Unexpected Antioxidant Efficiency of Chlorogenic Acid Phenolipids in Fish Oil-in-Water Nanoemulsions: An Example of How Relatively Low Interfacial Concentrations Can Make Antioxidants to Be Inefficient

Selecting effective antioxidants is challenging since their efficiency in inhibiting lipid oxidation depends on the rate constants of the chemical reactions involved and their concentration at the reaction site, i.e., at the interfacial region. Accumulation of antioxidants at the interface of emulsions is key to modulate their efficiency in inhibiting lipid oxidation but its control was not well understood, especially in emulsions. It can be optimized by modifying the physicochemical properties of antioxidants or the environmental conditions. In this work, we analyze the effects of surfactant concentration, droplet size, and oil to water ratio on the effective interfacial concentration of a set of chlorogenic acid (CGA) esters in fish oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions and nanoemulsions and on their antioxidant efficiency. A well-established pseudophase kinetic model is used to determine in the intact emulsified systems the effective concentrations of the antioxidants (AOs). The relative oxidative stability of the emulsions is assessed by monitoring the formation of primary oxidation products with time. Results show that the concentration of all AOs at the interfacial region is much higher (20–90 fold) than the stoichiometric one but is much lower than those of other phenolipid series such as caffeic or hydroxytyrosol derivatives. The main parameter controlling the interfacial concentration of antioxidants is the surfactant volume fraction, Φ_I, followed by the O/W ratio. Changes in the droplet sizes (emulsions and nanoemulsions) have no influence on the interfacial concentrations. Despite the high radical scavenging capacity of CGA derivatives and their being concentrated at the interfacial region, the investigated AOs do not show a significant effect in inhibiting lipid oxidation in contrast with what is observed using other series of homologous antioxidants with similar reactivity. Results are tentatively interpreted in terms of the relatively low interfacial concentrations of the antioxidants, which may not be high enough to make the rate of the inhibition reaction faster than the rate of radical propagation.     

A Physicochemical Study of the Effects of Acidity on the Distribution and Antioxidant Efficiency of Trolox in Olive Oil‐in‐Water Emulsions

The efficiency of antioxidants to inhibit the oxidation of lipid‐based emulsions depends on several factors including their nature and their concentration at the reaction site. Here, we have analyzed the effects of acidity and of surfactant concentration on the distribution and efficiency of the vitamin E analog Trolox (TR) in stripped olive oil‐in‐water emulsions stabilized with Tween 20. The distribution was assessed in the intact emulsions by employing a kinetic method that exploits the reaction between the hydrophobic 4‐hexadecylbenzenediazonium ions and TR. Kinetic results are interpreted on the grounds of the pseudophase model. The effects of TR on the oxidative stability of the emulsion were determined at different pH values by monitoring the formation of conjugated dienes over time. The results show that the efficiency of TR increases upon increasing pH even though its concentration in the interfacial region decreases.     

Investigation into the potential ability of Pickering emulsions (food-grade particles) to enhance the oxidative stability of oil-in-water emulsions

In this study the potential ability of food-grade particles (at the droplet interface) to enhance the oxidative stability was investigated. Sunflower oil-in-water emulsions (20%), stabilised solely by food-grade particles (Microcrystalline cellulose (MCC) and modified starch (MS)), were produced under different processing conditions and their physicochemical properties were studied over time. Data on droplet size, surface charge, creaming index and oxidative stability were obtained. Increasing the food-grade particle concentration from 0.1% to 2.5% was found to decrease droplet size, enhance the physical stability of emulsions and reduce the lipid oxidation rate due to the formation of a thicker interfacial layer around the oil droplets. It was further shown that, MCC particles were able to reduce the lipid oxidation rate more effectively than MS particles. This was attributed to their ability to scavenge free radicals, through their negative charge, and form thicker interfacial layers around oil droplets due to the particles size differences. The present study demonstrates that the manipulation of emulsions' interfacial microstructure, based on the formation of a thick interface around the oil droplets by food-grade particles (Pickering emulsions), is an effective approach to slow down lipid oxidation.     

