Glycomics and glycoproteomics: Approaches to address isomeric separation of glycans and glycopeptides

Changes in the glycome of human proteins and cells are associated with the progression of multiple diseases such as Alzheimer's, diabetes mellitus, many types of cancer, and those caused by viruses. Consequently, several studies have shown essential modifications to the isomeric glycan moieties for diseases in different stages. However, the elucidation of extensive isomeric glycan profiles remains challenging because of the lack of analytical techniques with sufficient resolution power to separate all glycan and glycopeptide iso‐forms. Therefore, the development of sensitive and accurate approaches for the characterization of all the isomeric forms of glycans and glycopeptides is essential to tracking the progression of pathology in glycoprotein‐related diseases. This review describes the isomeric separation achievements reported in glycomics and glycoproteomics in the last decade. It focuses on the mass spectrometry–based analytical strategies, stationary phases, and derivatization techniques that have been developed to enhance the separation mechanisms in liquid chromatography systems and the detection capabilities of mass spectrometry systems.     

Capillary electrophoresis/electrospray ion trap mass spectrometry for the analysis of negatively charged derivatized and underivatized glycans.

The increasing interest in the development of glycoproteins for therapeutic purposes has created a greater demand for methods to characterize the sugar moieties bound to them. Traditionally, released carbohydrates are derivatized using such methods as permethylation or fluorescent tagging prior to analysis by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), capillary electrophoresis (CE), or direct infusion mass spectrometry. However, little research has been performed using CE with on-line mass spectrometry (MS) detection. The CE separation of neutral oligosaccharides requires the covalent attachment of a charged species for electrophoretic migration. Among charged labels which have shown promise in assisting CE and HPLC separation is the fluorophore 8-aminonaphthalene-1,3,6-trisulfonic acid (ANTS). This report describes the qualitative profiling of charged ANTS-derivatized and underivatized complex glycans by CE with on-line electrospray ion trap mass spectrometry. Several neutral standard glycans including a maltooligosaccharide ladder were derivatized with ANTS and subjected to CE/UV and CE/MS using low pH buffers consisting of citric and 6-aminocaproic acid salts. The ANTS-derivatized species were detected as negative ions, and multiple stage MS analysis provided valuable structural information. Fragment ions were easily identified, showing promise for the identification of unknowns. N-Linked glycans released from bovine fetuin were used to demonstrate the applicability of ANTS derivatization followed by CE/MS for the analysis of negatively charged glycans. Analyses were performed on both underivatized and ANTS-derivatized species, and sialylated glycans were separated and detected in both forms. The ability of the ion trap mass spectrometer to perform multiple stage analysis was exploited, with MS5 information obtained on selected glycans. This technique presents a complementary method to existing methodologies for the profiling of glycan mixtures.     

Solid-phase methylamidation for sialoglycomics by MALDI-MS

Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) has been a major approach for glycan analysis. However, the preferential cleavage of the sialic acid moiety by in- and post-source decay influences the determination of sialylated glycans by MALDI-MS. Many chemical derivatization methods were introduced to stabilize the sialylated glycan during MALDI-MS. Among current derivatization methods, methylamidation is a promising means for simultaneous analysis of natural sialylated glycans regardless of their sialic acid linkage types. Here, a novel derivatization method was developed, in which proteins were conjugated on the solid-phase support in order to stabilize the sialic acids by methylamidation and to reduce sample loss and contamination during the derivatization process. This derivatization strategy was used to investigate N-glycans from fetuin, a glycoprotein containing different types of complex N-glycans. The developed method was also applied to the N-glycan profiling of human serum from patients and healthy volunteers. Results were consistent with N-glycan profiling by HPLC-fluorescence detection. This new method provided a sensitive, simple, and robust approach for profiling glycan structures of complex samples.     

