Single ion-channel recordings using glass nanopore membranes

Protein ion-channel recordings using a glass nanopore (GNP) membrane as the support structure for lipid bilayer membranes are presented. The GNP membrane is composed of a single conical-shaped nanopore embedded in a approximately 50 microm-thick glass membrane chemically modified with a 3-cyanopropyldimethylchlorosilane monolayer to produce a surface of intermediate hydrophobicity. This surface modification results in lipid monolayer formation on the glass surface and a lipid bilayer suspended across the small orifice (100-400 nm-radius) of the GNP membrane, while allowing aqueous solutions to fully wet the glass nanopore. The GNP membrane/bilayer structures, which exhibit ohmic seal resistances of approximately 70 GOmega and electrical breakdown voltages of approximately 0.8 V, are exceptionally stable to mechanical disturbances and have lifetimes of at least 2 weeks. These favorable characteristics result from the very small area of bilayer (10(-10)-10(-8) cm(2)) that is suspended across the GNP membrane orifice. Fluorescence microscopy and vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy demonstrate that a lipid monolayer forms on the 3-cyanopropyl-dimethylchlorosilane modified glass surface with the lipid tails oriented toward the glass. The GNP membrane/bilayer structure is well suited for single ion-channel recordings. Reproducible insertion of the protein ion channel, wild-type alpha-hemolysin (WTalphaHL), and stochastic detection of a small molecule, heptakis(6-O-sulfo)-beta-cyclodextrin, are demonstrated. In addition, the insertion and removal of WTalphaHL channels are reproducibly controlled by applying small pressures (-100 to 350 mmHg) across the lipid bilayer. The electrical and mechanical stability of the bilayer, the ease of which bilayer formation is achieved, and the ability to control ion-channel insertion, coupled with the small bilayer capacitance of the GNP membrane-based system, provide a new and nearly optimal system for single ion-channel recordings.     

Transmembrane Signaling with Lipid‐Bilayer Assemblies as a Platform for Channel‐Based Biosensing

Artificial and natural lipid membranes that elicit transmembrane signaling is are useful as a platform for channel‐based biosensing. In this account we summarize our research on the design of transmembrane signaling associated with lipid bilayer membranes containing nanopore‐forming compounds. Channel‐forming compounds, such as receptor ion‐channels, channel‐forming peptides and synthetic channels, are embedded in planar and spherical bilayer lipid membranes to develop highly sensitive and selective biosensing methods for a variety of analytes. The membrane‐bound receptor approach is useful for introducing receptor sites on both planar and spherical bilayer lipid membranes. Natural receptors in biomembranes are also used for designing of biosensing methods.     

Computational analysis of local membrane properties

In the field of biomolecular simulations, dynamics of phospholipid membranes is of special interest. A number of proteins, including channels, transporters, receptors and short peptides are embedded in lipid bilayers and tightly interact with phospholipids. While the experimental measurements report on the spatial and/or temporal average membrane properties, simulation results are not restricted to the average properties. In the current study, we present a collection of methods for an efficient local membrane property calculation, comprising bilayer thickness, area per lipid, deuterium order parameters, Gaussian and mean curvature. The local membrane property calculation allows for a direct mapping of the membrane features, which subsequently can be used for further analysis and visualization of the processes of interest. The main features of the described methods are highlighted in a number of membrane systems, namely: a pure dimyristoyl-phosphatidyl-choline (DMPC) bilayer, a fusion peptide interacting with a membrane, voltage-dependent anion channel protein embedded in a DMPC bilayer, cholesterol enriched bilayer and a coarse grained simulation of a curved palmitoyl-oleoyl-phosphatidyl-choline lipid membrane. The local membrane property analysis proves to provide an intuitive and detailed view on the observables that are otherwise interpreted as averaged bilayer properties.     

