Effect of extra-column volume on practical chromatographic parameters of sub-2-μm particle-packed columns in ultra-high pressure liquid chromatography

Effects of extra-column volume on apparent separation parameters were studied in ultra-high pressure liquid chromatography with columns and inlet connection tubings of various internal diameters (id) using 50-mm long columns packed with 1.8-μm particles under isocratic conditions. The results showed that apparent retention factors were on average 5, 11, 18, and 41% lower than those corrected with extra-column volumes for 4.6-, 3.0-, 2.1-, and 1.0-mm id columns, respectively, when the extra-column volume (11.3 μL) was kept constant. Also, apparent pressures were 31, 16, 12, and 10% higher than those corrected with pressures from extra-column volumes for 4.6-, 3.0-, 2.1-, and 1.0-mm id columns at the respective optimum flow rate for a typical ultra-high pressure liquid chromatography system. The loss in apparent efficiency increased dramatically from 4.6- to 3.0- to 2.1- to 1.0-mm id columns, less significantly as retention factors increased. The column efficiency was significantly improved as the inlet tubing id was decreased for a given column. The results suggest that maximum ratio of extra-column volume to column void volume should be approximately 1:10 for column porosity more than 0.6 and a retention factor more than 5, where 80% or higher of theoretically predicted efficiency could be achieved.     

Effect of mobile phase density gradients on efficiency in packed column supercritical fluid chromatography

Summary The efficiency of packed columns was measured as a function of flow rate, temperature, outlet density, and the density differential across the column, unsing pure carbon dioxide as the mobile phase. Although density differentials are often blamed for a serious loss in efficiency in packed column supercritical fluid chromatography, the results show that efficiency was not a function of the density differential. Peak shapes suggest that apparent loss in efficiency is actually due to inadequate solubility of the solute in carbon dioxide.     

Repeatability and reproducibility of retention data and band profiles on six batches of monolithic columns

Chromatographic data were acquired for eight different mixtures, under five different sets of experimental conditions, for a total of 30 neutral, acidic and basic test compounds, on a series of six Chromolith Performance columns from Merck. These columns are made of a C₁₈ chemically bonded silica monolith. Each column belonged to a different production batch, so the data reported here characterize their batch-to-batch reproducibility. The parameters studied in this work were the retention times, the retention and separation factors, the hydrophobic and the steric selectivities, the column efficiencies, and the tailing factors for all 30 compounds.     

Supercritical fluid chromatography of metoprolol and analogues on aminopropyl and ethylpyridine silica without any additives

Metoprolol and a number of related amino alcohols and similar analytes have been chromatographed on aminopropyl (APS) and ethylpyridine (EPS) silica columns. The mobile phase was carbon dioxide with methanol as modifier and no amine additive was present. Optimal isocratic conditions for the selectivity were evaluated based on experiments using design of experiments. A central composite circumscribed model for each column was used. Factors were column temperature, back-pressure and % (v/v) of modifier. The responses were retention and selectivity versus metoprolol. The % of modifier mainly controlled the retention on both columns but pressure and temperature could also be important for optimizing the selectivity between the amino alcohols. The compounds could be divided into four and five groups on both columns, with respect to the selectivity. Furthermore, on the aminopropyl silica the analytes were more spread out whereas on the ethylpyridine silica, due to its aromaticity, retention and selectivity were closer. For optimal conditions the column temperature and back-pressure should be high and the modifier concentration low. A comparison of the selectivity using optimized conditions show a few switches of retention order between the two columns. On aminopropyl silica an aldehyde failed to be eluted owing to Schiff-base formation. Peak symmetry and column efficiency were briefly studied for some structurally close analogues. This revealed some activity from the columns that affected analytes that had less protected amino groups, a methyl group instead of isopropyl. The tailing was more marked with the ethylpyridine column even with the more bulky alkyl substituents. Plate number N was a better measure than the asymmetry factor since some analyte peaks broadened without serious deterioration of symmetry compared to homologues.     

