Rate constants and mechanisms of intrinsically disordered proteins binding to structured targets

The binding of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) to structured targets is gaining increasing attention. Here we review experimental and computational studies on the binding kinetics of IDPs. Experiments have yielded both the binding rate constants and the binding mechanisms, the latter via mutation and deletion studies and NMR techniques. Most computational studies have aimed at qualitative understanding of the binding rate constants or at mapping the free energy surfaces after the IDPs are engaged with their targets. The experiments and computation show that IDPs generally gain structures after they are engaged with their targets; that is, interactions with the targets facilitate the IDPs' folding. It also seems clear that the initial contact of an IDP with the target is formed by just a segment, not the entire IDP. The docking of one segment to its sub-site followed by coalescing of other segments around the corresponding sub-sites emerges as a recurring feature in the binding of IDPs. Such a dock-and-coalesce model forms the basis for quantitative calculation of binding rate constants. For both disordered and ordered proteins, strong electrostatic attraction with their targets can enhance the binding rate constants by several orders of magnitude. There are now tremendous opportunities in narrowing the gap in our understanding of IDPs relative to ordered proteins with regard to binding kinetics.     

Do Intrinsically Disordered Proteins Possess High Specificity in Protein–Protein Interactions?

Specific protein–protein interactions are critical to cellular function. Structural flexibility and disorder‐to‐order transitions upon binding enable intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) to overcome steric restrictions and form complementary binding interfaces, and thus, IDPs are widely considered to have high specificity and low affinity for molecular recognition. However, flexibility may also enable IDPs to form complementary binding interfaces with misbinding partners, resulting in a great number of nonspecific interactions. Consequently, it is questionable whether IDPs really possess high specificity. In this work, we investigated this question from a thermodynamic viewpoint. We collected mutant thermodynamic data for 35 ordered protein complexes and 43 disordered protein complexes. We found that the enthalpy–entropy compensation for disordered protein complexes was more complete than that for ordered protein complexes. We further simulated the binding processes of ordered and disordered protein complexes under mutations. Simulation data confirmed the observation of experimental data analyses and further revealed that disordered protein complexes possessed smaller changes in binding free energy than ordered protein complexes under the same mutation perturbations. Therefore, interactions of IDPs are more malleable than those of ordered proteins due to their structural flexibility in the complex. Our results provide new clues for exploring the relationship between protein flexibility, adaptability, and specificity.     

Multitude of binding modes attainable by intrinsically disordered proteins: a portrait gallery of disorder-based complexes

Proteins are constantly involved in the multitude of various interactions creating sophisticated networks which define and control all (or almost all) the biological processes taking place in any living organism. Intrinsically disordered proteins or regions play a number of crucial roles in mediating protein interactions. The lack of fixed structure protruding to the high level of intrinsic dynamics and almost unrestricted flexibility at various structure levels, being the major characteristics of intrinsically disordered proteins, provides them with unprecedented advantages over the ordered proteins. The binding modes attainable by disordered proteins are highly diverse, creating a multitude of unusual complexes. Although the majority of studied to date intrinsic disorder-based complexes are ordered or static entities originating due to the global or local disorder-to-order transitions, a new development is the discovery of dynamic complexes in which intrinsically disordered proteins continue to sample an ensemble of rapidly interconverting conformations mostly devoid of structure even in their bound state. The goal of this critical review is to illustrate binding plasticity of intrinsically disordered proteins by representing a portrait gallery of the disorder-based complexes (119 references).     

Novel NMR Assignment Strategy Reveals Structural Heterogeneity in Solution of the nsP3 HVD Domain of Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis Virus

In recent years, intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and disordered domains have attracted great attention. Many of them contain linear motifs that mediate interactions with other factors during formation of multicomponent protein complexes. NMR spectrometry is a valuable tool for characterizing this type of interactions on both amino acid (aa) and atomic levels. Alphaviruses encode a nonstructural protein nsP3, which drives viral replication complex assembly. nsP3 proteins contain over 200-aa-long hypervariable domains (HVDs), which exhibits no homology between different alphavirus species, are predicted to be intrinsically disordered and appear to be critical for alphavirus adaptation to different cells. Previously, we have shown that nsP3 HVD of chikungunya virus (CHIKV) is completely disordered with low tendency to form secondary structures in free form. In this new study, we used novel NMR approaches to assign the spectra for the nsP3 HVD of Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus (VEEV). The HVDs of CHIKV and VEEV have no homology but are both involved in replication complex assembly and function. We have found that VEEV nsP3 HVD is also mostly disordered but contains a short stable α-helix in its C-terminal fragment, which mediates interaction with the members of cellular Fragile X syndrome protein family. Our NMR data also suggest that VEEV HVD has several regions with tendency to form secondary structures.     