Transport across artificial membranes–an analytical perspective

Biosensors that make use of transport processes across lipid membranes are very rare even though a stimulus, the binding of a single analyte molecule, can enhance the sensor response manifold if the analyte leads to the transport of more than one ion or molecule across the membrane. Prerequisite for a proper function of such membrane based biosensors is the formation of lipid bilayers attached to a support that allow for the insertion of membrane peptides and proteins in a functional manner. In this review, the current state of the art technologies to obtain lipid membranes on various supports are described. Solid supported membranes on transparent and electrically conducting surfaces, lipid bilayers on micromachined apertures and on porous materials are discussed. The focus lies on the applicability of such membranes for the investigation of transport phenomena across lipid bilayers facilitated by membrane embedded peptides, channel proteins and transporters. Carriers and channel forming peptides, which are easy to handle and rather robust, are used frequently to build up membrane based biosensors. However, channel forming proteins and transporters are more difficult to insert functionally and thus, there are yet only few examples that demonstrate the applicability of such systems as biosensor devices.      

Modeling membranes under a transmembrane potential

Accurate modeling of ion transport through synthetic and biological transmembrane channels has been so far a challenging problem. We introduce here a new method that allows one to study such transport under realistic biological conditions. We present results from molecular dynamics simulations of an ion channel formed by a peptide nanotube, embedded in a lipid bilayer, and subject to transmembrane potentials generated by asymmetric distributions of ions on both sides of the membrane. We show that the method is efficient for generating ionic currents and allows us to estimate the intrinsic conductance of the channel.     

The effect of secondary structures on the generation of characteristic events during the translocation of DNA hybrid through α-hemolysin

Nanopore has been developed to be a powerful,single-molecule analytical tool for sensing ions,small organic molecules and biomacromolecules such as proteins and DNAs.Generally,the identity of the analyte can be revealed by current amplitude changes and mean dwell time of the analyte binding events.In some cases,generation of highly characteristic current events affords an alternative way of analyte determination with high confidence level.However,we found that secondary structures in DNA/RNA hybrids might severely hinder the generation of signature events during their translocation through?-hemolysin nanopore.In this report,we propose a strategy to add a certain concentration of urea in the buffer solution for single channel recordings and validate that low concentration of urea can effectively denature the secondary structures in DNA hybrids and recover the generation of signature events.This finding might be useful in other secondary structure-related nanopore sensing activities.     

Fluorescence microscopy of the pressure-dependent structure of lipid bilayers suspended across conical nanopores

Glass and fused-quartz nanopore membranes containing a single conically shaped pore are promising solid supports for lipid bilayer ion-channel recordings due to the high inherent stability of lipid bilayers suspended across the nanopore orifice, as well as the favorable electrical properties of glass and fused quartz. Fluorescence microscopy is used here to investigate the structure of the suspended lipid bilayer as a function of the pressure applied across a fused-quartz nanopore membrane. When a positive pressure is applied across the bilayer, from the nanopore interior relative to the exterior bulk solution, insertion or reconstitution of operative ion channels (e.g., α-hemolysin (α-HL) and gramicidin) in the bilayer is observed; conversely, reversing the direction of the applied pressure results in loss of all channel activity, although the bilayer remains intact. The dependence of the bilayer structure on pressure was explored by imaging the fluorescence intensity from Nile red dye doped into suspended 1,2-diphytanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine bilayers, while simultaneously recording the activity of an α-HL channel. The fluorescence images suggest that a positive pressure results in compression of the bilayer leaflets and an increase in the bilayer curvature, making it suitable for ion-channel formation and activity. At negative pressure, the fluorescence images are consistent with separation of the lipid leaflets, resulting in the observed loss of the ion-channel activity. The fluorescence data indicate that the changes in the pressure-induced bilayer structure are reversible, consistent with the ability to repeatedly switch the ion-channel activity on and off by applying positive and negative pressures, respectively.     

DNA‐Based Nanopore Sensing

Nanopore sensing is an attractive, label‐free approach that can measure single molecules. Although initially proposed for rapid and low‐cost DNA sequencing, nanopore sensors have been successfully employed in the detection of a wide variety of substrates. Early successes were mostly achieved based on two main strategies by 1) creating sensing elements inside the nanopore through protein mutation and chemical modification or 2) using molecular adapters to enhance analyte recognition. Over the past five years, DNA molecules started to be used as probes for sensing rather than substrates for sequencing. In this Minireview, we highlight the recent research efforts of nanopore sensing based on DNA‐mediated characteristic current events. As nanopore sensing is becoming increasingly important in biochemical and biophysical studies, DNA‐based sensing may find wider applications in investigating DNA‐involving biological processes.     

