Demonstration of the ring conformation in polyproline by the Raman optical activity

Raman and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra of poly-L-proline were recorded in a wide frequency range and analyzed with respect to the proline side chain conformation. The analysis was based on comparison to ab initio simulations of spectral band positions and intensities. The presence of two conformer states of the five-member ring was found, approximately equally populated in the polypeptide. Additionally, Raman and ROA spectral shapes indicated that the peptide adopts the polyproline II helical conformation, in both aqueous and TFE solutions. The helix, however, is perturbed by fluctuations, which affects the vibrational coupling among amino acid residues and broadens the ROA bands. Contributions of the side and main peptide chains to the polyproline ROA intensities have comparable magnitudes. Thus understanding of the origins of both signals is important for determination of the peptide structure by ROA.     

Solvent effects on Raman optical activity spectra calculated using the polarizable continuum model

The integral equation formulation of the polarizable continuum model (IEFPCM) has been extended to the calculation of solvent effects on vibrational Raman optical activity spectra. Gauge-origin independence of the differential scattering intensities of right and left circularly polarized light is ensured through the use of London atomic orbitals. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations have been carried out for bromochlorofluoromethane, methyloxirane, and epichlorhydrin. The results indicate that solvent effects on the ROA differential scattering intensities can be substantial, and vary in sign and magnitude for different vibrational modes. It is demonstrated that both direct and indirect effects are important in determining the total solvent effects on the ROA differential scattering intensities. Local field effects are shown to be in general small, whereas electronic nonequilibrium solvation has a profound effect on the calculated solvent effects compared to an equilibrium solvation model. For molecules with several conformations, the changes in the relative stability of the different conformers also lead to noticeable changes in the ROA spectra.     

Understanding the Signatures of Secondary‐Structure Elements in Proteins with Raman Optical Activity Spectroscopy

A prerequisite for the understanding of functional molecules like proteins is the elucidation of their structure under reaction conditions. Chiral vibrational spectroscopy is one option for this purpose, but provides only indirect access to this structural information. By first‐principles calculations, we investigate how Raman optical activity (ROA) signals in proteins are generated and how signatures of specific secondary‐structure elements arise. As a first target we focus on helical motifs and consider polypeptides consisting of twenty alanine residues to represent α‐helical and 3₁₀‐helical secondary‐structure elements. Although ROA calculations on such large molecules have not been carried out before, our main goal is the stepwise reconstruction of the ROA signals. By analyzing the calculated ROA spectra in terms of rigorously defined localized vibrations, we investigate in detail how total band intensities and band shapes emerge. We find that the total band intensities can be understood in terms of the reconstructed localized vibrations on individual amino acid residues. Two different basic mechanisms determining the total band intensities can be established, and it is explained how structural changes affect the total band intensities. The band shapes can be rationalized in terms of the coupling between the localized vibrations on different residues, and we show how different band shapes arise as a consequence of different coupling patterns. As a result, it is demonstrated for the chiral variant of Raman spectroscopy how collective vibrations in proteins can be understood in terms of well‐defined localized vibrations. Based on our calculations, we extract characteristic ROA signatures of α helices and of 3₁₀‐helices, which our analysis directly relates to differences in secondary structure.     

Transfer and Amplification of Chirality Within the “Ring of Fire” Observed in Resonance Raman Optical Activity Experiments

We report extremely strong chirality transfer from a chiral nickel complex to solvent molecules detected as Raman optical activity (ROA). Electronic energies of the complex were in resonance with the excitation‐laser light. The phenomenon was observed for a wide range of achiral and chiral solvents. For chiral 2‐butanol, the induced ROA was even stronger than the natural one. The observations were related to so‐called quantum (molecular) plasmons that enable a strong chiral Rayleigh scattering of the resonating complex. According to a model presented here, the maximal induced ROA intensity occurs at a certain distance from the solute, in a three‐dimensional “ring of fire”, even after rotational averaging. Most experimental ROA signs and relative intensities could be reproduced. The effect might significantly increase the potential of ROA spectroscopy in bioimaging and sensitive detection of chiral molecules.     

