A hybrid evolutionary algorithm for the periodic location-routing problem

The well-known vehicle routing problem (VRP) has been studied in depth over the last decades. Nowadays, generalizations of VRP have been developed for tactical or strategic decision levels of companies but not both. The tactical extension or periodic VRP (PVRP) plans a set of trips over a multiperiod horizon, subject to frequency constraints. The strategic extension is motivated by interdependent depot location and routing decisions in most distribution systems. Low-quality solutions are obtained if depots are located first, regardless of the future routes. In the location-routing problem (LRP), location and routing decisions are tackled simultaneously. Here for the first time, except for some conference papers, the goal is to combine the PVRP and LRP into an even more realistic problem covering all decision levels: the periodic LRP or PLRP. A hybrid evolutionary algorithm is proposed to solve large size instances of the PLRP. First, an individual representing an assignment of customers to combinations of visit days is randomly generated. The evolution operates through an Evolutionary Local Search (ELS) on visit day assignments. The algorithm is hybridized with a heuristic based on the Randomized Extended Clarke and Wright Algorithm (RECWA) to create feasible solutions and stops when a given number of iterations is reached. The method is evaluated over three sets of instances, and solutions are compared to the literature on particular cases such as one-day horizon (LRP) or one depot (PVRP). This metaheuristic outperforms the previous methods for the PLRP.     

Solving the dynamic capacitated location-routing problem with fuzzy demands by hybrid heuristic algorithm

In this paper, the dynamic capacitated location-routing problem with fuzzy demands (DCLRP-FD) is considered. In the DCLRP-FD, facility location problem and vehicle routing problem are solved on a time horizon. Decisions concerning facility locations are permitted to be made only in the first time period of the planning horizon but, the routing decisions may be changed in each time period. Furthermore, the vehicles and depots have a predefined capacity to serve the customers with altering demands during the time horizon. It is assumed that the demands of customers are fuzzy variables. To model the DCLRP-FD, a fuzzy chance-constrained programming is designed based upon the fuzzy credibility theory. To solve this problem, a hybrid heuristic algorithm (HHA) with four phases including the stochastic simulation and a local search method are proposed. To achieve the best value of two parameters of the model, the dispatcher preference index (DPI) and the assignment preference index (API), and to analyze their influences on the final solution, numerical experiments are carried out. Moreover, the efficiency of the HHA is demonstrated via comparing with the lower bound of solutions and by using a standard benchmark set of test problems. The numerical examples show that the proposed algorithm is robust and could be used in real world problems.     

Solving the capacitated location-routing problem

This is a summary of the main results presented in the author’s Ph.D thesis, available at http://prodhonc.free.fr/homepage. This thesis, written in French, was supervised by Christian Prins and Roberto Wolfler-Calvo, and defended on 16 October 2006 at the Université de Technologie de Troyes. Several new approaches are proposed to solve the capacitated location-routing problem (CLRP): heuristic, cooperative and exact methods. Their performances are tested on various kinds of instances with capacitated vehicles and capacitated or uncapacitated depots.      

Using clustering analysis in a capacitated location-routing problem

The location routing problem (LRP) appears as a combination of two difficult problems: the facility location problem (FLP) and the vehicle routing problem (VRP). In this work, we consider a discrete LRP with two levels: a set of potential capacitated distribution centres (DC) and a set of ordered customers. In our problem we intend to determine the set of installed DCs as well as the distribution routes (starting and ending at the DC). The problem is also constrained with capacities on the vehicles. Moreover, there is a homogeneous fleet of vehicles, carrying a single product and each customer is visited just once. As an objective we intend to minimize the routing and location costs.     

The equitable location problem on the plane

This paper considers the problem of locating M facilities on the unit square so as to minimize the maximal demand faced by each facility subject to closest assignments and coverage constraints. Focusing on uniform demand over the unit square, we develop upper and lower bounds on feasibility of the problem for a given number of facilities and coverage radius. Based on these bounds and numerical experiments we suggest a heuristic to solve the problem. Our computational results show that the heuristic is very efficient, as the average gap between its solutions and the lower bound is 4.34%.     

A column generation approach for location-routing problems with pickup and delivery

In this paper we formulate an integer programming model for the Location and Routing Problem with Pickup and Delivery. We propose a column generation scheme and implement, for the subproblem, a label-setting algorithm for the shortest path with pickup and delivery and time windows problem. We also propose a set of heuristics to speed up this process. To validate the model, we implement the column generation scheme and test it on different instances developed in this paper. We also provide an analysis of how the costs of opening depots and the fixed cost of routes affect the optimal solution.     

