A comparison of silver stain and SYPRO Ruby Protein Gel Stain with respect to protein detection in two-dimensional gels and identification by peptide mass profiling

Proteomic projects are often focused on the discovery of differentially expressed proteins between control and experimental samples. Most laboratories choose the approach of running two-dimensional (2-D) gels, analyzing them and identifying the differentially expressed proteins by in-gel digestion and mass spectrometry. To date, the available stains for visualizing proteins on 2-D gels have been less than ideal for these projects because of poor detection sensitivity (Coomassie blue stain) or poor peptide recovery from in-gel digests and mass spectrometry (silver stain), unless extra destaining and washing steps are included in the protocol. In addition, the limited dynamic range of these stains has made it difficult to rigorously and reliably determine subtle differences in protein quantities. SYPRO Ruby Protein Gel Stain is a novel, ruthenium-based fluorescent dye for the detection of proteins in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) gels that has properties making it well suited to high-throughput proteomics projects. The advantages of SYPRO Ruby Protein Gel Stain relative to silver stain demonstrated in this study include a broad linear dynamic range and enhanced recovery of peptides from in-gel digests for matrix assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight (MALDI-TOF) mass spectrometry.     

Ultrasensitive fluorescence protein detection in isoelectric focusing gels using a ruthenium metal chelate stain

SYPRO Ruby IEF Protein Gel Stain is an ultrasensitive, luminescent stain optimized for the analysis of protein in isoelectric focusing gels. Proteins are stained in a ruthenium-containing metal complex overnight and then rinsed in distilled water for 2 h. Stained proteins can be excited by ultraviolet light of about 302 nm (UV-B transilluminator) or with visible light of about 470 nm. Fluorescence emission of the dye is maximal at approximately 610 nm. The sensitivity of the SYPRO Ruby IEF protein gel stain is superior to colloidal Coomassie blue stain and the highest sensitivity silver staining procedures available. The SYPRO Ruby IEF protein gel stain is suitable for staining proteins in nondenaturing or denaturing carrier ampholyte isoelectric focusing and immobilized pH gradient gel electrophoresis. The stain is compatible with N,N'-methylenebisacrylamide or piperazine diacylamide cross-linked polyacrylamide gels as well as with agarose gels and high tensile strength Duracryl gels. The stain does not contain extraneous chemicals (formaldehyde, glutaraldehyde, Tween-20) that frequently interfere with peptide identification in mass spectrometry. Successful identification of stained proteins by peptide mass profiling is demonstrated.     

Functional characterization of two-dimensional gel-separated proteins using sequential staining

Proteins separated by two-dimensional (2-D) gel electrophoresis can be visualized using various protein staining methods. This is followed by downstream procedures, such as image analysis, gel spot cutting, protein digestion, and mass spectrometry (MS), to characterize protein expression profiles within cells, tissues, organisms, or body fluids. Characterizing specific post-translational modifications on proteins using MS of peptide fragments is difficult and labor-intensive. Recently, specific staining methods have been developed and merged into the 2-D gel platform so that not only general protein patterns but also patterns of phosphorylated and glycosylated proteins can be obtained. We used the new Pro-Q Diamond phosphoprotein dye technology for the fluorescent detection of phosphoproteins directly in 2-D gels of mouse leukocyte proteins, and Pro-Q Emerald 488 glycoprotein dye to detect glycoproteins. These two fluorescent stains are compatible with general protein stains, such as SYPRO Ruby stain. We devised a sequential procedure using Pro-Q Diamond (phosphoprotein), followed by Pro-Q Emerald 488 (glycoprotein), followed by SYPRO Ruby stain (general protein stain), and finally silver stain for total protein profile. This multiple staining of the proteins in a single gel provided parallel determination of protein expression and preliminary characterization of post-translational modifications of proteins in individual spots on 2-D gels. Although this method does not provide the same degree of certainty as traditional MS methods of characterizing post-translational modifications, it is much simpler, faster, and does not require sophisticated equipment and expertise in MS.     

