Calibration-Free Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy: State of the art

The aim of this paper is offering a critical review of Calibration-Free Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (CF-LIBS), the approach of multi-elemental quantitative analysis of LIBS spectra, based on the measurement of line intensities and plasma properties (plasma electron density and temperature) and on the assumption of a Boltzmann population of excited levels, which does not require the use of calibration curves or matrix-matched standards. The first part of this review focuses on the applications of the CF-LIBS method. Quantitative results reported in the literature, obtained in the analysis of various materials and in a wide range of experimental conditions, are summarized, with a special emphasis on the departure from nominal composition values. The second part is a discussion of the simplifying assumptions which lie at the basis of the CF-LIBS algorithm (stoichiometric ablation and complete atomization, thermal equilibrium, homogeneous plasma, thin radiation, detection of all elements). The inspection of the literature suggests that the CF-LIBS method is more accurate in analyzing metallic alloys rather than dielectrics. However, the full exploitation of the method seems to be still far to come, especially for the lack of a complete characterization of the effects of experimental constraints. However, some general directions can be suggested to help the analyst in designing LIBS measurements in a way which is more suited for CF-LIBS analysis.     

Fast analysis of complex metallic alloys by double-pulse time-integrated Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy

Results are reported on the application of double-pulse Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) for fast analysis of complex metallic alloys. The approach followed for the determination of the composition of the alloys is based on the time-integrated acquisition of LIBS spectra emitted by plasmas induced by collinear double-pulse laser excitation. The spectra are analysed using the Partial Least Squares method, which allows the determination of sample composition even in the presence of strong spectral interferences. The results shown indicate the possibility of measuring the composition of complex metallic alloys in very short times and using relatively cheap LIBS instrumentation.     

基于黑体辐射提高自由定标激光诱导击穿光谱(CF-LIBS)定量精度的方法

自由定标激光诱导击穿光谱(Calibration-Free LIBS,CF-LIBS)技术是定量分析行业发展的主要趋势之一。该技术可直接基于局部热力学平衡等离子体模型,通过LIBS光谱数据和谱线参数计算出等离子体参数和各元素含量。且无需使用标准样品建立定标曲线,该技术不受基体效应的影响,非常适合实时、在线和多元素同时分析。但由光学厚而引起的自吸收效应是影响定量分析的重要因素。通过对比实验光谱数据与黑体辐射强度,研究等离子体温度,提高光学系统收集效率,抑制自吸收效应对CF-LIBS定量结果的影响。经过黑体辐射校正后,基体元素Fe的测定含量从88.700%提升到94.575%,相对误差(RE)从8.072%降低到1.984%。微量元素Cr、Mo和V的测定含量分别从0.635%、0.096%和0.023%降低至0.698%、0.143%和0.022%,相对误差(RE)从13.723%、45.455%和21.053%降低至5.163%、18.75%和15.789%。整体的平均绝对误差(MAE)从1.994%降低至0.497%。玻尔兹曼图拟合回归曲线有了更高的线性度。拟合系数R²     

Application of calibration-free laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy to radially resolved spectra from a copper-based alloy laser-induced plasma

In this work, the Calibration-Free approach for Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (CF-LIBS) was applied for the first time to radially resolved spectra emitted by a laser-induced plasma. The radial profiles of plasma temperature and electron number density were used to calculate the local relative concentration of the elements of interest. We analyzed a set of profiles of the local spectral emission coefficient obtained previously by means of spatial deconvolution of the spectra from a copper-based alloy (Cu 93, Fe 5, Mn 1, Ni 1 wt.%) laser-induced plasma. A spatially integrated spectrum of the same plasma was also analyzed for comparison purpose. The relative abundance of the minor components Fe, Mn and Ni was calculated. The results obtained from the central region of the plasma were closer to the nominal concentrations than those obtained from the spatially integrated spectrum. However, an increasing deviation was observed towards the plasma edge. It is proposed that this deviation could be the result of a gradual departure from Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (LTE) conditions due the significant decrease of the electron density at the external shells of the plasma.     

