Directed assembly of surface-supported bilayers with transmembrane helices

The lateral assembly of transmembrane (TM) helices gives rise to membrane proteins with complex folds, which play important roles in biochemical processes. Therefore, the assembly of surface-supported bilayers containing TM helices is the first step toward the development of functional biomembrane mimetics. Here we report novel directed assembly of surface-supported lipid bilayers with laterally mobile TM helices. The TM helices were incorporated into lipid monolayers at the air/water interface, and the monolayers were then transferred onto glass substrates using Langmuir-Blodgett (LB) deposition. Finally, bilayers were assembled using lipid vesicle fusion on top of the LB monolayers. The novelty is the incorporation of the peptides into the monolayer at the first step of bilayer assembly, which allows control over the peptide concentration and orientation. The transmembrane orientation of the peptides was confirmed using oriented circular dichroism (OCD), lateral mobility was assessed using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), and diffusion coefficients were determined using a novel boundary profile evolution (BPE) method. The described directed-assembly approach can be used to develop versatile bilayer platforms for studying membrane proteins interactions in native bilayer environments.     

Measuring lipid asymmetry in planar supported bilayers by fluorescence interference contrast microscopy

There is substantial scientific and practical interest in engineering supported lipid bilayers with asymmetric lipid distributions as models for biological cell membranes. In principle, it should be possible to make asymmetric supported lipid bilayers by either the Langmuir-Blodgett/Schafer (LB/LS) or Langmuir-Blodgett/vesicle fusion (LB/VF) techniques (Kalb et al. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1992, 1103, 307-316). However, the retention of asymmetry in biologically relevant lipid bilayers has never been experimentally examined in any of these systems. In the present work, we developed a technique that is based on fluorescence interference contrast (FLIC) microscopy to measure lipid asymmetry in supported bilayers. We compared the final degree of lipid asymmetry in LB/LS and LB/VF bilayers with and without cholesterol in liquid-ordered (l(o)) and liquid-disordered (l(d)) phases. Of five different fluorescent lipid probes that were examined, 1,2-dipalmitoyl-phosphatidylethanolamine-N-[lissamine rhodamine B] was the best for studying supported bilayers of complex composition and phase by FLIC microscopy. An asymmetrically labeled bilayer made by the LB/LS method was found to be at best 70-80% asymmetric once completed. In LB/LS bilayers of either l(o) or l(d) phase, cholesterol increased the degree of lipid mixing between the opposing monolayers. The use of a tethered polymer support for the initial monolayer did not improve lipid asymmetry in the resulting bilayer. However, asymmetric LB/VF bilayers retained nearly 100% asymmetric label, with or without the use of a tethered polymer support. Finally, lipid mixing across the center of LB/LS bilayers was found to have drastic effects on the appearance of l(d)-l(o) phase coexistence as shown by epifluorescence microscopy.     

Characterization of phospholipid bilayer formation on a thin film of porous SiO2 by reflective interferometric Fourier transform spectroscopy (RIFTS)

Classical methods for characterizing supported artificial phospholipid bilayers include imaging techniques such as atomic force microscopy and fluorescence microscopy. The use in the past decade of surface-sensitive methods such as surface plasmon resonance and ellipsometry, and acoustic sensors such as the quartz crystal microbalance, coupled to the imaging methods, have expanded our understanding of the formation mechanisms of phospholipid bilayers. In the present work, reflective interferometric Fourier transform spectrocopy (RIFTS) is employed to monitor the formation of a planar phospholipid bilayer on an oxidized mesoporous Si (pSiO(2)) thin film. The pSiO(2) substrates are prepared as thin films (3 μm thick) with pore dimensions of a few nanometers in diameter by the electrochemical etching of crystalline silicon, and they are passivated with a thin thermal oxide layer. A thin film of mica is used as a control. Interferometric optical measurements are used to quantify the behavior of the phospholipids at the internal (pores) and external surfaces of the substrates. The optical measurements indicate that vesicles initially adsorb to the pSiO(2) surface as a monolayer, followed by vesicle fusion and conversion to a surface-adsorbed lipid bilayer. The timescale of the process is consistent with prior measurements of vesicle fusion onto mica surfaces. Reflectance spectra calculated using a simple double-layer Fabry-Perot interference model verify the experimental results. The method provides a simple, real-time, nondestructive approach to characterizing the growth and evolution of lipid vesicle layers on the surface of an optical thin film.     