Resistive-pulse studies of proteins and protein/antibody complexes using a conical nanotube sensor

There is increasing interest in using nanopores in synthetic membranes as resistive-pulse sensors for molecular and macromolecule analytes. In general, this method entails measuring current pulses associated with translocation of the analyte through the nanopore sensor element. A key challenge for this sensing paradigm is building selectivity into the protocol so that the current pulses for the target analyte can be distinguished from current pulses for other species that might be present in the sample. We show here that this can be accomplished with a protein analyte by adding to the solution an antibody that selectively binds the protein. We demonstrate this concept using bovine serum albumin (BSA) and a Fab fragment from a BSA-binding polyclonal antibody. Because the complex formed upon binding of the Fab to BSA is larger than the free BSA molecule, the current-pulse signature for the BSA/Fab complex can be easily distinguished from the free BSA. Furthermore, the BSA/Fab pulses can be easily distinguished from the pulses obtained for the free Fab and from pulses obtained for a control protein that does not bind to the Fab. Finally, we also show that the current-pulse signature for the BSA/Fab complex can provide information about the size and stoichiometry of the complex.     

Ion current calculations based on three dimensional Poisson-Nernst-Planck theory for a cyclic peptide nanotube

Ion current calculations based on Poisson-Nernst-Planck (PNP) theory are performed for a synthetic cyclic peptide nanotube that consists of eight or ten cyclo[(-L-Trp-D-Leu-)4] embedded in a lipid bilayer membrane to investigate the ion transport properties of the nanotube. To explore systems with arbitrary geometries, three-dimensional PNP theory is implemented using a finite difference method. The influence of dipolar lipid molecules on the ion currents is also examined by turning on or off the charges of the lipid dipoles in dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC). Comparisons between the calculated and experimentally measured ion currents show that the PNP approach agrees well with the measurements at low ion concentrations but overestimates the currents at higher concentrations. Concentration profiles reveal the selectivity of the peptide nanotube to cations, which is attributed to the negatively charged carbonyl oxygens inside the nanotube. The dominant cation and the minimum anion concentrations inside the cyclic peptide nanotube suggest that these cyclic peptide nanotubes can be employed as ion sensors. In the case of the polar DPPC bilayer, smaller currents are obtained in the calculation. The variation of current with polarity of the lipids implies that both polar and nonpolar lipid bilayer membranes can be utilized to regulate ion currents in the peptide nanotube and other ion channels. Strengths and limitations of the PNP theory are also discussed.     

Resistive-pulse detection of multilamellar liposomes

The resistive-pulse method was used to monitor the pressure-driven translocation of multilamellar liposomes with radii between 190 and 450 nm through a single conical nanopore embedded in a glass membrane. Liposomes (0% and 5% 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-l-serine (sodium salt) in 1,2-dilauroyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine or 0%, 5%, and 9% 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho(1'-rac-glycerol) (sodium salt) in 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) were prepared by extrusion through a polycarbonate membrane. Liposome translocation through a glass nanopore was studied as a function of nanopore size and the temperature relative to the lipid bilayer transition temperature, T(c). All translocation events through pores larger than the liposome, regardless of temperature, show translocation times between 30 and 300 μs and current pulse heights between 0.2% and 15% from the open pore baseline. However, liposomes at temperatures below the T(c) were captured at the pore orifice when translocation was attempted through pores of smaller dimensions, but squeezed through the same pores when the temperature was raised above T(c). The results provide insights into the deformation and translocation of individual liposomes through a porous material.     

Natural and artificial ion channels for biosensing platforms

The single-molecule selectivity and specificity of the binding process together with the expected intrinsic gain factor obtained when utilizing flow through a channel have attracted the attention of analytical chemists for two decades. Sensitive and selective ion channel biosensors for high-throughput screening are having an increasing impact on modern medical care, drug screening, environmental monitoring, food safety, and biowarefare control. Even virus antigens can be detected by ion channel biosensors. The study of ion channels and other transmembrane proteins is expected to lead to the development of new medications and therapies for a wide range of illnesses. From the first attempts to use membrane proteins as the receptive part of a sensor, ion channels have been engineered as chemical sensors. Several other types of peptidic or nonpeptidic channels have been investigated. Various gating mechanisms have been implemented in their pores. Three technical problems had to be solved to achieve practical biosensors based on ion channels: the fabrication of stable lipid bilayer membranes, the incorporation of a receptor into such a structure, and the marriage of the modified membrane to a transducer. The current status of these three areas of research, together with typical applications of ion-channel biosensors, are discussed in this review.     

