A Comparison of Large Scale Extraction Methods in the Study of Annular Wake Flow

Large scale periodic structures can exist in selected flow fields. Examples are the Precessing Vortex Core in swirling flows, vortex shedding behind a cylinder or the wake of an annular jet. A number of techniques are available to extract these large scales from the turbulent fluctuations in the flow field. In this paper, an analysis is made of three such methods: Eulerian Time Filtering (ETF), Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) and non-linear least-squares regression POD (NLSR-POD). The accuracy of the three different extraction methods is compared quantitatively with phase averaged data of an annular wake flow. This flow was chosen as a test case, since it is widely used in industrial applications, such as for example bluff-body burners. It was shown that all three methods were able to reconstruct the flow field with reasonable accuracy. These techniques are therefore applicable to a number of periodic flows. The big advantage of these extraction methods is that they require 20 times less experimental data compared to phase averaging. All three methods require more or less the same computational time and since the computational time is a few orders of magnitude lower than the measurement time, application of these techniques results in a very large reduction in the total time to obtain the flow field characteristics. This results in a significant reduction of time in the design process of such flows.     

Time-averaged flow characteristics and mixing properties of double-concentric jets

We examined the flow behaviors and mixing characteristics of double-concentric jets using laser-assisted smoke flow visualization method to analyze typical flow patterns and binary boundary detection technique to investigate jet spread width. Time-averaged velocity vectors, streamline patterns, velocity distributions, turbulence properties, and vorticity contours were analyzed using Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV). Topological flow patterns were analyzed to interpret the vortical flow structures. Mixing properties were investigated using a tracer-gas concentration detection method. Four characteristic modes were observed: annular flow dominated mode, transition mode, central jet dominated mode-low shear, and central jet dominated mode-high shear. The jets’ mixing properties were enhanced by two major phenomena: the merging of annular flow and central jet at the centerline and the large turbulence fluctuations produced in the flow field. The merging of the jets induced stagnation points on the central axis in the annular flow dominated mode, which caused reverse flow on the central axis and drastic turbulence fluctuations of the near field region. When the central jet penetrated the recirculation region in the other three modes, the stagnation points on the central axis and the reverse flow vanished. Therefore, the mixing behaviors were prominently enhanced in the annular flow dominated mode.     

An investigation of forced structures in turbulent jet flows

In many cases, turbulence is superimposed on an unsteady organized motion of a mean flow. In the past, these turbulent flows have been studied by time or ensemble averaging methods and some decomposition techniques such as proper orthogonal decomposition (POD). In this study, a new decomposition technique called the turbulence filter will be used to decompose the forced turbulent jet flows. By using the turbulence filtering technique, the fluctuating (turbulent) part and the more organized (forced) part of the velocity field are analyzed. Within this context several experiments on organized turbulent jet flow have been carried out. In the experiments, variable frequency and amplitude oscillation are imposed on a 1D jet. An elliptical plate was used in order to obtain sinusoidal forcing. The axial distance, Reynolds number and the forcing frequency of the signal were varied. The multiple hot wires (six probes) were used to investigate the evolution of the signal along the radial distance. The obtained results of the turbulence filter are compared with those of phase-averaging and POD techniques. The eigenmodes of the data are also evaluated by using the POD method. Received: 31 July 1998/Accepted: 19 January 2000     

Space–time correlation measurements of high-speed axisymmetric jets using optical deflectometry

An optical deflectometry system is used to provide unique space–time correlation measurements at two positions separated by varying axial distances within a high-speed jet shear layer. The measurements were made for both pure air and for helium/air mixture jets at Mach numbers M=0.9 and M=1.5. The jets issue from round nozzles and the sensing volumes at the two measurement positions consist of small light filaments along spanwise lines that are tangential to the annular jet shear layer. Applying this technique to obtain measurements detailing the level of correlation, spectral content, and convection velocity for jet flows in these flow regimes near the end of the potential core is particularly important in the understanding and prediction of jet noise. Measurements near the end of the potential core along the jet lip line exhibit distinct cross-correlation curves for the pure air jet cases. However, helium/air mixture jets display much lower levels of correlation and little evidence of large-scale structure in the measured spectra. It is believed that the thick visual density gradients dominated by smaller scales throughout the shear layer of the helium/air mixture jets effectively mask the large-scale structure, thus, reflecting a limitation of this optical deflectometer. Finally, a decrease in normalized convection velocity with helium addition is observed.     