Dual column gas chromatographic system for use in mass spectral determination of nitrosamines.

A packed gas chromatographic column and a support coated open tubular (SCOT) column are connected in series. Between the columns are two micro-volume switching valves, one enabling solvent to be vented. Short retention nitrosamines are passed through both columns, whereas longer retention nitrosamines by-pass the SCOT column by means of the other switching valve.     

Modeling of thermal processes in high pressure liquid chromatography: I. Low pressure onset of thermal heterogeneity

Heat due to viscous friction is generated in chromatographic columns. When these columns are operated at high flow rates, under a high inlet pressure, this heat causes the formation of significant axial and radial temperature gradients. Consequently, these columns become heterogeneous and several physico-chemical parameters, including the retention factors and the parameters of the mass transfer kinetics of analytes are no longer constant along and across the columns. A robust modeling of the distributions of the physico-chemical parameters allows the analysis of the impact of the heat generated on column performance. We developed a new model of the coupled heat and mass transfers in chromatographic columns, calculated the axial and radial temperature distributions in a column, and derived the distributions of the viscosity and the density of the mobile phase, hence of the axial and radial mobile phase velocities. The coupling of the mass and the heat balances in chromatographic columns was used to model the migration of a compound band under linear conditions. This process yielded the elution band profiles of analytes, hence the column efficiency under two different sets of experimental conditions: (1) the column is operated under natural convection conditions; (2) the column is dipped in a stream of thermostated fluid. The calculated results show that the column efficiency is remarkably lower in the second than in the first case. The inconvenience of maintaining constant the temperature of the column wall (case 2) is that retention factors and mobile phase velocities vary much more significantly across the column than if the column is kept under natural convection conditions (case 1).     

Repeatability and reproducibility of retention data and band profiles on reversed-phase liquid chromatography columns. V. Results obtained with Vydac 218TP C18 columns

The general goal of this work is to investigate the precision of chromatographic data and to determine which properties of chromatographic columns influence this factor. Chromatographic data were acquired under five different sets of experimental conditions for 30 neutral, acidic and basic test compounds on columns packed with Vydac 218TP C18, a polymeric, wide-pore silica-based stationary phase. Five columns packed with samples from the same batch of this packing material were used to measure the column-to-column reproducibility and six columns packed with material from six different batches to measure the batch-to-batch reproducibility. The parameters studied were the retention time, the retention and separation factors, the hydrophobic and the steric selectivities, the column efficiency, and the tailing factor.     

Repeatability and reproducibility of retention data and band profiles on reversed-phase liquid chromatography columns. III. Results obtained with Kromasil C18 columns.

The reproducibility of the retention data and the band profiles was investigated with Kromasil C18 columns (silica-based monomeric type reversed-phase packing material). High precision data were obtained and statistically compared among five columns from the same batch (column-to-column reproducibility) and six columns, one from each of six different batches (batch-to-batch reproducibility). These data were acquired under five different sets of chromatographic conditions, for a group of 30 neutral, acidic and basic compounds selected as probes following an experimental protocol previously described. Data characterizing the retention time, the retention factor, the separation factor, the column efficiency and the peak asymmetry for the different probe compounds are reported. Factors describing the silica surface interaction with the selected probe compounds, such as the hydrophobic interaction selectivity, the steric selectivity, and the separation factors of basic compounds at different pH values were also determined. The influence of the underlying silica on these data and correlations between the chromatographic and physico-chemical properties of the different batches are discussed.     

