Confinement and processing effects on glass transition temperature and physical aging in ultrathin polymer films: Novel fluorescence measurements

Fluorescence intensity measurements of chromophore-doped or -labeled polymers have been used for the first time to determine the effects of decreasing film thickness on glass transition temperature, T _g, the relative strength of the glass transition, and the relative rate of physical aging below T _g in supported, ultrathin polymer films. The temperature dependence of fluorescence intensity measured in the glassy state of thin and ultrathin films of pyrene-doped polystyrene (PS), poly(isobutyl methacrylate) (PiBMA), and poly(2-vinylpyridine) (P2VP) differs from that in the rubbery state with a transition at T _g. Positive deviations from bulk T _g are observed in ultrathin PiBMA and P2VP films on silica substrates while substantial negative deviations from bulk T _g are observed in ultrathin PS films on silica substrates. The relative difference in the temperature dependences of fluorescence intensity in the rubbery and glassy states is usually reduced with decreasing film thickness, indicating that the strength of the glass transition is reduced in thinner films. The temperature dependence of fluorescence intensity also provides useful information on effects of processing history as well as on the degree of polymer-substrate interaction. In addition, when used as a polymer label, a mobility-sensitive rotor chromophore is demonstrated to be useful in measuring relative rates of physical aging in films as thin as 10 nm. Received 21 August 2001     

Heterogeneous dynamics at the glass transition in van der Waals liquids, in the bulk and in thin films

It has been shown over the last few years that the dynamics close to the glass transition is strongly heterogeneous, both by measuring the diffusion coefficient of tagged particles or by NMR studies. Recent experiments have also demonstrated that the glass transition temperature of thin polymer films can be shifted as compared to the same polymer in the bulk. We propose here first a thermodynamical model for van der Waals liquids, which accounts for experimental results regarding the bulk modulus of polymer melts and the evolution of the density with temperature. This model allows us to describe the density fluctuations in such van der Waals liquids. Then, by considering the thermally induced density fluctuations in the bulk, we propose that the 3D glass transition is controlled by the percolation of small domains of slow dynamics, which allows to explain the heterogeneous dynamics close to T _g. We show then that these domains percolate at a lower temperature in the quasi-2D case of thin suspended polymer films and we calculate the corresponding glass transition temperature reduction, in quantitative agreement with experimental results of Jones and co-workers. In the case of strongly adsorbed films, we show that the strong adsorption amounts to enhance the slow domains percolation. This effect leads to 1) a broadening of the glass transition and 2) an increase of T _g in quantitative agreement with experimental results. For both strongly and weakly adsorbed films, the shift in T _g is given by a power law, the exponent being the inverse of that of the correlation length of 3D percolation. Received 21 March 2000 and Received in final form 4 December 2000     

Molecular dynamics in thin films of isotactic poly(methyl methacrylate)

The molecular dynamics in thin films (18 nm-137 nm) of isotactic poly(methyl methacrylate) (i-PMMA) of two molecular weights embedded between aluminium electrodes are measured by means of dielectric spectroscopy in the frequency range from 50 mHz to 10 MHz at temperatures between 273 K and 392 K. The observed dynamics is characterized by two relaxation processes: the dynamic glass transition (α-relaxation) and a (local) secondary β-relaxation. While the latter does not depend on the dimensions of the sample, the dynamic glass transition becomes faster (≤2 decades) with decreasing film thickness. This results in a shift of the glass transition temperature T _g to lower values compared to the bulk. With decreasing film thickness a broadening of the relaxation time distribution and a decrease of the dielectric strength is observed for the α-relaxation. This enables to deduce a model based on immobilized boundary layers and on a region displaying a dynamics faster than in the bulk. Additionally, T _g was determined by temperature-dependent ellipsometric measurements of the thickness of films prepared on silica. These measurements yield a gradual increase of T _g with decreasing film thickness. The findings concerning the different thickness dependences of T _g are explained by changes of the interaction between the polymer and the substrates. A quantitative analysis of the T _g shifts incorporates recently developed models to describe the glass transition in thin polymer films. Received 12 August 2001 and Received in final form 16 November 2001     