The effect of an anionic surfactant on the rheology and stability of high volume fraction O/W emulsion stabilized by PVA

The effect of the addition of an anionic surfactant (sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate) on the rheology and storage stability of concentrated O/W emulsions stabilized by poly (vinyl alcohol) is reported. It was found that the surfactant markedly reduced the magnitudes of the storage modulii of the emulsions. This could be attributed to a reduction in the interfacial tension resulting from the formation of polyelectrolyte type complexes between the PVA and NaDBS at the O/W interface. The results were compared to the equation (given by Princen) relating concentrated emulsion rheology to the interfacial tension and droplet size. Reasonable agreement was found, though there was a small difference in the constants in the equation given by Princen and those found here. The agreement suggested that the emulsions were deforming above a critical volume fraction and that the rheological properties were dominated by the dilation of the interface during shear. Microelectrophoresis measurements showed that the addition of the surfactant conferred a charge onto the PVA stabilized droplets as a result of the formation of the polyelectrolyte complex. The NaDBS was found to reduce the long-term stability of the emulsions compared to emulsions containing PVA alone.     

Effects of Surfactant Volume Fraction on the Antioxidant Efficiency and on The Interfacial Concentrations of Octyl and Tetradecyl p-Coumarates in Corn Oil-in-Water Emulsions

Surfactants have been used for decades in the food industry for the preparation of lipid-based emulsified food stuffs. They play two main roles in the emulsification processes: first they decrease the interfacial tension between the oil and water, facilitating droplet deformation and rupture; second, they reduce droplet coalescence by forming steric barriers. However, addition of surfactants to binary oil-water mixtures also brings up the formation of three-dimensional interfacial layers, surrounding each emulsion droplet, that significantly alter chemical reactivity. This is the case, for instance, in the inhibition reaction between antioxidants and the lipid radicals formed in the course of the spontaneous oxidation reaction of unsaturated lipids, which are commonly employed in the preparation of food-grade emulsions. The rate of the inhibition reaction depends on the effective concentrations of antioxidants, which are mostly controlled by the amount of surfactant employed in the preparation of the emulsion. In this work, we analyze the effects of the surfactant Tween 20 on the oxidative stability and on the effective concentrations of two model antioxidants derived from cinnamic acid, determining their interfacial concentrations in the intact emulsions to avoid disrupting the existing equilibria and biasing results. For this purpose, a recently developed methodology was employed, and experimental results were interpreted on the grounds of a pseudophase kinetic model.     

Interface composition of multiple emulsions: rheology as a probe

We have investigated the dynamic rheological properties of concentrated multiple emulsions to characterize their amphiphile composition at interfaces. Multiple emulsions (W1/O/W2) consist of water droplets (W1) dispersed into oil globules (O), which are redispersed in an external aqueous phase (W2). A small-molecule surfactant and an amphiphilic polymer were used to stabilize the inverse emulsion (W1 in oil globules) and the inverse emulsion (oil globules in W2), respectively. Rheological and interfacial tension measurements show that the polymeric surfactant adsorbed at the globule interface does not migrate to the droplet interfaces through the oil phase. This explains, at least partly, the stability improvement of multiple emulsions as polymeric surfactants are used instead of small-molecule surfactants.     

Quantification of unadsorbed protein and surfactant emulsifiers in oil-in-water emulsions

Unadsorbed emulsifiers affect the physical and chemical behaviour of oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions. A simple methodology to quantify unadsorbed emulsifiers in the aqueous phase of O/W emulsions has been developed. Emulsions were centrifuged and filtered to separate the aqueous phase from the oil droplets and the concentration of unadsorbed emulsifiers in the aqueous phase determined. The quantification of unadsorbed surfactants based on the direct transesterification of their fatty acids was validated for Tween 20, Tween 80, citric acid ester (Citrem), Span 20 and monolauroyl glycerol. To determine unadsorbed proteins, results obtained with Folin-Ciocalteu reagent or UV-spectrophotometry were compared on emulsions stabilized by β-lactoglobulin (BLG), β-casein (BCN) or bovine serum albumin (BSA). The first method gave more accurate results especially during aging of emulsions in oxidative conditions. The whole methodology was applied to emulsions stabilized with single or mixed emulsifiers. This approach enables optimization of emulsion formulations and could be useful to follow changes in the levels of unadsorbed emulsifiers during physical or chemical aging processes.     