Surface-supported bilayers with transmembrane proteins: role of the polymer cushion revisited

Protein lateral mobility in surface-supported bilayers is often much lower than the mobility of the lipids. In the present study we explore whether the incorporation of a PEG cushion between the bilayer and the substrate increases the lateral mobility of transmembrane proteins in bilayers produced via directed assembly, a method based on Langmuir-Blodgett deposition techniques. In our experiments, the PEG cushions were incorporated by adding PEG lipids to the protein/lipid monolayer at the air/water interface, at the first step of bilayer assembly. The protein and lipid mobilities in 160 different bilayers, with various PEG molecular weights and PEG lipid concentrations, were measured and compared. We found that the measured diffusion coefficients do not depend on the PEG molecular weight or the PEG lipid concentration and are very similar to the values measured in the absence of PEG. Therefore, contrary to our expectations, we found that a PEG cushion does not necessarily increase protein mobility, suggesting that the low protein mobility is not a consequence of protein-substrate interactions. Furthermore, we showed that the low protein mobility is not due to protein aggregation. The major determinant of protein mobility in surface-supported bilayer systems appears to be the method of bilayer assembly. While proteins were always mobile if the bilayers were prepared using the directed assembly method, in the presence and absence of a PEG cushion, other bilayer assembly protocols resulted in complete lack of protein mobility.     

Vesicle adsorption on mesoporous silica and titania

Lipid bilayer formation via vesicle fusion on mesoporous silica and mesoporous titania was investigated using quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring (QCM-D) and fluorescent recovery after photobleaching (FRAP). Results showed that lipid bilayers were formed on mesoporous silica and that intact vesicle adsorption was obtained on mesoporous titania. From the FRAP results, it could be concluded that the lipid bilayer was fluid; however, it had a smaller diffusivity constant compared to bilayers supported on a nonporous silica.     

Subnanometer actuation of a tethered lipid bilayer monitored with fluorescence resonance energy transfer

Lipid membrane nanotechnology can play a key role in preserving the function of transmembrane proteins on biofunctional substrates. We show here that rational nanoscopic actuation of a polymer-tethered lipid bilayer can be achieved by modulating the dielectric environment at the membrane-substrate interface. This provides a hydrated platform with increased lipid mobility compared to bilayers supported directly onto silica. We suggest that this construct may be used for promoting the functional reconstitution of transmembrane proteins on planar surfaces for bioanalytical devices.     

Engineered lipids that cross-link the inner and outer leaflets of lipid bilayers

The application of supported lipid bilayer systems as molecular sensors, diagnostic devices, and medical implants is limited by their lack of stability. In an effort to enhance the stability of supported lipid bilayers, three pairs of phosphatidylcholine lipids were designed to cross-link at the termini of their 2-position acyl chain upon the formation of lipid bilayers. The cross-linked lipids span the lipid bilayer, resembling naturally occurring bolaamphiphiles that stabilize archaebacterial membranes against high temperatures. The three reactions investigated here include the acyl chain cross-linking between thiol and bromine groups, thiol and acryloyl groups, and cyclopentadiene and acryloyl groups. All three reactive lipid pairs were found to cross-link in liposomal membranes, as determined by thin-layer chromatography, ion-spray mass spectrometry, and 1H NMR. The monolayer film properties of the reactive amphiphiles were characterized by surface pressure-area isotherms and showed that stable monolayers formed at the air-water interface with limiting molecular areas comparable to that of pure saturated phosphatidylcholine lipids. Langmuir-Blodgett bilayers of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine incorporating 15 mol % of the reactive thiol and acryloyl lipids had diffusion coefficients comparable with pure dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine, while bilayers with more than 25 mol % of the reactive lipids were immobile, suggesting that interleaflet cross-linking of the lipids inhibited membrane diffusion. Our results show that the reactive lipids can cross-link within a lipid bilayer and are suitable for assembling supported lipid bilayers using Langmuir-Blodgett deposition. By using terminally reactive amphiphiles to build up supported lipid bilayers with cross-linked leaflets, bolaamphiphiles can be incorporated into asymmetric solid supported membranes to increase their stability in biosensor and medical implant applications.     