Static and dynamic properties of supercooled thin polymer films

The dynamic and static properties of a supercooled (non-entangled) polymer melt are investigated via molecular-dynamics (MD) simulations. The system is confined between two completely smooth and purely repulsive walls. The wall-to-wall separation (film thickness), D, is varied from about 3 to about 14 times the bulk radius of gyration. Despite the geometric confinement, the supercooled films exhibit many qualitative features which were also observed in the bulk and could be analyzed in terms of mode-coupling theory (MCT). Examples are the two-step relaxation of the incoherent intermediate scattering function, the time-temperature superposition property of the late time α-process and the space-time factorization of the scattering function on the intermediate time scale of the MCT β-process. An analysis of the temperature dependence of the α-relaxation time suggests that the critical temperature, T _c, of MCT decreases with D. If the confinement is not too strong ( D≥10monomer diameter), the static structure factor of the film coincides with that of the bulk when compared for the same distance, T - T _c(D), to the critical temperature. This suggests that T - T _c(D) is an important temperature scale of our model both in the bulk and in the films. Received 12 September 2001     

Magneto-optical Faraday and Kerr effect of orthoferrite thin films at high temperatures

Orthoferrites present, as bulk materials, reorientation transitions of their magnetic moment alignment at temperatures depending on the rare-earth (RE) ion. In particular, orthoferrites (REFeO₃) with RE = Sm, Dy, present this transition at T _SRT = 443 K and 36 K, respectively. The spectra of the complex Kerr and Faraday angle have been measured on orthoferrite thin films (RE = Sm, Dy, Y), which were prepared by pulsed laser deposition on amorphous quartz substrates. The obtained spectra exhibit contributions of both surfaces and interfaces. Propagation effects of the polarized light in the magneto-optical medium which is interpreted in terms of a simplified theoretical formalism, is also observed. For selected photon energies, temperature dependent Faraday rotation measurements, , on orthoferrite thin films (RE = Sm, Dy, Y) have been performed. A quite different thermal variation compared to the bulk magnetization has been observed. Curie temperatures are found to be close to the bulk values or slightly larger by 10 K to 20 K as in the case of DyFeO₃ and YFeO₃. For RE = Sm and Dy, increases with increasing temperature contrary to the saturation magnetization, passes through a maximum at about 460 K and vanishes with a T _C of 647±18 K, 695 K for RE = Sm and Dy respectively. Received 28 July 2000     

Spin-cast, thin, glassy polymer films: Highly metastable forms of matter

Ultra thin films of glassy polymers such as polystyrene (PS) can show a) anomalously large thickness changes, b) unexpected dewetting properties, c) large shifts in the glass temperature T_g. The present discussion focusses mainly on point a). A certain cascade of metastable states is presented together with (tentative) explanations. Received 1 March 2001 and Received in final form 10 May 2001     

Frequency-dependent fluctuational conductivity above in anisotropic superconductors: effects of a short wavelength cutoff

We discuss the excess conductivity at nonzero frequencies in a superconductor above T_c within the Gaussian approximation. We focus the attention on the temperature range not too close to T_c: within a time-dependent Ginzburg-Landau formulation, we phenomenologically introduce a short wavelength cutoff (of the order of the inverse coherence length) in the fluctuational spectrum to suppress high momentum modes. We treat the general cases of thin wires, anisotropic thin films and anisotropic bulk samples. We obtain in all cases explicit expressions for the finite frequency fluctuational conductivity. The dc case directly follows. Close to T_c the cutoff has no effect, and the known results for Gaussian fluctuations are recovered. Above T_c, and already for ε = ln(T/T _c) > 10^-2, we find strong suppression of the paraconductivity as compared to the Gaussian prediction, in particular in the real part of the paraconductivity. At high ε the cutoff effects are dominant. We discuss our results in comparison with data on high-T_c superconductors. Received 19 March 2002 Published online 25 June 2002     

The properties of free polymer surfaces and their influence on the glass transition temperature of thin polystyrene films

