Microbial Enhanced Oil Recovery in Fractional-Wet Systems: A Pore-Scale Investigation

Microbial enhanced oil recovery (MEOR) is a technology that could potentially increase the tertiary recovery of oil from mature oil formations. However, the efficacy of this technology in fractional-wet systems is unknown, and the mechanisms involved in oil mobilization therefore need further investigation. Our MEOR strategy consists of the injection of ex situ produced metabolic byproducts produced by Bacillus mojavensis JF-2 (which lower interfacial tension (IFT) via biosurfactant production) into fractional-wet cores containing residual oil. Two different MEOR flooding solutions were tested; one solution contained both microbes and metabolic byproducts while the other contained only the metabolic byproducts. The columns were imaged with X-ray computed microtomography (CMT) after water flooding, and after MEOR, which allowed for the evaluation of the pore-scale processes taking place during MEOR. Results indicate that the larger residual oil blobs and residual oil held under relatively low capillary pressures were the main fractions recovered during MEOR. Residual oil saturation, interfacial curvatures, and oil blob sizes were measured from the CMT images and used to develop a conceptual model for MEOR in fractional-wet systems. Overall, results indicate that MEOR was effective at recovering oil from fractional-wet systems with reported additional oil recovered (AOR) values between 44 and 80%; the highest AOR values were observed in the most oil-wet system.     

1D Simulations for Microbial Enhanced Oil Recovery with Metabolite Partitioning

We have developed a mathematical model describing the process of microbial enhanced oil recovery (MEOR). The one-dimensional isothermal model comprises displacement of oil by water containing bacteria and substrate for their feeding. The bacterial products are both bacteria and metabolites. In the context of MEOR modeling, a novel approach is partitioning of metabolites between the oil and the water phases. The partitioning is determined by a distribution coefficient. The transfer part of the metabolite to oil phase is equivalent to its ”disappearance,” so that the total effect from of metabolite in the water phase is reduced. The metabolite produced is surfactant reducing oil–water interfacial tension, which results in oil mobilization. The reduction of interfacial tension is implemented through relative permeability curve modifications primarily by lowering residual oil saturation. The characteristics for the water phase saturation profiles and the oil recovery curves are elucidated. However, the effect from the surfactant is not necessarily restricted to influence only interfacial tension, but it can also be an approach for changing, e.g., wettability. The distribution coefficient determines the time lag, until residual oil mobilization is initialized. It has also been found that the final recovery depends on the distance from the inlet before the surfactant effect takes place. The surfactant effect position is sensitive to changes in maximum growth rate, and injection concentrations of bacteria and substrate, thus determining the final recovery. Different methods for incorporating surfactant-induced reduction of interfacial tension into models are investigated. We have suggested one method, where several parameters can be estimated in order to obtain a better fit with experimental data. For all the methods, the incremental recovery is very similar, only coming from small differences in water phase saturation profiles. Overall, a significant incremental oil recovery can be achieved, when the sensitive parameters in the context of MEOR are carefully dealt with.     

Modeling and Simulation of Microbial Enhanced Oil Recovery Including Interfacial Area

The focus of this paper is the derivation of a nonstandard model for microbial enhanced oil recovery (MEOR) that includes the interfacial area (IFA) between oil and water. We consider the continuity equations for water and oil, a balance equation for the oil–water interfacial area, and advective–dispersive transport equations for bacteria, nutrients, and biosurfactants. Surfactants lower the interfacial tension (IFT), which improves oil recovery. Therefore, the parametrizations of the IFT reduction and residual oil saturation are included as a function of the surfactant concentration in the model. We consider for the first time in context of MEOR, the role of IFA in enhanced oil recovery. The motivation to include the IFA is to model the hysteresis in the capillary pressure–saturation relationship in a physically based manner, to include the effects of observed bacteria migration toward the oil–water interface and the production of biosurfactants at the oil–water interface. A comprehensive 2D implementation based on two-point flux approximation and backward Euler is proposed. An efficient and robust linearization scheme is used to solve the nonlinear systems at each time step. Illustrative numerical simulations are presented. The differences in the oil recovery profiles obtained with and without IFA are discussed. The presented model can also be used to design new experiments toward a better understanding and eventually optimization of MEOR.     