A new formulation and an exact approach for the many-to-many hub location-routing problem

An important problem of the freight industry is the parcel delivery network design, where several facilities are responsible for assembling flows from several origins, re-routing them to other facilities where the flows are disassembled and the packages delivered to their final destinations. In order to provide this service, local tours are established for the vehicles assigned to each of the processing facilities, which are then responsible for the pickup and delivery tasks. This application gives rise to the many-to-many hub location routing problem that is the combination of two well known problems: the vehicle routing problem and the single assignment hub location problem. In this work, a new formulation for this important problem is proposed and solved by a specially tailored Benders decomposition algorithm. The proposed method is robust enough to solve instances up to 100 nodes having 4 million integer variables.     

The variable radius covering problem

In this paper we propose a covering problem where the covering radius of a facility is controlled by the decision-maker; the cost of achieving a certain covering distance is assumed to be a monotonically increasing function of the distance (i.e., it costs more to establish a facility with a greater covering radius). The problem is to cover all demand points at a minimum cost by finding optimal number, locations and coverage radii for the facilities. Both, the planar and discrete versions of the model are considered. Heuristic approaches are suggested for solving large problems in the plane. These methods were tested on a set of planar problems. Mathematical programming formulations are proposed for the discrete problem, and a solution approach is suggested and tested.     

Location-routing: Issues,models and methods

This paper is a survey of location-routing: a relatively new branch of locational analysis that takes into account vehicle routing aspects. We propose a classification scheme and look at a number of problem variants. Both exact and heuristic algorithms are investigated. Finally, some suggestions for future research are presented.     

Selective capacitated location-routing problem with incentive-dependent returns in designing used products collection network

This paper addresses a generalization of the capacitated location-routing problem (CLRP) arising in the design of a collection network for a company engaged in collecting used products from customer zones. The company offers customers a financial incentive per unit of used products. This incentive determines the quantity of used products which are returned by customers. Moreover, it is not necessary for the company to visit all customer zones or to collect all returns in each visited customer zone. The objective is to simultaneously find the location of collection centers, the routes of vehicles, the value of incentive offered and the amount of used products collected from customer zones, so as to maximize the company's overall profit. We develop two mixed integer linear programming formulations of the problem and a heuristic algorithm based on iterated local search. Extensive computational experiments on this problem demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm.     

A genetic algorithm for the problem of configuring a hub-and-spoke network for a LTL trucking company in Brazil

A heuristic based on genetic algorithms is proposed to the problem of configuring hub-and-spoke networks for trucking companies that operate less-than-truckload (LTL) services in Brazil. The problem consists of determining the number of consolidation terminals (also known as hubs), their locations and the assignment of the spokes to the hubs, aiming to minimize the total cost, which is composed of fixed and variable costs. The proposed formulation differs from similar formulations found in the literature in the sense that it allows variable scale-reduction factors for the transportation costs according to the total amount of freight between hub terminals, as occurs to less-than-truckload (LTL) freight carriers in Brazil. Our genetic algorithm approach incorporates an efficient local improvement procedure that is applied to each generated individual of the population. Computational results for benchmark problems are presented. A practical application to a real world problem involving one of the top-ten trucking companies in Brazil is also described.     

An adaptation of SH heuristic to the location set covering problem

In a recent paper, a new surrogate heuristic (SH) has been proposed for the set covering problem. Here we present an adaptation of it in order to solve more efficiently the location set covering problem. We will show that our new version not only outperforms algorithm SH but that it is more accurate than the pair CMA/FMC. Its power is experimentally tested over a set of 65 randomly generated problems.     

The capacitated multiple allocation hub location problem: Formulations and algorithms

In this paper we consider and present formulations and solution approaches for the capacitated multiple allocation hub location problem. We present a new mixed integer linear programming formulation for the problem. We also construct an efficient heuristic algorithm, using shortest paths. We incorporate the upper bound obtained from this heuristic in a linear-programming-based branch-and-bound solution procedure. We present the results of extensive computational experience with both the heuristic and the exact methods.     