We present a detailed study of free polymer surfaces and their effects on the measured glass transition temperature (T_g) of thin polystyrene (PS) films. Direct measurements of the near-surface properties of PS films are made by monitoring the embedding of 10 and 20 nm diameter gold spheres into the surface of spin-cast PS films. At a temperature T = 378K( > T_g), the embedding of the spheres is driven by geometrical considerations arising from the wetting of the gold spheres by the PS. At temperatures below T_g ( 363K < T < 370K), both sets of spheres embed 3-4 nm into the PS films and stop. These studies suggest that a liquid-like surface layer exists in glassy PS films and also provide an estimate for the lower bound of the thickness of this layer of 3-4 nm. This qualitative idea is supported by a series of calculations based upon a previously developed theoretical model for the indentation of nanoscale spheres into linear viscoelastic materials. Comparing data with simulations shows that this surface layer has properties similar to those of a bulk sample of PS having a temperature of 374 K. Ellipsometric measurements of the T_g are also performed on thin spin-cast PS films with thicknesses in the range 8nm < h < 290nm. Measurements are performed on thin PS films that have been capped by thermally evaporating 5 nm thick metal (Au and Al) capping layers on top of the polymer. The measured T_g values (as well as polymer metal interface structure) in such samples depend on the metal used as the capping layer, and cast doubt on the general validity of using evaporative deposition to cover the free surface. We also prepared films that were capped by a new non-evaporative procedure. These films were shown to have a T_g that is the same as that of bulk PS (370±1 K) for all film thicknesses measured (> 7 nm). The subsequent removal of the metal layer from these films was shown to restore a thickness-dependent T_g in these samples that was essentially the same as that observed for uncapped PS films. An estimate of the thickness of the liquid-like surface layer was also extracted from the ellipsometry measurements and was found to be 5±1 nm. The combined ellipsometry and embedding studies provide strong evidence for the existence of a liquid-like surface layer in thin glassy PS films. They show that the presence of the free surface is an important parameter in determining the existence of T_g reductions in thin PS films.     

Effect of atmosphere on reductions in the glass transition of thin polystyrene films

We have used nulling ellipsometry to measure the glass transition temperature, T _g , of thin films of polystyrene in ambient, dry nitrogen, and vacuum environments. For all environments, the measured T _g values decrease with decreasing film thickness in a way that is quantitatively similar to previously reported studies in ambient conditions. These results provide strong reinforcement of previous conclusions that such reduced T _g values are an intrinsic property of the confined material. Furthermore, the results are in contrast to recent reports which suggest that the T _g reductions measured by many researchers are the results of artifacts (i.e. degradation of the polymer due to annealing in ambient conditions, or moisture content).     

Low temperature dependence of the penetration depth in YBCO thin films revisited by mm wave transmission and surface impedance measurements

We report results obtained with two different experimental set-ups in state-of-the-art YBCO thin films as similar as possible, prepared by pulsed laser deposition on LaAlO₃ substrates: a surface impedance measurement on 4000 ? thick films using a parallel plate resonator (10 GHz), and a far infrared transmission (100-400 GHz) measurement which requires thinner (1000 ?) samples. The former measurement yields the temperature variation of the penetration depth λ(T) and the real part of the conductivity, provided the absolute value of λ(T) is known. The latter yields the imaginary part of the conductivity, hence the absolute value of the penetration depth, as well as its temperature dependence at the measuring frequency. Combining these two experiments, we establish a quasi-linear temperature variation of λ(T), with a 2 ? K^-1 low temperature slope, and a fairly large zero temperature value λ(T = 0)=(1800±200) ? . The scattering rate of the quasi-particles calculated from a two-fluids model shows that the films compare to good quality single crystals, where twice a larger slope has been found. This surprising behavior is described in detail, including an in-depth structural analysis of the samples in order to evaluate their similarities. We find that the 10 GHz data obtained in the thickest films can be fitted to the dirty d-wave mode in the unitarity limit, with an extrapolated slope of 3 ? K^-1, but yield a scattering rate that is difficult to reconcile with the high T _c (92 K) of the films. Received 7 May 2001 and Received in final form 18 October 2001     

