Insights into Light‐driven DNA Repair by Photolyases: Challenges and Opportunities for Electronic Structure Theory

Ultraviolet radiation causes two of the most abundant mutagenic and cytotoxic DNA lesions: cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and 6‐4 photoproducts. (6‐4) Photolyases are light‐activated enzymes that selectively bind to DNA and trigger repair of mutagenic 6‐4 photoproducts via photoinduced electron transfer from flavin adenine dinucleotide anion (FADH^?) to the lesion triggering repair. This review provides an overview of the sequential steps of the repair process, that is light absorption and resonance energy transfer, photoinduced electron transfer and electron‐induced splitting mechanisms, with an emphasis on the role of theory and computation. In addition, theoretical calculations and physical properties that can be used to classify specific mechanism are discussed in an effort to trace the fundamental aspects of each individual step and assist the interpretation of experimental data. The current challenges and suggested future directions are outlined for each step, concluding with a view on the future.     

Photolyase: Dynamics and Mechanisms of Repair of Sun‐Induced DNA Damage

Photolyase, a photomachine discovered half a century ago for repair of sun‐induced DNA damage of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) and pyrimidine (6‐4) pyrimidone photoproducts (6‐4PPs), has been characterized extensively in biochemistry (function), structure and dynamics since 1980s. The molecular mechanism and repair photocycle have been revealed at the most fundamental level. Using femtosecond spectroscopy, we have mapped out the entire dynamical evolution and determined all actual timescales of the catalytic processes. Here, we review our recent efforts in studies of the dynamics of DNA repair by photolyases. The repair of CPDs in three life kingdoms includes seven electron transfer (ET) reactions among 10 elementary steps through initial bifurcating ET pathways, a direct tunneling route and a two‐step hopping path both through an intervening adenine from the cofactor to CPD, with a conserved folded structure at the active site. The repair of 6‐4PPs is challenging and requires similar ET reactions and a new cyclic proton transfer with a conserved histidine residue at the active site of (6‐4) photolyases. Finally, we also summarize our efforts on multiple intraprotein ET of photolyases in different redox states and such mechanistic studies are critical to the functional mechanism of homologous cryptochromes of blue‐light photoreceptors.     

Nucleotide excision repair proteins rapidly accumulate but fail to persist in human XP-E (DDB2 mutant) cells

The xeroderma pigmentosum (XP-E) DNA damage binding protein (DDB2) is involved in early recognition of global genome DNA damage during DNA nucleotide excision repair (NER). We found that skin fibroblasts from four newly reported XP-E patients with numerous skin cancers and DDB2 mutations had slow repair of 6-4 photoproducts (6-4PP) and markedly reduced repair of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD). NER proteins (XPC, XPB, XPG, XPA and XPF) colocalized to CPD and 6-4PP positive regions immediately (<0.1 h) after localized UV irradiation in cells from the XP-E patients and normal controls. While these proteins persist in normal cells, surprisingly, within 0.5 h these repair proteins were no longer detectable at the sites of DNA damage in XP-E cells. Our results indicate that DDB2 is not required for the rapid recruitment of NER proteins to sites of UV photoproducts or for partial repair of 6-4PP but is essential for normal persistence of these proteins for CPD photoproduct removal.     

Repair of the main UV-induced thymine dimeric lesions within Arabidopsis thaliana DNA: evidence for the major involvement of photoreactivation pathways.

The UV-B induced formation of thymine cis-syn cyclobutane dimer and related (6-4) photoproduct was monitored within DNA of cultured cells and plants of Arabidopsis thaliana. This was achieved using a sensitive and accurate HPLC-tandem mass spectrometry assay. It was found that the cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer was formed in a ninefold higher yield than the (6-4) photoproduct. The removal of the lesions was then studied by incubating irradiated cells either in the darkness, under visible light or upon exposure to UV-A radiation. Dark repair of both cyclobutane dimers and (6-4) photoproducts was found to be very ineffective. In contrast, a rapid decrease in the level of photoproducts was observed when UV-B-irradiated cells were exposed to UV-A and, to a lesser extent, to visible light. The removal of (6-4) adducts was found to occur more efficiently. These results strongly suggest that repair of UV-induced photolesions in plants is mainly mediated by photolyases.     