Wettability Alteration Mechanism for Oil Recovery from Fractured Carbonate Rocks

Oil can be recovered from fractured, initially oil-wet carbonate reservoirs by wettability alteration with dilute surfactant and electrolyte solutions. The aim of this work is to study the effect of salinity, surfactant concentration, electrolyte concentration, and temperature on the wettability alteration and identify underlying mechanisms. Contact angles, phase behavior, and interfacial tensions were measured with two oils (a model oil and a field oil) at temperatures up to 90°C. There exists an optimal surfactant concentration for varying salinity and an optimal salinity for varying surfactant concentration at which the wettability alteration on an oil-aged calcite plate is the maximum for anionic surfactants studied. As the salinity increases, the extent of maximum wettability alteration decreases; also the surfactant concentration needed for the maximum wettability alteration decreases. IFT and contact angle were found to have the same optimal salinity for a given concentration of anionic surfactants studied. As the ethoxylation increases in anionic surfactants, the extent of wettability alteration on calcite plates increases. Wettability of oil-aged calcite plates can be altered by divalent ions at a high temperature (90°C and above). Sulfate ions alter wettability to a greater extent in the presence of magnesium and calcium ions than in the absence. A high concentration of calcium ions can alter wettability alone. Magnesium ions alone do not change calcite plate wettability. Wettability alteration increases the oil recovery rate from initially oil-wet Texas Cordova Cream limestone cores by imbibition.     

Coreflooding Studies to Investigate the Potential of Carbonated Water Injection as an Injection Strategy for Improved Oil Recovery and CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> Storage

Carbonated water injection (CWI) is a CO₂-augmented water injection strategy that leads to increased oil recovery with added advantage of safe storage of CO₂ in oil reservoirs. In CWI, CO₂ is used efficiently (compared to conventional CO₂ injection) and hence it is particularly attractive for reservoirs with limited access to large quantities of CO₂, e.g. offshore reservoirs or reservoirs far from large sources of CO₂. We present the results of a series of CWI coreflood experiments using water-wet and mixed-wet Clashach sandstone cores and a reservoir core with light oil (n-decane), refined viscous oil and a stock-tank crude oil. The experiments were carried out to assess the performance of CWI and to quantify the level of additional oil recovery and CO₂ storage under various experimental conditions. We show that the ultimate oil recovery by CWI is higher than the conventional water flooding in both secondary and tertiary recovery methods. Oil swelling as a result of CO₂ diffusion into the oil and the subsequent oil viscosity reduction and coalescence of the isolated oil ganglia are amongst the main mechanisms of oil recovery by CWI that were observed through the visualisation experiments in high-pressure glass micromodels. There was also evidence of a change in the rock wettability that could also influence the oil recovery. The coreflood test results also reveal that the CWI performance is influenced by oil viscosity, core wettability and the brine salinity. Higher oil recovery was obtained with the mixed-wet core than the water-wet core, with light oil than with the viscous oil and low salinity carbonated brine than high-salinity carbonated brine. At the end of the flooding period, an encouraging amount of the injected CO₂ was stored in the brine and the remaining oil in the form of stable dissolved CO₂. The experimental results clearly demonstrate the potential of CWI for improving oil recovery as compared with the conventional water flooding (secondary recovery) or as a water-based EOR (enhanced oil recovery) method for watered out reservoirs.     

Network Modeling of EOR Processes: A Combined Invasion Percolation and Dynamic Model for Mobilization of Trapped Oil

A novel concept for modeling pore-scale phenomena included in several enhanced oil recovery (EOR) methods is presented. The approach combines a quasi-static invasion percolation model with a single-phase dynamic transport model in order to integrate mechanistic chemical oil mobilization methods. A framework is proposed that incorporates mobilization of capillary trapped oil. We show how double displacement of reservoir fluids can contribute to mobilize oil that are capillary trapped after waterflooding. In particular, we elaborate how the physics of colloidal dispersion gels (CDG) or linked polymer solutions (LPS) is implemented. The linked polymer solutions consist of low concentration partially hydrolyzed polyacrylamide polymer crosslinked with aluminum citrate. Laboratory core floods have shown demonstrated increased oil recovery by injection of linked polymer solution systems. LPS consist of roughly spherical particles with sizes in the nanometer range (50–150 nm). The LPS process involve mechanisms such as change in rheological properties effect, adsorption and entrapment processes that can lead to a microscopic diversion and mobilization of waterflood trapped oil. The purpose is to model the physical processes occurring on pore scale during injection of linked polymer solutions. A sensitivity study has also been performed on trapped oil saturation with respect to wettability status to analyze the efficiency of LPS on different wettability conditions. The network modeling results suggest that weakly wet reservoirs are more suitable candidates for performing linked polymer solution injection.     

