Behaviour of formula emulsions containing hydrolysed whey protein and various lecithins

Formula emulsion systems are used as enteral, sports and health products. In some formulas addition of hydrolysed protein is necessary to guarantee ease of digestion and hypoallergenicity. In the low fat emulsion model an increase in the content of lecithin (phospholipid mixture) was required, in consideration of the advice of the Food and Nutrition Board (USA) for choline supplementation. The individual and interactive effects of whey protein isolate (WPI) or hydrolysate (WPH) (3.7 and 4.9% w/w), unmodified deoiled or hydrolysed lecithin (0.48 or 0.7% w/w) and carbohydrate in the form of maltodextrin with dextrose equivalent (DE) 18.5 or glucose syrup with DE 34 (11% w/w) on the properties of formula emulsions with 4% v/w sunflower oil, were investigated using a full factorial design. The emulsions were characterised by particle size distribution, coalescence stability, creaming rate, and also surface protein and lecithin concentration. WPI-containing emulsions proved to be stable against coalescence and showed only little creaming after 1 and 7 days standing. There was a significant increase in the mean droplet size and a significant deterioration of coalescence and creaming stability when WPH instead of WPI was used as the protein source, due to the lower number of large peptides and lower surface activity of the WPH. Increasing the WPH concentration led to an increase in oil droplet size and further deterioration of the stability of the emulsions. The starch hydrolysate and lecithin also significantly influenced the emulsion properties. Their influence was less strong when the emulsion contained WPI. Under the conditions used WPH-based emulsions were more stable, in terms of creaming and coalescence, when a low level of protein was used in conjunction with hydrolysed lecithin and glucose syrup. Oil droplets in emulsions containing unmodified lecithin in either the continuous or disperse phase and WPH in the continuous phase were very sensitive to coalescence. The addition of starch hydrolysates (DE 18.5) induced intensive flocculation and phase separation in these emulsions.     

An NMR study of the freezing of emulsion-containing drops

Various nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques were used to monitor the freezing behaviour of suspended 2-mm-diameter drops. The drops were composed of hydrocarbon oils emulsified in either water or water/sucrose mixtures. As such they were good model systems for the study of spray freezing, sharing structural similarities with potential products such as ice cream. In particular, simple 1H NMR spectroscopy was used to monitor and individually quantify the freezing or solidification behaviour of the various constituent species of the drops. In addition, the effect of freezing on the emulsion droplet size distribution (and hence emulsion stability) was also measured based on NMR self-diffusion measurements. The effect of freeze/thaw cycling was also similarly studied. The nucleation temperature of the emulsion droplets was found to depend on the emulsion droplet size distribution: the smaller the droplets, the lower the nucleation temperature. Emulsion droplet sizing indicated that oil-in-sucrose-solution emulsions were more stable, showing minimal coalescence, whereas oil-in-water emulsions showed significant coalescence during freezing and freeze/thaw cycling.     

Zooming in on the role of surfactants in droplet coalescence at the macroscale and microscale

Coalescence of dispersed micrometer-scale droplets is an essential step toward the separation of emulsions. The thin film between droplets must form, drain, and rupture for coalescence to occur. In surfactant-stabilized emulsions, the film drainage and droplet coalescence processes are known to be hindered because of reduced interfacial mobility. However, a clear correlation between this mobility and the underlying surfactant transport and interfacial response to shear and dilatational deformations is undercharacterized. For microscale droplets, the effect of surfactant transport to the interface and along the interface is often difficult to isolate from other bulk effects on emulsion stability. In this work, we review surfactant-mitigated coalescence in both macroscale and microscale experiments, highlighting the importance of interfacial curvature and length scales when establishing a correlation between coalescence theory and film mobility.     