Comment on a sum rule for vibrational raman optical activity

The expressions for the sum of vibrational Raman optical activity (ROA) intensities indicate that the ROA intensity sum for chiral molecules is non-zero for those with an anisotropic electric dipole polarizability. The non-zero sum depends upon the electric dipole, magnetic dipole and electric quadrupole polarizability components and moments of inertia at equilibrium geometry.     

Theoretical study of the Raman optical activity spectra of 3(10)-helical polypeptides

Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy is a promising analytical method for studying the structure and conformation of polypeptides and proteins in solution. However, the structural information obtained from such vibrational spectra is only indirect and theoretical studies are often necessary to identify how the structure determines the observed spectra. One particular target is the identification and discrimination of different helical secondary structure elements. Herein, a theoretical investigation of the ROA spectra of a series of 3(10)-helical polypeptides is presented. In particular, the effect of chain length, C(α)-substitution pattern, the introduction of larger aliphatic side chains, and the variation of their conformation on the ROA spectra is studied. To extract general principles from these calculations, the positions, intensities, and shapes of the ROA bands are analyzed in terms of localized modes, which makes it possible to identify possible ROA signatures of 3(10) -helical structures, but also provides fundamental insight into the generation of ROA signals in complex polypeptides. Finally, the calculated spectra can be compared to the previously reported ROA spectrum of a specifically designed 3(10) -helical heptapeptide. This allows most of the features in the experimental spectrum to be assigned.     

Experimental and ab initio theoretical vibrational Raman optical activity of alanine

The vibrational Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra of l-alanine in water, 1 N NaOH and 1 N HCl between 720 and 1500 cm⁻¹ measured in backscattering are reported. Unlike the associated vibrational circular dichroism (VCD), the main ROA features are relatively insensitive to pH changes. Ab initio Raman and ROA intensities were evaluated using 6-31G and 6-31G* basis sets and found to agree remarkably well with the experimental parameters in the lower-frequency region.     

Paving the way to conformationally unravel complex glycopeptide antibiotics by means of Raman optical activity

It is crucial for fundamental physical chemistry techniques to find their application in tackling real-world challenges. Hitherto, Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy is one of the examples where a promising future within the pharmaceutical sector is foreseen, but has not yet been established. Namely, the technique is believed to be able to contribute in investigating the conformational behaviour of drug candidates. We, herein, strive towards the alignment of the ROA analysis outcome and the pharmaceutical expectations by proposing a fresh strategy that ensures a more complete, reliable, and transferable ROA study. The strategy consists of the treatment of the conformational space by means of a principal component analysis (PCA) and a clustering algorithm, succeeded by a thorough ROA spectral analysis and a novel way of estimating the contributions of the different chemical fragments to the total ROA spectral intensities. Here, vancomycin, an antibiotic glycopeptide, has been treated; it is the first antibiotic glycopeptide studied by means of ROA and is a challenging compound in ROA terms. By applying our approach we discover that ROA is capable of independently identifying the correct conformation of vancomycin in aqueous solution. In addition, we have a clear idea of what ROA can and cannot tell us regarding glycopeptides. Finally, the glycopeptide class turns out to be a spectroscopically curious case, as its spectral responses are unlike the typical ROA spectral responses of peptides and carbohydrates. This preludes future ROA studies of this intriguing molecular class.

Raman optical activity tackles the complex conformational space of glycopeptide antibiotics.     

Two Spectroscopies in One: Interference of Circular Dichroism and Raman Optical Activity

Previously, we and other laboratories have reported an unusual and strong Raman optical activity (ROA) induced in solvents by chiral dyes. Various theories of the phenomenon appeared, but they were not capable of explaining fully the observed ROA band signs and intensities. In this work, an analysis based both on the light scattering theory and dedicated experiments provides a more complete understanding. For example, double-cell magnetic circular dichroism and magnetic ROA experiments with copper-porphyrin complex show that the induced chirality is observed without any contact of the solvents with the complex. The results thus indicate that a combination of electronic circular dichroism (ECD) with the polarized Raman scattering is responsible for the effect. The degree of circularity of solvent vibrational bands is a principal molecular property participating in the event. The insight and the possibility to predict the chirality transfer promise future applications in spectroscopy, chemical analysis and polarized imaging.     