Finite-size scaling in systems with long-range interaction

The finite-size critical properties of the (n) vector ϕ⁴ model, with long-range interaction decaying algebraically with the interparticle distance r like r ^{-d - σ}, are investigated. The system is confined to a finite geometry subject to periodic boundary condition. Special attention is paid to the finite-size correction to the bulk susceptibility above the critical temperature T _c. We show that this correction has a power-law nature in the case of pure long-range interaction i.e. 0 < σ < 2 and it turns out to be exponential in case of short-range interaction i.e.σ = 2. The results are valid for arbitrary dimension d, between the lower ( d _< = σ) and the upper ( d _> = 2σ) critical dimensions. Received 2 July 2001 and Received in final form 4 Septembre 2001     

Glass transition and dynamics of single and stacked thin films of poly(2-chlorostyrene)

The glass transition temperature and the dynamics of the α-process have been investigated using dielectric relaxation spectroscopy for single and stacked thin films of poly(2-chlorostyrene) (P2CS). The stacked film consists of 10 layers of single thin films with thickness of 12 nm or 18 nm. The glass transition temperature T _g of the single thin films of P2CS is found to decrease with decreasing film thickness in a similar way as observed for polystyrene thin films. The magnitude of the depression of T _g for the stacked thin films is larger than that of the single thin films with corresponding thickness. The depression of the temperature at which the dielectric loss shows a peak due to the α-process at a given frequency, T _α, is larger than that of the single thin films, although the magnitude is smaller than that of T _g . Annealing at a high temperature could cause the T _g and T _α of the stacked thin films to approach the values of the bulk system.     

T g in Confined Systems: A Free Volume Approach

Abstract

In glass-forming materials confined in films or pores of small dimension, the glass transition temperature T _g is depressed or increased depending on the nature of the interactions at the interface. It is shown that these effects, observed in polymers and simple liquids, can be interpreted in the framework of the free volume model. Similar effects of confinement on the glass and melting transitions are stressed; this permits prediction of the variations of the cooperative molecular motions α with temperature.     

Heterogeneous dynamics at the glass transition in van der Waals liquids: Determination of the characteristic scale

Recent experiments have demonstrated that the dynamics in liquids close to the glass transition temperature is strongly heterogeneous. The characteristic size of these heterogeneities has been measured to be a few nanometers at T _g. We extend here a recent model for describing the heterogeneous nature of the dynamics which allows both to derive this length scale and the right orders of magnitude of the heterogeneities of the dynamics close to the glass transition. Our model allows then to interpret quantitatively small probes diffusion experiments. Received 29 March 2002 and Received in final form 11 November 2002 RID="a" ID="a"e-mail: long@lps.u-psud.fr     

Magnetism in very thin films of permalloy measured by spin polarized cascade electrons

The spin polarizationP of the low energy cascade electrons excited with a primary unpolarized electron beam is measured with ultrathin films of permalloy (Ni₈₀Fe₂₀) as a function of film thickness, external magnetic field, and temperatureT. Surface adsorbates of small concentrations of less than 10% of a monolayer can change the Curie point and the saturation value ofP ₀(T0) by as much as 30%. The Ta-substrate induces a magnetically dead region in permalloy. Conventional spin wave theory cannot account for the observed smallT-dependence of the magnetizationM. Films on a nonmagnetic substrate are compared to similar films coupled to bulk permalloy over an interface of Ta. TheT-dependence ofM with the coupled films can be explained by spin wave theory. At lowT, the films coupled to the bulk exhibit a faster decrease ofM than the uncoupled films. We propose that this thermal stabilization of the magnetization in very thin ferromagnetic films is due to quenching of the long wavelength spin modes.     

