Stochastic nanopore sensors for the detection of terrorist agents: Current status and challenges

Nanopore stochastic sensor works by monitoring the ionic current modulations induced by the passage of analytes of interest through a single pore, which can be obtained from a biological ion channel by self-assembly or artificially fabricated in a solid-state membrane. In this minireview, we overview the use of biological nanopores and artificial nanopores for the detection of terrorist agents including explosives, organophosphorus nerve agents, nitrogen mustards, organoarsenic compounds, toxins, and viruses. We also discuss the current challenge in the development of deployable nanopore sensors for real-world applications.     

A simple and rapid approach for measurement of dissociation constants of DNA aptamers against proteins and small molecules via automated microchip electrophoresis

Automated microchip electrophoresis was used as a simple and rapid method to measure effective dissociation constants (K(d,eff)) of aptamers against both large and small molecule targets. Human thrombin, immunoglobulin E (IgE), and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) were selected as model analytes to validate the method, with four ligands including two DNA aptamers for thrombin (two distinct epitopes), an IgE aptamer, and an ATP aptamer. The approach is based on a microchip version of a DNA mobility shift assay. Non-denaturing microchip gel electrophoresis separations of DNA could resolve and quantify unbound from target-bound aptamers when using large molecules as targets. To extend the technique to small molecule targets such as ATP, an aptamer/competitor strategy was used, in which a DNA competitor complementary to the aptamer could be displaced by ATP and electrophoretically resolved. Using an automated microchip electrophoresis platform, parallel separations of 11 titration samples were completed in ~0.5 h. Analytical performance comparisons show that our approach provides significant advantages in minimized reagent consumption (typically tens of pmol of aptamer and target), reduced analysis time, and minimized user interaction when compared to previously reported methods for aptamer K(d) measurement. Moreover, the flexibility and ease of K(d,eff) measurement for aptamers against large and small targets make this a unique and valuable approach that should find widespread use. Finally, the feasibility of using this method during aptamer selection processes (e.g. SELEX) was shown by accurate bulk K(d,eff) measurement of a known thrombin aptamer (THRaptA) spiked into a random-sequence DNA pool at as low as 5.0% (molar %) of the total pool; only ~825 fmol of total binding sequences were needed for an 11-point titration curve.     

A Universal Strategy for Aptamer‐Based Nanopore Sensing through Host–Guest Interactions inside α‐Hemolysin

Nanopore emerged as a powerful single‐molecule technique over the past two decades, and has shown applications in the stochastic sensing and biophysical studies of individual molecules. Here, we report a versatile strategy for nanopore sensing by employing the combination of aptamers and host–guest interactions. An aptamer is first hybridized with a DNA probe which is modified with a ferrocene?cucurbit[7]uril complex. The presence of analytes causes the aptamer–probe duplex to unwind and release the DNA probe which can quantitatively produce signature current events when translocated through an α‐hemolysin nanopore. The integrated use of magnetic beads can further lower the detection limit by approximately two to three orders of magnitude. Because aptamers have shown robust binding affinities with a wide variety of target molecules, our proposed strategy should be universally applicable for sensing different types of analytes with nanopore sensors.     

Label-free monitoring of the thrombin–aptamer recognition reaction using an array of nanochannels coupled with electrochemical detection

A sensitive and label-free method of monitoring the thrombin–aptamer recognition reaction has been developed using an array of nanochannels coupled with an electrochemical detection technique. Due to the highly amplified ion current produced by an array of nanochannels compared to a single nanochannel/pore, a significant increase in detection sensitivity has been achieved.     

Protein nanopores with covalently attached molecular adapters

Molecular adapters are crucial for the stochastic sensing of organic analytes with alpha-hemolysin (alphaHL) protein nanopores when direct interactions between analytes and the pore cannot readily be arranged by conventional protein engineering. In our earlier studies, cyclodextrin adapters were lodged noncovalently within the lumen of the alphaHL pore. In the present work, we have realized the controlled covalent attachment of a beta-cyclodextrin (betaCD) adapter in the two possible molecular orientations inside alphaHL pores prepared by genetic engineering. There are two advantages to such a covalent system. First, the adapter cannot dissociate, which means there are no gaps during stochastic detection, a crucial advance for single-molecule exonuclease DNA sequencing where the continuous presence of a molecular adapter will be essential for reading individual nucleotides. Second, the ability to orient the adapter allows analytes to bind through only one of the two entrances to the betaCD cavity. We demonstrate that the covalently attached adapters can be used to alter the ion selectivity of the alphaHL pore, examine binding events at elevated temperatures, and detect analytes with prolonged dwell times.     

