The dipole approach in ion-interaction chromatography of zwitterions

Summary The chromatographic behavior of zwitterions in Ion-interaction chromatography (IIC) is, investigated theoretically for the first time. The modification of the stationary phase in the presence of Ion-interaction reagent (IIR), and adsorption competition between test analytes and IIR for inner layer sites are shown theoretically to change the partition coefficient for zwitterions. Experimental results from the literature concerning retention behavior of zwitterions in IIC, were used to test the new thermodynamic theory. Very reasonable estimates of (i) ΔG ^o values for the IIR adsorption onto the stationary phase (II) total ligand concentration, and (iii) dipolar moments validate the present thermodynamic model for the IIC of zwitterionic analytes. Retention equations are compared to those which can be obtained, if the net charge of the analyte is zero, from the most important retention models in IIC. None of them is able to explain, even in a qualitative way, the retention behavior of zwitterions in IIC whereas, the present model is quantitatively able to do this.     

Correlation of the retention data of polyaromatic hydrocarbons obtained on various stationary phases used in normal- and reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Summary The correlation between the retention data of polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) obtained in normal-and reversed-phase liquid chromatography is investigated in order to determine the dominant factors controlling the retention. It is clear that the separation of PAHs on various chemically-bonded packing materials in normal- and/or reversed-phase modes is primarily controlled by the molecular structure and shape. The -electron interaction between the solute and the stationary phase also contributes to the retention, although pure silica shows a somewhat different behavior.     

The dipole approach in the lon-interaction chromatography of zwitterions— Use of a potential approximation to obtain a simplified retention equation

Summary In ion-interaction chromatography (IIC) the zwitterionic analyte is believed to interact with the stationary phase potential as a result of its electrical dipole, and to compete with the ion-interaction reagent (IIR) for available inner layer sites. The most reliable set of literature data relating to the retention behavior of zwitterions in IIC has been used for successful testing of a high surface-potential approximation which enables the fitting of retention data without detailed information about the physical and chemical properties of the mobile phase. This approach can explain quantitatively, very simply, the retention behavior of zwitterions in IIC.     

Convergence of retention for small solutes in reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Summary It is shown theoretically that when the concentration of organic solvent in the mobile phase increases, or solute size decreases, log k values of small solutes in reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) will tend to have a minimum value called the convergence point. A theoretical model for evaluating the convergent coordinates of small solutes is presented by using a stoichiometric displacement model for retention (SMDR). The physical meaning of the coordinates of each kind of convergence are also elucidated. The convergence points have either two-dimensional coordinates with a common ordinate (the logarithm of the phase ratio of the column, log ) or threedimensional corrdinates with two common axes: — log and the logarithm of the molar concentration of the pure displacing agent in mobile phase, log a_D. The other axis relates to the nature of the solutes, such as carbon number of a homolog, van der Waal's surface area, hydrophobic fragment constant etc. for the latter and those and/or concentration axis for the former. The model was tested with published data and found to give a good fit.     

Estimation of the degree of self-association of water using a novel retention model

Summary An attempt has been made to gain a semi-quantitative insight into the self-association of water molecules through hydrogen bonds. This was only possible with the use of a new solute retention model for the chromatographic systems by considering intermolecular interactions between the constituents of binary mobile phases. Four different sizes of the average associative aqueous multimer were assumed. By comparing measured and calculated retention values, the existence of associated aqueous multimers consisting of 100 aqueous monomer units is postulated as an average multimer structure.     

Modelling and prediction of retention in high-performance liquid chromatography by using neural networks

Summary Multi-layer feed-forward neural networks trained with an error back-propagation algorithm have been used to model retention behaviour of liquid chromatography as a function of the composition of the mobile phases. Conventional hydro-organic and micellar mobile phases were considered. Accurate retention modelling and prediction have been achieved using mobile phases defined by two, three and four parameters. With micellar mobile phases, the parameters involved included the concentrations of surfactant and organic modifier, pH and temperature. It is shown that neural networks provide a competitive tool to model varied inherent nonlinear relationships of retention behaviour with respect to the mobile phase parameters. The soft models defined by the weights of the networks are capable of accommodating all types of linear and nonlinear relationships, neural networks being specially useful when the relationships between retention behaviour and the mobile phase parameters are unknown. However, to train neural networks more experimental points than with hard-modelling methods are required, hence the use of the networks is recommended only for those cases where adequate theoretical or empirical models do not exist.     

