Sampling statistics and considerations for single-shot analysis using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy

A statistical analysis of single-shot spectral data is reported for laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS). Fluctuations in both atomic emission and plasma continuum emission are investigated in concert for a homogenous gaseous flow, and fluctuations in plasma temperature are reported based on iron atomic emission in an aerosol-seeded flow. Threshold irradiance for plasma initiation and plasma absorption were investigated for pure gaseous and aerosol streams, with detailed statistical measurements performed as a function of pulse energy in the breakdown regime. The ratio of the analyte atomic emission intensity to the continuum emission intensity (peak/base) provided a robust signal for single-shot LIBS analysis. Moreover, at optimal temporal delay, the precision of the LIBS signal was maximized for pulse energies within the saturation regime with respect to plasma absorption of incident energy. Finally, single-shot temperature measurements were analyzed, leading to the conclusion that spatial variations in the plasma volume formation and subsequent plasma emission collection, play important roles in the overall shot-to-shot precision of the LIBS technique for gaseous and aerosol analysis.     

A compact and portable laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy instrument for single and double pulse applications

We present LIBS experimental results that demonstrate the use of a newly developed, compact, versatile pulsed laser source in material analysis related to art and archaeological applications in view of research aiming at the development of portable LIBS instrumentation. LIBS qualitative analysis measurements were performed on various samples and objects, and the spectra were recorded in gated and non-gated modes. The latter is important because of advantages arising from size and cost reduction when using simple, compact spectrograph-CCD detection systems over the standard ICCD-based configurations.     

The development of fieldable laser-induced breakdown spectrometer: No limits on the horizon

In this review, new trends in the development of fieldable instrumentation based on laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) and its recent applications is presented. Depending on the LIBS configuration we will distinguish between portable, remote and stand-off instruments. Moreover, the development of portable systems gives greater flexibility and also increases the range of LIBS applications. In general, portable instruments are employed in close-contact applications like immovable artworks, contaminated soils and environmental diagnostic, while remote and stand-off instruments are normally used in analytical applications at distances where access to the sample is difficult or hazardous. Although remote and stand-off instruments are both used for chemical analysis at distances, the instrumental configurations are completely different. In remote analysis, an optical fiber is employed to deliver the laser energy a certain distance. This approach has been usually restricted to industrial applications, bulk analysis in water, geological measurements and chemical analysis on nuclear stations. In the case of stand-off applications, the laser beam and the returning plasma light are transmitted in an open-path configuration. In this article we also discuss the instrumental requirements in the design of remote and stand-off instruments.     

Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy applied on low-alloyed zinc samples

The use of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy for chemical analysis in the single-shot regime has been investigated for low-alloyed zinc samples. Several parameters that are important for plasma formation has been investigated and their importance for accurate and precise single-shot measurements are discussed. The standard deviation is compared for measurements performed on a day-to-day basis during four days and for a measurement series consisting of five measurements in one day. It was found that the spread is not larger for a measurement series performed on a single day compared to day-to-day basis. The influence of local spatial inhomogeneities of the alloy elements in the sample concentrations is discussed in this context and the reference samples have been investigated with a scanning electron microscopy and light optical microscopy to verify this. It is found that the relative standard deviation of the signal depends to large extent on the sample homogeneity at low concentrations. The importance of spatial averaging for LIBS when doing calibrations is established in this case. The relative error for single-shot measurements will depend on the slope of the analytical curve and increase at lower concentrations.     

Laser induced breakdown spectrometry with an échelle spectrometer and intensified charge coupled device detection

The combination of an échelle spectrometer with a time-gated intensified charge coupled device (ICCD) camera for simultaneous measurements of spectral lines in wide ranges of the optical spectrum is presented. The analytical and diagnostic power of the échelle-ICCD combination is demonstrated by laser induced breakdown spectrometry (LIBS) of solid samples. The apparatus allows complete elemental analysis by single shots as the spectral lines of major, minor and trace constituents are measured simultaneously. The analytical precision and detection limits in single shot measurements are improved by the evaluation of many lines for each element. Further, plasma parameters, such as the plasma temperatures, can be determined from the same spectrum and, if necessary, used for normalization of the analyte line intensities.     

Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy—From research to industry,new frontiers for process control

This paper presents R&D activities to explore new laser parameter ranges in pulse energy, time and space for laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy. The collinear double pulse effect, which is well studied for pulses of typically several 100 mJ energy can also be observed for laser pulses having a pulse energy two orders of magnitude lower. In this case, maximum line emission intensity occurs at interpulse separations of a few 100 ns. Temporal pulse tailoring to improve the performance of LIBS is only a first step. A comprehensive approach includes spatial pulse shaping to generate craters with predefined shape or to improve spatial averaging for the analysis of inhomogeneous samples. High performance components for LIBS systems such as spectrometers, electronics and sample stands are required to enable industrial applications. Latest developments offer wide-band single spectra acquisition with a high spectral resolution at a measuring frequency of up to 500 Hz. The next generation of multi-channel integrator electronics for Paschen–Runge spectrometers equipped with PMT detectors will further push the measuring speed to up to 5 kHz, thus opening a new area of high-speed LIBS microanalysis. Novel LIBS devices for various industrial applications presented include analysis of metallic process control samples with scale layers, on-site analysis of slag samples in secondary metallurgy, high-speed identification of Al scrap, mix-up detection of pipe fittings as well as recent work towards in-process identification of hot coils in a rolling mill.     

Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy in open-path configuration for the analysis of distant objects

A review of recent results on stand-off Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) analysis and applications is presented. Stand-off LIBS was suggested for elemental analysis of materials located in environments where any physical access was not possible but optical access could be envisaged. This review only refers to the use of the open-path LIBS configuration in which the laser beam and the returning plasma light are transmitted through the atmosphere. It does not present the results obtained with a transportation of the laser pulses to the target through an optical fiber. Open-path stand-off LIBS has mainly been used with nanosecond laser pulses for solid sample analysis at distances of tens of meters. Liquid samples have also been analyzed at distances of a few meters. The distances achievable depend on many parameters including the laser characteristics (pulse energy and power, beam divergence, spatial profile) and the optical system used to focus the pulses at a distance. A large variety of laser focusing systems have been employed for stand-off analysis comprising refracting or reflecting telescope. Efficient collection of the plasma light is also needed to obtain analytically useful signals. For stand-off LIBS analysis, a lens or a mirror is required to increase the solid angle over which the plasma light can be collected. The light collection device can be either at an angle from the laser beam path or collinear with the optical axis of the system used to focus the laser pulses on the target surface. These different configurations have been used depending on the application such as rapid sorting of metal samples, identification of material in nuclear industry, process control and monitoring in metallurgical industry, applications in future planetary missions, detection of environmental contamination or cleaning of objects of cultural heritage. Recent stand-off analyses of metal samples have been reported using femtosecond laser pulses to extend LIBS capabilities to very long distances. The high-power densities achievable with these laser pulses can also induce self-guided filaments in the atmosphere which produce LIBS excitation of a sample. The first results obtained with remote filament-induced breakdown spectroscopy predict sample analysis at kilometer ranges.     

LIBS using dual- and ultra-short laser pulses

Pre-ablation dual-pulse LIBS enhancement data for copper, brass and steel using ns laser excitation are reported. Although large enhancements are observed for all samples, the magnitude of the enhancement is matrix dependent. Whereas all of the dual-pulse studies used ns laser excitation we see interesting effects when using ps and fs laser excitation for single-pulse LIBS. LIBS spectra of copper using 1.3 ps and 140 fs laser pulses show much lower background signals compared to ns pulse excitation. Also, the atomic emission decays much more rapidly with time. Because of relatively low backgrounds when using ps and fs pulses, non-gated detection of LIBS is shown to be very effective. The plasma dissipates quickly enough using ps and fs laser pulses, that high pulse rates, up to 1,000 Hz, are effective for increasing the LIBS signal, for a given measurement time. Finally, a simple near-collinear dual-pulse fiber-optic LIBS probe is shown to be useful for enhanced LIBS measurements.     

Comment on “three-dimensional analysis of laser induced plasmas in single and double pulse configuration”

Laser induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) is an effective technique for real-time chemical analysis of samples in the laboratory and in the field. The performance of LIBS can be significantly improved by replacing the conventional LIBS configuration from single pulse laser to double pulse laser ablation. Corsi et al. showed that by firing two lasers with microsecond order delay can increase LIBS sensitivity [M. Corsi, G. Cristoforetti, M. Giuffrida, M. Hidalgo, S. Legnaioli, V. Palleschi, A. Salvetti, E. Tognoni, C. Vallebona, Three-dimensional analysis of laser induced plasmas in single and double pulse configuration, Spectrochimica Acta, Part B 59 (2004) 723–735] [1]. By studying plume evolution, they attribute this enhancement to the faster plume expansion in double pulse laser ablation. Blast wave theory was used in Corsi's paper to explain the higher expansion speed observed in double pulse laser ablation. However, it is questionable whether the blast wave theorem applies in laser ablation where the shockwave is driven by a vapor plume of mass. We introduce an alternative way to explain the faster plume expansion during double pulse laser through a more general thermodynamic relation.     