Effect of the cyclobutane cytidine dimer on the properties of Escherichia coli DNA photolyase

Cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) photolyases are structure specific DNA-repair enzymes that specialize in the repair of CPDs, the major photoproducts that are formed upon irradiation of DNA with ultraviolet light. The purified enzyme binds a flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD), which is in the neutral radical semiquinone (FADH(*)) form. The CPDs are repaired by a light-driven, electron transfer from the anionic hydroquinone (FADH(-)) singlet excited state to the CPD, which is followed by reductive cleavage of the cyclobutane ring and subsequent monomerization of the pyrimidine bases. CPDs formed between two adjacent thymidine bases (T< >T) are repaired with greater efficiency than those formed between two adjacent cytidine bases (C< >C). In this paper, we investigate the changes in Escherichia coli photolyase that are induced upon binding to DNA containing C< >C lesions using resonance Raman, UV-vis absorption, and transient absorption spectroscopies, spectroelectrochemistry, and computational chemistry. The binding of photolyase to a C< >C lesion modifies the energy levels of FADH(*), the rate of charge recombination between FADH(-) and Trp(306)(*), and protein-FADH(*) interactions differently than binding to a T< >T lesion. However, the reduction potential of the FADH(-)/FADH(*) couple is modified in the same way with both substrates. Our calculations show that the permanent electric dipole moment of C< >C is stronger (12.1 D) and oriented differently than that of T< >T (8.7 D). The possible role of the electric dipole moment of the CPD in modifying the physicochemical properties of photolyase as well as in affecting CPD repair will be discussed.     

Crystal Structure of the T(6‐4)C Lesion in Complex with a (6‐4) DNA Photolyase and Repair of UV‐Induced (6‐4) and Dewar Photolesions

UV‐light irradiation induces the formation of highly mutagenic lesions in DNA, such as cis‐syn cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD photoproducts), pyrimidine(6‐4)pyrimidone photoproducts ((6‐4) photoproducts) and their Dewar valence isomers ((Dew) photoproducts). Here we describe the synthesis of defined DNA strands containing these lesions by direct irradiation. We show that all lesions are efficiently repaired except for the T(Dew)T lesion, which cannot be cleaved by the repair enzyme under our conditions. A crystal structure of a T(6‐4)C lesion containing DNA duplex in complex with the (6‐4) photolyase from Drosophila melanogaster provides insight into the molecular recognition event of a cytosine derived photolesion for the first time. In light of the previously postulated repair mechanism, which involves rearrangement of the (6‐4) lesions into strained four‐membered ring repair intermediates, it is surprising that the not rearranged T(6‐4)C lesion is observed in the active site. The structure, therefore, provides additional support for the newly postulated repair mechanism that avoids this rearrangement step and argues for a direct electron injection into the lesion as the first step of the repair reaction performed by (6‐4) DNA photolyases.     

Repair of a Dimeric Azetidine Related to the Thymine–Cytosine (6‐4) Photoproduct by Electron Transfer Photoreduction

Photolyases are intriguing enzymes that take advantage of sunlight to restore lesions like cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers or (6‐4) photoproducts. This work focused on the photoreductive process responsible for splitting of the azetidine ring proposed to occur during (6‐4) photoproduct repair at a thymine–cytosine sequence. A model compound formed by photocycloaddition between thymine and 6‐azauracil has been designed to mimic the elusive azetidine intermediate. The photoinduced electron transfer process has been investigated by means of steady‐state and time‐resolved fluorescence using photosensitizers with oxidation potentials in the singlet excited state ranging from ?3.3 to ?2.1 V vs. SCE. Azetidine ring splitting and recovery of “repaired” bases were proven by HPLC analysis.     

Characterization of the Intermediate in and Identification of the Repair Mechanism of (6‐4) Photolesions by Photolyases

Quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics calculations are employed to assign previously recorded experimental spectroscopic signatures of the intermediates occurring during the photo‐induced repair of (6‐4) photolesions by photolyases to specific molecular structures. Based on this close comparison of experiment and theory it is demonstrated that the acting repair mechanism involves proton transfer from the protonated His365 to the N3′ nitrogen of the lesion, which proceeds simultaneously with intramolecular OH transfer along an oxetane‐like transition state.     

