Supramolecular chemistry in lipid bilayer membranes

Lipid bilayer membranes form compartments requisite for life. Interfacing supramolecular systems, including receptors, catalysts, signal transducers and ion transporters, enables the function of the membrane to be controlled in artificial and living cellular compartments. In this perspective, we take stock of the current state of the art of this rapidly expanding field, and discuss prospects for the future in both fundamental science and applications in biology and medicine.

This perspective provides an overview of the current state of the art in supramolecular chemistry in lipid bilayer membranes, including receptors, signal transducers, catalysts and transporters, and highlights prospects for the future.     

Curvature-modulated phase separation in lipid bilayer membranes

Cellular membranes exhibit a variety of controlled curvatures, with filopodia, microvilli, and mitotic cleavage furrows being only a few of many examples. Coupling between local curvature and chemical composition in membranes could provide a means of mechanically controlling the spatial organization of membrane components. Although this concept has surfaced repeatedly over the years, controlled experimental investigations have proven elusive. Here, we introduce an experimental platform, in which microfabricated surfaces impose specific curvature patterns onto lipid bilayers, that allows quantification of mechanochemical couplings in membranes. We find that, beyond a critical curvature value, membrane geometry governs the spatial ordering of phase-separated domain structures in membranes composed of cholesterol and phospholipids. The curvature-controlled ordering, a consequence of the distinct mechanical properties of the lipid phases, makes possible a determination of the bending rigidity difference between cholesterol-rich and cholesterol-poor lipid domains. These observations point to a strong coupling between mechanical bending and chemical organization that should have wide-reaching consequences for biological membranes. Curvature-mediated patterning may also be useful in controlling complex fluids other than biomembranes.     

Tethered bilayer lipid membranes with giga-ohm resistances

The successful reconstitution of a tethered BLM on μ-electrodes ranging from 4000 μm to 8 μm is shown in this article. The increase in membrane resistance with decreasing electrode size and the dependency of the membrane capacitance on the electrode size was studied. Furthermore the functional incorporation of α-hemolysin from Staphylococcus aureus into a tBLM situated on μ-electrodes was achieved.     

Reconstituted olfactory receptors in bilayer lipid membranes

Bullfrog olfactory receptors were reconstituted in bilayer lipid membranes (BLMs). Three odorants were presented to the reconstituted system. The three structurally related odorants were diethylsulfide (DES), thiophene (THP) and diethanolsulfide (DOS). The ordorants were presented in pairs. DOS induced a response in the presence of either of the other two odorants. DES and THP did not induce a response in the presence of either of the other two odorants. These observations suggest that there are two substructures, one common to the three odorants and one that is unique to DOS. The results support the notion that olfactory receptors detect certain molecular segments of odorants.     

Diffusion of liquid domains in lipid bilayer membranes

We report diffusion coefficients of micron-scale liquid domains in giant unilamellar vesicles of phospholipids and cholesterol. The trajectory of each domain is tracked, and the mean square displacement grows linearly in time, as expected for Brownian motion. We study domain diffusion as a function of composition and temperature and measure how diffusion depends on domain size. We find mechanisms of domain diffusion which are consistent with membrane-dominated drag in viscous L(o) phases and bulk-dominated drag for less viscous L(alpha) phases. Where applicable, we obtain the membrane viscosity and report activation energies of diffusion.     

Examination of bilayer lipid membranes for 'pin-hole' character

BLM prepared on electrode substrates by supporting or tethering were tested for 'pin-hole' character, comparing data from cyclic voltammetry (CV), surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and rotating disc electrodes (RDE). 1-hexadecylamine tethered BLMs on SAM modified gold electrodes were compared with BLMs assembled on modified polyHEMA or sol-gel layers. BLM formation followed by SPR showed that the initial phase of the assembly was complete in 5-20 minutes and produced layers of thickness >5 nm, compared with the expected final BLM thickness of approximately 3 nm. The CVs of the K(3)[Fe(CN)(6)] couple were significantly suppressed irrespective of the method of BLM assembly, without major differences emerging for the different methods. However, data from the RDE distinguished the 'pin-hole' character of the different preparations. The data were consistent with incomplete initial (<1 h, SPR estimated BLM thickness >5 nm) vesicle fusion leaving 'pin-holes' of approximately 2 microm (HDA-11-mercaptoundecanoic acid (MUA) tethered BLM) to approximately 3 microm (tetraethylorthosilicate sol-gel supported BLM) followed by a slow maturation (>15 h; impedance spectroscopy estimated thickness approximately 3 nm) and lateral spreading and fusion, resulting in loss of 'pin-hole' character (<1 microm). The BLM could be used in conjunction with potentiometric measurement to observe the incorporation of nystatin into the BLM and the rate of incorporation adjusted according to original permeability of the BLM. The 'pin-hole-free' BLM construction with lowest permeability (TEOS supported, 4 x 10(-10) cm s(-1) compared with HDA-MUA, 3 x 10(-9) cm s(-1)) gave a potentiometric signal independent of bulk ion-concentration across 5 decades change in concentration. Formed on an ion-selective electrode, nystatin incorporation could be followed as a change in potential, over >2 h, whereas the TEOS supported BLM with permeability 1 x 10(-9) cm s(-1) shows nystatin incorporation within 1 h. In this instance, addition of ConA reduced the potential to the same value as prior to nystatin incorporation, consistent with nystatin channel closure.     