Detection of thrombin using an excimer aptamer switch labeled with dual pyrene molecules

We constructed an excimer aptamer probe containing one pyrene molecule at each end of a DNA aptamer to achieve the detection of thrombin, which binds to the heparin-binding site of thrombin with high binding affinity. The specific binding of thrombin to the excimer aptamer probe brought the two pyrene molecules at the termini of the duplex of the aptamer into close proximity, generating an excimer. The excimer emitted a distinct fluorescence peak, and fluorometric measurement of excimer allowed the sensitive detection of thrombin. The effects of experimental conditions like pH, ionic strength, and cations were investigated and optimized. The detection limit for thrombin was about 42 pM. This aptamer switch has potential in the study of molecular interactions and protein sensing with other switch-based detection strategy.

Energy Landscape of Aptamer/Protein Complexes Studied by Single‐Molecule Force Spectroscopy

Aptamers are single‐stranded nucleic acid molecules selected in vitro to bind to a variety of target molecules. Aptamers bound to proteins are emerging as a new class of molecules that rival commonly used antibodies in both therapeutic and diagnostic applications. With the increasing application of aptamers as molecular probes for protein recognition, it is important to understand the molecular mechanism of aptamer–protein interaction. Recently, we developed a method of using atomic force microscopy (AFM) to study the single‐molecule rupture force of aptamer/protein complexes. In this work, we investigate further the unbinding dynamics of aptamer/protein complexes and their dissociation‐energy landscape by AFM. The dependence of single‐molecule force on the AFM loading rate was plotted for three aptamer/protein complexes and their dissociation rate constants, and other parameters characterizing their dissociation pathways were obtained. Furthermore, the single‐molecule force spectra of three aptamer/protein complexes were compared to those of the corresponding antibody/protein complexes in the same loading‐rate range. The results revealed two activation barriers and one intermediate state in the unbinding process of aptamer/protein complexes, which is different from the energy landscape of antibody/protein complexes. The results provide new information for the study of aptamer–protein interaction at the molecular level.     

Simulations of stochastic sensing of proteins

We have performed Langevin dynamics and Poisson-Nernst-Planck calculations to simulate detection of proteins by genetically engineered alpha-hemolysin channels. In the recent stochastic sensing experiments, one end of a flexible polymer chain is permanently anchored inside the protein channel at a specified location, and the other end undergoes complexation with an analyte. Our simulations, using coarse-grained modeling, reproduce all essential qualitative results of the electrophysiology measurements of stochastic sensing. In addition, the underlying macromolecular mechanisms behind stochastic sensing are revealed in vivid details. The entropic fluctuations of the conformations of the tethered polymer chain dictate crucially the unique signatures of the ionic current trace of the channel and provide design rules for successful stochastic sensing. The origin of strong fluctuations in the ionic current of the channel is found to arise from the obstruction of the entrance at the beta-barrel of the channel by the fluctuating segments of the tether. Silencing of the pore is due to the suppression of conformational fluctuations of the chain, and the permanent blockade of ionic current is due to the threading of the tether through the channel. The onset of silencing and permanent blockade of the channel current cannot necessarily be attributed to the capture of analytes. In order for detection events to be timed accurately, the length and anchoring location of the tether must be tuned appropriately.     

Characterization of the surface charge property and porosity of track-etched polymer membranes

As an important property of porous membranes, the surface charge property determines many ionic behaviors of nanopores, such as ionic conductance and selectivity. Based on the dependence of electric double layers on bulk concentrations, ionic conductance through nanopores at high and low concentrations is governed by the bulk conductance and surface charge density, respectively. Here, through the investigation of ionic conductance inside track-etched single polyethylene terephthalate (PET) nanopores under various concentrations, the surface charge density of PET membranes is extracted as ∼−0.021 C/m² at pH 10 over measurements with 40 PET nanopores. Simulations show that surface roughness can cause underestimation in surface charge density due to the inhibited electroosmotic flow. Then, the averaged pore size and porosity of track-etched multipore PET membranes are characterized by the developed ionic conductance method. Through coupled theoretical predictions in ionic conductance under high and low concentrations, the averaged pore size and porosity of porous membranes can be obtained simultaneously. Our method provides a simple and precise way to characterize the pore size and porosity of multipore membranes, especially for those with sub-100 nm pores and low porosities.     