Mechanism of retention loss when C8 and C18 HPLC columns are used with highly aqueous mobile phases

We describe investigations into the cause of retention losses encountered when C8 and C18 HPLC columns are used with highly aqueous (> 90% water) mobile phases. A procedure for quantifying these losses is described, involving stopping and restarting the flow. This procedure was used to study the dependence of retention loss on the pore size, surface concentration, and chemical structure of the bonded phase. Experiments were also carried out to determine how to restore the original retention of the columns by changing the composition of the mobile phase, or by increasing the pressure applied to the column. The results are shown to be consistent with a mechanism based on the theory of pore filling by non-wetting liquids, as employed in Mercury Porosimetry. The retention losses are attributed to the highly aqueous mobile phase being forced out of the pores when the flow is stopped and the pressure released. Retention is lost because the mobile phase is no longer in contact with the interior surface of the particles, where most of the surface area is located. The implications of this phenomenon for maximizing the reversed phase retention of polar analytes are discussed.     

Coupling miniaturized liquid chromatography to capillary gas chromatography (micro-LC-CGC): Possibilities of reversed phase LC

Retention gaps with different polarity treatments were evaluated for reversed phase solvents. Aminopropyl- and cyanopropyl-deactivated retention gaps showed the best results for methanol-water mixtures. A reversed phase packed fused silica capillary LC column is connected on-line with a capillary gas chromatography column. The combination was used for the analysis of diazepam in urine. Volume overloading on packed fused silica columns without loss of too much efficiency was demonstrated for propranolol.     

The impact of extra-column band broadening on the chromatographic efficiency of 5 cm long narrow-bore very efficient columns

Small columns packed with core-shell and sub-2 μm totally porous particles and monolith columns are very popular to conduct fast and efficient chromatographic separations. In order to carry out fast separations, short (2-5 cm) and narrow-bore (2-2.1 mm) columns are used to decrease the analyte retention volume. Beside the column efficiency, another significant issue is the extra-column band-spreading. The extra-column dispersion of a given LC system can dramatically decrease the performance of a small very efficient column. The aim of this study was to compare the extra-column peak variance contribution of several commercially available LC systems. The efficiency loss of three different type 5 cm long narrow bore, very efficient columns (monolith, sub-2 μm fully porous and sub-2 μm core-shell packing) as a function of extra-column peak variance, and as a function of flow rate and also kinetic plots (analysis time versus apparent column efficiency) are presented.     

Repeatability and reproducibility of retention data and band profiles on reversed-phase liquid chromatography columns: I. Experimental protocol

A procedure is described for the determination of the short-term and long-term repeatabilities and of the column-to-column and lot-to-lot reproducibilities of the retention and profile characteristics of the peaks obtained with a number of different reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) C₁₈-bonded silica columns of several commercial brands. Data characterizing the retention, the steric selectivity, the hydrogen bonding capacity, the hydrophobic interaction selectivity, the column efficiency and the peak asymmetry will be acquired for all the probe compounds. These include 30 neutral, acidic and basic compounds distributed into five groups to be eluted under as many different sets of chromatographic conditions. The data will be obtained using an HP 1100 liquid chromatograph. The compounds and experimental conditions selected were similar to those previously used by different authors for comparison purposes. Careful attention will be paid to minimization of external error contributions by adhering to a strict operational procedure. The precision expected will be high because preliminary results gave standard deviations of around 0.04% for the separation factors, below 0.15% for the retention times and around 1% for the column efficiency in short-term repeatability experiments performed with one column.     

Elution behavior for a large sample size of uranyl ions on reversed-phase columns using alpha-hydroxyisobutyric acid as an eluent

Large sample sizes of uranyl ions are eluted on a strenedivinylbenzene copolymer phase and an octadecyl phase column, respectively, using alpha-hydroxyisobutyric acid (alpha-HiBA) as an eluent. Chromatograms are obtained from variations of the uranyl sample amounts, eluent concentrations, concentrations of the sample matrix, and the pH of the sample solution for both columns, respectively. Column capacities are estimated from the loading factors measured from the retention times of the peaks. Bandwidths of the peaks and apparent column efficiencies are measured as a function of the loading factor and calculated using the equations derived from the assumptions of a Langmuir isotherm for a single solute. Comparison between the experiment and the calculation reveals that the former showed a broader bandwidth and worse column efficiency than the latter for both columns. The two columns are compared with regards to the retention time, peak shape, column capacity, column efficiency, etc. The PRP-1 column shows a rectangular-, triangle-type peak shape, longer retention time, lower column capacity, and better column efficiency, and the LC-18 column shows a distorted Gaussian curve, shorter retention time, higher column capacity, and worse column efficiency. Column capacity, peak shape, and retention time are dependent on the eluent concentration rather than the alpha-HiBA concentration in the sample solutions.     