Protein adsorption on supported phospholipid bilayers

Quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) measurements were used to investigate the adsorption of human fibrinogen, human serum albumin, bovine hemoglobin, horse heart cytochrome c, human immunoglobulin (hIgG), and 10% fetal bovine serum on supported bilayers of egg-phosphatidylcholine (eggPC) lipids. For comparison the adsorption of fibrinogen and hIgG to eggPC bilayers was also studied with surface plasmon resonance (SPR). The supported bilayers were formed in situ by vesicle adhesion and spontaneous fusion onto a SiO(2) surface. The supported lipid bilayer is highly protein resistant: The irreversible adsorption measured with the QCM-D technique was below the detection level, while reversible protein adsorption was detected for all the proteins in the range 0.3-4% of the saturation coverage on a hydrophobic thiol monolayer on gold. The adsorbed amounts were slightly higher for the SPR measurements. Possible mechanisms for the protein resistance of eggPC bilayers are briefly discussed.     

Asymmetric distribution of anionic phospholipids in supported lipid bilayers

Lipid bilayers with a controlled content of anionic lipids are a prerequisite for the quantitative study of hydrophobic-electrostatic interactions of proteins with lipid bilayers. Here, the asymmetric distribution of zwitterionic and anionic lipids in supported lipid bilayers is studied by neutron reflectometry. We prepare POPC/POPS (3:1) unilamellar vesicles in a high-salt-concentration buffer. Initially, no fusion of the vesicles to a SiO(2) surface is observed over hours and days. Once the isotonic buffer is exchanged with hypotonic buffer, vesicle fusion and bilayer formation occur by osmotic shock. Neutron reflectivity on the bilayers formed this way reveals the presence of anionic lipids (d(31)-POPS) in the outer bilayer leaflet only, and no POPS is observed in the leaflet facing the SiO(2) substrate. We argue that this asymmetric distribution of POPS is induced by the electrostatic repulsion of the phosphatidylserines from the negatively charged hydroxy surface groups of the silicon block. Such bilayers with controlled and high contents of anionic lipids in the outer leaflet are versatile platforms for studying anionic lipid protein interactions that are key elements in signal transduction pathways in the cytoplasmic leaflet of eukaryotic cells.     

Composition and asymmetry in supported membranes formed by vesicle fusion

The structure and formation of supported membranes at silica surfaces by vesicle fusion was investigated by neutron reflectivity and quartz crystal microbalance (QCM-D) measurements. The structure of equimolar phospholipid mixtures of DLPC-DPPC, DMPC-DPPC, and DOPC-DPPC depends intricately on the vesicle deposition conditions. The supported bilayer membranes exhibit varying degrees of compositional asymmetry between the monolayer leaflets, which can be modified by the deposition temperature as well as the salt concentration of the vesicle solution. The total lipid composition of the supported bilayers differs from the composition of the vesicles in solution, and the monolayer proximal to the silica surface is always enriched in DPPC compared to the distal monolayer. The results, which show unambiguougsly that some exchange and rearrangement of lipids occur during vesicle deposition, can be rationalized by considering the effects of salt screening and temperature on the rates of lipid exchange, rearrangement, and vesicle adsorption, but there is also an intricate dependence on the lipid-lipid interactions. Thus, although both symmetric and asymmetric supported bilayers can be prepared from vesicles, the optimal conditions are sensitive to the lipid composition of the system.     