The Impact of Pore Water Chemistry on Carbonate Surface Charge and Oil Wettability

Water chemistry has been shown experimentally to affect the stability of water films and the sorption of organic oil components on mineral surfaces. When oil is displaced by water, water chemistry has been shown to impact oil recovery. At least two mechanisms could account for these effects, the water chemistry could change the charge on the rock surface and affect the rock wettability, and/or changes in the water chemistry could dissolve rock minerals and affect the rock wettability. The explanations need not be the same for oil displacement of water as for water imbibition and displacement of oil. This article investigates how water chemistry affects surface charge and rock dissolution in a pure calcium carbonate rock similar to the Stevns Klint chalk by constructing and applying a chemical model that couples bulk aqueous and surface chemistry and also addresses mineral precipitation and dissolution. We perform calculations for seawater and formation water for temperatures between 70 and 130°C. The model we construct accurately predicts the surface potential of calcite and the adsorption of sulfate ions from the pore water. The surface potential changes are not able to explain the observed changes in oil recovery caused by changes in pore water chemistry or temperature. On the other hand, chemical dissolution of calcite has the experimentally observed chemical and temperature dependence and could account for the experimental recovery systematics. Based on this preliminary analysis, we conclude that although surface potential may explain some aspects of the existing spontaneous imbibitions data set, mineral dissolution appears to be the controlling factor.     

Injection of Acid Gas Mixtures in Sour Oil Reservoirs: Analysis of Near-Wellbore Processes with Coupled Modelling of Well and Reservoir Flow

The reinjection of sour or acid gas mixtures is often required for the exploitation of hydrocarbon reservoirs containing remarkable amounts of acid gases (H₂S and CO₂) to reduce the environmental impact of field exploitation and provide pressure support for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) purposes. Sour and acid gas injection in geological structures can be modelled with TMGAS, a new Equation of State (EOS) module for the TOUGH2 reservoir simulator. TMGAS can simulate the two-phase behaviour of NaCl-dominated brines in equilibrium with a non-aqueous (NA) phase, made up of inorganic gases such as CO₂ and H₂S and hydrocarbons (pure as well as pseudo-components), up to the high pressures (~100 MPa) and temperatures (~200°C) found in deep sedimentary basins. This study is focused on the near-wellbore processes driven by the injection of an acid gas mixture in a hypothetical high-pressure, under-saturated sour oil reservoir at a well-sector scale and at conditions for which the injected gas is fully miscible with the oil. Relevant-coupled processes are simulated, including the displacement of oil originally in place, the evaporation of connate brine, the salt concentration and consequent halite precipitation, as well as non-isothermal effects generated by the injection of the acid gas mixture at temperatures lower than initial reservoir temperature. Non-isothermal effects are studied by modelling in a coupled way wellbore and reservoir flow with a modified version of the TOUGH2 reservoir simulator. The described approach is limited to single-phase wellbore flow conditions occurring when injecting sour, acid or greenhouse gas mixtures in high-pressure geological structures.     

Impact of Rock Heterogeneity on Interactions of Microbial-Enhanced Oil Recovery Processes

Residual oil saturation reduction and microbial plugging are two crucial factors in microbial-enhanced oil recovery (MEOR) processes. In our previous study, the residual saturation was defined as a nonlinear function of the trapping number, and an explicit relation between the residual oil saturation and the trapping number was incorporated into a fully coupled biological (B) and hydrological (H) finite element model. In this study, the BH model is extended to consider the impact of rock heterogeneity on microbial-enhanced oil recovery phenomena. Numerical simulations of core flooding experiments are performed to demonstrate the influences of different parameters controlling the onset of oil mobilization. X-ray CT core scans are used to construct numerical porosity-permeability distributions for input to the simulations. Results show clear fine-scale fingering processing, and that trapping phenomena have significant effects on residual oil saturation and oil recovery in heterogeneous porous media. Water contents and bacterial distributions for heterogeneous porous media are compared with those for homogenous porous media. The evolution of the trapping number distribution is directly simulated and visualized. It is shown that the oil recovery efficiency of EOR/MEOR will be lower in heterogeneous media than in homogeneous media, largely due to the difficulty in supplying surfactant to unswept low-permeability zones. However, MEOR also provides efficient plugging along high-permeability zones which acts to increase sweep efficiency in heterogeneous media. Thus, MEOR may potentially be more suited for highly heterogeneous media than conventional EOR.     

