Latin squares with restricted transversals

We prove that for all odd m ≥ 3 there exists a latin square of order 3 m that contains an ( m ? 1 ) × m latin subrectangle consisting of entries not in any transversal. We prove that for all even n ≥ 10 there exists a latin square of order n in which there is at least one transversal, but all transversals coincide on a single entry. A corollary is a new proof of the existence of a latin square without an orthogonal mate, for all odd orders n ≥ 11 . Finally, we report on an extensive computational study of transversal‐free entries and sets of disjoint transversals in the latin squares of order n ? 9 . In particular, we count the number of species of each order that possess an orthogonal mate. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Combin Designs 20:124‐141, 2012     

Bachelor latin squares with large indivisible plexes

In a latin square of order n , a k ‐plex is a selection of kn entries in which each row, column, and symbol occurs k times. A 1 ‐plex is also called a transversal. A k ‐plex is indivisible if it contains no c ‐plex for 0 < c < k . We prove that, for all n ≥ 4 , there exists a latin square of order n that can be partitioned into an indivisible ? n / 2 ?‐plex and a disjoint indivisible ? n / 2 ?‐plex. For all n ≥ 3 , we prove that there exists a latin square of order n with two disjoint indivisible ? n / 2 ?‐plexes. We also give a short new proof that, for all odd n ≥ 5 , there exists a latin square of order n with at least one entry not in any transversal. Such latin squares have no orthogonal mate. Copyright © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Combin Designs 19:304‐312, 2011     

Multi-latin squares

A multi-latin square of order n and index k is an n×n array of multisets, each of cardinality k, such that each symbol from a fixed set of size n occurs k times in each row and k times in each column. A multi-latin square of index k is also referred to as a k-latin square. A 1-latin square is equivalent to a latin square, so a multi-latin square can be thought of as a generalization of a latin square.In this note we show that any partially filled-in k-latin square of order m embeds in a k-latin square of order n, for each n≥2m, thus generalizing Evans’ Theorem. Exploiting this result, we show that there exist non-separable k-latin squares of order n for each n≥k+2. We also show that for each n≥1, there exists some finite value g(n) such that for all k≥g(n), every k-latin square of order n is separable.We discuss the connection between k-latin squares and related combinatorial objects such as orthogonal arrays, latin parallelepipeds, semi-latin squares and k-latin trades. We also enumerate and classify k-latin squares of small orders.     

Latin Squares without Orthogonal Mates

In 1779 Euler proved that for every even n there exists a latin square of order n that has no orthogonal mate, and in 1944 Mann proved that for every n of the form 4k + 1, k ≥ 1, there exists a latin square of order n that has no orthogonal mate. Except for the two smallest cases, n = 3 and n = 7, it is not known whether a latin square of order n = 4k + 3 with no orthogonal mate exists or not. We complete the determination of all n for which there exists a mate-less latin square of order n by proving that, with the exception of n = 3, for all n = 4k + 3 there exists a latin square of order n with no orthogonal mate. We will also show how the methods used in this paper can be applied more generally by deriving several earlier non-orthogonality results.     

Transversals and multicolored matchings

Ryser conjectured that the number of transversals of a latin square of order n is congruent to n modulo 2. Balasubramanian has shown that the number of transversals of a latin square of even order is even. A 1‐factor of a latin square of order n is a set of n cells no two from the same row or the same column. We prove that for any latin square of order n, the number of 1‐factors with exactly n ? 1 distinct symbols is even. Also we prove that if the complete graph K_2n, n ≥ 8, is edge colored such that each color appears on at most edges, then there exists a multicolored perfect matching. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

On the number of transversals in Cayley tables of cyclic groups

It is well known that if n is even, the addition table for the integers modulo n (which we denote by B_n) possesses no transversals. We show that if n is odd, then the number of transversals in B_n is at least exponential in n. Equivalently, for odd n, the number of diagonally cyclic latin squares of order n, the number of complete mappings or orthomorphisms of the cyclic group of order n, the number of magic juggling sequences of period n and the number of placements of n non-attacking semi-queens on an n×n toroidal chessboard are at least exponential in n. For all large n we show that there is a latin square of order n with at least (3.246)ⁿ transversals.We diagnose all possible sizes for the intersection of two transversals in B_n and use this result to complete the spectrum of possible sizes of homogeneous latin bitrades.We also briefly explore potential applications of our results in constructing random mutually orthogonal latin squares.     