Highly specific purification of N-glycans using phosphate-based derivatization as an affinity tag in combination with Ti-SPE enrichment for mass spectrometric analysis

N-linked protein glycosylation is involved in regulation of a wide variety of cellular processes and associated with numerous diseases. Highly specific identification of N-glycome remains a challenge while its biological significance is acknowledged. The relatively low abundance of glycan in complex biological mixtures, lack of basic sites for protonation, and suppression by other highly abundant proteins/peptides lead to the particularly poor detection sensitivity of N-glycans in the MS analysis. Therefore, the highly specific purification procedure becomes a crucial step prior to MS analysis of the N-glycome. Herein, a novel N-glycans enrichment approach based on phosphate derivatization combined with Ti⁴⁺-SPE (solid phase extraction) was developed. Briefly, in this strategy, N-glycans were chemically labeled with a phospho-group at their reducing ends, such that the Ti⁴⁺-SPE microspheres were able to capture the phospho-containing glycans. The enrichment method was developed and optimized using model oligosaccharides (maltoheptaose DP7 and sialylated glycan A1) and also glycans from a standard glycoprotein (asialofetuin, ASF). This method experimentally showed high derivatization efficiency (almost 100%), excellent selectivity (analyzing DP7 in the digests of bovine serum albumin at a mass ratio of 1:100), high enriching recovery (90%), good reproducibility (CV<15%) as well as high sensitivity (LOD at fmol level). At last, the proposed method was successfully applied in the profiling of N-glycome in human serum, in which a total of 31 N-glycan masses were identified.     

Zwitterionic-type hydrophilic interaction nano-liquid chromatography of complex and high mannose glycans coupled with electrospray ionisation high resolution time of flight mass spectrometry

In this study we describe a new method for rapid and sensitive analysis of reduced high mannose and complex glycans using zwitterionic-type hydrophilic interaction nano-liquid chromatography (nano ZIC-HILIC, 75 μm I.D.×150 mm) coupled with high resolution nanoelectrospray ionisation time of flight mass spectrometry (nano ESI-TOF-MS). The retention of neutral glycans increases with increasing molecular weight and is higher for high mannose glycans than for complex-type glycans. The selectivity of ZIC-HILIC for sialylated glycans differs from that for the neutral glycans and is believed to involve electrostatic repulsion; therefore, charged glycans are eluted earlier than neutral glycans with comparable molecular weight. Due to the improved sensitivity achieved by employing a ZIC-HILIC nano-column, a range of less common complex glycans has been studied and the high resolution mass spectrometry enabled confirmation of glycan composition for the proposed structures. Good sensitivity for glycans was achieved without prior fluorescent labelling, and the time of the analysis was significantly reduced compared to the separation of glycans on a conventional-size column. The proposed method offers a fast and sensitive approach for glycan profiling applied to analysis of biopharmaceuticals.     

Characterization of Minor N-linked Glycans on Antibodies Using Endo H Release and MALDI–Mass Spectrometry

Abstract

A MALDI mass spectrometry method using Bruker Daltonic's LIFT technology for MS/MS analysis has been developed for profiling and characterizing low abundant N-glycans from recombinant immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies. In this method, Endoglycosidase H (Endo H) released N-glycans are derivatized at their reducing end with 2-aminobenzamide (2-AB) and separated by normal phase chromatography. Endo H hydrolyses the bond between the two GlcNAc residues of the trimannosyl core of high mannose and hybrid N-linked glycans, leaving the core GlcNAc attached to the protein. High mannose and hybrid type N-glycans are released from the glycoprotein whereas the more abundant, complex biantennary type oligosaccharide structures are unaffected. Analysis of Endo H treated glycan moieties by MALDI mass spectrometry identified several minor species of high mannose and hybrid type glycans. Subsequent MALDI TOF MS/MS analysis of the resulting products yielded information about structural features of the high mannose and hybrid type glycans. This study involving Endo H treatment followed by MALDI mass spectrometry coupled with LIFT technology for MS/MS analysis offers a specific and sensitive technique for visualizing, and characterizing minor glycan species.     