On-line determination of nanometric and sub-micrometric particle physicochemical characteristics using spectral imaging-aided Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy coupled with a Scanning Mobility Particle Sizer

Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy has been employed to detect sodium chloride and metallic particles with sizes ranging from 40 nm up to 1 µm produced by two different particle generators. The Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy technique combined with a Scanning Mobility Particle Sizer was evaluated as a potential candidate for workplace surveillance in industries producing nanoparticle-based materials. Though research is still currently under way to secure nanoparticle production processes, the risk of accidental release is not to be neglected. Consequently, there is an urgent need for the manufacturers to have at their command a tool enabling leak detection in-situ and in real time so as to protect workers from potential exposure.In this context, experiments dedicated to laser-induced plasma particle interaction were performed. To begin with, spectral images of the laser-induced plasma vaporizing particles were recorded to visualize the spatio-temporal evolution of the atomized matter and to infer the best recording parameters for Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy analytical purposes, taking into account our experimental set-up specificity. Then, on this basis, time-resolved spectroscopic measurements were performed to make a first assumption of the Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy potentialities. Particle size dependency on the LIBS signal was examined. Repeatability and limits of detection were assessed and discussed. All the experiments carried out with low particle concentrations point out the high time delays corresponding to the Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy signal emergence. Plasma temperature temporal evolution was found to be a key parameter to explain this peculiarity inherent to laser/plasma/particle interaction.     

Comparative study of different methodologies for quantitative rock analysis by Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy in a simulated Martian atmosphere

Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy was selected by NASA as part of the ChemCam instrument package for the Mars Science Laboratory rover to be launched in 2009. ChemCam's Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy instrument will ablate surface coatings from materials and measure the elemental composition of underlying rocks and soils at distances from 1 up to 10 m. The purpose of our studies is to develop an analytical methodology enabling identification and quantitative analysis of these geological materials in the context of the ChemCam's Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy instrument performance. The study presented here focuses on several terrestrial rock samples which were analyzed by Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy at an intermediate stand-off distance (3 m) and in an atmosphere similar to the Martian one (9 mbar CO₂). The experimental results highlight the matrix effects and the measurement inaccuracies due to the noise accumulated when low signals are collected with a detector system such as an Echelle spectrometer equipped with an Intensified Charge-Coupled Device camera. Three different methods are evaluated to correct the matrix effects and to obtain quantitative results: by using an external reference sample and normalizing to the sum of all elemental concentrations, by using the internal standardization by oxygen, a major element common to all studied matrices, and by applying the Calibration Free Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy method. The three tested methods clearly demonstrate that the matrix effects can be corrected merely by taking into account the difference in the amount of vaporized atoms between the rocks, no significant variation in plasma excitation temperatures being observed. The encouraging results obtained by the three methods indicate the possibility of meeting ChemCam project objectives for stand-off quantitative analysis on Mars.     

Spatial distribution of hydrogen and other emitters in aluminum laser-induced plasma in air and consequences on spatially integrated Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy measurements

The Stark broadening of hydrogen Balmer α line is often measured in Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) to evaluate the electron number density of the plasma. When measurements are carried out in air, hydrogen atoms are supposedly supplied by the atmosphere. This hypothesis casts some doubts on the validity of hydrogen as an indicator of the conditions in the inner part of the plasma. In this experiment, we acquired spectrally resolved images of a Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy plasma generated in air on an aluminum target by irradiation with the Nd:YAG fundamental emission. The evolution of the plasma was studied by acquiring images at several delay times. In particular, we imaged the spatial distribution of plasma emitters along the direction orthogonal to the target surface. The spatial distribution of hydrogen emission was compared to the one of the species ablated from the sample. Moreover, electron density and temperature were evaluated in the time- and space-resolved spectra extracted from the images, obtaining thus a picture of the propagation and internal structure of the plasma. The fluid dynamics implications of the plasma expansion were discussed. The z-resolved characterization was compared with the picture of the plasma obtained by processing space-integrated spectra.     

