Structure and reactivity of the dammarenyl cation: configurational transmission in triterpene synthesis

[reaction: see text] The dammarenyl cation (13) is the last common intermediate in the cyclization of oxidosqualene to a diverse array of secondary triterpene metabolites in plants. We studied the structure and reactivity of 13 to understand the factors governing the regio- and stereospecificity of triterpene synthesis. First, we demonstrated that 13 has a 17beta side chain in Arabidopsis thaliana lupeol synthase (LUP1) by incubating the substrate analogue (18E)-22,23-dihydro-20-oxaoxidosqualene (21) with LUP1 from a recombinant yeast strain devoid of other cyclases and showing that the sole product of 21 was 3beta-hydroxy-22,23,24,25,26,27-hexanor-17beta-dammaran-20-one. Quantum mechanical calculations were carried out on gas-phase models to show that the 20-oxa substitution has negligible effect on substrate binding and on the activation energies of reactions leading to either C17 epimer of 13. Further molecular modeling indicated that, because of limited rotational freedom in the cyclase active site cavity, the C17 configuration of the tetracyclic intermediate 13 can be deduced from the angular methyl configuration of the pentacyclic or 6-6-6-6 tetracyclic product. This rule of configurational transmission aided in elucidating the mechanistic pathway accessed by individual cyclases. Grouping of cyclases according to mechanistic and taxonomic criteria suggested that the transition between pathways involving 17alpha and 17beta intermediates occurred rarely in evolutionary history. Two other mechanistic changes were also rare, whereas variations on cation rearrangements evolved readily. This perspective furnished insights into the phylogenetic relationships of triterpene synthases.     

Enzymatic cyclization of dioxidosqualene to heterocyclic triterpenes

Oxidosqualene cyclases normally produce triterpenes from 2,3-(S)-oxidosqualene (OS) but also can cyclize its minor companion (3S,22S)-2,3:22,23-dioxidosqualene (DOS). We explored DOS cyclization in plant triterpene synthesis using a recombinant lupeol synthase (LUP1) heterologously expressed in yeast. Incubation of LUP1 with 3S,22S-DOS gave epoxydammaranes epimeric at C20 and a 17,24-epoxybaccharane in a 4:2:3 ratio. The products reflected a new mechanistic paradigm for DOS cyclization. The structures were determined by NMR and GC-MS, and recent errors in the epoxydammarane literature were rectified. Some DOS metabolites are likely candidates for regulating triterpenoid biosynthesis, while others may be precursors of saponin aglycones. Our in vivo experiments in yeast generated substantial amounts of DOS metabolites in a single enzymatic step, suggesting a seminal role for the DOS shunt pathway in the evolution of saponin synthesis. Quantum mechanical calculations revealed oxonium ion intermediates, whose reactivity altered the usual mechanistic patterns of triterpene synthesis. Further analysis indicated that the side chain of the epoxydammarenyl cation intermediate is in an extended conformation. The overall results establish new roles for DOS in triterpene synthesis and exemplify how organisms can increase the diversity of secondary metabolites without constructing new enzymes.     

Mechanistic insights into oxidosqualene cyclizations through homology modeling

2,3-Oxidosqualene cyclases (OSC) are key enzymes in sterol biosynthesis. They catalyze the stereoselective cyclization and skeletal rearrangement of (3S)-2,3-oxidosqualene to lanosterol in mammals and fungi and to cycloartenol in algae and higher plants. Sequence information and proposed mechanism of 2,3-oxidosqualene cyclases are closely related to those of squalene-hopene cyclases (SHC), which represent functional analogs of OSCs in bacteria. SHCs catalyze the cationic cyclization cascade converting the linear triterpene squalene to fused ring compounds called hopanoids. High stereoselectivity and precision of the skeletal rearrangements has aroused the interest of researchers for nearly half a century, and valuable data on studying mechanistic details in the complex enzyme-catalyzed cyclization cascade has been collected. Today, interest in cyclases is still unbroken, because OSCs became targets for the development of antifungal and hypocholesterolemic drugs. However, due to the large size and membrane-bound nature of OSCs, three-dimensional structural information is still not available, thus preventing a complete understanding of the atomic details of the catalytic mechanism. In this work, we discuss results gained from homology modeling of human OSC based on structural information of SHC from Alicyclobacillus acidocaldarius and propose a structural model of human OSC. The model is in accordance with previously performed experimental studies with mechanism-based suicide inhibitors and mutagenesis experiments with altered activity and product specificity. Structural insight should strongly stimulate structure-based design of antifungal or cholesterol-lowering drugs.     