Helical Propensity in an Intrinsically Disordered Protein Accelerates Ligand Binding

Many intrinsically disordered proteins fold upon binding to other macromolecules. The secondary structure present in the well‐ordered complex is often formed transiently in the unbound state. The consequence of such transient structure for the binding process is, however, not clear. The activation domain of the activator for thyroid hormone and retinoid receptors (ACTR) is intrinsically disordered and folds upon binding to the nuclear coactivator binding domain (NCBD) of the CREB binding protein. A number of mutants was designed that selectively perturbs the amount of secondary structure in unbound ACTR without interfering with the intermolecular interactions between ACTR and NCBD. Using NMR spectroscopy and fluorescence‐monitored stopped‐flow kinetic measurements we show that the secondary structure content in helix 1 of ACTR indeed influences the binding kinetics. The results thus support the notion of preformed secondary structure as an important determinant for molecular recognition in intrinsically disordered proteins.     

ABSINTH: a new continuum solvation model for simulations of polypeptides in aqueous solutions

A new implicit solvation model for use in Monte Carlo simulations of polypeptides is introduced. The model is termed ABSINTH for self-Assembly of Biomolecules Studied by an Implicit, Novel, and Tunable Hamiltonian. It is designed primarily for simulating conformational equilibria and oligomerization reactions of intrinsically disordered proteins in aqueous solutions. The paradigm for ABSINTH is conceptually similar to the EEF1 model of Lazaridis and Karplus (Proteins 1999, 35, 133). In ABSINTH, the transfer of a polypeptide solute from the gas phase into a continuum solvent is the sum of a direct mean field interaction (DMFI), and a term to model the screening of polar interactions. Polypeptide solutes are decomposed into a set of distinct solvation groups. The DMFI is a sum of contributions from each of the solvation groups, which are analogs of model compounds. Continuum-mediated screening of electrostatic interactions is achieved using a framework similar to the one used for the DMFI. Promising results are shown for a set of test cases. These include the calculation of NMR coupling constants for short peptides, the assessment of the thermal stability of two small proteins, reversible folding of both an alpha-helix and a beta-hairpin forming peptide, and the polymeric properties of intrinsically disordered polyglutamine peptides of varying lengths. The tests reveal that the computational expense for simulations with the ABSINTH implicit solvation model increase by a factor that is in the range of 2.5-5.0 with respect to gas-phase calculations.     

Magnetic Resonance Access to Transiently Formed Protein Complexes

Protein–protein interactions are of utmost importance to an understanding of biological phenomena since non-covalent and therefore reversible couplings between basic proteins leads to the formation of complex regulatory and adaptive molecular systems. Such systems are capable of maintaining their integrity and respond to external stimuli, processes intimately related to living organisms. These interactions, however, span a wide range of dissociation constants, from sub-nanomolar affinities in tight complexes to high-micromolar or even millimolar affinities in weak, transiently formed protein complexes. Herein, we demonstrate how novel NMR and EPR techniques can be used for the characterization of weak protein–protein (ligand) complexes. Applications to intrinsically disordered proteins and transiently formed protein complexes illustrate the potential of these novel techniques to study hitherto unobserved (and unobservable) higher-order structures of proteins.     

The importance of the compact disordered state in the fuzzy interactions between intrinsically disordered proteins

The intrinsically disordered C-terminal domain (CTD) of protein 4.1G is able to specifically bind a 26-residue intrinsically disordered region of NuMA, forming a dynamic fuzzy complex. As one of a few cases of extremely fuzzy interactions between two intrinsically disordered proteins/regions (IDPs/IDRs) without induced folding, the principle of the binding is unknown. Here, we combined experimental and computational methods to explore the detailed mechanism of the interaction between 4.1G-CTD and NuMA. MD simulations suggest that the kinetic hub states in the structure ensemble of 4.1G-CTD are favorable in the fuzzy complex. The feature of these hub states is that the binding ‘hot spot’ motifs βA and βB exhibit β strand propensities and are well packed to each other. The binding between 4.1G-CTD and NuMA is disrupted at low pH, which changes the intramolecular packing of 4.1G-CTD and weakens the packing between βA and βB motifs. Low pH conditions also lead to increased hydrodynamic radius and acceleration of backbone dynamics of 4.1G-CTD. All these results underscore the importance of tertiary structural arrangements and overall compactness of 4.1G-CTD in its binding to NuMA, i.e. the compact disordered state of 4.1G-CTD is crucial for binding. Different from the short linear motifs (SLiMs) that are often found to mediate IDP interactions, 4.1G-CTD functions as an intrinsically disordered domain (IDD), which is a functional and structural unit similar to conventional protein domains. This work sheds light on the molecular recognition mechanism of IDPs/IDRs and expands the conventional structure-function paradigm in protein biochemistry.