Investigation of the interaction between a bivalent aptamer and thrombin by AFM

Aptamers are a new class of molecular probes for protein recognition, detection, and inhibition. Multivalent aptamer-protein binding through aptamer assembly has been currently developed as an effective way to achieve higher protein affinity and selectivity. In this study, the specific interaction between bivalent aptamer Bi-8S and thrombin has been measured directly and quantitatively by atomic force microscopy to investigate the unbinding dynamics and dissociation energy landscape of the multivalent interaction. Bivalent aptamer Bi-8S contains thrombin's two aptamers, 15apt and 27apt, which are linked by eight spacer phosphoramidites. The results revealed the sequential dissociation of the two aptamers. Moreover, the dynamic force spectroscopy data revealed that the 27apt's binding to the thrombin remains largely unaffected by the eight-spacer phosphoramidites within Bi-8S. In contrast, the eight-spacer phosphoramidites stabilized the 15apt-thrombin binding.     

基于主客体竞争模式的凝血酶适配体传感器的研究

基于β-环糊精(β-CD)主客体竞争模式,构建了开关型凝血酶适配体电化学传感器.将末端修饰了二茂铁(Fc)的核酸适配体通过与β-CD的主客体识别固定在金电极表面,当凝血酶存在时,适配体由原来的直立线状构型变为"G-四链体",远离电极表面,适配体探针的氧化还原电流强度减小,即"Signal-off".利用此效应对凝血酶进行了灵敏检测,结果表明,在5.0×10-13~5.0×10-9 mol/L浓度范围内,凝血酶的浓度与电化学响应信号呈良好的线性关系,检出限为2.0×10-13 mol/L(3σ).与其它蛋白分子相比,本方法对凝血酶蛋白的检测具有高特异性.本传感器构建简单,再生性好,为生物血清样本中凝血酶的实时高效检测提供了方法.     

An aptamer-based assay for thrombin via structure switch based on gold nanoparticles and magnetic nanoparticles

An aptamer-based assay for thrombin with high specificity and sensitivity was presented. In the protocol, the aptamer for thrombin was immobilized on magnetic nanoparticle, and its complementary oligonucleotide was labeled with gold nanoparticles, then the aptamer was hybridized with the complementary oligonucleotide to form the duplex structure as a probe, this probe could be used for the specific recognition for thrombin. In the presence of thrombin, the aptamer prefer to form the G-quarter structure with thrombin, resulting in the dissociation of the duplex of the probe and the release of the gold labeled oligonucleotide. Upon this, we were able to detect thrombin through the detection of the electrochemical signal of gold nanoparticles. The strategy combines with the high specificity of aptamer and the excellent characteristics of nanoparticles. This assay is simple, rapid, sensitive and highly specific, it does not require labeling of thrombin, and it could be applied to detect thrombin in complex real sample. The method shows great potential in other protein analysis and in disease diagnosis.     

Fluorescence detection of DNA by the catalytic activation of an aptamer/thrombin complex

A conjugate consisting of a thrombin aptamer tethered to the thrombin, Th, with a sensing nucleic acid (1) is used for the optical detection of DNA. The thrombin/aptamer complex blocks the biocatalytic functions of Th. Hybridization of the analyte DNA (2) to the sensing nucleic acid 1 yields a rigid duplex that detaches the aptamer from Th, a process that activates the protein toward the hydrolysis of bis(p-tosyl-Gly-Pro-Arg)-R110 (3) to the rhodamine 110 fluorophore (4). The system allows the DNA sensing with a sensitivity limit of 1 x 10-8 M. The aptamer/Th conjugate is also immobilized on glass slides for the optical detection of DNA. The dissociation of the aptamer/Th complex upon hybridization and the subsequent dehybridization of the duplex and the regeneration of the catalytically inactive Th/aptamer complex duplicate machinery functions.     