Effect of strain-induced electronic topological transitions on the superconducting properties of La 2 - x Sr x CuO 4 thin films

We propose a Ginzburg-Landau phenomenological model for the dependence of the critical temperature on microscopic strain in tetragonal high-T _c cuprates. Such a model is in agreement with the experimental results for LSCO under epitaxial strain, as well as with the hydrostatic pressure dependence of T _c in most cuprates. In particular, a nonmonotonic dependence of T _c on hydrostatic pressure, as well as on in-plane or apical microstrain, is derived. From a microscopic point of view, such results can be understood as due to the proximity to an electronic topological transition (ETT). In the case of LSCO, we argue that such an ETT can be driven by a strain-induced modification of the band structure, at constant hole content, at variance with a doping-induced ETT, as is usually assumed. Received 1st October 2001 and Received in final form 5 December 2001     

Slow relaxation experiments in disordered charge and spin density waves: collective dynamics of randomly distributed solitons

We show that the dynamics of disordered charge density waves (CDWs) and spin density waves (SDWs) is a collective phenomenon. The very low temperature specific heat relaxation experiments are characterized by: (i) “interrupted” ageing (meaning that there is a maximal relaxation time); and (ii) a broad power-law spectrum of relaxation times which is the signature of a collective phenomenon. We propose a random energy model that can reproduce these two observations and from which it is possible to obtain an estimate of the glass cross-over temperature (typically T _g≃ 100-200 mK). The broad relaxation time spectrum can also be obtained from the solutions of two microscopic models involving randomly distributed solitons. The collective behavior is similar to domain growth dynamics in the presence of disorder and can be described by the dynamical renormalization group that was proposed recently for the one dimensional random field Ising model [D.S. Fisher, P. Le Doussal, C. Monthus, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 3539 (1998)]. The typical relaxation time scales like ∼τexp(T _g/T). The glass cross-over temperature T_g related to correlations among solitons is equal to the average energy barrier and scales like T _g∼ 2xξΔ. x is the concentration of defects, ξ the correlation length of the CDW or SDW and Δ the charge or spin gap. Received 12 December 2001     

Adsorption from pure and mixed vapours of n-hexane and n-perfluorohexane

We have used a modified surface force apparatus (SFA) to study adsorption onto mica surfaces from near-saturated vapours of n-hexane and n-perfluorohexane, and mixtures thereof. For relative vapour pressures in the range 0.9-0.998 the films adsorbed from vapours of the pure liquids range in thickness from 1 to 4 nm, in crude agreement with the predictions of non-retarded van der Waals-Lifshitz theory. The observed deviations from theory show a qualitative difference between the two liquids, which may reflect differences in the significance of structural contributions to the disjoining pressure. Under the same experimental conditions, adsorption from vapours of (one-phase) liquid mixtures gives rise to films which are significantly thicker, over a broad range of intermediate compositions, than those adsorbed from the pure vapours, with a broad maximum in thickness observed near the critical composition of the bulk liquid mixture. Received 30 July 2001     

The K * Kπ and ρππ couplings in QCD

The light cone QCD sum rules are derived for the K ^* Kπ coupling g _K ^* Kπ and the ρππ coupling g _ρππ. The contribution from the excited states and the continuum is subtracted cleanly through the double Borel transform with respect to the two external momenta, p ₁ ², p ₂ ²= (p−q)². Our result g _K ^* Kπ= (8.7 ± 0.5) and g _ρππ= (11.5 ± 0.8) is in good agreement with the experimental value. Received: 31 July 1998 / Revised version: 20 November 1998     

Physical aging in Zr46.75Ti8.25Cu7.5Ni10Be27.5 typical bulk metallic glass manifested as enthalpy relaxation

Enthalpy recovery is not only an important characteristic of physical aging of glass, but also a good tool to investigate the physical aging. Using differential scanning calorimeter (DSC), the enthalpy recovery of Zr_46.75Ti_8.25Cu_7.5Ni₁₀Be_27.5 bulk metallic glass (BMG) was studied. The typical characteristics of enthalpy recovery of glass including the sub-T _g peak and ‘overshot’ were found in BMG. The evolution of the sub-T _g peak and ‘overshot’ were described by the free volume theory and Hodge’s model, respectively. It was found that the former failed to describe the enthalpy recovery in the BMG, while the latter could give a qualitative explanation. In combination with the dynamics in the BMG, the origin of the enthalpy recovery in the BMG was discussed. The results show that BMGs are an ideal material to investigate the physical aging. The further understanding of physical aging of BMGs is useful to clarify the nature of glass and improve the application and device of new types of BMGs. Supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 50671118)