Encoding method for OBOC small molecule libraries using a biphasic approach for ladder-synthesis of coding tags

In the "one-bead one-compound" (OBOC) combinatorial library method, each compound bead displays only one compound entity. Hundreds of thousands to millions of compound beads can be synthesized rapidly and screened simultaneously. Positive compound beads are then isolated for structural analysis. To fully exploit the power of OBOC combinatorial small molecule libraries, a robust and high throughput encoding method is needed to decode the positive compound beads. In this paper, we report on the development of a novel encoding strategy that combines the concepts of ladder-synthesis and chemical encoding on bilayer beads. In these encoded libraries, small molecule compounds are displayed on the bead surface, and cleavable coding tags consisting of a series of truncated molecules reside in the bead interior. Such a library can be easily constructed using the biphasic approach (J. Am. Chem. Soc.2002, 124, 7678) to topologically segregate the functionalities of the beads during library synthesis. The ladder members and coding tags are then released for MALDI-TOF-MS analysis. To simplify the interpretation of the mass spectra, we purposely add bromine into the cleavable linker so that the cleavage products generate a characteristic isotope fingerprint. The chemical structure of library compounds can be determined by analyzing the mass differences between adjacent peaks on the mass spectra. This encoding strategy also provides valuable information on the quality of the testing compound on the surface of the bead. To validate this methodology, a model OBOC small molecule library with 12,288 members was synthesized on TentaGel beads and screened against streptavidin. The chemical structures of the compound on each positive bead were unambiguously identified.     

Partial alloc-deprotection approach for ladder synthesis of "one-bead one-compound" combinatorial libraries

The topologically segregated bilayer-bead concept has been applied to encoded "one-bead one-compound"(OBOC) combinatorial libraries to avoid the interference of coding tags with biological screening. In this paper, we report on the development of a novel partial Alloc-deprotection (PAD) approach and the use of this approach to establish a new ladder-synthesis method for OBOC combinatorial libraries to further exploit the concept. In the PAD approach, Alloc-protected beads are partially deprotected, sequentially layer by layer, starting from the outer layer toward the bead interior. The degree of deprotection (or thickness of each layer) is controlled by the time of exposure to the deprotecting agent, palladium. By repetitive use of the PAD approach, a small portion of Alloc-protected N termini in the bead interior is liberated in each synthetic cycle for generation of an additional ladder member such that each library bead will carry a full-length library compound on the bead surface and a series of truncated ladder members in the bead interior. For the libraries containing isobaric residues, a simple encoding strategy is introduced in the ladder-synthesis method so that the isobaric residues can be differentiated by the coding tags. One advantage of this encoding strategy is that the coding tags are confined together with the truncated ladder members in the bead interior, thus maintaining the arrangement that only the library compounds are displayed on the bead surface. The PAD approach of forming multiple concentric functional layers inside a bead is simple, reliable, and may have other applications in addition to OBOC combinatorial library bead encoding, such as the development of novel optically encoded beads for multiplex immunodiagnostics or even information recording.     

Global transformation of OBOC combinatorial peptide libraries into OBOC polyamine and small molecule libraries

In "one-bead-one-compound" (OBOC) combinatorial chemistry, a compound-bead library with hundreds of thousands to millions of diversities can be rapidly generated such that each bead displays only one chemical entity. The highly efficient "libraries-from-libraries" approach involves the global transformation of a peptide library into many small molecule solution-phase mixture libraries, but this approach has never been successfully applied to OBOC libraries. Here we report a novel approach that allows us to combine these two enabling technologies to efficiently generate OBOC encoded small molecule bead libraries. By using a topologically segregated bilayer bead and a "ladder-synthesis" method, we can prepare peptide libraries with the peptide on the bead surface and a series of peptide ladders in the bead interior. Various global transformation reactions can then be employed to transform the starting peptide library into a variety of peptidomimetic libraries. During the transformation reactions, the peptide ladders in the bead interior are also transformed in a predictable manner. As a result, individual compound bead can be decoded by analyzing the hydrogen fluoride-released encoding tags with matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization Fourier transform mass spectrometry. Using this novel approach, a random encoded dipeptide library was prepared and subsequently transformed into polyamine and poly- N-acetylamine sublibraries. Random beads isolated from these sublibraries were reliably decoded.     

OBOC small-molecule combinatorial library encoded by halogenated mass-tags

[reaction: see text] A bromine-/chlorine-containing mass-tag encoding strategy for a small-molecule OBOC combinatorial library is reported. The resulting MALDI FTMS isotope pattern of each tag clearly defines the component building blocks of each "hit" bead in an 1890-member demonstration library screened on-bead for binding against streptavidin via both enzyme-linked colorimetric and Quantum Dot/COPAS assays.     

