Evaluation of measurement uncertainties for the determination of total metal content in soils by atomic absorption spectrometry

In this work estimation of measurement uncertainties associated with the total metal content in soils was done by an intralaboratory approach based on method validation and quality control data, and using two certified reference materials (CRM). CRM and soil samples were analyzed following procedures based on the methods that are applied to silicate materials. All elements were determined by atomic absorption spectrometry following a quality assurance program previously established. Quality control actions were implemented in order to provide reliable data. The precision under within-laboratory reproducibility conditions was estimated from triplicate analysis. The trueness component was determined as recovery of the analyte from CRMs: soil sample, SO-2 and river clay sediment, LGC 6139. Combined measurement uncertainty was expressed in terms of precision and recovery uncertainties and the later further split on CRM replicate analysis and uncertainty of the certified value components. The results obtained are critically discussed on the basis of the different contributions. For the selection of the reference material, the CRM dependent terms are critically compared in order to fulfill specific requirements. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Speciation analysis of chromium in drinking water samples by ion-pair reversed-phase HPLC–ICP-MS: validation of the analytical method and evaluation of the uncertainty budget

The approach presented in this article refers to the modification of a method for the detection and quantitative determination of chromium species in water by high-performance liquid chromatography inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. The main aim of this work was to establish a detailed validation of the analytical procedure and an estimation of the budget of measurement uncertainty which was helpful in recognizing the critical points of the presented method. As a result of the method validation experiment, the obtained limit of quantification, repeatability and intermediate precision were satisfied for the quantification Cr(III) and Cr(VI) in water matrices. The trueness of the method was verified via an estimation of the recovery of the spiked real samples. The recovery rate of both determined analytes was found to be between 93 and 115 %. Considering that the validation of the method and the evaluation of measurement uncertainty are crucial for quantitative analysis, the above-mentioned assessment of the uncertainty budget was performed in two different ways: a modelling approach and a single-laboratory validation approach. The measurement uncertainties of the results were found to be 4.4 and 7.8 % for Cr(III), 4.2 and 7.9 % for Cr(VI) using the classical concept and method validation data, respectively. This paper is the first publication to presenting all the steps needed to evaluate the measurement uncertainty for the speciation analysis of chromium species. In summary, the obtained results demonstrate that the method can be applied effectively for its intended use.     

Measurement uncertainty evaluation and in-house method validation of the herbicide iodosulfuron-methyl-sodium in water samples by using HPLC analysis

A method for separation and quantitative determination of the iodosulfuron-methyl-sodium in water samples by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) was developed and in-house validated in order to demonstrate its performance for monitoring of heterogeneous photocatalytic elimination of the herbicide iodosulfuron-methyl-sodium from water. Surface and ground water samples were used to demonstrate its selectivity, detection and quantification limits, linearity, trueness and precision. In addition, stability of iodosulfuron-methyl-sodium was studied in function of temperature and time. Method accuracy was quantified through measurement uncertainty estimate based on method validation data. The paper gives practical and easy to follow guidance on how uncertainty estimates can be obtained from method validation experiments. It shows that, if properly planned and executed, key precision and trueness studies undertaken for validation purposes can also provide much of the data needed to produce an estimate of measurement uncertainty. Our analytical protocol allowed us to quantify iodosulfuron-methyl-sodium in ground water and surface water in concentration level between 2.50–50.0 μmol L⁻¹ with satisfactory recoveries (99–104%) and repeatability lower or equal than 0.3% for all the matrices. We also estimated within-laboratory reproducibility over 3-month period, which was 0.7%. We proved that the method was selective for determination of iodosulfuron-methyl-sodium in the relevant matrices. Measurement uncertainty of results was evaluated to be 4.0% with 95% confidence level. After validation and measurement uncertainty evaluation steps, results obtained showed that the method can be applied to efficiently monitor heterogenous photocatalytic degradation of the herbicide iodosulfuron-methyl-sodium.     

