Drug-like inhibitors of protein-protein interactions: a structural examination of effective protein mimicry

Protein-protein interactions represent targets for drug discovery that are highly relevant in a biological sense, but have proven difficult in a practical sense. Nevertheless, there have been recent successes in discovering drug-like small molecule inhibitors of protein-protein systems. To build on this progress, it is worth analyzing successful cases to understand at a molecular level the strategies by which these compounds effectively interfere with protein-protein pairing. A commonly observed situation is one wherein the small molecule acts as a direct mimic of one of the protein partners. This review focuses exclusively on cases where this strategy is employed, and examines the structural characteristics of the binding sites and the conformational attributes of the small molecule ligands. Common traits shared among these successful examples are identified, and formulated into potentially useful guidance for drug discovery efforts within this target class.     

Inhibition of polo-like kinase 1 by blocking polo-box domain-dependent protein-protein interactions

The serine/threonine kinase Polo-like kinase 1 (Plk1) is overexpressed in many types of human cancers, and has been implicated as an adverse prognostic marker for cancer patients. Plk1 localizes to its intracellular anchoring sites via its polo-box domain (PBD). Here we show that Plk1 can be inhibited by small molecules which interfere with its intracellular localization by inhibiting the function of the PBD. We report the natural product thymoquinone and, especially, the synthetic thymoquinone derivative Poloxin as inhibitors of the Plk1 PBD. Both compounds inhibit the function of the Plk1 PBD in vitro, and cause Plk1 mislocalization, chromosome congression defects, mitotic arrest, and apoptosis in HeLa cells. Our data validate the Plk1 PBD as an anticancer target and provide a rationale for developing thymoquinone derivatives as anticancer drugs.     

Detecting protein-protein interactions with a green fluorescent protein fragment reassembly trap: scope and mechanism

Identification of protein binding partners is one of the key challenges of proteomics. We recently introduced a screen for detecting protein-protein interactions based on reassembly of dissected fragments of green fluorescent protein fused to interacting peptides. Here, we present a set of comaintained Escherichia coli plasmids for the facile subcloning of fusions to the green fluorescent protein fragments. Using a library of antiparallel leucine zippers, we have shown that the screen can detect very weak interactions (K(D) approximately 1 mM). In vitro kinetics show that the reassembly reaction is essentially irreversible, suggesting that the screen may be useful for detecting transient interactions. Finally, we used the screen to discriminate cognate from noncognate protein-ligand interactions for tetratricopeptide repeat domains. These experiments demonstrate the general utility of the screen for larger proteins and elucidate mechanistic details to guide the further use of this screen in proteomic analysis. Additionally, this work gives insight into the positional inequivalence of stabilizing interactions in antiparallel coiled coils.     

Tyrosine sulfation: a modulator of extracellular protein-protein interactions

Tyrosine sulfation is a post-translational modification of many secreted and membrane-bound proteins. Its biological roles have been unclear. Recent work has implicated tyrosine sulfate as a determinant of protein-protein interactions involved in leukocyte adhesion, hemostasis and chemokine signaling.     

Antagonists of protein-protein interactions

Protein-protein interactions are often attractive, but not straightforward, targets for disease therapy. Two strategies for identifying inhibitors of these interactions, peptide phage display and high-throughput screening, have recently shown new promise.     

Application of a green fluorescent fusion protein to study protein-protein interactions by electrophoretic methods