Tertiary structural arrangements and overall compactness is important for interactions between IDPs.     

Disorder-to-order transition of an intrinsically disordered region of sortase revealed by multiscale enhanced sampling

Molecular functions of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) or intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs), such as molecular recognition and cellular signaling, are ascribed to dynamic changes in the conformational space in response to binding of target molecules. Sortase, a transpeptitase in Gram-positive bacteria, has an IDR in a loop which undergoes a disordered-to-ordered transition (called "disordered loop"), accompanying a tilt of another loop ("dynamic loop"), upon binding of a signal peptide and a calcium ion. In this study, all-atom conformational ensembles of sortase were calculated for the four different binding states (with/without the peptide and with/without a calcium ion) by the multiscale enhanced sampling (MSES) simulation to examine how the binding of the peptide and/or calcium influences the conformational ensemble. The MSES is a multiscale and multicopy simulation method that allows an enhanced sampling of the all-atom model of large proteins including explicit solvent. A 100 ns MSES simulation of the ligand-free sortase using 20 replicas (in total 2 μs) demonstrated large flexibility in both the disordered and dynamic loops; however, their distributions were not random but had a clear preference which populates the N-terminal part of the disordered loop near the bound form. The MSES simulations of the three binding states clarified the allosteric mechanism of sortase: the N- and C-terminal parts of the disordered loop undergo a disorder-to-order transition independently of each other upon binding of the peptide and a calcium ion, respectively; however, upon binding of both ligands, the two parts work cooperatively to stabilize the bound peptide.     

The Dynamic Multisite Interactions between Two Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Protein interactions involving intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) comprise a variety of binding modes, from the well‐characterized folding upon binding to dynamic fuzzy complexes. To date, most studies concern the binding of an IDP to a structured protein, while the interaction between two IDPs is poorly understood. In this study, NMR, smFRET, and molecular dynamics (MD) simulation are combined to characterize the interaction between two IDPs, the C‐terminal domain (CTD) of protein 4.1G and the nuclear mitotic apparatus (NuMA) protein. It is revealed that CTD and NuMA form a fuzzy complex with remaining structural disorder. Multiple binding sites on both proteins were identified by molecular dynamics and mutagenesis studies. This study provides an atomic scenario in which two IDPs bearing multiple binding sites interact with each other in dynamic equilibrium. The combined approach employed here could be widely applicable for investigating IDPs and their dynamic interactions.     

The Binding Mode of a Tau Peptide with Tubulin

The microtubule‐associated protein Tau promotes the polymerization of tubulin and modulates the function of microtubules. As a consequence of the dynamic nature of the Tau–tubulin interaction, the structural basis of this complex has remained largely elusive. By using NMR methods optimized for ligand–receptor interactions in combination with site‐directed mutagenesis we demonstrate that the flanking domain downstream of the four microtubule‐binding repeats of Tau binds competitively to a site on the α‐tubulin surface. The binding process is complex, involves partial coupling of different interacting regions, and is modulated by phosphorylation at Y394 and S396. This study strengthens the hypothesis of an intimate relationship between Tau phosphorylation and tubulin binding and highlights the power of the INPHARMA NMR method to characterize the interaction of peptides derived from intrinsically disordered proteins with their molecular partners.     

Characterisation by immobilised metal ion affinity chromatographic procedures of the binding behaviour of several synthetic peptides designed to have high affinity for Cu(II) ions.

In this investigation, several peptides containing an increasing number of histidine residues have been designed and synthesised. The peptides involved repeat units of either the pentameric EAEHA or the tetrameric HLLH sequence motifs. Adsorption isotherms for these synthetic peptides and hexahistidine (hexa-His) as a control substance were measured under batch equilibrium binding conditions with an immobilised Cu(II)-iminodiacetic acid (IDA) sorbent. The experimental data were analysed in terms of Langmuirean binding behaviour. In common with previous studies with synthetic peptides, these investigations have demonstrate that the sequential organisation of the histidine side chains in these peptides can affect the selectivity of the coordination interactions with borderline metal ions in immobilised metal ion affinity chromatographic systems. The results also confirm that peptides selected on the basis of their potential to form amphipathic secondary structures with their histidine residues presented on one face of the molecule can exhibit equivalent or higher affinity constants towards copper ions than hexa-His, although they contain fewer histidine residues. These findings are thus relevant to the selection of peptides produced inter alia by combinatorial synthetic procedures to have enhanced binding properties for Cu(II) or Ni(II) ions, or intended for use as peptide tags in the fusion handle approach for the affinity chromatographic purification of recombinant proteins.     

