premixed hydrogen/air flat flame was examined using high-speed laser and optical measurement techniques with frame rates of 5 kHz or more. OH* chemiluminescence was used to determine the downstream location of the first auto-ignition kernel as well as the stabilization height of the steady-state lifted jet flame. OH planar laser-induced fluorescence (PLIF) was used to determine further details of the auto-ignition with a higher spatial resolution. Simultaneous imaging of broadband luminosity from a viewing angle perpendicular to the OH* chemiluminescence was applied, to three-dimensionally reconstruct the ignition kernel location in space and to determine whether the first occurrence of the kernel was within or beyond the PLIF laser sheet. The development and expansion of the jet was characterized by high-speed Schlieren imaging. Statistics have been compiled for both the ignition time as well as the downstream location of the first auto-ignition kernel and the stabilization height of the steady-state lifted jet flame. From the PLIF images it was found that auto-ignition tended to occur at the interface between bulges of the inflowing jet and the coflow. For steady-state conditions, auto-ignition kernels were observed frequently below the flame base, emphasizing that the lifted jet flame is stabilized by auto-ignition.     

Impact of swirl and bluff-body on the transfer function of premixed flames

The frequency response of three lean methane/air flames submitted to flowrate perturbations is analyzed for flames featuring the same equivalence ratio and thermal power, but a different stabilization mechanism. The first flame is stabilized by a central bluff body without swirl, the second one by the same bluff body with the addition of swirl and the last one only by swirl without central insert. In the two last cases, the swirl level is roughly the same. These three flames feature different shapes and heat release distributions, but their Flame Transfer Function (FTF) feature about the same phase lag at low frequencies. The gain of the FTF also shows the same behavior for the flame stabilized by the central insert without swirl and the one fully aerodynamically stabilized by swirl. Shedding of vortical structures from the injector nozzle that grow and rollup the flame tip controls the FTF of these flames. The flame stabilized by the swirler-plus-bluff-body system features a peculiar response with a large drop of the FTF gain around a frequency at which large swirl number oscillations are observed. Velocity measurements in cold flow conditions reveal a strong reduction of the size of the vortical structures shed from the injector lip at this forcing condition. The flame stabilized aerodynamically only by swirl and the one stabilized by the bluff body without swirl do not exhibit any FTF gain drop at low frequencies. In the former case, large swirl number oscillations are still identified, but large vortical structures shed from the nozzle also persist at the same forcing frequency in the cold flow response. These different flame responses are found to be intimately related to the dynamics of the internal recirculation region, which response strongly differs depending upon the injector used to stabilize the flame.     

Influences of stoichiometry on steadily propagating triple flames in counterflows

Most studies of triple flames in counterflowing streams of fuel and oxidizer have been focused on the symmetric problem in which the stoichiometric mixture fraction is 1/2. There then exist lean and rich premixed flames of roughly equal strengths, with a diffusion flame trailing behind from the stoichiometric point at which they meet. In the majority of realistic situations, however, the stoichiometric mixture fraction departs appreciably from unity, typically being quite small. With the objective of clarifying the influences of stoichiometry, attention is focused on one of the simplest possible models, addressed here mainly by numerical integration. When the stoichiometric mixture fraction departs appreciably from 1/2, one of the premixed wings is found to be dominant to such an extent that the diffusion flame and the other premixed flame are very weak by comparison. These curved, partially premixed flames are expected to be relevant in realistic configurations. In addition, a simple kinematic balance is shown to predict the shape of the front and the propagation velocity reasonably well in the limit of low stretch and low curvature.     