LIBS结合图像筛选方法提高钢铁中Cu、Cr、Mn元素检测稳定性研究

优质特种钢材和低端粗钢之间的性能差异主要受其构成元素种类及其成分含量的影响,因此,如何快速准确地对物质成分进行定性及定量分析对钢铁产品的质量评估至关重要。针对传统方法难以实现对钢铁合金成分的快速准确检测的难题,采用激光诱导击穿光谱(LIBS)结合等离子体图像信息的方法,通过快速地对不同元素的特征光谱强度与激发生成的等离子体图像进行采集,分析两者之间的相关性,并通过提取的图像特征信息的异常值剔除了部分无效光谱数据,进而实现了对钢铁成分的高精度分析。通过分析延迟时间和激光能量等不同实验条件对元素特征光谱强度及其对应等离子体图像的影响规律,不仅证明了等离子体图像与光谱之间存在相关性,还利用等离子体图像特征信息的局部最优值确定了最优延迟时间、激光能量分别为1 000 ns与50 mJ,并根据图像特征的平均阈值来筛选无效光谱数据。结果表明,图像筛选优化数据后,各元素谱线校准模型的决定系数(R²)分别从原始数据的0.978、0.986、0.957、0.935提升至0.995、0.997、0.968、0.957,且其定标曲线对未知样品元素的预测浓度相对标准偏差(RSD)下降为原...     

Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy for Mars surface analysis: capabilities at stand-off distances and detection of chlorine and sulfur elements

An international consortium is studying the feasibility of performing in situ geochemical analysis of Mars soils and rocks at stand-off distances up to several meters using the Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) technique. Stand-off analysis for Martian exploration imposes particular requirements on instrumentation, and it is necessary to first test the performance of such a system in the laboratory. In this paper, we test the capabilities of two different experimental setups. The first one is dedicated to the qualitative analysis of metals and rocks at distances between 3 and 12 m. With the second one, we have obtained quantitative results for aluminum alloys and developed a spectral database under Martian conditions for sulfur and chlorine, two elements that are geologically interesting but generally difficult to detect by LIBS under standard conditions (atmospheric pressure, close distance). These studies were carried out to determine an optimal instrumental design for in situ Mars analysis. The quality of analytical results affected by the optical elements and spectrometer has been particularly highlighted.     

Multi-elemental analysis of solidified mineral melt samples by Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy coupled with a linear multivariate calibration

Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) has been successfully applied for multi-elemental analysis of solidified mineral melt samples containing several oxides present in various concentrations. The plasma was generated using a Nd:YAG laser and the spectra were acquired using an Echelle spectrometer, coupled to an ICCD detector, which covers a spectral range from 200 to 780 nm. Using a set of 19 calibration samples, we first established univariate calibration curves for the major elements (Al, Fe, Mg, Ca, Ti and Si). We found out that the presence of matrix effects makes such a model, traditionally used in LIBS, not satisfying for quantitative analysis of such samples. Indeed, no sufficiently linear trends can be extracted from the calibration curves for the elements of interest considering all the samples. Instead, a much more robust calibration approach was obtained by considering a multivariate model. The matrix effects are then taken into account by correcting the spectroscopic signals emitted by a given species due the presence of the others ones. More specifically, we established here a calibration model using a 2nd order polynomial linear multivariate inverse regression. The capability of this approach was then checked using a 2nd set of samples with an unknown composition. A good agreement was observed between the analysis provided by X-ray fluorescence (XRF) and the LIBS measurements coupled to the multivariate model for the unknown samples.     