Quantitative evaluation of sample application methods for semipreparative separations of basic proteins by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis

The use of cup-loading for sample application has become widely used in two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) for resolution of basic proteins, but no side-by-side quantitative study has been published which compares cup-loading with the alternative passive and active rehydration methods to fully promote one type of loading method over another. Replicate 2-D gels from each loading method were quantitatively evaluated for gel-to-gel reproducibility using IPG 6-11 strips and semipreparative protein loads (300 microg). Gels were stained with SYPRO Ruby and analyzed with PDQuest. An inexpensive home-made assembly for cup-loading was used with the Protean IEF Cell for separation of whole cell extracts from the archaeon, Sulfolobus solfataricus. Cup-loading was determined to be far superior for IPG 6-11 separations than active or passive rehydration methods. Cup-loading consistently produced the greatest number of detectable spots, the best spot matching efficiency (56%), lowest spot quantity variations (28% coefficient of variation, CV), and the best-looking gels qualitatively. The least satisfactory results were obtained with active rehydration, followed closely by passive rehydration in off-line tubes. Passive rehydration experiments, performed using an on-line isoelectric focusing (IEF) tray, produced comparable spot numbers to cup-loading (84%), with 55% of the spots having higher intensity but 10% more spot quantity variance than cup-loading.     

Background-free, high sensitivity staining of proteins in one- and two-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels using a luminescent ruthenium complex

SYPRO Ruby dye is a permanent stain comprised of ruthenium as part of an organic complex that interacts noncovalently with proteins. SYPRO Ruby Protein Gel Stain provides a sensitive, gentle, fluorescence-based method for detecting proteins in one-dimensional and two-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels. Proteins are fixed, stained from 3h to overnight and then rinsed in deionized water or dilute methanol/acetic acid solution for 30 min. The stain can be visualized using a wide range of excitation sources commonly used in image analysis systems including a 302 nm UV-B transilluminator, 473 nm second harmonic generation (SHG) laser, 488 nm argon-ion laser, 532 nm yttrium-aluminum-garnet (YAG) laser, xenon arc lamp, blue fluorescent light bulb or blue light-emitting diode (LED). The sensitivity of SYPRO Ruby Protein Gel Stain is superior to colloidal Coomassie Brilliant Blue (CBB) stain or monobromobimane labeling and comparable with the highest sensitivity silver or zinc-imidazole staining procedures available. The linear dynamic range of SYPRO Ruby Protein Gel stain extends over three orders of magnitude, which is vastly superior to silver, zinc-imidazole, monobromobimane and CBB stain. The fluorescent stain does not contain superfluous chemicals (formaldehyde, glutaraldehyde, Tween-20) that frequently interfere with peptide identification in mass spectrometry. While peptide mass profiles are severely altered in protein samples prelabeled with monobromobimane, successful identification of proteins by peptide mass profiling using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry was easily performed after protein detection with SYPRO Ruby Protein Gel stain.     

Comparison of fluorescent stains: relative photostability and differential staining of proteins in two-dimensional gels

The fluorescence of proteins stained with Deep Purple and SYPRO Ruby was measured over a time course of UV transillumination to determine the relative photostability of each stain. Mean spot fluorescence (n = 200 matched spots) in gels stained with Deep Purple decreased 27% following 2 min of UV transillumination, compared to SYPRO Ruby, which decreased 17%. After 19 min, an 83% decrease in Deep Purple fluorescence was observed, compared to 44% for SYPRO Ruby. By interpolation, the half-life of Deep Purple fluorescence was estimated to be approximately 6 min. The half-life of SYPRO Ruby fluorescence was not reached during the 19 min time course. Further, differential staining of proteins was observed in gels stained with Deep Purple and SYPRO Ruby as compared to colloidal Coomassie Brilliant Blue and silver staining.     