单分子荧光成像研究凝血酶核酸适体的折叠

通过对固定在表面的TMR标记凝血酶核酸适体进行单分子荧光成像, 在单分子水平上研究了凝血酶核酸适体的折叠. 在有K+存在的条件下, 核酸适体分子与K+结合后发生折叠, 形成G四分体结构, 使得TMR靠近富含鸟嘌呤的G四分体, 并与鸟嘌呤发生电子转移, 从而导致TMR荧光强度降低. 根据TMR的单分子荧光强度观察到不同K+浓度下核酸适体在折叠和无规卷曲两种状态下的分布. 结果表明, 可利用电子转移引起的荧光强度变化在单分子水平上研究核酸适体构象变化, 这一新方法的建立是对常用的单分子荧光共振能量转移(FRET)法的重要补充.     

Nanoscale protein pores modified with PAMAM dendrimers

We describe nanoscale protein pores modified with a single hyperbranched dendrimer molecule inside the channel lumen. Sulfhydryl-reactive polyamido amine (PAMAM) dendrimers of generations 2, 3 and 5 were synthesized, chemically characterized, and reacted with engineered cysteine residues in the transmembrane pore alpha-hemolysin. Successful coupling was monitored using an electrophoretic mobility shift assay. The results indicate that G2 and G3 but not G5 dendrimers permeated through the 2.9 nm cis entrance to couple inside the pore. The defined molecular weight cutoff for the passage of hyperbranched PAMAM polymers is in contrast to the less restricted accessibility of flexible linear poly(ethylene glycol) polymers of comparable hydrodynamic volume. Their higher compactness makes sulfhydryl-reactive PAMAM dendrimers promising research reagents to probe the structure of porous membrane proteins with wide internal diameters. The conductance properties of PAMAM-modified proteins pores were characterized with single-channel current recordings. A G3 dendrimer molecule in the channel lumen reduced the ionic current by 45%, indicating that the hyperbranched and positively charged polymer blocked the passage of ions through the pore. In line with expectations, a smaller and less dense G2 dendrimer led to a less pronounced current reduction of 25%. Comparisons to recordings of PEG-modified pores revealed striking dissimilarities, suggesting that differences in the structural dynamics of flexible linear polymers vs compact dendrimers can be observed at the single-molecule level. Current recordings also revealed that dendrimers functioned as ion-selectivity filters and molecular sieves for the controlled passage of molecules. The alteration of pore properties with charged and hyperbranched dendrimers is a new approach and might be extended to inorganic nanopores with applications in sensing and separation technology.     

Molecularly imprinted aptamers of gold nanoparticles for the enzymatic inhibition and detection of thrombin

We prepared thrombin-binding aptamer-conjugated gold nanoparticles (TBA-Au NPs) through a molecularly imprinted (MP) approach, which provide highly efficient inhibition activity toward the polymerization of fibrinogen. Au NPs (diameter, 13 nm), 15-mer thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA(15)) with different thymidine linkers, and 29-mer thrombin-binding aptamer (TBA(29)) with different thymidine linkers (Tn) in the presence of thrombin (Thr) as a template were used to prepare MP-Thr-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-Tn-Au NPs. Thrombin molecules were then removed from Au NPs surfaces by treating with 100 mM Tris-NaOH (pH ca. 13.0) to form MP-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-Tn-Au NPs. The length of the thymidine linkers and TBA density on Au NPs surfaces have strong impact on the orientation, flexibility, and stability of MP-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-Tn-Au NPs, leading to their stronger binding strength with thrombin. MP-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-T(15)-Au NPs (ca. 42 TBA(15) and 42 TBA(29) molecules per Au NP; 15-mer thymidine on aptamer terminal) provided the highest binding affinity toward thrombin with a dissociation constant of 5.2 × 10(-11) M. As a result, they had 8 times higher anticoagulant (inhibitory) potency relative to TBA(15)/TBA(29)-T(15)-Au NPs (prepared in the absence of thrombin). We further conducted thrombin clotting time (TCT) measurements in plasma samples and found that MP-TBA(15)/TBA(29)-T(15)-Au NPs had greater anticoagulation activity relative to four commercial drugs (heparin, argatroban, hirudin, and warfarin). In addition, we demonstrated that thrombin induced the formation of aggregates from MP-TBA(15)-T(15)-Au NPs and MP-TBA(29)-T(15)-Au NPs, thereby allowing the colorimetric detection of thrombin at the nanomolar level in serum samples. Our result demonstrates that our simple molecularly imprinted approach can be applied for preparing various functional nanomaterials to control enzyme activity and targeting important proteins.     