Theoretical study on the repair mechanism of the (6-4) photolesion by the (6-4) photolyase

UV irradiation of DNA can lead to the formation of mutagenic (6-4) pyrimidine-pyrimidone photolesions. The (6-4) photolyases are the enzymes responsible for the photoinduced repair of such lesions. On the basis of the recently published crystal structure of the (6-4) photolyase bound to DNA [Maul et al. 2008] and employing quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics techniques, a repair mechanism is proposed, which involves two photoexcitations. The flavin chromophore, initially being in its reduced anionic form, is photoexcited and donates an electron to the (6-4) form of the photolesion. The photolesion is then protonated by the neighboring histidine residue and forms a radical intermediate. The latter undergoes a series of energy stabilizing hydrogen-bonding rearrangements before the electron back transfer to the flavin semiquinone. The resulting structure corresponds to the oxetane intermediate, long thought to be formed upon DNA-enzyme binding. A second photoexcitation of the flavin promotes another electron transfer to the oxetane. Proton donation from the same histidine residue allows for the splitting of the four-membered ring, hence opening an efficient pathway to the final repaired form. The repair of the lesion by a single photoexcitation was shown not to be feasible.     

Photolyase Production and Current Applications: A Review

The photolyase family consists of flavoproteins with enzyme activity able to repair ultraviolet light radiation damage by photoreactivation. DNA damage by the formation of a cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) and a pyrimidine-pyrimidone (6-4) photoproduct can lead to multiple affections such as cellular apoptosis and mutagenesis that can evolve into skin cancer. The development of integrated applications to prevent the negative effects of prolonged sunlight exposure, usually during outdoor activities, is imperative. This study presents the functions, characteristics, and types of photolyases, their therapeutic and cosmetic applications, and additionally explores some photolyase-producing microorganisms and drug delivery systems.     

UNIQUE DNA REPAIR PROPERTY OF AN ULTRAVIOLET-SENSITIVE (radC MUTANT OF Dictyostelium discoideum

Abstract— Dictyostelium discoideum is an organism that shows higher UV resistance than other organisms, such as Escherichia coli and human cultured cells. We examined the removal of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) and 6–4 photoproducts from DNA in the radC mutant and the wild-type strain using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay with monoclonal antibodies. Wild-type cells excised more than 90% of both CPD and 6–4 photoproducts within 4 h. Dictyostelium discoideum appeared to have a special repair system, because 6–4 photoproducts were repaired faster than CPD in E. coli and human cultured cells. In radC mutant cells, although only 50% of CPD were excised from DNA within 8 h, effective removal of 6–4 photoproducts (80% in 8 h) was observed. Excision repair-deficient mutants generally cannot remove both CPD and 6–4 photoproducts. Though the radC mutant shows deficient excision repair, it can remove 6–4 photoproducts to a moderate degree. These results suggest that D. discoideum has two kinds of repair systems, one mainly for CPD and the other for 6–4 photoproducts, and that the radC mutant has a defect mainly in the repair enzyme for CPD.     

Influence of Phage Proteins on Formation of Specific UV DMA Photoproducts in Phage T7