Contrôle par jet pulsé de l'écoulement dans un divergent court à grand angle

This experimental study investigates the control of flow in a short diffuser with a 2×45° divergence angle, using wall synthetic jets. Measurements are made by particle image velocimetry. Velocity profiles, velocity fields, and vorticity maps show that the flow, initially separated as a free jet, undergoes a global excitation which creates periodic oscillating structures producing large fluid motions in the vicinity of the wall. This results in an increased mixing of the primary separated jet with the surrounding fluid.     

An experimental investigation of a large-scale structure of a two-dimensional backward-facing step by using advanced multi-point LDV

Measurements of spatio–temporal velocity fields at the separated shear layer and reattachment region of a two-dimensional backward-facing step flow are carried out simultaneously using a multi-point LDV. The objective of this paper is to clarify experimentally the structure of a large-scale structure of this flow field using a space and time correlation and conditional average. From the results of the correlation of the velocity fluctuation, the moving path of the vortex shedding from the separated shear layer to the reattachment region exhibits two patterns which it moves to near the wall region or the middle of the step height at the reattachment region. Especially, it moves to near the wall region when it grows larger in the separated shear layer. Moreover, the turbulence concerned with reattachment phenomenon transports from the reattachment region to a separated shear layer by recirculation flow. According to these transports of turbulence, a model for large-scale fluctuation is proposed as a self-excitation motion.     

Skin-friction drag reduction in a high-Reynolds-number turbulent boundary layer via real-time control of large-scale structures

While large-scale motions are most energetic in the logarithmic region of a high-Reynolds-number turbulent boundary layer, they also have an influence in the inner-region. In this paper we describe an experimental investigation of manipulating the large-scale motions and reveal how this affects the turbulence and skin-friction drag. A boundary layer with a friction Reynolds number of 14 400 is controlled using a spanwise array of nine wall-normal jets operated in an on/off mode and with an exit velocity that causes the jets in cross-flow to penetrate within the log-region. Each jet is triggered in real-time with an active controller, driven by a time-resolved footprint of the large-scale motions acquired upstream. Nominally, the controller injects air into large-scale zones with positive streamwise velocity fluctuations; these zones are associated with positive wall-shear stress fluctuations. This control scheme reduced the streamwise turbulence intensity in the log-region up to a downstream distance of more than five times the boundary layer thickness, δ, from the point of actuation. The highest reduction in spectral energy—more than 30%—was found for wavelengths larger than 5δ in the log-region at 1.7δ downstream of actuation, while scales larger than 2δ still comprised more than 15% energy reduction in the near-wall region. In addition, a 3.2% reduction in mean skin-friction drag was achieved at 1.7δ downstream of actuation. Our reductions of the streamwise turbulence intensity and mean skin-friction drag exceed a base line control-case, for which the jet actuators were operated with the same temporal pattern, but not synchronised with the incoming large-scale zones of positive fluctuating velocity.     

Experimental study of low precessing frequencies in the wake of a turbulent annular jet

This paper investigates the flow structure in the wake behind the centrebody of an annular jet using time-resolved stereoscopic PIV measurements. Although the time-averaged flow field is symmetric, the instantaneous wake is asymmetric. It consists of a central toroidal vortex (CTV), which closes downstream at the stagnation point. This stagnation point lies off-axis and hence the axis of the CTV is tilted with respect to the central axis of the geometry. The CTV precesses around the central axis, corresponding to a Strouhal number of 2.5 × 10⁻³. The phase averaging technique is used to study this large-scale motion as it can separate the precession from the turbulence in the flow field. It is found that the precession creates a highly three-dimensional flow field and for instance near the stagnation point, up to 45% of the rms velocity fluctuations are attributed to it.     