LIBS using dual- and ultra-short laser pulses

Pre-ablation dual-pulse LIBS enhancement data for copper, brass and steel using ns laser excitation are reported. Although large enhancements are observed for all samples, the magnitude of the enhancement is matrix dependent. Whereas all of the dual-pulse studies used ns laser excitation we see interesting effects when using ps and fs laser excitation for single-pulse LIBS. LIBS spectra of copper using 1.3 ps and 140 fs laser pulses show much lower background signals compared to ns pulse excitation. Also, the atomic emission decays much more rapidly with time. Because of relatively low backgrounds when using ps and fs pulses, non-gated detection of LIBS is shown to be very effective. The plasma dissipates quickly enough using ps and fs laser pulses, that high pulse rates, up to 1000 Hz, are effective for increasing the LIBS signal, for a given measurement time. Finally, a simple near-collinear dual-pulse fiber-optic LIBS probe is shown to be useful for enhanced LIBS measurements. Received: 1 August 2000 / Revised: 2 November 2000 / Accepted: 8 November 2000     

Combined Raman spectrometer/laser-induced breakdown spectrometer for the next ESA mission to Mars

Among the different instruments that have been pre-selected to be on-board the Pasteur payload on ExoMars is the Raman/laser induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) instrument. Raman spectroscopy and LIBS will be integrated into a single instrument sharing many hardware commonalities. An international team under the lead of TNO has been gathered to produce a design concept for a combined Raman spectrometer/LIBS elegant bread-board (EBB). The instrument is based on a specially designed, extremely compact, spectrometer with high resolution over a large wavelength range, suitable for both Raman spectroscopy and LIBS measurements. Low mass, size and power consumption are the main drivers of the instrument's design concept. In this paper, science objectives for the combined instrument are detailed. Background information on Raman spectroscopy and LIBS are presented, focussing on the synergy of these two techniques. In the last section, the instrument concept resulting from the assessment of the feasibility of the combined Raman/LIBS EBB is presented.     

基于双脉冲LIBS结合偏最小二乘回归的稀土元素定量分析

激光诱导击穿光谱(LIBS)是一种以激光为激发源的等离子体发射光谱分析技术,已有将其用于稀土元素的定量分析研究,但由于稀土矿基体差异大、元素含量低,定量分析灵敏度和准确度仍有待提高。通过使用单激光分束构造双脉冲LIBS系统,并结合偏最小二乘回归(PLSR)算法实现对稀土矿石样品中的稀土元素La、Dy、Yb和Y的定量分析。结果表明,双脉冲LIBS结合PLSR可建立更加稳定的定标模型,与常规基本定标法相比,La、Dy、Yb和Y元素的相对均方根预测误差(RMSEP)从0.0061 %、0.0037%、0.0045%、0.0280 %降低至0.0044%、0.0016%、0.0029%、0.0134%,平均相对预测误差(AREP)从10.88%、15.27%、6.42%、17.20%降低至6.67%、3.62%、4.10%、7.98%。因此,双脉冲LIBS结合PLSR方法可以有效地提高LIBS对稀土矿石中稀土元素的定量分析能力。     

Evaluation of self-absorption of manganese emission lines in Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy measurements

This paper is part of a more general study aimed to the determination of the best experimental procedures for reliable quantitative measurements of Fe–Mn alloys by LIBS. In this work, attention is pointed on the self-absorption processes, whose effect deeply influences the LIBS measurements, reflecting in non-linear calibration curves. The effect of self-absorption on the line intensity can be quantified by defining a self-absorption coefficient, that measures the deviation of the line intensity from the linear extrapolation of the curve of growth in the optically thin regime. The authors demonstrated in a previous paper that self-absorption coefficients could be calculated once the electron density of the plasma is known and the Stark coefficients of the lines are available. However, when the Stark coefficients of the lines of interest are not known, a different approach is needed. In this work a new method for evaluation of self-absorption coefficients in LIBS measurements is presented, which does not require the knowledge of Stark coefficients. In order to understand the basic principles and setting out the theoretical tools that will be used for the analysis of the alloys, a preliminary study was done on pure Mn; LIBS spectra were acquired in different experimental conditions, at different laser energies and different delays after the laser irradiation of the sample. Moreover, collinear double pulse measurements were also performed. Analytical relations were derived and experimental procedures devised for evaluation of the self-absorption coefficients of several Mn lines, which are important for characterization and control of the experimental conditions in which the analysis is performed.     

Dual-pulse laser induced breakdown spectroscopy: Time-resolved transmission and spectral measurements

Spectral analysis of laser-induced plasmas for surface ablation has demonstrated the possibility of analyte signal enhancement with dual-pulse configurations as compared with traditional single-pulse LIBS. Using an orthogonal dual-pulse arrangement, measurements were performed using glass microscope slides to allow both spectral analysis as well as optical transmission measurements. Order of magnitude enhancements in Mg and Si atomic emission signal peak intensities were recorded along with similar enhancements of the continuum emission for dual-pulse LIBS as compared to single-pulse. Peak-to-base measurements showed a roughly 50% increase, while signal-to-noise ratios were enhanced by a factor of 2–3. Temporal analysis of the measured transmitted laser pulse waveforms showed no significant differences between dual-pulse and single-pulse LIBS configurations, providing additional insight into the possible laser coupling processes for the dual-pulse configuration.     