Surface tension in bilayer membranes with fixed projected area

We study the elastic response of bilayer membranes with fixed projected area to both the stretching and shape deformations. A surface tension is associated to each of these deformations. By using model amphiphilic membranes and computer simulations, we are able to observe both the types of deformation, and thus, both the surface tensions, related to each type of deformation, are measured for the same system. These surface tensions are found to assume different values in the same bilayer membrane, in particular, they vanish for different values of the projected area. We introduce a simple theory which relates the two quantities and successfully apply it to the data obtained with computer simulations.     

Electronic processes and photosensitization in bilayer lipid membranes

Abstract— In part one of this paper, evidence for electronic processes in experimental and biological membranes are reviewed. The membrane under consideration, be it experimental or biological, is understood to mean an ultrathin bamer separating two aqueous phases. The question ‘can electronic processes occur in/across such a structure immersed in an aqueous environment?’ is answered affirmatively. In the second part of this paper, photosensitization by dyes and photoelectric effects in experimental bilayer lipid membranes observed recently are described.     

Tethered bilayer lipid membranes self-assembled on mercury electrodes

In order to incorporate integral proteins in a functionally active state, metal-supported lipid bilayers must have a hydrophilic region interposed between the bilayer and the metal. This region is realized with a hydrophilic molecule terminating at one end with a sulfhydryl or disulfide group that anchors this "hydrophilic spacer" to the surface of a metal, such as gold or mercury. The other end of the hydrophilic spacer may be covalently linked to the polar head of a phospholipid molecule, giving rise to a supramolecule called "thiolipid" (TL). With respect to gold, mercury has the advantage of providing a defect-free and fluid surface to the self-assembling spacer. Hydrophilic spacers consisting of a polyethyleneoxy or a hexapeptide chain, as well as thiolipids derived from these spacers, were employed to fabricate mercury-supported lipid bilayers. The formation of a lipid bilayer on top of a self-assembled monolayer of a hydrophilic spacer, or of a single-lipid monolayer on top of a self-assembled monolayer of a thiolipid, was realized by simply immersing the coated mercury electrode into an aqueous solution across a lipid film previously spread on its surface at its spreading pressure. Particularly stable mercury-supported lipid bilayers were obtained by using thiolipids. The biomimetic properties of these lipid bilayers were tested by incorporating channel-forming polypeptides (gramicidin and melittin) and proteins (OmpF porin). The effect of the transmembrane potential on the function of these channels was estimated by using a simple electrostatic model of the mercury-solution interphase.     

Specific binding structures of dendrimers on lipid bilayer membranes

Dissipative particle dynamics simulations are used to study the specific binding structures of polyamidoamine (PAMAM) dendrimers on amphiphilic membranes and the permeation mechanisms. Mutually consistent coarse-grained (CG) models both for PAMAM dendrimers and for dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) lipid molecules are constructed. The PAMAM CG model describes correctly the conformational behavior of the dendrimers, and the DMPC CG model can properly give the surface tension of the amphiphilic membrane. A series of systematic simulations is performed to investigate the binding structures of the dendrimers on membranes with varied length of the hydrophobic tails of amphiphiles. The permeability of dendrimers across membranes is enhanced upon increasing the dendrimer size (generation). The length of the hydrophobic tails of amphiphiles in turn affects the dendrimer conformation, as well as the binding structure of the dendrimer-membrane complexes. The negative curvature of the membrane formed in the dendrimer-membrane complexes is related to dendrimer concentration. Higher dendrimer concentration together with increased dendrimer generation is observed to enhance the permeability of dendrimers across the amphiphilic membranes.     

