部分权重信息下对方案有互补偏好的多属性决策法

研究了只有部分权重信息且对方案的偏好信息以模糊互补判断矩阵形式给出的多属性决策问题.首先,基于模糊互补判断矩阵的主观偏好信息,利用转换函数将客观决策信息一致化,建立一个目标规划模型,通过求解该模型得到属性权重,从而利用加性加权法获得各方案的综合属性值,并以此对方案进行排序或择优.提出了一种基于目标规划的多属性决策方法.该方法具有操作简便和易于上机实现的特点.最后,通过实例说明模型及方法的可行性和有效性.     

区间犹豫模糊ELECTRE多属性决策方法及应用

近年来,多属性决策问题一直是广大学者研究的重点,然而基于ELECTRE方法的区间犹豫模糊多属性决策问题的研究并不多见。因此,结合区间犹豫模糊集的信息表达优势和ELECTRE方法的思想,提出了一种区间犹豫模糊ELECTRE(IVHF ELECTRE)多属性决策新方法。首先构造了区间犹豫模糊决策矩阵,引入得分函数和可能度的概念,构造属性优势集和属性劣势集。然后通过设定阈值得到综合优先判定矩阵,从而得到各方案间的优先顺序。为了进一步得到各方案的整体排序,引入TOPSIS方法,通过计算各方案与正负理想点的相对距离来构造综合优先矩阵,从而得到各方案的总体排序。最后通过具体实例验证了该方法的可行性和合理性。     

Performance evaluation: An integrated method using data envelopment analysis and fuzzy preference relations

In a multi-attribute decision-making (MADM) context, the decision maker needs to provide his preferences over a set of decision alternatives and constructs a preference relation and then use the derived priority vector of the preference to rank various alternatives. This paper proposes an integrated approach to rate decision alternatives using data envelopment analysis and preference relations. This proposed approach includes three stages. First, pairwise efficiency scores are computed using two DEA models: the CCR model and the proposed cross-evaluation DEA model. Second, the pairwise efficiency scores are then utilized to construct the fuzzy preference relation and the consistent fuzzy preference relation. Third, by use of the row wise summation technique, we yield a priority vector, which is used for ranking decision-making units (DMUs). For the case of a single output and a single input, the preference relation can be directly obtained from the original sample data. The proposed approach is validated by two numerical examples.     

语言多属性决策的一种组合方法

研究了属性权重完全未知,方案属性值和偏好值均为语言变量的多属性决策问题.首先,通过分析相关文献中利用方案属性值与偏好值之间的偏差得到属性权重的不合理性,在最小化方案综合属性值与偏好值的偏差的基础上,建立了一个求解属性权重的规划模型.其次,在各方案的属性值与属性正理想点的偏差最小的基础上,又建立一个求解属性权重的规划模型.第三,在综合考虑各属性下所有决策方案总的组合偏差之和最小的基础上,将上述两个规划模型相结合,得到了一个反映出决策者对两种不同信息的偏好程度的求解属性权重的规划模型,得到了语言多属性决策的一种组合方法.最后,通过实例说明方法的可行性与有效性.     

Decision-making with a fuzzy preference relation

In most decisio-making problems a preference relation in the set of alternatives is of a fuzzy nature, reflecting for instance on the fuzziness of experts estimates of the preferences. In this paper, the corresponding fuzzy equivalence and strict preference relations are defined for a given fuzzy non-strict preference relation in an unfuzzy set of alternatives which are used to introduce in a natural way the fuzzy set of nondominated alternatives. Two types of linearity of a fuzzy relation are introduced and the equivalence of the unfuzzy nondominated alternatives is studied. It is shown that unfuzzy nondominated solutions to the decision-making problem exist, provided the original fuzzy relation satisfies some topological requirements. A simple method of calculating these solutions is indicated.     

基于方案贴近度和满意度的交互式不确定多属性决策方法

针对属性权重信息部分确知且对方案有偏好的不确定多属性决策问题,提出一种基于方案贴近度和满意度的交互式决策方法.方法首先利用已知的客观信息和决策者的主观要求建立单目标规划模型,其次通过对方案满意度和综合度的给定与修正来实现人机交互决策.最后,通过实例说明模型及方法的可行性和有效性.     

基于信息量的不确定型多属性决策方法

针对属性值为区间数的不确定型多属性决策问题进行了研究,给出了属性值满意度的概念和考虑风险系数的满意度评价函数计算方法;重定义了公理设计理论的信息量概念,提出了基于信息量的不确定多属性决策方案排序方法,为解决不确定型多属性决策问题提供了一种简单实用的方法。最后利用实例计算了验证了方法的有效性和可行性。     

Implausible alternatives in eliciting multi-attribute value functions

Many methods to elicit preference models in multi-attribute decision making rely on evaluations of a set of sample alternatives by decision makers. Using orthogonal design methods to create this set of alternatives might require respondents to evaluate unrealistic alternatives. In this paper, we perform an empirical study to analyze whether the presence of such implausible alternatives has an effect on the quality of utility elicitation. Using a new approach to measure consistency, we find that implausible alternatives in fact, have a positive effect on consistency of intra-attribute preference information and consistency with dominance, but do not affect inter-attribute preference information.     

