Enantiomeric and enantiotopic analysis of cone-shaped compounds with C(3) and C(3)(v) symmetry using NMR spectroscopy in chiral anisotropic solvents

We describe the enantiomeric and enantiotopic analysis of the NMR spectra of compounds derived from the functionalized cone-shaped core, cyclotriveratrylenes (CTV), dissolved in weakly oriented lyotropic chiral liquid crystals (CLCs) based on organic solutions of poly-gamma-benzyl-L-glutamate. The CTV core lacks prostereogenic as well as stereogenic tetrahedral centers. However, depending on the pattern of substitution, chiral and achiral compounds with different symmetries can be obtained. Thus, symmetrically nonasubstituted CTVs (C(3) symmetry) are optically active and exhibit enantiomeric isomers, while symmetrically hexasubstituted (C(3v) symmetry) derivatives are prochiral and possess enantiotopic elements. In the first part we use (2)H and (13)C NMR to study two nonasubstituted (-OH or -OCH(3)) CTVs, where the ring methylenes are fully deuterated, and show for the first time that the observation of enantiomeric discrimination of chiral molecules with a 3-fold symmetry axis is possible in a CLC. It is argued that this discrimination reflects different orientational ordering of the M and P isomers, rather than specific chiral short-range solvent-solute interactions that may affect differently the magnetic parameters of the enantiomers or even their geometry. In the second part we present similar measurements on hexasubstituted CTV with flexible side groups (-OC(O)CH(3) and the, partially deuterated bidentate, -OCH(2)CH(2)O-), having on the average C(3v) symmetry. No spectral discrimination of enantiotopic sites was detected for the -OC(O)CH(3) derivative. This is consistent with a recent theoretical work (J. Chem. Phys. 1999, 111, 6890) that indicates that in C(3v) molecules no chiral discrimination between enantiotopic elements, based on ordering, is possible. In contrast, a clear splitting was observed in the (2)H spectra of the enantiotopic deuterons of the side groups in the tri(dioxyethylene)-CTV. It is argued that this discrimination reflects different ordering characteristics of the various, rapidly (on the NMR time scale) interconverting conformers of this compound. Assuming two twisted structures for each of the dioxyethylene side groups, four different conformers are expected, comprising two sets of enantiomeric pairs with, respectively, C(3) and C(1) symmetries. Differential ordering and/or fractional population imbalance of these enantiomeric pairs leads to the observed spectral discrimination of sites in the side chains that on average form enantiotopic pairs.     

Chiral discrimination in the 13C and 2H NMR of the crown and saddle isomers of nonamethoxy-cyclotriveratrylene in chiral liquid-crystalline solutions

We report 2H and 13C NMR spectra of the crown and saddle isomers of nonamethoxy-tribenzocyclononene (1), dissolved in lyotropic achiral and chiral liquid-crystalline solutions based on poly-gamma-benzyl-glutamate and poly-gamma-benzyl-L-glutamate (PBG and PBLG). The 2H-[1H] measurements include spectra of compound 1 deuterated in the ring methylene and in the aromatic sites as well as of the methyl groups in natural abundance. Carbon-13 spectra were recorded in natural abundance as well as in two isotopomers enriched in the ring methylene and one of the methoxy groups. The crown isomer (c-1) is rigid with C3 symmetry and can be separated into its enantiomers using a chiral high-performance liquid chromatography column. The NMR spectra of racemic c-1 in PBLG solutions exhibit two sets of lines due to the enantiomers. The peaks were identified by comparing the spectra with those of the neat enantiomers. Analysis of the 2H quadrupolar splittings and the 13C residual chemical shift anisotropies shows that the dominant factor determining the chiral discrimination is the difference in the ordering of the two enantiomers in the chiral liquid crystals. The saddle isomer (s-1) is highly flexible, undergoing fast pseudorotation between six conformers. The "frozen" conformers have C1 symmetry and are therefore chiral. Three of these comprise one enantiomer, and the other three the second one. However, the rapidly interconverting species has, on the average, a C3h symmetry and is therefore achiral. The methylene groups in the latter are, however, prostereogenic, and their hydrogen/deuterium-carbon bonds constitute enantiotopic pairs. The 2H NMR spectra of the s-1 methylene-deuterated in PBLG solutions exhibit, in fact, enantio-discrimination with two quadrupolar doublets. This is in contrast to rigid prochiral molecules with a threefold symmetry axis, which normally do not show such discrimination. A detailed analysis of the effect is presented, and it is argued that the discrimination observed for s-1 reflects the different ordering of its enantiomers during the pseudorotation cycle.     