Characterization of fluorocarbon-in-water emulsions with added triglyceride

Fluorocarbon-in-water emulsions are being explored clinically as synthetic oxygen carriers in general surgery. Stabilizing fluorocarbon emulsions against coarsening is critical in maintaining the biocompatibility of the formulation following intravenous administration. It has been purported that the addition of a small percentage of long-chain triglyceride results in stabilization of fluorocarbon emulsions via formation of a three-phase emulsion. In a three-phase emulsion, the triglyceride forms a layer around the dispersed fluorocarbon, thereby improving the adhesion of the phospholipid surfactant to the dispersed phase. In the present study, we examined the effect of triglyceride addition on the physicochemical characteristics of the resulting complex dispersion. In particular, we examined the particle composition and stability of the dispersed particles using a method which first fractionates (classifies) the different particles prior to sizing (i.e., sedimentation field-flow fractionation). It was determined that the addition of a long-chain triglyceride (soybean oil) results in oil demixing and two distinct populations of emulsion droplets. The presence of the two types of emulsion droplets is not observed via light scattering techniques, since the triglyceride droplets dominate the scattering due to a large difference in the refractive index between the particles and the medium as compared to fluorocarbon droplets. The growth of the fractionated fluorocarbon emulsion droplets was followed over time, and it was found that there was no difference in growth rates with and without added triglyceride. In contrast, addition of medium-chain-triglyceride (MCT) oils results in a single population of emulsion droplets (i.e., a three-phase emulsion). These emulsions are not stable to droplet coalescence, however, as significant penetration of MCT into the phospholipid lipid interfacial layer results in a negative increment in the monolayer spontaneous curvature, thereby favoring water-in-oil emulsions and resulting in destabilization of the emulsion to the effects of terminal heat sterilization or mechanical stress.     

Investigations into the electrical and coalescence behaviour of water-in-crude oil emulsions in high voltage gradients

The stability of water-in-crude oil emulsions when subjected to high voltage electric fields depends on the nature of the crude oil and the presence of chemical additives. Optical microscopy, conductivity and coalescence measurements have revealed two distinct types of behaviour, designated type I and type II. These are shown to be related to the crude oil/water interfacial rheological properties. For incompressible crude oil/water films, droplet—droplet coalescence is hindered and chains of water droplets are established. These increase the electrical conductivity of the emulsion (type I behaviour). On the other hand, efficient droplet—droplet coalescence accompanied by minimal conduction occurs in electric fields if the interfacial film is compressible (type II).     

Aeration of emulsions by whipping

During aeration of food emulsions such as dairy cream and ice cream, small gas bubbles are introduced, which are often stabilized by a layer of adsorbed emulsion droplets. It is shown that the maximum achievable volume of gas bubbles that can be incorporated by whipping depends on the effectiveness of the introduction of gas during the first stage of whipping and is furthermore limited by packing constraints. The main factors relevant for the latter limitation are the thickness of the coating of emulsion droplets at the bubble surface, the ratio between the droplet and bubble radii, and the fat content of the emulsion. It is hypothesized that, during whipping, a dynamic process of bubble break-up and coalescence adjusts the average bubble size and the volume of gas incorporated in the foam to the constraint of close packing of the bubbles. The consequences of this mechanism for whipping of emulsions are discussed.     

Influence of oil polarity on droplet growth in oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by a weakly adsorbing biopolymer or a nonionic surfactant

The influence of oil type (n-hexadecane, 1-decanol, n-decane), droplet composition (hexadecane:decanol), and emulsifier type (Tween 20, gum arabic) on droplet growth in oil-in-water emulsions was studied. Droplet size distributions of emulsions were measured over time (0-120 h) by laser diffraction and ultrasonic spectroscopy. Emulsions containing oil molecules of low polarity and low water solubility (hexadecane) were stable to droplet growth, irrespective of the emulsifier used to stabilize the droplets. Emulsions containing oil molecules of low polarity and relatively high water solubility (decane) were stable to coalescence, but unstable to Ostwald ripening, irrespective of emulsifier. Droplet growth in emulsions containing oil molecules of relatively high polarity and high water solubility (decanol) depended on emulsifier type. Decanol droplets stabilized by Tween 20 were stable to droplet growth in concentrated emulsions but unstable when the emulsions were diluted. Decanol droplets stabilized by gum arabic exhibited rapid and extensive droplet growth, probably due to a combination of Ostwald ripening and coalescence. We proposed that coalescence was caused by the relatively low interfacial tension at the decanol-water boundary, which meant that the gum arabic did not absorb strongly to the droplet surfaces and therefore did not prevent the droplets from coming into close proximity.     

Fat crystallization in complex food emulsions: Effects of adsorbed milk proteins and of a whipping process

Crystallization of fat droplets in complex emulsions, which differed only by the initial structure of proteins, was studied by differential scanning calorimetry, before and after application of a whipping process. Upon cooling at 5 or 1°C min^–1, the temperature needed to initiate fat crystallization was lower, and one more distinguishable crystallization peak was detected in emulsions containing caseins, in comparison with the emulsion containing pure whey proteins. Furthermore, the whipping process was accompanied by more protein depletion from the fat droplet surface, less resistance to coalescence, and a lower supercooling effect in the emulsion based on pure whey proteins.This revised version was published online in November 2005 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Progress in understanding emulsion metastability and surface forces

We provide an overview of the most recent advances in the field of surfactant and polymer-stabilized emulsions. The article is focused on inter-droplet forces, monolayer adhesion, aggregation of emulsion droplets, emulsion gels and finally destruction through coalescence and Ostwald ripening.     