High-sensitivity staining of proteins for one- and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis using post migration covalent staining with a ruthenium fluorophore

This paper describes the use of a ruthenium complex ((bis(2,2'-bipyridine)-4'-methyl-4-carboxybipyridine-ruthenium-N-succidimyl ester-bis(hexafluorophosphate), abbreviated below as ASCQ_Ru) commercially available and chemically pure. This new ruthenium complex ASCQ_Ru brings an activated ester, allowing the selective acylation of amino acid side chain amines for the post migration staining of proteins separated in 1-DE and 2-DE. The protocol used is a simple three-step protocol fixing the proteins in the gel, staining and then washing, as no lengthy destaining step is required. First the critical staining step was optimized. Although in solution the best described pH for acylating proteins with this reagent is phosphate buffer at pH 7.0, we found that best medium for in-gel staining is unbuffered ACN/water solution (20/80 v/v). The two other steps are less critical and classical conditions are satisfactory: fixing with 7% acetic acid/10% ethanol solution and washing four times for 10 min with water. Sensitivity tests were performed using 1-DE on protein molecular weight markers. We obtained a higher sensitivity than SYPRO Ruby with a detection limit of 80 pg of protein per well. However, contrary to SYPRO Ruby, ASCQ_Ru exhibits a logarithmic dependency on the amount of protein. The dynamic range is similar to SYPRO Ruby and is estimated between three and four orders of magnitude. Finally, the efficiency of the post migration ASCQ_Ru staining for 2-D gel separation is demonstrated on the whole protein extract from human colon carcinoma cells lines HCT 116. ASCQ_Ru gave the highest number of spot detected compared to other common stains Colloidal CBB, SYPRO Ruby and Deep Purple.     

Simultaneous, two-color fluorescence detection of total protein profiles and beta-glucuronidase activity in polyacrylamide gel

A dichromatic method for measuring the specific activity of beta-glucuronidase from complex cell homogenates or partially purified protein fractions is presented. Dual fluorescence is achieved by using the green emitting fluorogenic substrate ELF 97 beta-D-glucuronide to detect beta-glucuronidase activity, followed by the red emitting SYPRO Ruby protein gel stain or SYPRO Ruby IEF gel stain to detect the remaining proteins in the electrophoretic profile. Both ELF 97 alcohol, the highly fluorescent hydrolytic product generated from the enzyme substrate, and the SYPRO Ruby total protein stains are maximally excited by ultraviolet illumination. ELF 97 alcohol emits maximally at 525 nm while the SYPRO Ruby dyes emit maximally at 610 nm. Since ELF 97 beta-glucuronide is a precipitating substrate, it allows precise localization of beta-glucuronidase activity with minimal band diffusion. The staining method is simple and direct, without the requirement for ancillary coupling reactions. Dichromatic protein detection is demonstrated after sodium dodecyl sulfate(SDS)-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, carrier ampholyte-mediated isoelectric focusing or two-dimensional gel electrophoresis.     

2-D native-PAGE/SDS-PAGE visualization of an oligomer's subunits: application to the analysis of IgG

A 2-D native-PAGE/SDS-PAGE method for detecting the subunit components of protein oligomers at low picomole sensitivity is presented. IgG was electrophoresed in a native acidic polyacrylamide gel in amounts ranging from 51 pmol to 60 fmol. Silver-staining (native fast silver stain, ammoniacal silver stain, permanganate silver stain), Coomassie-staining (R-250, G-250), metal ion-reverse-staining (zinc, copper), and fluorescent chromophore-staining (SYPRO Ruby) methods were used to visualize the IgG oligomers. The protein zones were then excised, separated by SDS-PAGE, and subunits visualized with a permanganate silver stain. The Coomassie R-250/permanganate silver-staining combination detected IgG subunits using 2 pmol of sample. Coomassie G-250 and native fast silver staining in the first-dimensional gel produced detectable subunits in the second-dimensional separation at 3 and 13 pmol, respectively. Staining with silver (ammoniacal, permanganate), copper, zinc, or SYPRO Ruby in the first-dimensional gel did not produce discernible subunits in the second-dimensional gels due to protein streaking or protein immobilization in the native gel. When using a 2-D native-PAGE/SDS-PAGE system, Coomassie staining of the first-dimensional native gel combined with permanganate silver staining of the second-dimensional denaturing gel provides the most sensitive method (2-3 pmol) for visualizing constituent subunits from their oligomeric assemblies.     