The driving force for solute retention in electron donor-acceptor chromatography: Electrostatic versus charge-transfer interactions

Summary Charge-transfer interactions are often assumed to be dominant among the noncovalent interactions that govern the solute retention in electron donor-acceptor chromatography. This popular view, however, has been called into question by recent studies that suggest an important role for electrostatic interactions in the formation of donor-acceptor complexes. We reported here an experimental investigation concerning the question as to whether charge-transfer or electrostatic interactions are the driving force for solute retention in donor-acceptor chromatography. Using three chromatographic systems composed of a dinitrobenzene derived stationary phase and a hexane based mobile phase, we determined retention factors for a range of aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons and correlated them with molecular properties that describe the solute's dispersion, charge-transfer, and electrostatic characteristics. It was found that the molecular polarizability and ionization potential give either very poor or no correlation with solute retention whereas the molecular quadrupole moment is a linear function of the logarithmic retention factor. These results were interpreted as showing that electrostatic, rather than charge-transfer or dispersion, interactions play a major role in determining solute retention. The dominance of the electrostatic interactions over the other noncovalent interactions was discussed in terms of distance dependency of the interaction energy. Dedicated to Professor John H. Knox on the occasion of his 70th birthday.     

On the chromatography mechanism of reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Summary An equation is derived which can describe how the retention of solutes is influenced by the composition of the mobile phase in reversed-phase liquid chromatography, the retention of solutes in alkyl bonded stationary phase regarded as the complexation between solute molecule and the active sites on the surface of the stationary phase. When the stationary phase is not fully saturated by the organic modifier, the activity of the active sites, the activity coefficient of the adsorbed solute as well as the activity coefficient of the solute in the mobile phase depend on the composition of the mobile phase. However, when the stationary phase is fully saturated, the composition of the mobile phase mainly influences the activity coefficient of the solute in the mobile phase. In addition, the selectivity of retention is discussed in terms of the derived equation.     

Factors influencing retention and resolution of substituted alkylbenzenes in reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Summary The retention data of isomeric xylenes, ethyltoluenes and diethylbenzenes, and of mesitylene, benzene, toluene and ethylbenzene were obtained on a reversedphase column using methanol-water and ethanol-water mobile phases at four different temperatures. This database was used to relate the dependence of solute retention and resolution on the polarity of the mobile phase, solute dipole moment, and column temperature. The additivity of the free energy of the transfer of solute molecules or solute segments from the stationary phase to the mobile phase, was examined for the isomeric compounds. For this, the logarithm of the net retention volume was substituted for the free energy. Deviations from the additivity of free energies indicate that the separation of isomeric substituted alkylbenzenes is governed by their differential interactions with both the polar mobile phase and nonpolar stationary phase. Among the disubstituted alkylbenzenes,ortho-isomers favor the mobile phase more andpara-isomers tend to prefer the stationary phase more. Themeta-isomers are found to follow the additivity rule closely. These trends are amplified as the polarity of the mobile phase is increased indicating that these isomers are resolved better in water-rich mobile phases. These findings are substantiated by analogous results from gas-liquid chromatographic retention data, estimation of dipole moment effects, and examination of the entropic and enthalpic contributions to the net retention volume.Dedicated to Professor Leslie S. Ettre on the occasion of his 70th birthday.     

Statistical evaluation of the validity of a method for characterizing stationary phases for reversed-phase liquid chromatography based on retention of homologous series

Summary The validity of a method for characterizing stationary phases for reversed-phase, liquid chromatography, based on the use of homologous series, has been evaluated. The method is based on a retention model which describes the dependence of the logarithm of the capacity factor on mobile phase composition and the carbon number of specific homologous series. A first-order as well as a second-order version of this model was investigated. The second-order model proved to be a significant improvement on the first-order model, even for smaller mobile-phase ranges. Nevertheless both models showed a significant lack of fit, reflecting the incompleteness of these models. Therefore, it is very questionable whether this method is suitable to describe HPLC-column characteristics like hydrophobicity and hydrophylicity.     

Calculation of amino acid hydrophilicity indices for retention of peptides on amide, diol and silica columns in normal-phase liquid chromatography

Summary A set of hydrophilicity parameters in a normal-phase liquid chromatography of peptides is presented in order to clarify the contribution of individual amino acid residues to peptide retention and to predict retention times. The retention of 100 peptides was studied using normal-phase liquid chromatography on amide, diol and silica columns. An acetonitrile-water mixed solution containing 0.2% trifluoroacetic acid +0.2% triethylamine was used as the mobile phase in a linear gradient elution system. The contribution of each residue upon retention was calculated by linear multiple regression analysis. This paper described the contribution values as “hydrophilicity retention coefficients”. Using these hydrophilicity retention coefficients, retention times could be predicted for peptides of known amino acid content and sequence. A set of hydrophilicity retention coefficients on each column was successfully explained by contributions to the degree of retention.     