Stereochemistry of water addition in triterpene synthesis: the structure of arabidiol

An oxidosqualene cyclase from Arabidopsis thaliana makes arabidiol, a tricyclic triterpene reported with indeterminate side-chain stereochemistry. We established the full structure of arabidiol through chemical degradation, NOE experiments, and molecular modeling. By examining the mechanistic constraints that govern water addition in triterpene synthesis, we further show how the stereochemistry of hydroxylation can generally be deduced a priori, why deprotonation is more common than hydroxylation, and why cyclases that perform hydroxylation also generate olefinic byproducts.     

Terpenoid Biosynthesis Off the Beaten Track: Unconventional Cyclases and Their Impact on Biomimetic Synthesis

Terpene and terpenoid cyclizations are counted among the most complex chemical reactions occurring in nature and contribute crucially to the tremendous structural diversity of this largest family of natural products. Many studies were conducted at the chemical, genetic, and biochemical levels to gain mechanistic insights into these intriguing reactions that are catalyzed by terpene and terpenoid cyclases. A myriad of these enzymes have been characterized. Classical textbook knowledge divides terpene/terpenoid cyclases into two major classes according to their structure and reaction mechanism. However, recent discoveries of novel types of terpenoid cyclases illustrate that nature’s enzymatic repertoire is far more diverse than initially thought. This Review outlines novel terpenoid cyclases that are out of the ordinary.     

Chemical phenotypes of the hmg1 and hmg2 mutants of Arabidopsis demonstrate the in-planta role of HMG-CoA reductase in triterpene biosynthesis

Plants produce a wide variety of cyclic triterpenes, such as sterols and triterpenoids, which are the major products of the mevalonate (MVA) pathway. It is important to understand the physiological functions of HMG-CoA reductase (HMGR) because HMGR is the rate-limiting enzyme in the MVA pathway. We have previously isolated Arabidopsis mutants in HMG1 and HMG2. Although the biochemical function of HMGR2 has been thought to be almost equal to that of HMGR1, based on similarities in their sequences, the phenotypes of mutants in these genes are quite different. Whereas hmg2 shows no abnormal phenotype under normal growth conditions, hmg1 shows pleiotropic phenotypes, including dwarfing, early senescence, and male sterility. We previously postulated that the 50% decrease in the sterol content of hmg1, as compared to that in the wild type, was a cause of these phenotypes, but comprehensive triterpene profiles of these mutants had not yet been determined. Here, we present the triterpene profiles of hmg1 and hmg2. In contrast to hmg1, hmg2 showed a sterol content 15% lower than that of the wild type. A precise triterpenoid quantification using synthesized deuterated compounds of beta-amyrin (1), alpha-amyrin (2), and lupeol (3) showed that the levels of triterpenoids in hmg1 and hmg2 were 65% and 25% lower than in the wild type (WT), respectively. These results demonstrate that HMGR2 as well as HMGR1 is responsible for the biosynthesis of triterpenes in spite of the lack of visible phenotypes in hmg2.     

Insights into the Dual Activity of a Bifunctional Dehydratase‐Cyclase Domain

Oxygen‐containing heterocycles are a common structural motif in polyketide natural products and contribute significantly to their biological activity. Here, we report structural and mechanistic investigations on AmbDH3, a polyketide synthase domain with dual activity as dehydratase (DH) and pyran‐forming cyclase in ambruticin biosynthesis. AmbDH3 is similar to monofunctional DH domains, using H51 and D215 for dehydration. V173 was confirmed as a diagnostic residue for cyclization activity by a mutational study and enzymatic in vitro experiments. Similar motifs were observed in the seemingly monofunctional AmbDH2, which also shows an unexpected cyclase activity. Our results pave the way for mining of hidden cyclases in biosynthetic pathways. They also open interesting prospects for the generation of novel biocatalysts for chemoenzymatic synthesis and pyran‐polyketides by combinatorial biosynthesis.     

Enzyme Mechanisms for Polycyclic Triterpene Formation

The mechanisms by which triterpene cyclases transform olefins into complex and biologically important polycyclic products have fueled nearly half a century of intense research. Recent chemical and biological studies, together with previous findings, provide intriguing new insights into the enzymatic mechanism of triterpene formation and form a surprisingly detailed picture of these elegant catalysts. It can be concluded that the role of the oxidosqualene cyclases involves protection of the intermediate carbocation against addition of water or deprotonation by base, thereby allowing the shift of the hydride and methyl groups along a thermodynamically and kinetically favorable cascade. Key questions in the areas of structural biology, site-directed mutagenesis, and directed evolution are apparent, now that the first structure of a triterpene cyclase is known.     