Enantiotopic discrimination in the deuterium NMR spectrum of solutes with S4 symmetry in chiral liquid crystals

Enantiotopic discrimination in the NMR spectra of prochiral rigid solutes in chiral liquid crystals (CLC), by the ordering mechanism, is limited to molecules possessing one of the four, so called, "allowed" symmetries, D(2d), C(2v), C(s), and S(4). So far, such spectral discrimination was demonstrated only for solutes possessing one of the first three symmetries. In this work, we present deuterium NMR measurements on a rigid S(4) compound dissolved in a chiral nematic solvent and demonstrate, for the first time, enantiotopic discrimination in such symmetry. The measurements were performed on the isotopically normal icosane derivative (1) and on its isotopomer (1-d(8)), specifically deuterated in its four core methylene groups. As a CLC solvent, a lyotropic mesophase, consisting of a solution of poly-γ-benzyl-L-glutamate (PBLG) in pyridine, was employed. For comparison with a corresponding achiral liquid crystal (ALC) solvent, a solution of a racemic mixture of poly-γ-benzylglutamate (PBG) of similar composition in the same co-solvent was used. The spectra were recorded at 92.1 MHz using the 2D Q-COSY Fz sequence with proton decoupling. In the CLC solvents they exhibited clear discrimination due to different enantiotopic sites, with components displaced symmetrically, at frequencies below and above those in the corresponding ALC, as expected for discrimination by ordering. Two procedures were employed for correlating the enantiotopic sites in the CLC spectra. For 1-d(8) the dipolar cross-peaks in a 2D (2)H-(2)H COSY-90 experiment provided identification of signals belonging to the same methylene (and hence the same enantiotopic) groups. For 1 the correlation was achieved using a least-square-deviation fitting of the experimental quadrupole splittings with respect to those expected from the molecular geometry. These results, with appropriate symmetry considerations were used to determine the symmetric (S(zz)) and antisymmetric (S(xy) and S(xx)-S(yy)) components of the Saupe ordering matrix. Interpretation of the NMR spectra of prochiral solutes in CLC suffers from the ambiguity in identifying the signals with specific enantiotopic groups. For this reason only the relative (but not the absolute) signs of the antisymmetric elements of the ordering matrix can be determined. For the S(4) group this leads to sign ambiguity in the rhombic term in the diagonalized ordering matrix. Similar (but not identical) ambiguities occur for solutes belonging to the other allowed groups. In a concluding section of the paper, the ambiguities in the antisymmetric order parameters for the various allowed groups are compared and their physical meaning are discussed.     

2H NMR studies on two-homopolypeptide lyotropic enantiodiscriminating mesophases: experimental quantification of solute-fiber affinities

The analytical potential and enantioselective properties of lyotropic mesophases made by mixing two chemically different chiral polypeptides are described. Here we examine the case of a mixture of poly-gamma-benzyl-L-glutamate (PBLG) and poly-epsilon-carbobenzyloxy-L-lysine (PCBLL). We demonstrate that 2H NMR spectroscopy on these chiral oriented mixtures can discriminate both enantiomers and enantiotopic directions in prochiral molecules. Moreover, in such systems, degree of enantiodiscrimination, resolution, and sensitivity can be conjointly optimized by changing the relative proportion of the two polypeptides. Therefore, these new enantiodiscriminating media provide a favorable alternative to single-polypeptide mesophases with respect to stereochemical applications. At a more fundamental level, the present work points out that solute distribution in the vicinity of each polypeptide partly governs the degree of enantiodiscrimination and NMR relaxation rates. To this end, the experimental trends of solute NMR observables (Delta nu Q, T1) versus the fraction of peptide units of each polymer were analyzed by using a "mean-field" model derived from that proposed for mixtures of thermotropic nematic solvents, and based on the separation of intermolecular interactions between the solute and both polypeptides. This approach allows the relative solute-fiber affinities in these lyotropic systems to be determined. To identify the factors controlling solute-polypeptide affinities, we investigated various solutes (polar/apolar, rigid/flexible, achiral/prochiral/chiral molecules) using 2H NMR at natural abundance or on isotopically enriched solutes.     