Behavior of packing materials in axially compressed chromatographic columns

The behavior of a packing material (Luna C18 from Phenomenex, Torrance, CA, USA) was studied during the consolidation of a column bed under axial compression stress. The kinetics of this consolidation, the permeability and efficiency of the columns obtained, and the reproducibility of these column properties were measured under different conditions. The consolidation process and the column properties are considerably affected by the friction between the packing material in the bed and the column wall. Clear evidence of this wall effect was demonstrated. The apparent permeability of columns consolidated under the same axial stress increases with increasing column length. The apparent modulus of elasticity of the beds increases with increasing column length. The shear resistance between the packed bed and the column wall was measured for columns of different lengths. It increases rapidly with increasing bed length. The column efficiency for thiourea (unretained) and phenyloctane (retention factor, k' approximately 1) was much poorer after recompression than after the first compression. It depended little on the compression stress. The effect of the column length was small.     

Stability of surfactant coated columns for ion chromatography

Ionic surfactant coatings are a popular means to convert reversed-phase columns into ion-exchange phases with adjustable ion-exchange capacity and selectivity. However, the perceived lack of stability of surfactant coatings has hindered their use for routine separations. Coating conditions (acetonitrile content, ionic strength, surfactant concentration and temperature) were varied to determine their effect on coating stability. Under all coating conditions, cetyltrimethylammonium (CTAB) coated columns exhibited an initial decrease in ion retention. However, after the initial 1 L flush, both retention times and efficiency remained stable for >or=3000 column volumes. Greatest column stability and control of column capacity are achieved if the surfactant in the coating solution is below its critical micelle concentration.     

Influence of frictional heating on temperature gradients in ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography on 2.1mm I.D. columns

The effects of viscous heat dissipation on some important HPLC parameters, such as efficiency (N) and retention factors (k), using 2.1mm columns at pressures up to 1000 bar have been investigated from both a theoretical and experimental point of view. Two distinct experimental set-ups and their respective influences on non-homogenous temperature gradients within the column are described and discussed. In the first instance, a still-air column heater was used. This set-up leads to approximate 'adiabatic' conditions, and a longitudinal temperature gradient is predicted across the length of the column. The magnitude of this gradient is calculated, and its occurrence confirmed with experimental measurements also indicating that no appreciable loss in efficiency occurs. Secondly, when a water bath is used to thermostat the column, a radial temperature gradient is prevalent. The extent of this gradient is estimated, and the loss in efficiency associated with this gradient is predicted and demonstrated experimentally. It is also observed that approximate adiabatic conditions can lead to floating retention factors. The implications of temperature gradients for routine HPLC analysis at ultra-high pressure are discussed.     

Thermally-treated clay as a stationary phase in liquid chromatography

Spray-dried, spherical synthetic hectorite particles have been thermally-treated at 500 degrees C for 16 h and used as adsorbent materials in reversed-phase liquid chromatography. The retention of a 22 mono and disubstituted aromatic compounds was evaluated to study the retention mechanisms on the clay mineral. The retention of solutes on the thermally-treated clays was markedly different than that measured on octadecylsilica (ODS) columns under identical conditions, but remarkably similar to retention characteristics of the same solutes on porous graphitic carbon columns. The clay columns exhibit an enhanced selectivity over the ODS column in separation of nitroaromatic positional isomers. Under identical mobile phase compositions, a selectivity, alpha, of 7.15 between ortho- and para-dinitrobenzene isomers was measured on the clay column compared to a alpha of 1.04 on the ODS column.     