The analytical potential of chemoreception at bilayer lipid membranes

The potential use of the bilayer lipid membrane as an electrochemical sensor is discussed through a study of model systems known to cause increased membrane conductance. The limit of detection for amphotericin B, a molecule capable of forming membrane pores, is in the region of 1O^-9 M. The current—time profile is discussed in terms of a mechanism which involves micelle formation in the aqueous and lipid phases. Unlike previous experiments, two current maxima with time are observed for valinomycin response (limit of detection 1O^-11 M). The first transient signal is attributed to increased membrane permeability caused by a conformational change in valinomycin in the “surface” volume of the bilayer. Selective interactions at membranes and the nature of membrane responses are discussed in terms of analytical parameters.     

Amphiphile bilayer films from DPPC: bilayer lipid membranes and Newton black films

Amphiphile bilayer films are obtained from 1,2 dipalmitoyl-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC): bilayer lipid membranes (BLM) and Newton black films (NBF), through thinning of the respective thin liquid films, thus allowing for a very precise determination of the moment of their formation. Stability (or rupture) and formation of BLM and NBF are considered from a unified point of view with the microscopic theory of Kashchiev–Exerowa [J. Colloid Interface Sci., 77 (1980) 501–511], based on the formation of nanoscopic holes in them. BLM and NBF are obtained and studied with the microinterferometric method of Scheludko–Exerowa in its contemporary version. The equivalent thickness of both BLM (in benzene solution between two water phases with 0.1 M NaCl) and NBF in aqueous DPPC solution (in the presence of 0.1 M NaCl) is determined as being h_w = 7.0 nm for BLM and h_w = 7.8 nm for NBF. By means of the dependences: BLM lifetime versus DPPC concentration and probability for BLM formation versus DPPC concentration, it is established that there exist metastable BLM and stable NBF. The good fit between the experimental results of τ(C) dependence and theory in the case of BLM allow to determine the three constants: pre-exponential factor A = 1.5 × 10⁻³ s, related to the process kinetics; constant B = 20.2 ± 0.2, related to the specific hole energy γ = 1.7 × 10⁻¹¹ J/m and the equilibrium concentration C_e = 6 × 10⁻⁴ ± 7.2 × 10⁻⁶ m/l. The specific hole linear energy γ = 1.7 × 10⁻¹¹ J/m determined as well as the binding energy Q between first neighbor molecules in the bilayers Q = 1.48 × 10⁻¹⁹ J (36 kT) are lower than the ones determined for DPPC foam bilayer in gel state γ = 9.1 × 10⁻¹¹ J/m and Q = 55 kT. This means that interaction is weaker in the case of BLM. The critical concentration C_c at which bilayer formation starts is: for BLM C_c = 30 μg/ml and for NBF C_c = 70 μg/ml. This concentration characterizes quantitatively the formation of the amphiphile bilayer and is a very useful parameter that can be used for various purposes.     

A novel method to fabricate patterned bilayer lipid membranes

We introduce a new method for forming tethered bilayer lipid membranes on surfaces patterned using a photocleavable self-assembled monolayer (SAM). A SAM terminated with a hydrophobic fluorocarbon residue was bound to a gold surface through a link containing a photocleavable ortho-nitrobenzyl moiety. Hydrophilic regions were produced by irradiation with soft UV (365 nm) through a photomask. The patterned surface was characterized by scanning electron microscopy and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. Tethered bilayer lipid membranes with well-defined bilayer and monolayer regions were then formed by exposure to egg PC vesicles. The membranes had resistance and capacitance values of 0.52 MOmega.cm2 and 0.83 microF.cm-2, respectively.     

Interactions between model inclusions on closed lipid bilayer membranes

Protein inclusions in the membranes of living cells interact via the deformations they impose on that membrane. Such membrane-mediated interactions lead to sorting and self-assembly of the inclusions, as well as to membrane remodelling, crucial for many biological processes. For the past decades, theory, numerical calculations and experiments have been using simplified models for proteins to gain quantitative insights into their behaviour. Despite challenges arising from nonlinearities in the equations, the multiple length scales involved and the nonadditive nature of the interactions, recent progress now enables for the first time a direct comparison between theoretical and numerical predictions and experiments. We review the current knowledge on the biologically most relevant case, inclusions on lipid membranes with a closed surface and discuss challenges and opportunities for further progress.     