Dialysis-assisted two-dimensional gel electrophoresis

2-DE is an important tool in proteomics research. However, intrinsic gel-to-gel variability of 2-DE often masks the biological differences between the samples and compromises quantitative comparison of protein expression levels. Here, we describe a modification of 2-DE that results in improved matching and quantification of proteins. This was accomplished by performing IEF of two samples in two IPG strips separated by a dialysis membrane. After IEF running, the strips were separated and the SDS-PAGE dimension was accomplished on two individual gels. After gel staining with CBB, ImageMaster 2D Platinum software (Amersham) was used for spot detection and quantification. Analysis of protein extracts from C2C12 myoblasts by this method resulted in 99% spot-matching efficiency and CV in stain intensity (% volume) was less than 0.5 for 98% of spots. We conclude that this technique, called dialysis-assisted gel electrophoresis, gives superior spot matching and quantitative reproducibility compared to IEF conducted on separate strips.     

Fluorescence detection and quantitation of recombinant proteins containing oligohistidine tag sequences directly in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels

Two fluorophore-nitrilotriacetic acid conjugates, Pro-Q Sapphire 365 and Pro-Q Sapphire 488 oligohistidine gel stains, have been developed for the fluorescence detection of fusion proteins containing oligohistidine tags directly in sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gels, without the requirement for electroblotting, reporter enzymes or secondary detection reagents. Pro-Q Sapphire 365 oligohistidine gel stain exhibits bright-blue fluorescence (emission maximum = 450 nm) when illuminated with UV-A or UV-B light from a standard ultraviolet transilluminator. Pro-Q Sapphire 488 oligohistidine gel stain exhibits bright-green fluorescence (emission maximum = 515 nm) when illuminated with visible light from a laser-based gel scanner equipped with a 470 nm second-harmonic generation (SHG) or 488 nm argon-ion laser source. Typically, 25-65 ng of oligohistidine-tagged fusion protein in whole cell lysates is detectable using either stain. After documenting the fluorescence signal from the Pro-Q Sapphire dyes, gels may be post-stained with the red-fluorescent SYPRO Ruby protein gel stain in order to reveal the total protein pattern.     

Optimized conditions for diluting and reusing a fluorescent protein gel stain

This study elucidates the optimum conditions at the minimum cost for using SYPRO Ruby protein gel stain. It deals with the effects of gel fixation and staining times, as well as dilution and reuse of SYPRO Ruby protein gel stain in one-dimensional (1-D) gels. Signal strength and dynamic range were highest in gels that were fixed thoroughly before staining, followed by overnight staining. Using the optimized protocol, dilution or reuse of the stain reduces the dynamic range and signal intensity. Sensitivity remains high if the stain is reused up to two times, but signal intensity is reduced up to 2.5-fold in twice used stain. Sensitivity also remains high if the stain is diluted 1:2 in water, but signal intensity is reduced up to 6-fold. Of the two options, reuse or dilution, reuse better retains signal intensity and dynamic range.     

Fluorescent staining of protein in SDS polyacrylamide gels by salicylaldehyde azine

As a noncovalent fluorescence probe, in this study, salicylaldehyde azine (SA) was introduced as a sensitive fluorescence‐based dye for detecting proteins both in 1D and 2D polyacrylamide electrophoresis gels. Down to 0.2 ng of single protein band could be detected within 1 h, which is similar to that of glutaraldehyde‐silver stain, but approximately four times higher than that of SYPRO Ruby fluorescent stain. Furthermore, comparative analysis of the MS compatibility of SA stain with SYPRO Ruby stain indicated that SA stain is compatible with the downstream of protein identification by LC‐MS/MS. Additionally, the probable mechanism of the SA stain was investigated by molecular docking. The results demonstrated that the interaction between SA and protein was mainly contributed by hydrogen bonding and hydrophobic forces.     