Supported lipid bilayer composition microarray fabricated by pattern-guided self-spreading

We report on the fabrication of a microarray of supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) with different chemical compositions and demonstrate its biosensing application. The technique utilizes the phenomenon of lipid self-spreading on a patterned surface, which offers complete positional selectivity for a supported lipid bilayer. We describe the fabrication of parallel 10-μm-wide lines, each filled with an SLB with a unique composition, at 5 μm intervals. Structures obtained with our new technique are finer and more highly integrated than previously reported structures that employ the vesicle fusion technique on patterned surfaces. We also detected specific binding between biotin and streptavidin with high contrast, indicating that the microarray is valuable for biosensing applications.     

Lateral mobility of tethered vesicle-DNA assemblies

Supported lipid membranes are particularly attractive for use in biochemical assays because of their resistance to nonspecific adsorption and their unique ability to host transmembrane proteins. Although ideal for use in many surface-based detection techniques, supported bilayers can make the incorporation of proteins problematic due to the steric constraints of the underlying substrate. A recently developed strategy overcomes this obstacle by tethering liposomes to supported lipid bilayers via cholesterol-tagged DNA. Due to the fluidity of the bilayer, the vesicle assemblies exhibited significant lateral mobility. The corresponding diffusion coefficients were then investigated using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP). The diffusivity was neither sensitive to the size of the vesicles nor to the length of the DNA tether. However, changing from single cholesterol tethers to double cholesterol tethers caused a decrease in the diffusivity of the assemblies by a factor of 3. Perhaps even more notable was the fact that single cholesterol-DNA without vesicles diffused 6 times faster than the corresponding assemblies. Double cholesterol-DNA diffused 11 times faster. This discrepancy is believed to arise from the fact that each vesicle is tethered to the bilayer by multiple DNA pairs.     

Nanoporous microbead supported bilayers: stability, physical characterization, and incorporation of functional transmembrane proteins

The introduction of functional transmembrane proteins into supported bilayer-based biomimetic systems presents a significant challenge for biophysics. Among the various methods for producing supported bilayers, liposomal fusion offers a versatile method for the introduction of membrane proteins into supported bilayers on a variety of substrates. In this study, the properties of protein containing unilamellar phosphocholine lipid bilayers on nanoporous silica microspheres are investigated. The effects of the silica substrate, pore structure, and the substrate curvature on the stability of the membrane and the functionality of the membrane protein are determined. Supported bilayers on porous silica microspheres show a significant increase in surface area on surfaces with structures in excess of 10 nm as well as an overall decrease in stability resulting from increasing pore size and curvature. Comparison of the liposomal and detergent-mediated introduction of purified bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and the human type 3 serotonin receptor (5HT3R) are investigated focusing on the resulting protein function, diffusion, orientation, and incorporation efficiency. In both cases, functional proteins are observed; however, the reconstitution efficiency and orientation selectivity are significantly enhanced through detergent-mediated protein reconstitution. The results of these experiments provide a basis for bulk ionic and fluorescent dye-based compartmentalization assays as well as single-molecule optical and single-channel electrochemical interrogation of transmembrane proteins in a biomimetic platform.     