一种基于残缺语言判断矩阵的群决策方法

本文针对具有残缺语言判断矩阵形式方案偏好信息的群决策问题,提出了一种决策分析方法.首先,阐述了二元语义的概念,并提出了一种扩展的二元语义有序加权平均(ETOWA)算子;然后,采用ETOWA算子集结具有残缺语言判断矩阵形式的方案偏好信息,可计算出每个方案优于其他方案的总体偏好程度,进而可得到所有方案的排序结果.最后,通过给出一个算例说明了本文提出方法的可行性和实用性.     

多属性决策中的目标规划

针对只有部分权重信息的对方案有偏好的多属性决策问题,本文给出了一种简单的目标规划模型,通过对该模型的求解却可得到决策方案的排序。最后给出了一个算例。     

偏好信息为模糊互反判断矩阵的模糊多属性决策法

研究只有部分权重信息且决策者对方案的偏好信息以模糊互反判断矩阵形式给出的模糊多属性决策问题。提出了一种基于目标规划模型的模糊多属性决策方法。该法首先基于模糊互反判断矩阵，利用转换函数将决策信息一致化，建立了一个目标规划模型．通过求解该模型确定属性的权重，然后运用加性加权法求出各方案的模糊综合属性值，并利用已有的三角模糊数排序公式求得决策方案的排序。文章最后把该法应用于解决风险投资领域中的项目评估问题。     

基于二元联系数距离的不确定语言多属性决策模型

研究了属性权重范围已知,方案主观偏好值为语言变量,决策信息为不确定语言决策矩阵的多属性决策问题.在给出不确定语言变量转换为二元联系数的公式以及二元联系数距离公式的基础上,将方案主观偏好语言评价值转换为二元联系数,将不确定语言决策矩阵转换为二元联系数决策矩阵,从而得到方案的二元联系数综合属性值,通过最小化方案的二元联系数综合属性值和主观偏好值之间距离,建立多目标优化模型,并将其转换为一个单目标规划模型计算出属性权重.然后,通过对方案的二元联系数综合属性值进行不确定性分析,得到各方案的排序总数,利用排序总数对方案进行排序择优.应用实例表明该决策方法可行有效.     

ELECTRE: Robust ordinal regression for outranking methods

We present a new method, called ELECTRE^GKMS, which employs robust ordinal regression to construct a set of outranking models compatible with preference information. The preference information supplied by the decision maker (DM) is composed of pairwise comparisons stating the truth or falsity of the outranking relation for some real or fictitious reference alternatives. Moreover, the DM specifies some ranges of variation of comparison thresholds on considered pseudo-criteria. Using robust ordinal regression, the method builds a set of values of concordance indices, concordance thresholds, indifference, preference, and veto thresholds, for which all specified pairwise comparisons can be restored. Such sets are called compatible outranking models. Using these models, two outranking relations are defined, necessary and possible. Whether for an ordered pair of alternatives there is necessary or possible outranking depends on the truth of outranking relation for all or at least one compatible model, respectively. Distinguishing the most certain recommendation worked out by the necessary outranking, and a possible recommendation worked out by the possible outranking, ELECTRE^GKMS answers questions of robustness concern. The method is intended to be used interactively with incremental specification of pairwise comparisons, possibly with decreasing confidence levels. In this way, the necessary and possible outranking relations can be, respectively, enriched or impoverished with the growth of the number of pairwise comparisons. Furthermore, the method is able to identify troublesome pieces of preference information which are responsible for incompatibility. The necessary and possible outranking relations are to be exploited as usual outranking relations to work out recommendation in choice or ranking problems. The introduced approach is illustrated by a didactic example showing how ELECTRE^GKMS can support real-world decision problems.     

Aggregation of fuzzy preference relations to multicriteria decision making

Weighted aggregation of fuzzy preference relations on the set of alternatives by several criteria in decision-making problems is considered. Pairwise comparisons with respect to importance of the criteria are given in fuzzy preference relation as well. The aggregation procedure uses the composition between each two relations of the alternatives. The membership function of the newly constructed fuzzy preference relation includes t-norms and t-conorms to take into account the relation between the criteria importance. Properties of the composition and new relation, giving a possibility to make a consistent choice or to rank the alternatives, are proved. An illustrative numerical study and comparative examples are presented.     