Ethanol-in-oil emulsion (E/O) stabilized by polyglycerol polyricinoleate: A potential delivery system for ethanolic extract

This study evaluated how variations in polyglycerol polyricinoleate (PGPR) concentration and ethanol dispersed phase content affect the stability of ethanol-in-oil (E/O) emulsions. Results indicate that the stable 10?wt% E/O emulsions can be produced using 2?wt% PGPR. Increasing the ethanol dispersed phased content at constant PGPR concentration caused instability in emulsion. These emulsions remained stable to droplet flocculation and coalescence in the presence of Centella asiatica ethanol extract. PGPR does not greatly decrease the interfacial tension of the ethanol–oil interface. However, it adsorbed at the interface and stabilized the ethanol droplets in the emulsion via steric mechanism.     

Spreading of partially crystallized oil droplets on an air/water interface

The influence of crystalline fat on the amount and rate of oil spreading out of emulsion droplets onto either a clean or a protein-covered air/water interface was measured for β-lactoglobulin stabilized emulsions prepared with either anhydrous milk fat or a blend of hydrogenated palm fat and sunflower oil. At a clean interface, liquid oil present in the emulsion droplets was observed to completely spread out of the droplets unimpeded by the presence of a fat crystal network. Further, the presence of a fat crystal network in the emulsion droplets had no effect on the rate of oil spreading out of the droplets. At a protein-covered interface, the spreading behavior of emulsion droplets containing crystalline fat was evaluated in terms of the value of the surface pressure (Π_AW) at the point of spreading; Π_AW at spreading was unaffected by the presence of crystalline fat. We conclude it is unlikely that the role of crystalline fat in stabilizing aerated emulsions such as whipped cream is to reduce oil spreading at the air/water interface. However, the temperature of the system did have an effect: spontaneous spreading of emulsion droplets at clean air/water interfaces occurred for systems measured at 5 °C, but not for those measured at 22 or 37 °C. Thus, temperature may play a more important role in the whipping process than commonly thought: the entering and spreading of emulsion droplets was favored at lower temperatures because the surface pressure exerted by protein adsorbed at the air/water interface was reduced. This effect may facilitate the whipping process.     

On the escape process during phase inversion of an emulsion

This paper deals with a phenomenon which plays an important role in the phase inversion process of emulsions. This process is governed by the interplay of coalescence of droplets, often leading to double emulsions, and the escape of those internal droplets. The latter process retards the inversion process. Coalescence has been the subject of many studies, contrary to the escape event. This paper addresses the escape process both theoretically and experimentally. The model developed analyses the rate of the escape of internal droplets from the mother droplet via a coalescence process, where the internal flow, as generated by the external flow, generates the viscous force for coalescence. Incomplete mixing in the droplet has been assumed. Experimental data on the escape rate of oil droplets from O/W/O emulsions have been analysed using a Computational Fluid Dynamics approach, where the model as indicated above has been incorporated. Experimental data and simulations compare very well. Data have been compared on varying the size of the inner droplets and the rotational speed of the vessel where the double emulsion has been formed and where the escape took place.     

Unique crystal morphologies of glycine grown from octanoic acid-in-water emulsions

We have obtained both porous and dendritic, intricate morphology crystals of beta-glycine by the novel and simple method of emulsion droplet adhesion and encapsulation. By using octanoic acid emulsified with nonionic surfactants, the adhesion of the emulsion droplets can be so strong that, remarkably, crystal growth often proceeds around the droplets, leading to their inclusion within the single crystals. Consequently, porous single crystals can be produced with the pore diameters ( approximately 10-25 mum) corresponding to the emulsion droplet sizes. Highly intricate, dendritic morphologies for glycine were obtained by increasing the surfactant concentration in the emulsions to 50%. In this case, partial droplet encapsulation results in crystal dendrites growing on either side of adsorbed droplets, with the complex morphologies developing due to the high density of dendritic branches that can occur. These intricate morphologies are in stark contrast to the facetted crystals that normally develop at these low supersaturations in the absence of octanoic acid droplets. This study demonstrates that complex architectures can be attained by using simple emulsion systems and tuning the degree of droplet adhesion.     