A novel and rapid encoding method based on mass spectrometry for "one-bead-one-compound" small molecule combinatorial libraries

A novel and efficient encoding method based on mass spectrometry for "one-bead-one-compound" small molecule combinatorial libraries has been developed. The topologically segregated bifunctional resin beads with orthogonal protecting groups in the outer and inner regions are first prepared according to our previously published procedure. Prior to library synthesis, the inner core of each bead is derivatized with 3-4 different coding blocks on a cleavable linker. Each functional group on the scaffold is encoded by an individual coding block containing a functional group with the same chemical reactivity. During the library synthesis, the same chemical reactions take place on the scaffold (outer layer of the bead) and coding blocks (inner core of the bead) concurrently. After screening, the coding tags in the positive beads are released, followed by molecular mass determination using matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization Fourier transform mass spectrometry. The chemical structure of library compounds can be readily identified according to the molecular masses of the coding tags. The feasibility and efficiency of this approach were demonstrated by the synthesis and screening of a model small molecule library containing 84 672 member compounds, with a model receptor, streptavidin. Streptavidin binding ligands with structural similarity (17) were identified. The decoding results were clear and unambiguous.     

Rainbow beads: a color coding method to facilitate high-throughput screening and optimization of one-bead one-compound combinatorial libraries

We have developed a new color-encoding method that facilitates high-throughput screening of one-bead one-compound (OBOC) combinatorial libraries. Polymer beads displaying chemical compounds or families of compounds are stained with oil-based organic dyes that are used as coding tags. The color dyes do not affect cell binding to the compounds displayed on the surface of the beads. We have applied such rainbow beads in a multiplex manner to discover and profile ligands against cell surface receptors. In the first application, a series of OBOC libraries with different scaffolds or motifs are each color-coded; small samples of each library are then combined and screened concurrently against live cells for cell attachment. Preferred libraries can be rapidly identified and selected for subsequent large-scale screenings for cell surface binding ligands. In a second application, beads with a series of peptide analogues (e.g., alanine scan) are color-coded, combined, and tested for binding against a specific cell line in a single-tissue culture well; the critical residues required for binding can be easily determined. In a third application, ligands reacting against a series of integrins are color-coded and used as a readily applied research tool to determine the integrin profile of any cell type. One major advantage of this straightforward and yet powerful method is that only an ordinary inverted microscope is needed for the analysis, instead of sophisticated (and expensive) fluorescent microscopes or flow cytometers.     

Functional Peptides from One-bead One-compound High-throughput Screening Technique

Combinatorial chemistry provides a cost-effective method for the rapid discovery of new functional peptides. One-bead one-compound(OBOC) high-throughput screening technique offers a lot of structurally diverse peptides to be rapidly synthesized and screened for binding to a target of interest. The OBOC peptide library screening involves three main steps: library construction, positive beads separation, and peptide sequencing. This review mainly summarizes some special technique tips during functional peptide screening and potential future directions of the OBOC high-throughput screening technique.     

Image subtraction approach to screening one-bead-one-compound combinatorial libraries with complex protein mixtures

To screen one-bead-one-compound (OBOC) combinatorial bead libraries,(1) one generally uses tagged purified protein as the screening probe. Compound beads that interact with the purified protein are then identified, for example, via an enzyme-linked colorimetric assay, and isolated for structure determination. In this report, we demonstrate a rapid and efficient method to screen OBOC combinatorial libraries utilizing two protein mixtures as screening probes, and by comparing optical images of the beads stained by one protein mixture but not the other, ligand beads unique to one of the two protein mixtures can be identified. The significance of this method is that it allows for rapid selection of ligands directed against proteins unique to one mixture while screening out positive beads resulting from proteins common to both mixtures as well as beads that are positive as a result of interactions with chemical and protein components found in the assay itself. The method is fast, efficient, and uses off-the-shelf equipment.     