Single Lipid Bilayers Constructed on Polymer Cushion Studied by Sum Frequency Generation Vibrational Spectroscopy

Planar solid supported single lipid bilayers on mica, glass, or other inorganic surfaces have been widely used as models for cell membranes. To more closely mimic the cell membrane environment, soft hydrophilic polymer cushions were introduced between the hard inorganic substrate and the lipid bilayer to completely avoid the possible substrate-lipid interactions. In this article, sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy was used to examine and compare single lipid bilayers assembled on the CaF(2) prism surface and on poly (L-lactic acid) (PLLA) cushion. By using asymmetric lipid bilayers composed of a hydrogenated 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycerol-3-phosphoglycerol (DPPG) leaflet and a deuterated 1,2-dipalmitoyl-(d62)-sn-glycerol-3-phosphoglycerol (d-DPPG) leaflet, it was shown that the DPPG lipid bilayers deposited on the CaF(2) and PLLA surfaces have similar structures. SFG has also been applied to investigate molecular interactions between an antimicrobial peptide Cecropin P(1) (CP1) and the lipid bilayers on the above two different surfaces. Similar results were again obtained. This research demonstrated that the hydrophilic PLLA cushion can serve as an excellent substrate to support single lipid bilayers. We believe that it can be an important cell membrane model for future studies on transmembrane proteins, for which the possible inorganic substrate-bilayer interactions may affect the protein structure or function.     

Formation and stability of a suspended biomimetic lipid bilayer on silicon submicrometer-sized pores

We report the fabrication of a thin silicon membrane with an array of micrometer and submicrometer pores that acts as a scaffold for suspending a lipid bilayer. We successfully deposited a lipid bilayer by the Langmuir-Blodgett method on a synthetic silicon membrane bearing arrays of pores with sizes of 1000, 650, and 300 nm. Topographic images obtained by AFM showed a suspended lipid film spanning the pores, whatever the pore size. Higher stability of bilayers supported on smaller pores was shown by AFM characterization. These results represent an important first step to creating a biomimetic environment to study cell membrane dynamics and/or in developing a biosensor.     

Lipid bilayers on polyacrylamide brushes for inclusion of membrane proteins

The ability of neutral polymer cushions to support neutral lipid bilayers for the incorporation of mobile transmembrane proteins was investigated. Polyacrylamide brush layers were grown on fused silica using atom-transfer radical polymerization to provide polymer layers of 2.5-, 5- and 10-nm thickness. Lipid bilayers composed of POPC (1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) were formed by vesicle fusion onto bare fused silica and onto each of the polyacrylamide layers. Bilayer fluidity was assessed by the diffusion of a probe, NBD-labeled phosphatidylcholine, using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching. A transmembrane protein, the human delta-opioid receptor, was inserted into each lipid bilayer, and its ability to bind a synthetic ligand, DPDPE, cyclic[2-d-penicillamine, 5-d-penicillamine]enkephalin, was detected using single-molecule fluorescence spectroscopy by labeling this ligand with a rhodamine dye. The transmembrane protein was observed to bind the ligand for all bilayers tested. The protein's electrophoretic mobility was probed by monitoring the fluorescence from the bound ligand. The 5-nm polyacrylamide thickness gave the fastest diffusion for the fluorescent lipid probe (D(1) = 2.0(+/-1.2) x 10(-7) and D(2) = 1.2(+/-0.5) x 10(-6) cm(2)/s) and also the largest electrophoretic mobility for the transmembrane protein (3 x 10(-8) cm(2)/V.s). The optimum in polymer thickness is suggested to be a tradeoff between decoupling from the substrate and increasing roughness of the polymer surface.     

Role of nanomechanical properties in the tribological performance of phospholipid biomimetic surfaces

The role of phospholipid bilayers in controlling and reducing frictional forces between biological surfaces is investigated by three complementary experiments: friction forces are measured using a homemade tribometer, mechanical resistance to indentation is measured by AFM, and lipid bilayer degradation is controlled in situ during friction testing using fluorescence microscopy. DPPC lipid bilayers in the solid phase generate friction coefficients as low as 0.002 (comparable to that found for cartilage) that are stable through time. DOPC bilayers formed by the vesicle fusion method or the adsorption of mixed micelles generate higher friction coefficients. These coefficients increased through time, during which the bilayers degraded. The friction coefficient is correlated with the force needed to penetrate the bilayer with the AFM tip. With only one bilayer in the contact region, the friction increased to a similar value of about 0.08 for the DPPC and DOPC. Our study therefore shows that good mechanical stability of the bilayers is essential and suggests that the low friction coefficient is ensured by the hydration layers between adjacent lipid bilayers.     