SEMICONTINUOUS EMULSION POLYMERIZATION OF VINYL ACETATE X. KINETICS OF HOMOPOLYMERIZATION,CO POLYMERIZATION,AND INITIATOR DECOMPOSITION IN THE PRESENCE OF SULFOSUCCINATE-TYPE SURFACTANTS

ABSTRACT

Miorocrystalline cellulose stabilized emulsions (o/w) were evaluated by means of brightfield and polarized light microscopy, freeze-etch electron microscopy, droplet size analyses and rheologic measurements. These studies indicated that miorocrystalline cellulose (Avicel RC591 ) forms a network around emulsified oil droplets. This structure provides a mechanical barrier at the o/w interface which stabilizes the emulsion without the necessity for decreasing interfacial tension, as in conventional surfactant-stabilized emulsions. Rheologic studies indicated that emulsions containing Avicel RC591 had a considerable degree of thlxotropy which contributed to their stability. When Tween 80 was incorporated in this system, oil droplets coalesced indicating that the stability of the emulsion was affected adversely.     

Influence of pH on the stability of oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by a splittable surfactant

A laboratory study was conducted to evaluate the effect of pH on the stability of oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by a commercial splittable surfactant Triton SP-190 by comparison with the results obtained by a common surfactant Triton X-100. The emulsion stability was explored by measuring the volume of oil phase separated and the size of the dispersed droplets. It was found that the addition of inorganic acids did not significantly affect the stability of emulsions stabilized by Triton X-100, but had a profound influence on the stability of emulsions stabilized by Triton SP-190. Moreover, the droplet size of a Triton X-100-stabilized emulsion and its dynamic interfacial activity were insensitive to acids. However, at lower pH the droplet size of the emulsions stabilized by Triton SP-190 was considerably increased. From the dynamic interfacial tension measurements the dynamic interfacial activity of Triton SP-190 at the oil/water interface was found to be strongly inhibited by the addition of acids, resulting in a slower decreasing rate of dynamic interfacial tension. The results demonstrate that the dramatic destabilization of Triton SP-190-stabilized emulsions could be realized by the use of acids, which evidently changed the interfacial properties of the surfactant and resulted in a higher coalescence rate of oil droplets.     

Stabilization and destabilization of water-in-crude oil emulsions from the norwegian continental shelf. Correlation with model systems

A summary of properties of water-in-crude oil emulsions from the Norwegian Continental Shelf or model water-in-oil emulsions is given. A separation method for the indigenous surface active crude oil components based on adsorption/extraction was developed. These components and their films were characterized by M_w determinations, FT-IR, Langmuir-Blodgett, surface/interfacial tension, dielectric spectroscopy and interactions with chemical destabilizers. The stability/instability properties of authentic water-in-crude oil emulsions can be reproduced by model W/O emulsions stabilized by the interfacially active crude oil fraction. Processes inside the water droplets and at the W/O interface taking place upon destabilization were followed by means of dielectric spectroscopy.     

Controllable preparation of monodisperse O/W and W/O emulsions in the same microfluidic device

This letter presents a simple way to prepare monodisperse O/W and W/O emulsions in the same T-junction microfluidic device just by changing the wetting properties of the microchannel wall with different surfactants. Highly uniform droplets ranging from 50 to 400 mum with a polydispersity index (sigma) value of less than 2% were successfully prepared. With the change in surfactants and surfactant concentrations, the interfacial tension and the wetting properties varied, and disordered or ordered two-phase flow patterns could be controllable. Monodisperse O/W and W/O emulsions were prepared under the action of a cross-flowing shear force or a perpendicular shear force by using an oil solution with 0.1-2.0 wt % Span 80 and an aqueous solution with 0.1-2.0 wt % Tween 20 as a continuous-phase flow, respectively. It gives a controllable method of preparing O/W and W/O emulsions in the same microfluidic device.     