Pore-Scale Imaging and Analysis of Wettability Order,Trapping and Displacement in Three-Phase Flow in Porous Media with Various Wettabilities

Three-phase flow in porous media is encountered in many applications including subsurface carbon dioxide storage, enhanced oil recovery, groundwater remediation and the design of microfluidic devices. However, the pore-scale physics that controls three-phase flow under capillary dominated conditions is still not fully understood. Recent advances in three-dimensional pore-scale imaging have provided new insights into three-phase flow. Based on these findings, this paper describes the key pore-scale processes that control flow and trapping in a three-phase system, namely wettability order, spreading and wetting layers, and double/multiple displacement events. We show that in a porous medium containing water, oil and gas, the behaviour is controlled by wettability, which can either be water-wet, weakly oil-wet or strongly oil-wet, and by gas–oil miscibility. We provide evidence that, for the same wettability state, the three-phase pore-scale events are different under near-miscible conditions—where the gas–oil interfacial tension is ≤?1 mN/m—compared to immiscible conditions. In a water-wet system, at immiscible conditions, water is the most-wetting phase residing in the corners of the pore space, gas is the most non-wetting phase occupying the centres, while oil is the intermediate-wet phase spreading in layers sandwiched between water and gas. This fluid configuration allows for double capillary trapping, which can result in more gas trapping than for two-phase flow. At near-miscible conditions, oil and gas appear to become neutrally wetting to each other, preventing oil from spreading in layers; instead, gas and oil compete to occupy the centre of the larger pores, while water remains connected in wetting layers in the corners. This allows for the rapid production of oil since it is no longer confined to movement in thin layers. In a weakly oil-wet system, at immiscible conditions, the wettability order is oil–water–gas, from most to least wetting, promoting capillary trapping of gas in the pore centres by oil and water during water-alternating-gas injection. This wettability order is altered under near-miscible conditions as gas becomes the intermediate-wet phase, spreading in layers between water in the centres and oil in the corners. This fluid configuration allows for a high oil recovery factor while restricting gas flow in the reservoir. Moreover, we show evidence of the predicted, but hitherto not reported, wettability order in strongly oil-wet systems at immiscible conditions, oil–gas–water, from most to least wetting. At these conditions, gas progresses through the pore space in disconnected clusters by double and multiple displacements; therefore, the injection of large amounts of water to disconnect the gas phase is unnecessary. We place the analysis in a practical context by discussing implications for carbon dioxide storage combined with enhanced oil recovery before suggesting topics for future work.

     

Displacement mechanisms of enhanced heavy oil recovery by alkaline flooding in a micromodel

Enhanced oil recovery (EOR) by alkaline flooding for conventional oils has been extensively studied. For heavy oils, investigations are very limited due to the unfavorable mobility ratio between the water and oil phases. In this study, the displacement mechanisms of alkaline flooding for heavy oil EOR are investigated by conducting flood tests in a micromodel. Two different displacement mechanisms are observed for enhancing heavy oil recovery. One is in situ water-in-oil (W/O) emulsion formation and partial wettability alteration. The W/O emulsion formed during the injection of alkaline solution plugs high permeability water channels, and pore walls are altered to become partially oil-wetted, leading to an improvement in sweep efficiency and high tertiary oil recovery. The other mechanism is the formation of an oil-in-water (O/W) emulsion. Heavy oil is dispersed into the water phase by injecting an alkaline solution containing a very dilute surfactant. The oil is then entrained in the water phase and flows out of the model with the water phase.     

