Study of the uncertainty of façade sound insulation measurements: Analysis of the ISO 12999-1 uncertainty proposal

The result of a measurement is an approximation of the true value of the measurand and is complete when it is accompanied by its uncertainty. Building acoustics requires an assessment of the uncertainties that is understandable and corresponds closely to reality. The new standard ISO 12999-1 gives general uncertainty values for typical sound insulation measurements. The objective of this work is to determine the most accurate method for evaluating the uncertainty of in situ façade sound insulation measurements for both the D_ls,2m,nT values in one-third octave bands and the global magnitude D_ls,2m,nT,w. We establish a comparative analysis between the uncertainty values proposed by the standard ISO 12999-1, the uncertainty values deduced from interlaboratory activities and the average uncertainties deduced from individual calculations for each in situ measurement. The comparison is based on uncertainty calculations for around 1000 in situ façade sound insulation measurements made by our laboratory. The uncertainties given by the standard ISO 12999-1 for D_ls,2m,nT in one-third octave bands are, at low and high frequencies, higher than the values deduced from individual calculations and smaller than the calculated values at mid frequencies. We believe that for D_ls,2m,nT, it is advisable wherever possible to make individual uncertainty calculations for each in situ façade measurement. Nevertheless, the comparison with ISO 12999-1 points to the suitability of including some uncertainty components in the calculation, such as the related to the measurement procedure or source directivity, which are not normally considered in the uncertainty evaluation. Although we have clearly endorsed the use of individual calculations to determine the uncertainty of the sound insulation magnitude in one-third octave bands, we believe the uncertainty proposed by standard ISO 12999-1 could be a more realistic and reasonable approximation for the global magnitude D_ls,2m,nT,w. Therefore if an individual calculation of the uncertainty of the global magnitude is required the Monte Carlo simulation has been shown to be a good method.     

A scale model investigation of sound radiation from building elements

The directionality of sound radiated by typical building elements was investigated by using the techniques of acoustic scale modelling. The governing parameters of the model were first established and suitable modelling materials were then selected. The radiation patterns of a number of typical building elements were recorded and from a systematic examination of these patterns a predictive method suitable for implementation on a small computer was established.     

An experimental study on the effect of rolling shutters and shutter boxes on the airborne sound insulation of windows

The façade of a room is usually composed of different construction elements, one of which is the window. This fulfils both an aesthetic function and closes the wall opening. In order to improve thermal behaviour and control solar radiation, the window is fitted with different protection features, such as the shutter. In climate zones with many hours of sunlight, windows in residential buildings commonly incorporate a rolling shutter. Traffic noise and higher standards of energy saving, comfort, durability and sustainability in buildings means that windows now have to comply with stricter requirements, including their sound insulation from airborne noise. This work contains a summary of studies carried out on the sound insulation from airborne noise in several types of windows (double side-hung casement and double horizontal sliding sash) with built-on shutter and prefabricated box. For each type of window, an analysis was made of the effects of the interior finishings in the shutter box, the shutter position (whether fully retracted or extended) and the weighted sound reduction index of windows for traffic noise in accordance with EN ISO 717-1.     

A scale model investigation of sound radiation from a large aperture in a building

Measurements were made on a 1:20 scale model of a large aperture in a building. The experimental results were compared with the predictions of a simple theoretical model. Large discrepancies were observed at large aperture widths and high frequencies. The experimental data were used to derive corrections which were applied to the computer predictions to yield design charts suitable for use by the building designer.     

Scale model study of balcony insertion losses on a building façade with non-parallel line sources

The screening effect of balconies on a building façade in the case where the noise source is not parallel to the façade is studied using scale model experiment in the present study. Results show that the angle of source inclination to the façade has substantial effects on the balcony insertion loss in the presence of a traffic noise spectrum. Less amount of noise amplification is observed when the source is inclined compared to the case of parallel source in the presence of balcony ceiling reflections. Regression formulae in terms of three independent angles which determine the positions of the balcony and its ceiling relative to the noise source are developed for the prediction of balcony insertion loss. The discrepancy between measurements and predictions is within engineering tolerance.     

Sound fields near building facades - comparison of finite and semi-infinite reflectors on a rigid ground plane

The sound field in front of, and close to a building facade is relevant to the measurement and prediction of environmental noise and sound insulation. For simplicity it is often assumed that the facade can be treated as a semi-infinite reflector, however in the low-frequency range (50-200 Hz) this is no longer appropriate as the wavelengths are similar or larger than the facade dimensions. Scale model measurements and predictions using integral equation methods have been used to investigate the effect of diffraction on the sound field in front of finite size reflectors. For the situation that is commonly encountered in front of building facades, the results indicate that diffraction effects are only likely to be significant in the low-frequency range (50-200 Hz) when the façade dimensions are less than 5 m. This assumes that there is a point source close to the ground and microphones at a height of 1.2 or 1.5 m, at a distance between 1 and 2 m in front of the façade.     