Mass spectrometry-based glycoprofiling of biopharmaceuticals by using an automated data processing tool: SimGlycan®

The therapeutic and immunological properties of biopharmaceuticals are governed by the glycoforms contained in them. Thus, bioinformatics tools capable of performing comprehensive characterization of glycans are significantly important to the biopharma industry. The primary structural elucidation of glycans using mass spectrometry is tricky and tedious in terms of spectral interpretation. In this study, the biosimilars of a therapeutic monoclonal antibody and an Fc-fusion protein with moderate and heavy glycosylation, respectively, were employed as representative biopharmaceuticals for released glycan analysis using liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry instead of conventional mass spectrometry-based analysis. SimGlycan® is a software with proven ability to process tandem MS data for released glycans could identify eight additional glycoforms in Fc-fusion protein biosimilar, which were not detected during mass spectrometry analysis of released glycans or glyco-peptide mapping of the same molecule. Thus, liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry analysis of released glycans not only complements conventional liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry-based glycan profiling but can also identify additional glycan structures that may otherwise be omitted during conventional liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry based analysis of mAbs. The mass spectrometry data processing tools, such as PMI Byos™, SimGlycan^®, etc., can display pivotal analytical capabilities in automated liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry and liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry-based glycan analysis workflows, especially for high-throughput structural characterization of glycoforms in biopharmaceuticals.     

The effects of abundant plasma protein depletion on global glycan profiling using NanoLC FT-ICR mass spectrometry

We report the results of abundant plasma protein depletion on the analysis of underivatized N-linked glycans derived from plasma proteins by nanoLC Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry. N-linked glycan profiles were compared between plasma samples where the six most abundant plasma proteins were depleted (n = 3) through a solid-phase immunoaffinity column and undepleted plasma samples (n = 3). Three exogenous glycan standards were spiked into all samples which allowed for normalization of the N-glycan abundances. The abundances of 20 glycans varying in type, structure, composition, and molecular weight (1,200–3,700 Da) were compared between the two sets of samples. Small fucosylated non-sialylated complex glycans were found to decrease in abundance in the depleted samples (greater than or equal to tenfold) relative to the undepleted samples. Protein depletion was found to marginally effect (less than threefold) the abundance of high mannose, hybrid, and large highly sialylated complex species. The significance of these findings in terms of future biomarker discovery experiments via global glycan profiling is discussed.     

Analysis of a series of isomeric oligosaccharides by energy‐resolved mass spectrometry: a challenge on homobranched trisaccharides

Glycans exist as part of glycoproteins and glycolipids, which are involved in a variety of biological functions. The analysis of glycan structures, particularly that of structural isomers, is fundamentally important since isomeric glycans often show distinct functions; however, a method for their structural elucidation has not yet been established. Anomeric configurations, linkage positions and branching are the major factors in glycans and their alteration results in a large diversity of glycan structures. The analysis of vicinally substituted oligosaccharides is extremely difficult because the product ions formed in tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) often have the same m/z values. In our endeavor to address the issue, we analyzed a series of homo‐substituted trisaccharides consisting only of glucose by collision‐induced dissociation (CID), especially energy‐resolved mass spectrometry (ERMS). It was found that these structurally related glycans could be distinguished by taking advantage of differences in their activation energies in ERMS. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

A rapid sample preparation method for mass spectrometric characterization of N-linked glycans

A rapid method for analysis of glycans of glycoproteins is presented. This method comprised deglycosylation, sample cleanup and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) analysis of glycans. The enzymatic deglycosylation of N-linked glycoproteins was enhanced in terms of speed and reproducibility using an enzyme-friendly surfactant. The released glycans were desalted using a micro-scale solid phase extraction (SPE) device packed with a hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) sorbent. Hydrophilic glycans were well retained by SPE, while salts and surfactants were removed from the sample. The glycans were eluted using 25-50 microL of solvent and analyzed directly without derivatization using MALDI-MS. MALDI quadrupole time-of-flight (Q-Tof) instrumentation was utilized for glycan profiling and structure characterization by tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). The presented method allows sensitive analysis of glycans benefiting from optimized deglycosylation reactions and efficient sample cleanup.     