Interfacial Behavior of Mixed Systems of Glycerylether-Modified Silicone and Polyoxyethylene-Modified Silicone

Undecylglycerylether-modified silicone (GES; the glycerylether-type surfactant with a silicone segment and alkyl chains (carbon number, 11) as the hydrophobic portion) forms a molecular aggregate (M.A.) with a small amount of water. This M.A. is similar to the reversed hexagonal liquid crystal formed by alpha-mono long-chain alkylglycerylether (3-isooctadecyloxy-1,2-propanediol; GE). From the investigation of the phase behavior in the water/GES/polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) ternary system, a wide three-phase region of water (W)+M.A.+oil (O) was observed. As this M.A. is insoluble in PDMS and easily orients in the interface between water and PDMS, the high water content silicone W/O emulsion using GES as a surfactant is well stabilized. However, as the PDMS content increased this W/O emulsion became less stable. In order to improve this stability, mixtures of GES and polyoxyethylene-modified silicone (PS) were applied to the silicone emulsion as co surfactant. By application of a PS with a methyl group at the end cap of the polyoxyethylene chain (PSM), the emulsion became most stable at a GES/PSM ratio of 1 : 2, and at the same time, the interfacial tension between the oil phase and the water phase became minimal. The reason for this was studied by the measurement of spin-lattice relaxation times (T(1)) of the alkyl chains of GES in the GES/PS/water system by (13)C NMR. We assumed that the W/O silicone emulsions were stabilized by the efficient orientation of the aggregates in the interface between the silicone phase and the water phase by using PSM as a cosurfactant. Copyright 2001 Academic Press.     

纳米SiO2与阳离子表面活性剂的相互作用及其诱导的正辛烷-水乳状液的双重相转变

研究了3种不同结构的水溶性阳离子表面活性剂对纳米二氧化硅颗粒的原位表面活性化作用, 它们分别是单头单尾的十六烷基三甲基溴化铵(CTAB)、单头双尾的双十二烷基二甲基溴化铵(di-C12DMAB)和双头双尾的Gemini型阳离子三亚甲基-二(十四酰氧乙基溴化铵)(II-14-3), 并通过测定Zeta电位、吸附等温线及接触角等参数对相关机理进行了阐述. 结果表明, 阳离子表面活性剂吸附到颗粒/水界面形成以疏水基朝向水的单分子层, 从而增强了颗粒表面的疏水性是原位表面活性化的基础. 通过吸附CTAB和II-14-3, 颗粒的疏水性适当增强, 能吸附到正辛烷/水界面稳定O/W(1)型乳状液; 而通过吸附di-C12DMAB所形成的单分子层更加致密, 颗粒的疏水性进一步增强, 进而使乳状液从O/W(1)型转变为W/O型; 当表面活性剂浓度较高时, 由于链-链相互作用, 表面活性剂分子将在颗粒/水界面形成双层吸附, 使颗粒表面变得亲水而失去活性, 但此时体系中游离表面活性剂的浓度已增加到足以单独稳定O/W(2)型乳状液的程度. 因此当采用纳米二氧化硅和di-C12DMAB的混合物作乳化剂时, 通过增加di-C12DMAB的浓度即可诱导乳状液发生O/W(1)→W/O→O/W(2)双重相转变.     

Multiple emulsion stability: pressure balance and interfacial film strength

The objective of this study was to investigate the significance of inner and outer phase pressure, as well as interfacial film strength on W/O/W multiple emulsion stability using microscopy and long-term stability tests. It was observed that immediately upon applying a coverslip to samples the multiple droplets deformed and there was coalescence of the inner aqueous droplets. Under certain conditions (such as lipophilic surfactant concentration and internal phase osmotic pressure) the destabilized multiple emulsions formed unique metastable structures that had a "dimpled" appearance. The formation of these metastable structures correlated with the real-time instability of the W/O/W multiple emulsions investigated. Multiple emulsion stability also correlated with the interfacial film strength (measured by interfacial elasticity) of the hydrophobic surfactant at the mineral oil/external continuous aqueous phase interface. The formation of the metastable dimpled structures and the long-term stability of the multiple emulsions were dependent on the osmotic pressure of the inner droplets and the Laplace curvature pressure as described by the Walstra Equation (P. Walstra, "Encyclopedia of Emulsion Technology" (P. Becher, Ed.), Vol. 4. Dekker, New York, 1996). It appears that the effect of coverslip pressure on multiple emulsions may be useful as an accelerated stability testing method or for initial formulation screening.     