Trinorlupeol: a major nonsterol triterpenoid in Arabidopsis

We report the structure determination of 20,29,30-trinorlup-18-en-3beta-ol (trinorlupeol) and establish this novel C 27 metabolite as a major nonsterol triterpenoid in Arabidopsis thaliana. Trinorlupeol was concentrated in cuticular waxes, notably in the plant stem, floral buds, and seedpods, but not in leaves. Based on expression data and functional characterization of A. thaliana oxidosqualene cyclases, we propose that LUP1 is the cyclase responsible for trinorlupeol biosynthesis. Also described are two oxidized trinorlupeols and additional biosynthetic insights.     

Arabidopsis camelliol C synthase evolved from enzymes that make pentacycles

We establish by heterologous expression that the Arabidopsis thaliana oxidosqualene cyclase At1g78955 (CAMS1) makes camelliol C (98%), achilleol A (2%), and beta-amyrin (0.2%). CAMS1 is the first characterized cyclase that generates predominantly a monocyclic triterpene alcohol. Phylogenetic analysis shows that CAMS1 evolved from enzymes that make pentacycles, thus revealing that its pentacyclic beta-amyrin byproduct is an evolutionary relic. Sequence alignments support prior suggestions that decreased steric bulk at a key active-site residue promotes monocycle formation.     

Cation-pi interaction in the polyolefin cyclization cascade uncovered by incorporating unnatural amino acids into the catalytic sites of squalene cyclase

It has been assumed that the pi-electrons of aromatic residues in the catalytic sites of triterpene cyclases stabilize the cationic intermediates formed during the polycyclization cascade of squalene or oxidosqualene, but no definitive experimental evidence has been given. To validate this cation-pi interaction, natural and unnatural aromatic amino acids were site-specifically incorporated into squalene-hopene cyclase (SHC) from Alicyclobacillus acidocaldarius and the kinetic data of the mutants were compared with that of the wild-type SHC. The catalytic sites of Phe365 and Phe605 were substituted with O-methyltyrosine, tyrosine, and tryptophan, which have higher cation-pi binding energies than phenylalanine. These replacements actually increased the SHC activity at low temperature, but decreased the activity at high temperature, as compared with the wild-type SHC. This decreased activity is due to the disorganization of the protein architecture caused by the introduction of the amino acids more bulky than phenylalanine. Then, mono-, di-, and trifluorophenylalanines were incorporated at positions 365 and 605; these amino acids reduce cation-pi binding energies but have van der Waals radii similar to that of phenylalanine. The activities of the SHC variants with fluorophenylalanines were found to be inversely proportional to the number of the fluorine atoms on the aromatic ring and clearly correlated with the cation-pi binding energies of the ring moiety. No serious structural alteration was observed for these variants even at high temperature. These results unambiguously show that the pi-electron density of residues 365 and 605 has a crucial role for the efficient polycyclization reaction by SHC. This is the first report to demonstrate experimentally the involvement of cation-pi interaction in triterpene biosynthesis.     

16-Aza-ent-beyerane and 16-Aza-ent-trachylobane: potent mechanism-based inhibitors of recombinant ent-kaurene synthase from Arabidopsis thaliana

The secondary ent-beyeran-16-yl carbocation (7) is a key branch point intermediate in mechanistic schemes to rationalize the cyclic structures of many tetra- and pentacyclic diterpenes, including ent-beyerene, ent-kaurene, ent-trachylobane, and ent-atiserene, presumed precursors to >1000 known diterpenes. To evaluate these mechanistic hypotheses, we synthesized the heterocyclic analogues 16-aza-ent-beyerane (12) and 16-aza-ent-trachylobane (13) by means of Hg(II)- and Pb(IV)-induced cyclizations onto the Delta12 double bonds of tricyclic intermediates bearing carbamoylmethyl and aminomethyl groups at C-8. The 13,16-seco-16-norcarbamate (20a) was obtained from ent-beyeran-16-one oxime (17) by Beckmann fragmentation, hydrolysis, and Curtius rearrangement. The aza analogues inhibited recombinant ent-kaurene synthase from Arabidopsis thaliana (GST-rAtKS) with inhibition constants (IC50 = 1 x 10-7 and 1 x 10-6 M) similar in magnitude to the pseudo-binding constant of the bicyclic ent-copalyl diphosphate substrate (Km = 3 x 10-7 M). Large enhancements of binding affinities (IC50 = 4 x 10-9 and 2 x 10-8 M) were observed in the presence of 1 mM pyrophosphate, which is consistent with a tightly bound ent-beyeranyl+/pyrophosphate- ion pair intermediate in the cyclization-rearrangement catalyzed by this diterpene synthase. The weak inhibition (IC50 = 1 x 10-5 M) exhibited by ent-beyeran-16-exo-yl diphosphate (11) and its failure to undergo bridge rearrangement to kaurene appear to rule out the covalent diphosphate as a free intermediate. 16-Aza-ent-beyerane is proposed as an effective mimic for the ent-beyeran-16-yl carbocation with potential applications as an active site probe for the various ent-diterpene cyclases and as a novel, selective inhibitor of gibberellin biosynthesis in plants.     