Phage T7 can be used as a biological UV dosimeter. Its reading is proportional to the inactivation rate expressed in HT7 units. To understand the influence of phage proteins on the formation of DNA UV photoproducts, cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) and (6-4)photoproducts ((6-4)PD) were determined in T7 DNA exposed to UV radiation under different conditions: intraphage T7 DNA, isolated T7 DNA and heated phage. To investigate the effects of various wavelengths, seven different UV sources have been used. The CPD and (6-4)PD were determined by lesion-specific antibodies in an immunodot-blot assay. Both photoproducts were HT7 dose-dependently produced in all three objects by every irradiation source in the biologically relevant UV dose range (1-10 HT7). The CPD to (6-4)PD ratios increased with the increasing effective wavelength of the irradiation source and were similar in intraphage T7 DNA, isolated DNA and heated phage with all irradiation sources. However, a significant decrease in the yield of both photoproducts was detected in isolated T7 DNA and in heated phage compared to intraphage DNA, the decrease was dependent on the irradiation source. Both photoproducts were affected the same way in isolated T7 DNA and heated phage, respectively. The yield of CPD and (6-4)PD was similar in B, C-like and A conformational states of isolated T7 DNA, indicating that the conformational switch in the DNA is not the decisive factor in photoproduct formation. The most likely explanation for modulation of photoproduct frequency in intraphage T7 DNA is that the presence of bound phage proteins induces an alteration in DNA structure that can result in an increased rate of dimerization and (6-4)PD production of adjacent based in intraphage T7 DNA.     

Structural and Functional Analysis of a Prokaryotic (6-4) Photolyase from the Aquatic Pathogen Vibrio Cholerae†

Photolyases are flavoproteins, which are able to repair UV-induced DNA lesions in a light-dependent manner. According to their substrate, they can be distinguished as CPD- and (6-4) photolyases. While CPD-photolyases repair the predominantly occurring cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer lesion, (6-4) photolyases catalyze the repair of the less prominent (6-4) photoproduct. The subgroup of prokaryotic (6-4) photolyases/FeS-BCP is one of the most ancient types of flavoproteins in the ubiquitously occurring photolyase & cryptochrome superfamily (PCSf). In contrast to canonical photolyases, prokaryotic (6-4) photolyases possess a few particular characteristics, including a lumazine derivative as antenna chromophore besides the catalytically essential flavin adenine dinucleotide as well as an elongated linker region between the N-terminal α/β-domain and the C-terminal all-α-helical domain. Furthermore, they can harbor an additional short subdomain, located at the C-terminus, with a binding site for a [4Fe-4S] cluster. So far, two crystal structures of prokaryotic (6-4) photolyases have been reported. Within this study, we present the high-resolution structure of the prokaryotic (6-4) photolyase from Vibrio cholerae and its spectroscopic characterization in terms of in vitro photoreduction and DNA-repair activity.     

DNA光解酶模型研究的近期进展

用模型化合物来模拟DNA光解酶与底物的作用, 有助于认识DNA光复活作用机理. 评述了环丁烷型嘧啶二聚体光解酶和(6-4)光产物光解酶的模型研究进展, 并展望了该领域的发展前景．     

PREFERENTIAL INHIBITION OF NUCLEOSOME ASSEMBLY BY ULTRAVIOLET-INDUCED (6-4)PHOTOPRODUCTS

We reconstituted nucleosomes in vitro using two kinds of damaged pBR322 plasmid DNA carrying cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) or (6-4)photoproducts. The results indicate that nucleosome assembly is inhibited preferentially by (6-4)photoproducts compared with CPD, suggesting that the regions carrying (6-4)photoproducts retain their nucleosome-free form, i.e. linker-like conformation until completion of the repair processes.     

Electrochemical approach to the repair of oxetanes mimicking DNA (6-4) photoproducts

Electrochemical study of oxetanes mimicking DNA (6-4) photoproducts gives new insight into the repair mechanism by (6-4) photolyase. Both electrochemical oxidation and electrochemical reduction at carbon electrodes lead to the cleavage of the oxetanes in a retro-Paterno-Büchi sequence. Within the family of compounds investigated and the range of driving forces offered, transient formation of unstable radical ions is observed, for both oxidative and reductive cleavage. Taking advantage of the electrochemical signature of these mimics, enzymatic assay with Escherichia coli CPD photolyase coupled to electrochemical monitoring of the reaction brings evidence that enzymatic repair of (6-4) DNA photoproducts does involve a catalytic dissociative electron-transfer mechanism at the level of an oxetane intermediate.     