Experimental study of a three-dimensional large-scale structure in a reciprocating oscillatory flow

An experimental investigation has been conducted on the large-scale structure of the reciprocating oscillatory turbulent flow in a rectangular duct. Using hot-wire anemometers and conditional sampling technique, we found that the Reynolds stress generated explosively in the decelerating phase, a characteristic feature of the flow, is caused by the three-dimensional large-scale structure. These structures are revealed to be a pair of counter-rotating fluid motions which change their form gradually as the phase-averaged velocity distribution changes. Phase differences of the turbulence intensity distribution in an oscillatory flow are found to take place in accordance with the generation-growth-decay process of the large-scale structure.     

Reconstruction of a quasi-instantaneous image of coherent structures from hotwire signals obtained by a multi-point simultaneous measurement system

The turbulent velocity components (u, v) at 11 points in a reciprocating oscillatory turbulent flow have been measured simultaneously by a set of eleven X-type hotwire probes located in a plane perpendicular to the mean flow. Using a conditional sampling technique and a new method of data analysis for the inverse estimation of flow fields called the “virtual plate/load and MASCON model”, a quasi-instantaneous three-dimensional image of coherent structures of turbulence was first reconstructed directly from the experimental velocity data. The quasi-instantaneous image was expressed in terms of the velocity components u, v, w and the vorticity components ω_x ω_y, ω_z and we found that the large-scale coherent structure was composed of a pair of counter-rotating fluid motions with asymmetry which was quite different from that of the ensemble-averaged one. Flow patterns induced by the large-scale structure have been clarified by perspective representations visualized by computer simulations that produce timelines and streaklines of fluid particle traces. Results showed that the new experimental method was applicable for investigating the three-dimensional feature of coherent structures including asymmetry.     

Turbulence characteristics of radially-confined impinging jet flows

Radially confined, axisymmetric impinging jet flows are investigated by using the standard particle image velocimetry experimental technique. The confinement is achieved by placing a confinement block around a jet, co-axially. The inner diameter of the block is successively varied to nine different values. The inlet-based Reynolds number of the jet is kept constant at 5000. The nine diametric values yielded nine different flows of widely different characteristics. Among other usage, an insight into the flow characteristics can be helpful in designing compact impinging jet applications, as such a radially confined flow is equivalent to passing the pre-impingement jet through a hole perforated in a solid wall (i.e. the jet source can be placed behind a wall). The study has revealed that the flows, in general, form two circulation zones, three mixing layers, and two boundary layers. Based on turbulence characteristics of the five shear layers, overall characteristics of the flows are understood systematically. Mean velocity and various turbulence statistics are also presented, and mechanisms underlying behind their variations are explained. Finally, scaling laws are obtained for the mean velocity and for the turbulence statistics, both in the impingement and in the wall jet regions.     

Higher-order and length-scale statistics of velocity and temperature fluctuations in turbulent boundary layer along a heated vertical flat plate