Doubly diagonal orthogonal latin squares

A pair of doubly diagonal orthogonal latin squares of order n, DDOLS(n), is a pair of orthogonal latin squares of order n with the property that each square has a transversal on both the front diagonal (the cells {(i, i):1?i?n}) and the back diagonal (the cells {(i, n + 1?i): 1?i?n}). We show that for all n except n = 2, 3, 6, 10, 12, 14, 15, 18 and 26, there exists a pair of DDOLS(n). Obbviously these do not exist when n = 2, 3 and 6.     

Construction of doubly diagonalized orthogonal latin squares

A transversal T of a latin square is a collection of n cells no two in the same row or column and such that each of the integers 1, 2, …, n appears in exactly one of the cells of T. A latin square is doubly diagonalized provided that both its main diagonal and off-diagonal are transversals. Although it is known that a doubly diagonalized latin square of every order n ≥ 4 exists and that a pair of orthogonal latin squares of order n exists for every n ≠ 2 or 6, it is still an open question as to what the spectrum is for pairs of doubly diagonalized orthogonal latin squares. The best general result seems to be that pairs of orthogonal doubly diagonalized latin squares of order n exist whenever n is odd or a multiple of 4, except possibly when n is a multiple of 3 but not of 9. In this paper we give a new construction for doubly diagonalized latin squares which is used to enlarge the known class for doubly diagonalized orthogonal squares. The construction is based on Sade's singular direct product of quasigroups.     

The recognition of symmetric latin squares

A latin square S is isotopic to another latin square S′ if S′ can be obtained from S by permuting the row indices, the column indices and the symbols in S. Because the three permutations used above may all be different, a latin square which is isotopic to a symmetric latin square need not be symmetric. We call the problem of determining whether a latin square is isotopic to a symmetric latin square the symmetry recognition problem. It is the purpose of this article to give a solution to this problem. For this purpose we will introduce a cocycle corresponding to a latin square which transforms very simply under isotopy, and we show this cocycle contains all the information needed to determine whether a latin square is isotopic to a symmetric latin square. Our results relate to 1‐factorizations of the complete graph on n + 1 vertices, K_{n + 1}. There is a well known construction which can be used to make an n × n latin square from a 1‐factorization on n + 1 vertices. The symmetric idempotent latin squares are exactly the latin squares that result from this construction. The idempotent recognition problem is simple for symmetric latin squares, so our results enable us to recognize exactly which latin squares arise from 1‐factorizations of K_{n + 1}. As an example we show that the patterned starter 1‐factorization for the group G gives rise to a latin square which is in the main class of the Cayley latin square for G if and only if G is abelian. Hence, every non‐abelian group gives rise to two latin squares in different main classes. © 2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Combin Designs 16: 291–300, 2008     

Automorphism free latin square graphs

In this paper, we show that there exists an automorphism free latin square graph of order n for all n ? 7 and that the number of such graphs goes to infinity with n. These results are then applied to the construction of automorphism free Steiner triple systems.     

A superlinear lower bound for the size of a critical set in a latin square

A critical set is a partial latin square that has a unique completion to a latin square, and is minimal with respect to this property. Let scs(n) denote the smallest possible size of a critical set in a latin square of order n. We show that for all n, . Thus scs(n) is superlinear with respect to n. We also show that scs(n) ≥ 2n?32 and if n ≥ 25, . © 2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Combin Designs 15: 269–282, 2007     

All group‐based latin squares possess near transversals

In a latin square of order n, a near transversal is a collection of n ?1 cells which intersects each row, column, and symbol class at most once. A longstanding conjecture of Brualdi, Ryser, and Stein asserts that every latin square possesses a near transversal. We show that this conjecture is true for every latin square that is main class equivalent to the Cayley table of a finite group.     

Symmetries that latin squares inherit from 1‐factorizations

A 1‐factorization of a graph is a decomposition of the graph into edge disjoint perfect matchings. There is a well‐known method, which we call the ??‐construction, for building a 1‐factorization of K_n,n from a 1‐factorization of K_{n + 1}. The 1‐factorization of K_n,n can be written as a latin square of order n. The ??‐construction has been used, among other things, to make perfect 1‐factorizations, subsquare‐free latin squares, and atomic latin squares. This paper studies the relationship between the factorizations involved in the ??‐construction. In particular, we show how symmetries (automorphisms) of the starting factorization are inherited as symmetries by the end product, either as automorphisms of the factorization or as autotopies of the latin square. Suppose that the ??‐construction produces a latin square L from a 1‐factorization F of K_{n + 1}. We show that the main class of L determines the isomorphism class of F, although the converse is false. We also prove a number of restrictions on the symmetries (autotopies and paratopies) which L may possess, many of which are simple consequences of the fact that L must be symmetric (in the usual matrix sense) and idempotent. In some circumstances, these restrictions are tight enough to ensure that L has trivial autotopy group. Finally, we give a cubic time algorithm for deciding whether a main class of latin squares contains any square derived from the ??‐construction. The algorithm also detects symmetric squares and totally symmetric squares (latin squares that equal their six conjugates). © 2005 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Combin Designs 13: 157–172, 2005.     