Electrochemical biosensor based on supported planar lipid bilayers for fast detection of pathogenic bacteria

This paper presents a new ion-channel biosensor based on supported bilayer lipid membrane for direct and fast detection of Campylobacter species. The sensing element of a biosensor is composed of a stainless-steel working electrode, which is covered by artificial bilayer lipid membrane (BLM). Antibodies to bacteria embedded into the BLM are used as channel forming proteins. The biosensor has a strong signal amplification effect, which is defined as the total number of ions transported across the BLM. The total number of (univalent) ions flowing through the channels is 10¹⁰ ions s⁻¹. The biosensor showed a very good sensitivity and selectivity to Campylobacter species.     

Potential analytical applications of lysenin channels for detection of multivalent ions

Transmembrane protein transporters possessing binding sites for ions, toxins, pharmaceutical drugs, and other molecules constitute excellent candidates for developing sensitive and selective biosensing devices. Their attractiveness for analytical purposes is enhanced by the intrinsic amplification capabilities shown when the binding event leads to major changes in the transportation of ions or molecules other than the analyte itself. The large-scale implementation of such transmembrane proteins in biosensing devices is limited by the difficulties encountered in inserting functional transporters into artificial bilayer lipid membranes and by the limitations in understanding and exploiting the changes induced by the interaction with the analyte for sensing purposes. Here, we show that lysenin, a pore-forming toxin extracted from earthworm Eisenia foetida, which inserts stable and large conductance channels into artificial bilayer lipid membranes, functions as a multivalent ion-sensing device. The analytical response consists of concentration and ionic-species-dependent macroscopic conductance inhibition most probably linked to a ligand-induced gating mechanism. Multivalent ion removal by chelation or precipitation restores, in most cases, the initial conductance and demonstrates reversibility. Changes in lipid bilayer membrane compositions leading to the absence of voltage-induced gating do not affect the analytical response to multivalent ions. Microscopic current analysis performed on individual lysenin channels in the presence of Cu²⁺ revealed complex open–closed transitions characterized by unstable intermediate sub-conducting states. Lysenin channels provide an analytical tool with a built-in sensing mechanism for inorganic and organic multivalent ions, and the excellent stability in an artificial environment recommend lysenin as a potential candidate for single-molecule detection and analysis.     

Single molecule measurements within individual membrane-bound ion channels using a polymer-based bilayer lipid membrane chip

The measurement of single poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) molecules interacting with individual bilayer lipid membrane-bound ion channels is presented. Measurements were performed within a polymer microfluidic system including an open-well bilayer lipid membrane formation site, integrated Ag/AgCl reference electrodes for on-chip electrical measurements, and multiple microchannels for independent ion channel and analyte delivery. Details of chip fabrication, bilayer membrane formation, and alpha-hemolysin ion channel incorporation are discussed, and measurements of interactions between the membrane-bound ion channels and single PEG molecules are presented.     

Lipid bilayer membrane technologies: A review on single-molecule studies of DNA sequencing by using membrane nanopores

Nanopores based on α-hemolysin and MspA represent attractive sensing platforms due to easy production and operation with relatively low background noise. Such characteristics make them highly favorable for sequencing nucleic acids. Artificial lipid bilayer membranes, also referred to as black lipid membranes, in conjunction with membrane nanopores, can be applied to both the detection and highly efficient sequencing of DNA on a single-molecule level. However, the inherently weak physical properties of the membrane have impeded progress in these areas. Current issues impeding the ultimate recognition of the artificial lipid bilayer as a viable platform for detection and sequencing of DNA include membrane stability, lifespan, and automation. This review (with 105 references) highlights attempts to improve the attributes of the artificial lipid bilayer membrane starting with an overview on the present state and limitations. The first main section covers lipid bilayer membranes (BLM) in general. The following section reviews the various kinds of lipid bilayer membrane platforms with subsections on polymer membranes, solid-supported membranes, hydrogel-encapsulated membranes, shippable and storable membrane platforms, and droplet interface bilayers. A further section covers engineered biological nanopore sensor applications using BLMs with subsections offering a comparative view of different DNA sequencing methods, a detailed look at DNA Sequencing by synthesis using alpha-hemolysin nanopores, sequencing by synthesis using the MspA nanopore and quadromer map, and on limitations of sequencing based on synthesis technology. We present an outlook at the end that discusses current research trends on single-molecule sequencing to highlight the significance of this technology and its potential in the medical and environmental fields.