The evaluation of measurement uncertainty from method validation studies

 A protocol has been developed illustrating the link between validation experiments, such as precision, trueness and ruggedness testing, and measurement uncertainty evaluation. By planning validation experiments with uncertainty estimation in mind, uncertainty budgets can be obtained from validation data with little additional effort. The main stages in the uncertainty estimation process are described, and the use of trueness and ruggedness studies is discussed in detail. The practical application of the protocol will be illustrated in Part 2, with reference to a method for the determination of three markers (CI solvent red 24, quinizarin and CI solvent yellow 124) in fuel oil samples. Received: 10 April 1999 / Accepted: 24 September 1999     

The evaluation of measurement uncertainty from method validation studies

 A protocol has been developed illustrating the link between validation experiments and measurement uncertainty evaluation. The application of the protocol is illustrated with reference to a method for the determination of three markers (CI solvent red 24, quinizarin and CI solvent yellow 124) in fuel oil samples. The method requires the extraction of the markers from the sample matrix by solid phase extraction followed by quantification by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with diode array detection. The uncertainties for the determination of the markers were evaluated using data from precision and trueness studies using representative sample matrices spiked at a range of concentrations, and from ruggedness studies of the extraction and HPLC stages. Received: 10 April 1999 · Accepted: 24 September 1999     

Practical digest for evaluating the uncertainty of analytical assays from validation data according to the LGC/VAM protocol

The estimation of the measurement uncertainty of analytical assays based on the LGC/VAM protocol from validation data is fully revisited and discussed in the light of the study of precision, trueness and robustness.     

塑料中镉的测定不确定度评定

建立了用实验室内精密度和偏差的数据来评定塑料中镉的测定不确定度的方法. 通过研究不同基体和不同含量水平的样品, 考察了方法的精密度和回收率, 分别计算并合并了两者的测量不确定度. 结果表明精密度和回收率的相对不确定度分量分别为0.026和0.068, 合成不确定度为0.072, 扩展不确定度为0.14. 此评定过程为实验室评定测量不确定度提供了一种新的方法, 简单、合理, 计算结果可靠.     

Validation of Some Procedures for Quantifying Platinum at sub‐μg/L Level in Some Real Matrices by Catalytic Adsorptive Stripping Voltammetry

The potential toxicological properties of platinum group elements, usually present in real matrices at sub‐ng/g level, explain the increasing interest in developing specific and sensitive analytical methods. In this work, a validation study was performed in order to ensure the fitness‐for‐purposes of procedures developed for quantifying platinum in tap water, beer and lettuce using an extremely sensitive method based on catalytic adsorptive stripping voltammetry. The work involved the estimation of selectivity, detection and quantitation limits, range, accuracy (trueness plus precision), uncertainty of measurement (UOM), robustness and recovery. The results are discussed in the light of the most recent literature findings.     

Conclusions from 13 years of stability testing of CRMs for determination of metal species

We present results of the systematic stability monitoring of certified reference materials (CRMs) for the mass fractions of metal species. Materials are tested regularly for the mass fractions of organotin, organomercury, organolead and organoarsenic species. Evaluation is based on ratios of results on samples stored under normal conditions and under even safer conditions (“reference stock”) to eliminate the effects of laboratory-to-laboratory variation. Of all results in this study, the results of organotin measurements show the highest relative standard deviations (up to 45%). Determination of methylmercury in sediment and fish is possible with much better precision (standard deviations of reproducibility below 5%). The accuracies of determinations of trimethyllead and organoarsenic species are slightly worse but still below 10%. The data confirmed stability since production (i.e. up to 13 years). However, shelf lives cannot be extended into the future based on these data, as uncertainty contributions for stability need to be included in the uncertainty budgets of CRMs to allow positive demonstration of the validity of certificates. Estimation of typical measurement uncertainties based on the data obtained from stability monitoring shows that potential degradation is negligible compared to uncertainties typical for this kind of measurement, demonstrating that the materials are still sufficiently reliable to demonstrate laboratory proficiency.     