A screening procedure for protein-protein interactions in cellular extracts using a green fluorescent protein (GFP) and affinity capillary electrophoresis (ACE) was established. GFP was fused as a fluorescent indicator to the C-terminus of a cyclophilin (rDmCyp20) from Drosophila melanogaster. Cyclophilins (Cyps) belong to the ubiquitously distributed enzyme family of peptidyl-prolyl cis/trans isomerases (PPlases) and are well known as cellular targets of the immunosuppressive drug cyclosporin A (CsA). The PPlase activity of the GFP fused rDmCyp20 as well as the high affinity to CsA remain intact. Using native gel electrophoresis and ACE mobility-shift assays, it was demonstrated that the known moderate affinity of Cyp20 to the capsid protein p24 of HIV-1 was detectable in the case of rDmCyp20 fused to the fluorescent tag. For the p24 / rDmCyp20-GFP binding an ACE method was established which allowed to determine a dissociation constant of Kd = 20+/-1.5 x 10(-6) M. This result was verified by size-exclusion chromatography and is in good agreement with published data for the nonfused protein. Moreover the fusion protein was utilized to screen rDmCyp20-protein interactions by capillary electrophoresis in biological matrices. A putative ligand of rDmCyp20 in crude extracts of embryonic D. melanogaster was discovered by mobility-shift assays using native gel electrophoresis with fluorescence imaging and ACE with laser-induced fluorescence detection. The approach seems applicable to a wide range of proteins and offers new opportunities to screen for moderate protein-protein interactions in biological samples.     

Selective protein-protein interactions driven by a phenylalanine interface

Highly specific protein-protein interfaces have been the subject of considerable study for their potential utility in disrupting or interrogating cellular signaling and control networks. We report that coiled-coil sequences decorated with phenylalanine core residues fold into stable alpha-helical bundles and that these self-sort from similar peptide assemblies with aliphatic core side chains. For self-assembled ensembles derived from 30-residue monomeric peptides, the DeltaG of specificity is -1.5 kcal/mol, comparable with earlier self-sorting coiled-coil systems. Intriguingly, although this interface is constructed from canonical amino acids, it does not appear to have been exploited in native proteins.     

Fluorinated amino acids: compatibility with native protein structures and effects on protein-protein interactions

Fluorinated analogues of the canonical α-L-amino acids have gained widespread attention as building blocks that may endow peptides and proteins with advantageous biophysical, chemical and biological properties. This critical review covers the literature dealing with investigations of peptides and proteins containing fluorinated analogues of the canonical amino acids published over the course of the past decade including the late nineties. It focuses on side-chain fluorinated amino acids, the carbon backbone of which is identical to their natural analogues. Each class of amino acids--aliphatic, aromatic, charged and polar as well as proline--is presented in a separate section. General effects of fluorine on essential properties such as hydrophobicity, acidity/basicity and conformation of the specific side chains and the impact of these altered properties on stability, folding kinetics and activity of peptides and proteins are discussed (245 references).     

Detecting protein-protein interactions by isotope-edited infrared spectroscopy: a numerical approach

We present a theoretical and numerical analysis of the vibrational coupling between isotope-edited amino acids in protein dimers. Depending on the presence and magnitude of coupling between 13Calpha=O peptide bond oscillators, characteristic level splittings of vibrational eigenstates are predicted. For the example of the Gramicidin A ion channel polypeptide, we observe typical IR fingerprints for the head-to-head and the antiparallel double-helical conformation of the dimer. We suggest that these findings can be used to clearly identify the structure of polypeptide aggregates using a particularly simple isotope substitution pattern.     

Real-time observation of temperature-dependent protein-protein interactions using real-time dual-color detection system

This study examined the ability of a real-time dual-color detection system to allow direct observations of the kinetics of temperature-dependent protein-protein interaction at a single-molecule level. The primary target protein was an Alexa Fluor^® 488-labeled actin conjugate, which had been pre-incubated with an unlabeled rabbit anti-actin antibody (IgG). The complementary fluorescent protein was Alexa Fluor^® 633-labeled goat anti-rabbit IgG antibody, which interacts with the rabbit anti-actin antibody (IgG) bound to the Alexa Fluor^® 488-labeled actin conjugate. The individual protein molecules labeled with different fluorescent dyes in solution were effectively focused, interacted with the other protein molecules at 500 aM, and detected directly in real-time using the dual-wavelength (λ_ex = 488 and 635 nm) laser-induced fluorescence detection system. The kinetics of the protein-protein interactions were examined at different temperatures (12-32 °C). At concentrations in the aM range, the number of bound complex molecules through the protein-protein interaction decreased gradually with time at a given temperature, and increased with decreasing temperature at a set time. A high concentration (above 500 pM) of the protein sample caused aggregation and nonspecific binding of the protein molecules, even though the protein molecules were not an example of complementary binding. The results demonstrated that the real-time kinetics of a protein-protein interaction could be analyzed effectively at the single-molecule level without any time delay using the real-time dual-color detection system.     