Optical colours and polarization of a model reflection nebula

Simple models of a reflection nebula in the form of a plane-parallel slab containing smooth spherical solid particles in submicron size range have been considered. Single scattering has been assumed. The effect of varying the composition and size distribution function of the grains have been brought out in the calculations using Mie theory of scattering. The analytical part of the geometry of the problem has been treated quite rigorously and the resulting expression for nebular intensity has been presented in a somewhat new form. In this paper, the case of the star behind the nebula has been examined. A comparison of the theoretical results with the observations of the Merope nebula shows that the dirty ice grains with index of refraction about 1·3–0·1i and size parametera ₀ = 0·5μ give reasonable agreement with the colours. Simultaneously, the polarization in the visual and blue wavelength bands agree approximately up to offset angle of 6 minutes of arc. The larger offset angles pose an intriguing problem. The general trends of nebular colours and polarization with variation of real and imaginary parts of index of refraction and the size distribution parameter have been tabulated to serve as a guide for further study of reflection nebulae with the star in the rear. A part of this work was presented at the first scientific meeting of the Astronomical Society of India, held on 27 and 28 February 1974 at Hyderabad. An erratum to this article is available at .     

A simple acoustic model to characterize the internal low frequency sound field in centrifugal pumps

Conventional centrifugal pumps with volute casing generate fluid-dynamic noise particularly at the so-called blade-passing frequency, which is attributed to the interaction of the flow exiting the pump impeller with the volute tongue. Following previous work by the authors to characterize the effect of that blade–tongue interaction on the tonal sound produced, this paper presents a simple acoustic model for centrifugal pumps that considers ideal sound sources of arbitrary position and properties. The model is to be implemented in a software code that applies it systematically to a pump previously tested at laboratory, until identifying the set of ideal sources that best reproduce the pressure fluctuation measurements. In this model, the ideal sources are assumed to radiate plane sound waves along the impeller channels, volute, and outlet diffuser. The volute was considered to be composed by a succession of slices, each of them equivalent to a linear 3-port acoustic system with individual sound transmission and reflection coefficients. A series of tests was conducted to check the validity of the acoustic model, by applying an external acoustic load onto the pump outlet duct and measuring the noise reflected. The resulting reflection coefficient was in good agreement with the predictions of the acoustic model. Finally, the model was used to investigate the pump internal sound field at the blade-passing frequency when operating at 70% of nominal flow rate. It was concluded that the sound field can be characterized reasonably by a dipole-like source located at the tongue region.     

随机起伏冰面三维声散射的Kirchhoff近似数值计算模型

针对随机起伏冰面的声散射问题,建立了随机起伏冰面三维声散射的Kirchhoff近似数值计算模型。利用Delaunay三角剖分方法对随机起伏冰面进行三角面元剖分,然后采用Z-buffer算法进行面元的遮挡消隐,得到处于声波照射亮区的面元,最后采用Gordon面元积分的板块元方法计算得到随机起伏冰面的散射强度。数值计算模型中,将冰面认为是局部阻抗表面,直接代入起伏冰面局部反射系数进行散射声场的计算,避免了解析计算模型中对反射系数的近似处理。对比分析了数值和解析计算模型在小粗糙起伏冰面、大粗糙起伏冰面及不同声波入射角和不同声波频率时的散射强度。相比解析模型计算结果,数值模型计算结果与实测结果更吻合。     

The characteristics of acoustic line array prototypes for scale model experiments

The sound fields created by three different settings of a 5 m long linear loudspeaker array were studied experimentally in the present investigation in an attempt to find out a method to produce a reasonable sound field for scaled down model experiments. The first setting was with all the loudspeakers facing vertically upward, while the second setting was with all the loudspeakers facing the horizontal. The last one resembled the first setting but the loudspeakers were put inside a small partial enclosure whose opening was facing vertically upward. Results show that the last setting can produce a sound field with characteristics close to those of a two-dimensional sound field. The second setting results in a sound directivity pattern relevant to that of the measured A-weighted traffic noise.     