Assessment of the determination of heavy metals in organic soil improvers by ICP–OES

Directive 86/278/EEC sets maximum levels of heavy metals in sewage sludge used in agriculture to regulate the risk of using these organic soil improvers. The assessment of the compliance of soil improvers with this legislation should be supported on measurements with adequately low uncertainty. This work presents a strategy for assessing the performance of the determination of aqua regia extractable Cu, Zn and Cr in organic soil improvers and urban sewage sludges following EN 13650 standard. The measurement procedure validation involves checking the adequacy of the linear weighted regression model for ICP–OES calibration, the determination of the limit of quantification, the assessment of measurement repeatability, intermediate precision and trueness, and the evaluation of the measurement uncertainty using the differential approach. Routine tests quality control, including the estimated measurement uncertainty, is checked through the analysis of control standards, equivalent to calibrators, and reference materials from proficiency tests. Since the estimated relative expanded uncertainty is smaller than the defined target value (40 %), measurements are fit for assessing compliance of the mass fraction of heavy metals in organic soil improvers with the council directive.     

Determination of measurement uncertainty for the determination of triazines in groundwater from validation data

Laboratories are increasingly urged to submit full uncertainties of their analytical results rather than only standard deviations. The determination of measurement uncertainties in compliance with the Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement (GUM) is demonstrated using the validation approach explicitly endorsed by the recent edition of the EURACHEM guide for the determination of measurement uncertainty. Measurement uncertainty was split into uncertainty of the sample mass, uncertainty of the concentration of the stock standard solution, uncertainty of the calibration and uncertainty connected to within- and between-series precision. Uncertainties of sample mass and of the concentration of the stock standard solution were 0.26 and 1.14% for all analytes, which is negligible compared with the contributions of precision and calibration. Uncertainty of calibration was estimated from the calibration graph. Relative uncertainty of calibration was found to be strongly concentration dependent and to be the main uncertainty contribution below 0.2 microgram L-1. Precision was split into within-series and between-series standard deviation, which dominate the combined standard uncertainty at higher concentrations. The results obtained from these calculations are compared with results for a certified reference material and with the performance in an interlaboratory comparison. It was found that all results agreed within their uncertainty with the target values, showing that the estimated uncertainties are realistic.     

Development of a certified reference material for the content of nitroimidazole parent drugs and hydroxy metabolites in pork meat

Nitroimidazoles have been applied in the past to poultry and pigs to treat protozoan diseases and to combat bacterial infections, but due to adverse health effects their use in food-producing animals has meanwhile been banned in the EU. The request for a certified reference material in a representative matrix was stipulated by the responsible Community Reference Laboratory and is underpinned by the need to improve the accuracy and comparability of measurement data and to establish metrological traceability of analytical results. The Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements (IRMM) has responded to this demand by developing and producing a new certified matrix reference material, ERM-BB124. This incurred lyophilised pork meat material was certified according to ISO guides 34 and 35 for the mass fractions of six nitroimidazole compounds. Processing of the frozen muscle tissue to the final material was accomplished by application of cutting, freeze-drying, mixing and milling techniques. Homogeneity and stability measurements were performed using liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry. The relative standard uncertainty due to possible heterogeneity showed to be below 1.8% for all analytes. Potential degradation during transport and storage was assessed by isochronous stability studies. No significant instability was detected at a storage temperature of −20 °C for a shelf-life of 2 years. The certified mass fraction values were assigned upon evaluation of the data acquired in an international laboratory inter-comparison involving 12 expert laboratories using different sample preparation procedures, but exclusively LC-MS/MS methods. Relative standard uncertainty contributions for the characterisation (between-lab variation of mean values) were found to be between 1.6 and 4.8%. Certified values for five analytes were in the range of 0.7 to 6.2 μg kg⁻¹, with expanded relative uncertainties ranging between 7 and 14%. Dimetridazole could be certified as “<0.25 μg kg⁻¹ with a probability of 95%”. All values are traceable to the International System of Units (SI). The material is intended to be used for method validation purposes (including trueness estimation) and for method performance assessment.     