Intensity‐Carrying Modes in Raman and Raman Optical Activity Spectroscopy

We describe a quantum‐chemical approach for the determination of modes with maximum Raman and Raman optical activity (ROA) intensity by maximizing the intensities with respect to the Raman and Raman optical activity intensity, respectively, which is shown to lead to eigenvalue equations. The intensity‐carrying modes are in general hypothetical modes and do not directly correspond to a certain normal mode in the spectrum. However, they provide information about those molecular distortions leading to intense bands in the spectrum. Modes with maximum Raman intensity are presented for propane‐1,3‐dione, propane‐1,3‐dionate, and Λ‐tris(propane‐1,3‐dionato)cobalt(III). Moreover, the mode with highest ROA intensity is examined for this chiral cobalt complex and also for the (chiral) amino acid L ‐tryptophan. The Raman and ROA high‐intensity modes are an optimal starting guess for intensity‐tracking calculations, in which selectively normal modes with high Raman or ROA intensity are converged. We present the first Raman and ROA intensity‐tracking calculations. These reveal a high potential for large molecules, for which the selective calculation of normal modes with high intensity is desirable in view of the large computational effort required for the calculation of Raman and ROA polarizability property tensors.     

A combined theoretical and experimental study of the structure and vibrational absorption, vibrational circular dichroism, Raman and Raman optical activity spectra of the L-histidine zwitterion

A combined theoretical and experimental study of the vibrational absorption (VA)/IR, vibrational circular dichroism (VCD), Raman and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra of l-histidine in aqueous solution has been undertaken to answer the questions (i) what are the species present and (ii) which conformers of the species are present under various experimental conditions. The VA spectra of l-histidine have been measured in aqueous solution and the spectral bands which can be used to identify both species (cation, zwitterion, anion) and conformer of the species have been identified and subsequently used to identify the species (zwitterion) and conformer (gauche minus minus, gauche minus plus for the side chain dihedral angles) present in solution at pH 7.6. The VCD spectral intensities have been used subsequently in combination with further theoretical studies to confirm the conclusions that have been arrived at by only analyzing the VA/IR spectra. Finally a comparison of measured Raman and ROA spectra of l-histidine with Raman and ROA spectral simulations for the conformers and species derived from the combined VA/IR and VCD experimental and theoretical work is presented as a validation of the conclusions arrived at from VA/IR and VCD spectroscopy. The combination of VA/IR and VCD with Raman and ROA is clearly superior and both sets of experiments should be performed.     

Coupled-cluster calculations of vibrational Raman optical activity spectra

We present the first calculations of Raman optical activity spectra at the coupled-cluster level of theory. Calculations are presented for (S)-methyloxirane and compared to recent experimental gas-phase measurements as well as the results obtained at the Hartree-Fock and density functional level of theory using the popular B3LYP functional. For the experimentally relevant frequency region of 400-1600 cm(-1), the Hartree-Fock, B3LYP and coupled-cluster spectra are very similar when the same force field is used, and the results also agree well with experiment. For high-frequency vibrational modes, differences in the ROA difference parameters are observed and are analyzed. The new coupled-cluster ROA code will allow for critical benchmarking of the accuracy of modern exchange-correlation functionals in the calculation of ROA spectra.     

Comparison of the Electronic and Vibrational Optical Activity of a Europium(III) Complex

The geometry and the electronic structure of chiral lanthanide(III) complexes are traditionally probed by electronic methods, such as circularly polarised luminescence (CPL) and electronic circular dichroism (ECD) spectroscopy. The vibrational phenomena are much weaker. In the present study, however, significant enhancements of vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectral intensities were observed during the formation of a chiral bipyridine–Eu^III complex. The ten‐fold enhancement of the vibrational absorption and VCD intensities was explained by a charge‐transfer process and the dominant effect of the nitrate ion on the spectra. A much larger enhancement of the ROA and Raman intensities and a hundred‐fold increase of the circular intensity difference (CID) ratio were explained by the resonance of the λ=532 nm laser light with the ⁷F₀ → ⁵D₀ transitions. This phenomenon is combined with a chirality transfer, and mixing of the Raman and luminescence effects involving low‐energy ⁷F states of europium. The results thus indicate that the vibrational optical activity (VOA) may be a very sensitive tool for chirality detection and probing of the electronic structure of Eu^III and other coordination compounds.     