Reversed-phase ion-pairing liquid chromatography/ion trap mass spectrometry for the analysis of negatively charged,derivatized glycans

The significant complexity, similar polarity and lack of ionizable sites make the analysis of glycans an analytical challenge. These compounds are often derivatized and separated by normal-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) or capillary electrophoresis (CE) followed by UV or fluorescence detection. Due to widespread use of reversed-phase chromatography coupled to electrospray mass spectrometry as an analytical tool, our laboratory has developed this methodology for the analysis of glycans derivatized with a negatively charged tag, 8-aminonaphthalene-1,3,6-trisulfonic acid (ANTS). It is possible to exploit the ability of this negatively charged tag to interact with a mobile phase ion-pairing reagent, allowing retention on a reversed-phase C(18) column for subsequent on-line UV or MS analysis. ANTS-derivatized samples, including a maltooligosaccharide ladder and glycans released from bovine ribonuclease B, bovine fetuin, and chicken ovalbumin, were analyzed using this method. In addition to reversed-phase retention, ribonuclease B and ovalbumin derivatives displayed highly desirable isomeric separation. With the use of mass spectrometric detection for glycan identity, this allowed relative quantitation of individual components.     

Comparing MALDI-MS, RP-LC-MALDI-MS and RP-LC-ESI-MS glycomic profiles of permethylated N-glycans derived from model glycoproteins and human blood serum

The glycomic profiling of purified glycoproteins and biological specimen is routinely achieved through different analytical methods, but mainly through MS and LC-MS. The enhanced ionization efficiency and improved tandem MS interpretation of permethylated glycans have prompted the popularity of this approach. This study focuses on comparing the glycomic profiling of permethylated N-glycans derived from model glycoproteins and human blood serum using MALDI-MS as well as RP-LC-MALDI-MS and RP-LC-ESI-MS. In the case of model glycoproteins, the glycomic profiles acquired using the three methods were very comparable. However, this was not completely true in the case of glycans derived from blood serum. RP-LC-ESI-MS analysis of reduced and permethylated N-glycans derived from 250 nl of blood serum allowed the confident detection of 73 glycans (the structures of which were confirmed by mass accuracy and tandem MS), while 53 and 43 structures were identified in the case of RP-LC-MALDI-MS and MALDI-MS analyses of the same sample, respectively. RP-LC-ESI-MS analysis facilitates automated and sensitive tandem MS acquisitions. The glycan structures that were detected only in the RP-LC-ESI-MS analysis were glycans existing at low abundances. This is suggesting the higher detection sensitivity of RP-LC-ESI-MS analysis, originating from both reduced competitive ionization and saturation of detectors, facilitated by the chromatographic separation. The latter also permitted the separation of several structural isomers; however, isomeric separations pertaining to linkages were not detected.     

Mass spectrometric study of N‐glycans from serum of woodchucks with liver cancer

Woodchucks have been a preferred lab animal model of chronic hepatitis B viral infection. The model recapitulates the disease progression of HBV infection to hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) and has documented similarities in protein glycosylation with human HCC. This study examined N‐glycans in serum of animals with(out) HCC. Oligosaccharides were released enzymatically using PNGaseF from total serum or from serum partially fractionated by extraction. Two different extraction procedures – reversed‐phase high‐performance liquid chromatography (RP‐HPLC) and solid‐phase extraction (SPE) on a cation‐exchange/reversed‐phase STRATA‐XC cartridge – were used with the purpose of confirming glycosylation profiles. Oligosaccharides were analyzed by matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI‐MS) after derivatization with phenylhydrazine and/or permethylation. Characteristic fragment ions produced under MS/MS conditions allowed discrimination between isomeric structures of oligosaccharides, including those sialylated with two types of acidic residues. The complementary methods allowed structural characterization of oligosaccharides from various N‐glycan classes. Furthermore, to validate results, glycosylation profiles of woodchuck sera were compared to glycans obtained from mouse serum on the same conditions. In summary, we have identified 40 N‐glycan structures in the serum of woodchucks and some types of oligosaccharide structures appeared to increase in HCC samples following protease digest. The study provides improved tools for the characterization of N‐glycans from total serum in the progression of liver disease. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Double‐layer poly(vinyl alcohol)‐coated capillary for highly sensitive and stable capillary electrophoresis and capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry glycan analysis