Dynamic control of protein-protein interactions

The capability to selectively and reversibly control protein-protein interactions in antibody-doped polypyrrole (PPy) was accomplished by changing the voltage applied to the polymer. Polypyrrole was doped with sulfate polyanions and monoclonal anti-human fibronectin antibodies (alphaFN). The ability to toggle the binding and dissociation of fibronectin (FN) to alphaFN-doped polypyrrole was demonstrated. Staircase potential electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (SPEIS) was performed to characterize the impedance and charge transfer characteristics of the alphaFN-doped PPy as a function of applied voltage, frequency, and FN concentration. Impedance measurements indicated oxidation of alphaFN-doped PPy promoted selective binding of FN to alphaFN antibodies and reduction of the polymer films facilitated FN dissociation. Moreover, SPEIS measurements suggested that the apparent reversibility of antigen binding to antibody-doped PPy is not due to the suppression of hydrophobic binding forces between antibody and antigen. Instead, our data indicate that reversible antigen binding to antibody-doped PPy can be attributed to the minimization of charge in the polymer films during oxidation and reduction. Furthermore, alphaFN-doped PPy was utilized to collect real-time, dynamic measurements of varying FN concentrations in solution by repeatedly binding and releasing FN. Our data demonstrate that antibody-doped PPy represents an electrically controllable sensing platform which can be exploited to collect rapid, repeated measurements of protein concentrations with molecular specificity.     

Photochemically-activated probes of protein-protein interactions

The activity of light-activatable ("caged") compounds can be temporally and spatially controlled, thereby providing a means to interrogate intracellular biochemical pathways as a function of time and space. Nearly all caged peptides contain photocleavable groups positioned on the side chains of key residues. We describe an alternative active site targeted strategy that disrupts the interaction between the protein target (SH2 domain, kinase, and proteinase) and a critical amide NH moiety of the peptide probe.     

Energy design for protein-protein interactions

Proteins bind to other proteins efficiently and specifically to carry on many cell functions such as signaling, activation, transport, enzymatic reactions, and more. To determine the geometry and strength of binding of a protein pair, an energy function is required. An algorithm to design an optimal energy function, based on empirical data of protein complexes, is proposed and applied. Emphasis is made on negative design in which incorrect geometries are presented to the algorithm that learns to avoid them. For the docking problem the search for plausible geometries can be performed exhaustively. The possible geometries of the complex are generated on a grid with the help of a fast Fourier transform algorithm. A novel formulation of negative design makes it possible to investigate iteratively hundreds of millions of negative examples while monotonically improving the quality of the potential. Experimental structures for 640 protein complexes are used to generate positive and negative examples for learning parameters. The algorithm designed in this work finds the correct binding structure as the lowest energy minimum in 318 cases of the 640 examples. Further benchmarks on independent sets confirm the significant capacity of the scoring function to recognize correct modes of interactions.     

Chemical control over protein-protein interactions: beyond inhibitors

Protein-protein interactions have become attractive drug targets and recent studies suggest that these interfaces may be amenable to inhibition by small molecules. However, blocking specific interactions may not be the only way of manipulating the extensive network of interacting proteins. Recently, several approaches have emerged for promoting these interactions rather than inhibiting them. Typically, these strategies employ a bifunctional ligand to simultaneously bind two targets, forcing their juxtaposition. Chemically "riveting" specific protein contacts can reveal important aspects of regulation, such as the consequences of stable dimerization or the effects of prolonged dwell time. Moreover, in some cases, entirely new functions arise when two proteins, which normally do not interact, are brought into close proximity with one another. Together with inhibitors, bifunctional molecules are part of a growing toolbox of chemical probes that can be used to reversibly and selectively control the interact-ome. Using these reagents, new insights into the dynamics of protein-protein interactions and their importance in biology are beginning to emerge. Future hurdles in this area lie in the development of robust synthetic platforms for rapidly generating compounds to meet the challenges of diverse protein-protein interfaces.     