Surface enhanced Raman optical activity (SEROA)

Raman optical activity (ROA) directly monitors the stereochemistry of chiral molecules and is now an incisive probe of biomolecular structure. ROA spectra contain a wealth of information on tertiary folding, secondary structure and even the orientation of individual residues in proteins and nucleic acids. Extension of ROA to an even wider range of samples could be facilitated by coupling its structural sensitivity to the low-concentration sensitivity provided by plasmon resonance enhancement. This leads to the new technique of surface enhanced ROA, or SEROA, which is complementary to both SERS and ROA. In this tutorial review, we present a survey of theoretical and experimental work undertaken to develop SEROA and discuss these efforts in the context of the ROA technique, and, based on the authors' work, outline possible future directions of research for this novel chiroptical spectroscopy.     

Determination of the absolute stereochemistry of limonene and alpha-santalol by Raman optical activity spectroscopy

Determining the absolute stereochemistry of organic compounds in solution remains a challenge. We investigated the use of Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy to address this problem. The absolute configurations of (+)-(R)- and (-)-(S)-limonene were determined by ROA spectroscopy, which can be applied to smaller amounts of sample as compared with vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) spectroscopy. This ROA method was also applied to (+)-(E)-alpha-santalol and shown to be successful in the determination of the absolute configuration of this compound. ROA spectroscopy shows promise as a useful tool for determining the absolute stereochemistry of many natural compounds.     

Resonance Raman optical activity and surface enhanced resonance Raman optical activity analysis of cytochrome c

High-resolution resonance Raman (RR) and resonance Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra of cytochrome c were obtained in order to perform full assignment of spectral features of the resonance ROA spectrum. The resonance ROA spectrum of cytochrome c revealed a distinct spectral signature pattern due to resonance enhanced skeletal porphyrin vibrations, more pronounced than any contribution from the protein backbone. Combining the intrinsic resonance properties of cytochrome c with the surface plasmon enhancement achieved with colloidal silver particles, the surface enhanced resonance Raman scattering (SERRS) and surface enhanced resonance ROA (SERROA) spectra of the protein were successfully obtained at concentrations as low as 1 microM. The assignments of spectral features were based on the information obtained from the RR and resonance ROA spectra. Excellent agreement between RR and SERRS spectra is reported, while some disparities were observed between the resonance ROA and SERROA spectra. These differences can be ascribed to perturbations of the physical properties of the protein upon adhesion to the surface of the silver colloids.     

Anharmonic effects in IR, Raman, and Raman optical activity spectra of alanine and proline zwitterions

The difference spectroscopy of the Raman optical activity (ROA) provides extended information about molecular structure. However, interpretation of the spectra is based on complex and often inaccurate simulations. Previously, the authors attempted to make the calculations more robust by including the solvent and exploring the role of molecular flexibility for alanine and proline zwitterions. In the current study, they analyze the IR, Raman, and ROA spectra of these molecules with the emphasis on the force field modeling. Vibrational harmonic frequencies obtained with 25 ab initio methods are compared to experimental band positions. The role of anharmonic terms in the potential and intensity tensors is also systematically explored using the vibrational self-consistent field, vibrational configuration interaction (VCI), and degeneracy-corrected perturbation calculations. The harmonic approach appeared satisfactory for most of the lower-wavelength (200-1800 cm(-1)) vibrations. Modern generalized gradient approximation and hybrid density functionals, such as the common B3LYP method, provided a very good statistical agreement with the experiment. Although the inclusion of the anharmonic corrections still did not lead to complete agreement between the simulations and the experiment, occasional enhancements were achieved across the entire region of wave numbers. Not only the transitional frequencies of the C-H stretching modes were significantly improved but also Raman and ROA spectral profiles including N-H and C-H lower-frequency bending modes were more realistic after application of the VCI correction. A limited Boltzmann averaging for the lowest-frequency modes that could not be included directly in the anharmonic calculus provided a realistic inhomogeneous band broadening. The anharmonic parts of the intensity tensors (second dipole and polarizability derivatives) were found less important for the entire spectral profiles than the force field anharmonicities (third and fourth energy derivatives), except for a few weak combination bands which were dominated by the anharmonic tensor contributions.     