Glycosylation plays an important role in protein conformations and functions as well as many biological activities. Capillary electrophoresis combined with various detection methods provided remarkable developments for high‐sensitivity glycan profiling. The coating of the capillary is needed for highly polar molecules from complex biosamples. A poly(vinyl alcohol)‐coated capillary is commonly utilized in the capillary electrophoresis separation of saccharides sample due to the high‐hydrophilicity properties. A modified facile coating workflow was carried out to acquire a novel multiple‐layer poly(vinyl alcohol)‐coated capillary for highly sensitive and stable analysis of glycans. The migration time fluctuation was used as index in the optimization of layers and a double layer was finally chosen, considering both the effects and simplicity in fabrication. With migration time relative standard deviation less than 1% and theoretical plates kept stable during 100 consecutive separations, the method was presented to be suitable for the analysis of glycosylation with wide linear dynamic range and good reproducibility. The glycan profiling of enzymatically released N‐glycans from human serum was obtained by the presented capillary electrophoresis method combined with mass spectrometry detection with acceptable results.     

Site-specific protein glycosylation analysis with glycan isomer differentiation

Glycosylation is one of the most common yet diverse post-translational modifications. Information on glycan heterogeneity and glycosite occupancy is increasingly recognized as crucial to understanding glycoprotein structure and function. Yet, no approach currently exists with which to holistically consider both the proteomic and glycomic aspects of a system. Here, we developed a novel method of comprehensive glycosite profiling using nanoflow liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (nano-LC/MS) that shows glycan isomer-specific differentiation on specific sites. Glycoproteins were digested by controlled non-specific proteolysis in order to produce informative glycopeptides. High-resolution, isomer-sensitive chromatographic separation of the glycopeptides was achieved using microfluidic chip-based capillaries packed with graphitized carbon. Integrated LC/MS/MS not only confirmed glycopeptide composition but also differentiated glycan and peptide isomers and yielded structural information on both the glycan and peptide moieties. Our analysis identified at least 13 distinct glycans (including isomers) corresponding to five compositions at the single N-glycosylation site on bovine ribonuclease B, 59 distinct glycans at five N-glycosylation sites on bovine lactoferrin, 13 distinct glycans at one N-glycosylation site on four subclasses of human immunoglobulin G, and 20 distinct glycans at five O-glycosylation sites on bovine κ-casein. Porous graphitized carbon provided effective separation of glycopeptide isomers. The integration of nano-LC with MS and MS/MS of non-specifically cleaved glycopeptides allows quantitative, isomer-sensitive, and site-specific glycoprotein analysis.     

花生致敏糖蛋白Ara h1糖链决定簇的质谱分析

以花生种子总蛋白及其主要致敏糖蛋白Ara h1为研究对象,采用"一釜法"对蛋白上的糖链进行释放并同时进行衍生化标记,通过C18固相萃取柱纯化,以电喷雾质谱(ESI-MS)、多级串联质谱(MSn)和亲水性液相色谱-质谱联用(HILIC-MS)进行结构解析和定量分析.结果表明,蛋白Ara h1共有10条N-糖链,其中7条为高甘露糖型,2条为木糖修饰,另外1条为与过敏原相关的核心α1,3-Fuc修饰N-糖链,其含量约占总糖链的12.45%.     

Distinguishing isomeric pyridylaminated high-mannose (Man7) oligosaccharides based on energy-resolved mass spectra

Analysis of posttranslational modifications of proteins is an important issue for understanding the relationship between protein structure and function. Micro-scale analytical methods capable of elucidating glycan structures are therefore gaining attention in connection with proteomics research. Recent efforts directed toward this goal have successfully distinguished and in some cases identified glycan structures based on collision-induced dissociation (CID) analysis. Despite these advancements, the identification of isomeric glycans such as high-mannose-type oligosaccharides, Man(7)GlcNAc(2), that are closely related structurally, is not yet possible. Using energy-resolved mass spectrometry (ERMS), we found that these isomers could be distinguished by comparing the intensities of certain fragment ions. ERMS is useful because the data obtained can be treated quantitatively. Furthermore, it was found that discrimination can be easily achieved by analyzing only the energy-resolved mass spectra of the sodiated isomeric compounds at the stage of MS(2). Thus, the importance and usefulness of ERMS, which provide the factor of activation energy under CID, in analyzing isomeric molecules are clearly shown.     