In situ study of the Porticello Bronzes by portable X-ray fluorescence and laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy

This paper reports the results of a measurement campaign performed at the National Museum of Magna Grecia in Reggio Calabria (Italy). Portable X-Ray Fluorescence (XRF) and Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) instrumentation allowed in situ analysis of several bronze pieces belonging to the group of the so-called Porticello Bronzes. The find occurred at sea, off the village of Porticello (Reggio Calabria) in 1969 and consists of a number of fragments, including a bearded head, pertaining to at least two statues. The use of X-Ray Fluorescence and Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy techniques allowed for a classification of the fragments according to their elemental composition. The fragments appear to belong to at least two different statues; although, in general, the compositional classification agrees well with the stylistic analysis of the fragments, significant improvements with respect to previous achievements emerge from the joint results of the two techniques used.     

Application of Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectrometry for analysis of environmental and industrial materials

Actual state of affairs, main advantages and problems of Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) in analysis of industrial materials and environmental samples are discussed. Methods for LIBS sensitivity enhancement such as double-pulse ablation, a combination of LIBS with laser-induced fluorescence, the use of additional sources of excitation (spark) and confinement of plasma by magnetic field or shock wave are compared with respect to figures-of-merit. A set of LIBS approach to qualitative fast classification of materials, especially based on the correlation between parameters of laser plasma and sample properties, are discussed in details. Progress in environmental analysis of soils, sands etc. with the use of LIBS is demonstrated. Detection limits of the most elements in soils and aluminum alloys obtained until now are critically considered.     

Calculation of self-absorption coefficients of calcium resonance lines in the case of a CaCl2–water plasma

The resonance escape factors for the lines emitted by a neutral calcium atom Ca I at 4226.73 Å and of ionic calcium Ca II at 3933.66 Å and at 3968.47 Å are calculated assuming a Voigt profile and in the case of CaCl₂–water plasma. The dependence of the escape factor on the optical thickness ?₀ from the line center which itself depends on the two main spectral line shape broadening mechanisms (pressure and Doppler effects) are considered. The variation of the resonance escape factors with the temperature, the CaCl₂ molar proportion and the size of the plasma are also investigated. This calculation is useful for the application of Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy in the quantitative analysis of elemental composition. Its application allows us to reduce the non-linearities in the relation between resonance lines intensities of calcium in our case and its concentration.     

Recognition of archeological materials underwater by laser induced breakdown spectroscopy

The detection of different materials immersed in seawater has been studied by means of Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy. The plasma emission was produced by a Q-Switched Nd:YAG laser operated at 1064 nm in a dual pulse mode. Different classes of materials potentially found in the undersea archaeological parks, such as iron, copper-based alloys, precious alloys, marble and wood have been examined. Data acquisition and processing were optimized for better signal control and in order to improve the detection threshold. In all the examined cases but wood, qualitative analysis was successful and allowed for the material recognition. The spectral features necessary to clearly distinguish marble materials from calcareous rocks have been also established. It was found that these characteristic spectral intervals could be also used for the recognition of sedimentary layers deposited on the underwater findings. Quantitative chemical analysis was also performed on submerged bronze samples, after generating calibration curves with standards of similar matrix composition.     

Methodologies for laboratory Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy semi-quantitative and quantitative analysis—A review

Since its early applications, Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy has been recognized as a useful tool for solid state chemical analysis. However the quantitative accuracy of the technique depends on the complex processes involved in laser induced plasma formation, ablation, atomization, excitation and ion recombination. Problems arising from laser target coupling, matrix effect, fractionation in target vaporization, local thermodynamic equilibrium assumption and interferences from additional air ionization should be properly addressed in order to obtain reliable quantitative results in laboratory to be used as starting point during field campaigns.     