Analysis of intramolecular dynamic processes in enantiomeric diaryl atropisomers and related derivatives by 2H NMR spectroscopy in polypeptide liquid crystals

We demonstrate the analytical potential of 2H-{1H} NMR spectroscopy in weakly ordering, chiral lyotropic liquid crystals made of poly(gamma-benzyl-L-glutamate) (PBLG) dissolved in chloroform or dichloromethane for investigating the intramolecular dynamic processes of four deuterated diaryls (derivatives of 1-(4'-methylphenyl)naphthalene). When the rotation of the aryl groups about the sp(2)--sp(2) bond is sufficiently slow relative to the NMR timescale, the method allows the spectral discrimination of enantiomeric atropisomers or enantiotopic directions in the prochiral derivatives. The effect of the position of substituents on the phenyl group on the conformational dynamics of these compounds has been examined as well as the nature of the organic co-solvent. When coalescence phenomena are observed, simulation of the experimental 2H-{1H} lineshapes using a formalism tailored for two deuterons undergoing mutual exchange allows the rate constants and the activation parameters for the internal rotation processes to be calculated. Experimental values of DeltaH(not equal) have been compared with data evaluated by molecular modelling calculations and the activation parameters are discussed for the various compounds. It is shown that these polypeptide mesophases have no significant impact on the interconversion dynamics of these compounds. In contrast with the nematic thermotropic phases, Haller's equation cannot be used to predict the evolution of the quadrupolar splittings (Deltanu(Q) values), and hence the order parameters, versus T in the PBLG mesophases. For these particular lyotropic systems, it is shown that an exponential function of the form Deltanu(Q)[Hz]=C x exp (-E/RT[K]) provides excellent agreement between the experimental and expected Deltanu(Q) values. Analysis of the results reported in this work suggests that orientation and chiral discrimination phenomena in these lyotropic solvents could be treated separately because they would involve different interaction mechanisms.     

NMR experimental evidence of the differentiation of enantiotopic directions in C(s) and C(2v) molecules using partially oriented, chiral media.

We report new and explicit experimental evidence of the differentiation of (1)H-(1)H, (13)C-(1)H, and (13)C-(2)H enantiotopic directions in prochiral molecules with C(s) and C(2v)symmetry dissolved in a chiral liquid-crystalline phase using (13)C and (2)H-[(1)H] NMR spectroscopy at the natural abundance level. The case of endo-bicyclo[2.2.2]oct-5-ene-2,3-dicarboxylic anhydride, bicyclo[2.2.1]hepta-2,5-diene, and ethyl alcohol oriented in organic solutions of poly-gamma-benzyl-L-glutamate (PBLG) or poly-epsilon-carbobenzyloxy-L-lysine (PCBLL) is investigated and discussed. Next, we describe the first NMR differentiation of enantiotopic directions in a C(2v) molecule with no prostereogenic carbon using malononitrile as a model. The various results presented in this work experimentally validate our recent theoretical arguments which predict that NMR spectra of nonplanar C(s) and C(2v) compounds embedded in a chiral oriented solvent should differ from those recorded in nonchiral oriented media, because their effective molecular symmetry point group (interacting molecule) is different from their molecular point group (isolated molecule). In addition, the differentiation of enantiotopic directions in C(2v) molecules exhibiting no prostereogenic tetrahedral center illustrates for the first time an old stereochemical hypothesis which speculates that "for molecules of the type CXXYY. the two X groups as well as the Y groups are equivalent and cannot be distinguished in chiral or achiral circumstances. However, the relationships between X and Y groups are not all equivalent. The four X-Y relationships may be ordered into two enantiotopic sets of two equivalent relationships" (Mislow, K.; Raban, M. Top. Stereochem. 1967, 1, 1) and validate the stereogenicity concepts proposed more recently by Fujita (Fujita, S. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1990, 112, 3390).     