Protamine binding to surfactants in emulsions: modelling and computer simulation

The cationic antimicrobial peptide, protamine, has been found to destabilize oil/water (O/W) emulsions formed using soy lecithin or Tween-20. Experiments suggested that the destabilization took place via flocculation. We have modelled the interactions between protamine and an O/W interface stabilized by hypothetical amphiphilic molecule (HAM) surfactants. The intent was to suggest what properties such surfactants must possess in order that protamine will not destabilize an O/W emulsion stabilized by HAMs. We considered interfaces formed from mixtures of neutral HAMs together with (a) positively charged HAMs which possess an attractive (van der Waals, hydrogen bonding) interaction with protamine or with (b) negatively charged HAMs with no significant attractive interaction. We represented the oil and water as continuum dielectrics, with the water containing 100 mM monovalent ions and we carried out Monte Carlo computer simulations. We found that a single protamine does not bind to a single interface in case (a) but that there is a range of charged-HAM concentration, c, for which the binding of protamine becomes progressively stronger as c increases in case (b). We investigated stability by studying under what conditions protamines will cause the aggregation of two HAM-stabilized interfaces, and we have identified values of c for which the interfaces are stable. We note that the transition from bound to unbound states of two HAM interfaces with five protamines are examples of entropy-driven unbinding transitions with the entropy of the protamines overcoming the net attractive interactions. We conclude by identifying regions of the phase diagram in which stable emulsions should exist in the presence of protamine.     

A one-step process for oil-in-water-in-oil double emulsion formation using a single surfactant

A one-step double emulsification protocol using one surfactant was developed for oil-in-water-in-oil (O(1)/W/O(2)) double emulsions. Two n-alkane oils and three different surfactants were studied, with focus placed on a formulation containing mineral oil, glycerol monoleate (GMO) and deionized water. Phenomenologically, double emulsion formation and stability originate from the combined actions of phase inversion and interfacial charging of the oil/water interface during high shear homogenization. Based on the extent of double emulsion formation and stability, a critical emulsification zone dependent on the weight ratios of GMO to water was identified. Within this critical zone, enhanced O(1)/W/O(2) emulsion formation occurred at higher pH and lower salt concentrations, demonstrating the key role of interfacial charging on double emulsification. Overall, this novel approach provides a novel platform for the development of double emulsions with simple compositions and processing requirements.     

Effect of silica particles on stability of highly concentrated water-in-oil emulsions with non-ionic surfactant

Water-in-oil, high internal phase emulsion made of super-cooled aqueous solution containing a mixture of inorganic salts and stabilized with non-ionic surfactant (sorbitan monooleate) alone was investigated. It was not possible to produce a highly concentrated emulsion (with aqueous phase fraction = 94 wt %), stabilized with surface-treated silica, solely: we were able to form an emulsion with a maximal aqueous phase mass fraction of 85 wt % (emulsion inverts/breaks above this concentration). The inversion point is dependent on the silica particle concentration, presence of salt in the aqueous phase, and does not depend on the pH of the dispersed phase. All emulsions stabilized by the nanoparticles solely were unstable to shear. So, the rheological properties and stability of the emulsions containing super-cooled dispersed phase, with regards to crystallization, were determined for an emulsion stabilized by non-ionic surfactant only. The results were compared to the properties obtained for emulsions stabilized by surface treated (relatively hydrophobic) silica nanoparticles as a co-surfactant to sorbitan monooleate. The influence of the particle concentration, type of silica surface treatment, particle/surfactant ratio on emulsification and emulsion rheological properties was studied. The presence of the particles as a co-stabilizer increases the stability of all emulsions. Also, it was found that the particle/surfactant ratio is important since the most stable emulsions are those where particles dominate over the surfactant, when the surfactant’s role is to create bridging flocculation of the particles. The combination of the two types of hydrophobic silica particles as co-surfactants is: one that resides at the water/oil interface and provides a steric boundary and another that remains in the oil phase creating a 3D-network throughout the oil phase, which is even more beneficiary in terms of the emulsion stability.     

