Cognitive styles,task presentation mode and mathematical performance

This paper reports the outcomes of an empirical study undertaken to investigate the relationship of prospective teachers’ cognitive styles and levels of performance in measurement and spatial tasks. A total of 116 prospective kindergarten school teachers were tested using the VICS and the extended CSA-WA tests (Peterson 2005) in order to place them along the Verbal/Imagery and the Wholistic/Analytic cognitive style continua. The same prospective teachers were also administered a mathematical test with 6 measurement and 6 spatial tasks. The results suggest that there were no significant differences between Verbalisers-Imagers and Wholistic-Analytic prospective teachers in their performance on the spatial pictorial and textual tasks, and on the measurement textual tasks. However, there were differences between Verbalisers-Imagers and Wholistic-Analytic prospective teachers in their performance on the measurement pictorial tasks. This difference was attributed to the performance of low achievers. High achievers performed in the same way independently of their cognitive styles.     

Recognising mathematical creativity in schoolchildren

Examples of tasks designed to recognise creative thinking within mathematics, used with 11–12-year-old pupuls, are described. The first construct empoyed in the design of these tasks is the ability to overcome fixation. Sometimes pupils demonstrate content-universe fixation, by restricting their thinking about a problem to an insufficient or inappropriate range of elements. Other times they show algorithmic fixation by continuing to adhere to a routine procedure or stereotype response even when this becomes inefficient or inappropriate. The second construct employed is that of divergent production, indicated by flexibility and originality in mathematical tasks to which a large number of appropriate responses are possible. Examples of three categories of such tasks are described: (1) problem-solving, (2) problem-posing, and (3) redefinition. Examples of pupils’ responses to various tasks are used to argue that they do indeed reveal thinking that can justifiably be described as creative. The relationship to conventional mathematics attainment is discussed-mathematics attainment is seen to limit but not to determine mathematical creativity.     

Problem modification as a tool for detecting cognitive flexibility in school children

This paper presents the results of an experiment in which fourth to sixth graders with above-average mathematical abilities modified a given problem. The experiment found evidence of links between problem posing and cognitive flexibility. Emerging from organizational theory, cognitive flexibility is conceptualized through three primary constructs: cognitive variety, cognitive novelty, and changes in cognitive framing. Among these components, changes in cognitive framing could be effectively detected in problem-posing situations, giving a relevant indication of students’ creative potential. The students’ capacity to generate coherent and consistent problems in the context of problem modification may indicate the existence of a strategy of functional type for generalizations, which seems to be specific to mathematical creativity.     

Connecting mathematical creativity to mathematical ability

This study aims to investigate whether there is a relationship between mathematical ability and mathematical creativity, and to examine the structure of this relationship. Furthermore, in order to validate the relationship between the two constructs, we will trace groups of students that differ across mathematical ability and investigate the relationships amongst these students’ performance on a mathematical ability test and the components of mathematical creativity. Data were collected by administering two tests, a mathematical ability and a mathematical creativity test, to 359 elementary school students. Mathematical ability was considered as a multidimensional construct, including quantitative ability (number sense and pre-algebraic reasoning), causal ability (examination of cause–effect relations), spatial ability (paper folding, perspective and spatial rotation abilities), qualitative ability (processing of similarity and difference relations) and inductive/deductive ability. Mathematical creativity was defined as a domain-specific characteristic, enabling individuals to be characterized by fluency, flexibility and originality in the domain of mathematics. The data analysis revealed that there is a positive correlation between mathematical creativity and mathematical ability. Moreover, confirmatory factor analysis suggested that mathematical creativity is a subcomponent of mathematical ability. Further, latent class analysis showed that three different categories of students can be identified varying in mathematical ability. These groups of students varying in mathematical ability also reflected three categories of students varying in mathematical creativity.     

Relationships between students’ learning and their participation during enactment of middle school algebra tasks

This study examines a sequence of four middle school algebra tasks through their enactment in three teachers’ classrooms. The analysis centers on the cognitive demand—the kinds of thinking processes entailed in solving the task—and the participatory demand—the kinds of verbal contributions expected of students—of the task as written in the instructional materials, as set up by the three teachers, and as discussed by the teachers and their students. Relationships between the nature of the task enactments and students’ performance on a pre- and post-test are explored. Findings include the fact that the enacted tasks differed from the written tasks with regard to both the cognitive demand and the participatory demand, which related to students’ lack of success on the post-test. Specifically, cognitive demand declined in the enacted curriculum at different points for different classes, and the participatory demand during enactment tended to involve isolated mathematical terms rather than students verbally expressing mathematical relations.     

On the role of creative thinking in problem posing

This paper addresses the relationship between creative thinking and problem posing as well as problem posing tasks in mathematics domains. Empirical studies were conducted to investigate on relationships and on tasks. Results of a study on arithmetic problem posing and its replication suggested that fluency is general in verbal creativity and problem posing, but flexibility is specific in problem posing. Further investigations into general mathematical problem posing were also carried out, having each of ninety-six elementary school children of Taiwan completing 18 problem posing test items in the Test on General Problem Posing. Results suggested that a general, rather than specific, problem posing competence exists in children and can be measured by the test.     