Solute retention in the stationary phase of a liquid-solid chromatographic system

Summary Utilizing the UNIFAC group model of activity coefficients the retention behaviour of a solute in the stationary phase of a liquid-solid chromatographic system is studied. By comparison of experimentally observed capacity ratios and calculated activity coefficients of solutes in the mobile phase, varying the concentration of a polar moderator, it is shown that the calculated activity coefficients in the stationary phase fit very well the equation formally identical with the Langmuir function. Comparison of activity coefficients in the mobile and the stationary phase proves equivalence between the solvent interaction and the competition theory.     

Use of molecular connectivity indices to predict LC retention of dansylamides in six different eluent systems

Summary Molecular connectivity indices (x) through the sixth order were calculated and compared with measured reversed-phase liquid chromatographic retention data of sixteen dansyl derivatives of amines (dansylamides). Retention measurements were performed in the capacity factor, k′, range 1–30 with organic solvent-water eluents using acetone, acetonitrile, ethanol, methanol, 1-propanol and 2-propanol. Mainly valence level indices were selected to describe retention. Indices of different order were selected in the different eluents, suggesting that there are differences in the retention mechanism in these eluents. Retention can be predicted with great accuracy by the molecular connectivity indices, as the high correlations between the calculated and observed retention indicate. Presented at the 15th International Symposium on Chromatography, Nürnberg, October 1984     

Modelling of retention behaviour of solutes in micellar liquid chromatography

In micellar liquid chromatography (MLC), the resolution for a given multi-component mixture can be optimized by changing several variables, such as the concentrations of surfactant and organic modifier, the pH and temperature. However, this advantage can only be fully exploited with the development of mathematical models that describe the retention and the separation mechanisms. Several reports have appeared recently on the possibilities of accurately predicting the solute retention in MLC. Although the retention and selectivity may strongly change with varying concentrations of surfactant, organic modifier and/or pH, the observed changes are very regular, and are well described by simple models. This characteristic enables a successful prediction of retention times and compensates the negative effect of the broad and tailed chromatographic peaks obtained for some solutes when micellar eluents are used. An overview of the models proposed in the literature to describe the retention behaviour in pure micellar eluents and micellar eluents containing an organic modifier, at a fixed pH or at varying pH, is given. The equations derived permit the evaluation of the strength of micelle-solute and stationary phase-solute interactions. The prediction of the retention based on molecular properties and the use of neural networks, together with the factors affecting the prediction capability of the models (linearization of the equations, dead time, critical micellar concentration, ionic strength and temperature) are commented on. The strategies used for the optimization of resolution are also given.     

A refined physico-chemical model of solute retention in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography with ternary mobile phases

Summary In our previous publication we have introduced a new model of solute retention in RP-HPLC systems with ternary mobile phases of the B+AB₁+AB₂ type (B: acetonitrile or tetrahydrofuran; AB₁: methanol; AB₂: water). That model proposed no stoichiometric differentiation between acetonitrile and tetrahydrofuran, alternatively present in the solvent system; moreover, it made some very rough assumptions only as to the intermolecular interactions among the mobile phase constituents.This paper introduces a significant refinement to the already established retention model, which is based on the simple quantitative relationships between acetonitrile and tetrahydrofuran, and the remaining components of the ternary liquid system. The refined model is tested with same experimental data.     

Influence of solvent effects on retention for a porous polymer sorbent in reversed phase liquid chromatography

Summary The influence of acetonitrile, methanol and isopropanol as retention selectivily modifiers in reversed phase liquid chromatography on a poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) macroporous polymer sorbent (PLRP-S) is evaluated using the solvation parameter model. Retention results from a combination of adsorption and partitioning and is influenced by the equilibrium absorption of organic solvent by the polymer from the mobile phase. The sorption of solutes is dominated by the ease of cavity formation in or on the solvated sorbent, with a small contribution from lone pair-lone pair electron interactions. All polar interactions, such as dipole-type and hydrogenbond formation, are more favorable in the mobile phase and reduce retention. Changes in the uptake of organic solvent from the mobile phase affect kinetic properties of the column such as band broadening and porosity as well as retention. The PLRP-S solvated sorbent is suitable for solid-phase extraction and is more retentive than typical silica-based, bonded phase sorbents for extraction from water. As a surrogate system for estimating solute lipophilicity and biological activity through retention-property correlations it provides a poor fit for hydrogen-bond acid solutes and is too dipolar/polarizable to fit some models.     

Correlation between retention and the C18 silica surface coverage in reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Summary Members of three homologous series and five non-homologous solutes with various functional groups were chromatographed on a series of well-characterized C₁₈ reversed stationary phases with a range of methanol-water mobile phases. Measured capacity factors of solutes were correlated with the concentration of C₁₈ ligands on the stationary phase. A linear relationship with the slope depending on a solute molecular structure and the volume fraction of methanol in the mobile phase was obtained. A method for the evaluation of phase ratio is also proposed. Presented at the 17th International Symposium on Chromatography, September 25–30, 1988, Vienna, Austria.