Conformational analyses of peptides and proteins by vibrational Raman optical activity

Recent developments of vibrational Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy enabled the detailed analyses of the backbone and side chain conformations of peptides and proteins in solution phases. ROA can be used as a powerful analytical technique for determining not only the structures of conformers, but also their populations even for systems in fast conformational equilibria where NMR spectroscopy is difficult to be applied. ROA enabled the monitoring of the secondary structures of denatured or unfolded proteins, such as an amyloid fibril and its prefibril intermediates.     

Raman Optical Activity (ROA) as a New Tool to Elucidate the Helical Structure of Poly(phenylacetylene)s

Poly(phenylacetylene)s are a family of helical polymers constituted by conjugated double bonds. Raman spectra of these polymers show a structural fingerprint of the polyene backbone which, in combination with its helical orientation, makes them good candidates to be studied by Raman optical activity (ROA). Four different well‐known poly(phenylacetylene)s adopting different scaffolds and ten different helical senses have been prepared. Raman and ROA spectra were recorded and allowed to establish ROA‐spectrum/helical‐sense relationships: a left/right‐handed orientation of the polyene backbone (M_helix/P_helix) produces a triplet of positive/negative ROA bands. Raman and ROA spectra of each polymer exhibited the same profile, and the sign of the ROA spectrum was opposite to the lowest‐energy electronic circular dichroism (ECD) band, indicating a resonance effect. Resonance ROA appears then as an indicator of the helical sense of poly(phenylacetylene)s, especially for those with an extra Cotton band in the ECD spectrum, where a wrong helical sense is assigned based on ECD, while ROA alerts of this misassignment.     

trans-1,2-Dicyano-cyclopropane and other cyano-cyclopropane derivatives

In this work we present the experimental vibrational absorption (VA), vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) and Raman spectra for (+)-trans-1(S),2(S)-dicyanocyclopropane and its dideuterio derivative, trans-1(S),2(S)-dicyano-1(S),2(S)-dideuteriocyclopropane, along with VA, VCD, Raman and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectral simulations. Here we investigate the applicability of various local and non-local exchange-correlation (XC) functionals, hybrids and meta-hybrids to reproduce the vibrational spectra of this strained ring system, which also bears two cyano groups. At the highest level of theory, B3PW91/ aug-cc-pVTZ, we also investigated the trans-, cis- and gem-dicyanocyclopropane (trans-, cis-, and gem-DCCP), cyanocyclopropane (CCP) and the parent molecule cyclopropane (CP). In doing so we have investigated the electronic effects (coupling) between the cyano groups and the cyclopropane ring. In addition to providing an interpretation of the experimentally observed vibrational spectra for these molecules, this work also provides benchmark calculations for other methods, especially semi-empirical based wave function and density functional theory (DFT) based methods, such as SCC-DFTB and PM6. For the semi-empirical DFT based methods to be used for 3-membered ring systems, one ought to document their reliability for systems which were not used in the parameterization. The small 3- and 4-membered ring systems are good test systems because they contain non-standard bonding, which may be difficult to determine accurately with the approximations used in the SCC-DFTB and other semi-empirical methods. Like molecular mechanics force fields, semi-empirical methods, based on DFT and wave function quantum mechanics (WFQM), must be benchmarked against high level ab initio and DFT calculations and experimental data. In addition to bonding, the changes in the electric dipole moment, magnetic dipole moment, electric dipole-electric dipole polarizability, electric dipole-magnetic dipole polarizability and electric dipole-electric quadrupole polarizability with respect to nuclear displacement and nuclear velocity can be determined by the VA, VCD, Raman and ROA intensities. Hence it is important that the semi-empirical based DFT and wave function methods not only be parameterized to determine energies, gradients and Hessians, but also the electric and magnetic moments and their derivatives that determine the electronic and magnetic properties of these molecules and their interactions with matter and radiation. This will allow biochemists, biophysicists, molecular biologists, and physical biologists to use experimental and theoretical VA, VCD, Raman and ROA spectroscopies to probe biophysical and biochemical function and processes at the molecular level. Festschrift in Honor of Philip J. Stephens’ 65th Birthday.