Long-range modulation of chain motions within the intrinsically disordered transactivation domain of tumor suppressor p53

The tumor suppressor p53 is a hub protein with a multitude of binding partners, many of which target its intrinsically disordered N-terminal domain, p53-TAD. Partners, such as the N-terminal domain of MDM2, induce formation of local structure and leave the remainder of the domain apparently disordered. We investigated segmental chain motions in p53-TAD using fluorescence quenching of an extrinsic label by tryptophan in combination with fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (PET-FCS). We studied the loop closure kinetics of four consecutive segments within p53-TAD and their response to protein binding and phosphorylation. The kinetics was multiexponential, showing that the conformational ensemble of the domain deviates from random coil, in agreement with previous findings from NMR spectroscopy. Phosphorylations or binding of MDM2 changed the pattern of intrachain kinetics. Unexpectedly, we found that upon binding and phosphorylation chain motions were altered not only within the targeted segments but also in remote regions. Long-range interactions can be induced in an intrinsically disordered domain by partner proteins that induce apparently only local structure or by post-translational modification.     

Folding of a salivary intrinsically disordered protein upon binding to tannins

We used ion mobility spectrometry to explore conformational adaptability of intrinsically disordered proteins bound to their targets in complex mixtures. We investigated the interactions between a human salivary proline-rich protein IB5 and a model of wine and tea tannin: epigallocatechin gallate (EgCG). Collisional cross sections of naked IB5 and IB5 complexed with N = 1-15 tannins were recorded. The data demonstrate that IB5 undergoes an unfolded to folded structural transition upon binding with EgCG.     

Structural impact of proline-directed pseudophosphorylation at AT8, AT100, and PHF1 epitopes on 441-residue tau

The intrinsically disordered protein tau becomes excessively phosphorylated and aggregates into neurofibrillary tangles in Alzheimer's disease. To obtain insight into the structural consequences of phosphorylation, we characterized a mutant protein of tau in which epitopes recognized by Alzheimer diagnostic antibodies were mimicked by mutation to glutamic acid [AT8 (S199E, S202E, T205E), AT100 (T212E and S214E), and PHF1 (S396E and S404E)]. A large number of distance restraints obtained from NMR paramagnetic relaxation enhancement in combination with ensemble conformer calculations demonstrate that pseudophosphorylation causes an opening of the transient folding of tau. Together with previous studies on the Parkinson-related protein α-synuclein, our data indicate that networks of transient long-range interactions are common properties of intrinsically disordered proteins and that their modulation is important for aggregation.     

Why does the silica-binding protein “Si-tag” bind strongly to silica surfaces? Implications of conformational adaptation of the intrinsically disordered polypeptide to solid surfaces

We recently reported that the bacterial 50S ribosomal protein L2 binds strongly to silica surfaces even in the presence of high salt concentrations, detergents, and denaturants such as 8 M urea. We designated L2 as Si-tag, a fusion tag for immobilizing functional proteins on silica materials. Here we discuss the remarkable properties of the Si-tag polypeptide in order to understand the mechanism underlying this binding. Experimental and theoretical studies have shown that the 60-aa N-terminal region and the 71-aa C-terminal region, both of which are rich in positively charged residues, lack a well-defined three-dimensional structure under physiological conditions. This lack of a stable tertiary structure suggests that Si-tag belongs to a family of intrinsically disordered (ID) proteins that exist as dynamic ensembles of rapidly fluctuating structures in aqueous solution. Because of its inherent flexibility, Si-tag could form a large intermolecular interface and optimize its structure for surface interactions by conformational adaptation at the binding interface. Such conformational adaptation occurring concomitantly with binding is common to many ID proteins and is called "coupled folding and binding". Through this conformational adaptation, Si-tag could optimize the interactions between its positively charged side chains and ionized surface silanol groups and between its apolar side chains and hydrophobic surface siloxane sites. The cumulative contribution of these contacts would significantly strengthen the binding of Si-tag, resulting in strong, virtually irreversible binding. Our study suggests that flexible ID proteins have tremendous potential for connecting biomolecules to inorganic materials.     

Selection of Secondary Structures of Heterotypic Supramolecular Peptide Assemblies by an Enzymatic Reaction

In a model study to investigate the consequence of reactions of intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) of proteins in the context of the formation of highly ordered structures, we found that enzymatic reactions control the secondary structures of peptides during assembly. Specifically, phosphorylation of an α‐helix‐dominant peptide results in mostly disordered conformations, which become β‐strand‐dominant after enzymatic dephosphorylation to regenerate the peptide. In the presence of another peptide largely with a β‐strand conformation, direct coassembly of the peptides results in amorphous aggregates consisting of α‐helix and β‐strand peptides, but the enzymatically generated peptide coassemblies (from the phosphopeptide) mainly adopt a β‐strand conformation and form ordered structures (e.g., nanofibers). These results indicate that enzymatic dephosphorylation instructs conformationally flexible peptides to adopt thermodynamically favorable conformations in homotypic or heterotypic supramolecular assemblies.