330 - Determination of surface charge of bilayer lipid membranes

The determination of the membrane surface charge is based on the measurement of the surface potential difference at both sides of the bilayer lipid membrane (BLM) connected with the asymmetrical concentration of the electrolyte in both solutions. In the short-circuit regime the intramembrane potential jump is caused by the difference in the two surface potentials. In order to find the intramembrane potential jump the BLM capacitance dependence on voltage was used. In some range of electrolyte concentrations a dependence of the potential jump on the surface charge was found. The charge density was calculated by applying the Gouy-Chapman theory of the diffuse double layer. Surface charges were determined for BLM of common bovine brain lipids, phosphatidylethanolamine, dioleyllecithin and azolectine.     

Real-time QCM-D monitoring of electrostatically driven lipid transfer between two lipid bilayer membranes

The lipid exchange/transfer between lipid membranes is important for many biological functions. To learn more about how the dynamics of such processes can be studied, we have investigated the interaction of positively and negatively charged lipid vesicles with supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) of opposite charge. The vesicle-SLB interaction leads initially to adsorption of lipid vesicles on the SLB, as deduced from the mass uptake kinetics and the concerted increase in dissipation, monitored by the quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) technique. Eventually, however, vesicles (and possibly other lipid structures) desorb from the SLB surface, as judged from the mass loss and the dissipation decrease. The mass loss is approximately as large as the initial mass increase; i.e., at the end of the process the mass load is that of a SLB. We interpret this interesting kinetics in terms of initial strong electrostatic attraction between the added vesicles and the SLB, forming a structure where lipid transfer between the two bilayers occurs on a time scale of 10-40 min. We suggest that this lipid transfer causes a charge equilibration with an accompanying weakening of the attraction, and eventually repulsion, between the SLB and vesicles, leading to desorption of vesicles from the SLB. The composition of the latter has thus been modified compared to the initial one, although no net mass increase or decrease has occurred. Direct evidence for the lipid exchange was obtained by sequential experiments with alternating positive and negative vesicles, as well as by using fluorescently labeled lipids and FRAP. The above interpretation was further strengthened by combined QCM-D and optical reflectometry measurements.     

Melting and mechanical properties of polymer grafted lipid bilayer membranes

The influence of polymer grafting on the phase behavior and elastic properties of two tail lipid bilayers have been investigated using dissipative particle dynamics simulations. For the range of polymer lengths studied, the L(c) to L(α) transition temperature is not significantly affected for grafting fractions, G(f) between 0.16 and 0.25. A decrease in the transition temperature is observed at a relatively high grafting fraction, G(f) = 0.36. At low temperatures, a small increase in the area per head group, a(h), at high G(f) leads to an increase in the chain tilt, inducing order in the bilayer and the solvent. The onset of the phase transition occurs with the nucleation of small patches of thinned membrane which grow and form continuous domains as the temperature increases. This region is the co-existence region between the L(β)(thick) and the L(α)(thin) phases. The simulation results for the membrane area expansion as a function of the grafting density conform extremely well to the scalings predicted by self-consistent mean field theories. We find that the bending modulus shows a small decrease for short polymers (number of beads, N(p) = 10) and low G(f), where the influence of polymer is reduced when compared to the effect of the increased a(h). For longer polymers (N(p) > 15), the bending modulus increases monotonically with increase in grafted polymer. Using the results from mean field theory, we partition the contributions to the bending modulus from the membrane and the polymer and show that the dominant contribution to the increased bending modulus arises from the grafted polymer.     

Stabilization of bilayer lipid membranes on solid supports by trehalose

Using the electrostriction method the effect of the glucose and trehalose on the elasticity modulus perpendicular to the membrane plane, E_⊥, and the electrical capacitance, C, of supported bilayer lipid membranes (s-BLM) formed on the freshly cut tip of Teflon-coated Ag wire was studied. Addition of saccharides into the electrolyte resulted in a decrease in the elasticity modulus of the s-BLM formed from the soybean phosphatidylcholine in n-hexadecane, while the capacitance was increased. In addition, the trehalose has a considerable stabilizing effect on the above parameters of the s-BLM. Treatment of the s-BLM in an electrolyte containing 0.3 M of the trehalose allowed storage of the s-BLM under dry conditions and under refrigeration, with the subsequent recovery of membrane parameters after the wire had been dipped into the electrolyte.