Time-developing direct numerical simulation (DNS) was performed to clarify the higher-order turbulent behaviors in the thermally-driven boundary layers both in air and water along a heated vertical flat plate. The predicted statistics of the heat transfer rates and the higher-order turbulent behaviors such as skewness factors, flatness factors and spatial correlation coefficients of the velocity and temperature fluctuations in the natural-convection boundary layer correspond well with those obtained from experiments for space-developing flows. The numerical results reveal that the turbulent structures of the buoyancy-driven boundary layers are mainly controlled by the fluid motions in the outer region of the boundary layer, and these large-scale structures are strongly connected with the generation of turbulence in the thermally-driven boundary layers, in accordance with the actual observations for space-developing flows. Moreover, to specify the turbulence structures of the boundary layers, the cross-correlation coefficients and the characteristic length scales are examined for the velocity and thermal fields. Consequently, it is found that with a slight increase in freestream velocity, the cross-correlation coefficient for the Reynolds shear stress and turbulent heat flux increases for opposing flow and decreases for aiding flow, and the integral scales for the velocity and temperature fields become larger for opposing flow and smaller for aiding flow compared with those for the pure natural-convection boundary layer.     

Investigation of noise generation by turbulent jets on the basis of numerical simulation of unsteady flow in mixing layers

In the previous experimental studies it was concluded that the turbulent jet noise is produced by large-scale motions in the mixing layer induced by turbulence intermittence. The burden of this numerical simulation is the validation of these conclusions. As a result of numerical calculations, the “instantaneous” flow patterns and the parameter distributions in the initial regions of turbulent jets are obtained. On the basis of this information the flow dynamics are investigated. In the jet flow there are observable slowly transforming low static pressure regions and zones of elevated static pressure. These regions are displaced at the convection velocity. The inflow induced by the low pressure in the mixing layer has streamlines entering into the low pressure zones and flowing around the elevated pressure zones. The motion of the zones of the static pressure varying along the flow produces velocity disturbances in the induced external flow. The succession of the transformations of the intermittence-induced static pressure disturbances into sound waves is determined. This transformation occurs in the regions occupied by the ejected air.     

Determination of two-dimensional space–time correlations in jet flows using simultaneous PIV and LDV measurements

The two-dimensional space–time turbulence statistics of free shear jet flows in the form of the two-point velocity correlation tensor are important for aeroacoustic noise source modelling based on the acoustic analogy approach. This paper presents a direct application of the Point-Referenced Global Correlation (PRGC) technique to measure the components of this correlation tensor for a sector of the flow field in two jet configurations. The PRGC approach combines single point and global measurement techniques and enables two-point space–time correlations over a region of the flow to be obtained. The technique is applied to a single stream jet and a co-axial coplanar jet at a Mach number of 0.24 using commercial Laser Doppler velocimetry (LDV) and low-speed particle image velocimetry (PIV) systems. Results for the one-dimensional correlations are shown to compare well with two-point measurements. The results for the two-dimensional space–time correlations are presented and the characteristics for both configurations discussed.     

Computation of a drastic flow pattern change in an annular swirling jet caused by a small decrease in inlet swirl

This paper investigates the flow pattern change in an annular jet caused by a sudden change in the level of inlet swirl. The jet geometry consists of an annular channel followed by a specially designed stepped‐conical nozzle, which allows the existence of four different flow patterns as a function of the inlet swirl number. This paper reports on the transition between two of them, called the ‘open jet flow high swirl’ and the ‘Coanda jet flow.’ It is shown that a small sudden decrease of 4% in inlet swirl results in a drastic and irreversible change in flow pattern. The objective of this paper is to reveal the underlying physical mechanisms in this transition by means of numerical simulations. The flow is simulated using the unsteady Reynolds‐averaged Navier–Stokes (URANS) approach for incompressible flow with a Reynolds stress turbulence model. The analysis of the numerical results is based on a study of different forces on a control volume, which consists of the jet boundaries. The analysis of these forces shows that the flow pattern change consists of three different regimes: an immediate response regime, a quasi‐static regime and a Coanda regime. The simulation reveals that the pressure–tangential velocity coupling during the quasi‐static regime and the Coanda effect at the nozzle outlet during the Coanda regime are the driving forces behind the flow pattern change. These physical mechanisms are validated with time‐resolved stereo‐PIV measurements, which confirm the numerical simulations. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Turbulence modification in vertical upward annular flow passing through a throat section