Identification and discrimination of bacterial strains by laser induced breakdown spectroscopy and neural networks

A method based on laser induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) and neural networks (NNs) has been developed and applied to the identification and discrimination of specific bacteria strains (Pseudomonas aeroginosa, Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium). Instant identification of the samples is achieved using a spectral library, which was obtained by analysis using a single laser pulse of representative samples and treatment by neural networks. The samples used in this study were divided into three groups, which were prepared on three different days. The results obtained allow the identification of the bacteria tested with a certainty of over 95%, and show that only a difference between the bacteria can cause identification. Single-shot measurements were sufficient for clear identification of the bacterial strains studied. The method can be developed for automatic real time, fast, reliable and robust measurements and can be packaged in portable systems for non-specialist users.     

Comparison of univariate and multivariate calibration for the determination of micronutrients in pellets of plant materials by laser induced breakdown spectrometry

The application of laser induced breakdown spectrometry (LIBS) aiming the direct analysis of plant materials is a great challenge that still needs efforts for its development and validation. In this way, a series of experimental approaches has been carried out in order to show that LIBS can be used as an alternative method to wet acid digestions based methods for analysis of agricultural and environmental samples. The large amount of information provided by LIBS spectra for these complex samples increases the difficulties for selecting the most appropriated wavelengths for each analyte. Some applications have suggested that improvements in both accuracy and precision can be achieved by the application of multivariate calibration in LIBS data when compared to the univariate regression developed with line emission intensities. In the present work, the performance of univariate and multivariate calibration, based on partial least squares regression (PLSR), was compared for analysis of pellets of plant materials made from an appropriate mixture of cryogenically ground samples with cellulose as the binding agent. The development of a specific PLSR model for each analyte and the selection of spectral regions containing only lines of the analyte of interest were the best conditions for the analysis. In this particular application, these models showed a similar performance, but PLSR seemed to be more robust due to a lower occurrence of outliers in comparison to the univariate method. Data suggests that efforts dealing with sample presentation and fitness of standards for LIBS analysis must be done in order to fulfill the boundary conditions for matrix independent development and validation.     

Miniaturized Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy for the in-situ analysis of the Martian surface: Calibration and quantification

We report on our ongoing studies to develop Laser-Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) for planetary surface missions to Mars and other planets and moons, like Jupiter's moon Europa or the Earth's moon. Since instruments for space missions are severely mass restricted, we are developing a light-weight miniaturized close-up LIBS instrument to be installed on a lander or rover for the in-situ geochemical analysis of planetary surface rocks and coarse fines. The total mass of the instrument will be ≈ 1 kg in flight configuration. Here we report on a systematic performance study of a LIBS instrument equipped with a prototype laser of 216 g total mass and an energy of 1.8 mJ. The LIBS measurements with the prototype laser and the comparative measurements with a regular 40 mJ laboratory laser were both performed under Martian atmospheric conditions.     

Local equivalence ratio measurements in turbulent partially premixed flames using laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy

One of the most recently applied laser-based techniques in combustion environment is the laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS). The technique has been extensively and successfully applied to elemental concentration measurements in solids and liquids. The LIBS signal is much weaker in gases and hence more work is required for quantitative measurements in flames. In the present work we used two orthogonal Nd:YAG lasers that operate at the fundamental wavelength with laser pulse energy of about 100 mJ/pulse. A Princeton-Instruments IMAX ICCD camera attached to a PI-Echelle spectrometer was used for signal detection. The lasers are focused using two 5-cm lenses. Several calibration points have been collected in well defined and homogeneous mixtures of air and fuel in order to be used as references for the measurements in turbulent partially premixed flames. This work shows that the application of the LIBS technique in a turbulent combustion environment is feasible and signal is enhanced by applying an orthogonal dual-pulse arrangement for air–fuel.     

Depth profile analysis of layered samples using glow discharge assisted Laser-induced Breakdown Spectrometry (GD-LIBS)

A microsecond-pulsed glow discharge is used to excite ablate material generated by the ablation laser in Laser-induced Breakdown Spectrometry (LIBS). The coupled system provides a simple means to excite the material ablated by the incident laser pulse by taking advantage of enhanced collisional excitation. In this way, one can effectively reduce laser energies below the excitation and ionization thresholds to those needed solely for ablation of the sample surface, in which the excitation of the material is performed by a high voltage discharge. Given this development, there exists the potential of improving upon depth resolutions in LIBS material characterization. This article presents the results of a comparative depth profile study conducted on various galvanized steels and layered brass standards by LIBS and GD-LIBS; demonstrating the advantages of coupling a pulsed glow discharge with a typical LIBS set-up used in materials analysis.