Effects of the binding of alpha/beta-type small, acid-soluble spore proteins on the photochemistry of DNA in spores of Bacillus subtilis and in vitro

The main lesion produced in DNA by UV-C irradiation of spores of Bacillus subtilis is 5-thyminyl-5,6-dihydrothymine (spore photoproduct [SP]). In contrast, cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) and pyrimidine (6-4) pyrimidone photoproducts (6-4PP) are the main photolesions in other cell types. The novel photochemistry of spore DNA is accounted for in part by its reduced hydration, but largely by the saturation of spore DNA with alpha/beta-type small, acid-soluble spore proteins (SASP). Using high-performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis of the photoproducts, we showed that in wild-type B. subtilis spores (1) UV-C irradiation generates almost exclusively SP with little if any CPD and 6-4PP; (2) the SP generated is approximately 99% of the intrastrand derivative, but approximately 1% is in the interstrand form; and (3) there is no detectable formation of the SP analog between adjacent C and T residues. UV-C irradiation of spores lacking the majority of their alpha/beta-type SASP gave less SP than with wild-type spores and significant levels of CPD and 6-4PP. The binding of an alpha/beta-type SASP to isolated DNA either in dry films or in aqueous solution led to a large decrease in the yield of CPD and 6-4PP, and a concomitant increase in the yield of SP, although levels of interstrand photoproducts were extremely low.     

The relative cytotoxicity of (6-4) photoproducts and cyclobutane dimers in mammalian cells

Abstract— The significance of the pyrimidine(6-4)pyrimidone photoproduct in mammalian cell killing is considered. Photochemical data indicate that the(6–4) photoproduct is induced at a substantial frequency compared to the cyclobutane dimer and that the action spectra for the induction of both lesions are equivalent. The repair of(6–4) photoproducts in various normal and UV-hypcrsensitive mammalian cell lines, including several recently derived somatic cell hybrids and transformants, is presented. The sensitivity of these cells to ultraviolet irradiation correlates better with the capacity to repair(6–4) photoproducts than cyclobutane dimers. These data are used to support that idea that the(6–4) photoproduct is one of the major cytotoxic lesions induced in DNA by ultraviolet light.     

WAVELENGTH DEPENDENT FORMATION OF THYMINE DIMERS AND (6-4)PHOTOPRODUCTS IN DNA BY MONOCHROMATIC ULTRAVIOLET LIGHT RANGING FROM 150 TO 365 nm

We investigated the wavelength dependence of cyclobutane thymine dimer and (6-4)photoproduct induction by monochromatic UV in the region extending from 150 to 365 nm, using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay with two monoclonal antibodies. Calf thymus DNA solution was irradiated with 254-365 nm monochromatic UV from a spectrograph, or with 220-300 nm monochromatic UV from synchrotron radiation. Thymine dimers and (6-4)photoproducts were fluence-dependently induced by every UV below 220 nm extending to 150 nm under dry condition. We detected the efficient formation of both types of damage in the shorter UV region, as well as at 260 nm, which had been believed to be the most efficient wavelength for the formation of UV lesions. The action spectra for the induction of thymine dimers and (6-4)photoproducts were similar from 180 to 300 nm, whereas the action spectrum values for thymine dimer induction were about 9- and 1.4-fold or more higher than the values for (6-4)photoproduct induction below 160 nm and above 313 nm, respectively.     

Crystal structure and photochemical behavior in solution of the 3'-N-sulfamate analogue of thymidylyl(3'-5')thymidine

The 3'-N-sulfamate analogue of thymidylyl(3'-5')thymidine (TnsoT, 1) exhibits a preference for a C3'-endo conformation in the solution and solid states. Its photochemical behavior in solution is compared to that of its natural counterpart, thymidylyl(3'-5')thymidine (TpT, 2), to get further insight into the significance of the C3'-endo conformation on the photoproduct formation at the single-stranded dinucleotide level. Irradiation at 254 nm of 1 led to the same type of photoproducts as observed with 2. However, 1 was significantly more photoreactive than 2, and accordingly, the initial rate of photoproduct formation was enhanced in accordance with its propensity to base stack compared to 2. The corresponding quantum yields were determined and showed that the enhancement factor (1 compared to 2) is moderate for the cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) (1.26) and much higher for the (6-4) photoproduct (1.8). These data strongly suggest that the CPD and (6-4) photoproduct arise from distinct minor stacked conformations.