Synthesis, screening, and sequencing of cysteine-rich one-bead one-compound peptide libraries

Cysteine-rich peptides are valued as tags for biarsenical fluorophores and as environmentally important reagents for binding toxic heavy metals. Due to the inherent difficulties created by cysteine, the power of one-bead one-compound (OBOC) libraries has never been applied to the discovery of short cysteine-rich peptides. We have developed the first method for the synthesis, screening, and sequencing of cysteine-rich OBOC peptide libraries. First, we synthesized a heavily biased cysteine-rich OBOC library, incorporating 50% cysteine at each position (Ac-X8-KM-TentaGel). Then, we developed conditions for cysteine alkylation, cyanogen bromide cleavage, and direct MS/MS sequencing of that library at the single bead level. The sequencing efficiency of this library was comparable to a traditional cysteine-free library. To validate screening of cysteine-rich OBOC libraries, we reacted a library with the biarsenical FlAsH and identified beads bearing the known biarsenical-binding motif (CCXXCC). These results enable OBOC libraries to be used in high-throughput discovery of cysteine-rich peptides for protein tagging, environmental remediation of metal contaminants, or cysteine-rich pharmaceuticals.     

High-throughput sequence determination of cyclic peptide library members by partial Edman degradation/mass spectrometry

Cyclic peptides provide attractive lead compounds for drug discovery and excellent molecular probes in biomedical research. Large combinatorial libraries of cyclic peptides can now be routinely synthesized by the split-and-pool method and screened against biological targets. However, post-screening sequence determination of hit peptides has been problematic. In this report, a high-throughput method for the sequence determination of cyclic peptide library members has been developed. TentaGel microbeads (90 mum) were spatially segregated into outer and inner layers; cyclic peptides were displayed on the bead surface, whereas the inner core of each bead contained the corresponding linear peptide as the encoding sequence. After screening of the cyclic peptide library against a macromolecular target, the identity of hit peptides was determined by sequencing the linear encoding peptides inside the bead using a partial Edman degradation/mass spectrometry method. On-bead screening of an octapeptide library (theoretical diversity of 160 000) identified cyclic peptides that bind to streptavidin. A 400-member library of tyrocidine A analogues was synthesized on TentaGel macrobeads and solution-phase screening of the library directly against bacterial cells identified a tyrocidine analogue of improved antibacterial activity. Our results demonstrate that the new method for cyclic peptide sequence determination is reliable, operationally simple, rapid, and inexpensive and should greatly expand the utility of cyclic peptides in biomedical research.     

(19)F-encoded combinatorial libraries: discovery of selective metal binding and catalytic peptoids

A (19)F NMR method for encoding of combinatorial libraries has been developed. Aryl fluorides whose chemical shifts are modified by aromatic substituents were prepared and attached to resin support beads that were used in the split-pool synthesis of peptoids. The detection of the (19)F NMR signal of tags derived from a single "big bead" was demonstrated. The library diversity arises from peptoid amines and the cyclic anhydrides used in their acylation. The resulting 90-compound library was examined for metal ion binding, and novel ligands for iron and copper were discovered. Their binding constants were determined to be in the low micromolar range using conventional methods. The library was also examined for autocatalysis of acylation, and a molecule possessing the catalytic triad of serine proteases was deduced.     

Ligand design by a combinatorial approach based on modeling and experiment: application to HLA-DR4

Combinatorial synthesis and large scale screening methods are being used increasingly in drug discovery, particularly for finding novel lead compounds. Although these "random" methods sample larger areas of chemical space than traditional synthetic approaches, only a relatively small percentage of all possible compounds are practically accessible. It is therefore helpful to select regions of chemical space that have greater likelihood of yielding useful leads. When three-dimensional structural data are available for the target molecule this can be achieved by applying structure-based computational design methods to focus the combinatorial library. This is advantageous over the standard usage of computational methods to design a small number of specific novel ligands, because here computation is employed as part of the combinatorial design process and so is required only to determine a propensity for binding of certain chemical moieties in regions of the target molecule. This paper describes the application of the Multiple Copy Simultaneous Search (MCSS) method, an active site mapping and de novo structure-based design tool, to design a focused combinatorial library for the class II MHC protein HLA-DR4. Methods for the synthesizing and screening the computationally designed library are presented; evidence is provided to show that binding was achieved. Although the structure of the protein-ligand complex could not be determined, experimental results including cross-exclusion of a known HLA-DR4 peptide ligand (HA) by a compound from the library. Computational model building suggest that at least one of the ligands designed and identified by the methods described binds in a mode similar to that of native peptides.     

In‐Bead Screening of Hydroxamic Acids for the Identification of HDAC Inhibitors

A one bead–one compound screening format is presented. Following solid‐phase synthesis on a photolabile linker, library compounds were readily released and screened inside polymer beads. The release of screening compounds was readily controlled by varying photolysis time and light intensity. Dose‐response experiments were carried out to effectively distinguish high‐ and low‐affinity ligands. A library containing 55 800 compounds was synthesized and screened in a fluorometric assay, thereby identifying potent HDAC inhibitors with IC₅₀ values in the nanomolar range.     