A statistical comparison of silver and SYPRO Ruby staining for proteomic analysis

Silver staining has been the method most commonly employed for high sensitivity staining of proteins following two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Whilst this method offers detection in the nanogram range it does have major drawbacks including a lack of linearity, nonstoichiometric staining of proteins, a lack of compatibility with the microchemical preparation of proteins for identification by mass spectrometric techniques, and a highly subjective assessment of the staining endpoint. SYPRO Ruby is a relatively new, ruthenium complex-based stain which is reported to offer advantages over silver, particularly in overcoming the limitations cited above. We describe a series of experiments where several protein staining procedures commonly employed are compared. To enable optimization of the in situ digestion procedure, a statistical approach has been undertaken. The effects of a variety of staining, digestion, and analysis protocols on the downstream processing of a test radiolabeled protein were studied. The data confirms that as well as offering sensitivity similar to silver, SYPRO Ruby staining is reproducible, linear, and offers a higher level of compatibility with the identification of proteins by mass spectrometry.     

Detection of glycoproteins in polyacrylamide gels and on electroblots using Pro-Q Emerald 488 dye,a fluorescent periodate Schiff-base stain

Pro-Q Emerald 488 glycoprotein stain reacts with periodic acid-oxidized carbohydrate groups, generating a bright green-fluorescent signal on glycoproteins. The stain permits detection of less than 5-18 ng of glycoprotein per band, depending upon the nature and the degree of protein glycosylation, making it roughly 8-16-fold more sensitive than the standard colorimetric periodic acid-Schiff base method using acidic fuchsin dye (pararosaniline). The green-fluorescent signal from Pro-Q Emerald 488 stain may optimally be visualized using charge-coupled device/xenon arc lamp-based imaging systems or 470-488 nm laser-based gel scanners. Though glycoprotein detection may be performed on transfer membranes, direct detection in gels avoids electroblotting and the specificity of staining is better in gels. After detecting glycoproteins with Pro-Q Emerald 488 dye, total protein profiles may subsequently be detected using SYPRO Ruby protein gel stain. Using computer-assisted registration techniques, images may then be merged to generate differential display maps.     

Software-induced variance in two-dimensional gel electrophoresis image analysis

Experimental variability in 2-DE is well documented, but little attention has been paid to variability arising from postexperimental quantitative analyses using various 2-DE software packages. The performance of two 2-DE analysis software programs, Phoretix 2D Expression v2004 (Expression) and PDQuest 7.2 (PDQuest), was evaluated in this study. All available background subtraction and smoothing algorithms were tested using both data generated from one single 2-DE gel image, thus excluding experimental variance, and with authentic sets of replicate gels (n = 5). A slight shift of the image boundaries (the "cropping area") caused both programs to induce variance in protein spot quantification of otherwise identical gel images. The resulting variance for PDQuest (CV(mean) = 8%) was approximately twice that for Expression (CV(mean) = 4%). In authentic sets of replicate 2-DE gels (n = 5), the experimental variance confounded the software-induced variance to some extent. However, Expression still outperformed PDQuest, which exhibited software-induced variance as high as 25% of the total observed variance. Surprisingly, the complete omission of background subtraction algorithms resulted in the least amount of software-based variance. These data indicate that 2-DE gel analysis software constitutes a significant source of the variance observed in quantitative proteomics, and that the use of background subtraction algorithms can further increase the variance.     

Adaptive contrast enhancement of two-dimensional electrophoretic protein gel images facilitates visualization, orientation and alignment

2-DE is a powerful technique to discriminate post-translationally modified protein isoforms. However, all steps of 2-DE preparation and gel-staining may introduce unwanted artefacts, including inconsistent variation of background intensity over the entire 2-DE gel image. Background intensity variations limit the accuracy of gel orientation, overlay alignment and spot detection methods. We present a compact and efficient denoising algorithm that adaptively enhances the image contrast and then, through thresholding and median filtering, removes the gray-scale range covering the background. Applicability of the algorithm is demonstrated on immunoblots, isotope-labeled gels, and protein-stained gels. Validation is performed in contexts of (i) automatic gel orientation based on Hough transformation, (ii) overlay alignment based on cross correlation and (iii) spot detection. In gel stains with low background variability, e.g. Sypro Ruby, denoising will lower the spot detection sensitivity. In gel regions with high background levels denoising enhances spot detection. We propose that the denoising algorithm prepares images with high background for further automatic analysis, without requiring manual input on a gel-to-gel basis.     