Enzymatic synthesis of an indole diterpene by an oxidosqualene cyclase: mechanistic, biosynthetic, and phylogenetic implications

Petromindole (1) is an unusual indole diterpene that bears a triterpene-like carbon skeleton, suggesting biogenesis from 3-(omega-oxido-geranylgeranyl)indole (4). We found that lupeol synthase (LUP1) from Arabidopsis thaliana cyclizes 4 to 1. Chiral HPLC comparisons of racemic 1 (from biomimetic cyclization of N-pivaloyl-4) with the LUP1 product and authentic 1 established the absolute stereochemistry of petromindole (3S) as that of cyclic triterpenes. Quantum mechanical calculations and conformational analysis of intermediates in the cyclization of 4 to 1 indicated that petromindole biosynthesis differs fundamentally from that of other indole diterpenes. This analysis revealed that radarins also originate from cyclization of 4 but undergo a backbone rearrangement rather than annulation to indole. The combined results support our hypothesis that native fungal petromindole synthase evolved from a pentacyclic triterpene synthase distant from most other indole diterpene synthases.     

Coordination of Polyketide Release and Multiple Detoxification Pathways for Tolerable Production of Fungal Mycotoxins

Efficient biosynthesis of microbial bioactive natural products (NPs) is beneficial for the survival of producers, while self-protection is necessary to avoid self-harm resulting from over-accumulation of NPs. The underlying mechanisms for the effective but tolerable production of bioactive NPs are not well understood. Herein, in the biosynthesis of two fungal polyketide mycotoxins aurovertin E ( 1 ) and asteltoxin, we show that the cyclases in the gene clusters promote the release of the polyketide backbone, and reveal that a signal peptide is crucial for their subcellular localization and full activity. Meanwhile, the fungus adopts enzymatic acetylation as the major detoxification pathway of 1 . If intermediates are over-produced, the non-enzymatic shunt pathways work as salvage pathways to avoid excessive accumulation of the toxic metabolites for self-protection. These findings provided new insight into the interplay of efficient backbone release and multiple detoxification strategies for the production of fungal bioactive NPs.     

Genome-wide identification of antioxidant component biosynthetic enzymes: comprehensive analysis of ascorbic acid and tocochromanols biosynthetic genes in rice

During the last two decades, several exciting reports have provided many advances in the role and biosynthesis of l-ascorbic acid (AsA) and tocochromanols, including tocopherols and tocotrienols, in higher plants. There are increasing bodies of experimental evidence that demonstrate that AsA and tocochromanols (especially tocopherols) play an important role as antioxidants and nutrients in mammals and photosynthetic organisms and are also involved in plant responses to stimuli. Although AsA and tocochromanol biosynthesis pathways have been well characterized using Arabidopsis, these pathways are still poorly understood in rice, which is an economically important monocot cereal crop. In this study using computational analysis of sequenced rice genome, we identified eight and seven potential non-redundant members involved in AsA and tocochromanol biosynthetic pathways, respectively. The results reveal that the common feature of these gene promoters is the combination of light-responsive, hormone-responsive, and stress-responsive elements. These findings, together with expression analysis in the MPSS database, indicate that AsA and tocochromanols might be co-related with the complex signaling pathways involved in plant responses.     

Trichodiene Synthase: Synthesis and Inhibition Kinetics of 12‐Fluoro‐farnesylphosphonophosphate for Sesquiterpene Cyclases