A general method for designing combinatorial peptide libraries decodable by amino acid analysis

Herein we describe an algorithm for designing combinatorial peptide libraries for split-and-mix synthesis on solid support that are decodable by amino acid analysis (AAA) of the beads. AAA is a standard service analysis available in most biochemical laboratories, and it allows one to control the quality of the peptide on each bead, an important feature that is missing from most library decoding protocols. In the algorithm, each AA is assigned to two variable positions in the sequence grouped in a "unique pair". This arrangement limits sequence design because both the number of unique pairs U (setting the maximum number of variable AA) and the maximum number S of different AA per variable position depend on the peptide length N (U=N(N-1)/2), S=N-1). The method is therefore only suitable for focused libraries. An application example is shown for the selection of peptides with N-terminal proline or hydroxyproline catalyzing an aldol reaction from a combinatorial library of 65536 octapeptides. A simple enumeration program is available to help design combinatorial libraries decodable by amino acid analysis. The method applies to linear and cyclic peptides, can be used for nonnatural building blocks, including beta-amino acids, and should help to explore the vast chemistry of linear and cyclic peptide for catalysis and bioactivity.     

Imaging combinatorial libraries by mass spectrometry: from peptide to organic-supported syntheses

Supported peptide and drug-like organic molecule libraries were profiled in single nondestructive imaging static secondary ion mass spectrometric experiments. The selective rupture of the bond linking the compound and the insoluble polymeric support (resin) produced ions that were characteristic of the anchored molecules, thus allowing unambiguous resin bead assignment. Very high sensitivity and specificity were obtained with such a direct analytical method, which avoids the chemical release of the molecules from the support. Libraries issued from either mix-and-split or parallel solid-phase organic syntheses were profiled, demonstrating the usefulness of such a technique for characterization and optimization during combinatorial library development. Moreover, the fact that the control was effected at the bead level whatever the structure and quantity of the anchored molecules allows the sole identification of active beads selected from on-bead screening. Under such circumstances, the time-consuming whole-library characterization could thus be suppressed, enhancing the throughput of the analytical process.     

On‐Bead Screens Sample Narrower Affinity Ranges of Protein–Ligand Interactions Compared to Equivalent Solution Assays

Conceptually, on‐bead screening is one of the most efficient high‐throughput screening (HTS) methods. One of its inherent advantages is that the solid support has a dual function: it serves as a synthesis platform and as a screening compartment. Compound purification, cleavage and storage and extensive liquid handling are not necessary in bead‐based HTS. Since the establishment of one‐bead one‐compound library synthesis, the properties of polymer beads in chemical reactions have been thoroughly investigated. However, the characterization of the kinetics and thermodynamics of protein–ligand interactions on the beads used for screening has received much less attention. Consequently, the majority of reported on‐bead screens are based on empirically derived procedures, independent of measured equilibrium constants and rate constants of protein binding to ligands on beads. More often than not, on‐bead screens reveal apparent high affinity binders through strong protein complexation on the matrix of the solid support. After decoding, resynthesis, and solution testing the primary hits turn out to be unexpectedly weak binders, or may even fall out of the detection limit of the solution assay. Only a quantitative comparison of on‐bead binding and solution binding events will allow systematically investigating affinity differences as function of protein and small molecule properties. This will open up routes for optimized bead materials, blocking conditions and other improved assay procedures. By making use of the unique features of our previously introduced confocal nanoscanning (CONA) method, we investigated the kinetic and thermodynamic properties of protein–ligand interactions on TentaGel beads, a popular solid support for on‐bead screening. The data obtained from these experiments allowed us to determine dissociation constants for the interaction of bead‐immobilized ligands with soluble proteins. Our results therefore provide, for the first time, a comparison of on‐bead versus solution binding thermodynamics. Our data indicate that affinity ranges found in on‐bead screening are indeed narrower compared to equivalent interactions in homogeneous solution. A thorough physico‐chemical understanding of the molecular recognition between proteins and surface bound ligands will further strengthen the role of on‐bead screening as an ultimately cost‐effective method in hit and lead finding.     

A Cleavable Scaffold Strategy for the Synthesis of One-Bead One-Compound Cyclic Peptoid Libraries That Can Be Sequenced By Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Many macrocyclic depsipeptides or related compounds have interesting medicinal properties and often display more favorable pharmacokinetic properties than linear analogues. Therefore, there is considerable interest in the development of large combinatorial libraries of macrocyclic peptidomimetic compounds. However, such molecules cannot be easily sequenced by tandem mass spectrometry, making it difficult to identify hits isolated from library screens using one bead one compound libraries. Here we report a strategy to solve this problem by placing a methionine in both the linker connecting the cyclic molecule to the bead as well as within the cycle itself. Treatment with CNBr both linearizes the molecule at a specific position and releases the molecule from the bead, making its characterization by tandem MALDI mass spectrometry straightforward.     