An agent-based system to discover protein-protein interactions, identify protein complexes and proteins with multiple peptide mass fingerprints

Proteins "work together" by actually binding to form multicomponent complexes that carry out specific functions. Proteomic analyses based on the mass spectrum are now key methods to determine the components in protein complexes. The protein-protein interaction or functional association may be known to exist among the extracted protein spots while analyzing the proteins on the 2D gel. In this study, we develop an agent-based system, namely AgentMultiProtIdent, which integrated two protein identification tools and a variety of databases storing relations among proteins and used to discover protein-protein interactions and protein functional associations, and identify protein complexes and proteins with multiple peptide mass fingerprints as input. The system takes Multiple Peptide Mass Fingerprints (PMFs) as a whole in the protein complex or protein identification. With the relations among proteins, it may greatly improve the accuracy of identification of protein complexes. Also, possible relationship of the multiple peptide mass fingerprints, such as ontology relation, can be discovered by our system, especially in the identification of protein complexes. The agent-based system is now available on the Web at http://dbms104.csie.ncu.edu.tw/ approximately protein/NEW2/.     

Analysis of protein-protein interactions with a multi-capillary electrophoresis instrument

Protein-protein interactions were analyzed by zone electrophoresis of premixed equilibrium mixtures of a fluorescence-labeled protein at a constant concentration and unlabeled protein at a variety of concentrations using a 96-CE instrument equipped with a LIF detector. The interactions between labeled-con A versus succinylated ovalbumin, labeled-trypsin versus four proteinaceous trypsin inhibitors and labeled-insulin versus seven anti-insulin monoclonal antibodies were analyzed using a dual buffer system, in which a 60 mM borate-Na buffer (pH 9.35) was used as electrophoresis buffer and 60 mM MOPS-Na (pH 7.35) containing 0.1% Tween 20 was used as a sample buffer. The dual buffer system allowed fast and reproducible analyses of interactions at a physiological pH using uncoated fused-silica capillaries. The change in the mobility moment, the first statistical moment of an electropherogram on the mobility axis (Shimura, K., Uchiyama, N., Enomoto, M., Matsumoto, H., Kasai, K., Anal. Chem. 2005, 77, 564-572), of the labeled proteins were analyzed as a function of the concentration of unlabeled proteins. The dissociation constants for seven antibodies ranging from sub nanomolar to micromolar was determined based on the results of one cycle of parallel electrophoresis runs, which completed in 30 min using 20 pmol (120 ng) of labeled insulin and 5 pmol (750 ng) each of the mAb.     

Studying protein-protein interactions using peptide arrays

Screening of arrays and libraries of compounds is well-established as a high-throughput method for detecting and analyzing interactions in both biological and chemical systems. Arrays and libraries can be composed from various types of molecules, ranging from small organic compounds to DNA, proteins and peptides. The applications of libraries for detecting and characterizing biological interactions are wide and diverse, including for example epitope mapping, carbohydrate arrays, enzyme binding and protein-protein interactions. Here, we will focus on the use of peptide arrays to study protein-protein interactions. Characterization of protein-protein interactions is crucial for understanding cell functionality. Using peptides, it is possible to map the precise binding sites in such complexes. Peptide array libraries usually contain partly overlapping peptides derived from the sequence of one protein from the complex of interest. The peptides are attached to a solid support using various techniques such as SPOT-synthesis and photolithography. Then, the array is incubated with the partner protein from the complex of interest. Finally, the detection of the protein-bound peptides is carried out by using immunodetection assays. Peptide array screening is semi-quantitative, and quantitative studies with selected peptides in solution are required to validate and complement the screening results. These studies can improve our fundamental understanding of cellular processes by characterizing amino acid patterns of protein-protein interactions, which may even develop into prediction algorithms. The binding peptides can then serve as a basis for the design of drugs that inhibit or activate the target protein-protein interactions. In the current review, we will introduce the recent work on this subject performed in our and in other laboratories. We will discuss the applications, advantages and disadvantages of using peptide arrays as a tool to study protein-protein interactions.