Sound propagation in forests: A comparison of experimental results and values predicted by the Nord 2000 model

The purpose of the work described in this paper is twofold: (i) to present the results of an experimental investigation of the sound attenuation in different types of forest, and (ii) to validate a part of the Nord 2000 model. A number of measurements have been carried out in regular and irregular forests with trees with deciduous and evergreen leaves, different tree density, different trunk diameter, etc. The experimental results indicate that trees have a noticeable effect on sound propagation at medium and high frequencies at distances longer than 40 m. The Nord 2000 model uses a simple algorithm to predict scattering effects when sound propagates in outdoor spaces with obstacles. The comparison of experimental results and predictions shows that the Nord 2000 model predicts the ground effect dip in forests with acceptable accuracy in about 60% of the cases if the flow resistivity of the ground is allowed to vary with distance. The high frequency effect of trees is in general not predicted very well.     

The influence of absorption factors on the sensitivity of a virtual room’s sound field to scattering coefficients

Currently there is limited information on what scattering coefficients (SCs) to assign materials in geometrical room acoustic computer models. As a result, room modelers rely on general guidelines and intuition when assigning SCs. How sensitive is the predicted sound field to the user’s choice of scattering coefficients? The sound field’s sensitivity depends on its diffusivity (without SCs); the more diffuse the room’s sound field is, the less sensitive the virtual room is to the selection of SCs. In rooms with no fittings to diffuse sound energy, the sound field diffusivity is influenced by (1) room shape, (2) volume, (3) amount and (4) location of absorption, and (5) the choice of SCs. This investigation focuses only on the latter three factors. A rectangular room is modeled in ODEON v6.5 with 10 absorption schemes. These schemes vary in terms of the area of mirrored reflective surfaces, average absorption coefficient, and standard deviation of absorption. The amount of diffuse reflections at each room boundary as dictated by the SC is increased uniformly in each room. Changes in the room sound field, in particular in the reverberation time (T30), are examined at each step. Sound field diffusivity, and consequently a virtual room model’s sensitivity to SCs, is found to depend most on the area of mirrored reflective surfaces. Also, a proposed quantity called the Scattering Sensitivity Index appears to predict sound field diffusivity.     

Investigating the absorption characteristics of open ceilings in multi-purpose halls using a 1:25 scale model

This paper investigated the absorption coefficients of acoustically transparent ceilings using 1:25 scale models. From a field survey of 18 existing halls, it was found that the open ceilings were equipped with steel truss structures, ducts, catwalks and ceiling surfaces. In order to investigate the absorption characteristics of the equipped ceilings, measurements were made using a 1:25 reverberation chamber based on ISO 354. Results showed that for an empty ceiling with a depth of 6 m, the absorption coefficient with a 50%-perforated ceiling surface is 0.2-0.3 above 500 Hz. If there were steel structures inside the ceiling, the absorption coefficient increased by 0.1 at 125 Hz to 2 kHz. Adding ducts and catwalks increased the absorption by 1-2 kHz. The absorption coefficients of the equipped ceilings ranged from 0.19 to 0.61 and the absorption characteristics were mainly found at high frequencies. Maximum absorption was observed in heavily equipped ceiling structures.     

Three-dimensional coupled-mode model and characteristics of low-frequency sound propagation in ocean waveguide with seamount topography

Large-scale topography, such as a seamount, substantially impacts low-frequency sound propagation in an ocean waveguide, limiting the application of low-frequency acoustic detecting techniques. A three-dimensional (3D) coupled-mode model is developed to calculate the acoustic field in an ocean waveguide with seamount topography and analyze the 3D effect. In this model, a correction is introduced in the bottom boundary, theoretically making the acoustic field satisfy the energy conservation. Furthermore, a large azimuth angle calculation range is obtained by using the operator theory and higher-order Padé approximation. Additionally, the model has advantages related to the coupling mode and parabolic equation theory. The couplings corresponding to the effects of range-dependent environment are fully considered, and the numerical implementation is kept feasible. After verifying the accuracy and reliability of the model, low-frequency sound propagation characteristics in the seamount environment are analyzed. The results indicate lateral variability in bathymetry can lead to out-of-plane effects such as the horizontal refraction phenomenon, while the coupling effect tends to restore the abnormal sound field and produces acoustic field diffraction behind the seamount. This model effectively considers the effects of the horizontal refraction and coupling, which are proportional to the scale of the seamount.     