Relationship between rheological properties and one-step W/O/W multiple emulsion formation

Formation of a normal (not temporary) W/O/W multiple emulsion via the one-step method as a result of the simultaneous occurrence of catastrophic and transitional phase inversion processes has been recently reported. Critical features of this process include the emulsification temperature (corresponding to the ultralow surface tension point), the use of a specific nonionic surfactant blend and the surfactant blend/oil phase ratio, and the addition of the surfactant blend to the oil phase. The purpose of this study was to investigate physicochemical properties in an effort to gain a mechanistic understanding of the formation of these emulsions. Bulk, surface, and interfacial rheological properties of adsorbed nonionic surfactant (CremophorRH40 and Span80) films were investigated under conditions known to affect W/O/W emulsion formation. Bulk viscosity results demonstrated that CremophorRH40 has a higher mobility in oil compared than in water, explaining the significance of the solvent phase. In addition, the bulk viscosity profile of aqueous solutions containing CremophorRH40 indicated a phase transition at around 78 ± 2 °C, which is in agreement with cubic phase formation in the Winsor III region. The similarity in the interfacial elasticity values of CremophorRH40 and Span80 indicated that canola oil has a major effect on surface activity, showing the significance of vegetable oil. The highest interfacial shear elasticity and viscosity were observed when both surfactants were added to the oil phase, indicating the importance of the microstructural arrangement. CremophorRH40/Span80 complexes tended to desorb from the solution/solution interface with increasing temperature, indicating surfactant phase formation as is theoretically predicted in the Winsor III region. Together these interfacial and bulk rheology data demonstrate that one-step W/O/W emulsions form as a result of the simultaneous occurrence of phase-transition processes in the Winsor III region and explain the critical formulation and processing parameters necessary to achieve the formation of these normal W/O/W emulsions.     

Effect of Emulsifier Type on the Characterization of O/W Emulsions Using a Spectroscopy Technique

The droplet size distribution (DSD) of emulsions is the result of two competitive effects that take place during emulsification process, i.e., drop breakup and drop coalescence, and it is influenced by the formulation and composition variables, i.e., nature and amount of emulsifier, mixing characteristics, and emulsion preparation, all of which affect the emulsion stability. The aim of this study is to characterize oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions (droplet size and stability) in terms of surfactant concentration and surfactant composition (sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate (SDBS)/Tween 80 mixture). Ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) transmission spectroscopy has been applied to obtain droplet size and stability of the emulsions and the verification of emulsion stability with the relative cleared volume technique (time required for a certain amount of emulsion to separate as a cleared phase). It is demonstrated that the DSD of the emulsions is a function of the oil concentration and the surfactant composition with higher stability for emulsions prepared with higher SDBS ratio and lower relative cleared volume with the time. Results also show that smaller oil droplets are generated with increasing Tween 80 ratio and emulsifier concentration.     

Factors in the Single-Step Bulk Process Preparation of a Triple Janus Emulsion

Some factors in the preparation of triple Janus emulsions in a single-step bulk process were investigated using optical microscopy. The emulsions consisted of water, O.097 weight fraction, a commercial surfactant, Tween 80, 0.03 weight fraction, a vegetable oil (VO), 0.18 weight fraction, and a silicone oil (SO), 0.72 weight fraction. A surprising connection was found between the state of the compounds prior to mixing and the final morphology as well as stability of the emulsion. Separately adding the compounds or with the surfactant dissolved in the vegetable oil, prior to mixing, did not result in a Janus emulsion. Instead, simpler emulsions with limited stability were attained even with prolonged mixing. Storing the compounds together without mixing for two days followed by mixing resulted in a Janus emulsion in which the (VO + SO)/W/VO drops were more sparsely populated with Janus drops, and emulsion stability was limited. Finally, preparing the emulsion from the aqueous surfactant solution and the two oils gave a (VO + SO)/W/VO/SO emulsion with the W drops heavily populated by Janus drops and with improved stability.