Poly-γ-S-perillyl-l-glutamate and Poly-γ-S-perillyl-d-glutamate: Diastereomeric Alignment Media Used for the Investigation of the Alignment Process

Residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) offer additional information for structure elucidation by NMR spectroscopy. They are measured in anisotropic media, such as lyotropic liquid crystalline phases of polypeptides. Today, some suitable polypeptides are known. Nevertheless, structural influences of these polypeptides on the alignment properties are not really understood. Thus, which influence a chiral side chain has on enantiodiscrimination and whether we can improve the enantiodifferentiation significantly by adding an additional chiral center in the side chain are questions of interest. Therefore, new diastereomeric polypeptide-based alignment media with an additional chiral center in the side chain derived from perillyl alcohol were synthesized and their properties were investigated (secondary structure, liquid crystallinity, etc.). The enantiomers of isopinocampheol and β-pinene were used as model analytes for the study of enantiodiscrimination. Additionally, the usage of ¹H–¹H-RDCs to improve the alignment tensor quality is demonstrated.     

Scalable weak aligning medium for enantiodiscrimination of water soluble chiral molecules

The study reports the first indication of a lyotropic liquid crystalline phase of an aqueous solution of polysaccharide xanthan gum, as a physical parameter dependent scalable and reversible weak alignment medium, for enantiodiscrimination of water soluble chiral molecules.     

NMR in chiral polypeptide liquid crystals: the problem of amines

It is shown that lyotropic liquid crystal mixtures made of poly-γ-benzyl-l-glutamate (PBLG) dissolved in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) are efficient anisotropic NMR solvents to distinguish the enantiomers of chiral amines through the effects of the differential ordering of enantiomers. This type of solvent overcomes problems often encountered when dissolving amines into the more conventional PBLG/CHCl₃ or PBLG/CH₂Cl₂ liquid crystals. Furthermore, it is shown that perdeuterobenzyl chloride is an excellent achiral deuterated derivatizing agent for enantiomeric excess measurements of chiral amines in conjunction with the PBLG/DMF solvent.     

Conformational studies by dynamic NMR. 83. Correlated enantiomerization pathways for the stereolabile propeller antipodes of dimesityl substituted ethanol and ethers

Below -100 degrees C, the NMR spectra of dimesityl derivatives of ethanol and of various ethers reveal how these molecules exist as M and P propeller-like stereolabile enantiomers, owing to the restricted rotation about the Ar-C bond. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction of one such derivative confirmed the existence of a two-blade propeller structure. Computer analysis of the NMR line shape allowed the barriers for the enantiomerization process to be determined. Theoretical modeling (Molecular Mechanics) of the interconversion circuit produced good agreement between the computed and experimental barrier for a correlated dynamic process where a disrotatory one-ring flip pathway reverses the helicity of the conformational enantiomers. Introduction of a configurationally stable chiral center allowed two distinct NMR spectra to be detected at appropriate low temperature for two stereolabile diastereoisomers.     

Assignment of absolute configuration of natural abundance deuterium signals associated with (R)- and (S)-enantioisotopomers in a fatty acid aligned in a chiral liquid crystal: enantioselective synthesis and NMR analysis

Previous experimental natural abundance deuterium (NAD) NMR results have shown an odd/even-related alternation in the ((2)H/(1)H) ratio of the methylene groups of fatty acids (ChemBioChem 2001, 2, 425) and, by NAD NMR in CLC, a marked difference between enantiotopic deuterons for each methylenic site (Anal. Chem. 2004, 76, 2827). However, to date, the assignment of the absolute configuration for each deuterium has not been possible. To investigate further the origin of these effects, the assignment of NAD quadrupolar doublets observed in chiral oriented solvent is required. Here we describe the assignment of R- and S-isomers resulting from the isotopic substitution in positions 4 and 5 in the aliphatic chain of 1,1'-bis(thiophenyl)hexane 1 (BTPH) derived from natural linoleic acid of plant origin. This was achieved using an optimized synthetic strategy to obtain separately four regio- and stereoselectively deuterated enantiomers of BTPH. By reference to the deuterium spectra of these isotopically labeled reference compounds, we demonstrate that, on both 4 and 5 positions of BTPH, the isotopic enantiomers of S configuration are depleted relative to those of R configuration. This finding effectively explains the observed low ((2)H/(1)H) ratio in NAD of some ethylenic sites of unsaturated fatty acids.     