Embedding an incomplete latin square in a latin square with a prescribed diagonal

We present necessary and sufficient conditions for the embedding of a given incomplete latin square R of side n,n?10 on the symbols σ₁,…,σ_t in a latin square T of side t on the symbols σ₁,…,σ_t for all t?2n+1 where the diagonal of T has been prescribed. The lower bound of 2n+1 for t is the best possible.     

Latin squares with bounded size of row prefix intersections

A latin square is a matrix of size n×n with entries from the set {1,…,n}, such that each row and each column is a permutation on {1,…,n}. We show how to construct a latin square such that for any two distinct rows, the prefixes of length h of the two rows share at most about h²/n elements. This upper bound is close to optimal when contrasted with a lower bound derived from the Second Johnson bound [6].     

Bounds on the number of autotopisms and subsquares of a Latin square

A subsquare of a Latin square L is a submatrix that is also a Latin square. An autotopism of L is a triplet of permutations (α, β, γ) such that L is unchanged after the rows are permuted by α, the columns are permuted by β and the symbols are permuted by γ. Let n!(n?1)!R _n be the number of n×n Latin squares. We show that an n×n Latin square has at most n ^{O(log k)} subsquares of order k and admits at most n ^{O(log n)} autotopisms. This enables us to show that {ie11-1} divides R _n for all primes p. We also extend a theorem by McKay and Wanless that gave a factorial divisor of R _n , and give a new proof that R _p ≠1 (mod p) for prime p.     

Latin Squares with Restricted Transversals

The original article to which this erratum refers was correctly published online on 1 December 2011. Due to an error at the publisher, it was then published in Journal of Combinatorial Designs 20: 124–141, 2012 without the required shading in several examples. To correct this, the article is here reprinted in full. The publisher regrets this error. We prove that for all odd there exists a latin square of order 3m that contains an latin subrectangle consisting of entries not in any transversal. We prove that for all even there exists a latin square of order n in which there is at least one transversal, but all transversals coincide on a single entry. A corollary is a new proof of the existence of a latin square without an orthogonal mate, for all odd orders . Finally, we report on an extensive computational study of transversal‐free entries and sets of disjoint transversals in the latin squares of order . In particular, we count the number of species of each order that possess an orthogonal mate. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Combin. Designs 20: 344–361, 2012     

Row-complete latin squares of every composite order exist

A construction for a row-complete latin square of order n, where n is any odd composite number other than 9, is given in this article. Since row-complete latin squares of order 9 and of even order have previously been constructed, this proves that row-complete latin squares of every composite order exist. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Combin Designs 6:63–77, 1998     

Symmetric latin square and complete graph analogues of the evans conjecture

With the proof of the Evans conjecture, it was established that any partial latin square of side n with a most n ? 1 nonempty cells can be completed to a latin square of side n. In this article we prove an analogous result for symmetric latin squares: a partial symmetric latin square of side n with an admissible diagonal and at most n ? 1 nonempty cells can be completed to a symmetric latin square of side n. We also characterize those partial symmetric latin squares of side n with exactly n or n + 1 nonempty cells which cannot be completed. From these results we deduce theorems about completing edge-colorings of complete graphs K_2m and K_{2m ? 1} with 2m ? 1 colors, with m + 1 or fewer edges getting prescribed colors. © 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

On the spectrum of critical sets in latin squares of order 2n

Suppose that L is a latin square of order m and P ? L is a partial latin square. If L is the only latin square of order m which contains P, and no proper subset of P has this property, then P is a critical set of L. The critical set spectrum problem is to determine, for a given m, the set of integers t for which there exists a latin square of order m with a critical set of size t. We outline a partial solution to the critical set spectrum problem for latin squares of order 2ⁿ. The back circulant latin square of even order m has a well‐known critical set of size m²/4, and this is the smallest known critical set for a latin square of order m. The abelian 2‐group of order 2ⁿ has a critical set of size 4ⁿ‐3ⁿ, and this is the largest known critical set for a latin square of order 2ⁿ. We construct a set of latin squares with associated critical sets which are intermediate between the back circulant latin square of order 2ⁿ and the abelian 2‐group of order 2ⁿ. © 2007 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Combin Designs 16: 25–43, 2008