Pore-Scale Monitoring of Wettability Alteration by Silica Nanoparticles During Polymer Flooding to Heavy Oil in a Five-Spot Glass Micromodel

It is well known that the oil recovery is affected by wettability of porous medium; however, the role of nanoparticles on wettability alteration of medium surfaces has remained a topic of debate in the literature. Furthermore, there is a little information of the way dispersed silica nanoparticles affect the oil recovery efficiency during polymer flooding, especially, when heavy oil is used. In this study, a series of injection experiments were performed in a five-spot glass micromodel after saturation with the heavy oil. Polyacrylamide solution and dispersed silica nanoparticles in polyacrylamide (DSNP) solution were used as injected fluids. The oil recovery as well as fluid distribution in the pores and throats was measured with analysis of continuously provided pictures during the experiments. Sessile drop method was used for measuring the contact angles of the glass surface at different states of wettability after coating by heavy oil, distilled water, dispersed silica nanoparticles in water (DSNW), polyacrylamide solution, and DSNP solution. The results showed that the silica nanoparticles caused enhanced oil recovery during polymer flooding by a factor of 10%. The distribution of DSNP solution during flooding tests in pores and throats showed strong water-wetting of the medium after flooding with this solution. The results of sessile drop experiments showed that coating with heavy oil, could make an oil-wet surface. Coating with distilled water and polymer solution could partially alter the wettability of surface to water-wet and coating with DSNW and DSNP could make a strongly water-wet surface.     

Simulations of Microbial-Enhanced Oil Recovery: Adsorption and Filtration

In the context of microbial-enhanced oil recovery (MEOR) with injection of surfactant-producing bacteria into the reservoir, different types of bacteria attachment and growth scenarios are studied using a 1D simulator. The irreversible bacteria attachment due to filtration similar to the deep bed filtration (DBF) is examined along with the commonly used reversible equilibrium adsorption (REA). The characteristics of the two models are highlighted. The options for bacteria growth are the uniform growth in both phases and growth of attached bacteria only. It is found that uniform growth scenario applied to filtration model provides formation of two oil banks during recovery. This feature is not reproduced by application of REA model or DBF with growth in attached phase. This makes it possible to select a right model based on the qualitative analysis of the experimental data. A criterion is introduced to study the process efficiency: the dimensionless time at which average recovery between pure water injection and maximum surfactant effect is reached. This characteristic recovery period (CRP) was studied as a function of the different MEOR parameters such as bacterial activity, filtration coefficients, and substrate injection concentrations. For both growth scenarios, there is a zone of optimal activity at which the CRP is minimal. Dependence of the CRP on substrate concentration for uniform growth scenario has also an optimal zone. Therefore, growth rate and the substrate concentration should be above a certain threshold value and still not be too high to obtain the minimum CRP. On the other hand, no such zone was found if the bacteria could grow only in the attached phase. Dependencies on both the injected concentration and filtration coefficient are monotonous in this case.     

A Percolation Study of Wettability Effect on the Electrical Properties of Reservior Rocks

Measurements of the electrical resistivity of oil reservoirs are commonly used to estimate other properties of reservoirs, such as porosity and hydrocarbon reserves. However, the interpretation of the measurements is based on empirical correlations, because the underlying mechanisms that control the electrical properties of oil bearing rocks have not been well understood. In this paper, we employ percolation concepts to investigate the effect of wettability on the electrical conductivity of a reservoir formation. A three-dimensional simple cubic network is used to represent an ideal reservoir formation, for which the effect of the wettability can be isolated from the others. The phase distribution in the network is analyzed for different flow processes, and the conductivity is then estimated using a power law approximation of the percolation quantities.To whom correspondence should be addressed.The proposed conceptual model predicts the generic behavior of reservoir resistivities of different wettabilities. It demonstrates that the resistivity index depends on saturation history and wettability. For strongly oil-wet systems, significant hysteresis is expected, while there is little hysteresis for strongly water-wet systems, and some hysteresis is also expected for intermediate wet systems. One of the interesting results from this study is that for intermediate wet systems, Archie's saturation exponent is between 1.9 and 3.0.Chemical Engineering Department, Technical University of Denmark, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark.     