Lipid bilayer deposition and patterning via air bubble collapse

We report a new method for forming patterned lipid bilayers on solid substrates. In bubble collapse deposition (BCD), an air bubble is first "inked" with a monolayer of phospholipid molecules and then touched to the surface of a thermally oxidized silicon wafer and the air is slowly withdrawn. As the bubble shrinks, the lipid monolayer pressure increases. Once the monolayer exceeds the collapse pressure, it folds back on itself, depositing a stable lipid bilayer on the surface. These bilayer disks have lateral diffusion coefficients consistent with high quality supported bilayers. By sequentially depositing bilayers in overlapping areas, fluid connections between bilayers of different compositions are formed. Performing vesicle rupture on the open substrate surrounding this bilayer patch results in a fluid but spatially isolated bilayer. Very little intermixing was observed between the vesicle rupture and bubble-deposited bilayers.     

Weakly coupled lipid bilayer membranes on multistimuli-responsive poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) copolymer cushions

Polymer-cushioned lipid bilayers are frequently used to mimic the native environment of cellular membranes in respect to the extracellular matrix and intracellular structures. With the aim to actively tune lipid membrane characteristics, we pursue the approach to use temperature and pH responsive polymer thin films of poly(N-isopropylacrylamide-co-carboxyacrylamide) (PNIPAAm-co-carboxyAAM) as cushions for supported lipid bilayers. A cationic lipid bilayer composed of dioleoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC) and dioleoyltrimethylammoniumpropane (DOTAP) (9:1) was formed on top of the polymer thin film in a drying/rehydration process. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) yielded higher lipid diffusion coefficients (6.3-9.6 μm(2) s(-1)) on polymer cushions in comparison to solid glass supports (3.0-5.9 μm(2) s(-1)). No correlation of the lipid mobility was found with the swelling state of (PNIPAAm-co-carboxyAAM), which is ascribed to restrained interfacial electrostatic interactions and dispersion forces. The results revealed a minimal coupling of the lipid bilayer with the polymer cushions, and thus, bilayers supported by (PNIPAAm-co-carboxyAAM) provide interesting opportunities for unperturbed lipid diffusion combined with control of transmembrane protein mobility due to the impact of a tunable frictional drag.     

Fusogenic tilted peptides induce nanoscale holes in supported phosphatidylcholine bilayers

Tilted peptides are known to insert in lipid bilayers with an oblique orientation, thereby destabilizing membranes and facilitating membrane fusion processes. Here, we report the first direct visualization of the interaction of tilted peptides with lipid membranes using in situ atomic force microscopy (AFM) imaging. Phase-separated supported dioleoylphosphatidylcholine/dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC/DPPC) bilayers were prepared by fusion of small unilamellar vesicles and imaged in buffer solution, in the absence and in the presence of the simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) peptide. The SIV peptide was shown to induce the rapid appearance of nanometer scale bilayer holes within the DPPC gel domains, while keeping the domain shape unaltered. We attribute this behavior to a local weakening and destabilization of the DPPC domains due to the oblique insertion of the peptide molecules. These results were directly correlated with the fusogenic activity of the peptide as determined using fluorescently labeled DOPC/DPPC liposomes. By contrast, the nontilted ApoE peptide did not promote liposome fusion and did not induce bilayer holes but caused slight erosion of the DPPC domains. In conclusion, this work provides the first direct evidence for the production of stable, well-defined nanoholes in lipid bilayer domains by the SIV peptide, a behavior that we have shown to be specifically related to the tilted character of the peptide. A molecular mechanism underlying spontaneous insertion of the SIV peptide within lipid bilayers and the subsequent removal of bilayer patches is proposed, and its relevance to membrane fusion processes is discussed.