Mathematical cognition: individual differences in resource allocation

Individuals scoring higher in tests of general cognitive abilities tend to perform better on novel and familiar mathematical tasks. It has been scarcely investigated how this superior mathematical performance relates to the amount of cognitive resources that is invested to solve a given task. In this study we propose that, on novel tasks, individuals with high cognitive abilities outperform less able individuals, because they allocate a higher amount of resources. On familiar tasks, however, individuals with higher abilities profit from more efficient processes compared to individuals of lower cognitive abilities. We tested this hypothesis by administering to 11th graders a geometric analogy task not practiced at school and an algebraic transformation task comprising operations that are routinely required during mathematical courses. General cognitive abilities were measured with Ravens Advanced Progressive matrices (fluid intelligence), the d2 (focused attention) and KAI-N (working memory capacity). Resource allocation was measured by assessing pupil diameter during the problem-solving process. Performance on both the analogy and the algebra task was correlated with general cognitive abilities, especially fluid intelligence. In line with our assumptions, a positive correlation between fluid intelligence and resource allocation was observed in the novel geometric analogy task, whereas the correlation was not significant in the more familiar algebra task.     

The role of multiple solution tasks in developing knowledge and creativity in geometry

This paper describes changes in students’ geometrical knowledge and their creativity associated with implementation of Multiple Solution Tasks (MSTs) in school geometry courses. Three hundred and three students from 14 geometry classes participated in the study, of whom 229 students from 11 classes learned in an experimental environment that employed MSTs while the rest learned without any special intervention in the course of one school year. This longitudinal study compares the development of knowledge and creativity between the experimental and control groups as reflected in students’ written tests. Geometry knowledge was measured by the correctness and connectedness of the solutions presented. The criteria for creativity were: fluency, flexibility, and originality. The findings show that students’ connectedness as well as their fluency and flexibility benefited from implementation of MSTs. The study supports the idea that originality is a more internal characteristic than fluency and flexibility, and therefore more related with creativity and less dynamic. Nevertheless, the MSTs approach provides greater opportunity for potentially creative students to present their creative products than conventional learning environment. Cluster analysis of the experimental group identified three clusters that correspond to three levels of student performance, according to the five measured criteria in pre- and post-tests, and showed that, with the exception of originality, performance in all three clusters generally improved on the various criteria.     

基于因子分析的元认知外语教学策略研究

从心理学、第二语言习得理论出发,研究了场独立与场依存认知风格的外语学习者特点,应用因子分析数学模型,进行了培养元认知策略意识及发展双重认知风格等教学策略的教学实验,仿真实验表明了该方法的实用性和有效性.     

Exploring new directions for research in problem structuring methods: on the role of cognitive style

Prior research has argued that cognitive style can have a significant impact on group decision making. In addition, several scholars have proposed that cognitive style can play a key role in the design and use of group decision support systems. However, cognitive style has not received a great deal of attention in the problem structuring methods (PSMs) community. This is surprising, given that PSMs are specifically developed to support a group in their decision making. The purpose of this paper is thus to examine the significance of cognitive style within PSMs. The paper identifies and explores the role of four different cognitive style functions in problem structuring interventions. This analysis is carried out by focusing on the different tasks embedded within a group process supported by PSMs. Implications for the research and practice of PSMs are then discussed.     

Transformations in the Visual Representation of a Figural Pattern

Multiple representations of a given mathematical object/concept are one of the biggest difficulties encountered by students. The aim of this study is to investigate the impact of the use of visual representations in teaching and learning algebra. In this paper, we analyze the transformations from and to visual representations that were performed by 18 students (aged between 10 and 13) in a task designed to explore a figural pattern. The data were collected from an audio recording of the class, the students’ work, and the teacher’s notes about each lesson. The results confirm that visual representations are important. However, visual treatments of any kind of representation are decisive, since they give students other possibilities for seeing and understanding tasks, continuity and flexibility in their activities, and the ability to make conversions between representations. The creative realization of visual treatments is necessary, and the teacher has a significant role in helping students to learn how to do this.     

系统讲授数学内容,激发大学生创新思维

针对大众化教育背景下的地方院校学生,以某个知识点为核心系统讲授数学内容,这是激发学生创新思维的重要途径。教学时以书本知识为载体,从显性知识、隐性内容及认知方式三个方面进行系统的讲授,旨在达到促进学生掌握数学工具和增进理性思维的同时,还能实现以创新教学激发创新思维的目的。     

Spatial visualization and measurement of area: A case study in spatialized mathematics instruction

The purpose of this study was to explore the influence of spatial visualization skills when students solve area tasks. Spatial visualization is closely related to mathematics achievement, but little is known about how these skills link to task success. We examined middle school students’ representations and solutions to area problems (both non-metric and metric) through qualitative and quantitative task analysis. Task solutions were analyzed as a function of spatial visualization skills and links were made between student solutions on tasks with different goals (i.e., non-metric and metric). Findings suggest that strong spatial visualizers solved the tasks with relative ease, with evidence for conceptual and procedural understanding. By contrast, Low and Average Spatial students more frequently produced errors due to failure to correctly determine linear measurements or apply appropriate formula, despite adequate procedural knowledge. A novel finding was the facilitating role of spatial skills in the link between metric task representation and success in determining a solution. From a teaching and learning perspective, these results highlight the need to connect emergent spatial skills with mathematical content and support students to develop conceptual understanding in parallel with procedural competence.     