Wetting Phase Bridges Establish Capillary Continuity Across Open Fractures and Increase Oil Recovery in Mixed-Wet Fractured Chalk

The effect of fractures on oil recovery and in situ saturation development in fractured chalk has been determined at near neutral wettability conditions. Fluid saturation development was monitored both in the matrix and in the fractures and the mechanisms of fracture crossing were determined using high spatial resolution MRI. Capillary continuity across open oil-filled fractures was verified by imaging the water bridges established within the fracture. Despite an alternate escape fracture for the water, separate water bridges were shown to be stable for the entire duration of the experiments. The established capillary contact resulted in oil recovery exceeding the spontaneous imbibition potential in the outlet-isolated cores by ca. 10% PV. This is explained by viscous recovery provided by water bridges across open fractures. The size of the bridges seemed to be controlled by the wettability of the rock and not by the differential pressure applied across the open fracture.     

Study of Microscopic and Macroscopic Displacement Behaviors of Polymer Solution in Water-Wet and Oil-Wet Media

Performance of a polymer flood process requires the knowledge of rheological behavior of the polymer solution and reservoir properties such as rock wettability. To provide a better understanding of effects of polymer chemistry and wettability on the performance of a polymer flood process, a comprehensive experimental study was conducted using a two-dimensional glass micromodel. A series of water and polymer flood processes were carried out at different polymer molecular weights, degrees of polymer hydrolysis, and polymer concentrations in both water-wet and oil-wet systems. Image processing technique was applied to analyze and compare microscopic and macroscopic displacement behaviors of polymer solution in each experiment. From micro-scale observations, the configuration of connate water film, polymer solution trapping, flow of continuous and discontinuous strings of polymer solution, piston-type displacement of oil, snap-off of polymer solution, distorted flow of polymer solution, emulsion formation, and microscopic pore-to-pore sweep of oil phase were observed and analyzed in the strongly oil-wet and water-wet media. Rheological experiments showed that a higher polymer molecular weight, degree of hydrolysis, and concentration result in a higher apparent viscosity for polymer solution and lower oil–polymer viscosity ratio. It is also shown that these parameters have different impacts on the oil recovery in different wettabilities. Moreover, a water-wet medium generally had higher recovery in contrast with an oil-wet medium. This experimental study illustrates the successful application of glass micromodel techniques for studying enhanced oil recovery (EOR) processes in five-spot pattern and provides a useful reference for understanding the displacement behaviors in a typical polymer flood process.     

Coreflooding Studies to Evaluate the Impact of Salinity and Wettability on Oil Recovery Efficiency

In this work, coreflood studies were carried out to determine the recovery benefits of low salinity waterflood compared to high salinity waterflood and the role of wettability in any observed recovery benefit. Two sets of coreflood experiments were conducted; the first set examined the EOR potential of low salinity floods in tertiary oil recovery processes, while the second set of experiments examined the secondary oil recovery potential of low salinity floods. Changes in residual oil saturation with variation in wettability, brine salinity and temperature were monitored. All the coreflood tests gave consistent increase in produced oil, corresponding to reduction in residual oil saturation and increase in water-wetness (for the second set of experiments) with decrease in brine salinity and increase in brine temperature.     

Flow behaviour in the presence of wettability heterogeneities

The physical processes occurring during fluid flow and displacement within porous media having wettability heterogeneities have been investigated in specially designed heterogeneous visual models. The models were packed with glass beads, areas of which were treated with a water repellent to create wettability variations. Immiscible displacement experiments show visually the effect of wettability heterogeneities on the formation of residual oil and recovery due to capillary trapping. This work demonstrates by experiment the importance of incorporating reservoir heterogeneity into pore displacement analysis, essential for the correct interpretation of core data and for directing the route for scale-up of the processes to reservoir scale.     

Effects of Fines Migration on Low-Salinity Waterflooding: Analytical Modelling

We discuss the governing system for oil–water flow with varying water composition. The model accounts for wettability alteration, which affects the relative permeability, and for salinity-variation-induced fines migration, which reduces the relative permeability of water. The overall ionic strength represents the aqueous phase composition in the model. One-dimensional displacement of oil by high-salinity water followed by low-salinity-slug injection and high-salinity water chase drive allows for exact analytical solution. The solution is derived using the splitting method. The analytical model obtained analyses the effects of wettability alteration and fines migration on oil recovery as two distinct physical mechanisms. For typical reservoir conditions, the significant effects of both mechanisms are observed.