Aza-crown macrocycles as chiral solvating agents for mandelic acid derivatives

A series of new chiral macrocycles containing the trans-1,2-diaminocyclohexane (DACH) subunit and arene- and oligoethylene glycol-derived spacers has been prepared in enantiomerically pure form. Four of the macrocycles have been characterized by X-ray crystallography, which reveals a consistent mode of intramolecular N-H···N hydrogen bonding and conformational variations about the N-benzylic bonds. Most of the macrocycles were found to differentiate the enantiomers of mandelic acid (MA) by (1)H NMR spectroscopy in CDCl(3); within the series of macrocycles tested, enantiodiscrimination was promoted by (i) a meta-linkage geometry about the arene spacer, (ii) the presence of naphthalene- rather than phenylene-derived arene spacers, and (iii) increasing length of the oligoethylene glycol bridge. (1)H NMR titrations were performed with optically pure MA samples, and the data were fitted to a simultaneous 1:1 and 2:1 binding model, yielding estimates of 2:1 binding constants between some of the macrocycles and MA enantiomers. In several cases, NOESY spectra of the MA:macrocycle complexes show differential intramolecular correlations between protons adjacent to the amine and carboxylic acid groups of the macrocycles and MA enantiomers, respectively, thus demonstrating geometric differences between the diastereomeric intermolecular complexes. The three most effective macrocycles were employed as chiral solvating agents (CSAs) to determine the enantiomeric excess (ee) of 18 MA samples over a wide ee range and with very high accuracy (1% absolute error).     

Discrimination and analysis of the NMR spectra of enantiomers dissolved in chiral liquid crystal solvents through 2D correlation experiments

The discrimination and analysis of the NMR spectra of optically active molecules dissolved in chiral liquid crystal solvents through 2D correlation experiments is studied. The technique allows the identification of the line positions of each enantiomer, thus providing a notable simplification of the spectral analysis. The 2D HOHAHA and multiple-quantum experiments are investigated and discussed. The potential of the method is illustrated using a sample of (±) 3,3,3-trichloroepoxypropane dissolved in a thermotropic cholesteric solvent. The case of chiral molecules bearing a fluorine or deuterium nucleus has also been studied. In addition, it is shown that 2D heteronuclear correlation experiments are powerful methods for correlating carbon and proton spectral data of two enantiomers. A specific example is given through (±) 2-bromopropanoic acid dissolved in a lyotropic polypeptide liquid crystal. Spectral parameters of each enantiomer are calculated for the different examples.     

Chiral resolution of diphenylalanine by high-performance liquid chromatography on a crown-ether-based chiral stationary phase and by NMR spectroscopy

Summary The enantiomers of diphenylalanine (DPA) were well separated by chiral HPLC and NMR spectroscopy on the chiral stationary phase (CSP) derived from (18-crown-6)-2,3,11,12-tetracarboxylic acid (18-C-6-TA). The chromatographic parameters such as separation factors and retention times were greatly influenced by the mobile phase conditions. The (+)-18-C-6-TA used in the CSP was also employed as a chiral solvating agent for the enantiodiscrimination of the DPA enantiomers by NMR spectroscopy. The proton of the DPA analyte showing the chemical shift nonequivalences was used in determining the enantiomeric composition of the analyte.     

Three-component chiral derivatizing protocols for NMR spectroscopic enantiodiscrimination of hydroxy acids and primary amines

The novel three-component chiral derivatization protocols have been derived for (1)H and (19)F NMR spectroscopic discrimination of a series of chiral hydroxy acids by their coordination and self-assembly with optically active α-methylbenzylamine and 2-formylphenylboronic acid. In addition, the optically pure (S)-mandelic acid in combination with 2-formylphenylboronic acid permits visualization of enantiomers of primary amines. These protocols have been demonstrated on enantiodiscrimination of chiral amines and hydroxy acids.     

Peptoid atropisomers

We report the isolation of N-aryl peptoid oligomers that adopt chiral folds, despite the absence of chiral centers. Peptoid monomers incorporating ortho-substituted N-aryl side chains are identified that exhibit axial chirality. We observe significant energy barriers to rotation about the stereogenic carbon-nitrogen bond, allowing chromatographic purification of stable atropisomeric forms. We study the atropisomerism of N-aryl peptoid oligomers by computational modeling, NMR, X-ray crystallography, dynamic HPLC, and circular dichroism. The results demonstrate a new approach to promote the conformational ordering of this important class of foldamer compounds.     