模糊多属性群体决策模糊距离折中比值法及应用

为解决复杂条件下的模糊多属性群体决策问题,利用模糊距离的概念,提出了模糊距离折中比值法(FCRM)。在FCRM中,属性权重和定性属性评估值由语言变量和三角模糊数描述,并用模糊距离度量模糊数之间的距离。FCRM的决策原则是所选择的最优解在尽可能地贴近正理想解的同时尽可能地远离负理想解,同时充分考虑多个决策者的主观态度。文中详细阐述了FCRM的决策过程,通过实例将其应用于军事航线优选问题并与其他相关方法进行了比较分析,证实了该方法的有效性。     

An integrated model-based interactive approach to FMAGDM with incomplete preference information

Incomplete fuzzy preference relations, incomplete multiplicative preference relations, and incomplete linguistic preference relations are very useful to express decision makers’ incomplete preferences over attributes or alternatives in the process of decision making under fuzzy environments. The aim of this paper is to investigate fuzzy multiple attribute group decision making problems where the attribute values are represented in intuitionistic fuzzy numbers and the information on attribute weights is provided by decision makers by means of one or some of the different preference structures, including weak ranking, strict ranking, difference ranking, multiple ranking, interval numbers, incomplete fuzzy preference relations, incomplete multiplicative preference relations, and incomplete linguistic preference relations. We transform all individual intuitionistic fuzzy decision matrices into the interval decision matrices and construct their expected decision matrices, and then aggregate all these expected decision matrices into a collective one. We establish an integrated model by unifying the collective decision matrix and all the given different structures of incomplete weight preference information, and develop an integrated model-based approach to interacting with the decision makers so as to adjust all the inconsistent incomplete fuzzy preference relations, inconsistent incomplete linguistic preference relations and inconsistent incomplete multiplicative preference relations into the ones with acceptable consistency. The developed approach can derive the attribute weights and the ranking of the alternatives directly from the integrated model, and thus it has the following prominent characteristics: (1) it does not need to construct the complete fuzzy preference relations, complete linguistic preference relations and complete multiplicative preference relations from the incomplete fuzzy preference relations, incomplete linguistic preference relations and incomplete multiplicative preference relations, respectively; (2) it does not need to unify the different structures of incomplete preferences, and thus can simplify the calculation and avoid distorting the given preference information; and (3) it can sufficiently reflect and adjust the subjective desirability of decision makers in the process of interaction. A practical example is also provided to illustrate the developed approach.     

Multicriterion analysis of preferences by means of pairwise actions and criterion comparisons (MAPPACC)

This paper presents a method for solving discrete choice problems characterized by multiple evaluative criteria. The proposed method, known as MAPPAC, is based on a pairwise comparison of alternatives relative to each pair of criteria, defining the two relations P (preference) and I (indifference), which constitute a complete preorder. Moreover, by aggregating these preferences, it is possible to obtain a variety of relations on a set of feasible actions.     

Incremental analysis for MCDM with an application to group TOPSIS

The study aims to exploit incremental analysis or marginal analysis to overcome the drawbacks of ratio scales utilized in various multi-criteria or multi-attribute decision making (MCDM/MADM) techniques. In the proposed 11-step procedure, multiple criteria of alternatives are first reorganized as two categories – benefits and costs – and decision information will be manipulated separately. The performances of alternatives are then evaluated on their incremental benefit–cost ratio, and the rank can be obtained by applying the group TOPSIS (technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution) model (Shih et al., 2007). Two representations of cost, i.e., a cost index and utility index, are proposed in the model to better-fit real-world situations. In addition, some considerations on costs and input–output relations are also discussed in order to understand the essentials of incremental analysis. In the final part, a case of robot selection demonstrates the suggested model to be both robust and efficient in a group decision-making environment.     

基于ANP与模糊TOPSIS-CRITIC方法的不确定多属性决策模型

随着多属性决策问题的日益流行,处理决策问题的复杂程度也逐渐增加,针对其中权重不确定,难以量化各影响因素主观权重与客观权重以及指标排序不精确的问题,提出了一种将网络层次分析法(ANP)与模糊指标相关性的指标权重确定法(CRITIC)、逼近理想解排序法(TOPSIS)相结合的不确定多属性决策模型首先,在分别使用ANP方法和CRITIC法确定各影响因素的主观、客观权重的基础上计算指标的综合权重,然后应用模糊TOPSIS方法对备选方案进行贴进度排序最后,通过一个实例将计算结果同其他三种决策方法进行对比分析,验证了所提出的ANP与模糊TOPSIS-CRITIC方法的可靠性和有效性.     

Multiperson decision-making based on multiplicative preference relations

A multiperson decision-making problem, where the information about the alternatives provided by the experts can be presented by means of different preference representation structures (preference orderings, utility functions and multiplicative preference relations) is studied. Assuming the multiplicative preference relation as the uniform element of the preference representation, a multiplicative decision model based on fuzzy majority is presented to choose the best alternatives. In this decision model, several transformation functions are obtained to relate preference orderings and utility functions with multiplicative preference relations. The decision model uses the ordered weighted geometric operator to aggregate information and two choice degrees to rank the alternatives, quantifier guided dominance degree and quantifier guided non-dominance degree. The consistency of the model is analysed to prove that it acts coherently.