Fast Epitope Mapping for the Anti‐MUC1 Monoclonal Antibody by Combining a One‐Bead‐One‐Glycopeptide Library and a Microarray Platform

Anti‐MUC1 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are powerful tools that can be used to recognize cancer‐related MUC1 molecules, the O‐glycosylation status of which is believed to affect binding affinity. We demonstrate the feasibility of using a rapid screening methodology to elucidate those effects. The approach involves i) “one‐bead‐one‐compound”‐based preparation of bilayer resins carrying glycopeptides on the shell and mass‐tag tripeptides coding O‐glycan patterns in the core, ii) on‐resin screening with an anti‐MUC1 mAb, iii) separating positive resins by utilizing secondary antibody conjugation with magnetic beads, and (iv) decoding the mass‐tag that is detached from the positive resins pool by using mass spectrometric analysis. We tested a small library consisting of 27 MUC1 glycopeptides with different O‐glycosylations against anti‐MUC1 mAb clone VU‐3C6. Qualitative mass‐tag analysis showed that increasing the number of glycans leads to an increase in the binding affinity. Six glycopeptides selected from the library were validated by using a microarray‐based assay. Our screening provides valuable information on O‐glycosylations of epitopes leading to high affinity with mAb.     

Solid phase combinatorial library of phosphinic peptides for discovery of matrix metalloproteinase inhibitors

A solid phase combinatorial library of 165,000 phosphinic peptide inhibitors was prepared and screened for activity against MMP-12. The inhibitors of the library had the structure XXX-Gpsi(PO2H-CH2)L-XXX, in which X is an arbitrary amino acid and Gpsi(PO2H-CH2)L is a Gly-Leu phosphinic dipeptide analogue. The library was constructed as a one-bead-two-compounds library so that every bead contained a common quenched fluorogenic substrate and a different putative inhibitor. In addition, the inhibitor part was prepared by ladder synthesis. After incubation with MMP-12, beads containing active inhibitors were selected, and the inhibitor sequences were recorded using MALDI-TOF MS. Statistical analysis of the sequences obtained from 86 beads gave rise to a consensus sequence which was resynthesized along with 20 related sequences. Three truncated sequences and 16 sequences originally present on beads were also resynthesized. The inhibitors were investigated in an enzyme kinetic assay with MMP-12 showing that the compounds derived from the consensus sequence were strong inhibitors with Ki values down to 6 nM, whereas the sequences originally present on beads varied in potency with Ki values from micromolar to nanomolar. Truncated sequences derived from the consensus sequence were poor inhibitors of MMP-12.     

A miniaturized arrayed assay format for detecting small molecule-protein interactions in cells

Background: Two complementary approaches to studying the cellular function of proteins involve alteration of function either by mutating protein-encoding genes or by binding a small molecule to the protein. A mutagen can generate millions of genetic mutations; correspondingly, split-pool synthesis can generate millions of unique ligands attached to individual beads. Genetic screening of mutations is relatively straightforward but, in contrast, split-pool synthesis presents a challenge to current methods of screening for compounds that alter protein function. The methods used to screen natural products are not feasible for large libraries composed of covalently immobilized compounds on synthesis beads. The sheer number of compounds synthesized by split-pool synthesis, and the small quantity of individual compound attached to each bead require assay miniaturization for efficient screening.Results: We present a miniaturized cell-based technique for the screening of ligands prepared by split-pool synthesis. Spatially defined droplets with uniform volumes of approximately 50–150 nanoliters (depending on well dimensions) are arrayed on plastic devices prepared using a combination of photolithography and polymer molding. Using this microtechnology, approximately 6,500 assays using either yeast cells or mammalian tissue culture can be performed within the dimensions of a standard 10 cm petri dish. We demonstrate that the biological effect of a small molecule prepared by split-pool synthesis can be detected in this format following its photorelease from a bead.Conclusions: The miniaturized format described here allows uniformly sized nanodroplets to be arrayed on plastic devices. The design is amenable to a large number of biological assays and the spatially arrayed format ensures uniform and controlled ligand concentrations and should facilitate automation of assays. The screening method presented here provides an efficient means of rapidly screening large numbers of ligands made by split-pool synthesis in both yeast and mammalian cells.