Experimental studies on the turbulence modification in annular two-phase flow passing through a throat section were carried out. The turbulence modification in multi-phase flow due to the interactions between two-phases is one of the most interesting scientific issues and has attracted research attention. In this study, the gas-phase turbulence modification in annular flow due to the gas–liquid phase interaction is experimentally investigated. The annular flow passing through a throat section is under the transient state due to the changing cross sectional area of the channel and resultantly the superficial velocities of both phases are changed compared with a fully developed flow in a straight pipe. The measurements for the gas-phase turbulence were precisely performed by using a constant temperature hot-wire anemometer, and made clear the turbulence structure such as velocity profiles, fluctuation velocity profiles. The behavior of the interfacial waves in the liquid film flow such as the ripple or disturbance waves was also observed. The measurements for the liquid film thickness by the electrode needle method were also performed to measure the base film thickness, mean film thickness, maximum film thickness and wave height of the ripple or the disturbance waves.     

Effects of Small- and Large-Scale Structures in a Piloted Jet Diffusion Flame

Laser Doppler Anemometry (LDA) and Planar Laser-Induced Fluorescence (PLIF) measurements have been performed in a turbulent nonpremixed jet flame. One of the features of this configuration is a central co-axial fuel jet surrounded by a turbulent annular air flow. The whole is placed within a low-speed coflowing air stream. This three-flow system with turbulent primary air differs from flow systems used for nonpremixed jet flames reported in the literature and is very useful for obtaining information on the mixing process between fuel and primary air. Next to the characterization of the velocity field, special attention has been paid to the conditional seeding of the central fuel jet and of the annular air flow. Together with visualizations of the OH radical, an important combustion intermediate which is formed during combustion, and the NO radical, which is seeded to the central jet flow, the resulting statistics reveal the properties of small- and large-scale structures in the flame.     

Numerical study of unsteady flow and heat transfer of circular tangential direction jets flowing over the inner cylinder surface in the annular chamber

In order to understand the dynamics of vortices on heat transfer, the unsteady flow field of tangential direction jets flowing in the annular chamber is numerically investigated by scale-adaptive simulation (SAS). The jet Reynolds number is 332,000 based on the jet’s diameter and inflow velocity for a specific geometric model. The analogy theory is used to obtain the convective heat transfer coefficient distribution on the hub surface. Spectral analysis via fast Fourier transform (FFT) is used to analyze frequency information that flows inside the chamber. The proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) method is performed on the velocity field in the chamber and the convective heat transfer coefficient on the hub surface using a snapshot method. The fast Fourier transform helps find the dominant frequency of the unsteady flow in the chamber. The time sequence of velocity fields on the radial plane shows the presence of cyclic flapping of the jet. The proper orthogonal decomposition analysis indicates that the unsteady periodic flow phenomenon in the chamber and unsteady heat transfer on the hub surface are mainly related to the dynamics of the counter-rotating vortices caused by the jet.     

Numerical study of hysteresis in annular swirling jets with a stepped‐conical nozzle

This study investigates the experimentally observed hysteresis in the mean flow field of an annular swirling jet with a stepped‐conical nozzle. The flow is simulated using the Reynolds‐averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) approach for incompressible flow with a k–ε and a Reynolds stress transport (RSTM) turbulence model. Four different flow structures are observed depending on the swirl number: ‘closed jet flow’, ‘open jet flow low swirl’, ‘open jet flow high swirl’ and ‘coanda jet flow’. These flow patterns change with varying swirl number and hysteresis at low and intermediate swirl numbers is revealed when increasing and subsequently decreasing the swirl. The influence of the inlet velocity profile on the transitional swirl numbers is investigated. When comparing computational fluid dynamics with experiments, the results show that both turbulence models predict the four different flow structures and the associated hysteresis and multiple solutions at low and intermediate swirl numbers. Therefore, a good agreement exists between experiments and numerics. Copyright © 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.