A microfluidic method to study demulsification kinetics

We present the results of experiments studying droplet coalescence in a dense layer of emulsion droplets using microfluidic circuits. The microfluidic structure allows direct observation of collisions and coalescence events between oil droplets dispersed in water. The coalescence rate of a flowing hexadecane-in-water emulsion was measured as a function of the droplet velocity and droplet concentration from image sequences measured with a high-speed camera. A trajectory analysis of colliding droplet pairs allows evaluation of the film drainage profile and coalescence time t(c.) The coalescence times obtained for thousands of droplet pairs enable us to calculate coalescence time distributions for each set of experimental parameters, which are the mean droplet approach velocity (v(0)), the mean dispersed phase fraction (φ) and the mean hydraulic diameter of a droplet pair (d(p)). The expected value E(t(c)) of the coalescence time distributions scales as E(t(c)) is proportional to (v(0))(-0.105±0.043)(d(p))(0.562±0.287), but is independent of φ. We discuss the potential of the procedure for the prediction of emulsion stability in industrial applications.     

Methylcellulose-induced stability changes in protein-based emulsions

The emulsifying and oil-in-water stabilizing properties of methylcellulose (MeC) were investigated in bovine serum albumin (BSA)-based emulsions. The creaming stability, flocculation, surface concentration of BSA and MeC and droplet size were determined. Results obtained showed modifications of creaming rates that were related to MeC concentrations in the continuous and dispersed phases. Viscosity effects on creaming and changes in average droplet size (d₄₃) relating to droplet coverage were identified and delineated. Studies performed on macroscopic oil–water and air–water interfaces were used to identify interfacial structuring and composition. A good agreement was found between droplet surface composition and the resistance to coalescence of emulsion droplets. Emulsions that demonstrated a more rigid-like adsorbed interfacial layer were more stable with respect to coalescence. This study involving model emulsion systems provides a new insight into the stability of industrial preparations containing mixtures of proteins and polysaccharides.     

Nanoparticles of varying hydrophobicity at the emulsion droplet-water interface: adsorption and coalescence stability

The coalescence stability of poly(dimethylsiloxane) emulsion droplets in the presence of silica nanoparticles ( approximately 50 nm) of varying contact angles has been investigated. Nanoparticle adsorption isotherms were determined by depletion from solution. The coalescence kinetics (determined under coagulation conditions at high salt concentration) and the physical structure of coalesced droplets were determined from optical microscopy. Fully hydrated silica nanoparticles adsorb with low affinity, reaching a maximum surface coverage that corresponds to a close packed monolayer, based on the effective particle radius and controlled by the salt concentration. Adsorbed layers of hydrophilic nanoparticles introduce a barrier to coalescence of approximately 1 kT, only slightly reduce the coalescence kinetics, and form kinetically unstable networks at high salt concentrations. Chemically hydrophobized silica nanoparticles, over a wide range of contact angles (25 to >90 degrees ), adsorb at the droplet interface with high affinity and to coverages equivalent to close-packed multilayers. Adsorption isotherms are independent of the contact angle, suggesting that hydrophobic attraction overcomes electrostatic repulsion in all cases. The highly structured and rigid adsorbed layers significantly reduce coalescence kinetics: at or above monolayer surface coverage, stable flocculated networks of droplets form and, regardless of their wettability, particles are not detached from the interface during coalescence. At sub-monolayer nanoparticle coverages, limited coalescence is observed and interfacial saturation restricts the droplet size increase. When the nanoparticle interfacial coverage is >0.7 and <1.0, mesophase-like microstructures have been noted, the physical form and stability of which depends on the contact angle. Adsorbed nanoparticle layers at monolayer coverage and composed of a mixture of nanoparticles with different hydrophobisation levels form stable networks of droplets, whereas mixtures of hydrophobized and hydrophilic nanoparticles do not effectively stabilize emulsion droplets.     