Influence of absorption properties of materials on the accuracy of simulated acoustical measures in 1:10 scale model test

This study investigated the absorption characteristics of materials in a multi-purpose hall using computer models, 1:10 scale model and actual hall measurements of Gimhae Arts Hall (GAH), in order to predict and evaluate the acoustical characteristics. The elements of this scale model, such as reflecting walls, seats, audience, and absorption banners, were made with materials selected according to their absorption coefficients, measured in a 1:10 scale model reverberation chamber. After the real hall was completed, in situ acoustical measurements were conducted in the GAH and compared with those of the scale model hall. Comparison of these measurements showed that the delay time of the major reflections in the scale model hall was similar to that of the real hall. However, the reverberation time especially at low frequencies showed a difference between the scale model hall and the real hall measurements. The results of computer simulations for both scale model and actual hall showed that the absorption of seats and audience, the structural detail of the reflecting walls with different thickness and air spaces, and the duct facilities in the open-type ceiling are the major differences. It was confirmed that there are more complicated absorption characteristics in the scale model design of a multi-purpose hall than a concert hall.     

A sound quality-based investigation of the HVAC system noise of an automobile model

Using methods and techniques of sound quality engineering, the noise of the heating, ventilation and air-conditioning system (HVAC) of an automobile model was studied. Such noise has a great influence on vehicle acoustical comfort and on overall quality perception of a vehicle. The study was divided into two steps. The first step aimed to identify the most significant attributes that contribute to the perception of similarity or dissimilarity of this kind of noise, using the paired comparison technique and correlation of the results with psychoacoustic models. Loudness, spectral composition and tonality, represented by the psychoacoustic models of loudness, sharpness, tone-to-noise ratio and prominence were found to be the most important dimensions for the perception of similarity and dissimilarity of HVAC-noise.In the second step of the study a model to predict subjective response to HVAC sounds using the semantic differential technique was developed. In particular the perception of annoyance was studied and it is shown that the annoyance caused by the HVAC noise can be satisfactorily described by Zwicker’s stationary loudness model, provided that the HVAC noises do not present tonal components. The loudness model also predicts scores on a quiet/loud scale. Both results confirm the power of the loudness dimension and its model introduced by Zwicker for the overall quality of stationary broadband sounds without slow fluctuations or tonal components. From the annoyance model developed in this study a maximum acceptable loudness level for HVAC-systems can be determined.     

Substituent effect study on 13Cβ SCS of styrene series. A Yukawa–Tsuno model and Reynolds dual substituent parameter model investigation

The Yukawa–Tsuno (Y–T) and Reynolds dual substituent parameter (DSP) models have been used to model ¹³C substituent chemical shift (SCS) of the C_β atom of 19 series of para‐substituted styrenes (X‐C₆H₄CR?CYW) with variable electronic and structural demands in the side‐chain. The best fit of the Y–T model was better than that of the Reynolds DSP model for most of the studied series. A high correlation was found between the ρ value of the Y–T model and ρ_F value of the Reynolds DSP model. The ρ value, which reflects the sensitivity of ¹³C_β SCS to the substituent field effect, was found to be influenced by the group W on the C_β atom. A W group that enhances the para‐substituent π‐polarization of the side‐chain has a higher ρ value than its counterpart W groups that induce counter π‐polarization in the side‐chain. The series with W in an E‐configuration to the aryl ring has higher ρ value than corresponding Z series. A lower ρ value is observed when W induces a counter π‐polarization of the side‐chain (as with NO₂ and COMe) or when the R substituent imposes a 65° dihedral angle between the side‐chain and the para‐substituted benzene ring (as with t‐Bu). When the W group is a heterocyclic ring, the closer the heteroatom is to C_β, the lower the ρ value is due to the greater counter π‐polarization. The two components of the substituent effect on ¹³C _β SCS, namely the field effect and resonance effect, behave inversely. The resonance demand (r⁺ value) increases, as the Y and/or W groups become more electron‐withdrawing (EW). The series with W as a hetrocyclic ring develop negative charge at the carbon atom of the hetrocyclic ring adjacent to C_β (and to which the styryl moiety is attached) and has a lower r⁺ value than those which fail to do so. The lowest r⁺ value was for those series with a 65° dihedral angle. Copyright © 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

A real-time investigation by RHEED of the homoepitaxial growth of GaAs on (0 0 1) oriented surfaces

In this letter we report on the formation of long-range surface disorder features during the growth by molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) of homoepitaxial GaAs (0 0 1) films having the β2(2 × 4) reconstruction. Observations were made in real-time at the growth temperature using reflection high energy electron diffraction (RHEED) and analyzed kinematically. We show that kinks (cooperative shifts of whole columns of 2 × 4 units along the [1 1 0] direction) form rapidly as growth commences and that the antiphase domain structure present on the substrate prior to growth as a result of the arrangement of As-As dimers persists. This produces a surface with two types of long-range disorder. We speculate on the role of incident Ga atoms on this process.