Set-up and evaluation of interlaboratory studies

Interlaboratory comparison by means of method performance precision and bias studies and proficiency testing schemes are described. The set-up of the experiments as well as the evaluation of the data by means of graphical and statistical methods are considered. The use of interlaboratory data for the estimation of measurement uncertainty is also addressed.     

Uncertainty estimation in organic elemental analysis using information from proficiency tests

We evaluate the uncertainty in organic elemental analysis of C, H, N, and S. We use data from six proficiency tests (PTs), in which some 35 Spanish laboratories participated. The uncertainty of the technique is estimated from the relative within-laboratory and between-laboratory variances for pure substances and samples with complex matrices (soil, powdered milk, oil, ash, and petroleum coke). We also calculate the relative standard uncertainties for individual laboratories when analysing pure substances using historical data from the participation of each laboratory in different editions of PTs. The uncertainty values obtained for the individual laboratories are comparable with the uncertainty of the technique and correlate with the combined z-scores. The evolution over time of those laboratories participating in common editions of PTs is also evaluated.     

Comparison of different approaches to estimate the uncertainty of a liquid chromatographic assay

A measurement result cannot be properly interpreted without knowledge about its uncertainty. Several concepts to estimate the uncertainty of a measurement result have been developed. Here, four different approaches for uncertainty estimation are compared on the example of the RP-high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) assay for tylosin for veterinary use: the guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement (GUM) approach, which derives the uncertainty of a measurement result by combining the uncertainties related to the uncertainty sources of the measurement process; the top-down approach, which uses the reproducibility estimate from an inter-laboratory study as uncertainty estimate; an approach recently presented by Barwick and Ellison, which combines precision, trueness and robustness data to obtain an uncertainty estimate of the measurement result and finally a further approach, which directly estimates the measurement uncertainty from a robustness test. The comparison shows that the different approaches lead to comparable uncertainty estimates.     

BCR®-701: a review of 10-years of sequential extraction analyses

A detailed quantitative analysis was performed on data presented in the literature that focused on the sequential extraction of cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb) and zinc (Zn) from the certified reference material BCR-701 (lake sediment) using the three-step harmonized BCR(?) procedure. The accuracy of data reported in the literature, including precision and different measures of trueness, was assessed relative to the certified values for BCR-701. Forty data sets were accepted following extreme outlier removal, and statistically summarized with measures of central tendency, dispersion, and distribution form. In general, literature data were similar in their measurement precision to the expert laboratories used to certify the trace element contents in BCR-701. The overall median precision for literature reported data was 10% (range 6-19%), compared to certifying laboratories of 9% (range 4-33%). One measure of literature data trueness was assessed via a confirmatory approach using a robust bootstrap method. Only 22% of the comparisons indicated significantly different (all were lower) concentrations reported in the literature compared to certified values. The question of whether the differences are practically significant for environmental studies is raised. Bias was computed as a measure of trueness, and literature data were more frequently negatively biased, indicating lower concentrations reported in the literature for the six trace elements for the three-step sequential procedure compared to the certified values. However, 95% confidence intervals about the average bias for the 18 comparisons indicated only four instances when a mean bias of 0 (i.e., measured=certified) was not incorporated-suggesting statistical difference. Finally, Z-scores incorporating a Horwitz-type function were used to assess the general trueness of laboratory data. Of the 468 laboratory Z-score values computed, 92% were considered to be satisfactory, 5% were questionable, and 3% were unsatisfactory. A detailed examination of the methodology sections of the various studies showed that despite claiming adherence to the harmonized BCR sequential extraction protocol, significant deviations were commonly observed; particularly in moisture correction, sample mass, centrifugation specifics, shaking specifics, and incorporation of filtration. It is likely that failure to strictly adhere to the protocol adversely impacted accuracy, by increasing the degree of imprecision and resulting in more discrepant trueness values.     