Conformational consequences of the dynamic processes in the stereolabile atropisomers of acyl-substituted m-terphenyl derivatives

By means of low-temperature NMR spectroscopy, conformers (stereolabile atropisomers) due to the restricted rotation about the Ar-Ar and Ar-C(O)R bonds were detected in a number of acylphenyl derivatives, substituted in positions 2 and 6 by the 3-isopropylphenyl moiety (compounds 1-3, R=H, Me, and t-Bu, respectively). The conformational assignment was accomplished on the basis of the symmetry of the low-temperature 13C NMR spectra with the added support of ab initio calculations. The interconversion barriers were also determined by complete line shape simulation of the NMR spectra, and the experimental values were satisfactorily reproduced by ab initio calculations. In the case of the asymmetric derivative 4, two enantiomers, generated by the restricted t-BuC(O)-Ar rotation, were found sufficiently stable to allow their separation by means of the enantioselective HPLC technique at ambient temperature and to obtain the corresponding CD spectra.     

Scanning tunneling microscopy of prochiral anthracene derivatives on graphite: chain length effects on monolayer morphology

The morphology of monolayers formed upon adsorption of prochiral 1,5-substituted anthracene derivatives on highly oriented pyrolytic graphite is investigated using scanning tunneling microscopy at the liquid-solid interface. The adsorption orientation of these prochiral anthracene derivatives positions one of their enantiotopic faces in contact with the graphite. The molecules adsorb in rows with contact between adjacent anthracenes. The anthracene side chains extend perpendicular to the direction of the row repeat. All molecules within a single row adsorb via the same enantiotopic face. Anthracenes with side chains containing an even number of non-hydrogenic atoms (C, S) form monolayers in which molecules in adjacent rows adsorb via opposite enantiotopic faces. Anthracenes with side chains that contain an odd number of non-hydrogenic atoms form two-dimensional chiral domains in which all rows contain molecules adsorbed via the same enantiotopic face. This chain length effect on monolayer morphology represents a generalized example of structural effects previously observed in alkanoic acid monolayers formed on HOPG. The variation of the STM current with position in the vicinity of the anthracenes indicates that the highest occupied molecular orbital is the predominant mediator of tunneling for the aromatic group.     

Influence of the chemical structure of water-soluble cryptophanes on their overall chiroptical and binding properties

The synthesis and the chiroptical properties of the two enantiomers of the hexacarboxylic acid cryptophane-A derivative, 1, are described in this article. The chiroptical and binding properties of 1 toward achiral and chiral guests have been investigated in water under basic conditions by polarimetry, electronic circular dichroism (ECD), vibrational circular dichroism (VCD), and (1)H NMR spectroscopy. These experiments reveal that the (1)H NMR spectra of 1 are very sensitive to the nature of the guest trapped in its cavity whereas ECD and VCD spectra remain unchanged. We also show that the two enantiomers of 1 are able to distinguish between the two enantiomers of a series of small chiral epoxides. The enantiodiscrimination increases with the size of the chiral guest whereas the corresponding binding constants decrease. In contrast to what was observed for other water-soluble cryptophanes, the molecular recognition process is found independent of the nature of the counterions surrounding host 1, shedding light on the importance of the chemical structure of cryptophanes on their binding and chiroptical properties.     

Determination of the absolute stereochemistry and the activation barriers of thermally interconvertible heterocyclic compounds bearing a naphthyl substituent

The enantiotopic methyl signals of the compounds studied were resolved in the presence of the optically active chiral auxiliary (S)-(+)-2,2,2-trifluoroanthryl ethanol, [(S)-TFAE] via complex formation between (S)-TFAE and the respective compounds. Two different solvation models were proposed for both M and P conformations leading to the assignments of the ¹H NMR signals and thus absolute conformations. The solvation models proposed also explained the strong temperature dependence of the ¹H NMR signals upon cooling. The activation barriers for interconversion between the enantiomers of the compounds studied have been determined by either temperature dependent NMR or enantioresolution on a chiral sorbent via HPLC.