Investigation of the validity of the kinetic plot method to predict the performance of coupled column systems operated at very high pressures under different thermal conditions

The present study investigates how strong the kinetic plot method is influenced by the changes in plate height, retention factor and apparent column permeability that arise under conditions of very high pressure. More precisely, the study investigates how well a set of performance measurements conducted on a single short column can be used to predict the performance of a long sequence of coupled columns. This has been investigated for the two practically most relevant thermal conditions, i.e., that of a forced-air oven and that of a still-air oven. Measuring column performance data for acetophenone and benzene on a series of coupled 3.5 μm columns that could be operated up to 1000 bar, it was found that the kinetic plot method provides accurate predictions of time versus efficiency for the still-air oven systems, over the entire range of investigated pressures and column lengths (up to 60 cm), provided k′ and K_v0 are evaluated at the maximal pressure. For the forced-air oven which leads to worse performances than the still-air oven, the kinetic plot prediction is less accurate, partly because the thermal conditions (near-isothermal) tend to vary if the number of coupled columns increases. The fact that the thermal conditions of the column wall might vary with the column length is an additional complexity making very-high pressure separations less predictable and harder to interpret and model.     

Capillary electrochromatography with monolithic silica column: I. Preparation of silica monoliths having surface-bound octadecyl moieties and their chromatographic characterization and applications to the separation of neutral and charged species

Monolithic silica columns with surface-bound octadecyl (C18) moieties have been prepared by a sol-gel process in 100 microm ID fused-silica capillaries for reversed-phase capillary electrochromatography of neutral and charged species. The reaction conditions for the preparation of the C18-silica monoliths were optimized for maximum surface coverage with octadecyl moieties in order to maximize retention and selectivity toward neutral and charged solutes with a sufficiently strong electroosmotic flow (> 2 mm/s) to yield rapid analysis time. Furthermore, the effect of the pore-tailoring process on the silica monoliths was performed over a wide range of treatment time with 0.010 M ammonium hydroxide solution in order to determine the optimum time and conditions that yield mesopores of narrow pore size distribution that result in high separation efficiency. Under optimum column fabrication conditions and optimum mobile phase composition and flow velocity, the average separation efficiency reached 160 000 plates/m, a value comparable to that obtained on columns packed with 3 microm C18-silica particles with the advantages of high permeability and virtually no bubble formation. The optimized monolithic C18-silica columns were evaluated for their retention properties toward neutral and charged analytes over a wide range of mobile phase compositions. A series of dimensionless retention parameters were evaluated and correlated to solute polarity and electromigration property. A dimensionless mobility modulus was introduced to describe charged solute migration and interaction behavior with the monolithic C18-silica in a counterflow regime during capillary electrochromatography (CEC )separations. The mobility moduli correlated well with the solute hydrophobic character and its charge-to-mass ratio.     

Coating properties of a novel water stationary phase in capillary supercritical fluid chromatography

The coating properties of a novel water stationary phase used in capillary supercritical fluid chromatography were investigated. The findings confirm that increasing the length or internal diameter of the type 316 stainless‐steel column used provides a linear increase in the volume of stationary phase present. Under normal operating conditions, results indicate that about 4.9 ± 0.5 μL/m of water phase is deposited uniformly inside of a typical 250 μm internal diameter 316 stainless‐steel column, which translates to an area coverage of about 6.3 ± 0.5 nL/mm² regardless of dimension. Efforts to increase the stationary phase volume present showed that etching the stainless‐steel capillary wall using hydrofluoric acid was very effective for this. For instance, after five etching cycles, this volume doubled inside of both the type 304 and the type 316 stainless‐steel columns examined. This in turn doubled analyte retention, while maintaining good peak shape and column efficiency. Overall, 316 stainless‐steel columns were more resistant to etching than 304 stainless‐steel columns. Results indicate that this approach could be useful to employ as a means of controlling the volume of water stationary phase that can be established inside of the stainless‐steel columns used with this supercritical fluid chromatography technique.