Universal proteolysis and MSn for N‐ and O‐ glycan branching analysis

The continually growing list of critical glycosylation‐related processes has made analytical methodology for detailed glycan characterization an area of increasing interest. Glycosylation is a post translational modification of unsurpassed complexity due to the variety of compositions and linkages formed by these biopolymers. Structural characterization of glycan isomers has been achieved using ion trap mass spectrometry and MSⁿ of released, permethylated glycans. However, N‐ and O‐glycans require different sample preparation strategies; and release of the glycans may be hindered, result in degradation of the glycan, and/or produce limited yields of permethylated product. In the current report, we demonstrate universal proteolysis of both N‐ and O‐linked glycoproteins to individual glycoamino acids. These samples were shown to be directly amenable to permethylation and MSⁿ analysis for isomeric structural determination. Universal proteolysis and permethylation provides an identical sample preparation strategy for both classes of glycans that avoids potential pitfalls of commonly used release methods. This methodology should be applicable to all glycoproteins and serve as an alternative to glycan release for MSⁿ branching analysis. Published 2013. This article is a U.S. Government work and is in the public domain in the USA.     

Enhanced sensitivity of LC-MS analysis of permethylated N-glycans through online purification

Aberrant glycosylation of proteins and lipids has been implicated in many human diseases, thus prompting the need for reliable analytical methods that permit dependable quantification of glycans originating from biological specimens. MS of permethylated glycans is currently employed to monitor disease-related aberrant glycosylation of proteins and lipids. However, enhancing the sensitivity of this type of analysis is still needed. Here, analysis of permethylated glycans at enhanced sensitivity is attained through miniaturized solid-phase permethylation and online solid-phase purification. Solid-phase permethylation method was miniaturized by reducing the amount of sodium hydroxide beads (one-third the original amount) packed in microspin columns. The efficiency of glycan permethylation was not adversely affected by this reduction. Online solid-phase purification of permethylated N-glycans derived from model glycoproteins, such as fetuin, α-1 acid glycoprotein and ribonuclease B, offered more sensitive and reproducible results than offline liquid-liquid and solid-phase extractions. Online solid-phase purification method described here permitted a 75% increase in signal intensities of permethylated glycans relative to offline purification methods. This is mainly due to the minimized sample handling associated with an online cleaning procedure. The efficiency and utility of online solid-phase purification was also demonstrated here for N-glycans derived from human blood serum. Online solid-phase purification permitted the detection of 73 N-glycan structures, while only 63 glycan structures were detected in the case of samples purified through liquid-liquid extraction. The intensities of the 63 structures that were detected in both cases were 75% higher for samples that were purified through the online method.     

Glycoform characterization of intact erythropoietin by capillary electrophoresis-electrospray-time of flight-mass spectrometry

Glycosylated proteins often show a large variation in their glycosylation pattern, complicating their structural characterization. In this paper, we present a method for the accurate mass determination of intact isomeric glycoproteins based on capillary electrophoresis-electrospray-time of flight-mass spectrometry. Human recombinant erythropoietin has been chosen as a showcase. The approach enables the on-line removal of nonglycosylated proteins, salts, and neutral and negatively charged species. More important, different glycosylation forms are separated both on the base of differences in the number of negatively charged sialic acid residues and the size of the glycans. Thus, 44 glycoforms and in total about 135 isoforms of recombinant human erythropoietin, taking also acetylation into account, could be distinguished for the reference material from the European Pharmacopeia. Distinct glycosylation differences for samples from different suppliers are clearly observed. Based on the accurate mass an overall composition of each single isoform is proposed, perfectly in agreement with data on glycan and glycopeptide analysis. This method is an ideal complement to the established techniques for glycopeptide and glycan analysis, not differentiating branching or linkage isoforms, but leading to an overall composition of the glycoprotein. The presented strategy is expected to improve significantly the ability to characterize and quantify isomeric glycoforms for a large variety of glycoproteins.