Laser induced breakdown spectroscopy on meteorites

The classification of meteorites when geological analysis is unfeasible is generally made by the spectral line emission ratio of some characteristic elements. Indeed when a meteorite impacts Earth's atmosphere, hot plasma is generated, as a consequence of the braking effect of air, with the consequent ablation of the falling body. Usually, by the plasma emission spectrum, the meteorite composition is determined, assuming the Boltzmann equilibrium. The plasma generated during Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) experiment shows similar characteristics and allows one to verify the mentioned method with higher accuracy. On the other hand the study of Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy on meteorite can be useful for both improving meteorite classification methods and developing on-flight techniques for asteroid investigation.

In this paper certified meteorites belonging to different typologies have been investigated by LIBS: Dofhar 461 (lunar meteorite), Chondrite L6 (stony meteorite), Dofhar 019 (Mars meteorite) and Sikhote Alin (irony meteorite).     

Influence of particle size and mineral phase in the analysis of iron ore slurries by Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy

Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) was applied to the analysis of iron ore concentrates. The objective was to determine the influence of particle size and mineral phase on the LIBS signal. The LIBS spectra of hematite and magnetite ore concentrates were qualitatively indistinguishable from each other but magnetite yielded systematically less than hematite. This behavior could be set into an empirical equation to correct the iron peak intensities according to the level of magnetite in the analyzed sample. Similarly, an increase of the LIBS signal was observed as the particle size of the ore samples decreased. Again, an equation could be written down to correct the intensity of either iron or silicon in response to a variation of the average particle size of the ore concentrate. Using these corrections, proper response of the silicon signal against the concentration of silica in the samples was restored. The observed dependence of the strength of the iron signal upon the mineral phase is attributed to oxidation of magnetite into hematite.     

Analytical optimization of some parameters of a Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy experiment

Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) experiments are performed on standard metallic samples, in air at atmospheric pressure, using a Nd:YAG laser at 1064 nm and a fiber located close to the plasma to collect its emission. This configuration is chosen because it is representative of many LIBS setups. The influence of several experimental parameters is studied in order to optimize the analytical performances: signal-to-background ratio (SBR), line intensity and repeatability. Temporal parameters of the detector are adjusted for each measurement to maximize the SBR. The signal is found to linearly depend on the pulse energy over our range of investigation. This behavior is related to the increase of the number of vaporized atoms when the pulse energy increases. Complementary measurements of plasma dimensions support our conclusions. We show the existence of an optimum fluence on the sample that gives the highest signal and the lowest relative standard deviation (RSD), and which does not depend on the pulse energy. Finally we demonstrate that ablation is much more efficient using a laser beam with a high numerical aperture, other experimental parameters being unchanged, because of a less pronounced laser shielding by the plasma. Analytical consequences of this result are discussed.     

Real time measurement of the electron density of a laser generated plasma using a RC circuit

A Nd:YAG laser pulse was focused, in air or on a Cu target, between the plates of a planar charged capacitor. The plasma generates a transient redistribution of the electrical charges on the plates that can be easily measured as a voltage drop across a resistor connected to the ground plate. At the same time, the Stark broadening of the H_α spectral line (656.3 nm) obtained from the optical emission spectrum of the plasma was measured. In this work, we show that the peak of electrical signal measured on the resistor is, in the energy range of our laser (30 mJ to 220 mJ) and at time delays typical of Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy applications (500–5000 ns), univocally related to the temporal evolution of the Stark broadening of the H_α line. Therefore, after a proper calibration depending on the material and the experimental geometry, the peak of the electrical signal can be used to predict the temporal evolution of the electron density of the generated plasma.     

Comparison of 1064 nm and 266 nm excitation of laser-induced plasmas for several types of plastics and one explosive

Comparative measurements of Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) for ultraviolet (UV) and near infrared (NIR) excitation wavelengths on a wide range of plastics and one kind of explosive are presented. The focus of work is on the influence of laser wavelength on the Signal-to-peak to peak noise ratio (SPPNR) for selected emission lines as well as the plasma thresholds for NIR and UV excitation wavelengths. The merits of both excitation wavelengths are discussed with respect to the detection of explosives.