trans, trans‐Farnesyl diphosphate (FPP) serves as a universal substrate for a large family of sesquiterpene cyclases that are responsible for biosynthesis of more than 300 structurally diverse sesquiterpenes in nature. A new FPP substrate analogue, 12‐fluoro‐farnesylphosphonophosphate (12‐F‐F‐CH₂PP), was synthesized in this paper for applications on kinetic and mechanistic studies of the enzyme family. Trichodiene synthase (TS), a sesquiterpene cyclase, catalyzes the conversion of trans, trans‐farnesyl diphosphate (FPP) to trichodiene. 12‐F‐F‐CH₂PP was tested as a potential inhibitor of TS. Inactivation and inhibition kinetic experiments showed that 12‐F‐F‐CH₂PP was not a mechanism‐based inactivator for TS; instead, a mixed‐type reversible inhibition was observed with inhibition constants K_i1 = 2.33 ± 0.50 μM and K_i2 = 25.80 ± 7.70 μM, values close to those previously determined for farnesylphosphonophosphate, K_i1 = 3.25 μM and K_i2 = 9.10 μM. Although 12‐F‐F‐CH₂PP did not irreversibly inactivate TS, this new analogue serves as a potential active‐site directed inactivator and mechanistic probe of other sesquiterpene cyclases and FPP‐utilizing enzymes, which utilize FPP as a common acyclic substrate.     

Evolutionary divergence of sedoheptulose 7-phosphate cyclases leads to several distinct cyclic products

Sedoheptulose 7-phosphate cyclases are enzymes that utilize the pentose phosphate pathway intermediate, sedoheptulose 7-phosphate, to generate cyclic precursors of many bioactive natural products, such as the antidiabetic drug acarbose, the crop protectant validamycin, and the natural sunscreens mycosporine-like amino acids. These proteins are phylogenetically related to the dehydroquinate (DHQ) synthases from the shikimate pathway and are part of the more recently recognized superfamily of sugar phosphate cyclases, which includes DHQ synthases, aminoDHQ synthases, and 2-deoxy-scyllo-inosose synthases. Through genome mining and biochemical studies, we identified yet another subset of DHQS-like proteins in the actinomycete Actinosynnema mirum and the myxobacterium Stigmatella aurantiaca DW4/3-1. These enzymes catalyze the conversion of sedoheptulose 7-phosphate to 2-epi-valiolone, which is predicted to be an alternative precursor for aminocyclitol biosynthesis. Comparative bioinformatics and biochemical analyses of these proteins with 2-epi-5-epi-valiolone synthases (EEVS) and desmethyl-4-deoxygadusol synthases (DDGS) provided further insights into their genetic diversity, conserved amino acid sequences, and plausible catalytic mechanisms. The results further highlight the uniquely diverse DHQS-like sugar phosphate cyclases, which may provide new tools for chemoenzymatic, stereospecific synthesis of various cyclic molecules.     

Dissection of the Catalytic Mechanisms of Transmembrane Terpene Cyclases Involved in Fungal Meroterpenoid Biosynthesis

Pyr4-family terpene cyclases are noncanonical transmembrane terpene cyclases involved in the biosynthesis of microbial meroterpenoids and catalyze diverse cyclization reactions. Despite the ubiquity of Pyr4-family terpene cyclases in microorganisms, their three-dimensional structures have never been experimentally determined. Herein, we focused on AdrI, the Pyr4-family enzyme for the andrastin A pathway, and its homologues, and performed a series of mutational experiments using their AlphaFold2-generated structures. Intriguingly, we found that AdrI and InsA7, which both accept the same substrate, use different amino acid residues for the initiation of the cyclization cascade. Furthermore, we obtained several AdrI variants with altered product selectivity, one of which dominantly yielded a new meroterpenoid species. Collectively, our study provides important insights into the catalytic functions of Pyr4-family terpene cyclases and will facilitate the engineering of these enzymes.     

Orchestration of discoid polyketide cyclization in the resistomycin pathway

Resistomycin is a bacterial polyphenolic metabolite from Streptomyces resistomycificus with a unique pentacyclic "discoid" ring system that clearly differs from the typical linear or angular architectures of aromatic polyketides. The first comprehensive cyclase amino acid sequence-function correlation revealed that the enzymes directing the nascent polyketide chain into a peri-fused system clearly differ from canonical linear and angular cyclases. All genes that are required and sufficent for resistomycin (rem) biosynthesis were identified through systematic dissection and reconstitution of the type II polyketide synthase (PKS) complex. The minimal rem PKS and the first cyclase were successfully cross-complemented with orthologues from the linear tetracenomycin polyketide pathway, indicating that both dekaketide pathways share early biosynthetic steps. In total three cyclases that are involved in discoid cyclization (RemI, RemF, and RemL) were identified by mutational analyses and in vivo pathway reconstitution. Analyses of the metabolic profiles of mutants expressing incomplete gene sets led to the discovery of a novel tetracenomycin derivative, TcmR1. The most surprising finding is that only the concerted action of the PKS and all three cyclases leads to the discoid ring structure. These results provide strong support for a model according to which the multienzyme complex forms a cage in which the polyketide is shaped, rather than a sequential cyclization of the polyketide chain by individual enzymes.