NH3/H2预混旋流火焰稳定性及燃烧极限实验研究

采用叶轮型旋流燃烧器,选取氢气作为燃料添加剂,研究了掺氢比对氨气旋流火焰稳定性的影响,分析了不同旋流数、叶片数、当量比以及预混气总流量条件下,旋流火焰形态变化。测定并分析了不同参数对旋流火焰燃烧极限范围的影响。结果表明,随掺氢比的增大,火焰逐渐由“V”型转化为稳定的“M”型,燃烧反应愈发充分;高旋流数(1.27)或低叶片数(6片)相比低旋流数(0.42)或高叶片数(8片)更有利于旋流火焰的稳定和燃烧的充分进行;相比富燃,贫燃有利于形成稳定的旋流火焰;预混气总流量较大时,火焰高度较高.对于燃烧极限,掺氢比越高,极限范围越大;总流量的变化对贫燃极限影响较小,对富燃极限影响较大;高旋流数(1.27)条件下,燃烧极限范围较大。     

A numerical study of auto-ignition in turbulent lifted flames issuing into a vitiated co-flow

This paper presents a numerical study of auto-ignition in simple jets of a hydrogen–nitrogen mixture issuing into a vitiated co-flowing stream. The stabilization region of these flames is complex and, depending on the flow conditions, may undergo a transition from auto-ignition to premixed flame propagation. The objective of this paper is to develop numerical indicators for identifying such behavior, first in well-known simple test cases and then in the lifted turbulent flames. The calculations employ a composition probability density function (PDF) approach coupled to the commercial CFD code, FLUENT. The in-situ-adaptive tabulation (ISAT) method is used to implement detailed chemical kinetics. A simple k–ε turbulence model is used for turbulence along with a low Reynolds number model close to the solid walls of the fuel pipe.

The first indicator is based on an analysis of the species transport with respect to the budget of convection, diffusion and chemical reaction terms. This is a powerful tool for investigating aspects of turbulent combustion that would otherwise be prohibitive or impossible to examine experimentally. Reaction balanced by convection with minimal axial diffusion is taken as an indicator of auto-ignition while a diffusive–reactive balance, preceded by a convective–diffusive balanced pre-heat zone, is representative of a premixed flame. The second indicator is the relative location of the onset of creation of certain radical species such as HO₂ ahead of the flame zone. The buildup of HO₂ prior to the creation of H, O and OH is taken as another indicator of autoignition.

The paper first confirms the relevance of these indicators with respect to two simple test cases representing clear auto-ignition and premixed flame propagation. Three turbulent lifted flames are then investigated and the presence of auto-ignition is identified. These numerical tools are essential in providing valuable insights into the stabilization behaviour of these flames, and the demarcation between processes of auto-ignition and premixed flame propagation.     

Injector spacing influences on flame blow-off in a linear array

Lean premixed flame stabilization at atmospheric conditions, in a linear array of five swirl injectors, was modeled using well-resolved large eddy simulation (LES) and chemical kinetics that were accurate both for ignition and flame speed. The effects of injector spacing were studied by selectively blocking injectors in the array to obtain five (F), two (T) and single (S) injector configurations. Each of these was simulated at well-anchored as well as near blow-off conditions. Experiments indicated a blow-off trend that was non-monotonic with spacing: the two-injector configuration exhibited the greatest resistance to blow-off, followed by the single-injector setup. The five-injector configuration proved to be the least resistant (by far) in comparison. In an earlier computational study [1], preferential blow-off in configuration F was successfully modeled and strong flame-flame interference could be investigated. This work is continued to assess the ability of a numerical model to study flames near blow-off, but with varying levels of flame-flame interaction. Passive scalar tracking was used to relate cross-injector transport of material to a given injector’s flame-holding ability. The non-monotonic blow-off trend could not be explained by stretch and heat release rate trends, but well-stirred reactor (WSR) theory was found to be more relevant as trends in recirculation zone residence times correlate well with blow-off sequences. In addition, cross-injector transport was studied due to the multi-injector scenario to assess how flameholding zones may be diluted. This work is expected to be useful for analyzing part-load behavior in multi-injector power-generating gas turbine combustion systems, and helps to characterize injector performance towards extending the range of lean operability.