Effect of Emulsifier Type on the Characterization of O/W Emulsions Using a Spectroscopy Technique

The droplet size distribution (DSD) of emulsions is the result of two competitive effects that take place during emulsification process, i.e., drop breakup and drop coalescence, and it is influenced by the formulation and composition variables, i.e., nature and amount of emulsifier, mixing characteristics, and emulsion preparation, all of which affect the emulsion stability. The aim of this study is to characterize oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions (droplet size and stability) in terms of surfactant concentration and surfactant composition (sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate (SDBS)/Tween 80 mixture). Ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) transmission spectroscopy has been applied to obtain droplet size and stability of the emulsions and the verification of emulsion stability with the relative cleared volume technique (time required for a certain amount of emulsion to separate as a cleared phase). It is demonstrated that the DSD of the emulsions is a function of the oil concentration and the surfactant composition with higher stability for emulsions prepared with higher SDBS ratio and lower relative cleared volume with the time. Results also show that smaller oil droplets are generated with increasing Tween 80 ratio and emulsifier concentration.     

Optimizing organoclay stabilized Pickering emulsions

Oil-in-water emulsions were prepared using montmorillonite clay platelets, pre-treated with quaternary amine surfactants. In previous work, cetyl trimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) has been used. In this study, two more hydrophilic quaternary amine surfactants, Berol R648 and Ethoquad C/12, were used and formed Pickering emulsions, which were more stable than the emulsions prepared using CTAB coated clay. The droplets were also more mono-disperse. The most hydrophilic surfactant Berol R648 stabilizes the emulsions best. Salt also plays an important role in forming a stable emulsion. The droplet size decreases with surfactant concentration and relatively mono-disperse droplets can be obtained at moderate surfactant concentrations. The time evolution of the droplet size indicates a good stability to coalescence in the presence of Berol R648. Using polarizing microscopy, the clay platelets were found to be lying flat at the water oil interface. However, a significant fraction (about 90%) of clay stayed in the water phase and the clay particles at the water-oil interface formed stacks, each consisting of four clay platelets on average.     

Flocculation and Coalescence of Oil-in-Water Poly(dimethylsiloxane) Emulsions

The stability of poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) oil-in-water emulsions has been investigated in the presence of added NaCl as well as in the presence of added surfactant. The emulsions were prepared using a combination of nonionic (C(x)E(y), x and y represent the number of methylene (C) and ethylene oxide (E) groups, respectively) and cationic (quarternary alkylammonium) surfactants. The droplets were observed to exhibit weak flocculation in the presence of high NaCl concentration (1 M). Phase separation and optical microscopic observations revealed that the principal mechanism for emulsion destabilization at high salt concentration was coalescence, which was accelerated at elevated temperature (50 degrees C). The effective coalescence rate for diluted emulsions was investigated using photon correlation spectroscopy. The small effective Hamaker constant for PDMS is the primary reason for the slow rate of coalescence observed for the emulsions at neutral pH in the presence of NaCl. The stability of PDMS emulsions to flocculation is qualitatively similar to that reported for low Hamaker constant dispersions (e.g., microgel particles). Addition of cationic surfactants (cetyltrimethylammonium chloride and dodecyl dimethylbenzylammonium chloride) to the negatively charged droplets after preparation was shown to decrease the emulsion stability once the surfactant concentration exceeded the CMC. Electrophoretic mobility measurements showed that added cationic surfactant changed the sign of the droplet charge from negative to positive at concentrations well below the CMC. Charged micelles of the same sign as the droplets are electrostatically excluded from close approach to the droplet surface within a distance (varepsilon) which results in depletion flocculation. Copyright 2000 Academic Press.     

Water-in-carbon dioxide emulsions stabilized with hydrophobic silica particles

W/C emulsions were stabilized using hydrophobic silica particles adsorbed at the interface, resulting in average droplet diameters as low as 7.5 microm. A porous cross-linked shell was formed about a hydrophilic (colloidal and fumed) silica core with a trifunctional silylating agent, (heptadecafluoro-1,1,2,2-tetrahydrodecyl)triethyoxysilane, to render the particles CO(2)-philic. The stability of emulsions comprising equal weights of CO(2) and water was assessed with visual observations of settling fronts and the degree of emulsion coalescence, and the average drop size was measured by optical microscopy. The effect of CO(2) density on both emulsion stability and droplet size was determined quantitatively. The major destabilizing mechanism of the emulsions was settling, whereas Ostwald ripening and coalescence were not visible at any density, even over 7 days. Flocculation of the settling droplets did not occur, although gelation of the emulsions through particle interactions resulted after longer periods of time. CO(2)-philic particles offer a new route to highly stable W/C emulsions, with particle energies of attachment on the order of 10(6)kT, even at CO(2) densities as low as 0.78 g ml(-1). At these low densities, surfactants rarely stabilize emulsions as the result of poor surfactant tail solvation.