用于纳米孔道分析的四通道电化学传感器设计与仿真

纳米孔道技术是一种基于空间限域的超灵敏的单分子分析技术.通过研究单个分子限域于纳米孔道中所产生的离子电流的变化,可在单分子尺度上获取其结构、尺寸、电性及与孔道间弱相互作用的信息.目前主要应用的纳米孔道测量仪器单次实验仅能测量单个纳米孔道,其检测通量较低.本文基于实验室前期自主设计研制的单通道纳米孔道测量仪器Cube-D2上,比较研究了两种互阻放大器的测量特性,从而选择了合适的测量电路设计了四通道电化学传感器放大电路.进一步通过仿真验证了四通道电化学传感器设计方案的可行性,为阵列化高通量纳米孔道单分子电化学测量仪器的设计提供了理论基础.     

采用超低场生物力谱技术研究核酸适配体与凝血酶蛋白的相互作用

蛋白质和核酸是构成生命体最为重要的两类生物大分子,它们之间的相互作用是分子生物学研究的中心问题之一,也是许多生命活动的重要组成部分。本文基于一种全新的超低场生物力谱技术,以凝血酶蛋白为研究对象,考察了凝血酶与其对应的核酸适配体之间的相互作用。结果表明,凝血酶蛋白与核酸适配体之间的结合力大小约为80 p N。同时,在分子水平上获得了凝血酶蛋白与核酸适配体之间的解离动力学信息。     

Single-Round DNA Aptamer Selection by Combined Use of Capillary Electrophoresis and Next Generation Sequencing: An Aptaomics Approach for Identifying Unique Functional Protein-Binding DNA Aptamers

In DNA aptamer selection, existing methods do not discriminate aptamer sequences based on their binding affinity and function and the reproducibility of the selection is often poor, even for the selection of well-known aptamers like those that bind the commonly used model protein thrombin. In the present study, a novel single-round selection method (SR-CE selection) was developed by combining capillary electrophoresis (CE) with next generation sequencing. Using SR-CE selection, a successful semi-quantitative and semi-comprehensive aptamer selection for thrombin was demonstrated with high reproducibility for the first time. Selection rules based on dissociation equilibria and kinetics were devised to obtain families of analogous sequences. Selected sequences of the same family were shown to bind thrombin with high affinity. Furthermore, data acquired from SR-CE selection was mined by creating sub-libraries that were categorized by the functionality of the aptamers (e. g., pre-organized aptamers versus structure-induced aptamers). Using this approach, a novel fluorescent molecular recognition sensor for thrombin with nanomolar detection limits was discovered. Thus, in this proof-of-concept report, we have demonstrated the potential of a “DNA Aptaomics” approach to systematically design functional aptamers as well as to obtain high affinity aptamers.     

High-sensitive determination of human alpha-thrombin by its 29-mer aptamer in affinity probe capillary electrophoresis

ACE technique provides an effective tool for the separation and identification of disease-related biomarkers in clinical analysis. In recent years, a couple of synthetic DNA or RNA oligonucleotides, known as aptamers, rival the specificity and affinity for targets to antibodies and are employed as one kind of powerful affinity probe in ACE. In this work, based on high affinity between antithrombin aptamer and thrombin (their dissociation constant is 0.5 nM), a carboxyfluorescein-labeled 29-nucleotide (nt) aptamer (F29-mer) was used and an aptamer-based affinity probe CE (aptamer-based APCE) method was successfully established for high-sensitive detection and quantitative analysis of thrombin. Experimental conditions including incubation temperature and time, buffer composition, and concentration of cations were investigated and optimized. Under the optimized condition, the linear range was from 0 to 400 nM and the LOD was 2 nM (74 ng/mL, S/N = 3), i.e., 40 amol, both in running buffer and in 5% v/v human serum. This LOD is the lowest one than those achieved by the previous APCE methods but based on a 15-mer aptamer. This approach offers a promising method for the rapid, selective, and sensitive detection of thrombin in practical utility. Further binding experiments using one carboxyfluorescein-labeled aptamer and the other nonlabeled aptamer or vice versa were carried out to deduce the formation of ternary complex when these two aptamers coexisted in the free solution with thrombin.