The Transit Route Arc-Node Service Maximization problem

This article presents a new method for determining optimal transit routes. The Transit Route Arc-Node Service Maximization model is a mathematical model that maximizes the service value of a route, rather than minimizing cost. Cost (distance) is considered as a budget constraint on the extent of the route. The mathematical formulation modifies and exploits the structure of linear programming problems designed for the traveling salesman problem. An innovative divide-and-conquer solution procedure is presented that not only makes the transit routing problem tractable, but also provides a range of high-quality alternate routes for consideration, some of which have substantially varying geometries. Variant formulations are provided for several common transit route types. The model is tested through its application to an existing street network in Richardson, TX. Optimal numeric results are obtained for several problem instances, and these results demonstrate that increased route cost is not correlated with increased service provision.     

A location-routing problem for the conversion to the “click-and-mortar” retailing: The static case

The static conversion from brick-and-mortar retailing to the hybrid click-and-mortar business model is studied from the perspective of distribution logistics. Retailers run warehouses and brick-and-mortar stores to meet the demand of their walk-in customers. When they decide to operate on the Web as an e-tailer, also click-and-mortar stores are needed which can serve both walk-in and online customers. While the distance between home and the nearest open store is used as a proxy measure for walk-in customers, a quality of service (QoS) guarantee for online customers is timely delivery of their orders. We describe and solve a static location-routing based problem for companies that embrace the clicks-and-bricks strategy in their retail operations. An augmented Lagrangian relaxation method embedded in a subgradient optimization procedure generates lower bounds, whereas a heuristic method finds feasible solutions. The performance of the Lagrangian-based solution method is tested on a number of randomly generated test problems.     

Improved modeling and solution methods for the multi-resource routing problem

This paper presents modeling and solution method improvements for the Multi-Resource Routing Problem (MRRP) with flexible tasks. The MRRP with flexible tasks is used to model routing and scheduling problems for intermodal drayage operations in which two resources (tractors and trailers) perform tasks to transport loaded and empty equipment. Tasks may be either well defined, in which both the origin and the destination of a movement are given, or flexible, in which the origin or the destination is chosen by the model. This paper proposes methods to effectively manage the number of options considered for flexible tasks (either feasible origins for a known destination or feasible destinations for a known origin). This modeling change generates sufficient options to allow for low-cost solutions while maintaining reasonable computational effort. We also propose a new solution method that uses randomized route generation. Computational results from test cases show that these changes improve the quality of solutions by at least 5% in the test cases as compared to methods from previous studies.     

A multi-objective mathematical model for the industrial hazardous waste location-routing problem

Industrial hazardous waste management involves the collection, transportation, treatment, recycling and disposal of industrial hazardous materials that pose risk to their surroundings. In this paper, a new multi-objective location-routing model is developed, and implemented in the Marmara region of Turkey. The aim of the model is to help decision makers decide on locations of treatment centers utilizing different technologies, routing different types of industrial hazardous wastes to compatible treatment centers, locations of recycling centers and routing hazardous waste and waste residues to those centers, and locations of disposal centers and routing waste residues there. In the mathematical model, three criteria are considered: minimizing total cost, which includes total transportation cost of hazardous materials and waste residues and fixed cost of establishing treatment, disposal and recycling centers; minimizing total transportation risk related to the population exposure along transportation routes of hazardous materials and waste residues; and minimizing total risk for the population around treatment and disposal centers, also called site risk. A lexicographic weighted Tchebycheff formulation is developed and computed with CPLEX software to find representative efficient solutions to the problem. Data related to the Marmara region is obtained by utilizing Arcview 9.3 GIS software and Marmara region geographical database.     

Heuristics for the fixed cost median problem

We describe in this paper polynomial heuristics for three important hard problems—the discrete fixed cost median problem (the plant location problem), the continuous fixed cost median problem in a Euclidean space, and the network fixed cost median problem with convex costs. The heuristics for all the three problems guarantee error ratios no worse than the logarithm of the number of customer points. The derivation of the heuristics is based on the presentation of all types of median problems discussed as a set covering problem.     

Heuristic methods for the sectoring arc routing problem

The sectoring arc routing problem (SARP) is introduced to model activities associated with the streets of large urban areas, like municipal waste collection. The aim is to partition the street network into a given number of sectors and to build a set of vehicle trips in each sector, to minimize the total duration of the trips. Two two-phase heuristics and one best insertion method are proposed. In the two-phase methods, phase 1 constructs the sectors using two possible heuristics, while phase 2 solves a mixed capacitated arc routing problem (MCARP) to compute the trips in each sector. The best insertion method determines sectors and trips simultaneously. In addition to solution cost, some evaluation criteria such as imbalance, diameter and dispersion measures are used to compare algorithms. Numerical results on large instances with up to 401 nodes and 1056 links (arcs or edges) are reported and analysed.