Production and evaluation of a reference material for moisture,ash, and total fat mass fractions,and titratable acidity in whole milk powder

Given the importance of reference materials (RM) in the structuring and maintenance of quality management systems for food analysis laboratories, RM were produced for the measurement of moisture, ash, total fat, and titratable acidity in whole milk powder. Two types of packaging and three storage temperatures were evaluated. The RM were considered homogeneous. The materials that were packaged in the pouches and those packaged in the amber glass bottles with screw caps (stored at room temperature) were not stable for moisture. Nevertheless, considering the four measurands, the amber glass bottles under refrigeration and freezing temperatures were the best packaging and storage conditions, respectively. Homogeneity and stability studies were carried out according to the ISO Guide 35, IUPAC harmonized protocol, and ISO 13528, considering the potential applicability of the produced materials as certified reference materials or even as RM for use in proficiency testing schemes. For homogeneity, despite the different criteria, there was agreement between the results. Considering the stability, the agreement depended on the evaluation of the regression assumptions, which is not required by the ISO Guide 35. The contribution of uncertainty associated with homogeneity was greater than that related to stability. The results indicated that the produced materials, i.e., the candidate certified RMs, were suitable for assessing trueness and could be submitted to further inter-laboratory characterization.     

Estimation of measurement uncertainty for the determination of nonylphenol in water using solid-phase extraction and solid-phase microextraction procedures

We describe an estimation of measurement uncertainty calculated by the “bottom-up” approach for the determination of the oestrogenic compound nonylphenol in treated water samples by solid-phase extraction (SPE) and solid-phase microextraction (SPME) procedures and GC/MS detection. The results were compared and the different contributions to the uncertainty were evaluated. A study of the linear range was established and validation was performed for both methods using statistical analysis of several indicative parameters. In terms of validation data, precision (R.S.D. values <20%) and trueness (relative error <11%) were obtained for both methods under day-to-day conditions. The results of the estimation of measurement uncertainty obtained for both methods for concentrations higher than 1 μg/l have demonstrated that the time-consuming SPE method has a lower relative uncertainty (32%) than the SPME method (42.8%). The chromatographic uncertainty value was the main factor in the SPME method whereas the recovery factor (used to calculate the concentration) was the main contribution to uncertainty in the SPE method.     

Operation of a proficiency testing scheme of trace elements in sewage sludge with reference values

A proficiency test (PT) was carried out to investigate the quality of laboratory results measuring trace elements in sewage sludge. The scheme relied on reference values, established through flame atomic absorption spectroscopy and instrumental neutron activation analysis. Within the framework of the project, ”Proficiency testing in Central and Eastern European Countries”, the measurements were done in parallel using induced coupled plasma mass spectrometry. This paper discusses the design of the PTS, the metrological concepts behind it and the way in which it was operated. The discussion includes the estimation of measurement uncertainty of the reference values obtained, homogeneity testing and its uncertainty evaluation, as well as all relevant quality assurance aspects. From the results, it can be concluded that all measurement methods involved agree within their respective uncertainties. Furthermore, it can be concluded that it is feasible to operate a proficiency test of trace elements in sewage sludge using reference values. The agreement between the reference values and the consensus values is satisfactory.     

肌酐纯度标准物质的定值方法及其不确定度评定研究

通过定性及定量分析,研究了肌酐纯度标准物质的定值方法,并进行了定值分析的不确定度评定。首先使用三重四极杆质谱仪及核磁共振谱仪(氢谱)对肌酐样品进行定性分析,然后采用质量平衡法(包括液相色谱法、水分、灰分、挥发性物质和无机元素分析)与定量核磁共振法共同对肌酐纯度标准物质进行准确定值,最后对定值结果进行不确定度评定。肌酐的定值结果为99.7%,扩展不确定度为0.4%。该研究对于实际检测中肌酐的准确测定及临床上相关疾病的正确诊断治疗具有重要意义,且经过定值的肌酐纯品还可做定量核磁共振法的定量内标使用。定量分析后的肌酐经过均匀性检验和稳定性考察后可申报为国家标准物质。