Fostering creativity through instruction rich in mathematical problem solving and problem posing

Although creativity is often viewed as being associated with the notions of “genius” or exceptional ability, it can be productive for mathematics educators to view creativity instead as an orientation or disposition toward mathematical activity that can be fostered broadly in the general school population. In this article, it is argued that inquiry-oriented mathematics instruction which includes problem-solving and problem-posing tasks and activities can assist students to develop more creative approaches to mathematics. Through the use of such tasks and activities, teachers can increase their students’ capacity with respect to the core dimensions of creativity, namely, fluency, flexibility, and novelty. Because the instructional techniques discussed in this article have been used successfully with students all over the world, there is little reason to believe that creativity-enriched mathematics instruction cannot be used with a broad range of students in order to increase their representational and strategic fluency and flexibility, and their appreciation for novel problems, solution methods, or solutions.     

A fuzzy approach for selecting project membership to achieve cognitive style goals

Decision makers select employees for a project to match a particular set of goals pertaining to the multiple criteria mix of skills and competencies needed. Cognitive style influences how a person gathers and evaluates information and consequently, provides skills and competencies toward problem solving. The proposed fuzzy set-based model facilitates the manager’s selection of employees who meet the project goal(s) for the preferred cognitive style. The paper presents background information on cognitive styles and fuzzy logic with an algorithm developed based on belief in the fuzzy probability of a cognitive style fitting a defined goal. An application is presented with analysis and conclusions stated.     

Prospective elementary teachers’ claiming in responses to false generalizations

When faced with a false generalization and a counterexample, what types of claims do prospective K-8 teachers make, and what factors influence the type and prudence of their claims relative to the data, observations, and arguments reported? This article addresses that question. Responses to refutation tasks and cognitive interviews were used to explore claiming. It was found that prospective K-8 teachers’ claiming can be influenced by knowledge of argumentation; knowledge and use of the mathematical practice of exception barring; perceptions of the task; use of natural language; knowledge of, use of, and skill with the mathematics register; and abilities to technically handle data or conceptual insights. A distinction between technical handlings for developing claims and technical handlings for supporting claims was made. It was found that prudent claims can arise from arguer-developed representations that afford conceptual insights, even when searching for support for a different claim.     

Long-term characteristics of analogical processing in high-school students with high fluid intelligence: an fMRI study

Intelligence is known to predict scholastic achievement and enables high performance in cognitive tasks. Fluid intelligence is strongly related to analogical reasoning abilities, which are fundamental to mathematical thinking. Geometric analogical reasoning is a prototypical measure of fluid intelligence. However, the cerebral correlates of geometric analogical reasoning and their developmental modulation over time are still rarely investigated. We report a 1-year follow-up functional magnetic resonance imaging study of a geometric analogical reasoning task in high fluid intelligence high-school students. This study was designed to characterise the cerebral correlates of geometric analogical reasoning and to improve our knowledge about the impact of general cognitive development on behavioural performance and on cerebral mechanisms underlying geometric analogical reasoning in adolescents. Our data indicate that a fronto-parietal network comprising the left and right parietal lobes and the left middle frontal gyrus was equally modulated by task difficulty at both measuring time points. At the behavioural level, however, participants showed improvements in performance at the second measuring time point. The behavioural improvements point to a more efficient task processing. As this is not accompanied by differential recruitment of fronto-parietal brain regions, the data suggest an increase in neural efficiency for these brain regions.     

Characterizing Interaction with Visual Mathematical Representations

This paper presents a characterization of computer-based interactions by which learners can explore and investigate visual mathematical representations (VMRs). VMRs (e.g., geometric structures, graphs, and diagrams) refer to graphical representations that visually encode properties and relationships of mathematical structures and concepts. Currently, most mathematical tools provide methods by which a learner can interact with these representations. Interaction, in such cases, mediates between the VMR and the thinking, reasoning, and intentions of the learner, and is often intended to support the cognitive tasks that the learner may want to perform on or with the representation. This paper brings together a diverse set of interaction techniques and categorizes and describes them according to their common characteristics, goals, intended benefits, and features. In this way, this paper aims to provide a preliminary framework to help designers of mathematical cognitive tools in their selection and analysis of different interaction techniques as well as to foster the design of more innovative interactive mathematical tools. An effort is made to demonstrate how the different interaction techniques developed in the context of other disciplines (e.g., information visualization) can support a diverse set of mathematical tasks and activities involving VMRs.