Improved conditions for fluorescent staining of proteins with 4,4′‐dianilino‐1,1′‐binaphthyl‐5,5′‐disulfonic acid in SDS‐PAGE

A simple and sensitive fluorescent staining method for the detection of proteins in SDS‐PAGE, namely IB (improved 4,4′‐dianilino‐1,1′‐binaphthyl‐5,5′‐disulfonic acid) stain, is described. Non‐covalent hydrophobic probe 4,4′‐dianilino‐1,1′‐binaphthyl‐5,5′‐disulfonic acid was applied as a fluorescent dye, which can bind to hydrophobic sites in proteins non‐specifically. As low as 1 ng of protein band can be detected briefly by 30 min washing followed by 15 min staining without the aiding of stop or destaining step. The sensitivity of the new presented protocol is similar to that of SYPRO Ruby, which has been widely accepted in proteomic research. Comparative analysis of the MS compatibility of IB stain and SYPRO Ruby stain allowed us to address that IB stain is compatible with the downstream of protein identification by PMF.     

Practical aspects of fluorescent staining for proteomic applications

SYPRO Orange and SYPRO Ruby staining methods, modified for use with large-format two dimensional (2-D) gels, are compared to the manufacturer's recommended protocols to determine sensitivity and reproducibility of the new methods. This study examines the critical aspects of fixation, washing, and staining to develop an optimized fluorescent staining method. It was determined that careful control of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) levels and pH in the gel was critical for successful staining with SYPRO Orange. Overnight fixation in 40% ethanol/2% acetic acid/0.0005% SDS preserved protein content, eliminated ampholyte-generated staining artifacts, and had no detrimental effects on staining. Three one-hour washes in 2% acetic acid/0.0005% SDS, followed by staining with SYPRO Orange diluted 1:5,000 with washing solution for 3 or more hours, produced high sensitivity, low background images using a STORM 860 laser scanner. Gels viewed two years after staining showed no significant changes with respect to the initial protein patterns, and allowed successful mass spectrometric postgel characterization of protein spots. Protocol changes applied to SYPRO Ruby staining improved the contrast of STORM 860-generated images, but had little impact on staining sensitivity. A comparison of the cost benefits of staining with SYPRO Orange vs. SYPRO Ruby is also discussed.     

Analysis of protein/polypeptide interactions in human plasma using nondenaturing micro-2-DE followed by 3-D SDS-PAGE and MS

Previously, we have reported on the analysis of human plasma proteins on a nondenaturing micro-2-DE (mu2-DE) gel, using in-gel digestion followed by MALDI-MS and PMF [1]. Many of the spots on the mu2-DE gel showed apparent masses much larger than the calculated masses of their assigned polypeptides, suggesting noncovalent or covalent interactions between the polypeptides. In the present study, we aimed to further analyze the plasma protein spots on a nondenaturing mu2-DE gel, on which protein/polypeptide interactions have been suggested. The proteins in the spots were extracted under alkaline conditions and subjected to 3-D separation using SDS-PAGE in microslab gel format (muSDS gel) with or without the sample treatment of reduction-alkylation. The clear bands in each lane of the muSDS gels demonstrated the successful extraction of proteins from the relevant gel spot and visualized the relative contents of the polypeptides in the spot. Most of the bands were assigned by in-gel digestion followed by MALDI-MS and PMF (MASCOT/Swiss-Prot). The large discrepancy between the apparent mass value of a protein spot and the estimated mass values of the polypeptide bands on a nonreducing muSDS gel strongly suggested noncovalent polypeptide interactions. The differences in the polypeptide separation patterns on the muSDS gels, between with and without the treatment of reduction-alkylation, confirmed polypeptide disulfide bonding. The method employed here, aiming to integrate information on the proteins separated on nondenaturing 2-DE gels with that on the interactions between polypeptides, would help the comprehensive understanding of complex protein systems.