Open image in new window

Graphical abstract Sequencing by Synthesis, a novel method of sequencing DNA, uses the αHL biological nanopore and the artificial lipid bilayer membrane platform. Polymer tags attached to nucleotides bind to the polymerase-primer–template complex and are characterized by the nanopore upon release.

     

Miniaturized planar lipid bilayer: increased stability, low electric noise and fast fluid perfusion

A microfluidic device was designed allowing the formation of a planar lipid bilayer across a micron-sized aperture in a glass slide sandwiched between two polydimethylsiloxane channel systems. By flushing giant unilamellar vesicles through a 500-μm-wide channel above the hole, we were able to form a planar lipid bilayer across the hole, resulting in a giga-seal. We demonstrate incorporation of biological nanopores into the bilayer. This miniaturized system offers noise recordings comparable to open headstage noise (under 1 pA RMS at 10 kHz), fast precision perfusion on each side of the membrane and the use of nanoliter analyte volumes. This technique shows a promising potential for automation and parallelization of electrophysiological setups.     

Transmembrane nanopores from porphyrin supramolecules

A porphyrin-based nanopore was constructed through a bilayer lipid membrane (BLM). The macrocyclic porphyrin (the inner diameter = ca. 2.1 nm) having six carboxylic acid groups directed up and down was synthesized by self-assembly of three trisporphyrins, metathesis linking, and subsequent hydrolysis. The porphyrin was incorporated into soybean lecithin based BLM, and the ion currents through the nanopore were observed under 500 mM KCl, LiCl, CaCl2, and tetraalkylammonium chloride solutions, indicating formation of a large pore through BLM. Blocking of the ion current was achieved by addition of the polycationic fourth-generation PAMAM dendrimer.     

Analytical theory of hysteresis in ion channels: two-state model

Channel-forming proteins in a lipid bilayer of a biological membrane usually respond to variation of external voltage by changing their conformations. Periodic voltages with frequency comparable with the inverse relaxation time of the protein produce hysteresis in the occupancies of the protein conformations. If the channel conductance changes when the protein jumps between these conformations, hysteresis in occupancies is observed as hysteresis in ion current through the channel. We develop an analytical theory of this phenomenon assuming that the channel conformational dynamics can be described in terms of a two-state model. The theory describes transient behavior of the channel after the periodic voltage is switched on as well as the shape and area of the hysteretic loop as functions of the frequency and amplitude of the applied voltage. The area vanishes as the voltage period T tends to zero and infinity. Asymptotic behaviors of the loop area A in the high- and low-frequency regimes, respectively, are A approximately T and A approximately T(-1).     

Resistive-pulse DNA detection with a conical nanopore sensor

In this paper, we describe resistive-pulse sensing of two large DNAs, a single-stranded phage DNA (7250 bases) and a double-stranded plasmid DNA (6600 base pairs), using a conically shaped nanopore in a track-etched polycarbonate membrane as the sensing element. The conically shaped nanopore had a small-diameter (tip) opening of 40 nm and a large-diameter (base) opening of 1.5 microm. The DNAs were detected using the resistive-pulse, sometimes called stochastic sensing, method. This entails applying a transmembrane potential difference and monitoring the resulting ion current flowing through the nanopore. The phage DNA was driven electrophoretically through the nanopore (from tip to base), and these translocation events were observed as transient blocks in the ion current. We found that the frequency of these current-block events scales linearly with the concentration of the DNA and with the magnitude of the applied transmembrane potential. Increasing the applied transmembrane potential also led to a decrease in the duration of the current-block events. We also analyzed current-block events for the double-stranded plasmid DNA. However, because this DNA is too large to enter the tip opening of the nanopore, it could not translocate the pore. As a result, much shorter duration current-block events were observed, which we postulate are associated with bumping of the double-stranded DNA against the tip opening.